Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
TO
SUBMITTED BY:
BBC PROFESSIONALS
[CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS]
CHRISTIAN AID (UK) NIGERIA
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL
FOR APPOINTMENT AS EXTERNAL AUDITORS
CONTENTS PAGE
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 1
1.0 EXPERTISE OF OUR FIRM
We also make bold to say that one of our own that trained and qualified in BBC Professionals,
Mr. Chidi Ajaegbu is the current Golden Jubilee President of the Institute, a rare privilege that
we cherish and which adds credence to our corporate existence.
Change of Name
In order to reposition the firm for better services to her prospective and numerous clients and
improve its brand name, the firm changed her name in October 2012 from Balogun Badejo & Co
to BBC PROFESSIONALS. As a result of the change, note that some of the documents that will be
included in this proposal had the old name.
International Affiliation
We are affiliated with PrimeGlobal which is a global network of accounting and consulting
firms with offices in over ninety (90) countries located in all the continents of the world. The
essence of all these is that we have expertise both locally and internationally to meet the
demands of our profession.
Our international office in MIAMI, FLORIDA (USA) together with any of PrimeGlobal offices in
the world are available to join us in carrying out any exercise should their services be required.
The World Headquarters of PrimeGlobal is located at:
9200 South Dadeland Boulevard
Suite 510 Miami
Florida 33156
USA
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 2
Status of BBC PROFESSIONALS
Our firm is a Partnership Business Registered with Nigeria Corporate Affairs Commission with
Business Registration No. BN133294. Currently, we have four (4) Partners in full time Practice.
Previously we had seven (7) Partners but two (2) retired on 31 March, 2012 while one (1)
retired on 31 March, 2013 after attaining the retirement age as contained in the Partnership
Agreement of the firm. Though they are retired, they are still available incase we require their
services.
The Firm presently has four (4) full time Partners as shown below:
3 4
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 3
Registration with Relevant Authorities
Our firm is registered with the following authorities amongst others:
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN)
Public Practice Section of ICAN (PPS)
Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC)
Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC)
Office of the Auditor-General of the Federation (AGF)
Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation (AGF)
Some Offices of the Auditor-General of the States
Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria (CITN)
Bureau of Public Enterprises (BPE)
Financial Reporting Council Of Nigeria (FRCN) - Partners
Partners
(Technical) (Non-Technical)
Managers Managers
Supervisors Supervisors
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 4
Our Most Valuable Asset
Our most valuable asset is Human Capital. We have no doubt of our ability to carryout the
proposed assignment based on the calibre of our Human Resources and experiences of over four
(4) decades.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 5
1.2 Audit improvement and value added in other clients
One of the advantages we have is that we have experienced personnel with varied local and
international experiences and qualifications. The capabilities and facilities we have that are
necessary for the audit and future assignments amongst others include:
The above has impacted on our daily jobs which led to improvements and added value to our
clients. Such improvements and value additions to our clients includes but are not limited to:
Carrying out review of internal control and compliance for appropriateness of procedures or
otherwise.
Review of operational manuals, processes and procedures generally.
Detection of lapses and loopholes.
Advising clients on improvements and measures necessary to strengthen internal controls
and safeguard the assets of the entity.
Better protection for systems, information, ICT Hard wares and integrity of data.
Review of systems flows for efficiency and better performance.
Detection and correction of errors in book keeping, posting and financial statements.
Improvements in the way and manner of clients dealings with regulatory authorities and
statutory matters.
Shorter time for audit completion and more credible financial statements.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 6
1.3 Our offer to Christian Aids
Our firm’s foundation for a quality financial statements audit is our firm’s system of
quality control. Our firm’s leadership is critical in setting the proper “tone at the top,”
conveying through words and actions that quality work is of paramount importance.
Our firm’s system of quality control consists of all the activities undertaken by us to
promote audit quality and includes, for example:
We the above standards, Christian Aid stands to benefit from some of the improvements and
value addition to clients as listed in 1.2 above.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 7
2.0 OUR OFFICES AND CONTACT
INFORMATION
Offices in Nigeria
Our firm has offices in the following locations in Nigeria:
Abuja Ibadan
Akure Kaduna
Benin City LAGOS - Headquarters
Our geographical spread and experiences affords us the advantage to handle the
assignment coupled with the ability of some of our staff to speak the popular local
languages such as Hausa, Igbo and Yoruba.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 8
3.0 PROPOSED METHODOLOGY AND
APPROACH
Christian Aid (UK), Nigeria invited Proposals for the provision of external audit services for
the Country Programme for the 2014/2015 financial year.
Background
Christian Aid is a Christian organisation that insists the world can and must be swiftly
changed to one where everyone can live a full life, free from poverty.
