Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1
Department of Health Policy and Planning, School of International Health, University of
Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan; 2Mother and Child Health Hospital, Vientiane, Lao PDR
Abstract. The purpose of this article is to explore whether the style and content of the IMCI
algorithm and delivery of the training course match the needs and capacities of the Lao health
workers. Unlike other IMCI studies that rely on external indicators, this study uses an open-
ended qualitative approach to focus on the perspectives of the trainees through observation
and trainee interviews. The findings showed that IMCI is a practical tool for health workers,
and the interactive course is an effective way to teach it. Health workers responded that learn-
ing the algorithm was challenging due to the novel format and guidelines, but easy due to its
clarity and straightforwardness. The main problems concerned the adaptability of guidelines
and shortage of time. Incorporating in-depth clinical explanations and inviting facilitators with
medical knowledge and experience using IMCI may be key to resolving such issues.
To achieve better outcomes with IMCI, it to the original IMCI protocol (WHO and UNICEF,
is important to first reveal the factors at the 1997). Notable changes include the division of
levels of the health system, health worker, malaria classification into three risk zones, and
patient, facility, and community that explain the addition of regular mebendazole treatment.
why certain health workers choose not to fol- Eleven out of 18 provinces have implemented
low procedures in certain situations. A limita- IMCI at the provincial, district, and health cen-
tion of previous studies was that they were ter levels, and training of Medical University fac-
disengaged from the views of the health work- ulty began in 2005 as the first step towards
ers who use IMCI. developing the pre-service curriculum for medi-
We therefore designed our study as an cal students.
open-ended examination of the perspectives This study examines three clinical IMCI
of the health workers, facilities, and patients. training courses held November 3-14, 2003,
We conducted our study in the Lao People’s November 17-29, 2003, and June 14-25,
Democratic Republic (PDR), which adopted 2004 at the Maternal and Child Health Hospi-
the IMCI strategy in 1999 and was implement- tal in Vientiane City. The participants were
ing one of its first full-scale clinical IMCI train- medical doctors, medical assistants, and
ing courses at the time of the study (2003- nurses from provincial hospitals, district hos-
2004). As a first installment, this paper focuses pitals and health centers. The first course in-
on the health workers who attended the clini- vited 18 participants from Oudomxay Prov-
cal IMCI training course, and examine whether ince, and the second and third courses each
the style and content of the IMCI algorithm invited 24 participants from Vientiane Province.
and the delivery of the course match the health The facilitators were Lao doctors from
workers’ backgrounds, needs, and expecta- Vientiane City and Vientiane Province. The
tions. We paid special attention to the appro- total cost for one training course was approxi-
priateness of IMCI in the sociocultural context mately US$5,000.
of Lao PDR.
Data collection and analysis
Data were collected from three sources:
MATERIALS AND METHODS
training course observations and participation
IMCI in Lao PDR by the first author (ST), participant interviews
Lao PDR is a country of 5.3 million that and supplementary questionnaires, and infor-
ranks among the least developed in the world, mal interviews with key informants.
with a per capita GNI of US$310 (World Bank, Detailed observations were taken during
2003). In 2001, the infant mortality rate was all three courses and at the facilitator meet-
82.2 and under-five mortality was 106.9 per ings held at the end of each day. In particular,
1,000 live births. The five diseases covered the participants were observed for their recep-
by IMCI – diarrhea, pneumonia, malaria, mal- tion of the course material, performance dur-
nutrition, and measles – accounted for 87% ing exercises and discussions, and remarks
of total child deaths (Ministry of Health, 2001). indicating changes in their understanding of
The IMCI materials were adapted by the Lao clinical case management. Facilitators were
IMCI–Working Group, under the Ministry of observed for the concepts they emphasized
Health, to reflect the health situation in the Lao in teaching, explanations to clarify concepts,
PDR, translated into the Lao language, and and ways they addressed participants’ con-
tested in three pilot districts. The content and cerns. During the second training course, the
style of the Lao version remain largely faithful first author joined as a mock participant, and
completed reading materials and exercises in curred and the results were discussed with the
English textbooks, discussed with other train- course director throughout the training course.
