Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
______________________________________
A Mini-Research Presented To
DR. ALFREDO M. DIMAANO, DBM
Faculty of the Decision Sciences and Innovation
College of Business
De La Salle University Manila
______________________________________
______________________________________
By
Acknowledgment
Statistics and for his guidance in writing this mini-research. I would also like to thank him
for inspiring our class through his lectures and his sharing of experiences from which we
Abstract
Employee loyalty has been an important factor in maintaining a successful
business, as human capital is still an important asset of any organization. . Reichheld
(2001) defined loyalty as ‘’the willingness to make and investment or personal sacrifice to
strengthen a relationship.’’ This study focuses on the surveying the employee loyalty of
sampled participants from MediaQuest Holdings Incorporated. The organizational loyalty
indicators used in the study were based on Kuhmar and Shekhar’s (2012) criteria for high
employee loyalty which includes: willingness to stay in the organization, productivity,
altruistic beahviour and reciprocal loyalty from the organization. MediaQuest is the media
arm conglomerate of PLDT. MQ owns PLDT’s digital cable provider (Cignal),
broadcasting companies (TV5, Unitel and the National Broadcasting Company), as well
as the shares and ownership of its newspaper enterprises (Philippine Star and the
Inquirer).
The study sampled 60 of MQ’s employees, with the primary goal of measuring (1)
organizational loyalty of the employees and (2) identifying whether there is any significant
relationship between age and organizational loyalty of its employees. Data analysis tools
that were used were descriptive statistical tools such as mean and standard deviation
measurement for organizational loyalty level, analysis of variance (ANOVA) and t-tests
for analysis of the significance of difference between organizational loyalty with respect
to the profile variables used in the survey instrument and a measure of relationship such
as Pearson Product-Moment Correlation in measuring the relationship of age and
organizational loyalty. Results of the study shows, that MediaQuest employees have a
high level of organizational loyalty, with the highest indicator being concerned with the
employees being productive and having altruistic behavior. The indicator with the lowest
mean organizational loyalty was concerned with the employees’ involvement in the
decision making and objective setting of the organization.
With the result of the measurement of the organizational loyalty of the employees,
MediaQuest can still improve on the given indicators of high employee loyalty. The
research also recommends the organization to increase involvement of rank-and-file
employees in the decision making and objective setting of the company. Also with age
having a significant relationship with organizational loyalty, the organization may use this
as a variable for future hiring and retaining of employees.
4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A. Title Page
B. Acknowledgment
C. Executive Summary
1. Introduction
1.1 Company Profile
1.2 Theoretical Framework
1.3 Statement of the Problem
1.4 Hypothesis
1.5 Significance of the Study
1.6 Scope and Limitations
2. Method
2.1 Research Design
2.2 Instrument
2.3 Data Gathering Procedure and Participants
2.4 Statistical Treatment
3. Results and Discussion
3.1 Tabular and/or Graphical Presentations
4. Conclusions
5. Recommendations
6. References
7. Attachments
5
1. INTRODUCTION
Having loyal clients are vital to the success of a successful business, but loyal employees
are equally important. It takes human capital to generate other capitals required by the
organization. While a machine may eliminate the need to have hundreds of production
workers to do manual labor, it still takes human capital to design and build the machine.
knowledge and high-level skills, human capital will become increasingly important.
How an employee perceives their organization drives employee commitment to the job
as well as to the company. Reichheld (2001) defined loyalty as ‘’the willingness to make
and business ethicists have done studies on employee work ethics, the concept of
McCusker and Wolfman (2002) surveyed on how employee loyalty is defined among HR
on women who worked in either Massachusetts or California, 60% having children, with
a median annual salary of $50,000 to $100,000. Loyalty was described by the researchers
as ‘’a devotion to the company, and a positive representation of the company to the
greater community. The ability of people to look at what's best for the organization and
sometimes put the company ahead of personal, family and other considerations.’’ The
respondents had a similar definition, which includes loyalty as being willing to stay through
6
good and bad times, internalizing company goals as personal goals, and giving extra time,
the 1990s by PLDT through its Beneficial Trust Fund, a retirement fund agency. Today,
Envisaging Employee Loyalty, perceptions that indicate high employee loyalty are as
follows:
that exceeds normal expectations, i.e., goes beyond the call of duty (Mowday, Porter and
Steers, 1982), c) Altruistic behavior (Laabs,1996) and d) Reciprocal, i.e., the employee’s
loyalty to the organization must be matched by the organization’s loyalty to the employee
(Solomon,1992).’’
