Similarities and Differences between First and Second Language Acquisition

Page historylast edited by Carmen Vanegas 9 years, 9 months ago

Standard 4B1

Similarities:
In both first and second language acquisition, universal grammar may influence learning. In second language
learning, universal grammar may influence learning either independently or through the first language.
In both first and second language acquisition, there are predictable stages, and particular structures are acquired in a set
order. Individuals may move more slowly or quickly through these stages, but they cannot skip ahead.
In both first and second language acquisition, making errors is a part of learning. Learners need to make and test
hypotheses about language to build an internal representation of the language. In the initial stages of learning, learners
may use chunks of language without breaking them down or processing them as independent units. In later stages, they
may make new errors as they begin to process the parts of each chunk according to the rules of their language system.
For example, a learner may start out using the correct form of an irregular verb as part of a language chunk, but later
overgeneralize and place a regular affix on that same verb.
In both first and second language acquisition, the learner uses context clues, prior knowledge, and interaction to
comprehend language.
In both first and second language acquisition, age is an important variable affecting proficiency.
In both first and second language acquisition, learners can often comprehend more complex language than they are able
to produce. In the initial stages of learning, learners go through a silent period.
In both first and second language acquisition, a learner's proficiency can vary across situations.
In both first and second language acquisition, learners may overgeneralize vocabulary or rules, using them in contexts
broader than those in which they should be used.
In both first and second language acquisition, learners need comprehensible input and opportunities to learn language
in context in order to increase their proficiency.
Differences:
In first language acquisition, the basis for learning is universal grammar alone. In second language acquisition,
knowledge of the first language also serves as a basis for learning the second language. There may be both positive and
negative transfer between languages in second language learning.
In first language acquisition, children spend several years listening to language, babbling, and using telegraphic
speech before they can form sentences. In second language acquisition in older learners, learning is more rapid and
people are able to form sentences within a shorter period of time.
In formal second language learning in older learners, learners are able to use more metacognitive processes in their
learning. They can consciously analyze and manipulate grammatical structures, and they can explicitly describe how
language works. This can speed the learning process.
In second language learning in older learners, learners bring more life experience and background knowledge to their
learning. They have more schemata and more learning strategies to help them learn the second language.
In second language learning in older learners, there may be less access to universal grammar, and sensitivity to
phonological distinctions not present in the native language will be reduced. Students learning in a classroom setting
may also have fewer opportunities to learn language authentically. These factors may reduce the likelihood that second
language learners will attain native-like proficiency. First-language learners always attain native proficiency, unless they
have a disability that affects language learning.
In first language acquistion, learners have many chances to practice with native speakers (especially caregivers). In
second language acquisition, learners may or may not have the opportunity to practice extensively with native speakers.
Almost everyone acquires a first language, but not everyone acquires a second language. Acquiring a first language
happens naturally, while acquiring a second language often requires conscious effort on the part of the learner.