9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

(http://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?
iu=/317810595/Default&sz=100x75&c=6793450028678447000)
(http://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?
iu=/317810595/Default&sz=800x600&c=6793450028678447000)

(/)

Search...

Subscribe (http://www.materialsperformance.com/subscribe)

Open Navigation

Home (/home) /  What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Coatings & Linings (/topics/coatings-linings)

What Do You Know about Inorganic

Zinc Coatings?
By Rob Francis on 6/6/2016 1:37 PM

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 1/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

FACEBOOK TWITTER LINKEDIN EMAIL

S
ingle-coat inorganic zinc (IOZ) silicate coatings can provide long-term protection to
steel, especially in marine atmospheric environments. As a single coat, they allow rapid
coating work. As a relatively thin coating, they are also very economical. Some problems
can arise when using these coatings, however, which have led to their avoidance, misuse,
or failure.

Does the Application of Inorganic Zinc Silicate Coatings Require

Special Skills?
Although the skills required for successfully mixing and applying IOZ coatings can be easily learned,
treating IOZ in the same way as other paint can result in faulty application. For example, zinc
pigment is heavy and will rapidly settle out. It must be continuously agitated. The applicator must
apply the coating as a wet coat in even, parallel passes. Thickness, temperature, and humidity
conditions are all critical for proper curing. Skilled applicators are essential.

How do Inorganic Zinc Silicate Coatings Cure?

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 2/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

For the solvent-borne product, the rst stage is evaporation of the solvent, which readily occurs
even under very cold conditions. After evaporation of the solvent, alkyl (typically ethyl) silicate
reacts with water (a hydrolysis reaction) to form a silanol and ethanol. The silanol molecules cross-
link in a condensation reaction to form a silicate polymer and water. The zinc ions, produced by the
addition of zinc dust to the silicate binder, serve to catalyze both the hydrolysis and condensation
reactions.

Although commonly believed to react with atmospheric moisture, Eccleston1 has shown by gas
chromatography that water for the hydrolysis reaction is, in fact, the water released from the
condensation reaction. This is con rmed by practical observations. One manufacturer has recently
introduced a humectant additive (the opposite of a desiccant) for dry conditions, which holds the
condensation reaction moisture within the coating lm while it cures. Moreover, some
manufacturers allow application of their products down to 0 °F (–18 °C), even though there is no
liquid water available in the atmosphere. Below the freezing point of water, the silicate liquid acts as
an antifreeze so the two reactions can still proceed, albeit at a slow rate. Above 32 °F (0 °C),
however, a humid environment is required to ensure that water remains within the uncured coating
so the practical effect is the same as if the reaction occurred with atmospheric moisture.

Ideal conditions for application of a solvent-borne IOZ silicate coating are a surface temperature of
68 to 77 °F (20 to 25 °C), with a relative humidity (RH) between 70 and 90%. Curing times increase
as actual conditions move further away from these ideal conditions. Under conditions of low
humidity, the coating “dries” but a soft, friable, uncured coating results. Water misting or steaming
must be carried out if the RH drops below 50% during curing (60% if overcoated), but such actions
will not cure a coating that has dried. The coating also will cure under very high humidity
conditions, but evaporation of the solvent will be slowed and there is greater risk of damage from
rain or condensation. There are a number of tests that have been suggested for checking the cure of
solvent-borne IOZ silicate coatings, but an investigation by Starr2 found that the methyl ethyl
ketone (MEK) solvent rub test (ASTM D47523) was the only reliable eld method.
For the water-borne product, the rst curing stage is evaporation of the water, so warm, dry
conditions are required. After the water evaporates, one of the rst reaction products during the
cure is an alkaline hydroxide (OH–) (typically potassium hydroxide [KOH]). Unlike the ethanol that
forms during cure of the solvent-borne product, the hydroxide remains on the surface. Under
normal conditions, this will neutralize through a reaction with atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2)
and moisture. However, heavy dew or water ponding can cause this hydroxide to attack the zinc or
unreacted silicate and cause spot rusting, blistering, or a soft, uncured lm (Figure 1).4 Heavy rain
will usually wash the hydroxide out of the lm, so this damage might not arise. Depending on the
weather conditions, it may be weeks or months before the hydroxide is reacted or removed from the
coating and a neutral surface is achieved.

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 3/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Figure 1: Spot rusting and blistering on a water-borne IOZ silicate coating due to alkali production from condensation during
curing.