7
Organizational Loyalty
organization
b) productivity
c) altruistic behaviour
d) reciprocal loyalty
that reciprocal loyalty and willingness to stay in the organization can be affected by the
following factors: (a) providing an emphasis on strong and committed leadership that is
augmented with clear communication strategies, (b) providing a safe and secure
environment; (c) providing tangible rewards that incorporate compensation and benefits
and providing intangible rewards such as recognition; (d) providing personal growth along
with a strategy for organizational growth; (e) providing an environment where there is
support from managers and coworkers to help balance the workforces' personal and work
lives. According to Maxham et. al (2008), both consumer satisfaction and loyalty are
related in the study that productivity is also a factor for employee satisfaction and loyalty
being human resource factors in the workplace. Altruistic behavior was defined by Laabs
8
(1996) as ‘’behaviour beyond call of duty’’ wherein an employee would go out of his or
her way to accomplish any tasks given by the organization despite obstacles.
This study aimed to assess the level of Organizational Loyalty (OL) among the
following inquiries:
1.1 gender;
1.2 age;
participants?
to the level of organizational loyalty of Media Quest employees with respect to the
profile variables?
9
MediaQuest employees?
1.4 Hypotheses
At 0.05 level of significance and 95% confidence limit, the following hypotheses
were tested:
MediaQuest employees.
The study was conducted to determine the organizational loyalty of Media Quest
employees in order to provide an assessment whether the employees are loyal to the
organization, using the indicators of the level of organizational loyalty mentioned in the
Specifically, the findings of this study will be addressed to the following groups and
individuals:
organizational loyalty among employees can aid the management in measuring whether
employee involvement is sufficient to maintain loyalty to the organization. This can also
help determine which indicators would aid in identifying which of the employees have the
highest tendency to stay, therefore reassuring that the company investments, such as
trainings and seminars, on the employee would benefit the organization. Variables
included such as age, salary, religion, civil status and length of service would also help
Employees. Awareness of one’s loyalty to the organization may help the employee
identify what are expected of him or her as a member of the organization. This can also
help the employee on deciding whether he or she is truly satisfied their current
Researchers. This research can provide other researchers the idea to come up
with other applications of the organizational loyalty indicators provided in the study in
Media Related Companies. Since the MQ is media company, the research can be
and Shekhar (2012) on measuring the employee variables, and will only factor in the
variables stated in the study such as reciprocal loyalty, altruism, productivity and
willingness to stay in the organization. The study would only be limited to employees of
2. METHOD
study. It discusses the rationale on the use of the research design, the conditions for
sample selection, reliability and validity of the instruments, the data gathering procedure,
and the basis for employing the different statistical techniques in the treatment of the data.
the level of OL and with respect to each of the profile variables. Descriptive research
design was used to obtain information concerning the current status of the phenomena
and to describe "what exists" with respect to variables or conditions in a situation. In the
context of the study, the research aims to describe the current status of organizational
loyalty among MediaQuest employees as well as the significance of the profile variables
using the OL indicators found in the literature. The OL indicators were based from Kuhmar
12
and Shekhar’s (2012) study on employee loyalty which includes: Willingness to Stay in
2.2 Instrument
The instrument used in the study was a two-part questionnaire, substantiated by the
which uses the OL indicators of the study. The instrument used in the study was a
The participants of the study were a sample of MediaQuest employees. The list of
names that were used in creating the sample of respondents was based on a randomly
generated list using the profiling software by the Human Resources Department of
MediaQuest. After the sample list was processed, the researcher proceeded to
13
administering the survey among the participants. The questionnaires were retrieved and
The data gathered from the respondents were analyzed using the following
statistical tools:
Frequency Count and Percentage Distribution (f and %). These statistical tools were
Mean and Standard Deviation (M and SD). These statistical device were used to
T-Test and Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). These statistical instruments were applied
the level of OL when they are grouped according to the profile variables.
14
association (MRA) tool was used to determine whether there exist a significant
This section presents the results of the study, provides in-depth analysis
and interpretation of data, and discusses the implications of the findings to quality
development goals in particular. The flow of the presentation and discussion of the data
follows the sequence of the research objectives postulated in the Statement of the
Problem.
Below is Table 1, containing the profile of the participants of the study distributed
according to the demographic variables included in the study. As seen in Table 1.1
Gender, majority of respondents were female (55%) while there were only 27 male
participants (45%).
