1. Trans World Airlines v.

CA, 165 SCRA 143

• • Atty. Rogelio Vinluan was traveling around Europe and the US with
Japan Airlines and other airlines
• • He had a first class ticket on his TWA flight from JFK to San Francisco
• • He reconfirmed twice
• • But when he got to JFK, he was told that there were no more first
class seats
• • Then he saw that Caucasians who checked-in after him were
accommodated
• • Vinluan was forced to take an economy class seat
• • Vinluan sued TWA for damages