ees, and received individual feedback from the Approval of this study was granted by the
course director. IMCI Working Group of the Lao MOH and the
During the third training course, semi- Japan International Coorperation Agency
structured interviews were conducted with 12 (JICA) Kidsmile project.
trainees in the last two days of the training
course. A purposive sampling strategy was RESULTS
used in which the facilitators were asked to
select four participants from each of the three There were four core themes that
groups such that a wide range of responses emerged from the analysis. The tables accom-
would be represented. The topic guide for the panying each theme present evidence from the
interview was composed of questions regard- data that were used to generate each theme.
ing the participants’ perception of the clinical Engaging training course style (Table 1)
content and training course style, level of sat- Many interviewees applauded the effec-
isfaction and confidence, challenges encoun- tiveness of the interactive training course style
tered, and expected constraints in implemen- in learning the material compared to the one-
tation. Proping questions were used to follow way lecture-format education common in Lao
up when appropriate. Informed consent was PDR (Sub-theme a). They noted that the one-
obtained before each interview, in which par- on-one feedback sessions with the facilitator
ticipants received a description of the study were particularly helpful (theme b). At the feed-
and were reminded that they were free to de- back sessions, the participants were respon-
cline at any time. In addition, a self-adminis- sible for explaining verbally, showing the mark-
tered questionnaire containing the interview ings on the recording sheet and referring back
topics was given to the 12 trainees who were to the chart booklet. This provides valuable
not interviewed; these results confirmed the practice to get accustomed to the format as
interviewees represented the views of partici- well as recognize points they did not under-
pants as a whole. stand.
Finally, informal interviews with trainees, In addition, the participants noted the
facilitators, and the course director were col- positive, enjoyable environment (theme c) in
lected as field notes during all three training which the facilitators taught communication
courses. The first author participated in plan- techniques by example, approaching the par-
ning and review meetings that involved repre- ticipants with friendliness and warmth. The fa-
sentatives from various donor agencies to cilitators built the trainees’ self-confidence by
understand the priorities and administrative praising what was done well before suggest-
structure behind Lao IMCI. ing improvements and making encouraging
Analysis was done by iterative and induc- remarks throughout. The participants were en-
tive theme generation. Data were thematically couraged to ask questions and make com-
coded, then sorted into emerging categories ments at any time and praised when they did.
until four core themes were generated. Data Further, by the end of the 11-day course, the
triangulation of sources and methods was used groups had built a team spirit, and actively en-
to ensure the reliability of the results (Denzin, gaged in discussion and helped each other in
1970). As one goal of the study was to gener- solving exercises. Interviewees reported the
ate recommendations to improve the training training course provided a valuable opportu-
courses, analysis was done as fieldwork oc- nity to learn from other trainees.
Table 1
Engaging training course style.
Themes Evidence
Table 2
Improving communication with the caretaker.
Sub-theme Evidence
In the past, many trainees had encoun- some health workers were quick to learn, while
tered problems communicating with patients those older and more experienced tended to
from different socioeconomic and cultural require more time (Sub-theme b). When train-
backgrounds. They were eager to engage in ees in the third training course were asked to
discussion and get advice regarding this (Sub- rate their level of confidence in using IMCI, the
theme c). Popular topics were how to coun- average was 77.5% (range 50-95); when
sel ethnic people who do not speak the na- asked why, the most frequent response was
tional (lowland) Lao language, or caretakers that it would take practice to get accustomed
who believed in feeding practices that were to using IMCI. All four health workers from
harmful to a child’s health. health centers in the third training course
Acquiring the IMCI case management proce- stated that IMCI was appropriate for their level
dure (Table 3) of practice, although one commented that it
All interviewees acknowledged that the may be difficult for some staff.
primary purpose of the training was to learn Interviews revealed the opposing yet in-
the procedure for assessing, classifying and extricably linked experiences of learning IMCI:
treating major child diseases in one consulta- it is challenging because they are required to
tion (Sub-theme a). Facilitators reported that master a process that is entirely new to them
Table 3
Acquiring the IMCI procedure.
