Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Amanda Schwartz
Adeola Ijiyode
Opeletia Helton
Elena Nourabadi
Princess Petrus
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is a chronic mental disorder that can lead to
seeking and receiving treatment at an increased rate compared to previous years, a significant
number of individuals with MDD fail to receive proper diagnosis and treatment. The African
American community has a suppressed outlook on mental health and mental health treatment, as
they have less resources available to them and mental health is just not as common a
conversation topic as it is in other communities. This is alarming given that African Americans
are more likely to experience mental health problems compared to other demographic groups
(e.g., Caucasians). Along with MDD in African Americans, this paper will discuss the failure to
properly diagnose in the African American community, service utilization, the barriers in service
utilization and crossing those barriers. The research will prove the disparity between African
Americans and mental health care services and how to combat this disparity. This paper will also
discuss suggested coping mechanisms and what this implies for the African American
community. This paper hypothesizes that young adult African Americans are less likely to seek
and receive treatment for MDD when compared to their demographic counterparts (e.g.,
Caucasians).
Key words: Major Depressive Disorder, African Americans, mental health treatment
Major Depressive Disorder in African Americans
Mental illness is the leading cause of disability in the U.S. (Mental Health). The rate of
depression has increased over time, either because of increased reporting or just an increasing
acceptance of mental illness as a disability. However, 56% of American adults with a mental
illness do not receive treatment. Along with that, African Americans and Hispanic Americans
each use mental health services at about one-half the rate of Caucasian Americans. Many cases
of mental illness, if left untreated for too long, can lead the individuals to many negative
alternatives, such as drug abuse, alcohol abuse, and even suicide, in an attempt to cope with their
disorder. Ergo, African Americans are at a higher risk for these risk factors, which can lead to
many other crippling life decisions, due to their increased risk for developing depression. It is
important for these disparities to be recognized so that they can be addressed and equal care can
failure to make resources relatable, we hypothesize that young adult African Americans are less
likely to seek and receive treatment for MDD when compared to other demographic groups (e.g.,
Caucasians).
Major Depressive Disorder
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is defined as having at least five of the following
symptoms present during the same two-week period, either everyday or most days, and as
presenting a change from previous functioning. Symptoms, with at least one of the symptoms
must be either depressed mood or loss of interest/pleasure, include the following: (1) “depressed
mood...as indicated by either subjective report (e.g., feels sad, empty, hopeless) or observation
made by others (e.g., appears tearful),” (2) decreased interest/pleasure in all or most activities,
(3) significant weight loss that is not the result of dieting or significant weight gain or significant
(9) recurrent thoughts about or of death, suicidal ideation without a plan, or a suicide attempt or
occupational, or other important areas of functioning in order for the individual to be considered
at-risk for MDD. Additionally, the individual’s depressive episode must not be attributable in
any way to the physiological effects of a medical condition or a substance. Some other things
that may exclude someone from having MDD include symptoms not being better explained by
specified or unspecified schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders, having a manic
As explained in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, there are
many different forms of MDD (American Psychiatric Association, 2013). Most broadly, there is
mild, moderate, and severe MDD. MDD can have psychotic features and it can also be
either partial remission (symptoms may still be present but full criteria is no longer met or it has
been less than two months without any significant symptoms of MDD) or full remission (there
has been two or more months with no significant signs/symptoms of MDD; American
Psychiatric Association, 2013, p. 188). MDD can also be further specified as being accompanied
“with anxious distress,” “mixed features,” “melancholic features,” “atypical features,” “mood-
Unfortunately MDD is associated with a rather high mortality rate (American Psychiatric
Association, 2013, p. 164-165). Much of this is due in part to lives taken by suicide. However,
the high mortality rate common amongst individuals with depression is also attributed to
depressed individuals’ increased likelihood of death within the first year of admittance into
test has been developed with a sufficient level of sensitivity in order to test for these
Risk factors for MDD include temperament, environment, genetics and physiology, and
course modifiers (American Psychiatric Association, 2013, p. 166). A major temperamental risk
a particularly difficult or adverse childhood and/or experiences stressful life events, s/he may be
at a greater risk for developing MDD. Additionally, a genetic predisposition to MDD, such as
having a first-degree family member (e.g., parent or sibling) with MDD, may increase an
individual’s risk for developing the disorder two to four times more compared to those with no
first-degree family member with MDD. Having a first-degree family member with MDD also
increases the risk of early-onset and recurrent forms of MDD. Therefore, the heritability of
MDD is approximately 40% with the personality trait of neuroticism accounting for a vast
majority of this genetic predisposition. Finally, if an individual has any other major, non-mood
disorder then s/he is automatically at an increased risk for developing MDD. Unfortunately,
individuals who develop MDD alongside another major, non-mood disorder follow a refractory
course, making their fight against mental illness even harder. The most common comorbid
disorders to depression are substance use, anxiety, and borderline personality disorder as well as
chronic or disabling medical conditions such as diabetes, morbid obesity, and cardiovascular
disease.
