Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Jami Hossain, Adviser (Technical), Indian Wind Energy Association, New Delhi
8
NS Prasad, Sr. Fellow & Adjunct Professor, TERI, New Delhi
Source C-WET
Developments in India
The first systematic efforts to harness wind energy in India were made
during the 1950s and the early 1960s by the CSIR (Council of Scientific and
Industrial Research) and the NAL (National Aeronautical Laboratory), mainly for
water-pumping applications. The efforts received a fresh impetus when specific
recommendations were made in the National Science and Technology Plan for
developing renewable sources of energy, including wind power.
Work on water pumping windmills continued till the mid-1980s. There was
limited success in the dissemination of this technology to some parts of the
country. A large number of these windmills were reported to have been
installed in Orissa and Tamil Nadu. However, due to the lack of evolved
institutional mechanisms to maintain these machines that were dis- persed in the
remote rural areas, the initiative could not be launched on a larger scale. A few
entrepreneurs who had come forward to supply and main- tain these systems
found it difficult to continue and, hence, withdrew.
The modern wind energy programme in India was launched in the early
1980s, with the setting up of the first modern wind turbine in 1985 in Veraval,
Gujarat, in the form of a 40-kW Dutch machine connected to the grid.1 Though
the performance of this machine was quite poor, it established the technical
viability of operating wind turbines in the grid-connected mode in India.
Subsequently, the Government of India planned several demonstration wind
farms in the coastal regions of the country and simultaneously launched a mas-
sive programme to identify sites suitable for wind projects.2 The Indian
wind-mapping programme has been the largest of its kind in the world. The
demonstration projects established beyond doubt both the technical and eco-
nomic viability of the wind energy projects (Hossain, Thukral, Kishore, et al.
1988), while the wind-mapping programme resulted in the identification of
many sites suitable for wind power projects (C-WET 2001; Mani 1990, 1992,
1994; Mani and Mooley 1983).
In 1990, the government came up with a policy for private sector partici-
pation in wind power. As a result of this policy, an investment to the order of
approximately 8 - 9 billion dollars has taken place in wind power in India.
The wind turbine technology has evolved and spread at a rapid pace.
Since 1985 till date, the size of the predominant type of wind turbine being
set up world wide has increased by more than 50 times, from 50 kW to 2.5
MW. Tamil Nadu now has more than 7000 MW of installed capacity. Similar
trends are being witnessed in several states across the country. A typical wind
turbine is shown in Figure 8.1.
1
The project, an initiative of late Dr K S Rao, the then Director of GEDA (Gujarat Energy Develop-
ment Agency), was a joint venture between GEDA and J K Synthetics Ltd.
2
Initiated under the supervision of late Ms Anna Mani, (former Deputy Director General of Indian
Meteorological Department), under a grant of MNES (now MNRE).
Regional
Knowledge of wind speed is needed at various regional levels—a continent, a
country, or a large widespread area. Referred to as ‘areas of interest’, these
regions are being looked upon by the industries, governments, and other
stakeholders to promote wind energy projects. At the regional level, the main
parameter of importance is the mean annual wind speed at a given height
above the ground level.
Based on this information, one is able to assess the potential for
harnessing wind energy in an economically viable manner. These estimates
are not expected to be very precise but provide sufficient information to the
Site assessment
More detailed and precise information is needed for the selection of the actual
sites to set up wind energy projects. Wind speeds have to be measured in
accordance with internationally acceptable norms at relevant heights.3 The
measurements are made by installing a monitoring mast and setting up wind-
measuring instruments, and are carried out for at least one year to obtain
information on wind speeds in all the seasons. The Centre for Wind Energy
Technology, Chennai, recommends at least 3 year record of data in order to
factor in year-to-year variations in wind speeds.
Often, data collected from a site is correlated with long-term data from
the nearest meteorological site to study year-to-year variations in the
wind speeds. Wind speeds measured at a given monitoring mast have to be
extrapolated over a larger area for planning wind energy projects.
Micrositing
Wind turbines are installed in clusters or arrays known as wind farms.
Planning a wind farm requires identification of precise locations of individual
3
Relevant heights are the heights at which commercially available wind turbines are set up. These are
also known as hub heights.
Figure 8.2 Aerial view of a 201-megawatt wind farm at Satara in Maharashtra, India
wind turbines in an array (Figure 8.2). The precise locations are to be deter-
mined for optimal generation from the wind farm, which requires the
consideration of many factors, such as the following.
• Terrain features of sectors in different directions4
• Surface characteristics of sectors in different directions
• Obstructions, buildings, and trees
• Wind speed distribution of sectors in different directions
• Rotor diameter
• Spacing between wind turbines
phere into kinetic energy. In the macro-meteorological sense, the winds are
movements of air masses in the atmosphere (Freris 1990).
Since long, the earth’s mean surface and atmospheric temperatures have
remained unchanged; there has been a net balance of radiant energy received
by the earth and emitted back into the space. Although there is a total
radiative balance, it does not hold for the individual latitude zones from the
equator to the poles. The incoming radiation in the tropics is in excess of the
outgoing, while the reverse holds true for higher latitudes and the polar
regions. This, along with the rotation of the earth results in the creation and
maintenance of large-scale wind systems of the globe (Figure 8.3). This, in turn,
results in the general circulation of the atmosphere, which transports heat and
air mass from the excess to the deficit regions. Air tends to move from regions
of high pressure to those of low pressure. Therefore, the force and speed of
the winds generated are proportional to the gradient of pressure. However, in
many large areas and in some seasons, the actual pattern can be vastly differ-
ent from the picture presented here. These variations are primarily due to
the irregular heating of the earth’s surface in time and space.