Sub-themes Evidence
a) Concept “IMCI taught me not only to focus on the main symptom, but on
all possible illnesses. We used to learn how to assess individual
diseases. “ (I)
b) Using IMCI “Using IMCI is quite difficult, but at the same time, quite easy” (I)
Facilitator at a facilitator meeting reports that some participants
are quick to learn, and some are struggling. (O)
“It will be challenging to use in the beginning. But I will be able to
do it perfectly once I review the lessons at home and get prac-
tice.” (I)
c) Format “IMCI is very detailed, and can be followed step-by-step.”
Recording sheet Participants forget where to tick and where to circle on the re-
cording sheet (O)
Participant misclassifies because she did not follow the classifi-
cation boxes from most severe to mild (O)
“It is challenging to always follow the chart booklet.” (I)
Chart booklet “Everything is in the chart booklet. Before, I needed to refer to
several books.” (I)
d) Guideline Facilitator at a facilitator meeting: “Some participants are confus-
ing the IMCI guidelines with what they used to do at home.” (O)
Assessment and classification “Classification of pneumonia is made easier by counting breaths
and looking for stridor.” (I)
Participants express dissatisfaction using breathing count. (O)
Participants ask the significance of malaria risk regions and how
they are determined. They ask why there are no risk regions for
measles. (O)
Classification of diarrhea is confused because there are three cat-
egories to be assessed: dehydration, dysentery, and persistence.
(O)
Treatment “Referral guidelines for severe cases and pre-referral treatment
were useful.” (I)
A participant says that she wants to treat all the symptoms before
referral. (O)
in a very short period of time, yet it is easy tive to them (Sub-theme c). Common mistakes
because IMCI is simpler and clearer than pre- were that trainees would skip assessment of
vious clinical methods. To discuss the chal- diseases for which there was no prominent
lenges, first, the trainees found the checklist symptom, or not follow the classification boxes
and flowchart format awkward because it pre- in order. At first, trainees appeared to find
sented a procedural logic that was not intui- reading off the recording sheet and chart
Table 4
Adapting IMCI to facility and patient.
Sub-themes Evidence
booklet tedious, and were occasionally ad- laria risk regions and breathing count in place
monished for trying to work from memory. of blood testing and stethoscope, and inquired
Hence, the facilitators allotted a significant about the meaning of those signs. Finally, the
portion of the training course to get accus- concept of urgent referral and pre-referral
tomed to using these tools correctly through treatment caused dissatisfaction, and one
repetition. Second, the clinical guideline de- doctor commented that she wished to treat
fined in IMCI was different from those that all symptoms, not just the urgent ones, be-
trainees had used before (Sub-theme d). Many fore referring.
were not aware that the guideline was de- On the other hand, the interviewees
signed to utilize a combination of signs that stated that IMCI was easy to use because they
are measurable at first-level facilities that gave could conduct the entire consultation by fol-
reasonable sensitivity and specificity, and lowing the instructions step by step. The as-
could be mastered by health workers in two sessment of general danger signs and other
weeks. The trainees responded with skepti- symptoms to classify severe disease and need
cism towards assessment signs such as ma- for referral was noted to be particularly use-
ful. Many mentioned that having a compact and expected it to bring positive changes to
reference containing major illnesses for chil- their facilities. While studies have shown that
dren was convenient compared to having the improved knowledge is not always a sufficient
information spread in several books. pre-condition for improving case management
Adapting IMCI to the facility and patient (Table practices (Brugha and Zwi, 1998), the enthu-
4) siasm and positive image delivered with the
IMCI algorithm can become an important in-
There were often questions regarding
centive for the participants to practice IMCI at
how rigorous IMCI had to be followed and how
their facilities. Further, effective communica-
open it was to adaptation. Concerning the
tion may bring other benefits. Detailed coun-
assessment process, trainees asked whether
seling can allow early detection of incorrect
they could skip some sections because ex-
feeding in rural and ethnic populations, and
amining all categories took too long. In re-
the friendly attitude may encourage those in
sponse, one facilitator asserted the impor-
urban areas to return to public hospitals, which
tance of assessing all symptoms, and said the
have become a second choice to private pro-
process would become faster with practice.
