Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
00
“
Quote in the Act
IMPACT
ISSN 0300-4155 “Well done.”
Asian Magazine for Human Transformation His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI, after reportedly
Through Education, Social Advocacy and Evangelization patting on the back visiting President Gloria Macapagal-
Arroyo who handed him a copy of the law abolishing
©
Copyright 1974 by Social Impact Foundation, Inc.
AUSTRALIA: Impact P.O. Box 2034, East Ivanhoe, Victoria 3079 “We must find ways to live with nature in
BANGLADESH: 1. Community Center, 5 Sadar Road, Barisal; 2. The Priest-in- some kind of balance. The government mainly
Charge, P.O. Box 152, Chittagong
CAROLINE ISLANDS: Social Action Center, Inc., P.O. Box 202, Truk,
wants to control nature, which is what did all
Caroline Islands 96942 the harm in the first place.”
“
HONGKONG: Catholic Periodicals Subscription Office, Catholic Centre, 16, CHAI ERHONG, an environmentalist and writer based
Caine Road, 11/F, Hong Kong
INDIA: 1. Asian Trading Corp., 310, The Mirabelle, Lotus-House, 33A, in Minqin (China), on the spread of expanding deserts in
Marine Lines, P.B. No. 11029, Bombay - 400 202; 2. Asian Trading Corp., China.
150 Brigade Rd., Bangalore - 56-0025
INDONESIA: 1. Y.S.T.M. Jl. Gunung Sahari III/7 Phone: 021-354700 Jakarta
Pusat; 2. YPD Jl. Veteran 7, P.O. Box 1066, Semarang 5010; 3. Biro Sosial, “My message to the Iraqi people is this:
Jl. Taman Srigunting 10, Semarang. seize the moment.”
JAPAN: Enderle Book Co. Ltd., Ichico Bldg., 1-5 Yotsudya Shinjuku-ku,
Tokyo 160, Japan U.S. President GEORGE BUSH, during his June 13 visit
KOREA: J. R. Heisse, C.P.O.. Box 206, Seoul, Korea to Iraq one week after the bombing strike that killed
MALAYSIA: 1. Anthonian Store Sdn. Bhd., Wisma Anthonian, 235, Jalan America’s most-wanted man in Iraq, Al Qaeda’s leader
Brickfields, Kuala Lumpur 09-08; 2. Catholic Information Services 50 E&F, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi.
Penang Rd., Penang
NEW ZEALAND: Catholic Depot Ltd., 64 Wyndham Street, Auckland
PAKISTAN: Fr. Joseph Louis, 8-Katchery Road, Lahore “That’s good pancreas music.”
PHILIPPINES: P.O. Box 2950, 1099 Manila
SINGAPORE: Select Books PTE. Ltd., 215 Tanglin Shopping Centre, 2/F 19, Endocrine surgeon Dr. William B. Inabnet of New
Tanglin Road, Singapore 10 York Prebyterian Hospital, on playing the Red Hot Chili
TAIWAN: P.O. Box 8-146, Taipei 100 Peppers (a lively musical band) while performing difficult
THAILAND: NASAC, 2 Saensuk, Prachasongkroh Road, Bangkok 10. operations.
U.S.A.: c/o Mrs. M. Taranella, Walsh Bldg., 1st Floor, Maryknoll, New York
10545
“
“In Lebanon, the quest for freedom is a
Published monthly by social action. Contrary to Dubai, it is not just
CBCP COMMUNICATIONS DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, INC. a form of freedom aimed at creating the right
OSCAR V. CRUZ, D.D. • ART T. NG • JO IMBONG
E DITORIAL B OARD atmosphere for business and tourism.”
PEDRO C. QUITORIO III Beirut-based Sociologist Leila Kfoury, opining that
E DITOR - IN -C HIEF Lebanon has maintained a relative freedom of values
BALTAZAR R. ACEBEDO despite the spread of extremism in the Arab world.
A SSOCIATE E DITOR
DENNIS B. DAYAO
M ANAGING E DITOR “I’m not sure anytime in history we’ve
PINKY BARRIENTOS • EULY BELIZAR • ROY CIMAGALA ever seen someone give away a sum of money
MIAMI EBILANE • ROY LAGARDE • LOPE ROBREDILLO that large to another foundation. Most people
S TAFF WRITERS
ROWENA DALANON with this sum of money would try to create
S ALES & A DVERTISING their own foundation in their own image.”
ERNANI RAMOS Gene Tempel, executive director of the Center on
C IRCULATION Philanthropy at Indiana University (USA), on Warren
LEAH KATRINA CARIASO Buffett’s $31 billion donation to the Bill & Melinda Gates
F INANCE O FFICER Foundation.
CORRESPONDENTS:India: Haranath Tadepally; Malaysia: Chandra Muzaffar;
Pakistan: James D'Mello; Sri Lanka: Harry Haas; Papua New Guinea:
Diosnel Centurion
CONSULTANTS : Mochtar Lubis, Indonesia; McGillicuddy Desmond, Ireland
(JPIC) MillHill, London; Sulak Sivaraksa, Thailand, (Communications);
SUBSCRIPTION RATES
S. Santiago, India, (Community Development); Juan Tan (BATU), Philip- Philippines
pines (Labor); Jessie Tellis Nayak, India, (Women); Dr. Paulita V. Baclig,
Philippines (Health); Maximo T. Kalaw Jr., Philippines, (Alternative Metro Manila - 1 year - Php 750.00
Futures) Provincial - 1 year - Php 800.00
EDITORIAL OFFICE: Asia - 1 year - US$ 45.00
P.O. Box 2481, Manila, Philippines Middle East, Australia, New Zealand - 1 year - US$ 50.00
3/F CBCP Bldg., 470 Gen. Luna St., Intramuros, Manila, Philippines USA, Europe, Canada - 1 year - US$ 55.00
Tel (632) 404-2182 • Telefax (632) 404-1612
LAYOUT BY DENNIS BALDOZA DAYAO
CONTENTS
EDITORIAL
Playing with Human Lives ......................................... 25 Is the Constitution really the cause of our
problems? If it is, let’s change it, for God's sake—
COVER STORY and soonest so that our problems will disappear to
Public Education: SAME OLD PROBLEMS ............16 smithereens before the next impeachment trial makes
a carnival out of congress.
But is it really? Corruption tops our list of
national headaches. This is the gigantic leech that
is sucking the lifeblood of Filipinos depriving them
of proper education, health care, social services
and a dignified future. If changing the constitution
COVER PHOTO CREDIT: DENNIS BALDOZA DAYAO
Volume 40 • Number 7 3
A R T I C L E S
T
he start of the new school year heavy for a poor family to carry. “Kung their skills and abilities as long as every-
brings with it much anticipation and hirap po kami, mas hirap sila,” Herbel states one is treated the same. The latter takes
excitement for the students who are of her classmates’ problems. more factors into account, such as those
eager to return to class, aware that educa- The stories of these two girls provide that equality usually overlooks.
tion will be their key to a better life in the evidence of a growing problem of provid- In essence then, and in the context of
future. Unfortunately, most of them are ing access to higher education for public higher education, providing ‘equitable’
unaware of the difficulties and challenges school students. It is a problem that, if left education is not so much about providing
that lie ahead of them as they progress to unattended, will eventually erode the foun- free tertiary education for all, although this
higher levels of education within our sys- dation of our basic education system in is the ultimate goal, but rather the provi-
tem that is seemingly biased towards those the country like termites starting from the sion of a just environment where individu-
who have more than to those with less. roof instead of just from the base of the als can fully realize their potential, regard-
Former classmates and best friends house. less of their socio-economic status.
Herbel Santiago and Jessica Lopez, both The first step to achieve this is by
16, are just a few of the fortunate youth Do all students have a fair further standardizing the competence lev-
who have been able to secure a college chance? els of our primary and secondary schools,
education. Herbel was the valedictorian of so that even public schools graduates can
Payatas High School while Jessica gradu- Equity as a concept has historically compete with their privately-schooled
ated with honors from Bagong Silang High been a tricky and difficult subject to pin counterparts not just during entrance ex-
School, both in Quezon City. Despite their down. For sure, it is not to be confused ams but also in the classroom. However
parents’ meager income, both of them are with ‘equality’, a term suggesting this is a daunting task considering the
entering respected private Universities this sameness and the provision of similar current developmental state of basic edu-
June with scholarships. cation in the country. Unfortu-
Though these two are the nately, most people equate better
exemptions to the usual fate of education with more of the same
most public high school gradu- While policy changes, things: more textbooks, class-
ates who do not go on to college, rooms and teachers instead of
the two honors students were not especially at the government looking at the competency and
spared the difficulties of finding a
school. Despite being the vale-
level, may take a long time quality of the service provided.