As a result of the average overheating of the earth in the equatorial
region, we have a low-pressure belt, also known as the doldrums. Here, the
warm air rises in a strong convective flow. Late afternoon showers are common
from the resulting adiabatic cooling, which is most pronounced at the time of
the highest diurnal temperature.
Ideally, there are two belts of high pressure and relatively light winds
which occur symmetrically around the equator at 30º N and 30º S latitudes.
These are called the subtropical calms, subtropical highs, or horse latitudes.
The high-pressure pattern is maintained by the vertically descending air inside
the pattern. This air is warmed adiabatically and, therefore, develops a low
relative humidity with clear skies. The dryness of the descending air is respon-
sible for the bulk of the world’s great deserts that lie in the horse latitudes.
There are two more belts of low pressure, which occur at 60º S latitude
and 60º N latitude, called the subpolar lows. In the Southern Hemisphere, due
to the oceans, the belt is fairly stable and does not change much from summer
to winter. In the Northern Hemisphere, however, there are large landmasses
and strong temperature differences between the land and water. These
differences cause the lows to reverse and become highs over land in winter
(the Canadian and Siberian highs). At the same time, the lows over the oceans,
called the Iceland low and the Aleutian low, become especially intense and
stormy low-pressure areas over the relatively warm North Atlantic and North
Pacific Oceans.
Finally, the polar regions tend to be more of high-pressure areas than
low-pressure areas. The intensities and locations of these highs may vary
widely, with the centre of the high-only rarely located at the geographic pole.
The combination of these high- and low-pressure areas with the Coriolis force
(see section Wind systems) produces the prevailing winds as shown in Figure 8.3.
The north-east and south-east trade winds are among the most constant winds
on the earth, at least over the oceans. This causes some islands, such as Hawaii
(20º N latitude) and Puerto Rico (18º N latitude), to have excellent wind
resources. The westerlies are well-defined over the southern hemisphere
because of lack of landmasses. Wind speeds are quite steady and strong during
the year, with an average speed of 8–14 m/s.
The wind speeds tend to increase with the increase in latitude in the
Southern Hemisphere, leading to the coining of descriptive terms roaring for-
ties, furious fifties, and screaming sixties. This means that islands and parts of the
southern continents in these latitudes should prove to be good wind resource
regions. Tasmania, an island in the south of Australia, is a good example.
In the Northern Hemisphere, the westerlies are quite variable and may
be masked or completely reversed by more prominent circulation around
moving low- and high-pressure areas. This is particularly true over the large
landmasses of the continents.
Physics of wind
Wind is the movement of air relative to the surface of the earth. Also known
as surface winds, as opposed to the upper atmospheric movements, they result
from changes in the climatic parameters. One of the basic principles is that
the air in the atmosphere flows from high-pressure zones to low-pressure
zones or from low-temperature zones to high-temperature zones. Such a
circulation of wind is called the wind system.
Wind systems
Surface winds are a result of uneven heating of the earth’s surface by solar
radiation. The solar radiation absorbed by the earth’s surface varies with
latitude—it is maximum at the equator and minimum at the poles. This
creates pressure gradients in the atmosphere and the resulting pressure gradient
force causes air movement from high-pressure zones to low-pressure zones.
The vertical pressure gradients are cancelled by the force of gravity, while the
horizontal gradients are the main cause of air movement near the surface of
the earth that we know as the wind system. Ideally, in the lower layers of the
atmosphere, closer to the earth’s surface, the horizontal pressure gradients
should establish a wind system between the poles and the equator, as the air
rises at the equator and sinks at the poles. However, the wind system is
not that simple. Other factors related to the earth’s rotation and its surface
characteristics, seasons, continents, oceans, and mountains result in a fairly
complex system of surface winds. Some of the other wind systems and factors
that influence winds due to the local topographical or climatic reasons are de-
scribed in the subsequent sections.
Geostrophic winds
The earth rotates at a speed of about 166 m/s at the equator, which tapers
down to zero at the poles. A 19th-century French engineer–mathematician,
Gustave-Gaspard Coriolis, introduced the concept of a force in rotating
co-ordinate systems as an apparent deflection of the path of an object that
moves within a rotating co-ordinate system. The object appears to deviate
from its path because of the motion of the co-ordinate systems (Manwell,
McGrowan, and Rogers 2002). Named after him, the Coriolis force – in the
context of the earth’s rotation – is an inertial force that results in an eastward
force component for the surface winds moving from the equator towards the
poles and a westward force component for the winds moving from the poles to
the equator.
Figure 8.4 The resulting path due to the Coriolis and the pressure gradient forces
The winds balanced by the Coriolis and the pressure gradient forces are
known as geostrophic winds. An air parcel initially at rest moves from high
pressure to low pressure because of the pressure gradient force. However, as
the air parcel begins to move, it is deflected by the Coriolis force to the right
in the Northern Hemisphere (to the left in the Southern Hemisphere). As the
wind gains speed, deflection increases until the Coriolis force equals the pres-
sure gradient force (Figure 8.4). At this point, the wind blows parallel to the
isobars and is referred to as geostrophic wind.
Frictional force
The surface of the earth exerts a frictional drag on the air blowing just above
it. This friction can act to change the wind’s direction and to slow it down, and
keep it from blowing as swiftly as the wind above the boundary layer (see
section Boundary layer wind below). Actually, the differences in the terrain
directly affects the friction exerted. For example, as the surface of a calm
ocean is quite smooth, the wind blowing over it does not move up, down, or
around any features. In contrast, features such as trees and forests, hills and
undulating terrain, and buildings force the wind to slow down and/or change
direction frequently.