Ideal conditions for the application of water-borne IOZ silicate coatings are a surface temperature of
68 to 77 °F (20 to 25 °C) and an RH between 40 and 50%. Under these conditions, curing to water
resistance can be achieved in 2 or 3 h, although high-ratio types can reach water insolubility within
an hour. Moving further away from the ideal conditions lengthens the coatings’ curing time. Water-
borne products should not be applied below 40 °F (5 °C), and high temperatures may result in dry
spray. The coating must be protected from rain or heavy dew during the curing period. Although not
often indicated, moving air is also important for drying any water-borne coating; and use of fans to
avoid stagnant air conditions is strongly recommended.5
To prevent an applicator from being forced to apply an IOZ silicate coating under climatic
conditions where it is not likely to achieve a satisfactory cure, provisions should be made by
speci ers to allow either a solvent- or water-borne silicate coating to be used depending on
prevailing conditions.

What Problems Arise with Excessive Thickness?

One of the problems with IOZ silicate coatings, especially solvent-borne, is their tendency to
mudcrack when applied too thickly; but mudcracking is not as serious as it may appear. With many
formulations, it does not become visible unless the coating is hundreds of microns thick.6 For
trained and experienced applicators, keeping the thickness at appropriate levels should not be a
problem. The corrosion products normally ll in the cracks in the same way that ne cracks in

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 4/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

concrete will often self-heal. A thorough visual inspection should be carried out to ensure there is
no severe mudcracking, which requires repair. Minor mudcracking that is adherent usually can be
left without serious consequences.
Szokolik7 notes that excessive thickness can adversely affect the cure of high-ratio, water-based IOZ
silicate coatings applied in less than favorable ambient conditions and suggests a maximum
thickness of 6 mils (150 µm) for these materials. This would probably be a reasonable upper limit for
any IOZ coating. It is more critical, however, to ensure there is suf cient coating covering every part
of the structure. To achieve this, the target lm thickness should eliminate the chance there will be
regions with less than 3 mils (~75 µm) of coating. To achieve this, skilled applicators should aim for
a minimum of <~4 mils (100 µm). This should ensure there is suf cient coating over the entire
surface to minimize the risk of premature breakdown in regions with low dry lm thickness (DFT).

Can an Inorganic Zinc Silicate Coating Be Repaired with Itself?

Repair recommendations for IOZ silicate coatings can range from complete removal to repair with
epoxy zinc or surface-tolerant epoxy coatings.8 In fact, with a few extra considerations that differ
from the repair of other coating types, an IOZ silicate coating can be recoated with itself, although
this requires skill and care.
If the coating is found to be too thin after application and an extra coat is required, the silicate
solution from any repair coat will migrate into the voids and leave a friable and powdery surface if
the surface porosity has not had a chance to ll with corrosion products. The liquid content of the
repair coat should be increased by 10 to 15% so there is suf cient liquid to prevent the surface layer
from becoming underbound and lacking in adhesion.
Once the coating has aged, porosity is no longer an issue. As with any other repair coating, the
surface must be properly cleaned before applying a topcoat of IOZ. As long as the surface is
thoroughly clean and free from loose contamination, it will be suitable for overcoating. An IOZ
coating can be repaired with either solvent-borne or water-borne IOZ silicate coating, which will
perform better than alternatives. The solvent-borne IOZ has better wetting characteristics and is
easier to apply in the eld, and therefore is recommended as long as humidity conditions are
suitable. The initial adhesion immediately after application of a repair IOZ coating is poor,6 but
once the repair coating is thoroughly cured (which may take several months), an adherent bond
develops between the new and old coatings, as shown in Figure 2.

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 5/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Figure 2: Repair coats develop good adhesion after several weeks.

Does a Topcoat Provide Additional Protection to a Single-Coat

Inorganic Zinc Silicate Coating?
More coats are usually better for conventional coatings, but IOZ silicate coatings behave differently.
As shown in the diagram in Figure 3, applying a topcoat prevents the formation of protective
corrosion products. Furthermore, the cathodic protection for bare areas of steel is reduced by a
topcoat as it considerably reduces the available area of the anodic zinc. Many tests have shown that
topcoating is not necessary and, in some cases, can actually be detrimental to the coating system’s
durability.9 Topcoats should only be applied if color is required, and then an epoxy zinc primer
system should be speci ed that is easy to apply, has fewer drying and curing restrictions, and
provides similar performance as a multi-coat system.10

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 6/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Figure 3: Protection by zinc is reduced with a topcoat.

