Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Jeffrey W. Estep
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 2
Abstract
This inquiry examines and compares quantitative and qualitative research along with
their perspective techniques. The relative merits and demerits of each will be evaluated,
The paper concludes with a discussion regarding advantages, disadvantages and what can
be attained when the two opposite approaches are used in conjunction with one another.
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 3
Qualitative studies are often conducted because the topic has yet to be explored.
Variables have not or cannot be easily identified, and theories are not available to explain
Like any other, qualitative research begins with a single focus. The main emphasis of
qualitative research is observation. The researcher closely watches ones routine (habitat,
environment, and lifestyle) in hopes of discovering a pattern. Data is collected from these
observations.
in the social sciences. This particular research has proven successful in market business
commitment to study and analyze a problem and typically demands a great deal of time.
Those in opposition of qualitative inquiries find that this type of research is not
structured, or that it is too “open ended”. Quantitative purist may argue that this research
is inductive. Their conclusions are made based upon a limited amount of information
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 4
gathered. The root of inductive is induce. By its own definition, when inducing, one’s
being studied, by either observing, or interacting, the prospect of bias exists. This
coercion could be involuntary in hopes that it supports ones specific theory or belief. It
could also simply be a variety of “Stockholm Syndrome” effect; except in this case the
researcher has grown fond of that in which they study. The possibility of the researcher
taking a neutral stance with qualitative research can be problematic. To err is human, but
methods that produce numerical data. This data then is used in an attempt to establish
and either supports a hypothesis, rejects it, or it can be inconclusive. The outcome is
measurable and replicable, allegedly loosing the prospect of subjectivity. The ability to
relationships.
Whereas qualitative research has not been explored, the basis of quantitative research is
that it has. The ability to quantify is lost if statistics in some form are not known prior to
beginning research. This fact alone makes quantitative research appropriate only when
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 5
specific issues to be tested and researched are known. Quantitative research would not be
appropriate in the initial learning phase, and wouldn’t be the chosen method to develop
Methods
Rather than discuss a specific method, this inquiry will cover a few different methods
Starting with qualitative, there are a wide variety of methods that are utilized in
qualitative measurement. The methods are largely limited by the imagination of the
Participant Observation: This method requires that the researcher become an actual
participant in that which is being observed. There are typically set guidelines that discuss
how the participant may interact as a participant, the collection and storage of field notes,
and the analysis of field data. Participant observation often requires months or years of
intensive work because the researcher needs to become accepted as a natural part of the
culture in order to assure that the observations are of the natural phenomenon.
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 6
Direct Observation: Direct observation, just as it sounds, requires that the researcher
simply observes and doesn't become a participant in that which is being observed.
the observations. From these observations, the researcher then collects and records
data.
respondent or group. Although the researcher may have some initial guiding
interviewer typically goes with the flow of the conversation. This is considered a
useful tool to broadly explore a topic, but that data collected is usually difficult to
analyze.
Quantitative research is generally made using typical time tested scientific methods,
which include:
• Evaluation of results
An attempt by the researcher to maintain control over all factors that may affect the result
of an experiment. In doing this, the researcher attempts to determine or predict what may
occur.
Experimental Design
This consists of a blueprint of a particular procedure that enables the researcher to test his
dependent variables.
Empirical method
This refers to the collection of data. The data collected is used to base a theory or derive a
scientific conclusion.
The primary disadvantage of quantitative research is that issues are only measured if they
are known prior to the beginning of the survey (and, therefore, have been incorporated
into the
Discussion
conclude that both are dependant on one another. Qualitative research enables us to
daydreams.
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 8
All quantitative research was previously a qualitative endeavor. In the same respect, all
qualitative research can be legitimized with quantitative backing. Both methods are
relevant.
research; both quantitative and qualitative, but more so qualitative. Every human being
has certain predispositions and prejudice based on their upbringing, education and life
experience.
A typical problem involving research especially that gleaned from a human subject is the
potential for error. We have to trust the data that is procured from the subject is
absolutely true and free of inconsistencies that can skew precious data. The way to reduce
this error is to increase the sample size, but there will almost always be a 00.5 (5%, 1 in
whole.
While any statistics gathered during research is undeniably helpful, one could assume
that portions cannot be completely relied upon. So it would seem that not only the
research itself, but the interpretation of the results cannot be taken as the complete truth
due to not only acceptable variance, but latent subjectivity on both sides of the research.
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 9
References
1557987912.
"Qualitative research." A Dictionary of Nursing. 2008. Retrieved May 11, 2010 from
Encyclopedia.com: http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1O62-qualitativeresearch.html
Patton, M. Q. (2002). Qualitative research and evaluation methods (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks,
http://wilderdom.com/research/QualitativeVersusQuantitativeResearch.html
Appendices
Appendix A
Quantitative Qualitative
Systematic in its approach Systematic in its approach
Objective Subjective
Deductive Inductive
Data in the form of numbers Data in the form of words
All aspects of the study are carefully The design emerges as the study unfolds.
designed before data is collected.
Recommended during latter phases of Recommended during earlier phases of
research projects. research projects.
The aim is to classify features, count them, The aim is a complete, detailed description.
and construct statistical models in an
attempt to explain what is observed.
Researcher uses tools, such as Researcher is the data gathering instrument.
questionnaires or equipment to collect
numerical data.
Researcher tends to remain objectively Researcher tends to become subjectively
separated from the subject matter. immersed in the subject matter.
Qualitative and Quantitative Inquiry 11
Appendix B