Sie sind auf Seite 1von 24

11 Encouraging

Immigration
Chapter How did the massive immigration to Canada near the turn of the
INQUIRY twentieth century affect the complex identity of our country?

Key

Immigration and Identity


CONCEPT
As people grow older, we change. We see new places, make new friends, and meet
new challenges. All these experiences influence who we are. The same thing
happens to a country. Over time, the characteristics that seem to describe it change.
Canada is a different country today from the Dominion of Canada of a hundred
years ago. It’s also different from what it will be a hundred years from now.
One of the important factors that change a country’s identity is immigration.
Many people come from other places to live in Canada. They change the makeup
of the country. They bring their own ideas and customs. These become a part of
life in Canada. In this way, the newcomers add to what it means to be Canadian.

Coming to Western Canada


At first, Canada did not attract many immigrants. The trip from other continents
was very long. Most people who did come to North America went to the United
States. Then, in the 1890s, things changed. Newcomers flooded the West.
Over the next 20 years, many different groups of immigrants came to
Western Canada. In this chapter, you will learn more about a few of these groups.
You’ll learn why they left their home countries and why they chose Canada. As
you read, think about how they added to the character of our country.

242
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

Honing
Your Skills
Do you like to “wow”
your audience? The
Skill Check feature
in this chapter
shows you how to
Design a Multimedia
Presentation. This
skill is important to
your studies because
it will enable you to
communicate what
you know effectively.
The project at the end
of the chapter will
ask you to design a
multimedia
presentation about
the cultural pluralism
of the West.

Think

Examine the graphic at left. It includes the have come to Canada more recently. To
First Peoples, the Canadiens and English find out who they are, go to the website
AHEAD Canadians, the Métis, and some of the for Statistics Canada.
immigrant groups that lived in Western c) Brainstorm some contributions these
Canada in the early twentieth century. recent citizens are making today.
a) Brainstorm some contributions each of d) Canadians from which of these groups live
these groups made to Canada. in your community today?
b) Another band could be added to the e) Draw a different graphic to illustrate the
rainbow to include immigrant groups that cultural mix in your community.

243
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

SKILL CHECK: Design a


Multimedia Presentation
ultimedia can turn a boring presentation into an exciting experience. By the end of
M this chapter, you’ll have learned a lot more about the pluralistic nature of Canada.
When you tell others about what you’ve learned, don’t just read them a report. Try
livening it up. Make social studies come alive with visuals, sounds, videos, and music.

Choosing the Media for Dramatization


Your Presentation Write an original script and present a
Any presentation can be a multimedia play. Build a set and design costumes. Use
presentation. You just need to use more music and sound effects to bring the play
than one form of media. For example, to life. Videotape it or present it live.
spruce up a bulletin-board display with
illustrations, graphs, and a tape recorder Website
set up to play traditional music. Make
people pay attention to your Design a website on your topic. First,
spoken presentation by sketch out the web pages for your site,
showing a “slide with one sheet of paper for each web
show” of digital page. The home page will need links to
photographs. Look sub-pages. Decide what photographs, text,
at this concept sound clips, cartoons, or video clips
web. It shows a would enhance your site. Provide a list of
few of the forms links to useful websites on your topic,
of presentation including libraries, museums, and
you could use. archives. If your school has the
Then read about technology, create your website.
what you might do
with each to make it Computer Presentation
truly multimedia.
Create a slide show with text, sound,
graphics, and video clips. You could use
Video or DVD PowerPoint, HyperStudio, AppleWorks, or
Create a documentary or a another program.
What form of presentation commercial. Write the
would you choose to illustrate dialogue. Include Audiotape or CD
Canada’s pluralistic society?
costumes, props, scenery,
Brainstorm different types of Become a radio broadcaster. Present an
and sound effects. These
media you could incorporate, interview, a radio drama, a book on tape,
make the video authentic.
with examples (for example, or a newscast. Include sound effects,
Present your documentary
drawings of immigrants’ music, and personal interviews.
or commercial on the
homes).
computer or television.

244
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

The Need for Immigrants


I n 1881, 4 381 256 people lived in
Canada, including 108 547 Aboriginal
people. Nearly 89 per cent of Canadians
What did Laurier need? People. Laurier
could not build a thriving country without
more people. In particular, he wanted
were of British or French descent. newcomers to start farms in the West. As you
Focus The vast majority of them lived in learned in Chapter 9, a strong farm economy
Why did Canada the East. in the West would help the whole country.
need immigrants? In the West, the First Nations Laurier also needed more workers for
and Métis were struggling to adjust all the country’s growing industries. Mines
to a life changed by the railway. Also in the were producing three times more gold,
West were the Canadiens. Through the fur copper, and coal in 1914 than they were in
trade, they had explored this region. Some 1896. The West was producing ten times
had established farms. Then there were the more wheat. Many factories opened.
English Canadians. The English had come
from Eastern Canada, Britain, and the
Note that Laurier already had people
United States.
who could have taken some of these
All in all, there weren’t very many
jobs: the First Nations and Métis.
people in the West. In this section, you will
People didn’t even think of that
see who wanted more people in the West,
possibility. Why would this be so?
and why. You will learn that migration
within Canada was not enough to do the job.

In 1881, Canadiens made up 41.5 per


cent of the non-Aboriginal population
of the North-West Territories. English
Canadians made up 41.2 per cent.

Don’t forget that the glossary and a dictionary are


both useful sources of information. If there is a term in
this section that is not familiar to you, look it up!

The Laurier Factor Figure 11.1 Wilfrid Laurier (at centre) on the
campaign trail in 1908. Laurier spoke both French
Sir Wilfrid Laurier was Canada’s first French
and English. His Francophone parents had sent
Canadian prime minister. Laurier’s most
him to English-language schools. Looking at the
famous remark was “The twentieth century photograph, think about how knowing both
belongs to Canada.” He meant that Canada’s English and French could help a Canadian
economy would soon get very big. He politician. How could it enable us to be more active
thought Canada would become a great citizens? Are there other languages to learn that
nation. would help us be better citizens?