What Factors Must be Considered if Topcoating Inorganic Zinc Is

Necessary?
Topcoating adds to the concerns and activities during application. Curing requirements for multi-
coat systems are even more critical than for single-coat systems because once the topcoat is applied,
further curing of the IOZ coating cannot take place. When applied to uncured zinc, topcoats can fail
by zinc splitting.

The porous nature of the zinc can cause bubbling (gassing) or pinholing of the topcoat, which
usually results in a cratered appearance when dry (Figure 4). There are a number of techniques used
to minimize this risk, including use of a low DFT mist coat, application of an extra topcoat that is
thinned down considerably, or use of a compatible tie coat.11 Ideally, the topcoat should be applied
after the IOZ has been exposed to the weather for several weeks, and these problems are rare when
topcoating shop-primed steel on site after construction.

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 7/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Figure 4: Bubbling can result from overcoating an IOZ coating if proper procedures are not carried out.

Water-borne IOZ coatings normally should not be topcoated because of the additional problem of
possible residual alkalinity, which can destroy any applied coating. However, a water-borne IOZ
silicate coating topcoated with acrylic latex is a unique system that combines excellent durability
with low or no volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and can be used as a “green” coating system
where color and good durability are required. This system was used when the iconic Golden Gate
Bridge that crosses the San Francisco Bay was repainted in the 1980s.
If this system is speci ed, it is essential that there is no residual alkalinity on the primer surface in
addition to all the other concerns regarding drying, curing, and topcoating. Investigations by the
U.S. Department of Transportation12 showed acrylic topcoats over water-borne IOZ coatings
inevitably blistered within 60 days unless the primer was neutralized. These researchers
recommended testing the pH of the surface if it is to be overcoated, to ensure it is between 4 and 7.

Conclusions
IOZ silicate coatings, whether solvent-borne or water-borne, provide a number of unique challenges
for the speci er and applicator. However, the excellent protection, rapid application, and good
economy provided by these systems suggest it is worth learning to apply them properly and

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 8/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

understanding their limits and idiosyncrasies. Successful application will reward the asset owner
with a unique and powerful product in the ght against corrosion.

References
1 G. Eccleston, “Effect of Cure Temperature and Humidity on the Properties of Solvent-Borne Zinc
Silicate Coatings,” JPCL-PMC Jan (1998): pp. 36-45.
2 T.L. Starr, “Improving the Reliability of Zinc- Rich Paint Systems,” JPCL Vol. 3 (3) (1986): pp. 22-
31.
3 ASTM D4752–10 (2015), “Standard Practice for Measuring MEK Resistance of Ethyl Silicate
(Inorganic) Zinc-Rich Primers by Solvent Rub” (West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM, 2015).

4 W.L. Mandeno, correspondence to author, March 14, 2013.

5 “Problem Solving Forum,” JPCL Oct (1995): p. 11.

6 R. Francis, et al., Corrosion & Materials Jun (2008): pp. 30-37.

7 A. Szokolik, “Field Testing of Inorganic Zinc Silicates,” JPCL May (1995): pp. 56-67.
8 “Problem Solving Forum,” JPCL Nov (1998): p. 11.

9 W.J. Paton, “Performance Characteristics of Zinc-Rich Coatings Applied to Carbon Steel,” NASA
Technical Note, D-7336, July 1973.

10 G.R. Ruschau, et al., “Speci cations vs. Reality for Selection of Protective Coatings,” CORROSION
2008, paper no. 017 (Houston, TX: NACE International, 2008).

11 SSPC-PS Guide 8.00, “Guide to Topcoating Zinc-Rich Primers” (Pittsburgh, PA: SSPC, 2002).

12 J.P. Ault, C.L. Farschon, “Adhesion Criteria Between Water-Based Inorganic Zinc Coatings and
Their Topcoats for Steel,” Federal Highway Administration, FHWA-RD-98-170, March 1999.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

ROB FRANCIS is the principal at R A Francis Consulting Services, Melbourne, VIC, Australia, e-
mail: robfrancis766@gmail.com (mailto:robfrancis766@gmail.com). He has more than 40 years
of academic, industrial, and consulting experience in metals, materials, and corrosion,
particularly regarding selection, speci cation, and inspection of protective coatings. He has a
Ph.D. in corrosion science from the Corrosion and Protection Centre at the University of
Manchester, is a NACE-certi ed Coating Inspector and instructor, and edited the book, Inorganic
Zinc Coatings—History, Chemistry, Properties, Applications and Alternatives in 2013. He is a 16-
year member of NACE International.

Related Articles
Inorganic Zincs—How Do They Cure? (/magazine/2008/may/inorganic-zincshow-do-they-
cure)

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 9/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Importance of the ‘Little Things’ in a Good Coating Job

(/magazine/2006/november/importance-of-the-little-things-in-a-good-coating-job)
Service Life Extension for Protective Coatings (/magazine/2009/march/service-life-extension-
for-protective-coatings)
Predicting Coating Life (/magazine/2008/march/predicting-coating-life)
The Importance of the Pre-Job Meeting (/magazine/2009/june/the-importance-of-the-pre-job-
meeting)
Managing a Coating & Plating Supply Chain (/magazine/2007/january/managing-a-coating-
plating-supply-chain)

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 10/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Sponsored Links

Gamers Around the World Have Been Waiting for this Game! Already 35 Million Players
Grepolis - Free Online Game

The Most 'Liked' Wedding Dress of All Time

Constative.com

Top 10 Best Countries To Travel To Alone In 2018

Bored Articles

This Woman Reads 100 Books A Month

Blinkist

20 Unbelievable Hotels You Won't Believe Actually Exist

Travel Den

International IQ Test - Take the Online Test!

international-iq-test.com

1 Comment Materials Performance 

1 Login

Sort by Best
 Recommend 4 ⤤ Share

Join the discussion…

LOG IN WITH
OR SIGN UP WITH DISQUS ?

Name

Amanullah Khan • a year ago

the mist coat is applied for the prevention of pinholes and bubbles but in a 20 ltr paint container
how we should specify the correct quantity of thinner as it is specified that mist coat should be
thinned 10 to 20 % that would be if 20 % it is 4 ltr and if 10 % it would be 2 ltr and accordingly then
applied to inorganic zinc, should we thinned to full 20 % or 10 % or is there any way to specify
thinner correct quantity?
△ ▽ • Reply • Share ›
http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 11/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

✉ Subscribe d Add Disqus to your siteAdd DisqusAdd 🔒 Disqus' Privacy PolicyPrivacy PolicyPrivacy

Sponsored Links

The Must-Play Strategy Game of the Year

Grepolis - Free Online Game

The Most 'Liked' Wedding Dress of All Time

Constative.com

5 Foods That Are Good for High Blood Pressure

Food Prevent

Cancer-Causing Foods You Should Avoid

Manuka Feed

International IQ Test - Take the Online Test!

international-iq-test.com

This Woman Reads 100 Books A Month

Blinkist

MORE ARTICLES

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 12/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

Coatings & Linings (/topics/coatings-linings)

Cathodic Protection (/topics/cathodic-protection)

Chemical Treatment (/topics/chemical-treatment)

Materials Selection & Design (/topics/materials-selection-design)

Phorgotten Phenomena (/topics/phorgotten-phenomena)

Failure Analyses (/topics/failure-analyses)

Case Histories (/topics/case-histories)

Corrosion Basics (/topics/corrosion-basics)

WHITE PAPERS
A New Standard in Corrosion Prevention: How Self-Healing Coatings Enable Signi cant ROI to End-User
(/white-papers/autonomic-materials-inc)

View All >> (/white-papers)

Home (/) Magazine (/magazine) News (/news) Topics (/topics) Advertise (/advertise)

Submit Manuscript (/submit-manuscript) Sitemap (/sitemap) Contact Us (/contact-us)

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 13/14
9/6/2018 What Do You Know about Inorganic Zinc Coatings?

(http://www.linkedin.com) (http://www.google.com)

(https://twitter.com/MPcorrosion)

(https://www.facebook.com/MaterialsPerformanceMagazine?ref=hl)

Materials Performance
15835 Park Ten Pl., Houston, TX 77084
Tel: +1 281-228-6200
© Copyright 2017 Materials Performance Magazine | Privacy Policy (/privacy-policy) | Terms of Use (/terms-
of-use)

(http://www.nace.org/home.aspx )

http://www.materialsperformance.com/articles/coating-linings/2016/06/what-do-you-know-about-inorganic-zinc-coatings 14/14