Monsoon system
Monsoons are large-scale regional wind systems. The seasonal temperature
gradients and the temperature gradients between the oceans surfaces, and the
landmasses of the continents result in large-scale seasonal movement of winds
known as the monsoons. Monsoons are active for approximately six months
from the north-east and six months from the south-west, principally in the
southern Asia and parts of Africa. The origin of the word ‘monsoon’ can be
traced to the Persian word mausam meaning weather.
During the summer months, the Afro-Asian continent is strongly
heated, resulting in the generation of an extensive heat low-pressure zone,
stretching from Eastern Sahara to East China. Under its influence, cool and
humid air from the Indian Ocean begins to move from early June towards the
trough of low pressure as the south-west monsoon. With the southward
movement of the sun, the cooling landmass gives rise to a high-pressure area
with its centre over eastern Siberia.
Summer monsoons have a dominant westerly component and a strong
tendency to converge, rise, and produce rain. Winter monsoons have a
dominant easterly component and a strong tendency to diverge, subside, and
cause drought. Both are the results of differences in annual temperature
trends over land and sea. The Indian monsoon is a perfect example of the
monsoon system.
The sea breeze normally starts some time in the noon and continues well
into the night.
5
Adiabatic temperature changes are those that occur without the addition or subtraction of heat;
they occur in the atmosphere when bundles of air are moved vertically. When air is lifted, it enters a
region of lower pressure and expands. This expression is accompanied by a reduction in temperature
(adiabatic cooling). When air subsides, it contracts and experiences adiabatic warming.
conditions. Usually, such winds are gentle and result in slow warming, but at
times may result in strong currents with a rapid increase in temperature. We
have such winds on the slopes of the Himalayas, the ‘waav’ in Kashmir, the
German Föhn in the Alps, Chinook in the North American Rockies, Ghibli in
Libya, and Zonda in the Andes of Argentina.
Katabatic wind
Katabatic winds are experienced in areas where the local topography is
characterized by the presence of a cold plateau adjacent to a relatively warm
region of lower elevation.
Such conditions are satisfied in areas in which major ice sheets or cold,
elevated land surfaces border warmer, large bodies of water. Air over the cold
plateau cools and results in the formation of a body of cold, dense air. This
cold air spills over into the lower elevations with speeds that vary from gentle
(a few km/h) to intense (93–185 km/h), depending on the incline action of
the slope of the terrain and the distribution of the background pressure field.
Two special types of katabatic winds are well-known in Europe. One is the
Bora that blows from the highlands of Croatia, Bosnia, Herzegovina, and
Montenegro to the Adriatic Sea. The other is the Mistral that blows out of
central and southern France to the Mediterranean Sea.
Desert wind
Strong winds blow due to the strong temperature contrasts that exist in
deserts in relation to the adjoining regions and the diurnal variations in
temperature. The pressure gradients between deserts and other geographical
areas or the sea cause these winds. Winds that blow in the Sahara desert, Gobi
desert, Thar desert in Rajasthan, and the Kachchh region are examples of such
winds. These winds are capable of transporting large amounts of sand and dust
to form sand dunes.
Mechanics of wind
A simple approach to studying the mechanics of the wind system is to model it
with the following.
• Pressure force
• Coriolis force
• Inertial force
• Frictional force
The force causing the air movement is the difference in air pressure
between the two regions.
The pressure force on the air (per unit mass) Fp is given by (Manwell,
McGowan, and Rogers 2002)
Fp pn ...(8.1)
where is the density of air and n is the direction normal to the lines of
constant pressure. The pressure gradient normal to the lines of constant
pressure is given by pn. The above equation can be derived from the
boundary layer equations, assuming laminar flow (see general textbooks on
heat and mass transfer, for example, Burmeister [1983] or Eckert and Drake
[1972]).
As soon as the wind motion is established, a deflective force, the Coriolis
force, is produced, which alters the direction of the motion. The Coriolis
force (per unit mass) Fc is given by
Fc = fU ...(8.2)
where U is the wind speed and f the Coriolis parameter [f = 2sin]. repre-
sents the latitude and represents the angular rotation of the earth. The
Coriolis force, therefore, is a function of wind speed and latitude.
If no other forces are present, the Coriolis force will exactly balance the
pressure gradient force and the wind will flow parallel to the isobars. For
straight or slightly curved isobars, the resultant wind is called the geostrophic
wind (Ug).
We have Fp = Fc
Ug = (–1/f)(p/n) ...(8.3)
...(8.5)
Finally, the gradient wind is subjected to friction near the earth’s surface.
The forces of friction reduce the wind speeds near the surface but
progressively become negligible as one approaches the boundary layer.
The kinetic energy per unit time, or the power of the flow is given by
2
P = (½)( )U ...(8.7)
Using Equation 8.6, the power contained in the wind per unit area is
All wind turbines are set up within the boundary layer and the modern
wind turbines that are rated at nearly 5 MW can have their rotor blade tips
going up to 150 m above the ground level. Knowledge of the vertical profile
of the wind speed characteristics is immensely important for wind project
developers, not only to ascertain the energy capture they can hope to have at
the height they set up the wind turbines, but also for design purposes, and for
understanding dynamic structural loads on the wind turbine structure.
There are two areas of interest.
1 Instantaneous variation in wind speed as a function of height over time
scales of a second.
2 Seasonal or monthly variation in wind speed with height.
Different methodologies apply to these two problems. Assessment of
instantaneous wind speed variations is beyond the scope of this chapter.
where U(z) is the wind speed at height z and U(zr) is the wind speed at
reference height zr. Reference height is the height at which wind speed
measurements have been carried out.
