This article was downloaded by: [University of Sydney]

On: 01 January 2015, At: 05:58

Publisher: Routledge
Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number:
1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street,
London W1T 3JH, UK

Philosophical Papers
Publication details, including instructions for
authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/rppa20

A Pragmatist Spin on
Analytical Marxism and
Methodological Individualism
a
Chandra Kumar
a
Rhodes University
Published online: 02 Sep 2009.

To cite this article: Chandra Kumar (2008) A Pragmatist Spin on Analytical Marxism
and Methodological Individualism, Philosophical Papers, 37:2, 185-211, DOI:
10.1080/05568640809485219

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/05568640809485219

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all
the information (the “Content”) contained in the publications on our
platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors
make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy,
completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions
and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of
the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis.
The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be
independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and
Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings,
demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
 or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in
relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.

This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study
purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution,
reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access
and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-
conditions
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015
 ! ! ! " # $ !%
*
# &' % " (!% ) %

+'& %&, & - '& . !% .. ! &' % " !% ) % )&

Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

&' % " ' ' )& ! ,&&! %&/ & & )&% 0 ' ! ! " # $ 1
2 '&! '! 3 & & ! 4 & !% '& ' )& " & % 5! ! - ) - &' % "
!% ) % - '& &-- 6& ! " # $ & 7 " &! -"8 !%
7 8 ' ! & & )& ! - # $ (! % ! '& ' )& & &! &%
&' % " !% ) % !&"& ! &% &! ! %% ! # $ -
," ! +' ) &5 '& & "' &! &% - ' '" & &" )& (
&% ' - "' & &" )& '& %&, & ,& 5&&! '& !% ) % !% '
' % ' )& ,&&! % )&% '& ' ! & )&% ! - ) - '& !% ) % (
& &% ' "' % ! 5 % &)&! &! '&! ! " # $ , &% &" !
! " &!& & 5 % & " !% " ,& ! '& " ! & 5 %
!% 5 - &!% & &' % " %&, &

!"& '& . '& ! " # $ ' )& &% '& " ,

" " 6& &! & - # $ '& 5 ' "" , ! '&
," ! !% % 5' "' '& & "& )&% ! ' '&
&) ! )& ! - # $ 9, ' 0 & & ! )& ! !% '& --"
# $ - '& - & 2 ! " & & : !& - '& - '
!&% " ! 5 "& ! 5' 5 % & ! ) ,& !
# $ !"& '& 7 8 !% % - ! " ' ' !% '&
% & & ' % - '& " " &!"& 5& & &% 9 '&
' ! %&! !"&% - - 7, & %& 8 ; 5&)& % ,&
' &! ! && & ! ,& ' & +' ,&" &
&) %&! 5'&! !& " ! %& ! & ! '& ' ' - " " &!"&
' 5 ' %&, &% 5 ' ! !% %& ! " # $ % !

*0 6 ! ' & 5 &% , 3< '& ' - "! ! 3& & "'
< !% ! !% (= '& 5&% ' 3& & "' 2 !" ! " !!&" ! 5 ' '& >&"
(%& : & ! !% = & " "
 ?

'& !% . '& & - &' % " !% ) % )&

&' % " ' (! % !" ! '& & )& - & & )& ! -
# $ & - '& ! " # $ ' )& !" " % &%
"& ! ! & ) &5 ! '& " " &!"& !% '& ' ' -
" " &!"& 5 ' '& & ' '& ' )& % 5! '& 5 ! & !
- ' & %&, &
: !& - '& & 5 ! & ! ( ' !6 '& ! ! ' # $ !&&%
,& !%&% ! & ' % " !% ) % 9 % " !& , 5'
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

" ! ! ""& , & & 7 " &! -"8 - - &$ ! ! ! '&

" " &!"& +'& ! & ! "' &! &' % "
!% ) % ! & - '& ! " # $ ' " &5 ' !
"' &! ! "' "& '& 5& @ %&, , & 5'& '&
7 ! "' "& # $ 8 ' % "&% ! ' ! &- & &) !
'& & ' " !% '& & ! & " !"& !&% 5 ' '
' ! & % ,&&! % " % ! ,& % & &--&" )& !%
! 5 ' '& - " %& , % ! "' " & " - !
"' "& '& 9 !% 5 ' '& , & )& "' &!
&$ ! ! ! & -7 &"' ! 8
# - " ' 5&)& 5 ! ,& ! ! "' "& '& , !
&' % " !% ) % 95' "' " !%& &!%&! -
! "' "& & '& & " &$ ! ! (5 & ' '&
"' &! &' % " !% ) % ' &) %&! ! '& 5 6
- & - '& ! " # $ !- ! & , ' ,&" &

+' ) &5 &$ & &% , ! '& &)&! A 6& .

:-" & 7 & &--&" )& !% ! 8 5 ,& " ! &% & )& !
% &!"& 3 ! "' "& # $ & &% 5 % ! % &!"& - 5' ! "' "&
'& 6 !% -! ! & @ - - " & 5' ! ! ! & ' %
,& ! & --, 7 ! "' "& # $ 8 5 ' & &! & - & ' % "
' ! , '& - - % &" " # $ 5 ' '& 5! " &' % "
5' "' '& ! " # $ &>&" && 2 ! " ? B? ! &' % "
!% ) % !% ! "' "& # $ C - & &!& &"&! " " - !
"' "& '& && A&' !&! !% D 6 6 !% 3& 3& !&& !
!% 5 ' & ! & %& ! " !"& ! - " &!"& " " & '& ! "' "&
'& 8 "' &! 7 &"' ! 8 ! ! '& ! ' 7 !)& !
&"' ! E E &' % " & 5 '- &% ", 8 ! '& "
" &!"& ?
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) %

%&% ! & - !% ,&" & " ! & % ! !!&"& / & -

&' % " ' % & &' ' ! % " -
% )& ! " &!& & - '& & " !% " ,& -
&9 & ! 5' '& ! " # $ ! &!%&% (- '
! ! "" ! - %& ,&

+'& &$ ( 5 ,& ! 5 ' 1 2 '&!8 7(! % " !8 '& &" !%

Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

&% ! - ' 2 '&! $) $$)

;& & 5& -!% & ! " , '& &' % " !%
' '" " &! - ! " # $ +'& ! "
# $ 2 '&! %&" & & & ! 5& ) ! " &% "& !
& ' % - & ! ! !% &"'! / & - !/ ' ! '& & ! -
'& , ! )& " -# $ " '& (! " '& &
" &% 5' '& " 7 ! ! , % &! &8 !% 7 ! !
! 5 &! & 8 (! '& , % &! & ! " ' !6 ! 7 &%
" &% F% &" " G ' !6 ! 8 ! '& ! 5 &! & 7 &% 5'
' ,& " &% F' "G ' !6 ! 8 $) ! " # $ 2 '&!
)& )& ,& ! " ! , ' '& & &! & !% '& 7,& &- ! '&
5& - ! , ' ! , % !% ! 5 &! & ! &) , &8
$$ ) ;& " ! ! & ! '& & !&
!% " &! # $ '& & &% " &!
" ) & ! , & ! '& 5 ' " &! ! "
&"'! / & +'& " &! '& &"'! / & 5& ' % " &-&"
! '! & ' ! " &! & ! &- ( &- & $ '&
%& !% - " & & &! !% &! 0 & ,& &)& '
! ," ! & ! " & !! & ! ! '&
, % &! & ! '& ! & - % &" " !% & ! ! '& ! 5
&! & ! '& ! & - ! !% ) % ' $$ )