245
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

Year Immigrants Year Immigrants Year Immigrants

1890 75 067 1899 44 543 1908 143 326


1891 82 165 1900 41 681 1909 173 694
1892 30 996 1901 55 747 1910 286 839
1893 29 663 1902 89 102 1911 331 288
1894 20 829 1903 138 660 1912 375 756
1895 18 790 1904 131 252 1913 400 870
1896 16 835 1905 141 465 1914 150 484
1897 21 716 1906 211 653
1898 31 900 1907 272 409
Source: David J. Hall, “Room to Spare,” Horizon Canada, 1985, vol. 7, no. 76, p. 1803.

Figure 11.2 The number of immigrants entering Canada, 1890 to 1914. Most of the immigrants that came to
the country from 1890 to 1914 went to the West. How many people came to Canada in Laurier’s first year in
office (1896)? How many came in his last year (1911)?

Laurier succeeded in bringing more bought land in the West and sold it to
people to Canada, as you can see in Figure immigrants at a profit.
11.2. How did he do it? His government Church groups took an interest. They
doubled the amount of railway track, making wanted to build religious communities in a
travel into the West easier. It advertised for new land. They liked Canada’s policy of
immigrants in far-off countries. Government religious freedom.
agents went overseas to find interested The railway companies were involved,
groups. Canada offered them special too. The government gave them land for
treatment. Some groups, for example, building the railway. For example, the
received large tracts of land. Canadian Pacific Railway owned land along
109 Street and Jasper Avenue in Edmonton. It
still owns land in downtown Calgary. In total,
Partners in the Effort ]
the CPR got about 100 000 square kilometres
The government worked hard to attract of prairie land. This is almost as big as the
people to Canada. As you’ll see in this area of the island of Newfoundland. Other
chapter, it was not the only organization rail companies got more than 20 000 square
eager to bring newcomers to the country. kilometres. All the companies made big
Some private companies got involved. They profits by selling their land.

Think It 1. a) Write “A Pluralistic Society” at the centre 2. Graphs make an excellent addition to a
of a concept web. Put the groups who multimedia project. Look at the statistics in
Through wanted immigrants to move to Canada Figure 11.2.
on the second level. Put the reasons they a) What type of graph would best display
wanted these immigrants to come to the this data visually? Why? (See Skill
West on the next level. Check: Use Statistics to Create Graphs
b) Describe another way to present this on page 124.)
information. b) What trends do you see?

246
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

Canada Calling
Y ou’ve learned that the Canadian
government wanted immigrants. It
was very successful in bringing them here.
In this section, you’ll look at the
Focus strategies the government used
How did the to persuade newcomers to come
Canadian government west.
encourage immigrants
to come to Canada
from Europe?
Spreading the
Word
The person in charge of immigration to Figure 11.3 Clifford Sifton, 1907. Some people
Canada was Clifford Sifton. Sifton was a didn’t like Sifton’s policies. Even so, no one
Member of Parliament from Manitoba. He questioned his loyalty to the Prairies. Do you think
Francophones already in the West would have
was also the Minister of the Interior from
agreed with his policies? Why or why not?
1896 to 1905.
Sifton started a publicity campaign. England. Here it stood in the front window
The goal was to attract people to Canada. as a symbol of the West. Later, it was
You know how products are advertised displayed at fairs all over Europe. This
today. In the same way, Canada was strategy worked. It got people excited.
advertised as a good place to live. Would it work today?
• Millions of posters and pamphlets were
made in many languages. Who the Government Targeted
• The government brought foreign Sifton sent advertisements to three regions.
journalists to Canada. They toured the • The United States. American farmers
country. They wrote newspaper stories knew how to farm on the prairies. By the
about it when they returned home. 1890s, though, the United States was
• The government sent speakers around running out of good farmland. The ads
the world. They spread the word about sent there called Western Canada “the
the great Canadian West. last, best West.”
Some of Canada’s efforts seem a little • Great Britain. Most Canadians were of
odd. In 1907, a huge buffalo died at the British origin. Some of them wanted
Banff zoo. The government had it stuffed other Britons to move here. They thought
and sent to the Canadian office in London, this would strengthen the British
character of the country.
• Eastern Europe. Sifton believed that
farmers from Eastern Europe were ideal
settlers for the prairies. They were
Notice how lists with bullets (•) make it easy to
experienced at growing crops. They
understand several key points. Think about how you
would put up with the hardships of
could use these kinds of lists in your own work.
pioneer life. He also believed they would
assimilate to English culture.

247
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

CASE Land for Sale!


STUDY
False advertising is using ads to mislead people. Was the Canadian government
guilty of false advertising? Examine these government ads to find out.

WANTED B ECAUSE of the dry-


ness of the inland
beneficial. Sleighing
parties of pleasure
climate, the cold is are arranged for the
14,000 men to build Railways in Canada. much less noticeable period of the full
than a stranger might moon, and the sound of
100,000 men to take, cultivate and own expect. Less snow falls the sleigh bells is a

FPO
farms in Canada. on the prairies than merry one. The snow
in the East, and on protects the autumn-
Highest wages in Railway work. account of the dryness sown wheat from the
of the air, it brushes frost and aids ... the
160 acres of the best land in the world free. off one’s coat like farmer in hauling his
dust. produce to market,
The industrious Everywhere the and so contributes
poor man’s chance.... appearance of snow is alike to business and
hailed as seasonable and pleasure.

Figure 11.4 A re-creation of an ad that appeared


in a 1908 pamphlet. It was called Canada: Work, Figure 11.5 A description of Canada that appeared in a 1906
Wages, Land: The Railway Route to a Free Farm. pamphlet. It was called Twentieth-Century Canada. What
Who would be interested in this information? feeling do you get when you read this? Which phrases are
exaggerations? Which don’t tell the whole story? Reword
the passage to make it more accurate.

Respond
How realistic are
the images of
Canada on this
page? Find examples Figure 11.7 A young woman dressed
of misleading up as Canada. She appeared at a rural
information. What Figure 11.6 Two posters distributed fair in Exeter, England, in 1907. Her
information was around 1910. Compare the two posters. bicycle is decorated with sheaves of
left out? How are they alike? How are they wheat. What kind of effect might this
different? Is either misleading? How? form of publicity have had on people?