The Organisation work globally for profound change that eradicates the causes of poverty,
striving to achieve equality, dignity and freedom for all, regardless of faith or nationality.
Christian Aid is also part of a wider movement for social justice and Provide urgent, practical
and effective assistance where need is great, tackling the effects of poverty as well as its root
causes.
Vision
Poverty is an outrage against humanity. It robs people of dignity, freedom and hope, of power
over their own lives. Christian Aid has a vision - an end to poverty - and believe that vision
can become a reality.
Essential purpose
To expose the scandal of poverty
To help in practical ways to root it out from the world
To challenge and change structures and systems that favour the rich and powerful
over the poor and marginalised.
Mandate
As an agency of churches in Britain and Ireland, she has the mandated to work on relief,
development and advocacy for poverty eradication. Christian Aid’s work is founded on
Christian faith, inspired by hope and acts to change an unjust world through charity – a
practical love and care for neighbours.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 9
Need for audit of financial statements
The need for stewardship, accountability, compliance with the statutory provisions and good
corporate governance of any organization has made the audit of its financial statements very
necessary. Hence the statutory audit has become a credible process by which professional
accountants look at what has transpired in an organization within a specified period and issue an
audit opinion as to the true and fair view of the entity’s financial statements.
There is also the need for the audit exercises to be conducted timely within an agreed period
and/or at regular intervals or else, it will not be useful in serving the intended purpose. In doing
this, the confidence of the stakeholders in the programmes and projects of the Organisation will
be greatly enhanced.
As in many parts of the world, the activities of Donor Agencies have touched millions of lives
particularly the poor; hence their contribution to the building and development of Nations
cannot be overemphasized.
In line with the above, our firm – BBC PROFESSIONALS [Chartered Accountants] hereby forward
its application to be considered for appointment as external auditors to Christian Aid (UK),
Nigeria. Having been in existence for over forty five (45) years in rendering similar services to
numerous clients, we want to be part of Organisation’s Project of Transformation, Transparency
and Accountability.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 10
3.2 Relevant experiences
We have relevant cognate experience and a strong record of value-added service to our
esteemed clients which we have been doing for over four (4) decades of our existence. Some of
the Audit & Assurance Work that we carried out or currently engaged in which are similar
to the proposed assignment are as stated below:
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 11
OTHER ASSIGNMENTS
Some Other assignments carried out by the firm in recent past are
listed below:
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 12
3.3 Description of the methodology and workplan for
performing the assignment
Summary of stages:
In summary, our job when appointed as external auditor by Christian Aid is as illustrated below:
Engagement activities
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 13
Preliminaries:
Upon our appointment as External Auditors, we shall carry out the following:
Consequently, we shall obtain necessary background information and documentation for the
purpose of the audit.
Such background information and documentation shall include but not limited to:
1. The Organisation’s Profile which will contain amongst others: History, Establishment,
Head Office, Other Offices, Board, Programme/Project officials, Top Management Staff, etc
2. Names and addresses of Former Auditors, Legal Advisers, Secretary and other
professional Advisers
3. Donor Agreements, MOU’s, Project Documents amongst others
4. List of Approved Projects/programmes
5. Obtain financial regulations, rules, policies and procedures that apply to the specific
Programmes and projects
6. Audited Financial Statements for the last three years
7. Management control report for the last three years
8. List of Bankers, Name of Account, Account Numbers and addresses of where the accounts
are maintained
9. Trial balance for the financial year (for audit purpose)
10. Management accounts
11. Systems process flow chart
12. Cash books (for all banks, cash and petty cash)
13. Bank reconciliation statements files for all the banks, cash and petty cash
14. Bank statements for the first quarter of the next financial year
15. Authorisation limit for cheques, purchases, contracts etc
16. imen signatures of Authorising officers and signatories to the banks.
17. Schedule of Fixed assets (including additions, on-going projects, re-classifications,
revaluations & disposals)
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 14
Preliminaries (Cont’d):
The above are expected to be obtained before or during the commencement of the assignment
after which such information will be discussed with the personnel to be engaged in the
assignment in order to:
acquaint professional staff with the background information;
brief the personnel on the core functions;
be well informed on the strategy to be adopted to ensure that the audit objectives and
timetable are borne in mind while carrying out the audit assignment
design appropriate audit Programme;
brief the team members as to the requirements, timing and explanation of work
programme; and
ensure that the audit is carried out efficiently and effectively in accordance with all
relevant local, regional and international standards on auditing.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 15
Work Plan and methodology
General procedures
We shall carry out pre-audit meeting/visits in order to clearly understand the
organizational structure in place, the relationship with Donors, implementing agencies,
other Foreign and Local Establishments. This will enable us to know the structure in place
and plan our staff strength and mix for the audit field work.
The preliminary discussions will enable us to design appropriate audit programme which
will be used by each Project Teams. In effect, Audit Programme and other procedures
designed for the assignment would be shared amongst the team members as
worksheet to be guided by the Engagement Partner with a view to ascertaining:
the existence of internal control systems;
adequacy and reliability of internal control system;
whether the Organisation has internal audit in place, their effectiveness and extent of
reliance to be placed on its work;
the main source of revenue or donation;
other sources of income available;
expenditures made and expenses pattern at the Head and branch offices;
recording, presentation and disclosure of transactions in the financial statements;
that incomes and expenditure have been treated accordingly and also with a view to
identifying:
i) adequacy of accounting and internal control system;
ii) whether all incomes recorded were properly treated in the financial
statements;
iii) adequate monitoring of expenditure and their validity;
iv) that expenditure are eligible and duly authorised; and
v) any ineligible expenditure and in-adequacies in record keeping for inclusion in
our management control report.
We shall carryout third party confirmation as part of our audit evidence which shall
support our audit opinion. Using the addresses collected from the Christian Aid, we shall:
write the Legal Advisers with a view to obtaining first hand information on litigations
involving the Organisation. This will assist us in knowing the extent of exposure to
other parties and also enable us to indicate same in the contingent liabilities as note
to the audited financial statements;
send circularization letters to all Bankers to confirm the account balances as at the
end of the year or period as the case may be;
circularize the Debtors at the year/period end in order to obtain evidences to
corroborate the records and this will form part of our audit evidences;
also circularize Creditors for the same purpose of obtaining audit evidences to
support our opinion.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 16
PROCESS OVERVIEW AND QUALITY ASSURANCE
Process overview and quality assurance obtainable in BBC is better experienced than
explained. Our process starts by planning the audit assignment. The plan sets out clearly
what Audit objectives we intend to achieve and at what time frame.
1. PRE-COMMENCEMENT
4. POST ASSIGNMENT - Briefings from the Supervising
-Reports & recommendations to Mgt. Partner
-Discussion of issues raised during the - Completion of Ethics and
assignment Independence documentations
-Identification of key officers that has - Review of Business environment
responsibility for mitigating risks that Client operates
-Follow up of issues raised and -Assessment of likely Market and
progress made to improve the Mgt business risks
Processes
2. FIELD WORK
3. HOME OFFICE -Review of Client Systems, Processes
-Work done by staff passed to the and Procedures
Supervisor for review -Review of Business and market risks
-Manager and Engagement Partner -Evaluation of the impact of
shall review the Files and Reports Transactions with related parties and
-Files and Reports shall be passed to others
the quality control department for -Review of Going-concern
final review assumptions made by Mgt
Although the Supervising Partner will be in-charge of the audit, we have a quality assurance
department headed by a Senior Partner, where all plans and jobs go through to ensure
completeness, accuracy and compliance with the relevant local and international standards,
laws and regulations.
In effect, our reports and other deliverables shall pass through the department before we
issue the draft reports to the Client.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 17
Final reports
Having carried out the audit field work and various stages of review, we shall issue the draft
financial statements and management control report alongside with outstanding issues (if
any). The management control report shall contain details of our review, issues observed,
consequences of lapses and recommendations.
We shall hold further meetings with the top management, finance committee (if applicable)
and Organization members to discuss the draft financial statements and management control
report.
After necessary consideration and approvals of the financial reports by all concerned, we shall
issue the final audited financial statements and management control report to the
Organization.
Conclusion
We recognize that all methodologies to be adopted in carrying out the audit may not have
been spelt out fully in this expression of interest while other approaches and methodology
will be contingent on-the-job and situations that may arise during the work.
The above is therefore the summary of what we intend to do if appointed by the Christian Aid
(UK) Nigeria to audit the financial statements for the 2014/2015 financial year.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 18
2.4 Details of other clients and references
Name of Client Contract Types of activities Date Contact Details
project Value undertaken Completed (Name, Phone,
N’000 Email)
2013 Audit of Federal Ministry of 9,300 - Audit of Principal and September, Mr. Eric Aramide
Nat. Malaria Health - National sub-recipient accounts 2014 +2348062386295
Elimination Malaria Elimination - Review of internal aramide.eric@gm
Prog. Global Programme control systems ail.com
Fund Grant - Follow up of prior
year issues
2014 audit of Honeywell Flour Mills 20,000 - Audit of financial June, 2014 Mr. Ibukun Ojo
financial Plc, Lagos statements +2348022232605
statements - System reviews iojo@honeywellfl
- Internal Control our.com
review
2013 audit of United Nations 10, 600 - Audit of Project CDR April, 2014 Mr. Hassan Jallow
UNDP Nigeria Development - Review of internal +2348039795127
NIM/NGO Programme control systems hassan.jallow@un
2013 - Follow up of prior dp.org
year issues
2011 Audit of National Agency for 5,000 - Audit of Principal and June, 2012 Mr. N Ebong
Gobal Fund the Control of AIDS sub-recipient accounts +2348065588252
Grant (NACA) - Review of internal info@naca.gov.ng
control systems
- Follow up of prior
year issues
2011 audit & Pipelines and Products 21,000 - Audit of financial July, 2012 Mrs. Rose Ogbole
Taxation Marketing Company statements +2348033732102
services Limited - Internal Control Roseline.ogbole@
review nnpcgroup.com
- Tax computations
-Filing of accounts with
Tax authority
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 19
4.0 MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE AND KEY
PERSONNEL
Our understanding of the project is that the audit will be carried out in Abuja Nigeria. The
Structure for management which shows the designation of proposed project personnel in the
firm and intended position during the project execution is as shown below:
The Proposed Project Team was chosen considering the Client, Nature of Job, Timing,
Deliverables expected and most importantly, the experience, exposure and calibre of Personnel.
We are confident that the Staff mix is adequate for the project and if there is need to deploy
additional personnel, we shall act accordingly.
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 20
4.3 CURRICULUM VITEA OF KEY STAFF
Education:
School Date Qualification
University of Benin, Benin City 1999 – 2001 MBA (Business Administration)
St. Paul Grammar School, Ebu 1982 – 1987 WAEC/GCE O’Level
Professional qualifications:
Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN) - FCA
Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria (CITN) - FCTI
Employment Record:
Company Period Position
BBC Professionals 1 April 2013 – date Managing Partner
BBC Professionals 1 April ‘12 to 31 March,‘13 Deputy Managing Partner
BBC Professionals 2005 to 31 March, 2012 Partner
BBC Professionals 2001 to 2004 Audit Manager
BBC Professionals 1997 to 2001 Audit Senior
BBC Professionals 1986 to 1997 Audit Trainee
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 21
4.3 CURRICULUM VITEA OF KEY STAFF
Engagement Partner
Proposed Position:
BBC PROFESSIONALS
Name of Firm:
Everestus Uche ITODO
Name of Staff:
Accountancy/Auditing
Profession:
15 December, 1973
Date of Birth:
Education:
School Date Qualification
University of Lagos, Akoka 2011 M.Sc. (Management)
Oxford Brookes University, Oxford, UK 2009 B.Sc. Applied Accounting
Skolak Resources Information Tech. Centre 1999 Cert. Data Processing
St. Theresa’s College, Nsukka 1992 Senior Sec. School Cert.
Ifrouka Primary School, Amalla 1986 First School Leaving Cert.
Professional qualifications:
Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN) - FCA
Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria (CITN) - ACTI
Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA), UK - ACCA
Employment Record:
Company Period Position
BBC Professionals 1 April ‘13 – date Deputy Managing Partner
BBC Professionals April ‘09 to 31 Mar, ‘13 Partner
BBC Professionals 2006 to 2009 Manager, Supervisor,
Audit Senior
Mu’allahyidi & Co, Kaduna 2003 to 2006 Assist. Audit Mgr, Senior
Supertex Limited, Kaduna 1995 to 2003 Shift Section Controller
Union Adhesive & Chem. Co Ltd. 1993 to 1995 Administrative Clerk
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 22
4.3 CURRICULUM VITEA OF KEY STAFF
Manager
Proposed Position:
BBC PROFESSIONALS
Name of Firm:
Education:
School Date Qualification
Professional qualification:
Employment Record:
Company Period Position
BBC Professionals 2011 to date Audit Manager
Balogun Badejo & Co 2007 to 2009 Supervisor, Senior
O A Adefeso & Co 2006 to 2007 Audit Senior
Abioye Abdul Razaq & Co 2004 to 2006 Trainee
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 23
4.3 CURRICULUM VITEA OF KEY STAFF
Education:
School Date Qualification
Federal Cooperative College Kaduna. 2011 HND
Government Technical College Nsukka 1999 WAEC & NABTEB
Community Primary School Nguru Nsukka 1993 FSLC
Professional qualification:
Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN) - ACA
Employment Record:
Company Period Position
BBC Professionals 2013 to date Audit Senior
Mhoa & Co Chartered Accountants 2011 – 2013 Audit Supervisor
Maaji & Co Chartered Accountants 2010 Audit Trainee
Denod Investment Company 2002-2009 Account Clerk
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 24
5.0 DOCUMENTS ATTACHED
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 25
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 26
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 27
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 28
The Finance Manager
Christian Aid (UK), Nigeria
No 8 Audu Ogbeh Street
Jabi
Abuja
“Expression of Interest”
“EXPRESSION OF INTEREST”
Technical Proposal for Appointment as External Auditors to Christian Aid – By BBC PROFESSIONALS Page 29