Argument Writing One Step Rubric

Advanced (91-100) Criteria (90-80) Needs Improvement (79-0)

Organized:
● Introduces claims with clear and
appropriate thesis statement that
previews what is to come
● Clear paragraphs by topic with topic
sentences that connect to thesis
statement
● Conclusion supports argument and
provides continued thinking about
the topic, including counterclaim and
rebuttal.
● Words / phrases / clauses to create
unity and clarify the relationship
among claims, counterclaims,
reasons, and evidence.

Develop the claims with clear reasons and

evidence that includes relevant and well
chosen
● facts
● Concrete details
● Quotations
● Paraphrased information from
research
● Examples
● Counterclaims and refutation

Formal argument writing style:

● Precise language
● Formal style (NO use of I, slang,
casual language)
● Correct use of citations
● MLA formatted Works Cited
● Complete sentences
● Correct punctuation, spelling,
homophone usage, etc.