39 - 45 1 0.02 2
46 - 52 1 0.02 2
Total: 60 1.00 100
The respondents were equally distributed in terms of civil status with 50% either
being married or single. Most participants were between the age of 26 – 30 yrs. old (38%),
with the majority earning P20,000 - P24,999 as monthly salary. In terms of religious
The respondents mostly consisted of Bachelor’s degree holders (67%) with only
13 (21%) respondents with graduate studies units and 7 (12%) without any college
degree, validating the notion of the importance of having a college degree in the
Being a fairly new company at the time of data collection, most of the employees
surveyed have only been in the organization 5 years or less (72%), with the majority of
Standard Verbal
Level of Organizational Loyalty Indicators Mean Deviation Interpretation
1. I feel a strong personal attachment to this
organization. 3.27 0.48 SA
2. I am proud to work for this institution. 3.25 0.47 SA
3. I would recommend this organization to potential
clients. 3.28 0.49 SA
4. I would recommend this organization to my friends
as a place to work. 3.18 0.50 A
5. I plan to work in this organization for many more
years. 3.22 0.56 A
6. There are many positions I could consider in the
local job market. 3.23 0.46 A
7. I prefer this organization than others because of
what it stands for, that is, its mission, values and
beliefs. 3.23 0.50 A
8. I appreciate the organizational leadership fostered
in this institution because it empowers other people
in organization to make and carry out decisions. 3.22 0.49 A
9. I would go above and beyond what is normally
expected to solve a problem. 3.27 0.45 SA
10. I’m always focused on what needs to be done and
not just what I’ve been assigned. 3.32 0.47 SA
11. I am willing to change on how I perform my job if
this will help this organization. 3.42 0.50 SA
12. When confronted with a problem or obstacle at
work, my response is “there’s got to be a way.” 3.42 0.50 SA
13. I feel my employer cares to develop me for the
long term, not just the current job. 3.25 0.51 SA
14. This organization gives me the freedom to make
my own decisions at work. 3.27 0.48 SA
15. I am sure that employees get the resources they
need to help them do their work well. 3.28 0.49 SA
19
Verbal Interpretations
Parameters: (VI) Qualitative Descriptors
3.25 - 4.00 Strongly Agree (SA) Very High
2.50 - 3.24 Agree (A) High
1.75 - 2.49 Disagree (D) Low
1.00 - 1.74 Strongly Disagree (SDA) Very Low
Examining the results of the given indicators and the mean of OL level,
MediaQuest employees have a high level of organizational loyalty which also means that
there is still room for improvement. It can be noticed that items 11 and 12, ‘’ I am willing
to change on how I perform my job if this will help this organization’’ and ‘’When
had the highest mean of 3.42 and a standard deviation of 0.5. This indicates that
MediaQuest employees exemplify productivity and altruistic behavior (Laabs, 1996). The
lowest indicator on the other hand, was item number 25 which asks the involvement of
the employee in the decision making and establishing of work objectives with the mean
of 2.88. This result can be attributed due to the work designation of the participants. 62%
of the sample consisted of rank and file employees who are not usually engaged in this
manner by large scale organizations since decision making and objective setting are
decided by those several tiers higher than rank and file employees and communicating
can be inefficient.
21
Based on the calculations of the T-tests and ANOVAs, none of the profile variables
employees. Despite the difference in the means of organizational loyalty level of the
grouped variables, the differences cannot be attributed to the grouped variable measured.
For example, even if there is a difference in the mean level of organizational loyalty
between males and females, it does not dictate whether males will always be more loyal
than females or vice versa. It can be interpreted that other variables than the ones used
relationship with organizational loyalty. Based on the graph, age and organizational
loyalty has a positive correlation which indicates that as age increases, organizational
loyalty increases. With this result it can be concluded that as employment opportunities
lessens for an aging employee, the more loyal he or she is with the organization he
belongs to. Roehling (2001) also supports this result wherein employees from 35 and
above have higher tendencies to stay and be loyal with organization they are with.
Maturity can also be a factor for this correlation as it can be an attribute that affects an
too idealistic with their expectations of workplace culture or their expected reciprocal
loyalty.
4. CONLCLUSIONS
According to the survey, the participant MediaQuest employees have a high level of
organizational loyalty. The researcher also concludes, based on the results of the data
MediaQuest employees and the profile variables that were used in the study. There is,
and their organizational loyalty which means that as the age of the employee increases,
5. RECOMMENDATIONS
MediaQuest can still improve in terms of organizational loyalty of It employees and may
use the theoretical framework of the study as a criteria on which factors can still be
Based on the findings, the researcher recommends exploring other possible profile
variables that can be used to acquire a significant difference with organizational loyalty.
It is also recommended that the organization should improve the involvement of rank-
and-file employees with the decision making and objective setting of the organization to
increase organizational loyalty. Due to the positive correlation of the age of employees
with organizational loyalty, the organization is also recommended to use age as a criterion
6. REFERENCES:
http://search.proquest.com/docview/304908391?accountid=28547. (304908391).
Kumar, D. S., & Shekhar, N. (2012). Perspectives Envisaging Employee Loyalty. Journal
132-142. doi:10.5465/AMR.1983.4287722
Reichheld, Frederick (2001), The Loyalty Effect: The Hidden Force Behind Growth,
Reichheld, F. F. (1996), The Loyalty Effect, Harvard Business School Press, Boston,
Massachusetts.
Roehling, P., Roehling M. and Moen, P. (2001) The Relationship Between Work-Life
Policies and Practices and Employee Loyalty:A Life Course Perspective. Journal of
Family and Economic Issues June 2001, Volume 22, Issue 2, pp 141-170
27