viders because of poor staff attitudes and oth-
On the other hand, in regards to the use of
erwise perceived low quality (Paphassarang
additional tools, such as blood testing, the
et al, 2002).
course director responded that the guidelines
were for reference and could be adapted to The straightforward IMCI procedure al-
suit the health facility. lows health workers to acquire it in a short
period and practice it correctly without exten-
Another concern was that IMCI-style
sive medical knowledge or tools. At the same
counseling, which involves explanation, dem-
time, the minimal guidelines failed to inform
onstration, and questions to check under-
the extent to which the guidelines can be ad-
standing, takes more time than they can af-
justed to suit facility capacity and patient
ford; others said that it was redundant for the
needs, and also account for the user’s clinical
population they were serving (Sub-theme b).
judgment.
The facilitators responded that the process is
important to make sure the caretaker under- One recurrent concern was time: the IMCI
stands, but if the health worker decides that procedures took more time than health work-
she has made it clear the first time and the ers were accustomed to, or were comfortable
caretaker seems to understand, it may not be spending. Although health workers are ex-
necessary to explain again. pected to become more efficient with use,
there is the danger that they will skip critical
DISCUSSION IMCI procedures to save time. A study in Niger
reported the nutrition section of the recording
This study highlights the success of quali- sheet was often not completed (Tawfik et al,
tative methods in revealing the concerns of 2001) and a facility-based evaluation in Lao
trainees regarding IMCI and the challenges PDR showed that over three-fourths of the re-
they faced acquiring it during the training cording sheets were incomplete, mostly in the
course. These help generate practical solu- assessment of the last four sections (vitamin
tions that may improve the training course and A, mebendazole, immunization, and feeding)
prevent poor performance at the facility. (Takada, unpublished data). Those health
Overall, the clinical IMCI training course workers reported that they do not have the
was positively endorsed by the health work- opportunity to refine their techniques because
ers, who said it taught useful, practical skills, the patient load is extremely low, and are con-
cerned of the caretaker losing patience or Bangladesh: early findings from a cluster-
other patients waiting. randomised study. Lancet 2004; 364: 1595-
602.
Because clinical IMCI is an in-service cur-
riculum, its implementers may consider incor- Brugha R, Zwi A. Improving the quality of private
sector delivery of public health services: chal-
porating more in-depth clinical explanations
lenges and strategies. Health Policy Plan
into the guidelines would allow trainees to
1998; 13: 107-20.
make more informed decisions on how to ad-
Bryce J, Victora CG, Habicht JP, Vaughan P, Black
just the procedure. While it is difficult to bal-
RE. The multi-country evaluation of the inte-
ance between teaching too much and too little
grated management of childhood illness strat-
information, in this case, the trainees would egy: lessons for the evaluation of public health
benefit from integrating IMCI into the larger interventions. Am J Public Health 2004; 94:
body of knowledge built from prior guidelines, 406-15.
training courses, and clinical experience. Be- Denzin NK. The research act. New Jersey: Prentice
cause the facilitators are the main source for hall, 1970.
practical advice in using and adapting IMCI, Factor SH, Schilinger JA, Kalter HD, et al. Diagno-
one solution may be to invite facilitators with sis and management of febrile children using
extensive medical knowledge as well as ex- the WHO/UNICEF guidelines for IMCI in
perience using IMCI at the health facility who Dhaka, Bangladesh. Bull World Health Organ
can effectively address such concerns. 2003; 79: 1096-105.