Major depressive disorder, regardless of its severity, can be treated (National Institute of
Mental Health, 2016). As with most other disorders, the earlier the treatment, the better.
norepinephrine, in order to help the affected individual be able to better control their mood and
stress. Due to a lack of sufficient and specific neurological testing for measuring
neurotransmitter levels, most people have to try several different antidepressant medications
before finding the one that improves their symptoms and has manageable side effects. Most
psychiatrists will begin with a medication that has helped either the affected individual or a
family member of the affected individual in the past. In addition, antidepressants often take two
to four weeks to take effect and, most commonly, the first symptoms to be alleviated are sleep,
appetite, and concentration problems, not mood. Unfortunately, some people with depression
who are prescribed antidepressants will cease to take their medication once they begin feeling
better and, therefore, enter a toxic cycle of a depressive episode, followed by treatment, followed
by remission, which is then followed by another depressive episode due to them taking
themselves off of their medication. Hence, it is essential for individuals who have depression to
Some of the most effective psychotherapies, or talk therapy, for MDD are cognitive-
behavioral therapy (CBT), interpersonal therapy (IPT), and problem-solving therapy (National
Institute of Mental Health, 2016). CBT emphasizes an individual’s relationship between their
belief systems, emotions, behaviors, what and how the individual thinks, and helps clients to
identify any distortions in their thinking that may be causing them distress (Maniacci, Sackett-
Maniacci, & Mosak, 2014, p. 60). IPT is a form of therapy that emphasizes that the triggers of
depressive episodes lie in disruptions in an individual’s “significant attachments and social roles”
and mainly focus around “grief, interpersonal disputes, role transitions, and interpersonal
deficits” (Verdeli & Weissman, 2014, p. 339). In IPT, the therapist works to resolve these issues
by clarifying with the patient the relationship between the onset of his/her depressive symptoms
and his/her interpersonal problems and by working to build the patient’s interpersonal skills so
that s/he can better manage and resolve these issues. Problem-solving therapy is a form of
therapy that works on teaching clients how to cope with the negative effects associated with
individual’s symptoms, a physician may suggest a brain stimulation therapy such as ECT
(National Institute of Mental Health, 2016). Today’s ECT is very different than the ECT shown
in movies and that of the past. For instance, ECT is typically performed as an outpatient
procedure and occurs in a series of sessions, usually three times per week, for a period of two to
four weeks. Additionally, despite what Hollywood may imply, ECT is not painful and patients
cannot feel the electrical impulses shot through their brains. This is because, prior to the
procedure, patients are placed under a brief anesthetic and given a muscle relaxant in order to
prevent any injuries from the procedure. Then, roughly an hour after the minutes-long procedure,
the patient is alert and awake. Side effects of ECT are often short-term and include confusion,
disorientation, and memory loss. Other brain stimulation therapies include repetitive transcranial
Other, everyday activities that may help depression include being active, exercising,
setting realistic goals, spending time with others, confiding in a trusted friend or relative,
resisting from isolating oneself, accepting help, expecting one’s mood to improve gradually
rather than immediately, postponing important decisions until the individual is able to discuss
them with someone who knows him/her well and is able to be objective, and psychoeducation
(National Institute of Mental Health, 2016). Major depressive disorder is known to be a risk
factor for cardiovascular disease (CVD). A study conducted by the National Survey of American
Life examined the co-occurrence of MDD and CVD in a nationally represented sample of 2,216
African American Women. The data shows that socioeconomic levels are strongly associated
with every indicator of cardiovascular problems of African American women with and without
MDD (see Appendix A for table showing results from a regression model of comorbidity of
MDD and CVD). For instance, women living in poverty are more likely to experience
cardiovascular problems, excluding a stroke. With those living in poverty, their access to
resources are limited. Therefore, this further stresses the importance of prioritizing daily exercise
for African American women both in poverty and not in poverty who have MDD as it is strongly
According to the Health and Human Services Office of Minority Health of Fact Sheet of
2007, African Americans are 20% more likely to experience serious mental health problems than
the general population (2017). One reason for this is that African Americans are more likely to
experience circumstances that merit an increased likelihood of developing mental health issues.