248
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

Betrayal of the Promise of The Trap []


Confederation
For many immigrants, the move to the West
Sifton and the government most wanted was “a trap.” Life here was much harder
new citizens who either spoke English or than the advertisements had led them to
would learn it. The government did not try believe. When homesteaders arrived in the
to convince Canadiens from Québec to West, they needed to build shelter before
move west. Farmland was scarce in Québec, winter. On much of the prairie there are few
yet the government did not advertise there. trees, so most newcomers made sod houses.
It did not offer free rail tickets. These were made of slabs of soil, grass, and
The government had a vision of grass roots cut from the prairie. After a
Canada as one nation with one language. downpour, it would
Over the years, Francophones began to feel continue to “rain” Tech Link
betrayed. Hadn’t Confederation made inside for days. Only Look on the Voices
Canada officially bilingual? Why wasn’t the later, when they had and Visions CD-ROM
government trying to make the West a place more money and to learn about the
for both Anglophones and Francophones? time, did homesteaders long hours and
Within a few decades, Francophones were build more permanent, tedious work involved
far outnumbered in the West. They began wood-frame houses. in a task we take for
to feel a great pressure to learn English, Few had money to pay granted today—
especially after the use of French stopped for the trip back home. making bread.
being protected.

VOICES
It was sometimes said that Sifton had an “open-door” policy. This meant that
everyone was welcome to come to Canada.

“ I do not care what language a man speaks, or what religion he professes, if he


is honest and law-abiding, if he will go on that land and make a living for
himself and his family, he is a desirable settler.

Source: Debates, House of Commons, July 1899.

Did Canada really have an “open door”? Let’s look at the facts. The government
advertised in the United States, Britain, and Eastern Europe. It did not advertise in
Québec or Asia, and it advertised very little in France and Belgium. Also, Sifton
wanted certain types of people to enter the country.
Respond
“ I think a stalwart peasant in a sheep-skin coat, born
on the soil, whose forefathers have been farmers for
ten generations, with a stout wife and a half-dozen
What kind of
people did Sifton
really want to attract
to Canada? Who did
children, is good quality. A Trades Union artisan who
he think would not
will not work more than eight hours a day … is, in my be suitable? Do you
judgement, … very bad quality.

Source: Maclean’s Magazine, April 1922.
agree with Sifton’s
reasoning? Explain.

249
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

VOICES
Mary Louisa Cummins and her husband, Colin, came
from England. They moved to Saskatchewan.

“ At the time, the CPR was plastering the country


with fascinating pictures of glorious wheat fields on
the great western prairies. There was a fortune for
everyone in three years, not to mention glittering
promises of practically free land. Hopes were high.
So we, poor fools, fell into the trap.

Source: Don Gillmor and Pierre Turgeon, Canada: A People’s History,
vol. 2 (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 2001), p. 13.
Figure 11.8 A sod house in the Camrose area of
Alberta, likely about 1900. It had a dirt floor. What
would be the benefits or drawbacks of raising
young children in this house?

Perhaps potential immigrants to


Canada would have been better off if
they had viewed Canada’s ads
critically. Are you media savvy? Look
at this screen capture of a 2005 Travel
Alberta web page. Think about it
critically. What is it trying to get you
to do? Does it exaggerate? Does it
leave out information? Do you believe
everything it says?

Think It 1. The government hoped to attract a) Prepare two posters. On one, show
immigrants from three regions in the an Alberta that would be an ideal
Through early 1900s. What were they? destination for immigrants. On the other,
a) Make a three-circle Venn diagram to show an Alberta that is more realistic.
compare these regions. b) Which one do you think your boss will
b) Write two sentences saying why these choose? Why?
areas were targeted, and not others. 3. On paper, design a website to advertise
c) What media did the government use to Canada. Alternatively, write the script for a
attract immigrants? radio or television commercial. First,
2. Imagine you’re working on a government brainstorm possible text, pictures, sounds,
campaign to promote Alberta today. and video clips you might include.

250
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

Push and Pull Factors


T he government promoted Canada
vigorously. Was that enough? In this
section, you’ll find out that the people who
• Political persecution. Several groups of
people were persecuted for their political
beliefs.
came here had good reasons for • Natural disaster. Famine, such as the
Focus leaving their homelands. They also Irish potato famine of 1847 (which you
Why did the had good reasons for choosing read about in Chapter 6), can lead people
government’s Canada. to leave their homes.
immigration policy • Affordable travel. Steamships made
succeed? voyages shorter and cheaper. After 1896,
Reasons for
a worldwide economic depression drew
Emigrating] to a close. With the return of better times,
Why were Canada’s new people could afford to move.
Tech Link immigrants looking for a place
To see a wagon where they could make a better
train of new life? For many, the conditions in
homesteaders their homelands made them
travelling north of want to leave. The factors that
Edmonton, open push people to leave their
Chapter 11 on your homelands are called push
Voices and Visions factors. The newcomers to the
CD-ROM. West were affected by a variety
of push factors. Here are the
main ones.
• Population growth. Europe was going
through a dramatic increase in population.
There were not enough jobs for everyone. Figure 11.9 A family of Scottish immigrants. They
There was not enough land to farm. arrived at Québec City in 1910. This was their first
• Religious persecution. A persecuted stop on a long journey to the prairies. What would
person is one who is treated badly it take to convince you and your family to move to
because of his or her beliefs. Several a different country? What would hold you back?
groups of people in Eastern Europe were
persecuted for their religious beliefs. Reasons for Immigrating
to Canada []
Near the turn of the twentieth century,
“Emigrant” and “Immigrant” millions of people were on the move.
Emigrant and immigrant are similar terms, but they Europeans were moving to the United States,
mean different things. Emigrants are people who Australia, New Zealand, and South America.
leave their homelands. They become immigrants Why did some of them choose Canada?
when they come to live in a new land. New Canada offered plenty of reasons. Factors that
Ukrainian Canadians, for example, emigrated from influence people to choose a certain country
Ukraine. They immigrated to Canada. are called pull factors. Here are the main pull
factors that drew people to Canada.

251
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

• Free land. Everyone could afford the • Improved farming techniques. Newly
inexpensive, plentiful land offered in developed kinds of wheat were better
Western Canada. suited to the prairie climate.
• Jobs. The developing West needed • Growing demand for wheat. As the
shopkeepers, coal miners, school demand for wheat grew, so did the price.
teachers, and so on. A wheat-farming family could do well.
• Completed railway. Immigrants who • Religious and political freedom. Canada
became Western farmers would be able allowed people to hold their beliefs.
to sell their grain in Eastern markets. • Friends and family. Some people chose
• Better machinery. Farms produced more Canada to be close to friends and family
crops with better farm machinery. already here.

Figure 11.10 Examples of push and pull


factors. Think of an instance where push
and pull factors work together.

Figure 11.11 Sources for immigrants to


Canada, 1901–1911. From which two
places did most immigrants come before
the First World War? Is a pie graph a good
way to present this information? Why or
why not?

Source: Daniel Francis, et al. Canadian Issues (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1998), p. 23.

Think It 1. Imagine you are a young man who can’t 2. Some push and pull factors can be
find work in Scotland. Write an entry in controlled. Others cannot. A huge tsunami
Through your journal in which you try to decide slammed into the shorelines of Southeast
whether or not to immigrate to Canada. Asia in December 2004. It pushed many
Mention the push and pull factors you people to leave their ruined communities.
might be thinking about. Alternatively, Many push and pull factors influenced the
present a soliloquy (a scene in which a people who came to Canada at the turn of
character talks to himself or herself ). the twentieth century. List them. Which
Include sound effects to make your scene were created by policies in Canada? Which
realistic. could the government not control?

252
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

Churches and Immigration


C hurches and religious groups took a
special interest in immigration. They
believed that the Canadian West offered a
the Canadian West should be filled with
English-speaking Anglicans. He thought this
would strengthen its “British” character. His
chance for their members to have a better advertisement said, “Let us take possession
life. In some cases, church members were of Canada. Let our cry be ‘Canada for the
being persecuted for their British.’ ”
Focus religious beliefs in their home Barr acquired a large tract of land on
What strategies countries. The Doukhobors, for the border of Saskatchewan and Alberta. In
did missionaries example, were pacifists. Even so, 1903 he led a party of 2684 men, women,
and religious the Russian government wanted to and children from England. He did not plan
communities use force them to fight in the army. the expedition well. To begin, the ship he’d
to attract Canada offered them a safe haven. arranged for, the SS Lake Manitoba, could
immigrants to It seemed to be a place where they carry only 900. He crammed everyone
Western Canada? could follow their faith in peace. aboard anyway. After the colonists arrived
in Saint John, they discovered that no rail
transport had been organized. Reverend
The Barr Colony[] George Lloyd stepped in and made the
Anglican Church leaders helped many arrangements. The immigrants ended up
British Anglicans come to Canada. (The losing most of their luggage. They had to
Anglican Church is the Church of England.) travel with few supplies by ox cart from
One of these leaders was a Canadian-born Saskatoon. But the immigrants came from
Anglican minister named Isaac Barr. In industrial towns. They didn’t know how to
1902, he placed an ad in British drive oxen. The journey was a disaster, and
newspapers. It called for people who many gave up.
wanted to go to Canada. Barr thought that Finally the colonists forced Barr to
resign. They replaced him with Lloyd, who
was experienced in the West. Lloyd helped
the newcomers at every step. The colonists
named their main town Lloydminster.

The Hutterites []
The Hutterites are a Protestant religious
group with a unique identity. Their religious
beliefs inspire them to live collectively in
isolated communities and to refuse to fight
as soldiers—they are pacifists. In Russia, the
Hutterites had been persecuted for their
Figure 11.12 Barr colonist camp in Saskatoon, April 1903. The
beliefs, including their belief in pacifism. In
government frantically put up these tents when the Barr colonists
came unprepared. It provided them with wagons for the rest of the 1864, they fled to South Dakota in the
journey. Before Barr left Canada for good, the newcomers tried to United States.
pelt him with eggs. Why would they be so angry?

253
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

Things were fine until the First World The Hutterites decided to move to
War. Then Americans began to view the southern Manitoba and Alberta. They would
Hutterites with suspicion. The Hutterites be permitted to avoid military service. They
spoke German, the language of the enemy. would be allowed to teach their children in
Further, the Hutterites refused to take up their own schools. A few instances of
arms. So other Americans took the discrimination did not discourage them.
Hutterites’ cattle and sheep. They made the Today, about 25 000 Hutterites live in
whole community feel unwelcome. Alberta in about 60 colonies.

CASE A Different Settlement Pattern


STUDY
Can a religious belief affect geography? Let’s think about settlement patterns.
Settlement patterns are the way human dwellings are arranged. They are part
of human geography.
Respond Most early farming families on the prairies lived on large farms.
Draw two Each family lived far away from other people.
diagrams. Draw
The Hutterites lived differently: they had a communal lifestyle.
one to show the
settlement pattern That means that there was no private property. Everyone in the
of Hutterite farming colony owned everything. That included farm equipment, books,
colonies. Draw toys, and even bank accounts. A group of elders made all important
another to show decisions.
the pattern that This way of life affected the settlement pattern of Hutterite
was more common
colonies. About 100 to 130 people lived in each colony. A colony was
in the West. (See
page 197 in known as a bruderhofe. Everyone lived together in a small village. All
Chapter 9.) the houses and the dining hall were in the centre of the village. The
farm buildings lay on the perimeter of
the village. All around the village were
the colony’s farmlands.
For the most part,
Hutterite colonies Tech Link
function the same Open Chapter 11
way today. on your Voices and
Visions CD-ROM to
see an aerial view of a
Hutterite colony.

Figure 11.13 Hutterite women at work in modern


times in Lethbridge, Alberta. What are they doing?
How is this scene the same as it would have been
had the photo been taken early in the last century?
How is it different? Hutterites still live separately
from the rest of Canadian society. How would this
affect the lives of Hutterite teenagers?

254
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

British Home Children ] Two types of groups set up these


ventures:
Between 1867 and 1924, 100 000 British • religious organizations—for example, the
children were sent to Canada. They Church of England Waifs and Strays
travelled on ships and by train, sometimes Society
all on their own. They hoped to join • charitable organizations—for example, the
Canadian families. Society for the Suppression of Juvenile
Vagrancy

CASE Dr. Barnardo’s Children


STUDY
Were the home children lucky to come to Canada?
Irish-born Thomas Barnardo was a young medical student in London,
England. He saw many children who were orphans or whose parents were too
poor to care for them. They had to make their own way in the world by
working, begging, or stealing. Many slept in the street. Some lived in
workhouses, where they worked long hours for no pay.
Dr. Barnardo felt he must help these “lost” children. In 1870, he opened
his first “home” where boys could live and receive some education. In time, a
series of Barnardo’s homes opened for boys and girls.
England did not offer much of a future for these children. On the other
hand, Canada needed more young workers. Further, many Canadian families
were willing to adopt these children. Barnardo believed that Canada offered
these youngsters a better life. He began sending some of
the children to live with families in Canada. The families Respond
were supposed to look after the orphans and make sure
What is the issue?
they went to school. Many children went to live on farms What would each of
in the West. Here they worked hard to pay for their keep. these people think
It was hoped that they would grow up to become about the issue?
homesteaders with farms of their own. • a worker at a
Barnardo home
in England
• a child taken
from her
penniless mother
• an orphan
welcomed into a
Canadian family
• a farmer hoping
for more help on
the farm
Figure 11.14 A group of Barnardo children, 1905. They’re on the dock in Saint • a teenager forced
John, New Brunswick. About 1000 Barnardo children came to Canada every year to work long
from 1883 to 1914. Would immigration like this be allowed today? Explain. hours on the farm

255
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

VOICES
Consider the statements of these home children. Describe what you think would be the best
experience for a home child. What would the worst be like?

“ In April 1907 I was called into a conference of


the family. I was 15 years old, nearly six feet tall
and weighed 160 pounds—pretty skookum.
will take everything away from you.” “Well,” I
said, “They won’t get my doll,” and I threw it
out the open window. I seemed to realize then
They asked me how I would like to go out to
western Canada and help to open up the
country. Well, after reading all the books of that
that I was really alone and I started to cry.

—Girl, name withheld

time about the Golden West—full of Indians,


cowboys and Mounties—I naturally agreed.
“ I was sent out to Arrow River in Manitoba, where
I was put on contract to this farmer for seven
Who wouldn’t at that age? … years. …
I feel it has been a privilege to have had a Those seven years were hell. I was beat up
hand in opening up the country.
” —Dave J. Brims
with pieces of harness, pitchforks, anything that
came in handy to hit me with I got it. I didn’t get
enough to eat. …

“ My first recollections of Canada are travelling


on the train through Québec to Montréal. We
They would buy me shoes that wouldn’t fit. I
used to cry with the pain. My feet are still crippled
were sitting three in a seat with the window
open. I had a doll, and the little girl next to me
said, “You know when you get to Canada they
over that.
” —Charles W. Carver

Source: All quotations from Phyllis Harrison, ed.,


The Home Children: Their Personal Stories (Winnipeg:
Watson & Dwyer Publishing Ltd., 1979), pp. 59, 84–85, 90.

Think It Many groups of immigrants came to Canada b) Think of other push and pull factors
because of the influence of a religious affecting your group.
Through organization. Choose one such group. c) Create a push–pull diagram for your group
a) What did the religious organization do to by following the model in Figure 11.10 on
encourage the move? page 252.

Francophones in the West


A s you have learned, Francophones had
lived in the West for generations.
They were the first non-Aboriginal
Leaving Their Mark
The Canadiens and Métis named rivers,
Focus people in the West. They had been
lakes, and regions. You can see the
How did Francophone presence in the many streets
trading furs and living off the land
Francophones and parks with French names. Many of the
here since 1730. In this section,
contribute to communities we live in have French names,
you will learn ways in which
the overall such as Batoche and Bellegarde in
Francophones put their mark on
development of Saskatchewan, and Beaumont, Morinville,
the West.
Western Canada? St. Paul, and Lac La Biche in Alberta.

256
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

You can see the mark left on the land company, had a major warehouse in
by the early Francophone farmers. For Edmonton. In Albertville, Saskatchewan, a
example, the farms on the Red and group of Francophone residents formed
Saskatchewan Rivers are quite distinct. They Saskatchewan’s first credit union in 1916.
are long and narrow, with houses near the
water. In other words, they are similar to the
Internal Migrants [
farms of the seigneurial system of New
France. Many Canadiens and English Canadians
Many Canadiens went west as moved westward during the period of
missionaries. The Sisters of Charity are a massive settlement from about 1890 to
good example. They are better known as 1914. People who move from one region to
the Soeurs Grises (Grey Nuns). They started another within one country are called
a convent and school in St. Boniface. They internal migrants.
started the hospital at Lac Sainte-Anne in At first, many Canadien migrants felt
1859. Francophone villages and towns grew welcome. They were confident that
near the French Catholic missions. These Manitoba was meant to be bilingual. They
included Lac Sainte-Anne, St. Albert, and were attracted to the educational system. It
St. Boniface. By the 1880s, the West had was modelled on the Québec system, which
many Francophone communities. allowed for Catholic (Francophone) schools.
Early Francophone businesses gave People had the right to speak French in the
people jobs and helped get the economy courts and in government. Many Canadiens
rolling. For example, the West Canadian moved to Edmonton. Here 60 per cent of
Collieries operated coal mines in the the non-Aboriginal population spoke French
Crowsnest Pass area of Alberta. It was by 1880.
owned by business interests in France and As time went by, Canadiens began to
run by local Francophones. Revillon Frères, see that the government would rather make
the second-most important fur-trading the West Anglophone. Fewer migrants from
Québec moved West.

The newspaper L’Ouest canadien


began publishing in Alberta in 1898. It
was founded to encourage people
from Québec to move west.

