TATA Projects Limited

TECHNICAL OFFER EVALUATION REPORT (TER) - GATE & GLOBE VALVE

Project : Interplant Fuel Gas & Industrial Gases Piping For All Units
Client : BSP, SAIL
Site : Bhilai, Chhattisgarh
Pkg No : 075

BIDDERS NAME

SL NO SIZE ITEM TYPE BRIEF ITEM DESCRIPTION QUANTITY Fouress Engineering Kalpana Valves Mfg. Sakhi Engineers Pvt.
Weir BDK Valves NSSL Limited
(I) Limited Co. Pvt. Ltd. Ltd.

Gate Valve, Design : API 602, Class 800, Rising Steam Type, Bolted Bonnet, Solid Wedge, Manually
2 DN25 Gate Valve Operated, Socket Weld End, Forged Carbon Steel : ASTM A105, Trim : SS (Minimum 13% Cr. Steel), Testing 38 (3) (3) (3) (3)(6) (5)
YES YES YES YES NO
: API 598, Compressed air service operating @ 7 kg/cm2 @ Ambient temparature

Globe Valve, Design : BS EN ISO 15761, Class 800, Rising Steam Type, Bolted Bonnet, Manually Operated,
2 DN25 Globe Valve Socket Weld End, Forged Carbon Steel, Trim : SS (13% Cr. Steel), Testing : BS EN ISO 15761/ API 598; 38 (3) (3) (3) (3)(6) (5)
YES YES YES YES NO
Compressed air service operating @ 7 kg/cm2 @ Ambient temparature

Note :
1. Scope of work include engineering, manufacture, assembly; shop testing, inspection, painting, packing, supply, transportation and delivery at site and performance guarantee of valves.
2. The performance guarantee parameters shall cover proper design as well as the functions.
3. 'YES" = Technically accepted, listed in approved make list and will be considered for further processing
4. "NO" = Have not quoted or Technically not accepted or not listed in approved make list and will not be considered for further processing
5. Technical offer received from Sakhi Engineers Pvt. Ltd is inline with our technical requiremnt but Sakhi Engineers Pvt. Ltd not listed in approved make list for supply of CS Gate/Globe Valve for Compressed Air Service.
6. NSSL Limited formerly known as Neco Schubert & Salzer Limited. As per GTS NECO listed in approved make list.
7. For detail specification refer attached data sheet.

Offer Reference :
1. Fouress Engineering (I) Limited : Offer Ref No : VIZ85619/2016-17/SNB, 22.11.2016
2. Kalpana Valves Mfg. Co. Pvt. Ltd : Offer Ref No : KVL/TPL/Q/2016-2017/1113, 07.12.2016; Confirmation received vide email dtd. 08.12.2016
3. NSSL Limited : Offer Ref No : NSSL/KOL/Q- 4042/320/16-17, 07.12.2016. Confirmation received vide email dtd. 08.12.2016
4. Sakhi Engineers Pvt. Ltd : Offer Ref No : Sales/LTB/LG/Dec/Qtn-309, 07.12.2016
5. Weir BDK Valves : Offer Ref No : ENQD-20161123-84675, 23.11.2016

Attachment :
1. Offer & Confirmation email received from Bidders.
2. Gate & Globe valve technical data sheet.
3. Approved Make List

TER - GATE & GLOBE Page 1 of 1