Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
SUMMARY
Steam turbine installations have dominated LNG carrier propulsion and electric power generation for the past forty years.
The ease with which these installations can utilize boil-off gas and their apparent reliability have kept them in a position
that has long been lost to diesel engines in all other segments of the shipping industry. Steam turbine installations are
however not very efficient. This has a negative impact on both the ship’s operating economy and its exhaust gas
emissions. Exactly these issues play an increasingly important role in LNG shipping today.
Encouraged by the latest developments in its gas engine technology, Wärtsilä started looking for a more economic and
environmentally friendly way to power LNG carriers. Machinery alternatives with two- and four-stroke diesel, high-
pressure gas-diesel and low-pressure dual-fuel engines, in mechanical and electric propulsion arrangements, with and
without boil-off reliquefaction, were studied. Dual-fuel-electric installations were found to be the most attractive
alternative to steam turbine installations.
The first dual-fuel-electric LNG carrier, Gaz de France Energy, will take to the sea later this year and two more dual-
fuel-electric LNG carriers are on order.
1. INTRODUCTION
Also for LNG carriers, like for any other kind of ship, Ships with steam turbine installations have rather poor
fuel costs are one of the most important components of manoeuvring characteristics. When considering transits
the ship’s operating costs. in light ice conditions and cargo operations offshore,
good manoeuvring characteristics become increasingly
2.2 ENVIRONMENTAL-FRIENDLINESS important.
Gas-diesel engines act according to the Diesel principle Emissions of gas-diesel engine installations are generally
and can virtually burn any possible mixture of gas and lower than those of steam turbine and diesel engine
liquid fuel, with only a few restrictions to the quality of installations as a result of higher efficiency and cleaner
the gas. fuel, respectively.
As the mixture of gas and liquid fuel is injected into the 3.3 DUAL-FUEL ENGINE ALTERNATIVES
combustion chamber during air compression (Fig. 2), the
required injection pressure is high. For four-stroke gas- When running on gas, dual-fuel engines act according to
diesel engines, a gas pressure of around 350 bar is the Otto principle. As the gas is mixed with air before
required, while for two-stroke gas-diesel engines some compression starts (Fig. 4), a gas pressure of about 5 bar
250 bar is deemed sufficient. is sufficient. This gas pressure is in the same range as the
gas pressures in steam turbine installations. Close to top-
dead-centre a very small amount of MDO is injected in
Exh Exh Exh
order to trigger ignition.
125%
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
Steam Two- Dual-fuel- Steam Two- Dual-fuel- Steam Two- Dual-fuel-
stroke electric stroke electric stroke electric
5.3 SAFETY
5.5 REDUNDANCY
5.6 ‘MAINTAINABILITY’
Case studies for various customers have shown that the Fig. 10 - Wärtsilä 6L50DF endurance test engine
required maintenance on dual-fuel-electric installations
can easily be carried out without affecting the ship’s 6.1 DUAL-FUEL ENGINES ON LAND
operational performance. Maintenance of dual-fuel-
electric installations is more costly than of steam turbine Seventeen Wärtsilä dual-fuel engines, with a combined
installation, but does no harm to the ship’s operating output of more than one-hundred megawatt, are in
economy. operation in land-based power plants in Turkey, the
United Kingdom, Denmark, Russia, India, the United
5.7 ‘CREWABILITY’ States of America and Spain.
6. MARKET INTRODUCTION
8. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Fig. 16 - Provalys
9. AUTHORS’ BIOGRAPHY
6.3 (c) Chantiers de l’Atlantique #P32
Barend Thijssen graduated as a Naval Architect M.Sc.
In July 2004, a joint-venture of NYK of Japan (60%) and from Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands
Gaz de France (40%) ordered a sister ship to Provalys at and joined Wärtsilä in 1997. After assignments in
Chantiers de l’Atlantique, which is scheduled for Switzerland and Greece, he now leads the sales activities
delivery at the end of 2006. of Wärtsilä Ship Power Solutions from Raisio in Finland.
Dual-fuel-electric machinery is presently being evaluated Wärtsilä Ship Power Solutions takes a holistic approach
by ship owners and shipyards around the world for a vast in engineering, marketing, selling and delivering ship
number of LNG carrier newbuilding projects. The cargo power installations to the marine industry. Installations
capacities of the envisaged ships are ranging from the for LNG carriers are one of the cornerstones of Wärtsilä
conventional 150’000 m3 to 200’000 and even 250’000 Ship Power Solutions.
m3. Port-to-port sailing distances are ranging from
several days to several weeks.
Article reproduced with the kind permission of The
In addition, dual-fuel engines are under consideration for Royal Institution of Naval Architects from their Design
application in various kinds of offshore installations, and Operation of Gas Carriers Conference September
including floating liquefaction units, as well as floating 2004.