Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Nabeel Khan, Dhruvan Patel, Chinmay Trivedi, Yash Shah, Gary Lichtenstein,
James Lewis, Yu-Xiao Yang
PII: S1542-3565(18)30012-0
DOI: 10.1016/j.cgh.2017.12.052
Reference: YJCGH 55638
Please cite this article as: Khan N, Patel D, Trivedi C, Shah Y, Lichtenstein G, Lewis J, Yang Y-
X, Overall and Comparative Risk of Herpes Zoster With Pharmacotherapy for Inflammatory Bowel
Diseases: A Nationwide Cohort Study, Clinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology (2018), doi: 10.1016/
j.cgh.2017.12.052.
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to
our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo
copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please
note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all
legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Overall and Comparative Risk of Herpes Zoster With Pharmacotherapy for Inflammatory Bowel
Diseases: A Nationwide Cohort Study
PT
1, 2 3 2 2 1
Authors: Nabeel Khan , Dhruvan Patel , Chinmay Trivedi , Yash Shah , Gary Lichtenstein , James
RI
1. Section of Gastroenterology, University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, Philadelphia,
PA
SC
2. Section of Gastroenterology, VA Medical Center, Philadelphia, PA
U
AN
Contact information for authors:
M
Nabeel Khan, MD
Email: nabeel.khan@mail.med.upenn.edu
D
Philadelphia, PA 19104
EP
Dhruvan Patel, MD
C
Email: pateldhruvan@gmail.com
AC
Philadelphia, PA 19102
Chinmay Trivedi, MD
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Email: Chinmay.Trivedi@va.gov
Philadelphia, PA 19104
PT
Yash Shah, MD
RI
Email: yash.shah@va.gov
SC
3900 Woodland Avenue
Philadelphia, PA 19104
U
AN
Gary Lichtenstein, MD
M
Email: gary.lichtenstein@uphs.upenn.edu
Division of Gastroenterology
D
GI Administration Offices
TE
th
7 Floor South, Room 753
Perelman Center
EP
Philadelphia, PA 19104
C
AC
Email: lewisjd@pennmedicine.upenn.edu
Philadelphia, PA 19104
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Email: yangy@mail.med.upenn.edu
PT
722 Blockley Hall
RI
Philadelphia, PA 19104
SC
Corresponding Author: To whom requests for reprints should be addressed:
U
Nabeel Khan, MD
AN
Assistant Clinical Professor of Medicine
Philadelphia, PA 19104
EP
Tel: 215-823-4451
C
Email: nabeelk@mail.med.upenn.edu
AC
Grant support
This study was supported by an unrestricted research grant from Pfizer pharmaceuticals. Pfizer had no
role in study concept, design, and analysis of data, critical review or drafting of the manuscript.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Disclaimer
The study sponsor had no role in study design, analysis and interpretation of the data and in the writing of
the report. The content of this report does not represent the views of the Department of Veterans Affairs
or of Pfizer Pharmaceuticals.
PT
RI
Disclosures
Dr. Lewis reports having served as a consultant for Janssen, AbbVie, UCB, Pfizer, and Takeda. All other
SC
authors have no potential conflicts (financial, professional, or personal) that are relevant to this
manuscript. The study was conducted and the manuscript was written and reviewed solely by the
U
authors.
AN
Author contribution:
M
Nabeel Khan has made substantial contribution to the study concept and design, acquisition of data,
D
analysis and interpretation of data, drafting of the manuscript, critical revision of the manuscript for
TE
important intellectual content and study supervision. Dhruvan Patel has participated in study concept and
design, analysis and interpretation of data as well as drafting of the manuscript. Chinmay Trivedi and
EP
Yash Shah have participated in acquisition of data as well as interpretation of data. Gary Lichtenstein has
participated in critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content. James Lewis has
C
participated in study design and critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content. Yu-
Xiao Yang has participated in study concept and design, analysis and interpretation of data, drafting of
AC
the manuscript, critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content and statistical analysis.
Abstract:
Background & Aims: Patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) might be at increased
risk for herpes zoster infection. We sought to quantify the risk of herpes zoster in patients with
IBD and evaluate the effects of IBD and IBD medications on the risk of herpes zoster.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
in study 2. We also estimated the incidence rate of herpes zoster based on age and IBD
medication subgroups.
RI
Results: Compared to no IBD, ulcerative colitis (UC) and Crohn’s disease (CD) were each
associated with significantly increased risk of herpes zoster infection. In multivariable Cox
regression (compared to no IBD), UC, CD, or IBD treated with 5-ASA treatment alone was
SC
associated with significantly increased risk of herpes zoster, with adjusted HRs (AHR) of 1.81
for UC (95% CI, 1.56–2.11), 1.56 for CD (95% CI, 1.28–1.91), and 1.72 for treated IBD (95%
CI, 1.51–1.96). In multivariable Cox regression analysis, compared to exposure to 5-ASA alone,
exposure to thiopurines (AHR, 1.47; 95% CI, 1.31–1.65) or a combination of thiopurines and
U
TNF antagonists (AHR, 1.65; 95% CI, 1.22–2.23) was associated with increased risk of herpes
zoster. However, exposure to TNF antagonists alone (AHR, 1.15; 95% CI, 0.96–1.38) was not
AN
associated with increased risk of herpes zoster. The incidence rates of herpes zoster in all age
groups and all IBD medication subgroups were substantially higher than that in the oldest group
of patients without IBD (older than 60 years).