+ & '& & " &% ! " &"'! / & & & &! - 2 '&!
7 ! !5 ! !& ""& '& & - & ! & -8 $$ )
(! 5' - 5 ( 5 ! & ! ! 2 '&!8 7, % &! &8 ! '&

+'& - &% ! & &% ! . ( " & ! 5 6 - ! " # $

 ! & - % &" " &' % ' '( & "& " ' ! 2 '&! -
'& %& - " &% 7 ! " & ' %8 !% , '& 7 5& - ! 8
! , ' ' &! & ( 5 ' 5&)& & ! ! ' 7! 5 &! &8 !
'& ! & - ! ! ! &% " ! ' " !
& ' " (! ' )& ! ( 5 & ' '& %&, & !
&' % " !% ) % # ( &&! ! ' ' %
! ' )& ,&&! & )&% 2 '&! && & '& ' )& ! - ) -
# ( )& &' % " ' # ; (- ! ' ! '& ,& ' %
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

' )& ,&&! )&% & '& &)& - , " ! 5' "' '&
" 5& & - &% @ 2 '&! && & ' & #(
& ! ! '& 7! 5 &! &895' "' - 2 '&! & 7 & !
& -8 ( ' !6 ! '& " ! ' ! " # $ ' % ! ,&
%% &% 5 ' " &! ! ! ' &! &9 & ' ! ' '&
2 '&! - '& - &% ! . %% ! % +'& & "& !
' 5!& 2 '&!8 " ! ,&' - - ! !% 7 '& & -
& !8 ( - ! !& - '& " / & - % ! ! " ' '
" ! - ) / & )& '& ' && %&" %& ' )&%
' # '& & ' 5&)& - " ! ! 2 '&!8 7! 58 &! & -
! && "& 5 &, ' ' 5& " ! ' )& ,& &
) &5 -5' '& ! " # $ !% '& -& 5 )& & ' )& % !&
,& '& !%& !% !% & '& 6& " -# $ , '
&$ ! !% ! )& !% ' !6 " & ! & ' )! %
5 ' " & ! '& 5 6 ! -" !% '& %& ,
, !% ! , - "
(5 "&&% - 5 < (5 ! & %& 5' 2 '&!
&! , 7 ! 8 ! '& ! 5 &! & - '& & +'&! ( 5 " "
% " 2 '&!8 " ! '& ' - 6 !% - "& "
5 % , ' &% " ! )& ! - # ( !% & ' " )& ! -
!% ) % !% ' !6 !/ 5'& '& " &! -"
! '& - - !/ ' ! & C !% '& ! &
& >% & &' % ! ! & - , "6 '&
7! ! "! & - & 8 , ! & - & !% " ! &/ &!"&
!" % ! '& & " & !% " ! &/ &!"& &!
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) % .

"! , ! %& , & " "& 3& &) ! '& & 8

)& ! & ' " '& ! "6 - 7 ! " & !& 8
!% &>&" ! - '& ! ! ' '& 6 - !/ "" &
& & &! ' ! > '& & ! '& & )& 9' 5 '& & &! &
- ! 6 !% - %& " ! " !"& ! - !
' ! !&& !&&% & B ( ! ! ' - 5& 6&
! 5' "' "&! !" %& ! ! & & &! !
' ) &5 - ! & !% & ! ! - - & ! " & !!
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

' '&! 5& 5 % % " % )& ! - !% ) % !%

' !% ' ! % ! 5& 5 % % "' & )& '& , -
' !6 ! ' '& & & 5 % !" " & ! &' % &
%&! &% , '& & & ( % 5 5 & ! - ' - '
! & ! ,& &' % " H' ' " %&, & &) ) ! !% # (
' % 5 6& , "6 & & , ! )& " ' "
! 5' "' " ! !% % & "&&% 5 ' &-& &!"& '& & &C
&" !% ' # ( ' % "& & ,& ! & &% !
" &% 7' "8 " !% - !" ! &$ ! ! !# $ !% !
" " &!"& &!&

(! ' "" ! - ! ! '& ! 5 &! & 2 '&! ) &/ &

5 ' - -# (
(! ' ! 5& &! & '& ! " !& - ! " # $
% ! &$ ! '&! &! , &-& &!"& '& "
"! &! !% " &"' ! ' & &" )& " & '& &! &
!% !%& & '& "& & 5' "' "" & &)& - & ! E
(! - ! " # $ & ! " ! ' ! 5& &! & '& &>&"
'& ! - ) &5 ! 5' "' " - ! !% " & & %& " &%
,& ! 5 - ,&' ) ' &! - !" ! - '& ,&' ) - '&
"! &! !% ) % $$

2 '&! ! ! ' 7 " ! 5 %& , & !% 5

, & &)&! - ! 5 ,& "' &)& !& ! " "&

B && '& & 3 .. !% & &! .. C

 .

)&! & - '& %&)& &! - " % " !&8 $$ ;&

!& & ' &) %&, & 5 ' ! 4 & ! - !" ! &$ ! !
!% '& !&&% - 7 " - !% !8 ! ' ' (! '& & %&, & 4 &
5 ! &! ! '& !&&% - ! "" ! - " - !% ! !% !
'& - !" ! '& & - ' " & 9 "' '& '& ' '&
7& !% " & " &8 - " & " ! ,& &$ !&% & !
& !& ! & - ,& ! - !" ! - '& &) ! & -
&" ! " % " ! (! '& 7(! % " !8 2 '&! ! ! '
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

' &! ! 4 & 5 ! ' - !" ! &$ ! ! " ! ,&

%&/ & 5 ' ! &$ " "" ! - " &"' ! , '
!" && "' " &$ ! ! & ! # $ 5 % ,&
& & " !%& ! '& ,& ! ! "&! -" ,&- & - '&
!)& ! ! , & &"' ! +'& & " !" ! "" % !
2 '&! ' 7 & ! " # $ 5 " &! -" !%&)& &%
'& ! '& 5 ' '& % ! " 5 ,&- & 5 & &! &% ,
" &"' ! " !% ! & "' " & ,&" & - - & & & &!
&! & "' / ! & - &" ! " " &
! & &! - '& & - !% &! " ! &! 8 $$ ) ? !
! '& ! 5 &! & '& &- & , & '& '& 7 & & &! 8 "
&)& " & & 6& 7&" ! " " &8 7" " !- " 8 7 ,
" 8 7 '& & & 8 !% ! ! & - '& 7 &
- !% &! "! &! 8 &% ,& !% ) % (! '& " ! &$ -
# $8 '& -' 2 '&! 7 " ' " ,&6
% 5! !% )& 5 " ! & ' 5 ' 5 ,&' ) -
!% ) % &% ' & !% ! ' ! & & & % ' & !"&
,&' ) - !% ) % & 5 5'& & '& " ! ! '& -!
! 8 $$ )
+'& & & 6 !&&% ,& ! "6&% ,&- & '& " ! & ,&

&& - &$ &4 & . . !% 2 '&! . .

? ( && 5 ' 2 ! " ? ' 2 '&! ' ' - &% ' ! & &$ &! !%
" !"&%&% & 4 & ' ! '& % % ! '& & & %&, & (! - " ( ) !
" && && &! 5 ' 2 ! " 8 " " " &! ! 2 '&!8 7(! % " !8 '&
&% ! (! ' & ( & &$ &! -& ' ! 2 !" 8 " " !
& & -" ! " 5 ' ! '& % &
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) % .