Figure 11.15 Le Musée de St-Boniface, built


1845–1851. The goal of the museum is to collect
and safeguard artifacts related to early Canadien
and Métis life in the West. The building began as
the convent of the Grey Nuns and the first hospital
in the West. It also served as a boarding school. It
is the oldest building in Winnipeg and the largest
oak log structure in North America. How would
Western Francophones have felt about having this
centre in their midst?

257
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

entity
IdIdentity
One Very Canadien Community: St. Boniface
What makes a community a cultural centre?
St. Boniface is a very important centre for Francophone artists, authors, publishers,
and festivals. It is the largest Francophone community west of Montréal. St. Boniface
became part of Winnipeg 30 years ago. It began, however, more than 150 years
earlier. In 1818, Bishop Provencher came here to set up a mission.
Today, St. Boniface has a population of 18 000. A majority of the people who live
here are fluent in both French and English. You can see the Canadien character of
the community by strolling through the town. The street signs for the many lovely,
tree-lined streets are in both French and English. Many business signs are in French,
and when you go into the shops, you will find a distinctive Francophone atmosphere.

Taking a Stroll through Old St. Boniface


Walking along avenue de la Cathédrale, you come upon St. Boniface Basilica. At the
end of the evening Mass or liturgy (celebrated in French), you will see crowds pour
out of the basilica! (Attending church is important to many Franco-Manitobans.)
Walking along boulevard Provencher, you will come upon cozy bistros,
Respond chocolatiers, and tiny clothing shops. Right on boulevard Provencher is the
You have read
Centre culturel franco-manitobain. It works to make sure everyone in Manitoba
about many signs
has a chance to experience Francophone culture.
of vitality in the
Francophone
community of
St. Boniface. Form
a small group.
Share signs of the
vitality of various
groups within your
community.

Figure 11.16 St. Boniface Basilica with the


grave of Louis Riel in the foreground. The
original cathedral was built around 1908. Figure 11.17 St. Boniface, which is now part of
It burned down in 1968. When the Winnipeg. Old St. Boniface was built at the turn
cathedral was rebuilt, the community of the twentieth century. Norwood is a lovely
saved the original stone front. Why would residential neighbourhood. Describe where
they do that? St. Boniface is in relation to downtown Winnipeg.

258
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

Boosting the Westerners tried to lure these people back


to Canada. For example, they made a
Francophone Population] special edition of the newspaper Le Courrier
It soon became clear that internal migration de l’Ouest in 1907. It was distributed in
would not be enough to keep the Québec, the Eastern United States, and
Francophone community strong. The France.
Canadiens saw that they might become a Francophone settlers came from
tiny minority. Belgium and France, as well. One group of
The Catholic Church took on the job of French army officers was led by Colonel
attracting more French Catholics to the Armand Trochu. In 1905, they started Le
West. It gave a number of priests the task of Ranch Sainte-Anne (St. Ann Ranch Trading
attracting them. Father Jean-Baptiste Morin Company) northeast of Calgary. The
alone drew 2475 Francophone migrants to surrounding town became Trochu.
Alberta from 1891 to 1899. In 1886, the Francophone population
Between 1860 and 1900, half a million of the prairies was about 16 000 people.
Canadiens from Québec had moved south Half of them were Métis. By 1921, that
to New England (on the east coast of the number had climbed to 137 000.
United States). This was about a third of the Francophones made up about 7 per cent of
Québec population. Most went because of the population of the prairies.
the many jobs in factories. Francophone

ography
BiBiography
Gabrielle Roy (1909–1983) He talked about beautiful rich
land and all the Canadian
Gabrielle Roy was born in St. Boniface, the
West where we should hurry
youngest of 11 children. Roy grew up to be a
to go and get established
world-famous author. Three of her books won
before the Scots and English,
the Governor General’s Award, which is Canada’s
who were arriving in droves
top literary prize. Her most famous book was
in those days. He told us the
Bonheur d’occasion, known in English as The Tin
whole country from ocean to ocean belonged to
Flute. Roy’s grandfather was a homesteader from
us, we of French blood, because of the French
Québec. Her father helped relocate migrants.
explorers who’d been all over it first. Our rights to
Roy remembers one of the Catholic priests who
our language and our religion would be respected.
convinced Québecers to go west:
Source: Gabrielle Roy, Enchantment and Sorrow: The Autobiography
of Gabrielle Roy (Toronto: Lester & Orpen Dennys, 1987), p. 16.

Think It 1. Identify a community with Francophone What if a million Francophones had


roots in Alberta. Do some research to find travelled to the West instead of 100 000?
Through out about its beginnings. How did it help a) How might various peoples already in
the West develop? the West have reacted to such a policy?
2. Imagine that the government had tried b) Using a paragraph or poem format,
hard to attract Francophones to the West. describe how the Canadian identity
would be different today.

259
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

Focus Settling In
How did the flow
of immigration
influence the
T he newcomers in the West
lived through many years of
hardship. This section looks at the
thousands of kilometres to a foreign land.
Here they endured years of hardship. They
built their own homes. They ploughed under
character of
new prairie society that began to the prairie sod with animal-drawn ploughs.
Western Canada?
emerge. They struggled every year to bring in crops
of wheat in Canada’s short growing season.
What was special about all this? They
A Pluralistic Society did it alongside people from a wide variety
By 1911, more than 80 per cent of the of backgrounds. Many Canadians wondered
people living in the Western provinces had how all these people would get along.
been born outside Canada. They had left the Would they argue all the time? Would this
communities where they were born to travel be the beginning of a pluralistic society?

Ethnic Origin 1881 1901 1911

British* 2 548 514 3 063 195 3 999 081


French 1 298 929 1 649 371 2 061 719
German 254 319 310 501 403 417
Scandinavian 5 223 31 042 112 682
Aboriginal 108 547 127 941 105 611
Jewish 667 16 131 76 199
Ukrainian 0 5 682 75 432
Dutch 30 412 33 845 55 961
Italian 1 849 10 834 45 963

Figure 11.18 Some communities in the West Russian 1 227 19 825 44 376
by 1905. In 1871, there were only a few villages
Asian 4 383 23 731 43 213
west of Ontario. By 1914, there were about
600 towns and cities. What problems might these Polish 0 6 285 33 625
communities have had when they first developed?
Other European 5 760 23 811 97 101
Here’s a hint: first think of all the goods and
services you have access to in your community. Other** 64 980 49 121 52 263
Total 4 324 810 5 371 315 7 206 643
Tech Link * The British and French numbers include the many Canadians whose
To see several families had been in Canada for centuries.
historical photographs ** “Other” refers to people having ethnic origins besides those listed here.
of the early Ukrainian Source: Daniel Francis and Sonia Riddoch. Our Canada, second edition
(Toronto: Pippin Publishing, 1995), p. 59.
community in the
West, open Chapter 11 Figure 11.19 Ethnic origins of Canadians. Describe the trend you
on your Voices and see in this table. Which ethnic group grew the most from 1881 to
Visions CD-ROM. 1901? From 1901 to 1911? What type of graph would you choose to
display this data? Why?

