Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Guohua BAI
Blekinge Institute of Technology
SE-372 25 Ronneby, Sweden
gba@bth.se
Abstract
By integrating system thinking and social psychology, this paper presents an Activity System
Theory (AST)1 approach to the platform design of e-service systems in general, and e-healthcare
systems in specific. In the first part, some important principles of AST and a sustainable model of
human activity system are introduced. Then a project ‘Integrated Mobile Information System for
Healthcare (IMIS)’ is presented to demonstrate how to construct a comprehensive platform for various
complex e-service systems based on the sustainable model of AST. Our research focused on the
complex e-healthcare system in Sweden, and the results showed that the model of AST can provide
the designers of e-service system with a comprehensive and sustainable platform for designing
various kinds of e-service systems.
Keywords: E-services, E-healthcare, sustainable platform design, activity system theory (AST)
1
It is often just called Activity theory in socio-psychological references.
JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004 437
A Sustainable Platform for E-service Systems Design
438 JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004
BAI
Activity
Respond to
Motivation
Respond to
Condition
Operation 1 Operation 2 Operation 3 Operation 4
JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004 439
A Sustainable Platform for E-service Systems Design
2.4 Modelling Human Activity – one unified system and logically interrelated
system (Figure 3).
Components and Relationship of an
2.5 Principle of Development –
Activity
For much current sociology, in a certain Contradiction Principle
sense only individuals exist: the individual Contradiction is a crucial concept or a
human being is the ontologically given starting general category in AST which describes the
point from which everything else must be relationships between components or between
deduced. Consequently, socialization, norms, activities. Contradiction is used to describe
values, and culture are popular means for dialectical relationships in a development
explaining why individuals unite into process such as mutuality, interdependence,
something called society (Qvortrup 1996). AST, diversity, and dynamics. Contradictions often
however, takes the relationship between an manifest themselves as problems, ruptures,
individual and his or her social cultures, norms, breakdowns, and clashes, and therefore people
and values as a molar unit (non-decomposable) used to think contradictions as bad as
of an activity and believes that activity is only destructive situations, such as conflicts, wars,
developed under conditions of co-operation battles. However, seeing another side of the
and social interaction among people (Leontèv same coin, AST sees contradictions as sources
1981, p55). Even though Leontèv pointed out of development (Engeström 1987, Bai &
the importance of social factors in an activity, Lindberg 1998, Turner P. & S. Turner 2001).
it is Engeström (1987) visualized the social Activities are virtually always in the process of
context, such as community, social and cultural working through contradictions (Kuutti 1996).
rules, norms, and social labour divisions into In Figure 3, together with the classical
Instrument
Production activity
Figure 3 The elements and relationships of human activity (based on Engeström, 1987, p78)
440 JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004
BAI
JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004 441
A Sustainable Platform for E-service Systems Design
Staff nurse
Lena (elderly home)
Personal assistant
Diabetic nurse
District nurse
Doctor
Information System for Diabetic Healthcare) the patient visits the care providers (if the visit
focuses on communication problems between is judged necessary after the communication),
healthcare providers and their healthcare the quality of the visit is increased, and the
receivers at home. IMIS is an Internet based quality of care or treatment of the visit gets
communication platform for diabetic even improved if they continue communicate
care-providers (hospitals, municipalities, after the visit. In Sweden, a guideline for
relatives, etc.) and persons with diabetics. diabetic healthcare (Socialstyrelsen Stockholm,
Many studies showed that most people with 1999) stated that ‘To a good quality of diabetic
diabetics regularly contact with their care healthcare there needs a team work in which
providers in various ways. Studies in the USA people with diabetics are in centre. They need
(American Diabetes Association, 1989) and in training, support, and supervising so they can
Sweden (Rachmani R., et. al. 2002) showed take care themselves, control own situation,
that the self-treatment and supervision of and self-treatment. They need to have access to
people with diabetes can greatly increase their the care team which consists of doctors with
quality of their daily life if they are provided competence and interests for diabetic patients,
with reliable and easy access to their care and nurses special trained for diabetic care
providers (doctors, nurses, relatives, etc.). Also who can provide with patients good advices,
if care providers and people with diabetics are and cooperate with dietician and foot
able to communicate with each other before therapist.’ Communication between all the
442 JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004
BAI
team members and patients is an essential need Municipality who helps her do some house
if the self- treatment of people with diabetics is work. Lena seems not very concerned about
possible. The IMIS project in this context is to her diabetes, and often eats fat foods and candy.
provide such a shared communication channel The concentration of glucose in the blood often
for all the team members and people with goes up steeply without her direct remark and
diabetes. Since the healthcare activities then too late. One day the personal assistant
compose a complex social system, the platform called the Home Care Centre and reported to
of IMIS must cover the complex system
the district nurse that Lena did not feel well.
components and map their relationships, and
The district nurse suspected that Lena had
meanwhile the platform must be sustainable to
eaten some sweet cookies. The district nurse
adapt changes. We believe that AST model
checked Lena’s record for her recent medical
(Figure 3) provides with such a sustainable
history. Then the nurse went to Lena’s house
model since it is based upon the general
with a device to measure the concentration of
understanding of all kinds of human activities,
glucose. After asking several questions, the
and therefore it can sustain for changes as far
as the activity alive. nurse took out the device and tried to measure
the glucose concentration for further decision.
3.2 A Scenario of Communication After a phone call to the diabetic nurse at the
Problem in Diabetic Healthcare Primary Care Centre from hospital (luckily the
In Sweden the mission of healthcare is phone was answered), the nurse drew a
divided among the county councils, hospitals, conclusion that Lena was in an acute situation.
municipality, and other private actors. To make Then Lena was sent to the doctor (hospital)
this complex labour division clear, a scenario immediately.
is showed in Figure 4. In the figure, the 70 In Figure 4, the mission of Lena’s
years old lady Lena with diabetes of type two healthcare are divided into at least three labour
found herself recently in a multi-diseases divisions, namely primary care from hospital,
caused by her high level of glucose. She is home care from county council, and home
3
normally visited by a staff nurse from the service from municipality respectively (private
Home Care Centre of County Council, who actors are not showed). There are two different
comes to her house twice a day to give her connection lines in Figure 4. The solid lines
insulin injections. There is also a personal stand for the normal/everyday connections. For
assistant from the home service of the example, the staff nurse and the personal
assistant visit the patient everyday. This means
3
There are two different types of nurses in Home
Care Center, staff nurse and district nurse. District that they should have quite lot face-to-face
nurse has more education background and more contacts. The dash-dot lines stand for mostly
responsibility than the staff nurse. The staff nurse
can have at most responsibility to give patients the information/communication flow among
medicine or insulin injections which are delegated healthcare actors in the above scenario.
by the district nurse.
JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004 443
A Sustainable Platform for E-service Systems Design
Hospital
Healthcare
receivers
County Council/
Hospital
IMIS platform
Municipality
There are lot communication problems in arrived at Lena’s house, there was no way to
the above scenario. First, the information flow access to the patient’s records. Besides, there
from the staff nurse to other actors is missing. are also some problems for different
The staff nurse goes to patients’ house twice a organizations to share information between
day to give injections. She/he knows a lot of them. For example, the personal assistants
details about the patient. And all those details from municipality and the nurses from County
are sometimes important for the diagnosis. Council cannot share their information with
However, it is not record and communicated to
each other. If they have a shared
other relevant actors. When the district nurse
communication platform on which they can
got noticed that the patient did not feel well,
communicate with each other and access to the
she/he had no contact with the staff nurse.
Besides, during and after the district nurse patient’s journal no matter where and when,
gave diagnosis, staff nurse was not informed the efficiency and quality of the healthcare will
either. Phone calls are the most common way be much improved. The IMIS communication
for them to communicate each other, and platform is to build up such a platform as
however phone calls are often not reliably Figure 5 shows.
answered.
Within this platform, the communication
Second, communication problems exist not
channels are not only the mobile phone and
only among nurses, but also between the pocket PC, but expanded to all medical
nurses and the patients’ medical journal. For equipments that are linked to computer
example, before going to Lena’s house, the network. The dash lines stand for the
district nurse checked the patient’s history communication channels that access to Internet
record in the office. When the district nurse through either stationary PC or pocket PC.
444 JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004
BAI
Figure 6 The conceptual platform of IMIS for decision makers (team leaders)
JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004 445
A Sustainable Platform for E-service Systems Design
standards – regulation for what and how and operations is very important not only for
healthcare should be done, (5) community – consistent and verified date, but also for the
cooperative partners, and (6) labour division – communication peer-to-peer and between the
responsibility to whom and to do what. Those decision makers and the healthcare workers.
components compose a healthcare data Communication between different (data)
warehouse or knowledge base shown in Figure structures implies extra translation, or
6. Probably some parts of the above mentioned transformation. This will lead to problem of
components exist in different places already, validity and reliability of data, problem of
and in this case the IMIS is to integrate the fragmentation, and problem of extra cost of
needed knowledge from other sources for the human resource. Just because the AST model
decision makers ready to use. is generally applicable for all kinds of
To support operational tasks in the fields of activities (recursive or heritable properties), the
healthcare the information in IMIS must be components specified in the model cover also
targeted (personalized just-for-you, just the needs for healthcare workers in the field.
enough), and mobile. More over, the contents Without changing the generic platform of
must be constructed as a recursive subset of the components specified in healthcare data
overall platform in order to integrate the part of warehouse, we can construct the part of IMIS
field work into the healthcare warehouse. This for the field workers by just changing some
recursive structure between decision activities specific contents shown in Figure 7. Since this
446 JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004
BAI
part is installed in the hand computers of field healthcare activities must be worked out. As
workers, and the contents are individually example in the Figure 8, a category covers
configured by each field worker, therefore it is topics of (1) new services needed, (2) report
the dynamic subset of the healthcare data problems, and (3) changed service schedule.
warehouse. Secondly, targeted receivers must be specified.
To support communication peer-to-peer and The so-called misinformation and information
communication between the decision makers overload could be reduced if an object-oriented
and the healthcare workers are very essential. communication as such is applied. Finally,
It is the communication that unites all parts operations to carry out the communication
working together to carry out the healthcare must be followed, such as to send, archive,
activity. The physical channels of the answer, etc. This simple model will be applied
communication in IMIS could be wireless or in IMIS to support communication activities
through the Internet. Communication in the
logical level must be properly managed. 4. Conclusion
This paper proposes an object-oriented Based upon the concepts and models of
model to construct the communication as AST, we have developed a sustainable
shown in Figure 8. This model suggests that platform for e-business in general, and
communication must consider (1) the objects e-healthcare in specific. Based on some
of the communication (the right recipients), (2) primary observations from some tests by users,
topics/subject of source, (3) the channel to the platform could cover the various
communicate, and (4) ways or actions to the information need for healthcare work, and
communication. Firstly, a list of topics about meanwhile the structure could integrate existed
JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004 447
A Sustainable Platform for E-service Systems Design
448 JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004
BAI
JOURNAL OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND SYSTEMS ENGINEERING / Vol. 13, No. 4, December, 2004 449