M
Introduction:
C
Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), Crohn’s disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC) are chronic
AC
inflammatory disorders involving the gastrointestinal tract of unknown etiology. The altered immune
regulation seen in patients with IBD as well as medications used to treat IBD may predispose patients to
1
systemic complications, such as an increased risk of infection.
2
Herpes zoster (HZ) results from reactivation of latent varicella zoster virus (VZV) infection. The clinical
presentation is characterized by a painful, unilateral vesicular eruption and is often complicated by post-
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
3
herpetic neuralgia (PHN). Previous studies observed that the risk of HZ is elevated by 1.2 to 1.8 times in
patients with IBD as compared to patients without IBD, but these studies were either done prior to the
4-6
advent of biologics, or excluded patients who were over the age of 64. Additionally, these prior studies
have not assessed the validity of the codes used to identify HZ and also did not account for the impact of
PT
vaccination. They also did not take into consideration the severity of the disease or degree of steroid
exposure.
RI
To overcome these limitations and to evaluate the incidence and risk factors for HZ in a nationwide IBD
SC
population, we used a Veterans’ Affairs (VA) cohort for our study. The VA has predominantly older
7
population which makes it an ideal cohort to study HZ incidence in a high-risk population. Unlike
U
insurance databases, the VA database can be validated internally and vaccination records are
documented. Our aims were to determine whether patients with IBD have an increased risk of HZ
AN
independent of immunosuppressive medication use and to quantify the extent that immunosuppression
Methods:
TE
We conducted two retrospective cohort studies among patients in the US national VA healthcare system
EP
using data from the VA Informatics and Computing Infrastructure (VINCI) from January 1, 2000 through
June 30, 2016. We obtained inpatient and outpatient International Classification of Diseases, Version 9 &
C
10, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM, ICD-10-CM) diagnosis codes, encounters, procedures, pharmacy
AC
Study Population
The cohort study period was from January 1, 2000, through June 30, 2016. The study population
included all veterans who had an ICD-9-CM or ICD-10-CM diagnosis for inflammatory bowel disease
(IBD) during the study period. IBD was defined by the presence of an inpatient or outpatient diagnosis
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
code of Crohn’s Disease (556.xx), (K51.xx) and/or Ulcerative Colitis (555.xx), (K50.xx) respectively (see
appendix 1). We performed a validation of the algorithm based on IBD diagnostic codes. Two members of
the investigative team (YS and CT) manually reviewed the VA electronic medical records of 200 randomly
selected patients who had any of the IBD diagnostic codes. The IBD diagnosis was confirmed in 189 out
PT
of 200 patients (94.5%) with 100% concordance between the two reviewers. To be included in the final
cohort for this study the following criteria must have also been met: (1) ≥1 ICD-9 or ICD-10 diagnosis
RI
code for UC and/or CD, (2) ≥1 outpatient visit in VA health care system, (3) At least 1 outpatient
pharmacy claim for any of the IBD medications in Group 1-5 ([1] 5-ASA only, [2] Thiopurines, [3] Anti-TNF
SC
agents, [4] a combination of thiopurines and anti-TNF, [5] Vedolizumab) (4) At least two prescriptions of
one distinct medication in medication groups 1-5 (5) the censor date could not be preceded by the date
U
of the first prescription of IBD medication/pharmacy claim. For all patients, the follow-up began at the time
of the start of the first IBD medication in any of the 5 medication groups and ended at the first of any
AN
following events: (1) incident herpes zoster (HZ) diagnosis, (2) HZ vaccination (i.e., CPT code 90736), (3)
death, or (4) last prescribed medication course for any of the 5 medication groups.
M
Exposure
EP
The exposed group (n=13,001) in this cohort study consisted of those IBD patients who were categorized
C
in only medication group 1 (i.e., 5-ASA) and without any exposure to corticosteroids. The unexposed
AC
group consisted of a cohort of randomly selected non-IBD patients (n=35,510) from CDW who were
matched with the exposed group at a ratio of up to 1:4 with respect to 1) Veterans Integrated Service
Network (VISN) number which designates the geographic location of clusters of VA facilities in the same
region; 2) year of first outpatient receipt of care in the VA; 3) Age (at criteria 2 visit date), and 4) gender.
Outcome
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
The outcome was time to the first occurrence HZ in the follow-up period defined by relevant ICD-9-CM
(053.xx), ICD-10-CM (B02.xx) codes for HZ and their complications (see appendix 3). In order to validate
the coding algorithm for HZ, two members of the investigative team (YS and CT) performed manual
review of the VA electronic medical records of 200 randomly selected patients who had any of the HZ
PT
diagnostic codes. HZ diagnosis was confirmed in 182 out of 200 patients (91%) with 100% concordance
RI
Statistical Analyses
SC
The baseline characteristics of the exposure groups were compared using descriptive statistics.
U
were calculated as the number of events per 1000 patient-years. Multivariable Cox regression was used
to estimate the HR and CI for HZ risk associated with having IBD, UC or CD and being exposed to 5-ASA
AN
versus not having IBD, adjusting for the geographical location, health care utilization defined as the
number of patient visits (outpatient and inpatient) , race, and the baseline comorbid medical conditions
M
pulmonary disease, congestive heart failure, renal failure, liver disease, and AIDS/HIV. CDW data was
D
stored in Microsoft SQL Server database and extracts were created from T-SQL coding using Microsoft
TE
SQL Server Management Studio. Final dataset creation and analysis were completed using SAS
Enterprise Guide 7.1 software on SAS/Grid computing environment in SAS 9.4 intelligence platform.
EP
Analyses were also performed using R software, version 3.3.1 (R Core Team (2016). R: A language and
environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. URL
C
https://www.R-project.org/).
AC
We conducted a second retrospective cohort study using the same national VA data in VINCI.
Exposure Groups
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
The exposure of interest was use of IBD medications categorized in 5 groups: (1) 5-ASA only, (2)
Thiopurines, (3) Anti-TNF agents, (4) a combination of Thiopurines and Anti-TNF medications (5)
Vedolizumab (see appendix 2). Medication use information was based on all inpatient and outpatient
prescription records and related procedure codes. To determine exposure status to the medication
PT
groups on any given day during follow-up, a patient is considered to be exposed to a medication or
medication combination in a given medication group starting from the first day of prescription. The patient
RI
continued in that medication group until the earliest of the following events: a medication from a higher-
numbered medication group was prescribed, a 90-day gap was found between prescriptions, or until
SC
censoring. Regarding infusible medications which included infliximab and vedolizumab, we included 3
months after the last CPT code entry as the period of exposure. A patient could also go back to a lower
U
group if a medication was stopped and they were still on a medication from a lower group. Ninety day
gaps were considered as completion of a round of medication. A new round would start with the next
AN
prescription. The exposure was measured in a time dependent manner. Specifically, the follow-up time
for each patient was divided into consecutive 60-day intervals (except for the last interval which could be
M
<60 days). Within each interval, the exposure status was determined based on exposure to a medication
group for any duration. In instances where medication group switches occurred during an interval, the
D
exposure status was assigned according to the medication group associated with the longest duration
TE
Outcome
The outcome was time to incident HZ during the follow-up period among each medication group as
C
defined above.
AC
Statistical Analyses
Demographic and clinical characteristics were summarized with counts and percentages for categorical
Overall incidence of HZ, the incidence by medication groups as well as by age groups at the time of HZ
diagnosis (<50, 50-60, and >60 years) within each medication group were estimated as the number of
PT
We performed Cox regression with time-dependent analysis to examine the risk of HZ by medication
RI
group. Medication group 5 (Vedolizumab group) was excluded from the survival analyses due to its small
sample size and no observed cases of HZ in this group. Specifically, we constructed multivariable Cox
SC
regression model with robust standard errors to estimate the aggregate hazard ratios and 95% CIs by
pooling the interval-specific associations between the medication exposure group status at the beginning
U
of each 60-day interval (i.e., index date) and the risk of HZ during that interval. The model was adjusted
for the following time-varying covariates updated in each interval: age at index date, intensity of
AN
prednisone use up to each index date (i.e., total amount of prednisone taken from the beginning of follow-
up divided by the total number of days up to the index date), oral prednisone use within 30 days before
M
index date, a proxy for disease flare up (i.e., presence of any of the following events during a 60-day
interval: a hospitalization, IV corticosteroid use, abdominal and or pelvic CT, stool C. difficile toxin testing.
D
In addition, we also included the following fixed covariates: IBD diagnosis (UC/CD), geographical location
TE
(Midwest, North Atlantic, Pacific, Southeast, Continental), health care utilization (<6, 6 to 12, ≥13
visits/year), race (white, black, others, unknown), gender, and the baseline comorbid medical conditions.
EP
prior to first medication date. An outpatient diagnosis was only kept if two distinct diagnosis records
AC
greater than 30 days apart were found. Hazard ratios (HRs) between medication groups were estimated
Results:
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Cohort 1 (IBD vs non-IBD) included 13,001 eligible IBD patients (42, 510 person-years of total follow-up)
who had only been exposed to 5-ASA and 35,510 randomly selected matched non-IBD patients (334,017
person-years of total follow-up) from VINCI. Table 1 presents the baseline characteristics of these two
matched comparison groups. The overall crude incidence rate for HZ was 7.55 per 1000 person-years in
PT
the IBD group versus only 3.22 per 1000 person-years in the non-IBD group. IBD patients who required
only 5-ASA for disease control had significantly increased risk of HZ compared to matched non-IBD
RI
patients. In multivariable Cox regression, compared to the non-IBD reference group, having either UC or
CD, or any IBD (with 5-ASA treatment alone) was associated with significantly increased risk of
SC
developing HZ with adjusted HRs (AHR) of 1.81 (95 % CI: 1.56-2.11) for UC, 1.56 (95% CI: 1.28-1.91) for
CD, 1.72 (95% CI: 1.51-1.96) for IBD. (Table 2) Using CD as a control group, we found that UC patients
U
did not have statistically higher risk of HZ development (AHR 1.16, 95% CI: 0.92-1.47).
