Partial Safety Factors For Evaluation of Existing Bridges According To Eurocodes

.
m
2012
18th International Conference
ENGINEERING MECHANICS 2012
Svratka, Czech Republic, May 14 – 17, 2012
pp. 681–690
Paper #268
!

.1&9 )7"-
#01/"$1 38-*5&5*68-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(8467+462&8*6.&17&3)14&)*++*(876*(422*3)*)&((46).3,
84 964(4)*+46'6.),*2*2'*6779'/*(8*)84'*3).3,&6*56*7*38*) 38-*+6&2*4+6*7*&6(-&(8.:.8.*74+
8-* *5&682*38 4+ 7869(896*7 &3) '6.),*7 8-* 24).+.*) 6*1.&'.1.8= 1*:*17 +46 *<.78.3, '6.),* *:&19&8.43
;*6*)*6.:*).6781=8-*7*1*:*17;*6*97*)+46)*8*62.3.3,5&68.&17&+*8=+&(8467+462&8*6.&1147*1=
8-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(8464+78**1&3)(43(6*8*;*6*)*8*62.3*))*5*3).3,438-*&,*4+8-*'6.),*&3)43
8-*6*2&.3.3,1.+*8.2*4+8-*'6.),**;24).+.*)6*1.&'.1.8=1*:*17+46*:&19&8.434+*<.78.3,'6.),*7&6*
&174&++*(8*)8-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(84674+14&)7
&64./%0

-1/.%2$1).-
G>9<:H6G:8DCH>9:G:9ID7:6C>CH:E6G67A:6C9HIG6I:<>86AANK:GN>BEDGI6CIE6GID;I=:IG6CHEDGI6I>DC
>C;G6HIGJ8IJG: 6C9 I=:N H=DJA9 =6K: HJ8= E6G6B:I:GH CDI ID 7:8DB: I=: A>B>I>C< 8DBEDC:CI D; I=:
8DBBJC>86I>DC 86E68>IN 6C9 IG6;;>8 G:A>67>A>IN %C I=: E6HI 7G>9<: B6>CI:C6C8: G:E6>G 6C9
G:=67>A>I6I>DC68I>K>I>:HL:G:E:G;DGB:9DC6C\6H
C::9:9]76H>H0=>H8=6C<:9>CI=:A6I: H L=:C
6H:G>:HD;7G>9<:;6>AJG:H;D8JH:9EJ7A>86II:CI>DCDCI=:9:I:G>DG6I>DCD;:M>HI>C<7G>9<:H BDI>K6I>C<
<DK:GCB:CIH ID >C>I>6I: HI6C96G9>O:9 7G>9<: >CHE:8I>DC 6C9 :K6AJ6I>DC EGD8:9JG:H 6I6 8DAA:8I:9
I=GDJ<= I=:H: >CHE:8I>DC 68I>K>I>:H ;DGB:9 I=: 76H>H ;DG ;JIJG: 8DBEJI:G 76H:9 7G>9<: B6C6<:B:CI
HNHI:BH)/(6JG>9H:C :I6A 0=DBEHDC :I6A 2>S6C :I6A
0=::K6AJ6I>DCD;:M>HI>C<8DC8G:I:7G>9<:HIGJ8IJG:H>HI=:BDHI>BEDGI6CIEGD8:HH>CI=:<AD76A
G>9<:)6C6<:B:CI/NHI:B)/7:86JH:D;EGDK>9>C<I=:76H>8>C;DGB6I>DC67DJI:M>HI>C<7G>9<:H
G:FJ>G:9;GDBI=:K>:LED>CID;9:8>H>DC B6@>C<EGD8:HHG:A6I:9IDI=:DEI>B6A7G>9<:B6>CI:C6C8:6C9
G:=67>A>I6I>DCHIG6I:<N0=:G:;DG: I=::M>HI>C<7G>9<::K6AJ6I>DCH=DJA97:B69:CDIDCAN6HI=:G:HJAI
D; E:G>D9>8 >CHE:8I>DC DC I=: 76H: D; HJ7?:8I>K: :K6AJ6I>DC D; 68IJ6A 7G>9<: 8DC9>I>DC 7JI ;GDB I=:
K>:LED>CID;I=:7G>9<:G:A>67>A>IN>:;GDBI=:K>:LED>CI=DLI=:68IJ6A7G>9<:8DC9>I>DC6;;:8IHI=:
7G>9<:G:A>67>A>IN;DGG:B6>C>C<7G>9<:A>;:I>B:0=JH I=:7G>9<::K6AJ6I>DC7:8DB:HG:A:K6CIL=:CI=:
H><C>;>86CI9:K>6I>DCH;GDBI=:EGD?:8I9:H8G>EI>DCH6G:;DJC9 L=:CHDB:G:A:K6CI96B6<:>HD7H:GK:9
DGL=:CI=:7G>9<:A>;:I>B:=6H<DC:7:NDC9EA6CC:9DC: :I8
0=:E6E:G9:6AHL>I=I=:9:I:GB>C6I>DCD;I=:BD9>;>:9G:A>67>A>INA:K:AH;DG:K6AJ6I>DCD;:M>HI>C<
8DC8G:I: 7G>9<:H0=: I=:DG:I>86A 6EEGD68=I6@>C< >CID 688DJCII=: 8DC9>I>DC6AEGD767>A>IN L6H JH:9
0=: BD9>;>:9 A:K:AH 9:E:C9 DC I=: 6<: D; I=: 7G>9<: 6C9 DC I=: EA6CC:9 G:B6>C>C< A>;:I>B: 6C9
BDG:DK:G >C;AJ:C8:I=:E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGHD;B6I:G>6AH6C9AD69H
&+)"#)+)16#"0&% &3"+2"1).-.'&5)01)-($.-$/&1&#/)%(&0
0=: G:A>67>A>IN A:K:A ;DG C:LAN 9:H><C:9 7G>9<:H ;DG L=DA: A>;:I>B: 09 09 N:6GH L=>8= >H
G:EG:H:CI:97N;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN,; 9 ,; 9 P
DG7NG:A>67>A>IN>C9:M 9 9 >H<>K:C>C6
!JGD8D9:$DL:K:G I=:G:A>67>A>INA:K:A;DG:K6AJ6I>DCD;:M>HI>C<7G>9<:H;DGG:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:I G >H
CDI<>K:C>CI=:!JGD8D9:H

%C< ,:I:G 'DI:U ,= :E6GIB:CI D; /IGJ8IJG:H 6C9 G>9<:H >K>A !C<>C::G>C< "68JAIN 1C>K:GH>IN D; V>A>C6
1C>K:GO>ICQ V>A>C6 /' :
B6>A @DI:H;HI6KJC>O6H@

,GD; %C< &DH:; 2>S6C ,= :E6GIB:CI D; /IGJ8IJG:H 6C9 G>9<:H >K>A !C<>C::G>C< "68JAIN 1C>K:GH>IN D; V>A>C6
1C>K:GO>ICQ V>A>C6 /' :
B6>A K>86C;HI6KJC>O6H@
682 Engineering Mechanics 2012, #268
#:C:G6AAN I=:EGD8:HHD;I=::M>HI>C<7G>9<::K6AJ6I>DC=6HK6G>DJH9>;;:G:C8:H>C8DBE6G>HDCL>I=
I=:G:A>67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CID;C:LAN9:H><C:97G>9<:%CI=:86H:D;I=::M>HI>C<7G>9<:HIGJ8IJG: C:L
>C;DGB6I>DC8DC8:GC>C<I=:68IJ6A7G>9<:8DC9>I>DC>H6K6>A67A:L=>8=>HJC@CDLC>CI=:9:H><CE=6H:
0=:8:GI>;>86I:HD;B6I:G>6AEGDE:GI>:H B:6HJG:B:CIHD;68IJ6A7G>9<:<:DB:IGN 8DAA:8I>DCAD6996I6
G:HJAIH D; EGDD; AD69 I:HI>C< 6C9 :HE:8>6AAN G:HJAIH D; I=: E:G>D9>8 >CHE:8I>DCH G:<JA6GAN E:G;DGB:9
L>I=>C A>;:I>B: D; I=: D7H:GK:9 7G>9<: 6G: I=: B6?DG G:HDJG8:H D; I=>H >C;DGB6I>DC 0=: :MIG6
>C;DGB6I>DCJC@CDLC>CI=:9:H><CE=6H:86C7:JH:9CDIDCAN;DGK:G>;>86I>DCD;I=:8DGG:8I7G>9<:
E:G;DGB6C8:DG;DG9:I:8I>DCD;EDHH>7A:B>HI6@:H8DC8:GC>C<I=:8DBEJI6I>DC6ABD9:A6HHJBEI>DCHDG
86A8JA6I>DCH 7JI 6AHD =:AEH ID G:9J8: HDB: JC8:GI6>CIN G:A6I:9 ID I=: 7G>9<: B:B7:G G:H>HI6C8: 6C9
AD69E6G6B:I:GH:CI:G>C<I=::K6AJ6I>DCEGD8:HH
%C 67GD69 I=: EGD7A:B D; :K6AJ6I>DC D; :M>HI>C< 7G>9<:H L6H HDAK:9 >C ;G6B: D; I=: 9:K:ADE>C<
G>9<: )6C6<:B:CI /NHI:BH 76H:9 DC 8DBEJI:G
6>9:9 :ME:GI HNHI:BH 0=: G:A>67>A>IN
76H:9
:K6AJ6I>DC D; :M>HI>C< 7G>9<:H >H EG:;:GG:9 >C I=: LDG@H D; B:G>86C *DL6@ #GJC>
"G6C<DEDA !HI:H 6C9 6C69>6C AA:C 6GIA:II :I 6A 6JI=DGH 0=:DG:I>86A
DJIEJIH D; I=:H: H8>:CI>;>8 HIJ9>:H 8G:6I: I=: 768@<GDJC9 D; I=: 8DCI:BEDG6GN 6C69>6C .::A
<DGL6A 6C9+CI6G>D+$ HI6C96G9H;DGI=::K6AJ6I>DCD;:M>HI>C<GD697G>9<:H6C9
9:I:GB>C>C< I=:>G AD69 86GGN>C< 86E68>I>:H >C I=: ;DGB D; (>K: (D69 .6I>C< "68IDGH ((." DI=
HI6C96G9H 6G: 76H:9 DC I=: EGD767>A>IN BD9:A D; I=: HIGJ8IJG6A G:A>67>A>IN K:G>;>86I>DC L>I= I=:
9>;;:G:CI>6I:9 G:A>67>A>IN A:K:A 9:E:C9>C< DC I=: 7G>9<: 8DBEDC:CI >BEDGI6C8: >C I=: L=DA: 7G>9<:
HIGJ8IJG:
%CI=:6G:6D;!JGDE: H:K:G6A6JI=DGH6C9>CHI>IJI>DCH=6K:;D8JH:9I=:>GG:H:6G8=68I>K>I>:HDCI=>H
EGD7A:BA6HIN:6GH 3DC<6G6A G6;I EJ7A>86I>DCD;I=:&D>CIDBB>II::DC
/IGJ8IJG6A /6;:IN &// >6B6CI>9>H >H 7:>C< 9:K:ADE:9 0=>H EJ7A>86I>DC 8DCI6>CH HDB:
EG68I>86A6C9DE:G6I>DC6AG:8DBB:C96I>DCH6C9GJA:H;DGI=: 6HH:HHB:CID;:M>HI>C<HIGJ8IJG:H
&+)"#)+)16"-"+60)0
"GDBI=:7G>9<:G:A>67>A>INK>:LED>CI I=:G:9J8I>DCD;I=:AD696C9G:H>HI6C8:E6G6B:I:GJC8:GI6>CI>:H
9:8G:6H:H ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN D; :M>HI>C< 7G>9<: HIGJ8IJG: I=6I B:6CH I=: EDHH>7>A>IN ID 69B>I ADL:G
G:A>67>A>INA:K:A;DG:K6AJ6I>DCD;:M>HI>C<7G>9<:I=6C>I>H>CI=:86H:D;C:LAN9:H><C:9DC:
%CI=:I=:DG:I>86A6C6ANH>H >I>H6HHJB:9I=6II=:7G>9<:HIGJ8IJG6A:A:B:CIL6H9:H><C:9;DGIDI6A
A>;:I>B:0L>I=8DGG:HEDC9>C<G:A>67>A>IN>C9:M <>K:C7N;DGBJA6
2! 2" 7! 7"
L=:G: B. H. 6G:I=:76H>8E6G6B:I:GHD;I=:CDGB6AAN9>HIG>7JI:9G6C9DBK6G>67A:G:H>HI6C8:.

D;67G>9<:HIGJ8IJG6A:A:B:CIH
B/ H/ 6G:I=:76H>8E6G6B:I:GHD;I=:CDGB6AAN9>HIG>7JI:9G6C9DBK6G>67A:AD69:;;:8IH/
D;I=:H6B:7G>9<::A:B:CI
0=: 7G>9<: >CHE:8I>DC L6H E:G;DGB:9 6I I=: I>B: I>CHE 0 9JG>C< L=>8= I=: D7H:GK:9 HIGJ8IJG6A
:A:B:CI L6H ;DJC9 ID 7: L>I=DJI G:A:K6CI ;6>AJG: 9J: ID DK:G8GDHH>C< >IH A>B>I HI6I:H 0=>H EDH>I>K:
>C;DGB6I>DC :MEG:HH:H I=6I G:H>HI6C8: . D; I=: D7H:GK:9 HIGJ8IJG6A :A:B:CI H6I>H;>:H I=: ;DAADL>C<
G:A6I>DC
! 2&<".+46.AA8
0=: AD69 :;;:8IH / / _ /C 6G: BJIJ6AAN >C9:E:C9:CI CDGB6AAN 9>HIG>7JI:9 6C9 D88JG >C
HJ88:HH>DC 7JI G6C9DBAN >C I>B: 6C9 *I B:6CH I=: G6C9DB CJB7:G D; I=:B L>I=>C I>B: >CI:GK6A
I *I >H 8DCH>9:G:9 6H I=: G6C9DB K6G>67A: =6K>C< ,D>HHDC 9>HIG>7JI>DC L>I= E6G6B:I:G I
>CI:CH>IND;AD69:;;:8IHL=>8= >H8DCHI6CIDGA>C:6GAN9:E:C9:CIDCI>B:I688DG9>C<IDG:A6I>DC
8 .375 8 8.375
L=:G: D >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G 6II=:I>B:I

Koteš P., Vičan J. 683
I >CHE >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G 6II=:I>B:I I>CHE D;I=: E:G>D9>8>CHE:8I>DC

%;I=:;DAADL>C<;DGBJA6>H8DCH>9:G:9
8
8 )

I=:CI>B:D88JGG:C8:D;>C9>K>9J6AH:IHD;AD69:;;:8IH/> H6I>H;>:HI=:;DAADL>C<9:E:C9:C8:
8 3 8 3 * 8 3 +46 3 0
%;I=:E6G6B:I:GZI>H8DCHI6CI>CI>B: I=:;DAADL>C<G:A6I>DCB6N7:D7I6>C:9JH>C<I=:G:A6I>DC

8 8
6C9>;I=:E6G6B:I:G>HA>C:6GAN 9:E:C9:CIDCI>B: JH>C<HJ7HI>IJI>DCID>HD7I6>C:9

8 8 .375 8 8
.375
H =6H 7::C H=DLC >C >IA:KH:C )69H:C I=: JE96I:9 ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN ,;J D; I=:
D7H:GK:9HIGJ8IJG6A:A:B:CI6II=:I>B:E:G>D9I>CHE 0H=DJA97:D7I6>C:97NB:6CHD;I=:8DC9>I>DC6A
EGD767>A>IN688DG9>C<IDI=:;DGBJA6:
+9 + # + 8.375 + 8.375
0=: 8DGG:HEDC9>C< JE96I:9 G:A>67>A>IN >C9:M J D; I=: D7H:GK:9 HIGJ8IJG6A :A:B:CI ;DG I=:
G:B6>C>C<I>B:E:G>D9I>CHE 0 0986C7:9:I:GB>C:9>C688DG96C8:L>I=
9 +9
L=:G:
>HI=:>CK:GH:9>HIG>7JI>DC;JC8I>DCD; HI6C96G9>O:9 CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DC*
0=: ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN ,;0 ,;I>CHE 86C 7: D7I6>C:9 ;DG CDGB6AAN 9>HIG>7JI:9 7G>9<: :A:B:CI
G:H>HI6C8: . 6C9 CDGB6AAN 9>HIG>7JI:9 AD69 :;;:8IH / > JH>C< I=: ;DAADL>C< ;DGBJA6: ;DG 8DBEA:I:
EGD767>A>IN >IA:KH:C)69H:C

#
< 2"
< 2!
+ # B6M ". . # . *
7"
)<

7! 7!

L=:G: >HI=:EGD767>A>IN9:CH>IN;JC8I>DCD; HI6C96G9>O:9 CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DC*

1H>C<I=:>C;DGB6I>DC I=:JE96I:9G:A>67>A>IN>C9:M J 86C7:<G:6I:GI=6C9:H><C:9>C9:M 9
*:MI L:6G:67A:IDHDAK:768@I=:69?JHI:9I6G<:I;6>AJG:EGD767>A>IN,;I I6G<:IG:A>67>A>IN>C9:M I;DG
L=>8= I=: :A:B:CI H=DJA9 7: :K6AJ6I:9 ;DG G:B6>C>C< A>;:I>B: 0
I>CHE HD I=6I L: 86C 68=>:K: I=:
G:FJ>G:9 K6AJ: D; I=: I6G<:I ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN , ;I L>I= B>C>B6A DC: >CHE:8I>DC 0=: 8=6C<: D; I=:
JE96I:9G:A>67>A>IN>C9:M J 6C9I=:I6G<:IG:A>67>A>IN>C9:M I >CI>B:>HH=DLC>C"><>C9:E:C9:C8:
DC I>B: D; >CHE:8I>DC 6C9 DC I=: K6AJ:H D; I=: E6G6B:I:G Z "GDB I=: ">< 86C 7: H::C I=6I I=:
JE96I:9G:A>67>A>IN>C9:M J >H>C8G:6H>C<>CI>B:B6G@:9AN>CI=::C9D;A>;:I>B:"GDBI=>HG:6HDC
I=:I6G<:IG:A>67>A>IN>C9:M I >H9:8G:6H>C<>CI>B:

.,$5)&8*)6*1.&'.1.8=.3)*< 9 &3)8-*8&6,*86*1.&'.1.8=.3)*< 8 .3)*5*3)*3(*43.375*(8.43

8.2*
0=: G:A>67>A>IN A:K:A <>K:C 7N ;6>AJG: EGD767>A>IN ,;I DG 7N G:A>67>A>IN >C9:M I H=DLC >C "><
9:E:C9H?JHIDCI=:;JAAG:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:0
I>CHE [ ;GDBI>B:D;>CHE:8I>DCI>CHE IDI=::C9D;I=:
A>;:I>B:0JIEG68I>86AAN >I>HJHJ6AANID:K6AJ6I:I=:HIGJ8IJG:;DGH=DGI:C>C<A>;:I>B: [ JHH:A:8I:9
I>B:>CI:GK6A"DG:M6BEA: >I86C7:I>B:7:IL::CILD>CHE:8I>DCHDG>;I=:HIGJ8IJG:9D:HCDIH6I>H;N
;DG ;JAA G:B6>C>C< A>;:I>B: 0
I>CHE %C I=>H 86H: I=: HIGJ8IJG: 86C 7: :K6AJ6I:9 DC H=DGI:C>C<
G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B: [ EA6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:IG
0=: I=:DG:I>86A 6EEGD68= >H I=: H6B: 6H 67DK: B:CI>DC:9 JI I=: A>;:I>B: 0 D; I=: B:B7:G
H=DJA97:H=DGI:C>C<ID9:I:GB>C:I=:G:FJ>G:9G:A>67>A>IND;D7H:GK:9B:B7:G;DGEA6CC:9>CI:GK6AI G
%IB:6CHI=6II=:L=DA:A>;:I>B:>HCDI0 N:6GH 7JI>I>H:FJ6AIDHJBI>CHEIG
0=>H6EEGD68=>H>BEDGI6CI;DG7G>9<:DLC:G 7:86JH:>I<>K:HIDDLC:G67>A>INIDH6K:I=:;JC9H
0=:G:HJAIH6G:H=DLC>C"><
., #&6,*86*1.&'.1.8=.3)*< 8 .3)*5*3)*3(*438.2*4+.375*(8.43&3)51&33*)6*2&.3.3,1.+*8.2*
&+)"#)+)16+&3&+0
0=:D7I6>C:9G:A>67>A>INA:K:AH9:E:C9DCI=:6<:D;I=:7G>9<:6C9DCI=:EA6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:
0=:G:HJAIHD;I=:G:A>67>A>INA:K:AH;DG7G>9<::A:B:CICDIG:HE:8I>C<I=:9:<G696I>DC9J:IDG:<JA6GAN
E:G;DGB:9B6>CI:C6C8:6G:H=DLC>C067
#&'!*1.&'.1.8=1*:*17+46*<.78.3,'6.),**:&19&8.433486*75*(8.3,)*,6&)&8.43
.:B6>C>C< 0=:6<:D;I=:7G>9<:4N:6GH5
A>;:I>B: N:6GH N:6GH N:6GH N:6GH N:6GH
N:6GH XI ,;I XI ,;I XI ,;I XI ,;I XI ,;I
P
P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P

P
P
P

P
P

P

.:B6>C>C< 0=:6<:D;I=:7G>9<:4N:6GH5
A>;:I>B: N:6GH N:6GH N:6GH N:6GH
N:6GH XI ,;I XI ,;I XI ,;I XI ,;I

P P P P

P
P
P
P

P
P
P
P

P
P
P

P
P

P

"/1)"+0"'&16'"$1./0
*:LBD9>;>:9G:A>67>A>INA:K:AH;DG:K6AJ6I>DCD;:M>HI>C<7G>9<:H<>K:C>C0676;;:8II=:K6AJ:HD;
E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGH;DGB6I:G>6AG:H>HI6C8:6C9;DGAD69H 6AHD%CI=:EG68I>86A9:H><C I=:G:A>67>A>IN
A:K:AH6G:IG6CH;DGB:9IDI=:9:H><CK6AJ:HD;I=:B6I:G>6AG:H>HI6C8:6C9AD69H %CI=:E6GI>6AH6;:IN
;68IDGH B:I=D9 I=: 9:H><C K6AJ:H D; B6I:G>6A G:H>HI6C8: 6C9 AD69H 6G: 9:I:GB>C:9 7N B:6CH D;
8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:H6C96EEGDEG>6I:E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGH(D69H6C9G:H>HI6C8:6G:IG:6I:96HG6C9DB
K6G>67A:H6C96G:9:H8G>7:97N7>6H;68IDGHZ:MEG:HH>C<G6I>DD;B:6CK6AJ:IDCDB>C6AK6AJ:6C97N
8D:;;>8>:CID;K6G>6I>DCK
"/1)"+0"'&16'"$1./0'./,"1&/)"+
DCH>9:G>C<CDGB6AAN9>HIG>7JI:9G6C9DBK6G>67A:G:H>HI6C8: I=:E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGH D;8DC8G:I:6C9
G:>C;DG8:B:CI!*

6G:<>K:C7N;DGBJA6:
!0 0 :!

!) ! 8 :!
L=:G: .@ >HI=: 8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:D;I=:B6I:G>6AG:H>HI6C8:
.9 >HI=: 9:H><CK6AJ:D;I=:B6I:G>6AG:H>HI6C8:

. >HI=:H:CH>I>K>IN8D:;;>8>:CI
K. >HI=:8D:;;>8>:CID;K6G>6I>DCD;B6I:G>6AG:H>HI6C8:
@ >HI=: G:A>67>A>IN >C9:M8DGG:HEDC9>C< ID EGD767>A>IN K6A>9 ;DG 8=6G68I:G>HI>8
K6AJ:H
I >H I=: G:8DBB:C9:9 I6G<:I G:A>67>A>IN >C9:M 9:E:C9>C< DC I=: 6<: D; I=: 7G>9<:
6C9DCI=:EA6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B: 067
0D 9:I:GB>C: K6AJ:H D; E6GI>6AH6;:IN ;68IDGH I=: 76H>8 HI6I>HI>86A8=6G68I:G>HI>8H H=6AA 7: @CDLC
:HE:8>6AAN8D:;;>8>:CID;K6G>6I>DCK.%C I=:86H:D;E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDG 8 ;DG8DC8G:I: I=:K6AJ: D;
K6G>6I>DC8D:;;>8>:CIK. L6H 768@L6G986A8JA6I:9;GDB;DGBJA6:;DG 8 ;DGC:L9:H><C:9
7G>9<:H6C9G:A>67>A>IN>C9:M I /D I=: K6AJ:D;8D:;;>8>:CIHD;K6G>6I>DC K. L6H JH:9
;DG9:I:GB>C>C<I=:E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGHD;8DC8G:I:
1H>C< B:CI>DC:9 E6G6B:I:GH C:L K6AJ:H D; E6GI>6A H6;:IN ;68IDGH ;DG 8DC8G:I: L:G: 9:I:GB>C:9
8DCH>9:G>C< I=: EA6CC:9 G:B6>C>C< A>;:I>B: 6C9 6 7G>9<: 6<: 0=: 9:I:GB>C:9 K6AJ:H 6G: H=DLC >C
067
#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(846 ( +46(43(6*8*786*3,8-:&1.)+46*<.78.3,'6.),**:&19&8.43

8
6<:D;7G>9<: 4N:6GH5
,A6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:IG
4N:6GH5
N:6GH
N:6GH N:6GH

[
[
[

%C I=: 86H: D; I=: E6GI>6A H6;:IN ;68IDG / ;DG G:>C;DG8:B:CI >I >H EDHH>7A: ID JH: I=: K6AJ: D;
K. L=>8= >H 8DGG:HEDC9>C< ID E6GI>6A H6;:IN ;68IDG H ;DG G:>C;DG8:B:CI ;DG C:L
9:H><C:97G>9<:H 6C9G:A>67>A>IN>C9:M I 0=:9:I:GB>C:9K6AJ:HD;I=:E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGH;DG
G:>C;DG8:B:CI 6G: H=DLC >C 067 "DG I=: H:GK>8:67>A>IN A>B>I HI6I: L:G: 9:I:GB>C:9 K6AJ:H
8 8 6C9 H
#&'
#-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(8467 7+466*.3+46(*2*38:&1.)+46'6.),**<.78.3,*:&19&8.43
,A6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:IG H
6<:D;7G>9<: 4N:6GH5
4N:6GH5 N:6GH
N:6GH N:6GH

[
[
[

"/1)"+0"'&16'"$1./0'./+."%0
0=:AD69D;I=:7G>9<:H>H<>K:C>CI=:8D9: /0*!*
0=:AD69BD9:AH6G:6C>BEDGI6CI
E6GI D; :K6AJ6I>DC 0=: 76H>8 AD69 8DB7>C6I>DC ;DG GD69 7G>9<:H >H 6 H>BJAI6C:DJH D88JGG:C8: D;
E:GB6C:CIAD696C9K6G>67A:AD690=:8D9: /0*!*
HE:8>;>:HI=:8=6G68I:G>HI>8AD69H
E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGH;DGC:LAN9:H><C:97G>9<:H6C9I=:AD698DB7>C6I>DCH$DL:K:G I=:86A8JA6I>DC
D; AD69 E6GI>6A H6;:IN ;68IDGH ;DG :K6AJ6I>DC D; :M>HI>C< 7G>9<:H G:FJ>G:H @CDLA:9<: D; I=: HI6I>HI>86A
BD9:AH D; H>C<JA6G AD69H >C E6GI>8JA6G 9>HIG>7JI>DC ;JC8I>DC 9:CH>IN ;JC8I>DC HI6C96G9 9:K>6I>DC
8D:;;>8>:CID;K6G>6I>DC I>B:K6G>6I>DC6C98DGG:A6I>DCL>I=DI=:GAD698DBEDC:CIH
&/,"-&-1+."%0
0=: E6GI>6A H6;:IN ;68IDGH D; E:GB6C:CI AD69H G:HE:8I>C< I=: G:8DBB:C9:9 BD9>;>:9 G:A>67>A>IN
A:K:AH :MEG:HH:9 7N I <>K:C >C 067 8DCH>9:G>C< CDGB6AAN 9>HIG>7JI:9 G6C9DB K6G>67A:H L:G:
:HI67A>H=:9JH>C<I=:;DGBJA6:
") " 8 :
. ") ") . ") " 8 : .
"0 .
L=:G: /@ >HI=: 8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:D;AD69

/9 >HI=: 9:H><CK6AJ:D;AD69

/ >HI=:H:CH>I>K>IN8D:;;>8>:CID;AD69H
Y/9 >HI=: E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGD;BD9:AJC8:GI6>CI>:H
K# > 6G:I=:8D:;;>8>:CIHD;K6G>6I>DCD;H>C<A:E:GB6C:CIAD69H
88DG9>C<IDHI6C96G9 /0*!* * I=:E:GB6C:CIAD69H6G:9>K>9:9>CID 86HI
>C
EA68: B69: EGD9J8:H L>I= G:8DBB:C9:9 K6AJ: D; E6GI>6A H6;:IN ;68IDG Y# ;DG C:L 9:H><C:9
7G>9<:H 6C9 ;68IDGN
B69: EGD9J8:H 6C9 IG6CHEDGI:9 ID 8DCHIGJ8I>DC L>I= G:8DBB:C9:9 K6AJ: D;
E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDG Y# ;DGC:L9:H><C:97G>9<:H 0=:K6AJ: D; K6G>6I>DC8D:;;>8>:CIK. >H:FJ6A
ID K# ;DG 86HI
>C
EA68: B69: EGD9J8:H 6C9 K# ;DG ;68IDGN
B69: EGD9J8:H 6C9
IG6CHEDGI:9ID8DCHIGJ8I>DC
0=:C:LG:8DBB:C9:9E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGHD;E:GB6C:CIAD69H9:E:C9>C<DCI=:6<:D;7G>9<:H
6C9DCEA6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:6G:H=DLC>C067 6C9067
#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(84674+5*62&3*3814&)7 (&78.351&(*2&)*564)9(*7
,A6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B: # >
6<:D;7G>9<: 4N:6GH5
IG 4N:6GH5 N:6GH
N:6GH N:6GH

[
[
[

#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(84674+5*62&3*3814&)7 +&(846=2&)*564)9(*7 &3)86&375468*)84
(437869(8.43
,A6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B: # >
6<:D;7G>9<: 4N:6GH5
IG 4N:6GH5 N:6GH
N:6GH N:6GH

[
[
[

"/)"#+& +."%0
0=: K6G>67A: AD69H 6G: G6C9DB K6G>67A:H L>I= #JB7A: 9>HIG>7JI>DC 688DG9>C< ID /0* !*
0=: E6GI>6A H6;:IN ;68IDGH D; K6G>67A: AD69H G:HE:8I>C< I=: G:8DBB:C9:9 BD9>;>:9 G:A>67>A>IN
A:K:AH:MEG:HH:97N I<>K:C>C0678DCH>9:G>C< #JB7A: 9>HIG>7JI:9G6C9DB K6G>67A:HL:G: 6AHD
:HI67A>H=:9JH>C<I=:;DGBJA6:
"7 : 4 1313 " 8 5
") ")
"0 : 4 ACAC 5
L=:G: /@ >HI=: 8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:D;AD69

/9 >HI=: 9:H><CK6AJ:D;AD69

/ >HI=:H:CH>I>K>IN8D:;;>8>:CID;AD69H
Y/9 >HI=: E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGD;BD9:AJC8:GI6>CI>:H
K- >H I=:8D:;;>8>:CIHD;K6G>6I>DCD; K6G>67A:AD69
0=: K6G>67A: AD69H 6G: 9>;;:G:CI ID K6G>67A: AD69H D; GD69 7G>9<:H 6C9 K6G>67A: AD69H D; G6>AL6N
7G>9<:H %C I=: 86H: D; GD69 7G>9<:H 688DG9>C< ID HI6C96G9 /0* !* * I=: E6GI>6A
H6;:IN;68IDG>H:FJ6AID Y- 6C9>CI=:86H:D;GD697G>9<:H I=:E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDG>H:FJ6AID
Y- ;DGC:L9:H><C:97G>9<:H0=:K6AJ: D; K6G>6I>DC8D:;;>8>:CIK- >H:FJ6AID K- ;DG
AD69HDCGD697G>9<:H6C9 K- ;DGAD69HDCG6>AL6N7G>9<:H8DCH>9:G>C<I=:;DGBJA6:
0=:C:LG:8DBB:C9:9E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGHD; K6G>67A: AD69H9:E:C9>C<DCI=:6<:D;7G>9<:H6C9
DCEA6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B:6G:H=DLC>C067 6C9067
#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(84674+ :&6.&'1* 14&)7 4364&)'6.),*7
,A6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B: - >
6<:D;7G>9<: 4N:6GH5
IG 4N:6GH5 N:6GH
N:6GH N:6GH

[
[
[

#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(84674+ :&6.&'1* 14&)7 436&.1;&='6.),*7
,A6CC:9G:B6>C>C<A>;:I>B: - >
6<:D;7G>9<: 4N:6GH5
IG 4N:6GH5 N:6GH
N:6GH N:6GH

[
[
[

.-$+20).-0
0=: E6E:G EG:H:CIH I=: G:HJAIH D; I=: G:H:6G8= 8DC8:GC>C< I=: G:A>67>A>IN A:K:AH ;DG :K6AJ6I>DC D;
:M>HI>C< 7G>9<:H0=: BD9>;>:9 G:A>67>A>IN A:K:AH ;DG :K6AJ6I>DC L:G: 9:I:GB>C:9 6C9 I=:N 9:E:C9 DC
I=: 7G>9<: 6<: 6C9 DC EA6CC:9 G:B6>C>C< A>;:I>B: 0=: K6AJ:H D; I=: A:K:AH 6G: K6A>9 ;DG B:B7:GH
HJ7?:8I:9ID7:C9>C< 0=:DG:I>86AG:A>67>A>IN76H>H;DGBD9>;>86I>DCD;E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGB:I=D99J:
ID6AADL>C<;DGI=:B6?DG9>;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C:M>HI>C<7G>9<::K6AJ6I>DC6C99:H><CD;I=:C:LDC:H>H
EG:H:CI:9
%C;>C6A8DCH:FJ:C8: I=:ADL:GG:A>67>A>INA:K:AHG:;A:8I>CIDI=:E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGHD;B6I:G>6AH
6C9AD69H%CI=:E6E:G6G:H=DLC9:I:GB>C:9E6GI>6AH6;:IN ;68IDGH;DG8DC8G:I: 8 E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDG
;DGG:>C;DG8:B:CI H 6C9E6GI>6AH6;:IN;68IDGH;DGE:GB6C:CIAD69H # > 6C9K6G>67A:AD69H - >
$*-.4+&%(&,&-1
0=>HLDG@L6HHJEEDGI:97N.:H:6G8=,GD?:8ICD HJEEDGI:97N/ADK6@#G6CI<:C8N
&'&/&-$&0
AA:C ! 6C69>6C$><=L6NG>9<:!K6AJ6I>DC.:A>67>A>IN%C9:M &3&).&34963&14+.:.1
3,.3**6.3, 2DAJB: EE

6GIA:II ") J8@A6C9 ,# ':CC:9N & 6C69>6C$><=L6NG>9<:!K6AJ6I>DC :G>K6I>DCD;
A6JH: D;*/ [ [ &3&).&34963&14+.:.13,.3**6.3, EE

>6B6CI>9>H 64'&'.1.78.(77*772*384+<.78.3,"869(896*7.>A:B,J7A>86I>DCH/.(68=6C
:9:M
>IA:KH:C + )69H:C $+ "869(896&1!*1.&'.1.8=*8-4)7&D=C3>A:N6C9HDCH
G6;I *:*1&3)*:*1 > *8-4)74+77*772*38+466.),*73/I@>CH(DC9DC
!*

!JGD8D9: (8.43437869(896*7 > &68*3*6&1&(8.437 > *37.8.*77*1+;*.,-8
.2547*)14&)7+46'9.1).3,7 !*GJHH:A:
"G6C<DEDA ) !HI:H /NHI:B.:A>67>A>IN;DGDC9>I>DC!K6AJ6I>DCD;G>9<:H %C "
%4607-45?:&19&8.434+<.78.3,"8**1&3)42547.8*6.),*7@(6JH6CC: EE

(6JG>9H:C & ?:GGJB & C9:GH:C *$ (6HH:C G:6I>C<6G>9<:)6C6<:B:CI/NHI:B
"869(896&13,.3**6.3,38*63&8.43&1 2DAJB: EE

*DL6@ / #GJC> $* 6A>7G6I>DCD;I=:+CI6G>D$><=L6NG>9<:D9:!9>I>DC6C69>6C
4963&14+.:.13,.3**6.3, 2DAJB: EE

+$ 38&6.4.,-;&=6.),**7.,34)* G9:9>I>DC)>C>HIGND;0G6CHEDGI6I>DC DLCHK>:L
+CI6G>D
.::A ./ <DGL6A .:A>67>A>IN
6H:9/:8I>DCD;I=: G6;I6C69>6C$><=L6NG>9<: :H><C
D9: %C ";4607-45?:&19&8.434+<.78.3,"8**1&3)42547.8*6.),*7@(6JH6CC: EE

/0*!* &7.74+7869(896&1)*7.,3 /10* E
/0*!* &7.74+7869(896&1)*7.,32*3)2*38 /10* E
/0*!* * &7.74+7869(896&1)*7.,32*3)2*38&8.43&1&33*< /10* E
/0*!*
(8.43437869(896*7&68 #6&++.(14&)743'6.),*7 /10* E
/0*!*
* (8.43437869(896*7&68 #6&++.(14&)743'6.),*7 &8.43&1&33*< /10* E
0=DBEHDC , /B6AA !, &D=CHDC ) )6GH=6AA 0=:,DCI>HG>9<:)6C6<:B:CI
/NHI:B "869(896&13,.3**6.3,38*63&8.43&1 2DAJB: EE

2>S6C &6I6AA 6.),*&3&,*2*38"=78*2 > *8-4)414,=4+8-*<.78.3,!4&)6.),*:&19&8.43 ">C6A
.:EDGI;DG/ADK6@.D699B>C>HIG6I>DC1C>K:GH>IND;V>A>C6 >C/ADK6@
3DC< /) $D77H .! +CD; !A:B:CI6C9/NHI:B.>H@DCH>9:G6I>DCH>C$><=L6NG>9<:
HH:HHB:CI %C 64(4+ 8-38*63&8.43&143+*6*3(*43966*38&3)9896*#6*3)7.3?6.),**7.,3
437869(8.43&3)&.38*3&3(*@ 'J6A6(JBEJ

Partial Safety Factors For Evaluation of Existing Bridges According To Eurocodes

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originaltitel

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Partial Safety Factors For Evaluation of Existing Bridges According To Eurocodes

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

.

!

L=:G: B. H. 6G:I=:76H>8E6G6B:I:GHD;I=:CDGB6AAN9>HIG>7JI:9G6C9DBK6G>67A:G:H>HI6C8:.

L=:G: D >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G 6II=:I>B:I

I >CHE >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G 6II=:I>B:I I>CHE D;I=: E:G>D9>8>CHE:8I>DC

6C9>;I=:E6G6B:I:G>HA>C:6GAN 9:E:C9:CIDCI>B: JH>C<HJ7HI>IJI>DCID>HD7I6>C:9

L=:G: >HI=:EGD767>A>IN9:CH>IN;JC8I>DCD; HI6C96G9>O:9 CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DC*

.,$5)&8)61.&'.1.8=.3)< 9 &3)8-8&6,861.&'.1.8=.3)< 8 .3)53)3(43.375(8.43

., #&6,861.&'.1.8=.3)< 8 .3)5*3)3(438.24+.375(8.43&3)51&33)62&.3.3,1.+8.2

#&' #-5&68.&17&+8=+&(846 ( +46(43(687863,8-:&1.)+46<.78.3,'6.),**:&19&8.43

L=:G: /@ >HI=: 8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:D;AD69

#&' #-5&68.&17&+8=+&(84674+562&33814&)7 (&78.351&(2&)564)9(*7

L=:G: /@ >HI=: 8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:D;AD69

#&' #-5&68.&17&+8=+&(84674+ :&6.&'1* 14&)7 4364&)'6.),*7

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen

Partial Safety Factors For Evaluation of Existing Bridges According To Eurocodes

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originaltitel

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Partial Safety Factors For Evaluation of Existing Bridges According To Eurocodes

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

.

   !     

L=:G: B. H. 6G:I=:76H>8E6G6B:I:GHD;I=:CDGB6AAN9>HIG>7JI:9G6C9DBK6G>67A:G:H>HI6C8:.

L=:G: D >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G  6II=:I>B:I 

I >CHE >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G  6II=:I>B:I  I>CHE D;I=: E:G>D9>8>CHE:8I>DC

6C9>;I=:E6G6B:I:G>HA>C:6GAN 9:E:C9:CIDCI>B: JH>C<HJ7HI>IJI>DCID>HD7I6>C:9

L=:G: >HI=:EGD767>A>IN9:CH>IN;JC8I>DCD; HI6C96G9>O:9 CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DC* 

.,$5)&8*)6*1.&'.1.8=.3)*< 9 &3)8-*8&6,*86*1.&'.1.8=.3)*< 8 .3)*5*3)*3(*43.375*(8.43

., #&6,*86*1.&'.1.8=.3)*< 8 .3)*5*3)*3(*438.2*4+.375*(8.43&3)51&33*)6*2&.3.3,1.+*8.2*

#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(846 ( +46(43(6*8*786*3,8-:&1.)+46*<.78.3,'6.),**:&19&8.43

L=:G: /@ >HI=: 8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:D;AD69

#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(84674+5*62&3*3814&)7  (&78.351&(*2&)*564)9(*7

L=:G: /@ >HI=: 8=6G68I:G>HI>8K6AJ:D;AD69

#&' #-*5&68.&17&+*8=+&(84674+ :&6.&'1* 14&)7 4364&)'6.),*7

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen

!

L=:G: D >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G 6II=:I>B:I

I >CHE >HI=:K6AJ:D;E6G6B:I:G 6II=:I>B:I I>CHE D;I=: E:G>D9>8>CHE:8I>DC

6C9>;I=:E6G6B:I:G>HA>C:6GAN 9:E:C9:CIDCI>B: JH>C<HJ7HI>IJI>DCID>HD7I6>C:9

L=:G: >HI=:EGD767>A>IN9:CH>IN;JC8I>DCD; HI6C96G9>O:9 CDGB6A9>HIG>7JI>DC*

.,$5)&8)61.&'.1.8=.3)< 9 &3)8-8&6,861.&'.1.8=.3)< 8 .3)53)3(43.375(8.43

., #&6,861.&'.1.8=.3)< 8 .3)5*3)3(438.24+.375(8.43&3)51&33)62&.3.3,1.+8.2

#&' #-5&68.&17&+8=+&(846 ( +46(43(687863,8-:&1.)+46<.78.3,'6.),**:&19&8.43

#&' #-5&68.&17&+8=+&(84674+562&33814&)7 (&78.351&(2&)564)9(*7

#&' #-5&68.&17&+8=+&(84674+ :&6.&'1* 14&)7 4364&)'6.),*7