The need to find simpler approaches has led many people to look for
simpler, empirical expressions that yield satisfactory results. The most com-
mon of these simpler expressions is the power law, expressed as
where U2 and U1 are the mean wind speeds at heights z2 and z1, respectively, and
is the power law index.
The power law index can be used to extrapolate the mean wind speed,
frequency distributions, and even direction-wise distribution of wind speed.
If wind speeds are not known at two heights, terrain surface roughness
can be used in various empirical relations to compute . One of the empirical
relations given by Counihan (1975) is
= 0.096 (log10 z0) + 0.0016(log10 z0) + 0.24 ...(8.13)
Across the world, at many wind measurement sites, the average value of
has been determined and is found to be closely approximated by 1/7. This has
led to the common reference to Equation 8.11 as the 1/7 power law equation.
In view of the large number of possible values that can assume, the
approximation should be used only if site-specific data is not available.
Example 1
The monthly average wind speeds recorded at 10-m height at a site Surajbari,
Gujarat, are given in the table below. The site is in an open agricultural field
with very scattered low building structures. Estimate the mean monthly
wind speeds at 20-m height by the extrapolation techniques described in this
chapter and plot them against the actual wind speeds given in the table below.
Try to ascertain if there is anything exceptional about this site.
Month Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep. Oct. Nov. Dec.
Speed: 10 m 8.83 9.92 11.56 16.51 23.36 24.65 23.32 18.68 14.48 9.55 8.59 8.33
(kmph)
Actual speed at 13.10 14.41 15.69 20.46 26.83 28.47 27.94 22.89 18.20 12.83 13.31 13.18
20 m (kmph)
Solution
The corresponding wind speeds at 20-m height are calculated separately using
Equations 8.10 and 8.13, and the 1/7 power law assuming z0 = 0.03 for an open
agricultural area without fences and hedgerows, and very scattered buildings
(Table 8.2). The calculated results are compared against the actual wind speeds
at 20-m height in Figure 8.10. It can be seen that all three methods closely
follow the actual wind speeds and that there is better approximation in
summer months. In case of average annual wind speeds recorded at 10 m and
20 m heights at this site, using Equation 8.12 we find that the power law index
is 0.39. This is an exceptionally high figure and one can conclude that perhaps
it is an exceptional site.
Example 2
At a site, Kethanur in Tamil Nadu, wind speeds at heights 10 and 20 m have
been recorded as 19.90 and 21.91 kmph (Mani 1994, page 349, table 47). The
terrain is open agricultural field similar to that in Example 1. Compare the ver-
tical profile of wind speeds till 150 m above the ground level, using all the
approaches given in this chapter by plotting them.
Solution
Using Equation 8.12 at this site, we find that the power law index is 0.14.
In the wind speed values plotted till 150 m above the ground level, shown in
Figure 8.11, it can be seen that the power law index, 1/7 power law, and the
logarithmic profile (Equation 8.10) approaches are in agreement, while the
Example 3
At a site, Okha Madhi in Gujarat, the mean annual wind speed measured at a
height of 10 m above ground level is 16.89 kmph. The site is located in the
midst of a salt lake, which stretches around the site for several miles.
1 Use Equation 8.13 to estimate the mean annual wind speed at 20 m above
the ground level on this site.
2 If the actual measurements show a mean annual wind speed of 19.05
kmph at 20 m height, calculate the power law index and use it to estimate
the mean annual wind speed at 50 m height above the ground level.
3 Assuming an air density of 1.225 kg/m3, calculate the percentage change in
energy content of the wind moving from 20 to 50 m.
Solution
1 From Table 8.2, we take surface roughness z0 for a calm open sea as ap-
plicable to this site. Therefore, we have z0 = 0.20. Using Equation 8.13, we
compute the power law index at the site as 0.18.
2 We apply Equation 8.12 to obtain = 0.1907 and apply Equation 8.11 as in 1.
We have u1 = 19.05 kmph, z1 = 20, z2 = 50
0.1907
or u2 = 2.5 * 19.05 = 22.68 kmph
Therefore, the increase in the energy content of the wind in moving from
20-m height to 50-m height is 68.9%.
6
Parallel lines along the direction of fluid flow are known as streamlines that never intersect.
This phenomenon, also known as the speed-up of the wind, makes hilltops
a particularly good site for wind turbines.
According to Hassan and Sykes in Freris (1990), the turbulence levels
over a hill are generally lower than those over the ground level if the hill is not
so steep as to cause the flow to separate. Hills with slopes less than 1:4 are
considered suitable. Hassan and Sykes report of several analytical studies that
have established an understanding of the wind flow over small rounded hills.
Figure 8.13 shows the flow field over a hill of height H and length L,
which is defined as the distance from the crest to the point where the height
of the ground is half the height of the hill.
The mean wind speed profile upstream of the hill is assumed to be
defined by the log-law model. For mean wind speeds over the summit of the
hill
where U(z) is the mean wind speed at height z above the hill, U0(z) is the
upstream mean wind speed at the same height above the ground, and u(z) is
the speed-up of the mean wind speed. According to Hassan and Sykes, the
speed-up has been found to depend linearly on the slope of the hill and can be
used to define a non-dimensional speed-up u by
Hassan and Sykes cite studies undertaken by Jackson (1979), Mason (1979), and
Taylor (1979) to present a simplified expression.
...(8.16)
Assuming that roughness on the hill is the same as for the area down-
wind, if the wind moves from a rough plain to a smooth hill, there are two
factors accelerating the flow.
• Change in the roughness factor
• Speed-up on the slope
The two effects are approximately additive, which would make such a
location an ideal site for wind power generation.
In nature, the terrain normally tends to be complex and ideal smooth
hills are rather uncommon. Many high-wind areas lie in mountainous regions
as the hills and ridges speed up the air flow. While selecting sites for wind
turbines in a complex terrain, it is important to take into account the fact that
the turbulence around hill sites tends to be greater. Moreover, the vegetation
on hill slopes is often rougher and the speed-up due to the hill, to some extent,
could get cancelled out by the deceleration due to the roughness change.
Steep hills with slopes greater than 30º, or less if very rough, behave as
bluff bodies and cause flow separation at the leading edge or the peak, de-
pending on the actual shape of the hill. The hill imposes an additional drag on
the wind flow, which leads to increased turbulence and perhaps flow separa-
tion. This causes very low wind speeds near the separation region. As hills are
seldom symmetrical, some hills can have good flow characteristics for certain
sectors of the wind directions, but very poor characteristics for other sectors.
The air flow at the hill is also influenced by the terrain features upwind.
Additional turbulence and shelter effects may be important. There are
many numerical models, which try to model the effect of orography, but
the complexity of most hilly or mountainous areas makes this difficult.
The effect of atmospheric stability can also often lead to air flows that are
difficult to predict.
Monsoons are also caused by the fact that landmasses cool down and
warm up faster than the sea. On a global scale, the differential cooling and
heating of continents and oceans results in regional or global wind circulation
systems which are the monsoons.
The north-eastern or winter monsoons prevail from November to March
and the south-western monsoon from June to September. As seen in
Figure 8.14, India receives monsoon rains and winds in summer as the heating
creates a low-pressure area over the basin of the Indus river. Known as the
South Asian (or Iranian) low, it appears in April and is fully developed from
June to August. The onset of monsoons in India and South-east Asia is related
to changes in the circulation pattern that occur by June. The monsoon air
masses flow into the monsoonal low-pressure zone over northern India from a
cell of high pressure, just off the eastern coast of southern Africa. Because of
the Coriolis force, winds south of the equator change direction from south-
east to south-west in the Arabian Sea and Bay of Bengal. The south-west
monsoon bursts on the Malabar Coast of India in early June and gradually
moves northward over most of India. The monsoon period coincides with
high wind speeds in most of southern and western India.
In winter monsoons, the temperature over central Asia is lower, resulting
in a zone of high pressure over the continent. This causes outward wind flow
towards the sea.
Different altitudinal climatic zones are most clearly defined on the
southern slopes of the Himalayas where they vary from the subequatorial and
tropical climates of the foothills, at the lowest levels, to the snowy climate of
the peaks, at the highest altitudes. The Foehn effect is seen when a strong wind
traverses a mountain range and is deflected downward as a warm, dry, gusty,
erratic wind. We have the valley mountain systems and the Foehn in many
parts of the Himalayan region. One example is the wind-swept Leh valley.
Figure 8.15 Tanmarg in Jammu and Kashmir where mountain valley wind system
are experienced
Topography
A topographical map of the region should be examined for highlands,
plateaus, ridges, hills, and cliffs. Elevated locations are naturally prone
to higher wind speeds due to the effect of the boundary layer and speed-ups
associated with the slopes. Topographical maps also indicate the complexity of
the terrain. In a highly complex terrain, wind flow is also likely to be complex
and perhaps turbulent. On the other hand, plain terrain and smooth surfaces
give rise to more uniform wind flow. Elevated areas and slopes should be
marked on the topographical map.
Local knowledge
Though it would be difficult for a scientist or a technician to have knowledge
of wind-prone areas in a region without carrying out measurements, local
people generally have this information. They know of the seasons, the
locations, and even a particular time-of-day when wind speeds are high. For
example, where the region of interest includes water bodies and areas like sea
shores and/or large lakes, the fishermen always know exactly when the wind
speeds would be maximum. Similarly, in the case of a mountainous terrain,
where it is very difficult to identify good wind sites, local knowledge can
provide insights that would otherwise not be possible.
Judgement
Wind speeds and their directions can be assessed within +10% merely by
judgement. Golding (1955) presented a compilation devised by Admiral Sir
Francis Beaufort of British Navy in 1805. This is now very common and is
known as Beaufort scale. The Beaufort scale is shown in Table 8.3 and can be
useful in arriving at some level of quantification of information gathered in
this manner.
Eolian landforms
On the surface of the earth, there are often forms and features that have been
shaped by strong and persistent winds. These are called the Eolian features or
Eolian landforms. Observation and study of these forms provide us with
insights into the strength of the winds, their flow patterns, and sometimes the
prevalent direction. Figure 8.17 shows the wind-swept smooth and rounded
landforms, highlands, and ridges at Dhank in Gujarat, an area within 100 km
of the Arabian Sea. Wind speeds at this site are the highest in Gujarat. Some
of the Eolian features are discussed in the following sections.
Sand dunes
Sand dunes are one of the common Eolian features found in arid regions.
Dunes tend to be elongated parallel to the dominant wind flow. The wind
picks up the finer materials from the site where wind speeds are higher and
deposits them at the site where wind speeds are lower. The size distribution of
sand at a given site thus gives an indication of the average wind speed, with
coarser sand indicating higher wind speed. The movement of a sand dune over
a period of several years is proportional to the average wind speed. This
movement can be recorded by a satellite or aerial photographs. The following
are some of the different types of dunes (Figure 8.18).
• Barchan Crescent-shaped, solitary, tips point downwind, indicate
constant wind direction
• Linear dunes Indicate the possibility of a ridge
• Transverse dunes Wind direction goes over the top of the crest and not
parallel along the ridge as seen with linear dunes
• Parabolic Crescent-shaped, but ends point upwind
• Star dunes Show lack of directional predominance in wind
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Playa lake
The wind scours out a depression in the ground that fills with water after
rains. When the water evaporates, the wind scours out the sediments at the
bottom. These lakes go through a maturing process and their stage of maturity
gives a relative measure of the strength of the wind (Figure 8.19).
Sediment plumes
Other Eolian features include sediment plumes from dry lakes and streams,
and wind scour, where air-borne materials gouge out streaks in exposed rock
surfaces.
Vertical cliffs
Cliffs often carry on them marks created by the particles in the wind. The face
of vertical cliffs exposed to the winds carries marks of sand particles that have
been blown into the cliff.
Wave-like landforms
Often, one comes across wave-like forms or ripples on the surface, particularly
in wind-swept valleys and deserts. These too are indicators of strong winds.
It is difficult to get a precise estimate of the average wind speeds
through Eolian landforms. Further research can hone this area as a more effec-
tive tool for wind prospecting. The distance by which the sand dunes are
moved, the size of dust or soil particles, average distances, and wave-like rip-
ples in landforms can be calibrated with average wind speeds in a region.
Eolian features, however, in the absence of any other data, dramatically in-
crease the level of confidence in selecting sites or in comparing different
sites. An experienced meteorologist or a wind-prospecting engineer can use
the Eolian indicators very effectively.
Biological indicators
Winds also leave tell-tale marks on plants. While Eolian indicators may be
more useful in areas that lack vegetative cover, in areas that have some trees,
shrubs, etc., one can examine the biological indicators that offer more precise
information than the Eolian features.
Strong winds deform trees and shrubs so that they indicate an integrated
record of the local wind speeds during their lives. Different species of trees
show up this effect differently. Therefore, in a site-prospecting exercise, to the
extent possible, one should examine only one species of trees. Often one can
corroborate the findings by examining both biological indicators and Eolian
indicators to arrive at a better understanding of the wind flow in a region.
Tree deformation caused by winds shows up best on coniferous
evergreens because their exposure to the wind is relatively constant during
the year. On the other hand, species like deciduous trees that shed their leaves
seasonally change the exposed area tremendously. However, tree trunks may
still carry on them marks of the long-term impact of wind speeds.
According to Katzhan (1989), winds blowing below an average speed of
4 m/s have little effect on the vegetation, and trees cannot generally survive
winds averaging speed above 12 m/s. Among the significant biological indicators
of unidirectional wind speed are foliar deformation, girth asymmetry, and
growth ring asymmetry.
Putnam (1948) lists five types of foliar deformation in trees: brushing, flag-
ging, throwing, wind clipping, and tree carpets.
Brushing
A tree is said to be brushed when the branches are bent to leeward (downwind).
It is usually seen only on the deciduous trees and other trees that are not
evergreen and occurs due to the light prevailing winds. It is only useful in
ascertaining the seasonal wind direction (Figure 8.20).
Flagging
A tree is said to be flagged when the wind causes its branches to stretch out
leeward, leaving the windward side bare, so that the tree appears like a flag-
pole carrying a banner in the breeze. This is an easily observable and
measurable effect that occurs over a range of wind speeds important to
wind power applications (Figure 8.21).
Windthrowing
A tree is said to be windthrown when the main trunk as well as the branches
are deformed such that they lean away from the prevailing wind. This effect is
produced by the same mechanism that causes flagging, except that the wind in
this case is strong enough to modify the growth of the upright leaders of the
tree as well as the branches (Figure 8.22).
Clipping
Trees are said to be wind clipped when the wind has been sufficiently severe to
suppress the leaders and hold the tree tops to a common, abnormally low level.
Every twig that rises above that level is promptly killed so that the upper
surface is as smooth as a well-kept hedge.
Carpeting
Tree carpets are the extreme case of clipping in which a tree may grow only a
few centimetres tall before being clipped. The branches will grow out along
the surface of the ground, appearing like a carpet because of the clipping
action. The result may be a tree 10-cm tall but extending 30 m to the leeward
of the sheltering rock where the tree sprouted (Figure 8.23).
A rating scale for tree deformation has been proposed (Figure 8.24). In
this scale, Class 0 corresponds to no wind damage; Classes I–IV to various
degrees of flagging; Class V to flagging plus clipping; and Class VI to
throwing. Class VII is a flagged tree with the flagging caused by factors other
than a strong prevailing wind, such as salt spray from the ocean or mechanical
damage from a short, intense storm. In coastal areas, particularly in India, care
has to be taken to account for Class VII type of flagging.
Crown deformation
A common kind of wind deformation of trees is a pronounced asymmetry
in the crown of the tree so that it grows more in the direction away from
the prevalent direction of the wind. This deformation would represent the
prevalent seasonal wind direction rather than the strength of the wind speed,
though in high-wind-speed regions, the deformation may be more pronounced,
leading to flagging or carpeting. In areas where sufficiently strong winds are
experienced from different directions, crown deformation may not be a good
indicator. For a given species of trees, an index of deformation can be
computed by drawing an imaginary vertical line from the tip of the crown to
the ground and computing the ratio of the distances from the vertical line to
the outer periphery at the widest plane level of the crown. Again, only one
species of trees should be considered for comparison (Figure 8.25 ).
Ring asymmetry
Long-term effect of the winds can also be seen in the asymmetry of the tree
rings. Again, trees at locations that experience wind speeds uniformly from all
directions may not show a high level of asymmetry in the tree rings, though
the average wind speeds at these sites will be reasonably high (Figure 8.26).
The average wind speed at which these effects occur varies from one
species to another. Therefore, for a given species, calibration is necessary.
In a complex terrain, deformations also show the location of high wind
speed zones caused by the reflection or deflection of wind from certain terrain
features. It is difficult to gain such insights, merely by theoretical or analytical
approaches. Tables 8.4 and 8.5 summarize all the indicators of windy sites that
are generally useful in wind prospecting.
Instrumentation
A wind-measuring system tracks, records, and displays wind speeds and/or
wind direction. The instrument used for recording wind speed is known as an
anemometer while the direction is recorded by a wind vane. The wind-measur-
ing system consists of sensors, signal conditioning units, and displays, and/or
recorders. The devices can be read out magnetically, optically, electrically, or
mechanically with virtually no error.
Wind vane
Wind vanes are known to have been used extensively in the past. A wind vane
is a simple device that consists of a flat asymmetrical plate (vane) mounted on
a vertical shaft on which it is free to revolve. The wind vane revolves with the
movement of the wind and comes to a position that offers least resistance to
the wind flow (Figure 8.29). The direction of the wind is observed by noting
the position of the pointer against the fixed rods mounted beneath the vane
showing the four directions. Indication at a distance can be provided using
contact closures, potentiometers, or servo-mechanisms. In the electrical
selsyn wind vane, a self-synchronous motor connected to the vane spindle
transmits the position of the vane to a receiver selsyn where the direction is
indicated on a meter graduated from 0º to 360º. In photoelectric wind vanes, a
Data presentation
Most wind-measuring systems are equipped with modern data acquisition
systems that record instantaneous or average wind speeds over time scales of
one second or less, while the analysis of wind resource requires information
over time scales of one hour to one year (8760 hours). The data acquisition
system should have the capability to record average wind speeds over time
scales of a few minutes. It is normal to maintain average hourly wind speed
records. However, for design purposes and to study the turbulence intensity, a
time series even in seconds may be used. Maximum gusts, even if they are of
short duration, also need to be recorded for the purpose of design.
For the purpose of wind resource assessment, annual frequency distribu-
tion of average hourly wind speeds is adequate. Normally, this data is recorded
in bins of 1 m/s or 1 kmph width in each of the 12 direction sectors. In addition
to frequency distribution, the average monthly wind speeds, average monthly
power law index, and air density should also be computed.
Wind distribution
Wind speeds at any given location vary widely throughout the year, but nev-
ertheless follow a statistical distribution. It has been shown (Lysen 1982,
Manwell, McGowan, and Rogers 2002) that a good representation of wind
speed frequency distribution is the Weibull distribution function, charac-
terised by the shape parameter k and scale parameter c. The cumulative
probability distribution function F(U) is given by
...(8.17)
where U is the wind speed. The probability density function f(U) is obtained
by differentiating F(U)
...(8.18)
The mean velocity is obtained by integrating (8.18)
...(8.19)
where is the gamma function* defined as
...(8.20)
In terms of the gamma function, F(U) and f(U) are given by
F(U) = 1–exp [–k (1+1/k) (U/ U)k ...(8.21)
...(8.22)
Manwell, McGowan, and Rogers (2002) and Lysen (1982) have present-
ed empirical expressions that can be used as good approximations of gamma
function, as given below.
...(8.23)
...(8.24)
when k = 2 the Weibull distribution reduces to a Rayleigh distribution, which
is often used for making assessments on wind energy output at a given site in
the absence of any knowledge on frequency distribution. For Rayleigh distri-
bution,
c2 = c1 (z2/z1) ...(8.25)
A = a + b lnc1 ...(8.26)
...(8.27)
...(8.28)
...(8.29)
Method B is based on the work of Justus (1978)
...(8.31)
...(8.32)
c2 = c1 (z2/z1)c ...(8.33)
...(8.34)
where 0 = (z0/zr)0.2
Uh is the homogeneous wind speed, and zr is the reference height (Equation
8.10).
...(8.35)
Of the above methods, Poje and Civindini, based on the work they
carried out for a large number of sites, recommend Method B. As in Meth-
od B, extrapolation of c requires computation of B, which is to be further
computed from a relation (Equation 8.31) that requires knowledge of surface
roughness z0, an easier approach is to first calculate k2 using Equation 8.32 and
then to use the relation between k and c, given by Lysen, to estimate c2.
– ...(8.36)
Wind energy resources • 491
Example 4
The average wind speed at a height of 20 m at Narsimhakonda is 20.08 kmph.
1 Assuming the Rayleigh distribution, calculate the scale factor c.
2 Given that the power law index at the site is 0.27, develop the per cent
frequency distribution of the site at 50-m height and compare it with the
per cent frequency distribution at 20-m height.
Solution
1 Value of the shape factor k for Rayleigh distribution = 2
Using Equation 8.22, we have
G = k(1+1/k) = 0.79
Now (1+1/k) = G1/k
In this case since k = 2, we have
(1+1/k) = G = 0.886
From Equation 8.17, we have
—
c =U/(1+1/k)
Therefore, c = 20.08/0.886 = 22.7 kmph
...(8.39)
Lysen (1982) has plotted this function, which is shown in Figure 8.33.
Therefore, if standard deviation is calculated as
then the corresponding k value can be found from Figure 8.33. Alternatively,
7
k can also be estimated using the maximum likelihood estimation.
7
Details available at, <http://www.weibull.com/LifeDataWeb/maximum_likelihood_estimation.htm>,
last accessed in January 2005.
Wind energy resources • 493
Wind rose
A wind rose is a graphic representation of the information on direction-wise
distribution of wind speeds.
In a wind rose 360 degrees of a circle representing all the directions is di-
vided into 12 sectors of 30 degrees each as shown in Figure 8.34. (A wind rose
may also be drawn for 8 or 16 sectors, but 12 sectors tend to be the standard set
by European Wind Atlas.)
The radius of the boundary in each sector presents the relative fre-
quency of winds from that sector as a part of total wind from all the sectors.
The second inner boundary gives the same information, but multiplied by the
average wind speed in each particular direction. The result is then normalized
to add up to 100 per cent. This tells how each sector contributes to the aver-
age wind speed at a particular location.
The innermost boundary gives the same information as the first, but
multiplied by the cube of the wind speed in each particular location. The re-
sult is then normalized to add up to 100 per cent. This shows how much each
sector contributes to the energy content of the wind at a particular location.
Wind roses vary from one location to the next. They actually are a form
of meteorological fingerprint.
A look at the wind rose is extremely useful for siting wind turbines. If a
large share of the energy in the wind comes from a particular direction, then
one should have as few obstacles as possible, and as smooth a terrain as possi-
ble in that direction.
8
Details available at, <http://www.wasp.dk>, last accessed in Janaury 2005.
The central point in the wind transformation model of WASP – the so-
called wind atlas methodology – is the concept of a regional or generalized wind
climate, or wind atlas. The RWC (regional wind climate) is the hypothetical
wind climate for an ideal, completely flat terrain with uniform surface rough-
ness, assuming the same overall atmospheric conditions as those of the
measuring position.
To deduce the wind climate at a location of interest from the RWC and
to introduce the effect of different terrain features such as terrain height
variations, surface roughness, and sheltering obstacles, a flow model shown in
Figure 8.35 is used. To deduce the regional wind climate from the measured
wind in the actual terrain, the same flow model is used, but in a reverse
manner, to remove the local terrain effects.
Figure 8.35 Flow diagram of a Wind Atlas Analysis and Application Program model
Exercises
Question 1
A parcel of air from the Sahara desert under pressure is moving towards the
north. In which direction will its path get modified due to the Coriolis force?
Question 2
At Jaisalmer, the wind speed at 10-m height is 14.92 kmph. Using three
different approaches, calculate the mean annual wind speeds at 20-m height.
• If actual measurements at 20-m height indicate a mean annual wind speed
of 17.37 kmph, calculate the power law index.
• Which of the three methods used above are in close agreement with the
power law index approach?
Question 3
A wind project developer is evaluating different sites to arrive at a site with
maximum mean annual wind speed at 50 m above the ground level. From the
sites given in the following table, which of the sites will be selected by him?
Mean annual wind speed (kmph)
Site 10 m 20 m
Alagiyapandiyapuram 18.13 20.88
Ayikudi 18.16 21.35
Talayuthu 18.84 20.51
Question 4
At a site Lamba in Gujarat, the mean annual wind speed at 20-m height is
20 kmph and the power law index is 0.13. A wind prospecting engineer is
evaluating a site Lamba-2 in a very similar terrain about 10 km from Lamba.
At this site, no measurements have been carried out so far. The engineer
estimates the surface roughness to be 0.025. Estimate the mean annual wind
speed at 30-m height above the ground level at Lamba-2.
Question 5
Average wind speed at 20-m height at a site MPR dam is 19.85 kmph.
• Assuming Rayleigh distribution, calculate scale factor c.
• Given that the power law index at the site is 0.08, develop the per cent
frequency distribution of the site at 50-m height and compare it with the
per cent frequency distribution at 20-m height.
• If the actual shape parameter at 20-m height is 1.9 and the scale para-
meter is 21.7, plot the frequency distribution at 50-m height.
Nomenclature
A Area (m2)
c Scale parameter
f Coriolis parameter
Fp Pressure force on the air (per unit mass)
Fc Coriolis forcer (per unit mass)
H Height of hill
k Shape parameter
L Monin-Obukhov length
m Mass flow rate (kg/s)
n Direction normal to the lines of constant pressure
P Power (watt)
R Radius of curvature of the path of air particles
U Wind speed
U• Friction velocity
Ug Geostrophic wind
Ugr Gradient wind
Uh Homogenous wind speed
U0(z) Upstream mean wind speed at the same height above the ground
u Non-dimensional speed-up
z Height
z0 Surface roughness length
zr Reference height
Power law index
Constant
Gamma function
Density
p/n Pressure gradient normal to the lines of constant pressure
Angular rotation of the earth
References
Burmeister L C. 1983
Convective Heat Transfer
New York: Wiley Interscience. 790 pp.
.
Burton T, Sharpe D, Jenkins N, Bossanyi E. 2001
Wind Energy Handbook
London: John Wiley & Sons Ltd
C-WET. 2001
Wind Energy Resource Survey in India–VI
C-WET. 696 pp.
Freris L L. 1990
Wind Energy Conversion Systems
New Jersey: Prentice Hall International. 388 pp.
Golding E W. 1976
The Generation of Electricity by Wind Power
Trowbridge: Redwood Burn Ltd
Katzhan M T. 1989
Assessing regional wind energy resources with biological indicators:
a decision-analytic approach
Solar Energy 42(1): 15–25
Lysen E H. 1982
Introduction to Wind Energy
The Netherlands: Publication SWD 82-1 Steering Committee Wind Energy Developing
Countries. 310 pp.
Mani A. 1990
Wind Energy Resource Survey for India–I
New Delhi: Allied Publishers Ltd. 347 pp.
Mani A. 1992
Wind Energy Resource Survey for India–II
New Delhi: Allied Publishers Ltd
Mani A. 1994
Wind Energy Resource Survey for India–III
New Delhi: Allied Publishers Ltd