Some of these factors include homelessness, of which African Americans compose 40% of the
care, and child welfare systems. Depression in many African Americans goes undiagnosed due
to stigma, misconceptions, and disbelief in the notion that depression is truly a clinical condition.
Instances such as these further deteriorate one’s mental health when left untreated and increase
the burden of depression in one’s life. According to a study conducted by Williams and
colleagues (2007), when African Americans do suffer from depression, they are more likely to
consider their condition to be severe and disabling, when compared to white Americans
racial prejudice and discrimination, it was found that among the African American community
there is a positive relationship between everyday discrimination and risk for past-year MDD. In
the study, James examined the role of self-esteem and low ethnic identities as mediators of the
relationship between internalized racism and past-year MDD of African Americans. James found
that, “internalized racism reinforces the superiority of Whites and maintains a self-perpetuating
cycle of oppression among racial minorities” (James, 2017). When having to embrace
“whiteness” and use Whites’ perspective to outline racial identities, it can lead to negative self-
worth and feelings of intimacy with one’s race or ethnicity (James, 2017).
Another study conducted by Taylor, analyzing the role major depressive disorder plays in
romantic relationships of African Americans. In the Journal of Affective Disorders, a study was
included that examined the relationship between marital and relationship status and 12-month as
well as lifetime prevalence of MDD among African Americans (Taylor et al., year). Data was
collected from an African American subsample of 3570 subjects from the National Survey of
American Life. The World Mental Health Composite International Diagnostic Interview was
used to assess 12-month as well as lifetime MDD. The results (see Appendix B) exemplify a
status. It was found that married individuals as well as those cohabitating have the lowest
prevalence of depression out of the three marital statuses. Those that have been previously
married show higher levels of MDD, while those never married nor actively in a relationship
show the greatest odds of 12-month and/or lifetime MDD. These findings indicate that “African
Americans who are depressed are not only less likely to be married; they are also significantly
less likely to be involved in a romantic relationship” (Taylor et al.). Depression may be hindering
African Americans are repeatedly underdiagnosed and incompetently managed in primary care.
Patient factors include being poor, uninsured, restrictive insurance policies, biological-
and stigma (i.e., attitudes and perceptions of mental illness). Physician factors include
diagnosis and assessment, physician characteristics, physician bias, and culture; and
treatment setting factors include systemic variables such as lack of or poor access to
While examining the severity of depression, a study done by Williams and colleagues (2007)
showed that 56.6% of African Americans compared to 36.8% of Caucasians reported that their
episodes of depressions as being disabling (Copeland et al., 2017). The researchers concluded
that, when African Americans do acquire MDD, it is likely debilitating and persistent. After
conducting a national survey on clinical depression, The National Mental Health Association
reported that approximately 63% of African Americans view mental illness as a “personal
weakness” (Copeland et al., 2017). This mindset, which is different from other cultural groups,
can cause difficulties in efforts for diagnosis. Other key concepts play a role in misdiagnosis of
African Americans. It is found that African Americans are more likely to report physical pain
rather than emotional related symptoms. Washington Journal reports, “data from Robins and
whites” (Bailey et al., 2009). Other symptoms that African Americans report more than
Caucasians include sleep disturbances, loss of appetite, weight loss, and hypochondriasis.
Limited resources can hinder the the ability to a quality mental evaluation. Additionally,, once
an assessment has been conducted, interpersonal bias can alter the accuracy of the diagnosis.
Unfortunately, such discrepancies occur rather often and should be addressed by developing an
Service Utilization
Notably, African Americans do not have readily available access to mental health
services. In the instance that African Americans do receive treatment from a mental health
professional or establishment, the quality of care is more likely to be poor (2017. In addition to
this issue, research shows that African Americans are less likely to seek treatment for depression.
acceptable. According to the Mental Health Association survey on African Americans’ attitude
towards depression, only 31% of African Americans believe depression is a “health” problem
(Cooper, et al., 2003). Approximately 30% of African Americans surveyed said they would
“handle” the depression themselves if they were depressed, while 20% said they would turn to
their friends and family for help with depression (Cooper, et al., 2003). Surveys like these reveal
the lack of mental health literacy of African Americans and reinforce the notion that African
Americans are less likely, compared to White Americans, to seek mental health treatment for
depression or to even recognize the severity of the illness (Cooper, et al., 2003).
According to Bussing and Gary (2012), there are numerous health disparities that affect
than white and receive poorer qualities of care (Bussing & Gary, 2013). The articles also
describe the barriers in two tiers: systematic and individual. Within the tier of systematic
disparities, the barriers include an underrepresentation of ethnic minority health providers, the
school-to-prison pipeline, and the lack of current clinical research data on ethnic minorities. The
lack of diversity in health providers leads to lack of cultural competence, bias, and misdiagnosis
(Bussing & Gary, 2013, p. 663; National Alliance on Mental Illness, 2017). African-Americans,
due to stigma, are more likely to disclose their physical symptoms related to mental health
problems rather than their emotional symptoms (National Alliance on Mental Illness, 2017).
Culturally incompetent health providers tend to overlook the connection between physical
symptoms and mental health. Additionally, African-American men who display symptoms of
mood disorders or PTSD are often misdiagnosed as having schizophrenia. The school-to-prison
pipeline is perpetuated by the increased use of the zero-tolerance discipline; therefore, minority
youth who display behavioral or learning problems are more likely to be streamlined into school
detention or incarceration rather than receive high quality mental health assessments and
treatments (Bussing & Gary, 2013). The lack of clinical and research data on minorities
contributes to a limit in professional expertise; they aren’t using evidence-based practices for
those clients (Bussing & Gary, 2013, p. 664). In fact, the National Alliance on Mental Illness
(NAMI, 2017) found that, though medications tend to metabolize slower in African-Americans,
they tend to receive higher dosages which increases the chances of negative side effects and
The National Alliance on Mental Illness thoroughly explains the second tier of barriers,
individual, in their article, African American Mental Health (2017). They first acknowledge
minority communities’ lack adequate information about mental illness which makes it difficult
for them identify their symptoms and know when to seek help (National Alliance of Mental
Illness, 2017). Mental illness in African American communities is seen as either a personal
weakness or a curse from God. They secondly noticed that African Americans tend to rely more
on their churches, family, and friends for emotional support as a treatment for their symptoms
rather than seeking out mental health care providers. The last individual barrier they noticed was
the reluctance and inability of African-Americans to access mental health services. Historical
context of maltreatment from health care providers causes an inherent distrust and, in 2012, 19%
of African-Americans did not have health insurance. Those who do have insurance face the
It is proven that increasing diversity within the mental health profession “improve[s]
communication, and improve[s] quality and satisfaction outcomes” (Bussing & Gary, 2013, p.
664). Mental health professionals who commit to continuing their education improve their
cultural competence and psychological comfort when dealing with minority clients (Bussing &
Gary, 2013, p. 665). Mental health professionals who befriend colleagues from minority
backgrounds increase their understanding of cultural nuances, skills, and anxieties such as
communities come to understand the diverse groups’ norms and practices and decrease stigma.
Mentorship targeted toward those with an interest in primary care is also proven to be effective
since African-Americans are more likely to consult their primary care doctor rather than a mental
health professional. Therefore, the primary care provider needs to be competent enough to
identify the symptoms and refer their client appropriately. Lastly, involvement in professional
advocacy organizations for mental illness helps to increase competency of both providers and
families.
Coping with Major Depressive Disorder
When understanding major depressive disorder, there are many types of coping
mechanisms an individual can perform in order to help aid while undergoing a depressive
episode. Adults may find it difficult to make time for pleasant activities or exercises that can aide
them while enduring an episode due to their daily activities such as work, family, or household
chores. It is with specific daily strategies that make ordinary activities that people with major
It is beneficial for an individual to find an activity they enjoy and to partake in it. With
depression, it can be extremely hard for an individual to find the motivation to do what they want
to do, rather than what they find productive or comfortable. In other words, it can be easier for
someone to busy themselves with household chores rather than spend time outside or go to a
movie (Rohan, 2009, p. 51). This emphasizes the importance of time management in order to set
activities into a daily routine helps to actively better the depressive symptoms one is undergoing.
Having specific coping mechanisms planned out in one’s day can cause encouragement in
completion of prioritized responsibilities when knowing there is time for a pleasant activity to
come at the end. Dr. Kelly Rohan, specialist of psychopathology and treatment of adult mood
disorders, mentions in her book, Coping with the Seasons (2009), “a high frequency of pleasant
activities is associated with satisfaction and happiness; a low frequency of pleasant activities is
associated with depressed moods” (p.51). This is often times played out with those that suffer
from SAD, a seasonal affective depressive disorder. Experiencing states of “cabin fever” is not
uncommon for those that suffer from this. Rohan writes, “during fall and winter, people with
SAD tend to experience fatigue and lack of energy, when they do not feel like doing anything” (
Because there are varying types of depression as well as all different types of
personalities and passions, it is crucial to find a coping mechanism that specifically relates to an
individual’s interests. Rohan suggests to learn something new that one has expressed interest in
(2009). Also, performing tasks that causes one to feel skilled can spark a positive mood. A brief
report included in the Journal of Affective Disorders studies how positive social interactions are
encouraged as well as physical activities and exercises (Rohan, 2009, p. 51). When giving these
things a try, individuals often times come across obstacles that hinder their enjoyment associated
with the activity. With MDD, it is not uncommon for individuals to experience a loss of
enjoyment in pleasurable activities. Rohan’s advice is to “fake it until you make it” (Rohan,
2009, p. 49). It is found that, with consistent repetition of the activity, gradual satisfaction will
return. For those that experience fatigue, it is beneficial to talk oneself through it. These
individuals should remind themselves that completing these activities will help their well being
and, that, if they do not follow through with execution of these exercises, they will only be stuck
in the depressive mood. The fatigueness should reduce over time as one gradually completes
more and longer tasks. Emotions can also get in the way of these coping mechanisms. If an
individual experiences anxiety, irritability or discomfort with social situations, this can hinder
their enjoyment with the activity. Even if this is the case, this should not hamper one from
following through with it. Rohan suggests, “identify the source of the emotional discomfort and
work on removing it. If you feel irritable or anxious, find effective ways to relax before doing the
pleasant activity” (Rohan, 2009, p. 52). She advises to not make excuses, but rather remember
that it should become more comfortable the more times the activity is done.
When advising someone with MDD, it is important to remind them that these pleasant
activities are needed in order to boost their mood. Specifically with the African American
community, exercise is encouraged due to the association between cardiovascular problems and
depression (Bailey et al., 2009). Physical activities are also highly encouraged. For those that
experience difficulty with pursuing a romantic relationship, positive social interactions would be
beneficial in establishing relations with others. Commitment is also crucial as well as readiness
to make life choices and establish priorities in furtherance of bettering one’s life.
Methodology
The methodology for this paper included searching for empirical sources on scholarly
databases such as PsycInfo and Google Scholar. Then we synthesized the information provided
in these articles and books in order to reach our conclusions. For this paper, we hypothesized that
that young adult African Americans would be less likely to seek and receive treatment for major
Because this is a literature review, we have collected no novel data or results. Therefore,
we have no data or results to report or analyze. However, based on the information suggested by
the empirical articles cited in this paper, we can conclude that the data do support our hypothesis.
Conclusion and Implications
Based on the stated literature review and analysis of data, African Americans are at a
disparity for mental illnesses, including major depressive disorder. From the years of systemic
oppression and the lack of minorities included in research about mental health care, the mental
health field has failed to adequately address and meet the needs of African Americans. In order
to begin to correct these failures, more holistic research must be tailored to the experiences of
Association (Eds.), Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th Edition
http://www.div12.org/sites/default/files/WhatIsProblemSolvingTherapy.pdf
Bailey, R. K., Blackmon, H. L., & Stevens, F. L. (2009). Major depressive disorder in the african
Bussing, R. & Gary, F. A. (2012). Eliminating mental health disparities by 2020: Everyone’s
actions matter. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry,
Cooper, L. A., Gonzales, J. J., Gallo, J. J., Rost, K. M., Meredith, L. S., Rubenstein, L. V., . . .
American, Hispanic, and white primary care patients. Medical Care,41(4), 479-489.
doi:10.1097/01.mlr.0000053228.58042.e4
Copeland, V. C., Newhill, C. E., Jackson Foster, L. J., Braxter, B. J., Doswell, W. M.,
Lewis, A. N., & Eack, S. M. (2017). Major depressive disorder and cardiovascular
Doi: 10.1080/01488376.2017.1370682
James, D. (2017). Internalized racism and past-year major depressive disorder among African-
Americans: The role of ethnic identity and self-esteem. Journal of Racial and Ethnic
Brooks/Cole.
https://www.lhsfna.org/index.cfm/health-promotion/mental-and-emotional-health/
Mental Health America (2017). Black & African American communities and mental
health
National Alliance on Mental Illness (2017). African American Mental Health. Retrieved
from https://www.nami.org/Find-Support/Diverse-Communities/African-American
https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/topics/depression/index.shtml
Rohan, K. J. (2009). Coping with the seasons: A cognitive behavioral approach to seasonal
http://www.health.am/ab/more/clinical_depression_and_african_americans/
Williams, D. R., González, H. M., Neighbors, H., Nesse, R., Abelson, J. M., Sweetman, J., &
Americans, Caribbean blacks, and non-Hispanic whites: Results from the National
doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.64.3.305
Appendix A
Table 1 shows results from a logistic regression model of comorbidity of Major Depressive Disorder and CVD of
the sample.
Appendix B