The goal of equitable educa-
dictorian of her class, Herbel was in the making, one tion is not simply the creation of
clueless when it came to college more structures and the acquisi-
application procedures and the organization has aimed to tion of more facilities, but more
scholarships available for her. address some of these importantly the improvement of
For Jessica, the fact that she instruction in our education insti-
had to get information about the problems with tangible tutions especially in the public
schools she was applying to from
her neighbors rather than from
results. Pathways to Higher sector. It is alarming, for example,
that only around 19% of the 53,000
her school gave her the impres- Education (Pathways) is a public school teachers around the
sion that her school did not give country passed the English profi-
importance to the future of its program that aims to assist ciency test conducted by the
graduates, “hindi priority ang deserving public high school DepEd in 2004 (PIA Press Release,
college para sa kanila, hindi 26 April 2006). Expectedly, only
(sila) concerned sa students.” students enter college and 5% of public high school gradu-
(Encouraging the students to go
to college was not a priority for
secure financial scholarships. ates that same year can speak En-
glish well enough for college.
the school).
Unlike their counterparts in Double standard
private schools, public school students opportunities. More than equivalence,
are given very little, if nothing at all, when equity is infused with the liberal notions of The current education system has
it comes to their preparation for college. justice and fairness—in contrast to the allowed for the co-existence of duplicity of
Private high schools provide free entrance more egalitarian if not utopian attitudes standards: one for private schools and the
exam reviews, career guidance counsel- embedded in ‘equality’. In practice, the other for public schools. The disparity
ing, and information on possible scholar- difference is reflected in the implementa- between both standards has grown wider
ships and application procedures while tion of just and considerate programs and over time, as evidenced by the poor perfor-
public schools simply wait for any enter- policies. Equality presupposes the notion mance of public school students in a re-
prising college recruiter to come and visit that what is given to one should be given cent international math and science test.
their schools. to all. Equity on the other hand acknowl- In public schools alone, more than half of
As a result, many talented but poor edges the existence of the individual po- those surveyed for the high school readi-
students are discouraged from pursuing tential and is focused on realizing these. ness test failed when the passing grade
higher education. With the cost of educa- The first does not bother so much with level was at 75%, when it was decreased to
tion rising yearly, even the 300 pesos en- what one can achieve in the future or the 50%, the number of passers increased only
trance exam fee becomes a burden too differences among individuals in terms of slightly. Without saying that the quality
44 IMPACT •• July
IMPACT July 2006
2006
Pathways to
Higher Education © Denz Dayao / IMPACT
of education in private schools is better, ters offering short courses for “in-demand” discouraging considering that by the time
there is definitely a need to raise both to an jobs today such as care giving, computer a generation of school-aged children
equal level of competency and quality. But technology, and nursing aide. Of this num- reach college, only 14% of the students
in this deregulated industry, what mecha- ber, only 174 (9%) are public HEIs, while who entered Grade 1 would have known
nisms have been put in place to ensure all 1,605 are private schools (85%) (CHED). how it feels like (the other 86% would
educational institutions, public and pri- But are these numerous private institu- have already dropped out of basic school-
vate, are providing the proper quality edu- tions performing well? ing). It means that the best of the best, or
cation proportionate to the amount par- Taking as a case the nursing licen- at least those that were left standing to
ents or taxpayers spend their hard-earned sure examination and despite the prolif- continue college, still fail to perform ex-
money for? eration of private “specialized” centers cellently in licensure examinations. But
for training nurses, only 12 (7%) schools again these numbers do not depict the
Higher Education Institution— the had a 90% or higher passing rate. Of these exact situation yet, considering that the
national situation 12, 4 are state universities (UP-Manila calculation is based only on the 89% and
obtaining a 100% passing rate, West 61% of the school aged children who
Currently there are around 1,880 higher Visayas State University, Mindanao State enrolled in elementary and high schools
education institutions (HEIs) in the coun- University-Marawi, and Pamantasan ng (DepEd). In short, there are others not
try recognized by the Commission on Lungsod ng Maynila) (PRC). Within the included in the numbers; children who
Higher Education, and this list does not context of the bigger picture, the situa- may never set their feet on a school in
include small vocational schools and cen- tion that these numbers paint is very their lifetimes.
Volume 40
Volume 40 •• Number
Number 77 55
P a t h w a y s t o H i g h e r E d u c a t i o n
I
n its Final Report submitted to President Aquino in October In a republican and democratic government, such as ours,
1990, one of the recommendations of the Fact-Finding Com- government authority emanates from the people. Ours, however,
mission was a recognition of the unique position of the is not a direct democracy. This authority is expressed through the
Catholic Church in the Philippines as an arbiter on moral issues people’s representatives who are of two general categories,
even in the realm of politics, asserting that: namely, the elective representatives and appointive representa-
The biblical passages condemning rebellion, the exhor- tives. These representatives hold public offices which, by ex-
tation against contributing to it, the moral duty to uphold press mandate of the Constitution, are public trusts. The public
duly-constituted authority, provide the church with strong trust character of a public office demands from its holder account-
moral persuasion to deter rebels and to unite people behind ability to the people at all times, utmost responsibility, integrity,
democracy. Its influence should also be brought to bear on loyalty, and efficiency; and requires the holder to act with
solving the problems of gambling, graft and corruption, and patriotism and justice and to lead a modest life (Section 1 Art. XI,
structural poverty. In the more immediate future, the role of the Constitution).
church is to catalyze the peace process and to progressively Politics is deeply ingrained in governance in a democratic
expand it, regardless of the obstacles placed in its path. The and republican system of government. In its true essence, politics
success of the peace process would heal the festering wounds is the art of good government and effective governance. It means
of the nation and also pave the way to a meaningful electoral civilis ratio, or matters of state, state affairs, statesmanship, or
process and democratic change in 1992. public service (Burton, Legal Thesaurus, 2nd ed., 372).
Volume 40 • Number 7 7
Promoting and Strengthening Mora
whom were dismissed from the service. election day, churches should denounce,
For the same period, 862 court personnel through any possible medium of commu-
were imposed disciplinary sanctions, 114 nication, politicians who resort to dirty
of whom were dismissed from the service. practices to win, and emphasize the sanc-
Also, we used spiritual approach to tity of the ballot and the evils of selling
strengthen moral and ethical values. In votes.
connection with the celebration of the In short the Church must always stress
centenary of the Supreme Court on 11 June that the faithful should never glorify the
2001, we adopted a prayer for the Courts to crooks in public offices.
be recited before meetings or activities of Likewise, we must help cultivate in
the Supreme Court and the Judiciary and our youth the values and virtues of politi-
before court sessions in all other courts. cal morality and decency and the sacred-
The message I wish to put across is ness of the task public officials are to
that our leaders must throw the books, so perform. Our educational system is princi-
to speak, against all those who fail to carry pally called upon to do this. But the CBCP
the sacred task as public servant or refuse again can do more because of its prestige,
or neglect to honor the trust character of spiritual influence, and credibility. It can
their offices. start with the Catholic schools. It can even
Incumbent public officials and politi- embark on a high profile project jointly
cians must change their ways. They must with the COMELEC, such as a project
uphold and honor the public trust charac- providing moral formation for would-be
ter of their offices. This may be extremely politicians. Or it can lend meaningful sup-
difficult to accomplish. But we can help port to some renewal groups and church
them. We can, little by little, prick their organizations now focusing on moral val-
consciences or help them improve not ues. Furthermore, the bishops may con-
their intelligible quotient or IQ but their sider assigning priests to focus on con-
conscience quotient or CQ. The CBCP can science-formation work in the political
do it in a big way—the spiritual way. arena.
Through the priests in the parishes na- Finally, with the spirituality of the
tionwide, the CBCP can effectively pro- desired transformation in mind, the CBCP
mote a spiritual renewal program for the may purse projects and activities ensuring
public officials and personnel through the growth and strengthening of the beau-
various modes, such as, through pastoral tiful practice of daily encounters with God
letters stressing the need for selfless ser- by public officials. As a public official, I
vice and sacrifice, and a reminder of God’s had always started my day with a reading
punishment for ill-gotten wealth. Prov- of the bible. I still and will ceaselessly do
erbs 1:19 says so eloquently: “this is the so, for it makes me feel good during the
fate of everyone greedy of loot: unlawful day. Doing so also takes one way from evil
© Rowena Dalanon / IMPACT
gain takes away the life of him who ac- during the day. And 3 John 11 says: “Be-
articulated the vision-mission with the quires it.” loved, do not imitate evil but imitate good.
introduction and implementation of the Moreover, the parishes may hold regu- Whoever does what is good is of God;
most comprehensive judicial reform pro- lar workshops or focus group discussions whoever does what is evil as never seen
gram the Philippines ever had, under the or ecumenical recollections for the local God.”
title Action Program for Judicial Reform government officials and personnel on the There are many more things we can
(APJR). The World Bank and many other same subject matter. In their homilies local do. In short, we have no reason to lose
institutions recognize this as a model, which priests must also unceasingly stress moral hope for the motherland. The Philippines
other judiciaries may adopt. Under its six and spiritual values and moral leadership. is still the best country for me. In this
components are projects to develop high The parishes should maximize the unfortunate dilemma between good and
sense of moral and ethical values and availment of the support of the various lay evil, the good will always triumph in the
adopt measures to apply these values in religious organizations, such as the end. The book of Revelation teaches us
the performance of judicial duties. Among Knights of Columbus, the Daughters of that despite the painful vicissitudes of
other things, we adopted a New Code of Mary Immaculate International, the CWL, devastations and adversities which we
Judicial Conduct for the Philippine Judi- and the Legion of Mary. When govern- may be subjected to and the occurrences
ciary and a Code of Conduct for Court ment officials and politicians see or are of evil from within or without, for so long
Personnel. At the same time, we imposed made aware that they are being watched, as we trust in the Lord Jesus, and faithfully
disciplinary sanctions on erring justices, they can hearken to the voice of con- awaits His coming, we shall triumph for
judges, and court personnel ranging from science. Jesus is the Victor, the Alpha, and the
dismissal from the service, suspension And during election period, churches Omega. I
from office, impositions of fines, repri- should serve as watchdogs in the conduct (This article is condensed from the paper delivered by
mand, censure to admonition. From Janu- of the election to ensure that voters vote Chief Justice (ret.) Hilario G. Davide, Jr., during the
ary 1999 to 15 November 2005 alone, 747 freely and their votes are counted cor- seminar of the Bishops preceding their 92nd Plenary
Assembly held at Pope Pius XII Catholic Center in
Justices and judges were disciplined, 48 of rectly. Long before and continuously until Manila on January 24, 2006)
Volume 40 • Number 7 9
A R T I C L E S
T
he first message of Pope Benedict achieve or acquire values in life, other
XVI for this year 2006 is entitled “In values are required, the absence of which
Truth, Peace.” It expresses the renders the acquired values immoral or at
Pope’s conviction that “wherever and least questionable.
whenever men and women are enlightened 1. The value of wealth must be sup-
by the splendor of truth, they naturally set ported by the value of work. Wealth
out on the path of peace” (In Truth, Peace, without work means getting some-
3). “If peace is to be authentic and lasting, thing for nothing. One earns but he
it must be built on the bedrock of the truth does not work for it. In this situation,
about God and the truth about man. This one starts telling rational lies to justify
truth alone can create a sensitivity to jus- his wealth taken from graft and corrup-
tice and openness to love and solidarity, tion. Rather wealth must be the fruit of
while encouraging everyone to work for a honest work, not of deception, lies or
truly free and harmonious family” (ITP 15). plain theft. St. Augustine said: “A
Jesus’ saying “The truth will make state which is not governed according
you free” (Jo. 8/32) is the key to clear moral to justice would be just a bunch of
behavior. “According to Christian faith thieves.” (Deus Caritas Est, 28).
and the Church’s teaching,” Pope John 2. The value of pleasure must be accom-
Paul II wrote, “only the freedom which panied by the value of conscience. To
submits to the Truth leads the human be avoided, therefore, is pleasure with-
person to his true good. The good of the out conscience. Pleasurable activities
person is to be in the Truth and to do the without social responsibility or ac-
Truth” (Veritatis Splendor, 84). countability surely leads to degrada-
Human life from one perspective is a tion of integrity and living a life of
warfare between good and evil. We must do double identity. Example of this is pros-
good and avoid evil. Now the Church teaches titution and trafficking of women and
that “there exist acts which per se and in children.
themselves, independently of circumstances, For the protectors of peace, there is
are always seriously wrong by reason of always the struggle to maintain consis-
their object” (VS 80; Reconcilatio et tency in the truth of our identity both in
Poenitentia 17). Vatican II, in Gaudium et our public life and in our private life. As
Spes, gives a number of examples of such we search for the truth and integrity in
acts: “Whatever is hostile to life itself, such our leaders today, we have to strive to
as any kind of homicide, genocide, abortion, be credible prophets as well? let us
euthanasia and voluntary suicide; whatever protect and check our ranks!
violates the integrity of the human person, 3. The acquisition of knowledge must
such as mutilation, physical and mental tor- lead to development of character. To
ture and attempts to coerce the spirit; what- be avoided, therefore is knowledge
ever is offensive to human dignity, such as without character. When one closes
subhuman living conditions, arbitrary im- himself to listen to the knowledge or
prisonment, deportation, slavery, prostitu- suggestion of others, believing that
tion and trafficking in women and children; he has the monopoly of knowledge by Angel N. Lagdameo, DD
degrading conditions of work which treat and of truth, there lies the danger. He
laborers as mere instruments of profit, and will have a myopic view of the situa-
not as free responsible persons; all these and tion and his decision will be less character to face and accept the truth?
the like are a disgrace, and so long as they grounded. Present studies today show the truth that we made a mistake?
infect human civilization they contaminate that a person need not only have IQ 4. What about business and morality?
those who inflict them more than those who (intelligence quotient) and EQ (emo- Economic and political transactions
suffer injustice, and they are a negation of tional quotient) but also AQ (adver- must ultimately be based on moral
the honor due to the Creator” (GS 27; VS 80). sity quotient). Adversity quotient is foundations. People get into trouble
The Pope reiterates: “If acts are intrinsically the capacity of the person to deal with when elements in the transaction are
evil, a good intention or particular circum- the adversities of his life (Paul Stoltz, covert, hidden, secret. When they keep
stance can never transform an act intrinsi- Adversity Quotient: Turning Ob- hidden agenda and they rationalize
cally evil by virtue of its object into an act stacles into Opportunities.) Character even the wrong or immoral activities,
‘subjectively’ good or defensible as a choice” is the capacity to face the truth regard- when it is business without moral
(VS 81). ing the consequences of the choices values it will soon be bad economics or
The CBCP has entitled one of its re- that one has made in life. bad politics. Morality in business leads
cent Pastoral Statements as “Renewing There are times in the service we thought to trust, confidence and transparency.
Public Life through Moral Values!” Tak- we had made the best decision, be- 5. Science and technology must serve
ing its suggestion, we can say that values cause the matter was thoroughly ana- the common good. However when it is
formation is an urgent and necessary step lyzed, but later it was found out that it developed for the advantage only of
towards social transformation. In order to was not correct. Will we have the some groups or individuals, then it
does not serve the good of society. sacrifice to serve the needs of other welfare of the greatest number.
Science without humanity can also be people ? the sacrifice of our own pride What I have outlined are some seven
exploitative of people and natural re- and prejudice, the sacrifice of our com- ways to truth and peace, some seven ways
sources. Those who want to gain from fort and pleasure, the sacrifice of our of renewing public life through the corre-
scientific technologies may present time and treasure ? the sacrifice of our sponding values. The combination of
bias information giving emphasis on life. Religion without sacrifice is not wealth and work, pleasure and conscience,
the benefits but not pointing out the a genuine religion knowledge and character, business and
negative effects to environment and 7. The same may be said about politics. morality, science and humanity, religion
to people, such as happening with Politics must be governed and guided and sacrifice, politics and principles. Keep
some mining industry. by the values of principle. Politics with- the pairs together. The first in the enu-
6. What about religion and sacrifice? out principle is very dangerous: it can meration must not be without the other. In
When the purpose of doing religious be exploitative and is a disservice to the the way to peace, personal, communitarian
ritual like prayer and offering Mass, is welfare of the people it is to protect and or national, the truth of one must be guided
only to save oneself, then such a reli- serve. The key to a healthy society is to by the truth of the other.
gious act is wanting and not a product get the social will, the value system (The foregoing piece is a talk delivered by CBCP
of true religion. True religion produces aligned with correct principles. Prin- President Archbishop Angel N. Lagdameo to the
life giving relationships and maintains ciple-guided politics will always be members of the Philippine National Police on
this relationship by sacrifice. It takes purpose-driven politics and that is the May 15, 2006, Manila.)
Volume 40 • Number 7 11
A R T I C L E S
D
uring the first weekend of February ods too difficult to adopt? The objectives for our NFP program
2006, I joined a training seminar on From our pastoral experience in Ipil, include the following:
natural family planning methods in we realize that the majority of couples • To adopt a proactive pastoral approach
Roxas City. This was sponsored by the today have three felt needs: a) They want to address the felt needs of couples for
Archdiocese of Capiz which was inter- family planning—i.e., to plan the size of family planning;
ested to know more about our All-NFP their family and to space births; b) They • To offer an All-NFP program by making
program for Responsible Parenthood in prefer natural family planning, if given available information on all modern,
Ipil Prelature. Hence, three trainors from adequate information on fertility aware- scientific NFP methods; and
the prelature teamed up with two Manila- ness and NFP methods; and c) They want • To promote the value formation that is
based trainors from the Institute for Re- to choose among NFP methods—to suit integral to our Family Life Apostolate
productive Health to give the intensive their own circumstances and preference. and to enable couples to make an in-
2½-day seminar on all NFP methods. In all, Our biggest challenge then may not formed and responsible choice, based
there were 62 participants representing 29 be to confront government or an interna- on the formation of a right conscience.
of the 33 parishes of the archdiocese. tional conspiracy but rather to address In the light of these vision and objec-
Some participants had already been the felt needs of thousands of married tives, we have adopted four pastoral
teaching the Billings Ovulation Method couples in our rural and urban poor neigh- guidelines for our All-NFP program in the
in pre-Cana seminars. Only a few, how- borhoods. For the most part, these are prelature.
ever, had heard about the Standard Days couples who are looking for and are ready We are pro-life. This is our first prin-
Method. And no parish at all had a moni- to adopt any of the NFP methods that we ciple. We are at the service of life from the
toring system to follow up actual users. can show them to be safe, reliable, inex- moment of conception. Hence, we are
Everyone agreed that much more needed pensive, and practicable. against abortion, which is also proscribed
to be done to mainstream NFP by our Constitution.
and to reach out to as many We are for Responsible Par-
Ecclesial Communities at
into the world is the right and
Pastoral Situation responsibility of Christian par-
ents.