AN
Table 3 shows HZ incidence rate in IBD and non-IBD group stratified by age <50 years, 50-60 years and
>60 years. The IBD group had a higher incidence for HZ than the matched non-IBD group. In fact, the
M
incidence of HZ among the youngest age group of patients with IBD (i.e., 8.62 per 1000 person-years)
exceeded that of the oldest group of control patients (i.e., 3.3 per 1000 person-years).
D
TE
Cohort 2 (IBD by medication use) included a total of 54,919 eligible IBD patients who accumulated
243,506 person-years of at risk time. During this follow-up period, 2,007 total episodes of incident HZ
were observed. A comparison of the patients who contributed at-risk time in each of the medication
EP
exposure groups with respect to total at-risk time, number of incident HZ episodes, crude HZ incident
rate, and baseline characteristic is shown in Table 4. Because of the time-varying nature of the exposure
C
variable, a patient may contribute at-risk time in more than one medication groups. Of note, there were
AC
no incident HZ events in Vedolizumab group which only included 167 patients. Therefore, Vedolizumab
In multivariable Cox regression analysis, compared to exposure to 5-ASA alone, exposure to thiopurines
[AHR 1.47 (95%CI 1.31-1.65)] or a combination of thiopurines and anti-TNF agents [AHR 1.65 (95% CI
1.22-2.23)] was associated with increased risk of HZ. However, exposure to anti-TNF agents alone [AHR
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
1.15 (95% CI 0.96-1.38)] was not associated with increased risk of HZ (Table 5). Both cumulative [AHR
1.02 (95% CI 1.01-1.03)] and short term [1.27(95% CI 1.10-1.48)] exposure to prednisone were
associated with an increased risk of developing HZ. As expected, increased age [1.01 (95%CI 1.01-1.02)]
and disease flare [3.69 (95% CI 3.22-3.43)] as described above was also associated with an increased
PT
risk of developing HZ. Multivariate analysis of other risk factors for HZ development among IBD patients
is mentioned in table 5.
RI
Table 6 shows the absolute risk of HZ across the 4 medication groups stratified by age groups. There
SC
was a clear trend of increasing risk of HZ with rising age. However, patients in the younger age group
(e.g., < 50) who were exposed to immunomodulators, anti-TNF or a combination of these medications
U
can have absolute risk of HZ comparable or higher than those over the age of 60 in patients exposed to
5-ASA only.
AN
M
Discussion:
D
In this large nationwide VA cohort with IBD patients, we analyzed the incidence and risk factors for HZ
TE
and the impact of IBD medications upon them. We found that IBD itself without immunosuppressive
medicine can predispose patients to develop HZ. Within the IBD cohort, older age, use of thiopurine or
EP
thiopurines and anti-TNF (combination therapy), IBD flare, higher cumulative prednisone use or
prednisone use within the last 30 days were independent risk factors for HZ incidence. In multivariate
C
analysis, after controlling for multiple confounding factors including IBD flare, anti-TNF medicine use
alone was not an independent risk factor for HZ in IBD. IBD patients who were <50 years of age and on
AC
combination therapy had a higher risk of HZ than those who were >60 years of age and on mesalamine
therapy alone. The highest risk was observed amongst IBD patients who were >60 years of age and on
Patients with IBD have been previously shown to have an increased risk of HZ compared to general
4-6
population in prior studies. In our study, we compared IBD patients who were only on mesalamine
therapy to matched control group who had no IBD and we found that patients with both UC and CD have
significantly higher chance of developing HZ. The incidence of HZ was slightly higher in UC patients (7.98
PT
per 1000 PYs) compared to CD patients (6.83 per 1000 PYs) in our cohort but it was not statistically
significant. This is in contrast with previous case-control studies which showed that patients with CD had
RI
4, 5
higher risk of HZ than patients with UC. Unlike those studies, in our case-control analysis we excluded
IBD patients who were on prednisone as well as immunosuppressant medicines because we wanted to
SC
study the effect of the disease process in the absence of medication-induced systemic
immunosuppression on HZ development. Our aim was to ascertain whether the immune dysregulation
U
associated with IBD is in itself a factor that predisposes patients to an increased risk of herpes zoster
while removing the impact of known pharmacological risk factors such as corticosteroids which have been
AN
extensively studied. Additionally, we censored our IBD cohort as well as non-IBD cohort for HZ
vaccination which other prior studies did not. Our result proposes that innate immune dysregulation in IBD
M
Because of higher risk of HZ in IBD population, it is important to understand the HZ risk factors which
TE
predispose IBD patients to develop HZ. In our cohort, use of thiopurine alone [AHR 1.47 (95%CI 1.31-
1.65)] and combination therapy [AHR 1.65 (95% CI 1.22-2.23)] were independently associated with the
EP
increased risk of HZ after adjusting for other confounding factors. Previous studies that have evaluated
the risk of HZ in IBD found a similar result of increased HZ risk with the use of thiopurine and combination
C
4-6, 9
therapy. Interestingly, the use of anti-TNF alone [AHR 1.15 (95% CI 0.96-1.38)] was not an
AC
independent risk factor of HZ incidence after controlling for all possible confounding variables, most
importantly for IBD flare. This is in contrast with existing literatures which states that anti-TNF use
4-6, 9
increases the risk of HZ incidence in IBD. However, none of these previous studies have evaluated
IBD flare as one of the confounders which could have overestimated the risk of HZ incidence in patients
taking anti-TNF medicines. Although it is difficult to accurately capture all flares in a retrospective study
we feel that the criteria we devised would capture the majority of the flares. As suspected, IBD flare had
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
the strongest association with the development of HZ (HR 3.69, 95%CI 3.22-4.23). Further studies are
Cumulative exposure of prednisone over the course of the disease and current use of prednisone could
PT
serve as a proxy of disease severity and associated with increased HZ risk. While performing time-
dependent analysis and including two additional time-dependent covariates designed to capture both
RI
chronic (i.e., cumulative prednisone use per unit follow-up time) and current (i.e., presence of events
specific for IBD flare) disease activity, we found that intensity of cumulative prednisone exposure ( HR
SC
1.02, 95% CI 1.01-1.03) and prednisone use within 30 days of index date (HR 1.27, 95% CI 1.10-1.48)
were both independent risk factors for HZ incidence after controlling for confounding factors. The result is
U
in keeping with previous studies which have identified that longer duration and higher dose of
10
glucocorticoids use confer a greater risk of HZ in IBD as demonstrated by Winthrop et al.
AN
In addition to the use of immunosuppressive medicine, we found that advancing age (HR 1.01, 95% CI
M
1.01-1.02) is another independent risk factor for development of HZ in IBD population. A novel aspect of
this study was the assessment of the combined effect of older age and medication use on HZ incidence in
D
an IBD population. We found that IBD patients who were >60 years of age and on combination therapy
TE
had the highest risk of HZ development which approached almost 2% per year.
EP
Advancement has been made in the field of vaccination against herpes zoster. Recently a new
recombinant subunit vaccine for HZ was developed by GlaxoSmithKline and in clinical trials it has shown
C
11
97.2% efficacy in patients >50 years of age. Current ACG (American College of Gastroenterology)
AC
12
guidelines have recommended vaccination among patients over the age of 50 in patients with IBD. The
high herpes zoster rates observed in patients with <50 years of age and on combination therapy or with
immunomodulatory therapy in our study raises the question of whether younger patients with IBD should
also be vaccinated for the prevention of HZ. Further studies should be conducted on universal vaccination
among IBD population to assess the efficacy and feasibility of this new vaccination.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
The major strength of this study was that data was captured form a nationwide cohort and had one of the
longest follow up duration spanning a 16-year period. As we evaluated IBD patients long after the advent
of anti-TNF medicines, we were able to capture a large number of patients on anti-TNF and thiopurines
4-6, 9
unlike previous studies focused on the same hypothesis. The older population in VA system also
PT
makes it an ideal cohort to study the incidence and risk factors for HZ in this high-risk group unlike one of
the previous studies which excluded patients who were >64 years of age.5 HZ vaccination record is
RI
widely available in the VA system and ours was the first study that accounted for the use of zostavax.
Additionally, we internally validated ICD-9 and ICD-10 codes for both IBD and HZ diagnosis. Our
SC
validation demonstrates that the diagnosis of HZ and IBD in our data is accurate with positive predictive
value of 91% for HZ and 94.5% for IBD diagnosis. Another strength of our study is that we controlled for
U
additional measure of disease activity/severity (cumulative prednisone exposure as well as prednisone
exposure within 30 days and the first study to control for IBD flare) which would help minimize the effect
AN
of confounding by indication. Lastly, we used other surrogate measures as a mechanism for evaluating
There are certain limitations in our study. The VA population is a selected cohort not only due to the male
D
predominance but this is also an older population, and thus our results may not be generalizable to a
TE
general population. However, none of the previous studies have shown that gender as a risk factor for HZ
infection in IBD population. Moreover, the size of the population still allowed us to perform meaningful
EP
age-specific subgroup analyses. Because we used the VA pharmacy database to estimate medication
exposure rates, prescriptions filled outside the VA were not captured by our analysis. We do not
C
anticipate this has created any bias as previous reports have shown that veterans have very good
AC
13-15
adherence in using the VA pharmacy. We employed a time-varying analytical approach and
estimated the incidence of HZ risk for the respective medication groups based on the total person-time of
exposure to a particular medication group and the number of HZ events that occurred during such
person-time of exposure. Based on the known pharmacological effects of the IBD medications, we
expected that any impact of IBD medications on herpes zoster (HZ) risk would primarily be limited to the
period of exposure to the respective medication groups. To the extent that this assumption might not
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
precisely reflect the true induction periods between exposure to the various groups IBD medications and
HZ risk, our effect estimates could potentially contain some degree of error. A better understanding of the
mechanism(s) mediating the effect of IBD medications on HZ risk would allow future studies to more
accurately define the etiologically relevant exposure window and minimize such error.
