Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Issue: Whether there is jurisdiction for a Mexican national, abducted to the US,
when US and Mexico had an extradition treaty. -Yes.
Reasoning:
• First court looks at the Extradition treaty to decide whether the abduction
violates it.
○ Treaty says nothing about US and Mexico's obligations to refrain from
abducting people, or the consequences if this happens.
○ Treaty only says that neither party is bound to delivery upon the other
its own nationals. At each country's discretion.
Notes
• US first sought extradition, was denied, then kidnapped him.
• Treaty outlines what gov't can do, but not exhaustive; doesn’t say what else
they can do
○ Treaty is silent on this
• Uses case law: Kirby v. Illinois
○ Private kidnapping permitted, and allowed to prosecute
• Dr also says this is in violation of CIL
○ b/c its actually gov't kidnapping (while in Kirby it was a private
citizen)
○ Dissent says this is bad policy
• Pg 238 - this abduction may be shocking, and violate CIL, but we have to go by
the treaty