From a national perspective,
the latest Philippine demographic the chapel and neighborhood We are for Natural Family
Planning. This is our recom-
and health survey indicates that
only 33% of currently married cell levels. Indeed, our mended means in consonance
with the moral teaching of the
all, the question can be raised whether or has been a pilot area for the earlier NFP All-NFP program for the prelature.
not these couples are forced by circum- methods—such as the Basal Body Tem- SDM is a new calendar-based method
stances to make uninformed and irrespon- perature method (BBT) and the Billings of family planning based on fertility aware-
sible choices in a matter that is crucial to Ovulation Method (BOM). However, with ness. It helps a woman know her fertile
their family life. Ultimately, neither the the dissociation of the church from the days by simply counting the days of her
government nor the church can make this government’s family planning program cycle, starting with the first day of men-
choice for couples. It is their inherent and the end of outside funding by the struation. It identifies days 8-19 of the
right and duty as responsible parents and mid-80’s, the NFP program reached a pla- cycle as the fertile period when preg-
citizens to have this freedom of choice for teau and slowed down. nancy may occur if there is intercourse.
themselves. This is the goal of Respon- In October 2001, some of our prelature Days 1-7 and the rest of the days after day
sible Parenthood that both Church and workers visited Impasugong, Bukidnon, 19 are identified as non-fertile days.
State subscribe to. where a new NFP method, called the Stan- SDM’s “fertile window” of days 8-19
dard Days Method (SDM), was being has been standardized and is applicable
Towards an All-NFP Program piloted among small farmer couples. Be- only for women whose menstrual cycles
cause of its simplicity in teaching fertility range from 26 to 32 days. It is estimated
Since the mid-70’s, the Prelature of awareness with the aid of a string of cycle that three-fourths of all women are within
Ipil, which was then a Jesuit Mission beads, practically all the parishes agreed this cycle range. Hence, it is made clear
District of the Archdiocese of Zamboanga, to include SDM in, what we now call, the from the outset that SDM is not appli-
Volume 40 • Number 7 13
A R T I C L E S
ease!
Rel
New cable to all women. In this sense, despite
its simplicity, SDM cannot be the exclu-
provider at the household level; and (5)
periodic reporting from the kapilya to
sive NFP method for the local church to the parish up to the prelature levels.
promote; but neither should it be the In September 2004, our NFP parish
excluded method. coordinators underwent a four-day re-
SDM was developed by the Institute fresher course on all NFP methods, given
for Reproductive Health (IRH) of by the staff of the Institute for Repro-
Georgetown University, the oldest Catho- ductive Health (Phil.), an affiliate of
lic university in the United States. It is the Georgetown University which had de-
result of an extensive research process veloped SDM and other simplified NFP
spanning six years since the mid-90’s, methods. Starting with an overview of
involving pilot sites in Bolivia, Peru and fertility awareness, the IRH staff went
the Philippines. It has been clinically on to discuss the distinctive features of
tested with a high effectiveness rate of each method to enable the participants
ovc.blogspot.com
Its Place in
these duties, rights and func-
tions, harmonious interplay and
dynamic order are to be observed.
T
he presence of the Conse- the labor force. A substantial been straddling was formerly
crated life in dioceses and amount was imposed on the ad- used as a parochial school. Both larly of sacred power and of the
other local Churches is ministration to pay labor. But it the school and the lot were administration of the sacraments,
more often than not taken as a appeared that the fiscal obliga- owned by the archdiocese. Later, is properly ordered; that the
matter of fact. Yet its impact on tion was too onerous. It was for more efficient administration mutual relationships of Christ’s
the life of the faithful cannot be brought to the higher court. But it was donated to the said reli- faithful are reconciled in justice
denied. Hence, the need to study the court of appeal upheld the gious congregation with a spe- based on charity, with the rights
its juridical status in its relation decision of the lower court. So cific condition that it be used for of each safeguarded and de-
to the local Church. It may ap- the fiscal obligation remained. Catholic education. When in the fined” (Ap. Const.: Sacrae
pear to many as a tame topic, but The religious community, the future it will no longer be used for Disciplinae Leges, 25 January
once one comes into it, he will be owner and administrator of the that purpose, the lot has to be 1983).
surprised at how interesting it university, on the face of such a returned to the diocese. The What then is the juridical
really is. A case at bar will con- staggering amount declared it- contract had been drawn accord- locus of the consecrated life in
firm the point. self bankrupt and officially closed ing to this specification and duly the diocese? This question be-
The issue happened in the shop. Not reneging on the obli- signed by the parties concerned comes more pressing when we
Archdiocese of Palo. Some ten gation exacted by the court, the . Based on this, the diocese pur- take into consideration that
years ago the Divine Word Uni- religious congregation started sued its right; the religious con- many of them have become inte-
versity of Tacloban was closed, paying by installment. But it gregation dilly-dallied. The gral part of the life of the local
depriving Leyte and Samar the soon discovered some irregu- former requested Rome to inter- churches, welcomed by bishops
Catholic university that stands larities in the way the money was vene. Rome obliged. And so all and priests within the diocesan
as a symbol of their educational distributed among the employ- parties, that is, the religious con- and parochial structures, yet,
standard. The cause of the clo- ees themselves. Payment was gregation, the diocese, and la- sustain some elements foreign
sure is some labor problems. The stopped. Hope for the univer- bor were called to resolve the to the hierarchical church. These
employees were demanding for sity to open again was getting issue. Last February 21, 2006, all are the structures of the conse-
better benefits. As no positive dimmer. the parties concerned finally crated life, the physical institu-
response was taken by the reli- Meantime, the Archdiocese agreed on the final resolution of tions of the religious congrega-
gious congregation, the owner of Palo felt itself aggrieved by the case. A Catholic school will tions.
and administrator of the said the case, not only because the again be opened. At first blush it would seem
university, the employees people of the place clamored for In the cited case, the Con- that the institutes of consecrated
brought the case to court for intervention, but also because it secrated life which runs the uni- life are pitted against the dio-
proper resolution. After years of has a ground to complain. As versity is no longer a mere still cese/parish as two contrasting
litigation, the court handed down history would tell, the lot on picture, nor an abstract defini- structures. The diocese/parish
a decision that was favorable to which the university complex has tion lifted from canon law books, Consecrated Life / p. 20
Volume 40 • Number 7 15
C O V E R S T O
by Marilou Mahilum
A
pparently, President Arroyo’s outburst and the tongue-
lashing Acting Secretary Fe Hidalgo of DepEd received
during the May 30 Cabinet meeting would have spurred
a much-needed dose of good news for the country’s long
deteriorating educational system: that, as it were, the Arroyo
government has finally licked the perennial problem of classroom
shortage. This, Arroyo claimed to have done—and thus after
having publicly rebuked Acting Secretary Hidalgo for suppos-
edly reporting the “wrong” information on classroom short-
ages—by declaring the adoption of a double-shift class schedule
and the ratio of 100 students to a class.
Has President Arroyo’s decree, less her outburst, struck a
spot of cheer? Almost immediately, it did. Touted as creative
arithmetic, the Philippine Daily Inquirer in its June 6 editorial
rushed to point out that Arroyo’s decreed adoption of a double-
shift schedule and a ratio of 100 students to a class “miracu-
lously” solved, albeit as palliative measure, a very real shortage
of over 74,000 classrooms.
But it’s not all that well and simple—and informed critics
aren’t taking Arroyo’s “creative solution” hook, line and sinker.
That there is indeed a very real shortage of classrooms in the
country—74,115 classrooms, if estimated on the ideal single-
shift setting at 50 students per class—is a fact beyond dispute.
But that Arroyo’s creative arithmetic of double-shift and 100
students to every class would “miraculously” wipe out or solve
the over 74,000-clasroom shortage, critics cannot but remain
skeptical about such “miracle”. Even, as Yvonne Chua of the
Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism reported, to go
double-shift at 50 students per class, which is reportedly the
President’s preferred strategy, there would still be a shortage of
6,832 classrooms, the figure which Secretary Hidalgo rightly
reported—and earned the President’s outburst.
“There is a serious shortage of classrooms nationwide that no
amount of ‘manipulation of numbers’ will do away wit it. And we
better face up to this fact rather than try to wish that shortage away
through economics or mathematics or whatever form of analysis
there is in the highest office in the land,” Chua pointed out.
Neither double-shifting class hours nor lumping 100 students
into small rooms like sardines is a productive solution to the ever
declining quality of education in the country. “The truth is that a
classroom should only be used by one class per day (especially in
the higher grades) because double or even triple-shifting takes
away class time from students. And as everyone should know,
cutting short class time will only serve to cut short learning time.
If students don’t learn because they have less time in class, that
is the crux of the low achievement problem,” Chua argued.
16 IMPACT
IMPACT • July 2006
O R Y
Public Education:
SAME OLD PROBLEMS
©
Volume 40 • Number 7 17
P u b l i c E d u c a t i o n :
country’s educational system yet remains to learn a lot if five or six of them have to mally learned by a Grade 4 student.
on the edge of a never-ending cycle of the share one textbook?” • Roughly 1% of Filipino children, de-
same old problems, faintly remedied, if rather “The teachers are the key people in the spite of President Arroyo’s educa-
perpetrated, by mere politically-coated pal- educational system. But how can we expect tion-for-all imperative, do not have
liative, and the measure of success of which the teachers to teach well if they themselves access to basic elementary education.
are as illusive as its political posturings. are ill-trained? There are many stories of • Only 68% of students complete the
“That the Philippine educational sys- teachers who are semi-literate or who teach elementary grades, 42% finish high
tem is in a bad shape has been known for the their students the wrong things, or who are school, and 14% graduate from col-
past two or three decades, but nothing just one chapter ahead of their students in lege.
really radical has been done to correct the digesting the books they use in teaching. • Of the country’s Grade 6 kids, only 26%
situation. Remedies have at best been The best teachers are leaving for jobs have a mastery of English, 15% of
palliatives or stop-gap measures,” stated abroad, and the mediocre ones are left to Science and 31% of Math.
the Philippine Daily Inquirer’s editorial of teach the nation’s youth in the public • Only 7% of senior high school stu-
last June 6. schools. How can we expect our children to dents had mastered English; 2% Sci-
More ostensibly, the same editorial do well in school if they have poorly edu- ence, and 16% Math.
didn’t miss to mention the cyclical prob- cated teachers?,” the Inquirer editorial • The national average score in the
lems, apart from classroom shortage, that added. TIMSS (Trends in Math and Science
continue bedeviling the country’s school Survey) in 2003 was 378 in Math—89
system. “Every year, the complaints are the Grim Statistics points behind the international aver-
same: a shortage of classrooms, desks and age and 227 points away from the
textbooks and a lack of trained teachers. If that litany of never-ending educa- highest score notched by Singapore.
What is worse is that some of the textbooks tion woes sounds like a repetitive hype, “It will take the Philippines 11 to 12
have been found to contain many errors.” it’s not. More than the continuing cycle of years to narrow the gap with the world
Not only is there a scourge of scarcity the same old problems which likely have average in achievement tests and 25 to 28
of physical resources but the country is already desensitized not a few Filipinos years to reach the Singapore level,” Papa
undoubtedly suffering even more the curse vis-à-vis such problems, official statistics said, quoting the DepEd in a presentation
of a deteriorating quality of education pre- on the current grim state of Philippine to the Cabinet in July 2005.
cipitated by double-shift class hours, ex- education are themselves very telling even
ploding student population in every class, more. Licking the Perennial Woes
and overseas migration of competent teach- Alcuin Papa, in his Special Report
ers. article in the June 5 issue of the Philippine Given the undisputed enormity of de-
The Inquirer editorial pointedly stated, Daily Inquirer, reports the following reali- bilitating education woes and with a govern-
“The physical setting, of course, is second- ties as drawn from the Department of ment yet likely unable to forge any radical
ary in importance to the content of educa- Education’s data: reform, the country’s education sector yet
tion. But is it the ideal setting for students • Of the 57.6 million Filipinos aged 10 to faces hard questions on how to put an end
to be packed into small rooms like sardines, 64 years, 9.2 million or 16% are “func- to the cycle of same old problems.
or be made to rush through several subjects tionally illiterate”. This means these Already, to date, some resonant voices
in four-hour sessions, so that the next batch people are unable to read, write, sub- for reforms and other creative ways to lick the
can be accommodated for the afternoon tract and add, or understand simple ailing, if dying, education system have vari-
session? And how can we expect students instructions—something that is nor- ably sprouted to the fore—largely from pri-
vate sector assistance, believed to one of the Power has since been conducting skills train- tion. Vietnam, which basically has the same
rare bright spots in the current bleak public ing workshops to public school teachers number of students as the Philippines, ac-
school system. nationwide. cording to former Education Secretary
One, according to informed observers But still, even the aggregate initiatives Florencio Abad, is increasing education’s
and critics, is to increase private and public and contributions of these private groups share of its budget to 22 percent next year. It
sector partnerships. A prominent example of and corporations are yet deemed not enough is fielding about a million teachers for the
this is the GASTPE (government Assistance gleaned against a backdrop of a burgeoning, same number of students as the Philippines.
to Students and Teachers in Private Educa- if exploding, public school population But, according to Abad, it is not a ques-
tion) program, created through Republic Act prompted by the equally wrenching eco- tion of money. It is about setting priorities
6728. Since the early 1990s, GASTPE has nomic crisis. right. He points to the P300-billion-a-year
paid private high schools an annual subsidy A rather rational solution, echoed by fiscal incentives program. “We are giving up
so that lower-income families could enroll most critics and observers, to the ailing incentives to all sorts of businesses that, I
their children in these schools. In school educational system is to jack up the budget think, most anyway don’t need,” he says.
year 2005-2006, GASTPE—lodged in the outlay for the education sector. Thanks On the whole, hence, critics and non-
DepEd budget—paid over 382,000 students though to the May 30 incident about the critics alike may yet agree that the key to
from low-income families to study in over President’s tongue-lashing on Acting Sec- licking, once and for all, the wrenching pe-
1,700 private high schools nationwide at a retary Hidalgo which, in an apparent stroke rennial education muck in the country may
rate of P4,000 per student. Managed by of serendipity, has yielded a good result: the just lie on the question of “setting the priori-
FAPE (Fund for Assistance to Private Edu- members of the bicameral conference com- ties right” on the part of the government.
cation), the total budget for GASTPE was 1.5 mittee on the proposed 2006 national budget Inarguably, the urgent imperative to reform
billion in 2005 and 1.72 billion in 2006. agreed to increase the Department of or rescue the ailing education system right-
But not all went well though with Education’s P102-billion outlay by about P4 fully calls for the government to precisely
GASTPE. Private schools, mostly Catholic billion. make, through firm resolve or political will,
ones, have decried the perennial delays of Even so, critics decry, that such amount education as prime priority—in budget allo-
the subsidy payment. As of March 2005 for is inarguably paltry enough to effect any cation, and comprehensively as well in its
instance, according to CEAP (Catholic Edu- significant reform to salvage or rescue the programs and strategies, devoid of political
cational Association of the Philippines) na- sinking state of education. posturings. This includes, for one, putting
tional executive director Mariano Piamonte, Education is supposed to get, most an end to the era of palliatives and stop-gap
roughly 50% of GASTPE beneficiaries in observers believe, the biggest share of na- measures—like that of President Arroyo’s
private schools have not been paid yet their tional budget, but it is not: debt service gets “creative arithmetic”—or stripping away bu-
grants for the school year 2004-2005. In some the biggest outlay. In the current national reaucratic layers and finding a mechanism to
cases, Piamonte added, back accounts of budget, the outlay for debt service is P301.7 make the bureaucracy answerable to the
GASTPE beneficiaries in private schools billion or almost three times the P102-billion people.
would remain unsettled even after gradua- appropriation for the Department of Educa- But, whichever means or ways, the tall
tion. tion. order of the day likely calls for setting, en-
In a new twist, GASTPE has recently DepEd’s current budget share actually forcing and realizing an authentic, lasting or
become a “voucher” program and in all like- represents only 12-percent of the national sustainable policy and program for educa-
lihood the distribution of vouchers will now budget, way below the international bench- tion, and thus ensure that every child is
be given to the local government units, mark of a 20-percent budget share for educa- better educated, and with better value. I
rather than to the education sector. With
this, critics believe, the program is being
hijacked for political rather than education
ends.
Private businessmen and corporate do-
nors have likewise contributed reform initia-
tives to the ailing public school system. The
Federation of Filipino-Chinese Chambers of
Commerce and Industry, Inc. (FFCCCII), for
instance, is the biggest and longest-running
private donor of classrooms, with 3,200 two-
room schoolhouses built since 1960. There
is also the Ayala Foundation Inc. (AFI)
which hopes to connect, in the next five
years, all 5,500 high schools nationwide to
the Internet. The Foundation for the Up-
grading of Education (FUSE), also, has pro-
duced a set of instructional tapes known as
Constel (Continuing Studies Through Edu-
cation) which have since been viewed by
around 10,000 public school teachers. And
lastly, the “Mentoring the Mentors” project
of the Foundation for Worldwide People
Volume 40 • Number 7 19
A teacher’s guide called “Adolescent
Consecrated Life / from p. 15 understand Christ without the Holy Spirit. Reproductive Health” (A Population
(www.crossroadsinitiative.com/ Education Concept) has been stirring
is hierarchical in its juridical embodiment library_article/549/ Theological Locus of debates among church circles and pro-
while the institute of consecrated/religious Ecclesial Movements) life groups. The lessons were based on
life, notwithstanding its public juridical struc- To clarify the issue at hand, the Cardinal the Population Education Curriculum
ture within the church, is charismatic in ty- then presented the perspective of Church and integrated with the competencies
pology. Its existence is real, but non-hierar- history. He said that in the history of the in the Basic Education Curriculum 2002
chical. Ordinarily, it exercises great influence Church as a whole, the local Church with the of the secondary level.
in the local community, yet it enjoys an Episcopal office as its defining mark, is not in While some applauded its bravado
autonomy of life, programs and activities contraposition with the apostolic movement. in teaching sex education, others
that oftentimes are not within the purview of The apostles were not bishops of particular voiced fear it could introduce minors
the local authority. It possesses its own local churches, but responsible for the whole to a dangerous territory.
communal yet private properties, assets and world and for the whole Church that was to
The module claims to help stu-
liabilities and yet is not required to give a be built. It is through this apostolic office that
dents “understand their sexuality and
regular accounting report to the bishop of gave birth to local churches. Hence, from the
very beginning, there existed two structures protect them from unwanted pregnan-
the territory. It seems that it is alien to the cies, sexually transmitted diseases, and
hierarchical organization, yet it is a flesh- in the Church, namely, the universal (apos-
tolic) and the local. They existed side by side the subsequent risk of infertility.”
and-blood reality within the church, with a Critics of the project, initially
life ever pointing to something mysterious with each other with smooth interrelation-
ship. They are the supporting structure that implemented in public schools in
beyond the horizon of the community’s natu- Parañaque City and Payatas which
ral consciousness. permanently upholds the edifice of the
Church through all ages. Hence, the bishops served as the “pilot schools”, de-
Is duality of the hierarchical structure of nounce its content especially on the
the diocese and the charismatic institutions must not forget this perspective of history.
In the thick of his activities in building up the “active promotion of value free sex
of religious institutes the accepted locus to education.”
ground the relationship between these two local Church assigned to him, he must al-
ways consider the Church as a whole and It claims to foster values, restraint
realities, ever invoking the dialectic of re- and responsibility yet it implies that
spect for each others’ autonomy and inde- therefore must go beyond the administra-
tion of their respective dioceses. They must sexual activity outside marriage maybe
pendence? Is it right to say that the Church acceptable for as long as it does not
is constituted with two independent struc- ensure the carrying on of Jesus’ mission to
make all nations his disciples and to bring the result to ‘unwanted pregnancy’ and
tures based on the dual contrasting, if not sexually transmitted infections (STI)
opposing, principles, namely, 1) institution gospel to the ends of the earth. They have to
sustain the universal dynamism of the by ‘protected sex,’ says Dr. Angelita
and charism; or, 2) Christology and Aguirre of Human Life International.
Pneumatology? Or, are there other existing apostolate and must be opened to the work-
ing of the Spirit who has guided the Church However, interview with some
ecclesial principles that could assure a closer people reveal that they view the pro-
communion and participation between the and caused irruptions of charisms, which
have prodded the rise of the great move- gram as reflecting reality more than
particular Church and the charismatic insti- anything else.
ments that have built up the local Churches
tutes of consecrated life? On one hand, they view the pro-
as well as the Church as a whole. (Ibid).
In this regard, it is interesting to note It is for this reason that Cardinal gram as a commendable idea of incor-
that Cardinal Ratzinger (who became Pope Ratzinger appealed for deeper understand- porating sex education into various
Benedict VI), in his June 1999 address to the ing between the two structures, the apos- high schools subjects.
bishops gathered in Rome for a meeting on tolic (universal Church) and the local Eighteen-year old Joan Santos
ecclesial movements in the Church, sum- Churches. He said: “All must let themselves said, “At young age, children must be
marily brushed off the attempts to resolve be measured by love for the unity of the one taught to be responsible when it comes
the seemingly conflicting issues between Church, which is only one in all local churches to sex when they reach their reproduc-
the local Church and the institutes of conse- and appears as such again and again in the tive ages.”
crated life by the invocation of the dialectic apostolic movements.” He then concluded: “It must be one of the youth’s
of dual principles. He denies that the local “The local churches and the apostolic move- rights to properly know the things re-
institution is in contraposition to charism. ments must constantly recognize and accept lated to their very own body. And if the
For he averred that analyzing closely the the simultaneous truth of two propositions: parents can’t do the job, better give it
local church, it is not all human organizations ubi Petrus, ibi ecclesia – ubi episcopus, ibi to the school institutions,” Santos
and structures. Deep within its life is its ecclesia. Primacy and episcopacy, the local added.
dependence on the irruption of the Holy ecclesial system and apostolic movements, For Alex Danao, however, some of
Spirit. Hence, for the local Church not to need each other: the primacy can live only the contents are a bit “too much” for
atrophy it must live its spiritual office with and through a living episcopacy, the students. Still, the sixteen-year old
charismatically, that is, it must have an intrin- episcopacy can preserve its dynamic and said, “sex education is important.”
sic openness to charisms. He also denies the apostolic unity only in ordination to the Some parents find the program “of-
attempt of contrasting Christology and primacy. Where one of the two is weakened, fensive” and fear the promotions of
Pneumatology, putting Christ in the Church as a whole suffers”. I contraceptives are likely to interest
contraposition to the Holy Spirit. For, “the (Most Rev. Leonardo Y. Medroso, DD, is the
young people in trying out sex.
Spirit cannot be correctly understood with- bishop of the Diocese of Borongan and the Chair-
Had it not been exposed earlier,
out Christ, but it is equally impossible to man of the CBCP Commission on Canon Law.)
the program might have been success-
by Roy Lagarde
fully and quietly smuggled into vari- of the Philippines (CBCP), there’s more
ous subjects. But it was yanked by for the DepEd’s new program than just
inter-faith groups. mere education on sexuality.
Getting the “negative” feedback, In truth, the modules are a way to
DepEd Acting Secretary Fe Hidalgo push the hidden agenda of the United
recalled the guides and ordered a de- Nations Population Fund (UNPF) popu-
tailed evaluation and additional con- lation control program, says Aniceto.
sultation. “We share the Church’s con- And for Aguirre, it’s business as
cern over such a sensitive issue and usual. She said DepEd module pub-
we hope we can work things out with lishers must study the data presented
them in relation to the issue,” she by demographers and economists who
points out. do not benefit from the birth control
The rationale for the module is industry.
supposed to be “overpopulation and The module is devoid of “full dis-
poverty.” But for Archbishop Paciano closure and truth telling” because it
Aniceto, chairman of the Episcopal fails to inform the students that a con-
Commission of Family (ECFL) and Life dom does not guarantee 100-percent
of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference protection from sexually transmitted
Volume 40 • Number 7 21
A R T I C L E S
I
’m happy to learn that our alienated from the world, a forces… gospel passages to justify their
bishops have declared this Christian life excessively con- “The direct duty to work actions, much like the devil
year as the Year of Social cerned with personal sanctity for a just ordering of society, who, in tempting Christ in the
Concerns. I suppose it’s one but indifferent to the apostolate on the other hand, is proper to desert, also quoted Scriptural
concrete way of sensitizing ev- in all its expressions. the lay faithful. As citizens of lines with clearly twisted inten-
eryone of the need to develop Love for God always en- the State, they are called to take tions.
a deep and effective social men- tails love for neighbor. Our Lord part in the public life in a per- They say their cause is
tality. said, “As long as you did it to sonal capacity—in the many just and useful. They fail to
We cannot exaggerate one of your least brethren, you different economic, social, leg- realize that their actuations lead
that need. We know that man, did it to me.” (Mt 25, 40) Love islative, administrative and to recklessly using the Church
while an individual person, is for God would be nullified if cultural areas… for the com- merely to voice personal opin-
also a social being. The two there is no accompanying love mon good.” ions and partisan views, or to
positions, while distinct and for neighbor. I find these words clear develop social and political
demanding specific require- But like Christ, we have to enough, and yet they are fron- theories, etc. Amazing!
ments cannot be separated. know how to show this love for tally violated when some At this age where informa-
They always have to go to- neighbor, how this social men- Church leaders choose to take tion come to us quick and fast,
gether. tality ought to be developed concrete sides in social and it pains me to see these clerics
We just have to find a way and expressed. I believe we political issues. still out in the dark insofar as
to blend these two dimensions have big problems in this deli- With brazen show of primi- proper Church attitude and
together, voiding the extremes cate area, not yet properly un- tive clericalism, acting like prima clergy behavior with respect to
of selfish personal individual- derstood even by ecclesias- donnas, if not like clowns, com- social and political issues are
ism and pietism on the one tics. plete with shrill voices and concerned.
hand, and mindless, impersonal One clarification can come comic gestures, they directly Is this the way to unite the
socialism and activism on the from Pope Benedict’s first en- and actively participate in po- Christian faithful, to strengthen
other. cyclical, Deus caritas est, where litical activities, pontificating our sense of Church? Where
With the Church’s stress he said: “The formation of just on issues that are open to opin- are the corrections, the mea-
on social concerns for this year, structures is not directly the ion. sures to keep us away from
I guess the idea is to correct a duty of the Church, but be- Some have managed to these leaders who are showing
Christianity that tends to be longs to the world of politics, convey to the press ideas that clear signs of being false proph-
too ‘vertical’ in its attitudes the sphere of the autonomous are clearly dangerously impro- ets?
and practices towards God at use of reason... vised, with hardly any basis The clergy should concen-
the expense of her ‘horizontal’ “The Church has an indi- scientifically or pastorally. In trate on our specific field of
duties towards our neighbor. rect duty in that she is called to the end, only embarrassment concern. That’s more than what
Other ways of describing contribute to the purification for the whole Church is we can handle without stray-
this anomaly are a Christianity of reason and to the achieved. ing into areas for which we
confined to the churches and reawakening of the moral Some even dare to quote have no direct authority. I
ANSWER TO LAST ISSUE: IN SCIENCE THE CREDIT GOES TO THE MAN WHO CONVINCES THE WORLD, NOT TO THE MAN WHOM THE IDEA FIRST
OCCURS -- FRANCIS DARWIN
Volume 40 • Number 7 23
F R O M T H E B L O G S
L
ying, cheating and stealing, deception, op- political power and influence, it is a big betrayal
pression and exploitation, abduction, vio of their commitment to the Gospel truth if church- social condition of the country. When churchmen
lence and murder—these are definitely not men would play blind, deaf, and dumb and thereby are quiet and in peace, this means that the govern-
simply political issues but downright moral ab- do nothing to counter such socio-political atroci- ment is by and large doing well. But when they
errations. Politics is the art of governance—not ties. When people are downgraded in dignity and begin to talk in public fora and act in public places
the right to promote selfish political interests violated in their human rights, woe to the church due to social issues, this is a marked indication
over and above the dictates of justice and truth, when this says and does nothing about it. that there must be something that stinks in and
the demands of public good and common welfare. The ministry of love by the Church certainly about the government.
Confronted by such falsity and malevolence includes the work of social justice. Love of neigh- When will the “trapos” learn -- if ever!
promoted or perpetrated by those in position of bor means much more than just feeding, clothing www.ovc.blogspot.com
T
o allow or to stop im- right or wrong, the difference
peachment. To surface Malacañang Predicament between licit and illicit, the dis-
the truth or to live in tinction between what is moral
doubt. To confirm legitimacy and immoral. Precisely, the
or to govern under the shadow politicians who think and act
of illegitimacy. These consti- with utter disregard between
tute the big Malacañang pre- virtue and vice, are those who
dicament of the days ahead. are big social liabilities. They
The choice among the are precisely the promoters of
above alternatives will spell public injustice, disorder and
what is in store for the adminis- discontent.
tration in the coming years. Will It is disastrous both for
it be a stable government or social justice and peace if poli-
one that is repeatedly chal- tics and ethics were altogether
lenged in its existence? Will it divorced. If politicians and mor-
be a trusted and respectable als were irrelevant to each other.
government or one that has to Precisely, at the bottom of all
bear continuous accusations government lies, cheatings and
and repeated indictments? stealing happen when those
Unless the Malacañang holding public offices think, live
predicament is resolved for the and act without ethical prin-
better, then it becomes the worst ciples, above moral norms.
for the government as well as for Only the resolution of the
the people. The adverse effects Malacañang predicament in
of such a big predicament are favor of justice and truth would
already on hard. They consti- © Rowena Dalanon / IMPACT
give a closure to the long on-
tute the basic causal factor of Impeachment is said to be peachment merely reduced to going public dissent and re-
national poverty and public dis- a political matter. But is it purely the tyranny of political allies, sentment, would make the
orientation, the division of a political issue divested of any to the issue of majority party? country move on, would bring
people and the beclouding of and all moral elements? Con- Woe to a country if politi- about public order and peace.
the country’s future. sidered a partisan issue, is im- cians were above the norm of www.ovc.blogspot.com
Volume 40 • Number 7 25
S T A T E M E N T
Liberating Our Country offer our country a new breed and brand of
leaders; 3) that if charter change is to be
pursued, it should be through a Constitu-
from “Unfreedoms”
tional Convention, whose delegates are
elected by the people. We are not against
charter-change per se; but we are against
charter-change by the present congress
converting itself into a Constituent As-
sembly. From history we learn that dicta-
W
e celebrate today the Philippine that we are experiencing.
Independence Day with grati- In 1998 during the Centennial Celebra- tors are products of and supported by
tude for everything that has been tion of our Independence, the CBCP al- parliamentary forms of government.
in our history. We honor the heroes big ready stated that “our liberty is eroded not Philippine Independence Day is an
and small, known and unknown, who have so much by foreign invaders, as by inequal- occasion to promote “a spirituality of citi-
worked for our liberation as a nation. ity and lack of participation, injustice and zenship” which fosters a sense of patrio-
But while we succeeded in breaking exploitation, deficient cultural values and tism and of being responsible for our coun-
the yoke and chain of Spanish, Japanese mindset, destruction of the ecosystem, and try. “It develops Filipinos into becoming
and American colonizers, are we succeed- deterioration of peace and order.” Alas, active and constructive participants in
ing in breaking the yoke and chain of what we said then we can say again. social and political life. It enables the laity
fellow Filipinos? Ang masakit na We have freed ourselves from the to take their rightful leadership role in the
karanasan ng mga Filipino ngayon ay punishment of death penalty. But we still social transformation of our country”
bagamat nakalaya na tayo sa pang- have to free ourselves from drug addiction (CBCP Pastoral Exhortation, “Building a
aalipin ng mga banyaga, ay mayroon and drug lords, from jueteng addiction and Civilization of Love”).
namang mga kapwa Filipino na jueteng lords, from the temptation to extort
umaalipin sa kanilang kapwa Filipino. and to bribe, from exploitation of women Archbishop Angel N. Lagdameo, DD
Gathered in the atmosphere of prayer, and children, from the killings of militants, June 12, 2006
we invite ourselves to pray that we may be labor leaders and journalists without the (A Message read at the Inter-faith Prayer Rally at
delivered from the many “unfreedoms” benefit of just trial, from torture and mal- Liwasang Bonifacio, Manila June 12, 2006)
Beloved People of God: renity that allows for rational discussion to them because they could save money
I
t is publicly known that efforts known and debate” (CBCP Statement, 2006). Like with the cancellation of the next elections
as ‘People’s Initiative’ for Charter them we also recognize and respect the in 2007 under the amendments being pro-
Change are on-going in Eastern Samar desire of a number of Filipinos to change posed. In a word, the CBCP’s twofold
and in the Philippines. It is also publicly some aspects of the constitution for the parameter for a morally principled Charter
known that such efforts are largely the sake of better governance and more as- Change, namely, (1) “widespread partici-
initiative of government officials, both sured attainment of the common good. But pation, total transparency, and relative
national and local. What is less known to we also “view with alarm…the present sig- serenity that allows for rational discus-
many is the fundamental principle that nature campaign endorsed by the govern- sion and debate” and (2) that “the reasons
“political authority, either within the po- ment. Signatures are apparently collected for constitutional change…be based on
litical community as such or through the without adequate information, discussion the common good rather than on self-
organizations representing the state must and education” (Pastoral Statement on the serving interests or the interests of politi-
be exercised within the limits of the moral Alleged ‘People’s Initiative’ to Change the cal dynasties” (CBCP Statement, 2006) may
order” (Pastoral Constitution on the Constitution, no. 2). have been violated in various parts of
Church in the Modern World, Gaudium et In many parts of Eastern Samar, for Eastern Samar, if not the whole country
Spes, no. 74). We see signs of deceit and instance, the CBCP’s general observation itself. As your pastors, we must denounce
misinformation. For this reason we, Your has been verified by specific reports from such acts because, in violating morality,
Bishop and Your Priests, have to speak certain priests and responsible lay leaders they do not serve the people’s true wel-
because these are an affront to true justice in our parish communities. Not only are fare.
and morality. After all, as the Second adequate information, discussion and edu- May the Risen Lord empower us to die
Plenary Council of the Philippines de- cation on the proposed changes lacking; to self-serving motivations and rise to
clares, we your “pastors have compe- in many cases signatures have been col- genuine character change, not simply char-
tence in the moral principles governing lected using downright deception, for in- ter change, as a people and as a nation.
politics” (PCP II, n. 342). stance, as people’s registration for
We stand with the Catholic Bishops Philhealth. People have been prodded to Yours in the Lord,
Conference of the Philippines when it sign their names on vague promises of
teaches that “changing the Constitution “better times ahead under a new constitu- +Leonardo Y. Medroso, D.D.
involving major shifts in the form of gov- tion” or even “better-paying jobs”. Signifi- Bishop of Borongan
ernment, requires widespread participa- cantly forthright are admissions of some Priests of the Diocese of Borongan
tion, total transparency, and relative se- local officials that the initiative is favorable April 25, 2006
Volume 40 • Number 7 27
F R O M T H E I N B O X
”Carrots, eggs, and coffee,” she Am I the egg that starts with a
replied. malleable heart, but changes with the
Her mother brought her closer heat? Did I have a fluid spirit, but after
A carrot, an egg, and a and asked her to feel the carrots. She a death, a breakup, a financial hardship
did and noted that they were soft. The orsomeothertrial,haveIbecomehard-
cup of coffee... mother then asked the daughter to take
an egg and break it. After pulling off
ened and stiff? Does my shell look the
same, but on the inside am I bitter and
the shell, she observed the hard boiled tough with a stiff spirit and hardened
egg. Finally, the mother asked the heart?
daughter to sip the coffee. The daugh- Or am I like the coffee bean? The
ter smiled as she tasted its rich aroma. beanactuallychangesthehotwater,the
Thedaughterthenasked,“Whatdoesit very circumstance that brings the pain.
mean,mother?” When the water gets hot, it releases the
Her mother explained that each fragrance and flavor. If you are like the
of these objects had faced the same ad- bean,whenthingsareattheirworst,you
versity:boilingwater.Eachreacteddif- get better and change the situation
ferently. The carrot went in strong, around you. When the hour is the dark-
hard, and unrelenting. However, after est and trials are their greatest, do you
being subjected to the boiling water, it elevate yourself to another level? How
softenedandbecameweak.Theegghad do you handle adversity? Are you a
been fragile. Its thin outer shell had carrot,aneggoracoffeebean?
protected its liquid interior, but after Mayyouhaveenoughhappiness
sitting through the boiling water, its to make you sweet, enough trials to
inside became hardened. The ground make you strong, enough sorrow to
A
young woman went to her placed carrots, in the second she placed
mother and told her about her eggs, and in the last she placed ground coffeebeanswereunique,however.Af- keep you human and enough hope to
life and how things were so coffee beans. She let them sit and boil, ter they were in the boiling water, they makeyouhappy.
hard for her. She did not know how she without saying a word. had changed the water. Thehappiestofpeopledon’tnec-
was going to make it and wanted to In about twenty minutes she ”Which are you?” she asked her essarily have the best of everything;
give up. She was tired of fighting and turned off the burners. She fished the daughter. “When adversity knocks on they just make the most of everything
struggling. It seemed as one problem carrots out and placed them in a bowl. your door, how do you respond? Are that comes along their way. The
was solved, a new one arose. She pulled the eggs out and placed you a carrot, an egg or a coffee bean? brightest future will always be based
Her mother took her to the them in a bowl. Then she ladled the Think of this: Which am I? Am I on a forgotten past; you can’t go for-
kitchen. She filled three pots with wa- coffeeoutandplaceditinabowl.Turn- the carrot that seems strong, but with ward in life until you let go of your
ter and placed each on a high fire. Soon ingtoherdaughter,sheasked,“Tellme pain and adversity do I wilt and be- past failures and heartaches. I
the pots came to boil. In the first she what you see.” come soft and lose my strength? rowena.dalanon@cbcpworld.net
M
y mother used to ask me: “What is the
most important part of the body?”
Through the years I would take a guess at
what I thought was the correct answer. When I was
younger, I thought sound was very important to us as
humans, so I said, “My ears, Mom.” She said, “No.
Many people are deaf. But you keep thinking about it
and I will ask you again soon.”
Severalyearspassedbeforesheaskedmeagain.
Since making my first attempt, I had contemplated
the correct answer. So this time I told her, “Mom,
sight is very important to everybody, so it must be The Most Important Body Part
our eyes. She looked at me and told me, “You are
learning fast, but the answer is not correct because I was shocked when she asked me this now. I Everybody needs a shoulder to cry on sometime in
therearemanypeoplewhoareblind.”Stumpedagain, always thought this was a game between her and me. life, my dear. I only hope that you have enough love
I continued my quest for knowledge. Over the years, She saw the confusion on my face and told me, “This and friends that you will always have a shoulder to
Mother asked me a couple more times and always her question is very important. It shows that you have cry on when you need it.” Then and there I knew the
answer was, “No, but you are getting smarter every really lived in your life. For every body part gave me most important body part is not a selfish one. It is
year,mychild.” in the past, I have told you were wrong and have given sympathetic to the pain of others. People will forget
Then last year, my grandpa died. Everybody you an example why. But today is the day you need to what you said. . .
was hurt. Everybody was crying. Even my father learn this important lesson.” She looked down at me Peoplewillforgetwhatyoudid...Butpeoplewill
cried. I remember that especially because it was only as only a mother can. I saw her eyes well up with tears. NEVERforgethowyoumadethemfeel.Trueornot,the
thesecondtimeIsawhimcry. MyMomlookedatme She said. “My dear, the most important body storymakesyoustopandthink.Beblessed. Beabless-
when it was our turn to say our final goodbye to part is your shoulder.” I asked, “Is it because it holds ing. Getyourshoulderready...andsharethismessageto
Grandpa. She asked me, “Do you know the most up my head?” She replied, “No, it is because it can everybodyyouknow. Theyalsoneedtoknow. I
important body part yet, my dear?” hold the head of a friend or a loved one when they cry. rowena.dalanon@cbcpworld.net
28
28 IMPACT •• July
IMPACT July 2006
2006
R E V I E W S
Volume 40
Volume 40 •• Number
Number 77 29
29
N E W S B R I E F S
BAHRAIN open door for a bright where. To continue serv- as the Maoists’ “people’s
future after they were ing English speaking read- government,” which rules
Alleged terrorists to be given by the Madrid based ers, news from the territory they control.
acquitted Fontilles Association to “Katorikku Shimbun” will
Fight Leprosy the chance still be translated and com-
After not finding hard to enter school, accord- piled in a section called PHILIPPINES
evidence that would press ing to Fides Service. “Japan Scene.” The
six Islamists who had These are children, 116 online newsletter will be
RP kills death penalty
been charged with plot- boys and 114 girls, who available at the http://
ting attacks in the emir- President Gloria Ar-
have experienced leprosy cbcj.catholic.jp.
ate, a Bahraini court said and suffered a lot and royo finally signed a law
it will issue a release or- because of social stigma totally abolishing the
der for them, a French that isolates people with MALAYSIA death penalty. The sign-
news agency reported. such disease from other ing ceremony took place
It said the court found people.
Genetic selection of ba- June 24, a day before she
the section of the penal bies to be banned left for Vatican to meet
code under which they the Pope.
were tried was unconsti- INDONESIA The use of pre-implan- “This could be another
tutional. The six have been tation genetic testing important, nice step to go
ordered to remain at their HRW: Military business techniques to choose a on in showing that the
residence and are barred threatens human rights baby’s sex and looks will
culture of life is alive and
from leaving the country. be banned under a new
The Indonesian law being drafted, Ma- important in this coun-
government’s plan to re- laysian Medical Associa- try,” said Archbishop
CHINA form military-owned busi- tion (MMA) said. Con- Fernando Filoni, the Pa-
ness do not sufficiently demning this activity, pal nuncio in the Philip-
Court ends trial of NY address the human rights MMA the procedure pines.
Times reporter problems fueled by the should only be used to
current system, Human diagnose serious medical
The closed-door trial Rights Watch (HRW) conditions in high-risk SAUDI ARABIA
in Beijing of a researcher said. patients, and not to de-
for the New York Times It said the military’s termine the baby’s fea-
King approves amnesty
accused of disclosing “money-making” under- tures and abilities.
“state secrets” and King Abdullah of Saudi
mines civilian control that Arabia has announced an
“fraud” ended recently instead of protecting its
without the court’s citizens, troops are using NEPAL amnesty for Islamic ter-
reaching a verdict. violence and intimidation rorists during a cabinet
Zhao Yan, 44, was to further their business
Maoist rebels accept role meeting in Jeddah, Saudi
tried at the Beijing No. 2 interests. in government newspaper reports re-
Intermediate People’s cently. The announce-
Court, but his family, After a meeting with ment comes amid an on-
friends and journalists JAPAN top government officials, slaught on extremism in
were denied access to the the leader of Nepal’s the kingdom. In the last
hearing, which was com- Japan Catholic News Maoist rebels known as two months, already 40
pleted in a single day. He Goes Online “Prochanda” announced suspected terrorists have
pleaded not guilty to both an agreement recently to
To reach a wider scope make his group part of been nabbed.
charges.
of readers, the monthly the Himalayan kingdom’s According to daily
news letter of the Japan government for the first Arab News, similar am-
INDIA Catholic Bishops’ Con- time. nesty two years ago
ference “Japan Catholic He said an interim pushed some extremists
Education for hapless News” ceased circulation agreement, which will within al-Qaeda network
Indian children of its printed version and create a new constitution, in Saudi Arabia to sur-
went online, after 57 will be formed and will render to police. They
A total of 230 children years of service to the replace the current na- were released after five
of Tami Nadu see an local church and else- tional parliament as well months.
• Internal Medicine
• Obstetry & Gynecology
• Ophthalmology
• Orthopedics & Traumatology
• Plastic & Cosmetic Surgery
• Pediatrics
• Pulmonology
• Radiology
• Urology