PT
RI
In conclusion, using a large nationwide VA database we found that IBD itself and treatment with
thiopurines alone or in combination with anti-TNF agents, cumulative and recent use of prednisone within
SC
30 days were independently associated with a higher risk of HZV. The highest risk of HZ was observed in
IBD patients who were >60 years of age and on combination therapy. IBD patients younger than 50 years
U
who were on combination therapy had higher risk of HZ compared to IBD patients older than 60 years of
age who were not on immunosuppressive therapy. With the approval of the new HZ vaccine further
AN
studies into its efficacy and expansion of use among the IBD population should be undertaken.
M
References:
D
TE
1. Irving PM, Gibson PR. Infections and IBD. Nature Clinical Practice Gastroenterology &
Hepatology. 2008;5(1):18-27.
EP
3. Sampathkumar P, Drage LA, Martin DP, editors. Herpes zoster (shingles) and postherpetic
C
4. Gupta G, Lautenbach E, Lewis JD. Incidence and risk factors for herpes zoster among patients
5. Long MD, Martin C, Sandler RS, et al. Increased risk of herpes zoster among 108 604 patients
6. Marehbian J, Arrighi HM, Hass S, et al. Adverse events associated with common therapy
2009;104(10):2524-33.
PT
8. Quan H, Sundararajan V, Halfon P, et al. Coding algorithms for defining comorbidities in ICD-9-
RI
9. Osterman MT, Haynes K, Delzell E, et al. Effectiveness and Safety of Immunomodulators With
Anti–Tumor Necrosis Factor Therapy in Crohn’s Disease. Clinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology.
SC
2015;13(7):1293-301. e5.
10. Winthrop KL, Baddley JW, Chen L, et al. Association between the initiation of anti–tumor necrosis
U
factor therapy and the risk of Herpes Zoster. Jama. 2013;309(9):887-95.
11. Lal H, Cunningham AL, Godeaux O, et al. Efficacy of an adjuvanted herpes zoster subunit
AN
vaccine in older adults. New England Journal of Medicine. 2015;372(22):2087-96.
12. Farraye FA, Melmed GY, Lichtenstein GR, et al. ACG Clinical Guideline: preventive care in
M
13. Klein R, Stockford D. Data on the Socioeconomic Status of Veterans and on VA Program Usage.
D
14. U.S. Government Accountability Office Report VHC. Use of VA Services by Medicare-Eligible
15. Wolinsky FD, Miller TR, An H, et al. Dual use of Medicare and the Veterans Health
Administration: are there adverse health outcomes? BMC Health Services Research. 2006;6(1):131.
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Table 1. Baseline characteristics of IBD patients receiving only 5-ASA and matched non-IBD
patients
PT
All (%) 35,510 13,001 4632 (35.63) 8369 (64.37)
RI
Female 2486 (7.5) 826 (6.35) 311 (6.71) 515 (6.15)
SC
Race, no. (%)
African American 4566 (12.86) 1146 (8.81) 393 (8.48) 753 (9)
U
11,283 (86.79) 4039 (87.2) 7244 (86.56)
AN
Others 648 (1.82) 204 (1.57) 57 (1.23) 147 (1.76)
North Atlantic 13,791 (38.84) 4595 (35.34) 1673 (36.12) 2922 (34.91)
<50 years 4322 (12.17) 2088 (16.06) 750 (16.19) 1338 (15.99)
AC
50-60 years 4001 (11.27) 1902 (14.63) 720 (15.54) 1182 (14.12)
>60 years 27187 (76.56) 9011 (69.31) 3162 (68.26) 5849 (69.89)
visits/year
PT
>13 10,457 (29.45) 4854 (37.34) 1744 (37.65) 3110 (37.16)
RI
median]
All 9.41 (4.41), 10 4.24 (3.98), 2.87 4.40 (4.04), 3.06 4.15 (3.95), 2.76
SC
HZ diagnosis 6.38 (3.93), 5.96 3.71 (3.37), 2.71 4.00 (3.43), 2.90 3.56 (3.34), 2.58
U
no. (%)
AN
Last recorded date 24,559 (69.16) 10146 (78.04) 3636 (78.5) 6510 (77.79)
HZ diagnosis date 1076 (3.03) 321 (2.47) 109 (2.35) 212 (2.53)
M
HZ vaccination date 4970 (14) 1612 (12.4) 554 (11.96) 1058 (12.64)
Hypertension
66 (0.19) 101 (0.78) 29 (0.63) 72 (0.86)
Complicated
Hypertension
EP
Diabetes
AC
Chronic Pulmonary
1073 (3.02) 850 (6.54) 289 (6.24) 561 (6.7)
Disease
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Congestive Heart
600 (1.69) 319 (2.45) 107 (2.31) 212 (2.53)
Failure
PT
HIV 63 (0.18) 54 (0.42) 12 (0.26) 42 (0.5)
None of the above 24,286 (68.39) 7025 (54.03) 2553 (55.12) 4472 (53.44)
RI
IBD, Irritable Bowel Disease; UC, Ulcerative Colitis; CD, Crohn’s Disease; HZ, Herpes Zoster; SD,
SC
standard deviation; District, geographical VA district recorded at first outpatient visit in the VA; Age,
calculated at end of follow up date ; Last recorded date, last prescription date for IBD or last visit date for
U
non-IBD; Comorbidities, diagnosed in the year prior to group time
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Table 2. Association between IBD and IBD subtype status and the risk of HZ*
Ratio**
Comparison groups
PT
IBD (5-ASA treatment only) 1.72 (1.51, 1.96)
RI
CD only 1.56 (1.28, 1.91)
SC
* the comparison groups of overall IBD (5-ASA treatment only) group and non-IBD group were matched
U
on age, sex, calendar year of start of follow-up, VISN.
AN
**this analysis adjusted geographic region, intensity of VA healthcare utilization, race, and baseline
comorbidity status (i.e., Hypertension (controlled and uncontrolled), diabetes mellitus, lymphoma,
metastatic cancer, Chronic Pulmonary Disease, Congestive heart failure, renal failure, liver disease,
M
AIDS.)
D
TE
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Episodes of HZ
PT
per 1000 person 8.62 9.03 7.15
years
RI
IBD case cohort
No. of patients 35 53 233
SC
Patient-years 4062.56 5866.16 32582.06
Episodes of HZ
cohort
No. of patients 77 131 868
M
Medication Group*
5-ASA Thiopur
PT
(n=5491 (n=5096 (n=1317 agents and anti-TNFs Vedolizuma
RI
IBD
SC
CD 1655 (65.31) 95 (56.89)
(38.57) (36.21) (53.25) (62.27)
U
UC 879 (34.69) 72 (43.11)
(61.43) (63.79) (46.75) (37.73)
AN
63.8 65.7 59.3 52.4
Age, mean (SD) years 13.67 (52.7) 51.8 (14.99)
(14.83) (14.18) (14.93) (14.47)
M
Geographical region
PT
8828 8159 2252 1253
Pacific 520 (20.52) 39 (23.35)
(16.07) (16.01) (17.09) (18.83)
RI
10552 9895 2406 1270
Southeast 434 (17.13) 27 (16.17)
(19.21) (19.42) (18.26) (19.09)
SC
Episodes of HZ, no. 2007 1372 437 152 46 0
U
10 43 4
AN
Episodes per
years
M
Comorbidities
D
116 111 18
Lymphoma 7 (0.11) 1 (0.04) 0 (0)
(0.21) (0.22) (0.14)
55
Metastatic Cancer 56 (0.1) 4 (0.03) 2 (0.03) 0 (0) 0 (0)
(0.11)
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Chronic
3553 3358 563
Pulmonary 244 (3.67) 80 (3.16) 6 (3.59)
(6.47) (6.59) (4.27)
Disease
PT
Failure (2.16) (2.19) (1.45)
RI
(1.47) (1.43) (1.06)
SC
(1.47) (1.44) (1.38)
138 135 12
HIV 11 (0.17) 3 (0.12) 0 (0)
U
(0.25) (0.26) (0.09)
AN
None of the 33574 30820 9299 4886
1925 (75.97) 126 (75.45)
above (61.13) (60.48) (70.59) (73.44)
M
* Because of the time-varying nature of the exposure variable, a patient may contribute at-risk time in
D
more than one medication groups. This table presents a comparison of the patient who contributed at-risk
time in each of the medication group. Therefore, a patient may be included in more than one exposure
TE
group. The baseline characteristics reflect status at the beginning of the total follow-up for each patient
IBD, Irritable Bowel Disease; UC, Ulcerative Colitis; CD, Crohn’s Disease; HZ, Herpes Zoster; SD,
Adjusted Hazard
Variable 95% CI p value
Ratio*
PT
Medication Group
RI
Thiopurines 1.47 (1.31, 1.65) <0.001
SC
Anti-TNF agents 1.15 (0.96, 1.38) 0.132
Thiopurines and
U
1.65 (1.22, 2.23) 0.001
anti-TNF agents
AN
Age at index date 1.01 (1.01, 1.02) <0.001
M
Prednisone
1.02 (1.01, 1.03) 0.002
cumulative (mg/day)
D
Prednisone within 30
TE
IBD Diagnosis
C
District
PT
Race
RI
White 1.17 ( 0.99, 1.37) 0.062
SC
Other 1.33 ( 0.95, 1.88) 0.097
Gender
U
AN
Female Reference Reference Reference
Baseline comorbid
C
medical conditions
AC
Complicated
1.41 ( 0.68, 2.95) 0.355
Hypertension
Uncomplicated
1.02 ( 0.92, 1.13) 0.698
Hypertension
Chronic
PT
Pulmonary 1.13 ( 0.94, 1.37) 0.183
Disease
RI
Congestive Heart
1.06 ( 0.77, 1.46) 0.707
Failure
SC
Renal failure 1.02 ( 0.63, 1.68) 0.923
U
AN
AIDS 1.31 ( 0.47, 3.62) 0.601
M
* adjusting for IBD type, age at index date, cumulative prednisone, prednisone use within 30 days prior to
the index date, disease flare, geographic region, intensity of VA healthcare utilization, race, gender, and
D
baseline comorbidity status ( i.e., Hypertension (controlled and uncontrolled), diabetes mellitus,
TE
lymphoma, metastatic cancer, Chronic Pulmonary Disease, Congestive heart failure, renal failure, liver
disease, AIDS.)
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Age 50-60
Age<50 years Age>60 years
years
PT
Rate of HZ per
RI
years
5-ASA
Number of
145 275 952
SC
patients
U
Rate of HZ per
AN
1000 person- 8.2 11.0 13.9
years
Thiopurines
M
Number of
79 97 261
patients
D
Rate of HZ per
years
EP
Anti-TNF
Number of
agents
38 50 64
patients
C
Rate of HZ per
(Thiopurines + years
Anti-TNF) Number of
13 16 17
patients
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Rate of HZ per
1000 person- 0 0 0
years
Vedolizumab
PT
Number of
0 0 0
patients
RI
Patient-years 34.51 11.45 24.47
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Appendix 1.
PT
icd9code Description
RI
555.1 REGIONAL ENTERITIS OF LARGE INTESTINE
SC
555.9 REGIONAL ENTERITIS OF UNSPECIFIED SITE
U
556.1 ULCERATIVE ILEOCOLITIS
AN
556.2 ULCERATIVE PROCTITIS
icd10code Description
EP
PT
K50.118 CROHN'S DISEASE OF LARGE INTESTINE WITH OTHER COMPLICATION
RI
K50.80 CROHN'S DISEASE OF BOTH SMALL AND LARGE INTESTINE WITHOUT COMPLICATIONS
K50.811 CROHN'S DISEASE OF BOTH SMALL AND LARGE INTESTINE WITH RECTAL BLEEDING
SC
CROHN'S DISEASE OF BOTH SMALL AND LARGE INTESTINE WITH INTESTINAL
K50.812 OBSTRUCTION
U
K50.813 CROHN'S DISEASE OF BOTH SMALL AND LARGE INTESTINE WITH FISTULA
K50.814 CROHN'S DISEASE OF BOTH SMALL AND LARGE INTESTINE WITH ABSCESS
AN
K50.818 CROHN'S DISEASE OF BOTH SMALL AND LARGE INTESTINE WITH OTHER COMPLICATION
K50.819 COMPLICATIONS
PT
K51.213 ULCERATIVE (CHRONIC) PROCTITIS WITH FISTULA
RI
K51.218 ULCERATIVE (CHRONIC) PROCTITIS WITH OTHER COMPLICATION
SC
K51.30 ULCERATIVE (CHRONIC) RECTOSIGMOIDITIS WITHOUT COMPLICATIONS
U
K51.312 ULCERATIVE (CHRONIC) RECTOSIGMOIDITIS WITH INTESTINAL OBSTRUCTION
PT
K51.813 OTHER ULCERATIVE COLITIS WITH FISTULA
RI
K51.818 OTHER ULCERATIVE COLITIS WITH OTHER COMPLICATION
SC
K51.90 ULCERATIVE COLITIS, UNSPECIFIED, WITHOUT COMPLICATIONS
U
K51.912 ULCERATIVE COLITIS, UNSPECIFIED WITH INTESTINAL OBSTRUCTION
Appendix 2.
Medication Group
EP
5 VEDOLIZUMAB
C
BALSALAZIDE
AC
1 OLSALAZINE
SULFASALAZINE
AZATHIOPRINE
2
MERCAPTOPURINE
ADALIMUMAB
3
CERTOLIZUMAB
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
GOLIMUMAB
INFLIXIMAB
PT
Appendix 3.
RI
ICD9Code Description
SC
HERPES ZOSTER WITH UNSPECIFIED NERVOUS SYSTEM
053.1 COMPLICATION
U
053.11 GENICULATE HERPES ZOSTER
053.19 COMPLICATIONS
D
ICD10Code Description
PT
B02.39 OTHER HERPES ZOSTER EYE DISEASE
RI
B02.8 ZOSTER WITH OTHER COMPLICATIONS
SC
CPT code Description
U
90736 INJECTION
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC