Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Plaintiff, )
vs. ) Division
) KS.A Chapter 60
ERIC MUATHE, )
Defendant, )
COMES NOW, the Defendant, Eric M. Muathe, as himself and Pro-Se who files this
1. It has come to Defendant's attention that since January 25th, 2018 Plaintiff has filed
several pleadings with this court WITHOUT ANY SUCH PLEADINGS/FILINGS BEING
MAILED TO DEFENDANT.
2. Defendant just became aware of the filing of these pleadings, around June 12th,
2018, when a case summary docket print out of this case was attached to a pleading
Page 10f7
in a currently pending federal court case styled Eric Muathe vs. Wells Fargo Bank
3. The said docket printout - labeled "Exhibit B" - is attached to this motion. Defendant
is not aware if any other pleadings have been filed by the Plaintiff, or the Court,
since the June 1st, 2018 date of the above mentioned docket print out.
4. Since January 25th, 2018 it appears that the Plaintiffs counsel have filed the
following pleadings: [April 20th, 2018] Motion to Amend Scheduling Order, [April
27th, 2018] Proposed Second Amended Scheduling Order, [May 1st, 2018] Proposed
Motion For Summary Judgment on Muathe's Counterclaim, and [May 31st, 2018]
7. Defendant requests this court to strike all pleadings filed by Plaintiff, and Plaintiffs
attorneys, since January 25th, 2018 and bar the Plaintiff from refilling the same.
8. This is not the first time that pleadings have not been sent to Defendant.
Attorney Matthew Hubbard similarly had not been mailing hard copy Pleadings to
Defendant as per his certificate of services. Attorney Matthew Hubbard does not
dispute this fact. The difference being that attorney Matthew Hubbard had sent
Defendant a copy of his court fillings via email but neglected to send hard copies as
Page 2 of7
9. Here no service of filed pleadings of any kind have been sent to Defendant since
Service and filing of pleadings and other papers. (a) Service; when required.
(1) In general. Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, each of the
following papers must be served on every party:
(A) An order stating that service is required;
(B) a pleading filed after the original petition, unless the court orders
otherwise under subsection (c) because there are numerous defendants;
(C) a discovery paper required to be served on a party, unless the court
orders otherwise;
(D) a written motion, except one that may be heard ex parte; and
(E) a written notice, appearance, demand, offer of judgment or any similar
paper.
Service; how made [] (2) Service in general. A paper is served under this
section by 0 (C) mailing it to the person's last known address, in which event
service is complete upon mailing;
13. Defendant's mailing address has not changed. Even though Defendant would prefer
14. In sum, Defendant has a statutory right to receive a copy of the motions/pleadings
Plaintiff filed. This also incorporates the basic constitutional due process
argument on any pleading prior to a judge ruling on it. Failure of Plaintiff to serve
copies ofthe above mentioned pleadings since January 25th, 2018 violates
bad faith and subjects Defendant to losing his property and counterclaims without
Page 3 of7
the constitutional right of due process and with no opportunity to present his
15. Too many pleadings, stretching a period of many months, have not been sent to
Defendant and assuming the certificates of service stated that pleadings were sent
court.
16. Without being given notice, as per K.S.A60-205, Defendant would have no way of
knowing the up-to-date status of the pending case and that it causes substantial
17. The basic elements of procedural due process are notice and an opportunity to be
SRS, 274 Kan. 396,409,49 P.3d 1274, cert. denied 537 U.S. 1088 (2002)
18. The Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment prohibits the United States-as the
depriving any person of property without due process of law. U.S. Const. Amends. V,
XIV; see Dusenbery v. United States, 534 U.S. 161, 167 (2002).
19. As stated by the United States Supreme Court in Piper v. Pearson, 2 Gray 120, cited in
Bradley v. Fisher, 13 Wall. 335, 20 L.Ed. 646 (1872), '[w] here there is no jurisdiction,
20. Subject matter jurisdiction is vested by statute or constitution and establishes the
court's authority to hear and decide a particular type of action. Parties cannot confer
subject matter jurisdiction upon the courts by consent, waiver, or estoppel. Parties
cannot confer subject matter jurisdiction by failing to object to the court's lack of
Page 4 of7
jurisdiction. If a trial court determines that it lacks subject matter jurisdiction, it has
absolutely no authority to reach the merits of the case and is required as a matter of
law to dismiss it. Kingsley v. Kansas Dept. of Revenue, 288 Kan. 390, 395, 204 P.3d
562 (2009).
21. Defendant also believes that failure to follow K.S.A 60-205 violates the Kansas rules
22. This Court should consider sanctions on Plaintiffs attorneys since this practice of
failure to notice Defendant has been going on ever since Lathrop Gage LLP joined
the case.
23. It is apparent that severe sanctions are needed due to failure to serve defendant
even after Defendant filed attorney ethics complaints against Lathrop Gage LLP
attorneys where this failure to follow the certificate of service issue was brought up .
This is an abuse of the process and is calculated willful, bad faith, practice aimed at
winning the case without affording the opposing party an opportunity to respond.
Plaintiff requests oral arguments pursuant in part to Supreme Court Rule 133 (c) (1).
Supreme Court Rule 133(c)(1) (2017 Kan. S. Ct. R. 198) provides: "A party may
party."
Page 5 of7
WHEREFORE, Defendant Prays for an order striking ALL of Plaintiffs filings since
January 25th, 2018, and bar Plaintiff from refilling said pleadings, or for any other
Respectfully submitted,
BY:.bnC/~
Eric M. Muathe
1410 Bitner Terrace, Pittsburg, Kansas, 66762
(913) 980-7286 < muathedotcom@gmail.com >
Page 60f7
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that on June 13, 2018 the foregoing was mailed via PRIORITY mail- with
tracking - to the following address:
I certify that on June 13, 2018 the foregoing was mailed via first class mail to the
following address:
JEHAN K. MOORE,
C/O LATHROP GAGE LLP,
2345 GRAND BLVD., STE. 2200
KANSAS CITY, MO 64108-2618
BY:~
Eric M. Muathe
1410 Bitner Terrace, Pittsburg, Kansas, 66762
(913) 980-7286
muathedotcom@gmail.com
Page 70f7
Case 2:18-cv-02064-CM-TJJ Document 11-2 Filed 06/01118 Page 1 of 4
EXHIBITB
Case 2:18-cv-02064-CM-TJJ Document 11-2 Filed 06/01/18 Page 2 of 4
5131/2018 Case Summary
8 Show/Hide Participants
Plaintiff[s] Counsel of Record
Wilmington Trust Company Jehan Kamil Moore
1270 Northland Dr #200 2345 Grand Ave Suite 2200
Mendota Heights, MN 55120 Kansas City, MO 64108-2684
(816) 292-2000
Michael J Abrams
2345 Grand Blvd., Suite 2800
Kansas City, MO 64108-2684
(816) 292-2000
Citimortgage Inc
C/O The Corporation Company
https:lldistrictfiler.kscourts.org/notify/cmsFuIIHistory.html?pageAction=QueryCmsFuIIHist¬ifierCaselnfold=307157&caseNumber=2014-CV-000086-P&companyld=·
Case 2:18-cv-02064-CM-T JJ Document 11-2 Filed 06101/18 Page 3 of 4
5/31/2018 Case Summary
Number: 260402
12-09-2('-14 Designation of Lead CounselDocument ID Number: 261178
12-i1-2!Jl4 Plaintiffs Suggestions in Opposition To Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Petition Document ID Number: 261278
12-19-20t-l Defendants Reply in Support of Defendants Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Standing Document ID Number: 262228
02-D9-2015 Generated from document Case Mgmt Conf filed Feb 9, 2015
02-20-ZfJ15 Assignment Order-Hen. Janice RusseliDocument ID Number: 268657
02-23-2015 Letter From Elaine BradshawDocument ID Number: 268679
04-02-2015 Letter from Judge RusseliDocument ID Number: 273382
05-06-201.5 Motion For Disqualification of Judge Plus Request For Oral ArgumentsDocument ID Number: 277243
OS-U:5-2D1S Motion For Telephonic Hearing Document ID Number: 276733
OS--D8-2'}15 Objection to Hearing Document ID Number: 277678
05-08-2015 Notice of Filing of Motion of Disqualification Which is AttachedDocument ID Number: 277680
05-12-2015 Letter from Judge Wachter Document ID Number: 277842
05-i8-2015 Motion For Disqualification fo Judge Plus Affidavit in SupportDocument ID Number: 278982
05-26-2015 Letter From Judge Robert Fleming Document ID Number: 280019
06-01-1015 Assignment No. 14 (Ward Iimited)Document ID Number: 280790
OG-O:,-20l5 Order Granting Change of JudgeDocument lD Number: 281703
06-15-2015 Designation of Lead Counsel Document ID Number: 282546
06-1;;-2015 Assignment No 21 - Hon. Richard Smith Document ID Number: 282840
G7-B-1015 Notice Of HearingDocument ID Number: 285712
07-2+1015 Motion For Continuance Document lD Number: 287139
07-24·2015 Motion For Disqualification of Judge Plus Request for Oral ArgumentsDocument ID Number: 287140
07-2+201.5 Motion To Determine Jurisdiction Plus Request For Oral ArgumentsDocument lD Number: 287141
07-27-20(5 Order Denying Change of Judge And Granting Request For Continuance. Copies Mailed to all parties. Document ID Number: 287332
08-10-7.015 Motion For Disqualification of Judge Plus Affidavit in Support Document ID Number: 288949
H!-(lS-2015 Designation of Lead Counsel Document ID Number: 295032
1.2-11-2015 OrderDocument ID Number: 302145
12-23-2015 Assignment No. 15 (Creitz Iimited)Document lD Number: 303278
01-0<-2016 Certificate of Service Document lD Number: 303884
01-()---J(rt6 Order For Further Findings And Counterclaim Document ID Number: 303885
01-21-2uI6 Letter From Eric MuatheDocument ID Number: 305710
01-2.3-2016 Response to Requet For Clarification Document ID Number: 306073
01-21-2016 Letter Pursuant to KSA 60 237 Objecting Premature Discovery Document ID Number: 306510
OHJl-2;)16 Supplemental Motion For Disqualifiction Of Judge Richard Smith Document ID Number: 306970
02-16-2016 Defendants Motion to Stay Discovery Document ID Number: 308550
02~29-2016 Order Overruling Defendants Motion For Disqualification Document ID Number: 309806
02-2"-1016 Plaintiffs Memorandum In Opposition To Defendant Eric Muathe's Motion To Stay Discovery Document ID Number: 309807
04-05-2016 Notice Of HearingDocument ID Number: 313856
04-07-2016 Letter From Eric Muathe to Elaine BradshawDocument ID Number: 313928
0·1-07-2016 Motion For ContinuanceDocument ID Number: 313930
O~-07-2.G16 Letter From Eric Muathe to Elaine Bradshaw Document ID Number: 313932
04-07-101.6 Motion For ContinuanceDocument ID Number: 313933
04C11-20i6 Plaintiffs Response To Defendants Motion For ContinuanceDocument ID Number: 314232
O'H";·20.t6 Plaintiffs Response to Defendants Motion For Continuance Document ID Number: 315662
04-28-2016 Order on Pending Motion Document ID Number: 316128
05-06-201.6 Letter Requesting Clarification and Request For 30 Day Extension to File Answer and/or Counterc/aimDocument ID Number: 317492
05...10<i016 Clerks Fourteen Day Extention of Time To File An Answer and/or CounterdaimDocument ID Number: 317445
05-12-201.6 Letter From Eric Muathe Requesting "Answer/Counterclaim" To Be Filed In The Case FileDocument ID Number: 318084
05-12-20.!.6 Answer to Petition + Counterclaim Document ID Number: 318087
Order On Letter Requesting Clarificaton and Request for 30 day extension to Fife Answer/or CounterclaimDocument ID Number:
05-19-201()
318816
06-02.-2016 Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Eric Muathe's Answer/Counterclaim MOT: Motion (Generic)
06-02·2016 Memorandum in Support of Motion to Strike Answer and Counterclaim INF: Memorandum
(l6-14·1016 Notice of Hearing Motion to Strike NOT: Notice - No Service Required
06·22,-2OJ.6 Letter Dated June 21 2016 to Clerk of the CourtDocument ID Number: 323166
06·2]:-:1016 Response to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Defendants Answer/Counter Claim Document ID Number: 323168
06··27 '20").6 Letter Dated June 272016 To Clerk of the CourtDocumentID Number: 323170
06-27-2016 Amended Answer to Petition + Counterclaim Document ID Number: 323172
06-29-2DI6 Military Service Affidavit AFF: Affidavit (Generic)
06-3[)-2016 Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment MOT: Summary Judgment
07-07-2{1l6 Scheduling OrderDocument ID Number: 323998
07-i1-201.6 Letter Dated July 7th 2016 to Clerk of the CourtDocument lD Number: 324258
07·ll 20t6 Objection to Proposed Scheduling OrderDocument ID Number: 324259
https:lldistrictfiier.kscourts.org/notify/cmsFuIIHistory.html?pageAction=QueryCmsFuIIHist¬ifierCaselnfold=307157&caseNumber=2014-CV-000086-P&companyld='
Case 2:18-cv-02064-CM-T JJ Document 11-2 Filed 06/01/18 Page 4 of 4
5/3112018 Case Summary
https;lIdistrictfiler.kscourts.org/notify/cmsFuIiHistory.html?pageAction=QueryCmsFuIiHist¬ifierCaselnfold=307157&caseNumber=2014-CV-000086-P&companyld=-
6/12/2018 Gmail - Wilmington v. Muathe: WF rfa answers, WF rfp responses, WF irog answers pdf
I have been waiting for your discovery responses via regular mail over the last few days I have NOT yet received anything* via regular mail as per your November 11th,
2016 certificate of service.
I have to, and will, object that there is a disturbing pattern you have now established right from the beginning where your certificates of service say you mailed a
pleading but it never arrives via regular mail, or even worse in one instant it was mailed several days well after the date stated on the certificate of service.
This is improper!
I have been busy with two federal cases and two Kansas court appeals (one moving to the KSC soon) so would like to take a look at your discovery responses but they
have NOT arrived in the mail as per your certificate of service.
Could you send the discover pleadings since I haven't received them.
Eric Muathe
[Quoted text hidden]
"And therefore our contemplation of this source, as the power which we want, gives us the ability to use that power. And the way we use this process is to contemplate
ourselves as surrounded by the conditions which we want to produce." - Thomas Troward.
Namaste,
Eric Muathe
CEO / Founder
Encare Financial Inc.
http://www.muathe.com
6/12/2018 Gmail - Wilmington v. Muathe: WF rfa answers, WF rfp responses, WF irog answers pdf
~ ~
We are fed-exing you the hard copies of the discovery pleadings and documents for overnight delivery. We get used to emailing everything these days and
sometimes forget that you have requested hard copies. Let me know if you have any questions.
Thanks,
Matt