& &% 5& 5 && '& " % ,& ! "6&% ! 5 ' 6&
'& - ) , ' 5 % !%& !& '& ! ! ' ! !
! 5 &! & % ! '& " &% 7 ! " 8 " '& - !
'& 6 !% - " '& 5& '& ! ! ' #( ! "'
' "& % ! ' , &- #; @ ! - 2 '&!8 %& " !
- ! ! ! 5 &! & ! ) !) )& " &!
' ' / & ! , & &% " ! !%H & ' " !-&" &% )& !
-# ( ' ! " # $ ! " " " '& " ! )& 5&
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

5 ' C (5 "

2 '&!8 % -7 ! !% ) % ' 8 ! &% ! "' 5

' )& " & 5' "' )& ! -# ( '& ' !6 " &" +'& %& '
5 &!& ! , " - ! !% " & & 7 - !" !
- '& ,&' ) - '& " ! &! !% ) % 8 , ,& 5&&!
7 "' 5 !% &!& ! & 5 &!& !
, !% ) % 8 !% 7 '& ,&' ) - !% ) % & ! !&
!& ! ,& - '& " "& & !%& ! "' 5 !%
&!& ! 8 +'& & " ( ' !6 ) C '& - & !
# & )& '& )& " ! ,& 5&&! !% ) % !% '
,& " & 5& ' !% ) % & '& 7- !% &!
"! &! 8 - " & "& ! &$ ! - !% ) % % @
" !)& & !% ) % & " ,& ! & ,& - " & & ' % 5&
'&! ' "& '& 7- !% &! & 8- 5' "' !% ) %
& & &I (- ' & %&% ! , %5 - & 6 ! 5' !
& , % ' ! '& " , !% ) % ,& ! &
7- !% &! 8I = 5& ' )& ! &- , & %& - 5' ' !
7 !% ) % 8 ' ! ! %& - " ,& ! 5 & &%
" &% 5 ' ! & " ! 5 ' ' )! ! & " &% 5 ' '&
!% ) % I < & &" )& '& 5' & %& - & !
"& ! 5' & - !% &! '& !% ) % '&
 .

" " &" ) , % !& (! & " ! &$ - &

& ,& & -" ! !% ) % C ! '& " ! &$ - '&
& ,& & &- 6 , ! ! "
" & 0 ' ' !6 ' !& - '& & 5 - 6 ! ,& &
& & &! " & 7 & 8 ' ! '& '& I (-
& ! & ! &% - & & &! ! '& ! ! " &
, !& & ! " " ' ! ' )& &) )&% ' '&
" & 5 ' &!) ! &! !% )& '&! 6 5' "'
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

) ", & - !% &! ! '& &! & ' & & &! &
- ! !&& !&&% & ' 5& ' )& 6
, % - & / & ! < '& / & ! 5'& '& '&
!% ) % '& " & - !% &! ' % & - ,& / & !&%
( ' % 5 ,& 6&% 7 & - !% &! ! 5' &! & ! 5' "'
" ! &$ !% - 5' "' & I8
+'& & &!& & 6 ' % ,& 6& ! !% ! '& - 5 ! &
%& &% % " ! -# ( (5 ! 5 "&&% 6 & - '&
&! ' ' )& ,&&! %& ! ' & !% % 5 "& !
" !" ! - '& , ' , '& %&, & ,& 5&&! '& !% ) %
!% ' !% , 5' ' ' % & ! - ! " # $

# &' % " !% ) % % " !& , & & &$ ! !

! '& " " &!"& ' ' ,&&! ) %&, &% & 5 "& !
'
'& "&! ! '& !% ? 5 ' %&-&!%& - # ( "' <
; &6 . !% " " "' # "& # !%& , . '&!
- '& & '& . 5 ' %&-&!%& "' ! 4 & .
= ! & A & .. !% '! 3 & & . !% " " "'
! 1 -!6& . 3 "' % # & . !% &5 A&) !& A&) !&
. !% + ,>J ! +K!! >J .. ' '# $ 5 '&

: !& &$ & - "' &$ " ! ! 5 '! ! " # $ = !& A &8
%&-&!"& - 7 ! " !% ) % 8 A & .. . ! '& &$ & %&
! " # $ - - & %&! - 2 '&! 3 >&&) @' ' ) 5' &&
%&-&!% 6 !% - & ' " ' @' ' ) ..
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) % .

"&! & - , ' %&, & '& & %&, & % !" )& ! ' 5
! %&, & 5 ' ! ! " # $ & - '& ! "
# $ "' 3 & & !% 4 & ,& ! %&)& , !% -
7 ! "' "& # $ 8 5' "' '& !6&% #( ! & -
&! &! , - --! # ( '& ' ' 5&! &!" & 6
- " - !% ! 7 '& &)& - '& !% ) % 8C !% ! "' "&
'& 5 & &% ! &$"& &! )&' " & - '
+' 5' & !& - & ! ! & ' '& & ! !&& !
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

!" &% " ! ,& 5&&! !% ) % !% ' &$ ! ! +'&

! / & ! , & # !%H@ % % ! ! &
! & ' ' " ) &5C '& % - '& (!% ) % !% '&
" && ' )& ! & &% !% ( 5 ! & ' '
&$ ! 5' '& %&, & ,& 5&&! &' % " !% ) % !%
' ' ! ,&&! %&/ & & )&% '& % )&% 5 ' !
! " # $ 9 %& ! " # $ - ' &
+'& ! & )& ! -# ( '& ! ! ' ! & & "
&$ ! !"! ! !" & ,& &% "&% &$ ! ! ! & - '&
"' " & " - !% ) % C- ! &% " , & ! & &
&$ ! ! &% ! ' 5 '& % " !& & &/ & ! ' !
! 5& ; 5 " % &$ ! ! ! & - '& "' " & " -
!% ) % " &$ ! ! 5 ' " & &) ! - '& & 5& &
! &$ ! 5 6 ,& ! % !& - ! " , ! ,
'& ,& 5&&! !% ! !% ) % ! '& 5 % ,
& !I( ' ! ! ) % , & !% - % & ! ,&" & !" &
5' '& & &) ! " ! # ( 5 % ,&I ; 5 5 % &' % "
"' % --& I ; " & '& &$ ! & -
" & ! " " & !% " ! ! (- '& " !
!% ) % " &$ ! ! &$ ! ! ! & - " & ! !%
" " & 5' '& ! & -' "! I= & " !&
! " !"& ! - - !% &! " !% ) % I; 5"!

< " " " / & - '& % - '& (!% ) % !% " && = &5&
.
 .B

5& %&! - !% ) % - '& " & !I( & &) !

! % !" ! - !%& !% ! - ,
& '& &$ ! ! - " " &! ' ! > !
" " "I
(! %% & ! '& & / & ! 5& " ! , & )& ' # ( " !
" &% 5 ' '& & - ! &! ! "' " &$ ! !
7 '& &)& - '& !% ) % 8 ! '& " " &!"& !% 7' 8 5 '
" '& - - , % ! ! ! &! ! &$ ! ! (- # (
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

"! &% &% " ! % " !& " ! ,& 6&! '& '& ' '&
& & - &$ ! ! 5'& & & & &% " , & ! !" &
'& - & ! ! &% " )& # ( 5 % )& '& 5& 6& " ' '&
& &$ ! ! !&&% ,& & &! &% , ! &% "&% '&
- & C ! '& & - ! "' "& '& & &! &% , !
"" ! - 7 " - !% !8 7 " &"' ! 8 (! '& &--
6& & - ! & " " &!"& &"'! / & - %" &
! - '& ! " # $ ' )& % &% ' ! & -7 " 8
!% 7 " 8 +'& ' )& %& & - ! "' "& '& !% &
'& ! &# $ '& & , "& !% ' 5&
%% & / & ! , '& > "& - " !% " +' '
' ! -& & - 2 '&!8 5 6 '& && '& & &"'! / & !% -
- !/ - ! ! !& - 5' '& " ! ! '&
7! 5 &! &8 !% ! , '& 7(! % " !8 '& ! 5 &&
' !6 ' '& & !% &! , & % " " &!"&
; 5&)& '& & %&! - 5 " & % !" & -
&$ ! ! !%& '& '& % ! 7 !% ) % 8 !% 7' 8 !& - 5' "'
'& ' " !&&% & '& ,& &% "&% & &! &% ,
'& '& '& !% ) % " && ,& "- '& -
5& " &- " ! %& 5' " !) )&% ! " &$ ! ! !
! ! ) " '& &$ ! ! ! 5 &-& &
" , ' '& -7&! & 8 & ' &% , &$ ! '
!% ' & & ' &% , &$ ! !% ) % " " &
! ! !% " & ! ! '& !& ' !% !% '& ,& &- !%
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) % .

%& & - !% ) % ! '& '& . & ' "! & !"&

'& & ! 5 !" , & '& & ! 5 ' & '& &
7 !% ) % 8 &$ ! ! - '& & " " 7' "8
&$ ! ! (! - 5& % ! ' ! &" ! " " -
" &)& - ! '& & % !" ! & " ! &$ & )& !%
& )& &$ ! !% '& &C -" ! % --& &!
- " & ! ! ! !% ) % &)& & !% %& ) )&
" & +'& & ! & ! ' !6 ' 5& & %& ! '& & 5 '
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

" ! &$ ! "&!%&! & ' " % !" ! " & !% ! ' '&
!% 5& &)& -3& & '& 7 & - !% &! 8 ' ! '& '&
! ' & ' " &! & - 7 & - !% &! 8 ! '& &
% !" ! ( 5 & %&- & 2 '&!8 " , '& & -
! ! '& ! 5 &! & ! ! " # $

: !& - '& - !% ! & ,& - ! " # $ ! 4 & '

,&&! ! %&! %&-&!%& - # ( )& '& & , ! &
> 5' # ( " " & ! 4 &8 ! 5 ! ;& ' %&
! " , , ! "& ' 5 '& & " &' 5 '
& "' '& - & %&, & 5 ' 2 '&! ! 2 '&!8 ! ! !% ) % %
!% '& 4 & " & ,& &)& ' # ( ' ' " &" !
7& &! ) % " !&8 4 & .. ,& !& ' '
"! ! ,&&! ) &% , # $ 9 "" % ! '& 4 & -
. '& !
L# (M & !& '& ! " & &" )& ! ' & ! ,& 5&&!
!% ) % &! 5 &% " , & '& ! % " &% " & ! &
" ,& 5 ' ! &" -" & - ) ! ! ! "' "&
'& & ! & -&" !& ! '& !! & 7 )&!8 "' " & -
%& & " ! &! 5 ' '& ) &5 ' %& & & ' &% , "& '
, '& !% ) % ! -! E " !% ) % ,& !

. 2 !" ) %&% " & ! &! - ' ! '& " - #( %& ,

' & && & . ? !% 2 !" . && - " " - & 8
)& ! -# ( +K!! >J ..
 .?

&' % " % " !& " ,& 5 ' ! " ! )&

&! ! ..

(- # ( ! !& - '& , )& ' ! 5' &" & !% 5' % &

I 4 & 8 ! 5& ! 5 ' - -
' & 7&$ ! '& " &$ , '& &9 '&
!" & ' ' , ' , " &! -" & ! '& - "& -
6 !% - ' " ," ! 8 .. +'& & & 5 % --& &! %&
'& & : !& ' # ( & &% "& '& " &$ '& & '& '&
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

' ) % 7' " ," ! 8 +'& & % --& &! %& ,&" &
!& " ! " ! &! &>&" "& ! & ' " - -' 5' &
,& ! "& " - !% ) % - - &% " ! +'& -'
4 & ' % ! !% )& &% ! '& ;& & ! # $ !
% ! 4 & . B. )& - - 7' " ," ! 8 !
' % ! !" %& '& %& ' 7; 8 ! &! ! &-
/ ! &! ! &! 5 ' ! & ' " &
&' 5 & & ' ! '& !% ) % " ! '& & ' !6
!% " !% ' !% ) % & ! " & '&! &!
! -& ! - " &- , ! " " & "
5' &
(- # ( > '& ! ' &>&" - -' '
&$ ! 5' 4 & ' " & & % ! 7& &! )
% " !&8 +'& & & '& & ' " - -' 5 ' ! "&
&$ ! ! & & )& ) & ! '& " " &!"& +'& & !
& ! ' !6 '& & ! ! & ! &% &$" , & - '&
! -" ! " & - # $ '& !" % ! '& '& -' +'&
& &- ! &- # $ &$ ! - &5 6 ' 5&
' )& +'& & - -' !% ) % " &! &
5 ' "' " & " 5& ! " ,& !% ) % ' &
&% ,& & - !% &! & ! & &! & ' ! '&
!% ) % '& & )& +' 5' A&) !& ,& !% 0 ' ! '&
! & ! # ( !% # $ " &% 7 % " ' 8 . +'&
" ! %& &% ' - -' ,& > ,& 9 '&
%& ' '& 7 ! % " &% " & - !% ) % 8 " ! &$ ! "' -
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) % .

! -" !"& ! " )& '& "' " & &% &&6
&$ ! ! ! & - "' " & " - !% ) % ' " ! ,&
%&! -&% !% !%& % 5 ' &)&! " &-& &!"& "
& ! A 6& '& &$ & & - -' &! !&% , )& ' !
&$ & & ) &5 -% , !& , !% -&5 " ! " %'& &! ,
'& & ! % " ! ! ' " ! &$ < !"& 5& , !% !
, ' !% &! & & 7 %" ' 8 ! !
! &$ ! ! ! & - & ! ,& 5&&! !% ! !% ) %
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

' " & ! +'& & ! "' ,& 5&&!

! &! ! !% ! ! ! &! ! " &$ ! ! , '
" &$ " &-& & ! ,& 5&&! !% ! !% ) %
!% !& '& &-& &)& - & 7' '& 8 7%&& & 8 ' ! '& '&
+'& % --& &!"& ,& 5&&! # ( !% ! ! &% " ! - -# ; ' %
! ,& ) &5&% & ' " % --& &!"&9 % --& &!"& ,& 5&&! '&
! " - !% ) % 5 ' '& ,& &- !% %& & ! '& !&
' !% !% " ! ! !% "& & 5 ' '& & !'
,& 5&&! !% ) % '& & , % ! '& '& @ '&! 5' '&
% --& &!"&I
, &! '& & ' " - " !% ) % !% -
!% ) % " &! & ' &$ 7 , )& !% ,& !%8 !% ) %
! ,) ' 5 5& ' % ! 5& ' / & !9 ' ' ! '&
& & - &! > &% ' '& & ! ,) ! 5& !&
' % & ! , ! '& % & ' " % !" ! ! ' ' '& , "6
% : !& " ! ! 5& ( ' )& & &% ' % !" )&
!% ) % &$ ! ! " & &$ ! ! ! & - '&
! &! ! "' " & ,& &- &-& &!"& %& & -
!% ) % 5'& & ! ! !% ) % &$ ! ! " &$ ! !
& - " " & 0 ' (5 ! & ' !"&
5& ' )& &>&" &% !% % " ' '& " &% 7 !% ) % 8
&$ ! ! & ! ! &! & " 5' & '& " &% 7' 8
&$ ! ! 6& &-& &!"& ! 7 & - !% &! 8 & ' ! '&
& ! !% ! & " ! - !% ) % C !% ' ! ' - ' 5&
' % "6 5 ' '& % !" ! ,& 5&&! ! &! ! !% ! ! ! &! !
 .