Guows E, Bryce J, Habicht JP, et al. Improving
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS microbial use among health workers in first-
level facilities: results from the Multi Country
The training courses were organized by Evaluation of the Integrated Management of
the Maternal and Child Health Center (MCH) Childhood Illness strategy. Bull World Health
of the Ministry of Health, and sponsored by Organ 2004; 82: 509-15.
the Japan International Cooperation Agency Horwood C, Liebeschuetz S, Blaauw D, Cassol S,
(JICA) Kidsmile project. We are grateful for the Qazi S. Diagnosis of paediatric HIV infection in
support provided by the staff of MCH, the a primary health care setting with a clinical
Kidsmile project, and the WHO office in Lao algorithm. Bull World Health Organ 2003: 81;
PDR. We thank Dr Moazzam Ali, and Dr 858-66.
Masamine Jimba (University of Tokyo) and Dr Luby S, Zaidi N, Rehman S, Northrup R. Improving
Yasuo Sugiura (Ministry of Health, Labour, and private practitioner sick-child case manage-
ment in two urban communities in Pakistan.
Welfare) for their contributions to the manu-
Trop Med Int Health 2002: 7; 210-9.
script. This study would not have been pos-
sible without the contributions of the partici- Ministry of Health. Report on national health survey:
health status of the people in Lao P.D.R.
pants and the assistance of our translator, Mr
Vientiane: Lao PDR, 2001.
Anusone Inthavong.
Musinguzi J, 2001. A report on the public discussion
on “Persistently high infant and child mortality
REFERENCES
rates in Uganda-a Function of poverty?” [Cited
Anand K, Patro BK, Paul E, Kapoor SK. Manage- 2005 Nov 18]. Available from: URL: www.
ment of sick children by health workers in futuresgroup.com/Documents/UgaInfant.pdf
Ballabgarh: Lessons for Implementation of Paphassarang C, Philavong K, Boupha B, Blas E.
IMCI in India. J Trop Pediatr 2004; 50: 41-7. Equity, privatization and cost recovery in urban
Arifeen SE, Blum LS, Hoque DME. Integrated Man- health care: the case of Lao PDR. Health
agement of Childhood Illness (IMCI) in Policy Plan 2002; 17: 72-84.
Rimón MM, Kheng S, Hoyer S, et al. Malaria dip- experience in strengthening supervision, im-
sticks beneficial for IMCI in Cambodia. Trop proving availability of child survival drugs
Med Int Health 2003; 8: 536-43. through cost recovery, and initiating training
Sahin F, Ulukol B, Aysev D, Suskan E. The validity for Integrated Management of Childhood Ill-
of diagnostic criteria for streptococcal ness (IMCI). BMC Int Health Human Rights
pharyngitix in integrated management of child- 2001; 1: 1.
hood illness (IMCI) guidelines. J Trop Pediatr Weber M, Herman J, Jaffar S, et al. Clinical predic-
2003; 49: 377-9. tors of bacterial meningitis in infants and
Simoes EAF, Peterson S, Gamatie Y, et al. Manage- young children in The Gambia. Trop Med Int
ment of severely ill children at first-level health Health 2002; 7: 722-31.
facilities in sub-Saharan Africa when referral is World Bank. World development report 2004:Mak-
difficult. Bull World Health Organ 2003: 81; ing Services Work for Poor People. Washing-
522-31. ton DC: Oxford University Press, 2003.
Tanzania IMCI Multi-country Evaluation Health Fa- WHO and UNICEF. Integrated Management of
cility Survey Study Group. The effect of Inte- Childhood Illness. a WHO/UNICEF initiative.
grated Management of Childhood Illness on Bull World Health Organ 1997; 75: (suppl 1).
observed quality of care of under-fives in rural World Health Organization and UNICEF. Integrated
Tanzania. Health Policy Plan 2004: 19; 1-10. Management of Childhood Illness. WHO/CHD/
Tawfik YM, Legros S, Geslin C. Evaluating Niger’s 97.3 (A-L), 1997.