Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Training Course on
ne
tiv nd
ow
Principles in Tunnel Design
ec rl a
e
sp e
Centro Asturiano, Mexico, D.F. 02 – 04 May 2013, 10:30 – 11:30 am
re itz
ir w
he - S
Sprayed Concrete Support System
ft n
O tio
© a
n nd
Harald Wagner, PhD.,PE
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
Consulting Engineer
lI C
Al ITA
www.drharaldwagner.com
Sprayed Concrete (Concreto
r-s
Lanzado) has to be
ne
tiv nd
ow
economically viable.
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
It shall meet the challenges
ir w
he - S
of the future of underground
ft n
space use through
O tio
© a
Technological Innovations n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
Concrete .
Unsupported inclined access shaft in stable ground
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
Future Sprayed Concrete Developments
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
• Conventional Tunnelling with Sprayed Concrete
sp e
re itz
• Foreign Assistance in Design and Construction
ir w
he - S
• Risk Preparedness for New Technologies
ft n
O tio
• Trained Engineers and Miners
© a
• n nd
3 Main Components System Method Process
tio ou
ra F
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
Geotechnical Conditions in
ne
mountainous conditions are
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
characterized by
e
sp e
re itz
ir w
residual stresses,
he - S
numerous fault zones,
ft n
O tio
complex folding, and by
© a
thrust zones. n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
Sprayed Concrete
Al ITA
Is such challenged.
©
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
CTM Tunnel support
ne
tiv nd
elements, e.g. shotcrete,
ow
ec rl a
has been used since more
e
sp e
re itz
than 50 years in good rock.
ir w
he - S
ft n
However, successful
O tio
applications were related to
© a
Foreign Assistance in n nd
tio ou
ra F
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
New Construction Methods are faced with
re itz
ir w
resistance as they are considered to be risky and
he - S
ft n
such unwanted by decision makers.
O tio
© a
New Technologies are therefore imported until its
n nd
tio ou
success provides a safe base for decisions.
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
The future of Sprayed Concrete in both
ec rl a
e
sp e
mountainous and urban conditions depend on
re itz
ir w
experienced teams in design and construction.
he - S
ft n
O tio
Trained Engineers and Miners need to be
© a
n nd
recruited locally and international together with
tio ou
ra F
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
Sprayed Concrete
ne
tiv nd
ow
of today offers for
ec rl a
e
sp e
the future a huge
re itz
ir w
potential of
he - S
Innovation,
ft n
O tio
consisting of 3 main
© a
components. n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
Sprayed Concrete face wall and break through from adverse tunnel site.
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
ne
In full excavation, partial
tiv nd
ow
and full mechanized
ec rl a
e
tunnel systems have a
sp e
re itz
potential for future
ir w
he - S
development.
ft n
O tio
© a
Sprayed Concrete
n nd
tio ou
Application Systems will
ra F
be permanently installed
st T
llu E
on Tunnel Boring
lI C
Al ITA
Machines.
©
Portal wall with center drift excavation between side wall galleries.
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
Future developments in Sprayed Concrete
ec rl a
e
sp e
Technology include
re itz
ir w
he - S
Wet Processed Shotcrete and the use of
ft n
O tio
Steel Fibers for Reinforcement
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
bars.
Al ITA
©
www.drharaldwagner.com
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
Case History RAMPUR HEP/HRT (Himalaya/India)
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
GE-1
PACKA
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
43.2 M LONG CUT & COVER
ir w
CRITICA
E- L RE
5899 M ACH
ST
he - S
21
KA
AT
M
3107
85
NJHPS 1500 MW
IO
C
N
M
PA
10.5 M Ø 15.08 KM LONG HRT
12
ft n
KAJO ADIT
90
795 M LONG
O tio
KUNNI ADIT
0
OW
M
593.89 M LONG
FL RAMPUR INTAKE AT
© a
SURGE SHAFT TRT OUTFALL OF NJHPS
M
n nd
81
11 RAMPUR INTAKE TUNNEL 10.50 M Ø 484 M
4M 5M LONG
tio ou
1 72 290
CONSTRUCTION ADIT CUM
TRT
ra F
SPILL TUNNEL
2M 10.15 M HORSE SHOE SHAPE 335 M LONG
46
st T
GOSHAI ADIT
1089.60 M LONG
llu E
POWER HOUSE
lI C
COMPLEX
BAEL ADIT
Al ITA
578 M LONG
©
ER
SATLUJ RIV
www.drharaldwagner.com
BEST AVERAGE RATE OF PROGRESS ACHIEVED
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
AVERAGE RATE OF EXCAVATION 80 M /MONTH
e
sp e
re itz
IN HEADING
ir w
he - S
ft n
AVERAGE RATE OF EXCAVATION 131 M /MONTH
O tio
© a
IN BENCHING
n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
LINING (OVERT)
Al ITA
©
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
AVERAGE RATE OF EXCAVATION 52 M /MONTH
e
sp e
IN HEADING
re itz
ir w
he - S
AVERAGE RATE OF EXCAVATION 69 M /MONTH
ft n
O tio
IN BENCHING
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
ne
WITH IMPROVED CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
AVERAGE RATE OF EXCAVATION 80 M /MONTH
re itz
ir w
IN HEADING
he - S
ft n
O tio
AVERAGE RATE OF EXCAVATION 200M /MONTH
© a
IN BENCHING n nd
tio ou
ra F
LINING (OVERT)
Al ITA
©
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
925
ir w
4546 9638
he - S
ft n
O tio
2898 3239 2846 3106 2418 277
© a
n nd
tio ou
BAYAL GOSHAI KASHOLI KUNNI KAJO SPILL
ra F
st T
www.drharaldwagner.com
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
Head Race Tunnel (HRT) Benching Condition
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
HRT – Final Lining Condition
ow
ne
r-s
Kasholi D/s Heavy Water Seepage @ 22 litres/sec.
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
ir w
he - S
ft n
O tio
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
www.drharaldwagner.com
Goshai U/s Cavity. ( RD 1243m)
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
ir w
he - S
ft n
O tio
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
ir w
he - S
ft n
O tio
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
www.drharaldwagner.com
DEFORMATION IN MM
-20.000
0.000
20.000
40.000
60.000
80.000
100.000
120.000
140.000
08.09.09
© 11.09.09
16.09.09
19.09.09
Al ITA
lI C 20.09.09
llu E 23.09.09
24.09.09
04.10.09
st T
06.10.09
ra F
08.10.09
tio ou
12.10.09
15.10.09
n nd
© a
21.10.09
23.10.09
O tio
30.10.09
ft n
02.11.09
he - S
06.11.09 ir w
DATE 09.11.09
13.11.09
re itz
16.11.09
sp e
24.11.09
AFTER HEADING
26.11.09
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
30.11.09
tiv nd
03.12.09
e
07.12.09
10.12.09
ow
14.12.09
ne
01.01.10
AT GOSHAI HRT UPSTREAM RD:229.5M
06.01.10
r-s
18.01.10
30.01.10
02.04.10
DEFORMATION CURVE MEASURED BY PAPER TARGET
AB
AC
BC
r-s
DEFORMATION CURVE MEASURED BY SPBX AT GOSHAI HRT
ne
tiv nd
UPSTREAM RD:230M
ow
ec rl a
AFTER BENCHING
e
sp e
160.00
re itz
DEFORMATION IN MM
140.00
ir w
he - S
120.00
100.00
ft n
O tio
80.00
© a
LEFT SIDE AT SPL
n nd
60.00
LEFT CROWN
tio ou
40.00
CENTER CROWN
ra F
-20.00
Al ITA
11.06.2011
15.06.2010
20.06.2011
24.06.2011
02.07.2011
08.07.2011
16.07.2011
23.07.2011
30.07.2011
01.08.2011
06.08.2011
10.08.2011
13.08.2011
19.08.2011
24.08.2011
28.08.2011
01.09.2011
05.09.2011
09.09.2011
16.09.2011
24.09.2011
©
DATE
www.drharaldwagner.com
Primary Lining Support Efforts with insufficient effect.
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
ir w
he - S
ft n
O tio
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
www.drharaldwagner.com
Primary Lining of shotcrete and steel arches
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
ir w
he - S
ft n
O tio
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
www.drharaldwagner.com
Installation of support with Ribs & Lagging
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
sp e
re itz
ir w
he - S
ft n
O tio
© a
n nd
tio ou
ra F
st T
llu E
lI C
Al ITA
©
Rock desintegration and loosening due to slow lining installation (Kunni D/s)
www.drharaldwagner.com
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
Tunnelling with Backhoe and Shotcrete Support
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
Top Heading / Bench Excavation
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
Shotcreting primary lining and face protection
r-s
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
Invert excavation stages and construction of closed ring
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
©
Al ITA
lI C
llu E
st T
ra F
tio ou
n nd
© a
O tio
ft n
he - S
ir w
re itz
sp e
ec rl a
www.drharaldwagner.com
tiv nd
e
ow
ne
r-s
r-s
ne
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
Ground is viewed as integrated element of support
e
sp e
re itz
Ground reactions narrow measured to check stability
ir w
he - S
ft n
Shotcrete essential to keep the ground undisturbed
O tio
© a
n nd
Support Design between RAPID RIGID & SLIM DEFORMABLE
tio ou
ra F
www.drharaldwagner.com
r-s
ne
Principles in Tunneling Design
tiv nd
ow
ec rl a
e
Mexico, D.F. 02 – 04 May 2013
sp e
re itz
ir w
he - S
Disclaimer
ft n
O tio
© a
a) The speakers are presenting their own personal views and are not expressing the view
of the Foundation. n nd
tio ou
ra F
b) Papers and documents displayed or handed out during the Event are copyrighted. The participants
st T
llu E
must observe and comply with all applicable law regulations concerning the copyright.
lI C
Al ITA
©
www.drharaldwagner.com