&$ ! ! 5 ' !! & & &' % " & ' "

) & & '& & 0 '& '& !& & ,& & & ,& &
&- & & &) ! & " &! -" & &! ' &! ! ' ! '& '&
!% 5'& '& &)&! & ! ! 5& '& &/ & ! '&
'& %& &!% &! & ! '& '& & " " ! &$ '& , ! )& "
!) )&% !% '& & &$ ! ! & &&! ! 5& A&
& ,& ! &$ ! 5' ( & ! 5 ' &-& &!"& '& , "
&! &% ! = ! % = ) % !8 5 ! ! !& & ! !%
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

7 & !! ' 8
+ &$ ! " '&! &! ! ! & - !% ) % 8 &!
! &! ! & 5& ,& , & &" - & - '& ,& &- !%
5 ! - !% ) % 0&% ' ! " '& , ! - ,& &-
&/ & ' 5& & ,& )& , & '& & ,& &- ! &! &!"&
&( , & & !& ,& &- ' '& !%& % , '&
& & (! , ! "' ,& &- " ( ' )& , &%
' - - '& ,& &- '& ' '& & & & & !% & &&
' '& & ! & & & && & ! ' ' & && &
% , '& & & ' '& & & !% % - &! "' '
!& " ! ,& !%& % !% ! !%&- ! & (- ( , & ,& &-
'& 5' "' " ! % " ! '& ,& &- ( ' )& , &% '& "
-( &! !& " !"& !&% 5 ' 6 ! &! & - ' & ! (5
& '& & ! & & '& & ! ! - '& 5 % 5 ' 5' "' ( ' !
'& ,& &- ! %& 6& '& ,& &- ! ! " ! % " (
&$ ! '& " ! % " ! &$ ! 5' & ! ! ' !5 %
' )& "' " ! % " ,& &- (! '& "& - , ! ,& &-
& !& ( 6 ! &! & - '& C '& & 5 "& & &
& &!& ! & , & (! % ! ' ( & ' ( ' &
& ! !% % - & ! ! 5 ' '& & ! 5' (

&& = ) % ! . . +'& &! ! & &! &% '& & , &% !

= ) % !8 %& ! & !! !% ! & & ! && ,& ! & 5 A %5
0 &! & !8 &! ! '& , - 7 ) & ! &8 ! '
" !% ! '& " " & '& - & !! ' 0 &! & ! ' &-
' % &) %&-&!%&% ! ' #
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) % ..

, ! ,& &- '& 5 & 5 % ,& ' % &' ,&

&)&! &" ! & '& ,& ! ! & & !% ' &$ &!
& ! ( & ' 5& ' & ! ,& &- !% ' 5& 5 %
' )& & & 5 ! !% !&&% ! " " !"&
: ! = ) % !8 ) &5 % --& &!"& ! ,&" & ! & ,& &!
! , % , "6 !% - ' &% ,& &- !% ! & & ! 5'
5& ,& &)& ! " ! ) %& '& , - '& %& &" ! -
% && &!
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

6& ! '& & ' > , , ! " ,& &-

& !& 5& ' " !% " , & ! &
& &% ,& &- '& 9 & &% - &$ & , 5! !% % -
!-& &!"& 0 & % ! !% " !! " , & ,& &- 5 !
& &5 ' , ! -! & - ! &! & ! & &
! -" ! ! - @ ! & " , " '&! &! !
!% '& & ! ! - 5 % & !"& !% ' ' & &%
! &9 &% '& " ! & -5 % !
0 '&! " & & !! '& & ! " & 7 ! %&8 !%
7 %&8 !% !% ) % & ' ' !% ' ' " !% ) %
" ! ! " - - " -& + ,& &)& 5 !
&'! ,& %& &!%&! ! !&8 )& ,& &) ! !%
%& ! ! '& ' ' ! & (!% ) % & & &
- & "' '& , ' ' !% %& & ' )& ! !& ! , "
"' " & (! &! ! &$ ! ! ,& % --& &! - "
&$ ! ! , ! ! ) & - &-& ! ! - & "
" &% !% ) % ,>&" ! " !& & ! -
!% ) % '& &- & ! & ,& " ' ! '& - - 7' "
," ! 8 ' 4 & %& %&
@ 5& ' )& &&! 4 & &>&" &% !% % ! '&%
- # ( 5' "' ! ' ) &5 &% " ! , ! #(
4 & & &% &% "& '& " &$ '& & @ - '& 7 &8
& &! 6& & &! !" , & !% ) % 5 ' '&
) & ! & 5' & '& I 4 & % " &% ' ! ! & & , 6
$ ! 5' "' 7 &% " ! E 5 "' " & &%
 & "' - 8 4 & .. ;& & 4 & 8 %& " !
- 5' &% " ! 9 !% '&!"& - 4 & # (9 & ! ! ' , 6
!% 5' &! !
"" % ! ' & & &! '& % --& &!"& ,& 5&&! '& !%
&"' ! !& - -!&!& - ! '& 5 6& 7(- '&!8
& &! & ! ! ! &"&%&! & , &/ &! !& &"' !
) %& '& " "' ! ' &% & ,& 5&&! '& 5 & (! '&
, &!"& - &"' ! '& 5 & & , "6 , $ E (! '& & &!
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

&$ ! '& & !% &"' ! % --& ! &)& - &!& '& ' !

-!&!& - ! (! & & & ! ! - '&
&"' ! - 7(- '&! 5 @8 7(- '&! 5 2 = 4 <
!% @ 8 : ! '& ) &5 & '& & ! - '& &"' !
- 7(- '&! 5 @8 7(- '&! & & @8 ; 5&)& ( &
'& - '& )& 7(- '&! & & 2 = 4 < !% @8 ..

(! ' & ! " & 5' 4 & & ! , '& 7" &$8 !% '&
7 &8 ! " " &!"& " & 5' 6& !% ) %
&$ ! ! % --& &! - ! ! !% ) % ' " &$ ! ! (
> ' !% ) % &$ ! ! & &"' ! 5' & ' "
!& % ! I +' 5 % ,& / & ! ,& ! - '& ' " %
' '& % ! %&! '& !&&% - &"' ! , & '&
!&&% - &$ ! ! ! & - " -" ' & ! &&
"' " & " - !% ) % 9! & & '& ,& &- !% %& & -
&$ & (- 5& & ! % "& ! 5' 4 & &! , #( &
5' ! - ' 5'& '& ! '& ' ) %&% %
%&-! ! '& , )& & " , !&% 5 ' '& &) / & -
4 & & ' "' (! & 6! -#( 4 & % & ! &!
& ! "' "& !! &!& 7 )&!!& 8 - %& &
" ! )& !% ) % 0 & 6! 5 4 & ' !6 - # ( !
7& &! ) % " !&8 ' & ! '& - " &!"& !% !
7' " ," ! 8 &% "& '& " &$ '& & !% 5&
6! 5 ' '& ' !6 - # ( 7 & "' - &"' ! 8 ' !6
' ' " "& '& '&
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) %

( '& % " '& & " ! '& " ! &$ - ' '& ,
%& ! " ' " & % 2 ! %& '& " ' '&
%& - 7% ) !& '8 &) &% ! & %& ! 4 & ,&" &
& )&% & & '& & -6 ! !% " ! %&& 2' !
" &9 ! 5& &% ! ' 5 '& " !&& 4 & 8 ) &5
&& ,& ' - ' &$ ! ! ,& & & '& 7, "6 , $8
,& 5&&! '& " !&& - 6! !% " !% @ '&
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

&) &!"& - '& %& - % ) !& ' !&&% ,& - &% ! 5 ' !
"" ! - &"' ! 2 = 4 E +' - '& ' '& ,&
" &% , & ! 5& '& / & ! 7% % % '& %& - % ) !& '
&) ! & %& ! 4 &I8 '& & ' ,& ! ! 5& '&
/ & ! 7 ! %% ! 5& ! '& " !&& - 6! !%
" &% '& &) &!"& - '& %& - % ) !& ' ! &
%& ! 4 &I8 ! 5& ! '& & / & ! 5 % )& &
&% " !
4 & " & # ( 5 ' '& & & - / & ! '& 7' 58
/ & ! &)&! - '& % & !8 %&-!& # ( ! '& & & +'& - '!
! & ! ' " ! &$ ' &)&! - 5& ! 5& &% 4 & 8 7' 58 / & !
, &"' ! 5& 5 % ! !&"& ' )& & - &%
&% " ! +' 5& 5 % ! ' )& ' 5! ' '& ! ' '&
5' "' 5 ! ! 5& 75' 8 / & ! " % ! !" & ,& & ! &%
! -) - '& ! 5& '& 7' 58 / & ! & 5& & ,&
&" - '& & &) ! &"' ! !"& 4 & " !"& !&% 5 '
"' " &"' ! & & 5& " % & ,&
, 5' "' " & 6! &% , ' '& & !% &%
! & ! & '& %& - % ) !& '9 &' ! % --& &! 5 !
) ! %& && !% - % --& &! & ! 0 & % " )& & &
&"' ! 2 = 4 < !% 1 ( " " '& & 1 -!6& 5 %
& &! ! '& - - &$ ! ! 0' "
!&& ' '& & ! ' '& &"' ! 5& &
% --& &! - '& " !& '& " "& & !6 ! @
5& & ! &$ " 5' '& 5& & '& %& - % ) !& '9 &
 & " , & - !" ! &/ ) &! 95 % ' )& &) &%
! 5 )&! '& & - &" ! " & '&! , ! ! )&! '&
" " & ' &- !% )&! '& & !% "
% ! ' "' " & &% ' & % +' % & ! &!
' '& %& 5 &% - , )& ' %% !
! 5& & !&&% - '& &% ( ' '& '
&$ ! 5' '& %& 5 " % ! ! ' ! 5& &%
'& ! & & - '& 6 ! !% " C ' % ,&&! ! '& "
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

!&& )&! '& " ! !% '& &--&" )& % ! &

"! - '& %& " ! ! 95' # $ " &% '& 7 & ! -
&! % " !89 5 % ! ' )& ,&" & " % ! !
& % & - '& & &% - '& , ! " &
4 & 5 % ! & ! & 7+'& - " ' ! '& , &!"& - '&
" & ! " & L '& " &"' ! M & '& " & L &
'& &"' ! M 5 % ' )& , ' , '& &
&--&" % & ! ! ! 5 %& " - '& &$ ! - "& - '&
" " &8 4 & . ?? ( 5 ' %5& ! ! ' ! 4 &
&& '& & - %& ! ' '
( )& - " - ' ' '& ) & !% '& ,& &- - '& ,>&"
&!% '& & - '& % ! ! , ( ,& &)& ' ! &!&
' "" ' ' '& ! !& !)&! ! - ! %& , '& ,>&"
'& & )& , 5 -% ! !"& &% " ! ' ' '& !
& "& ! - " " L+'& & & & -4 & 8 7 &"' ! 8 !
5 ' '& "' & - %&"& ! 5 '- ' !6 ! !% ) - "& "'
'& - " -" !M . ?B

(! %& -" ! '& & -#( (5 & )& %& '& % ,

& " " ' %& & "' !& ,& - && 6&
%& & " & %& & & ! &!& 7 ! !&
!)&! &%8 , '& ) " - '& & %& & 4 & & ' 2 '&!8
,>&" ! ' !& - & ! ! 5 ' !
5& & ! ,
,& &)& 7 ' ! '& , &!"& - "' ! %& & ! '& & &!"& -
&,& %& '& & 5 % ' )& " "6&% % 5! ! '& ,>&"
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) %

, ) &! & & !8 -& ' ' ' &!&% & & &%
' ' ' +' % & ! && - -& "'&% & ' !
" " & & '& & - '& &" ! " % ! ! " 5 ,&
, &% , &"' ! 7,& ! &!% &! !% ! !&
,& &- ! '& ! & - '& & ' ' & & )&
& L &' & & $ & - '& 5 ! 5 '
'& F &"' ! GM8 !% 4 & &!%& 2 '&!8 ! - 5
7 ' ' &)& - &!& '& & - !" ! &$ ! ! L! & -
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

&" ! " " & !% " !&& M - '& & &!"& - "'
&"' ! 8 (! & ! & 4 & 7(! '& 5 % 5'&! 6&% F0 '
'& &IG !& " % ! 5& F@&" & - ' % ! ,&&! '& &
& ' ! & & 5 ' '& & " ! &/ &!"& 5 % ' )& ,&&! '& &G8
. ? ?
# & "" & !% "' , !%& % ( ' !6 2 '&!8 !
" ! ,& " ! &% - 5 1 )&! '& &) &!"& - ! &" ! "
" & ! 5' "' '& &" ! " % ! ! " - ! & "
! '& & 5 ,& ! %& &--&" )& ! '& & - '&
-&5 )& '& ! ! '& " &"' ! ,& 5' "' , !
' , C "' %& & &) ,&" & - '& - !" ! & !
, ! - -" & !% '& &" ! " " & - 5' "'
'& & - - & & 4 & 6& ! '& ' !&)& - !% '
" !) !" ! ! &$ ! ! < ' '& 7&$ ! - "&8 - '&
" " &9 '& " &"' ! 9 ! --&" &% , '& %&
& ' & '& " &"' ! 5 % ' )&
% "&% '& & &--&" ! , &!"& 5 % && '
! 4 & 8 ) &5 '& ,& &$ ! ! - '& &) &!"& - %& &
! '& & - '& -&5 )& '& ! ! ' '& "
" & 5 &! & ' & ! %& 5 &) '
"' %& & &) ,&" & - '& & ! "! % ! "'
" & 3 '& 4 & 8 ! && ,& ' '& ,& &$ ! !
5 ) 5 ' 5' &)& &"' ! & & &! 5' "' & % ' &
(- ! !& " & '& % ! ! &"' ! 7% ! !"& &% " !8 - !
! '& !% " ! ! ' ' & ! !% '& &
 B

" "& - ! ! '& 5 '- ' !6 ! !% - ! ! '& ) &!

& & ! & & ! ' %&" )& --&" '& - ) &5
% & ! &% , '& %& " ! ! 5& ' )& - % --& &!
&$ ! ! &)&! ' ' 5& ' )& % & ! &% ! !
5 &!& - " & & - ,& &) ! ' ! & "' " & &
'& &"' ! " ,! ! - &"' ! 5 % ' )& % "&%
& ! '& , &!"& - '& " &"' ! ; 5 " % 5&
" % 5& & ! , > % & 5'& '& 2 '&! 4 & 5 & !&
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

" &" ! ' %&, &I

: !"& ! ( ' !6 ,& 6& ! +'& % &
,& 5&&! 2 '&! !% 4 & ' % ! ,& " ! &% ,& ! , '&
! & - &$ ! ! "' '& / & ! - & & )&
& &- - &$ ! ! ! " " &!"& &!& +' '
4 & !% & & &$ &! 2 '&! &!%&% & '& & ! '& &
, % % - ' !&% ' ' - " &!"& & 5& " ! ,& &
, '& & & +' 5 % !) )& ) &5 ! '& &
&) ) ! !% '& / & ! -! ! ! ' %5 !
- ! &$ ! ! ! ' " ! &$ 0 & !&&% &! ! '&
&)& - &!& - '& &$ ! ! 5& &&6 5& '& &
5& ' )& %& 5 % ' % ' )& ! 6 ! '& / & !
5' "' &$ ! ! & ! 5& +'& & ! & ! ' !6 '
& '& 4 & 2 '&! ' )& !%& % '& & & &!"&
& ! ! - 7" 8 7&$ ! !8 & &! %& &! &
'& & ' '& & ! ) & ! ' '" & ! ! '& &
& (- 5& 5 ! ! &$ ! ! ! & - &"' ! - 5& &
! & & &% ! '& "' " &)&! ! ! "' " 7! !%
, 8 - ! & ! %& " & &)
'&! 4 & 8 "" ! & '& 7 &"' ! "8
"" ! 5 % && & (- 5& 5 ! 6! 5 ! %& &
&--&" )& ! '& & - '& -&5 )& '& ! ' )& ,&&! &
!% 5 ,& " % ! ! ! ! ! %& " " " "& &
& ! '& &"' ! ' " & % ' &
2 '&!8 "" ! && & ,& ! & 6 !% - ! 5&
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) %

!% > 2 '&! & "" ! ! & -" " & & &
' '& & & &" 7 &"' ! 8 & "& & ' '
5' "' '& " & ! !&% & % "&% 4 & & "" !
! & - &"' ! & & , "6 !% - " "
" !% ! 95' "' '& 7 &"' ! 8% ! & & ! "
!% ! ! )"
2 " '& & ' 5 ' 4 & 8 "' ! &% " ! && ' )&
"" &% ' 7 &"' ! "8 ! , % & ! ! 5& '& &
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

/ & ! 2 '&!8 7- !" ! 8 ! +' 4 & 8 7 &"' ! "8

! ! &)&! %% & '& / & ! - 5' 5 % ' )& ,&
% --& &! - ,& '& " & ' ! %& ! '& & -
'& -&5 )& '& ! &) ! " ! -2 '&!8 "" ! '
'& &) ! & ! - % " ! ,& "' ! &% !%&&%
%& " &% - 5& & " & )& ! 5 % & )& - && -
%& & ' &--&" )& '& & - '& -&5 )& '& !
, &! "' - !% &! " !- ! '& & 5 " ! ! &
,& 7 &"' ! 8 ) ! 5 ' " ! &$ &! & ' "' %& & %
&) ! & ' ' '& " !! ,& &% ! &
!%
(- 4 & 8 ) &5 ' # ( & & &!> ! 6 7' 58 / & !
, &"' ! '& & % & ! && ,& ! ' ! , '& )&
! & - "' 7' 58 / & ! ' &/ & & ' 7 '&
"' " & " - "& " ! ,& &$ !&% ! - '&
"' " & " - !% ) % 8 5' "' & , 5' % !" )&
!% ) % ! 5 % ' 5 1 -!6& . < 4 &
7 &' % " !% ) % & % '& !% ) % ' !
" ! '& , " , % ! , "6 - & & " '&! &! 8 !%
7! &!& 5 ! " ! " ! ,& &$ !&% , '& ) ! !%
,& &- - '& " 8 +' '& 7 ' - 5 - '&
%&-! ! - " ! % !" - & & ,&' ) 8 4 & ..
& , '&! - 4 & '& &% " ! - '& " &$ '& &
5' "' &% ,& '& ' 6 - #( '& &% " ! -
7 & & " '&! &! 8 7 '& !% ) % " !8
 ?

(- 4 & - 5 - '& )& & !! - 7 " !8 '

" ! 7" ! ,& &$ !&% , '& ) ! !% ,& &- - '& " 8
% & ' & ! &$ ! ! ! & - ,& &- !% ) ! 5
&! , & &$ ! 7 & & " '&! &! 8I < , &-
% " ! - %& ' % ,& " & ' ! &" & ! 5
! &! , & # ) ! !% ,& &- ) - "&
"& !% 5 ' ! "& !% & ! %& &--&" )& !
'& & - '& -&5 )& '& ! "! &) %& & '& ) !
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

# & )& ) ! !% ,& &- & & ,& &$ !&% &
! & -- " '& ' ! ) ! !% ,& &- (! ' " ! &$
!& ! & ' '& & & ! " '& &! && ! ,&# $
/ # $ ! & !% &$ ! ! ! --& ' % ! &&
%'& & 4 &8 " & : !& ' " ! %& - &$ & &%
= !%8 &$ ! ! -5 % )& ! ' N& N& 5 !! !
' ( ' C &$ ! ! ' & &% " ,
& '" &" " &"'! " !% " -" ! ' C
' ! " % ,& % - = ) % ; )& 8 ! - '& & & &!"&
- 7!&5 & 8 ! & -' ! ! - 7 "" ! ,
% & !8 !% '& &!%&!" -" ,& -- " &% 5 ' " & -
)& "" ! ; )& @ ' = !% !% ; )& ! '&
" ' " ! & 5 & !% &- "& 5 ' &! !
! , " & & ' " '& ! '& " "& 7 ! 8 ! 2 '&!8
, % &! & , '& % ! ) %& 5 ' &$ ! ! ' &
&% " , & "' " &"' ! 7 '& &)& - '& !% ) % 8
% '& -& ' & '& % !" ! ,& 5&&! ! &! ! !% "
&$ ! ! C '& '& )& - && ,& 5&&! '& 5 # $' &-
%% 5 ' ) ! '& & ! -" ! & ' " % ) %& !
% ! ( " ! ,& % &$& " & 5'&! - "&% 5 ' , " '& !
, " " &!"& & ' % 6 " & - , ! )& "
! && 5'& '& '& , " &' % " % " !& "
6& &! & ! '& & " ! &$
: -" & '& & !& &! & ! 5' "' 7 '& !% ) % ' ! " !8
'& 7, % ! , "68 - " '&! &! '& ' ! &% ,
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) %

" '& "' # $ !% & ' &)&! '& "' ' O &
= 6'& ' " " & & &!& '& % " - '&
)& " ) - !% ) % " " & &
" '& & - '& ! & " ! - !% ) % ! 5' &)&
&!% '& ' )& @ ' 7 !% ) % 8" % & ! &! '
" &)& '& ,& & & " !% % & - 7 % " &!"&8
,& & &! &% , -!& !&% " ! & & !& &% "&%
'& & ( & ! ' 5& ,& , & '
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

'& " "& & & % ! " &)& '&! &! 5 6 ' '
'& &!" - !% ) % 95' "' ! & ' ! ' # $ !%
&)&! = 6'& 5 % ' )& ""& &%
@ 4 & " % && !"& - ' # ( 7& &! ) 8 @
'&! 5' 6& "' - , I ;& !% '& "' 3 & &
5& ! ! !# $ 5 & ' )& &!% &% # ( % !" )&
% " !& 5 - &$ !! 7 & & "
'&! &! 8 !% '& ' )& % ' % " !& ' ' , !
,&&! ) &% , ! '& ' ! # $ " '& @ '&!
! ) ( ! ,&" & ) 5'&! "' " & &% ! 5
' ! &)&! ' "' = 6'& 5 % %&! ( '
' & &) !"& ! - , "6 ! "& ! - - 7' " ," ! 8
' ' % ! " " &! &!% & & & ( && &
' &$ 2 ! " ' ! ! &% '& - '& ,& !%
&% '& & ! ! '& & & 6
@&' !% & ' % " !% ) % 6 !% - ! " !$ & 9 -&
- '& ! & &" ! & ' 5& ! & ' ! & 5& &% "&
&)& ' ! '& &% ! ,& " " '& &!"& - '& !% ) %
,>&" @ 5' " !8 5& ,& & % , "6 , ! I 0 ' " !8 5&
% '& 6 !% - & &% , P !& ! & % &
!% ' 5' 5& & " &% -- ! '& &$ &!"& - &
' & &! & 5' "' ,& " , &% '& & &-& I ! 5&8 &
--" &! ' ! '& & 5' ! & '& & & 5' !
I 2 !" ? .

&& '& & A 6& 8 % " ! -= 6'& ! A 6& . ? 5& A &8

% " ! ! A & .. ..
 @ 5' ! ! %% ! ,& !% P !& !% "& & & 6 ! -
7 ! 8 & '& I 0 & !&&% 6 5' "' & " '& & )&
& &- " '& &! " &'&! )& , & &$ ! !
!& & ! !% ! & @ '& & & ! & ' " / & !
: !"& 5& 6& P !& ! !% &, % ! % & !
6 - 7 ! 8 ,&" & 3 "' % 3 & &% - -
& " ! ,&- & ! %&% ' '" % !I
! & ,& ' !"& !% ) % & " ,& ! !%
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

! &! ! " ! " )&! '& = ) % ! ! &! >

" !) &% , '& " "' " & - ! &! ! & '& & &! &
! 5' "' ! !% ) % ' ! " ! !& ! , " !% 5
& & , "6 !% - 7 & & " '&! &! 8 (! '
" ! &$ ,& & & ' ' ! '& %& - !% ) % ,& ! '&
7, % ! , "6 8 - " & ' ,& '& %& - 5 )& ' &
!& ,&- '& !% ! "& ! < 5'&! 5& &" - '&
" ! &! - '& 7, % ! , "68 & ' 5& 5 ,& ' % & &% &
! '! & , ! ' ! '& " ! ! &' % "
7 !% ) % 8 " ' " " & & " &% , '&
! & " ! - !% ) % '& ' ! ' 5 % %&! 95'
3 "' % # & " &% ! 7 !% ) % "! ! ! 8 '&
' ! & ) !% ) % "! ! ! &$ ! ! # & .
4 & 5& " !! 6 - " ! ! - '& 5& & ! '"
7 !"& & &! '& & " &" ! - ' ! ,& ! 8 .. +'
& & )&! "& ! & % ! , % & ! ) %& , -
% !" )& &' % ' ' % ! ' 7 !% ) % 8 -
7' 8 &$ ! ! @ % " '& % & ! &/ & '&
! ' " ! ! & ! '" ' '& &!
" &% - !% ) % ' ! ,& ! 5' !% ! "& ! & !
& "' '&

+ 6! "6 ( ' !6 5& % 5 '& - 5 ! " !" ! (! -

" &! #( ' ) &% " &! '& 7 ! "
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) % .

&"'! / & 8 ' 2 '&! " & 5 ' ! " # $ "

! "' "& '& !% '& & ' % - !& " " &" ! " '&
" ! %& ! & &! &% '& & ' % & & & '& &! '
- '& & &"'! / & 0 '&! # ( " ! &% ! 5 ' 6& "&
!% % !" )& &% " ! % " !& , ,&
&!& &' % " !" & &)&! - &% " ! ,&
!% %& , &C 5'&! "! &% ! 5 ' "& , )
! % !" )&C !% 5'&! "! &% ,& ! &% " ! " !"& !&%
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

5 ' &"' ! ) & !% '&!"& &% " ! ,

! & &% , # $ !% '& ! ! ) - - " &)&
7' "8 '& ! &!> ! ! &$ ! ! ! & - '&
& ! !% ! & " ! - !% ) % ! ! & &)&! " & 5'
#( " ' 5 % --& - ! ! & ' " - -# ;
,&" & ' % & % & -" ' % ! "& ' ! & '&
1 )&! '& & " ! %& ! !& ' % ,& "& " - ' % " !& !%
! " # $ ' %! 2 '&! && & ,& 7 , & 8
" &% ( 5 % ,& ,& & - '& ,&" & & &
! '& ' !6 ! 5 &% & , &' % "
!% & , '& - & 5 % & ' & " !%
'& " !"& !&% 5 ' ' ! & !" ! # ( %& & '& ! &! !
- ! " # $ %&-&!%& && ,& '& & " &-!& &!
' % & ! %) !"& '& & " !"& ! @ '&! ! &-!& &!

) *

@' ' ) 3 .. " : $- % 2 &!% !

&
2 !" . 2 , % & &
QQQQQQQ ? 71 2 '&! !% '& 2 / & - "
4" ! 8 + B
2 '&! 1 . 7< !" ! 4$ ! ! 3& 4 &8
.
 QQQQQQQ . 73& 4 & ! # $ < !" ! !% 1 &
+'& 8 B B .
QQQQQQQ L. M : $- % : R
= ) % ! = . . 7 % ! (! & & ! (! & & 8 ! 4 & !%
; !% &% , 2 , % & 2R
..
QQQQQQQ L . BM " - " " : $- % : R
.
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

= &5& . ) S ;&! ; T 2 !
4 & . 72 '&! ! # $8 +'& -; 3&) &5 - 1
2 '&! ./ 0

QQQQQQQ . 7# $ < !" ! !% 1 & +'& +'&

2 &- # &' % " (!% ) % 8
B B B
QQQQQQQ . ' 2 , % & 2R
QQQQQQQ . 2 , % & 2R
QQQQQQQ .. 2 , % & 2R
; )& = 1 !" : $- % : R
; &6 < . 2 1 &!" & (A < &&
&
1 -!6& . , $ &5 ; )&! S & R ! )&
&
A&' !&! !% D 6 6 7R ! & " ! -
3 ! 2 ' "& +'& 8

A&) !& ,& 4 0 ' 4: . # "' 7# $ !%

# &' % " (!% ) % 8 1 !# ) !( ? ? B
A & = .. 3 $ @ %& 2 : 0 & ) &5
&
A 6& . 4 0 . # % A !% ! &! !
QQQQQQQ 7# $ !% '& 4! ' &! &! 8 ! & # !%
# < "' &% B B
 ! " # $ !% # & ' % " (!% ) %

# !%& , # . 7 "& A 5 8 5 6
B
# & 3 . 7# & ' % " (!% ) % !% " 4$ ! !8
B B B
& &! D .. @ %& 2 : 0 & ) &5
&
QQQQQQQ 7 '& & " 3 "' % 3 8
B
Downloaded by [University of Sydney] at 05:58 01 January 2015

& . ? ! 7/ !" & !% " ! 4$ ! !8

/ B? .B
3& 7= 0 & &&% # &"' !
! '& " " &!"& I8
? B
3 & & . 7# & ' % " (!% ) % !% = &% " )&
# $ 8 B
3 3 .. 2 , % & 2R
& # !% < "' # &% ) $ $
1 '& S & '& @ 6
+K!! >J + .. 7# & ' % " (!% ) % 8 "- ?.