260
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

VOICES
Figure 11.20 A 1903 political cartoon. Which figure is
meant to be Canada? What song is the choir singing?
This song was once Canada’s unofficial anthem. Why is
the choir standing in wheat? What is the artist trying to
say about the changes taking place in Canada? What
groups of people were not included in the cartoon?
What does this say about Canadian society?

Points of View on Immigration


As you read, choose one quality that you think “ All the difficult times I had with the white
people did not make me condemn them. I just
each of the speakers might use to describe a figured I had to face whatever came along and
valuable Canadian citizen. What do you think accept how we were going to be used by white
makes a valuable Canadian citizen? man. I made no fuss about it for the longest
Ralph Connor was a church minister and time, I just took it all. Little did I know there
author. He wrote about the changes in Western were some good people in this world besides
Canada. those who put me down and kept me low.

Source: Madeline Katt Theriault, Moose to Moccasins:

“ In Western Canada there is to be seen today


that most fascinating of all human phenomena,
The Story of Ka Kita Wa Pa No Kwe (Toronto: Natural
Heritage/Natural History Inc., 1992), pp. 116–117.

the making of a nation. Out of [people] diverse


Lily Chang’s grandfather came from China. He
in traditions, in ideals, in speech, and in manner
helped build the Canadian Pacific Railway. She
of life … one people is being made.

Source: Ralph Connor, The Foreigner: A Tale of Saskatchewan
(Toronto: Westminster Co., Ltd., 1909).
remembers what he said about people learning
to get along:

J.S. Woodsworth was another church minister


who wrote about the West. He called
“ These things, the coming together of different
cultures, they take time, like the flowering of a
cherry tree. And, like a cherry tree, when the
immigrants “strangers within our gates.”

“ Foreigners in large numbers are in our midst.


blossom comes it is a thing of beauty.

Source: “The Building of the CPR,” http://www.auraltrad.
com/goldrush/s-l/chang-e.html.
More are coming. How are we to make them
into good Canadian citizens?

Source: J.S. Woodsworth (James Shaver),
Strangers Within Our Gates (Toronto: University of
Respond
What question does Woodsworth ask?
Toronto Press, 1909, 1972), p. 234.
Many people believed that assimilation
was necessary to create “good citizens”
In ethnically diverse Canada, people could be and a strong country. What do you think
cruel to people from other groups. Ka Kita Wa the various immigrants thought about
Pa No Kwe, or Wise Day Woman, tells about that? Would the Canadiens in the West
coping with bad treatment. have a different perspective? Why?

261
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

The Great Grain Growers] railway was there to carry the crop to
distant markets.
The homesteaders living on the prairies
came from a variety of ethnic groups. Most The Wheat
worked from sun-up to sundown, and they Early farmers used a type of wheat known
knew their neighbours worked hard, too. as Red Fife. It made excellent flour, but it
The homesteaders had something else in ripened late in the season. An early frost
common: nearly everyone was farming could wipe out an entire harvest. Early in
wheat. the 1900s, Canadian government scientists
William Saunders and his son Charles
The Machinery produced a new type of wheat. It was called
When homesteaders first arrived at their Marquis, and it ripened quickly. Marquis
land, they had to clear away brush. Then wheat made it possible to open vast new
they “broke” the hard sod with a team of areas of the West for farming. For this
oxen and a plough. This prepared it for reason, Westerners called it “the discovery
seeding. After planting and a long summer, of the century.”
the harvest was brought in by hand, too.
The grain was cut, tied into bundles, and The Exports
piled into stooks. Wheat became the most important crop in
By the end of the nineteenth century, Canada. It was shipped around the world to
new machinery was being produced that feed many people. The first shipment of
made farming much easier. Steam-powered wheat left Manitoba in 1876. It was a tiny
tractors replaced horses and oxen. Farmers cargo of 884 bushels of wheat. It travelled
used binders to harvest the wheat. A binder to Ontario. By 1921, Canada produced
cut the wheat, rolled it into bundles called 156 billion bushels of wheat, most of it from
sheaves, and tied each sheaf with twine. the new prairie farms. Other grains, such as
Farmers then used mechanical threshers to barley and oats, added to the harvest. In the
separate the grain from the stalk. The West, though, wheat was king.

Figure 11.21 The photo on the left shows homesteaders breaking prairie sod. After a few decades, a
farmer’s fields looked more like the photo on the right. It was taken near Edmonton about 1910 and
shows a thresher at work, harvesting “prairie gold.” Compare and contrast the work required of the
farmers in these two photographs.

262
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11

entity
IdIdentity
The Prairie Way
Most prairie families lived far apart. They worked in isolation. What kind of
community identity evolved from this?
Most prairie homesteaders didn’t see their neighbours for days and sometimes
weeks. So people learned to depend on themselves. Self-sufficiency is a proud prairie
trait. Even so, the homesteaders learned together that the best way to survive was to
help one another in times of need. The First Nations were probably the first to begin
this tradition.

It was about 1909. Jim Grey-Eyes was a well-established farmer on the Muskeg
Reserve.… One day, Grey-Eyes went riding along the Saskatchewan River and came to
the Doukhobor village of Petrofka. The Doukhobors had just recently come to Canada
from Russia, and they did not have any horses. What Grey-Eyes saw was twenty
women, big strong Doukhobor women, hitched up to a wooden walking plow cutting
furrows in the ground. Grey-Eyes watched for a while and then went home, rounded up
four of his horses, and took them plus harnesses and eveners to Petrofka the next day.
It was difficult to carry on a conversation because Grey-Eyes spoke only Cree and the
Doukhobors spoke only Russian, but he did his best.
Grey-Eyes left the horses there and went home. About a week later he returned to see
how they were making out. He was dismayed at the condition of the horses. They had
been overworked and underfed. At home, these animals were used to a daily ration of
oats, but here all they got was what they could forage on the prairie. The Doukhobors
had been so pleased with the amount of land that could be broken with the horses that
they had worked the animals far more than the horses could take. Grey-Eyes was so
mad that he took his horses home.
When he got home, he decided that help was needed. So he got another team of four
horses and took along his hired man, Mike Otterchild. He left Otterchild with the
Doukhobors for a short while to show the Doukhobors how to look after and work the
horses. A firm bond was established between the [Cree] and Doukhobor communities.
Nick Popoff, one of the Doukhobor leaders, came to visit Jim Grey-Eyes every year.

Tech Link Source: Shirley Bear, et al., … And They Told Us Their Stories, edited by Jack Funk
and Gordon Lobe (Saskatoon: Saskatoon Tribal Council, 1991), p. 80.
Look on the Voices
and Visions CD-ROM
In another form, this spirit of helpfulness showed itself in the
to see photographs
tradition of the community bee. Bees were held for any big
of the Doukhobors.
job that could be done quickly with a lot of workers. They
included barn-raising bees and quilting bees.
In 1998, grain farmer Scott Bonnor got his foot caught in the auger at the
bottom of his combine hopper. He was rushed to hospital, but his foot was mangled.

263
VOICES VOICES
AND VISIONS
AND VISIONS A Story of Canada

Bonnor would not be able to harvest nearly 800 hectares (2000 acres) of grain on
Respond his farm. Westerner Mike O’Brien tells the story of the modern combine bee that
Homesteading helped Bonnor in a time of need.
families had
hardship and hard
work in common. The next Saturday, one week after the accident, six combines came together on
How would these Bonnor’s fields. By Sunday, there were 10. Over those two days, Bonnor’s
experiences neighbours took almost all of his crops off the fields. “They were still combining
encourage active themselves,” Bonnor said from his bed in the Regina General Hospital. “But they
citizenship? Do you gave up a day to work on our farm…. That took a lot of pressure off.”
think they helped
The neighbours’ wives brought food both days and turned the task into an
forge a unique
Western identity?
old-time social event. And it was “old-time.” Things like this have happened ever
Explain. What since farmers first planted their futures in this vast quilt of land. “It’s something
community money can’t buy,” Bonnor said. “It’s the people. The generosity of the people. You
traditions reflect a can’t get that just anywhere. We help each other. It was my time to get help.”
spirit of citizenship
in your community? Source: Mike O’Brien, Calling the Prairies Home: Origins, Attitudes, Quirks & Curiosities
(Vancouver: Raincoast Books, 1999), p. 2.

Think It 1. Look at the artifacts below. Immigrants take something to remind you of the
brought these items to Canada in the early place you have left? Or will you choose
Through twentieth century. something that will be useful in the
a) These items are an important part of place you are going? Describe your
Canadian heritage. Why is that so? choice. Why did you choose this item?
b) Imagine that your family has decided to c) Take a picture of your chosen item, or
move to another country. You are told make a drawing of it. Show this to the
that there is room for you to bring only class. Explain why you would bring it
one possession. Think about it. Will you with you to a new country.

Figure 11.22 A Ukrainian


chest. It carried family
belongings to
Saskatchewan in 1902.

Figure 11.24 A brass


samovar (a type of tea-
Figure 11.23 A silk-lined kettle). A Russian army
bassinet. An American officer carried it across
family brought it with them the ocean when he
when they moved to British came to Canada in 1917.
Columbia in 1908.

264
Encouraging Immigration Chapter Chapter
11 11


Think It 2. Create a map like the one in Figure 11.18, • Where in Canada did most of them
Through using GIS if possible. Label each settle?
community with the major ethnic groups • What are two or three of this group’s
(continued)
associated with it. traditions or customs?
3. Various groups of immigrants came to • What contributions has this group made
Western Canada near the turn of the to Canada?
twentieth century. Investigate one group. • What impact did this group have on
(Refer to Figure 11.19 for ideas.) Here are First Nations peoples, and vice versa?
six questions you might use to focus your Collect your information. Refer to the
investigation: chapter project to create a multimedia
• When did most of the people in this presentation of your findings.
group come to Canada? 4. How did the massive immigration to Canada
• What were the push and pull factors near the turn of the twentieth century affect
affecting their decision to move? the complex identity of our country?

Chapter 11 PROJECT The Prairie Patchwork Quilt

Find and Select]


T he West became the destination of choice
around 1890. Europeans, Americans, and
Eastern Canadians joined the First Nations there.
5. With your group, plan your presentation, and
decide what types of media you would like to
Together they become a prairie patchwork of include.
ethnic groups, religious groups, and language 6. On your own, collect multimedia segments for
groups. In this chapter project you will develop a the immigrant group you researched. For
multimedia presentation. It will explore the example, you might collect or create visuals,
cultural pluralism of the West. audio clips, or video clips.
7. Work together to create your “Patchwork Quilt”
Focus presentation. A storyboard is a useful tool.

1. Refer to the research you completed in Think


It Through activity 3 above. You will use this Prepare to Present []
research to make your multimedia 8. Organize all the tools you will need for your
presentation. presentation. For example, you might need a
2. Form a group with three other students. Each television, computer, stereo, or DVD player.
of you should have researched a different 9. Rehearse your presentation to ensure a
immigrant group. smooth show.
3. Brainstorm with your class. How does the
theme “Patchwork Quilt” reflect the Canadian
identity? How could you use this theme in a Present and Reflect[]
multimedia presentation? Present your multimedia presentation to your
4. With your group members, decide what type class. Return to your group and discuss the
of multimedia presentation you want to finished project. How would you fix the glitches?
develop. Were your choices of media suitable to the topic?
What would you do differently next time?

265

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen