Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
DOI 10.1007/s10029-013-1150-3
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
H. Paajanen
Received: 19 February 2013 / Accepted: 28 July 2013 / Published online: 9 August 2013
Ó Springer-Verlag France 2013
123
54 Hernia (2015) 19:53–59
ischemia and necrosis after inguinal hernia surgery are moderate surgical complications and bodily injuries are
uncommon complications [1, 2]. The current incidence is reported. Bodily injuries refer to an illness, treatment
difficult to calculate and the most reports predate laparo- injury, equipment-related injury, infection or unreasonable
scopic hernia repairs. For primary open inguinal hernio- injury during or after surgical procedures. Patient insurance
plasty, testicular atrophy occurs in 0.5 %, while for open compensates such costs as medical treatment expenses, loss
recurrent hernioplasty the incidence can approach even of income, pain and suffering, permanent functional defect
5 % [3–5]. Orchiectomy as a result of acute ischemia or or permanent cosmetic injuries after surgery.
chronic intractable testicular pain has been reported rarely Our national register study consisted of all 335 com-
after open or laparoscopic hernia repair [6, 7]. Other tes- plications related to inguinal and femoral hernia surgery
ticular adverse events including swelling and orchitis are reported to the Patient Insurance Centre from January
observed in between 0.9 and 1.5 % of laparoscopic ingui- 2003 through December 2010 (Fig. 1). The study data
nal hernia repairs [8]. Testicular injury after inguinal hernia were retrospective and based on the records of Finnish
surgery is thought to be due to acute thrombosis of the Patient Insurance Centre. In the present study, all uro-
venous plexus, arterial or nerve injuries, or mesh irritation logical complications (n = 62) occurring in open or lap-
of cord [9, 10]. aroscopic hernia repair in adult patients (18 years or older)
Approximately 11,000 inguinal herniorrhaphies are were included. In the analysis, we divided inguinal hernia
performed each year in Finland with a population of 5.4 procedures into four categories: laparoscopic vs. open
millions, over 80,000 operations in United Kingdom and surgery and mesh vs. non-mesh operations. Furthermore,
over 800,000 in the United States [11–13]. Recently, data hospital status (university, central, local or private hospi-
from national hernia registers have been available from tals) and surgeon’s training level (resident, specialist) were
Denmark and Sweden. These registers have mainly focused separately analysed. Surgery for inguinal hernias in Fin-
on hernia recurrences and the frequency of chronic inguinal land was performed in 37 local hospitals, 14 central
pain after surgery, but not on testicular adverse effects [14, community-based hospitals and five university hospitals.
15]. Recent urological reviews of chronic testicular pain The patients suffering from moderate testicular or scrotal
have discussed the role of inguinal hernia surgery as a chronic pain and treated without orchiectomy (n = 17),
cause of pain, but no prevalence data have been reported so intractable chronic testicular pain or atrophy resulting in
far [1, 2]. late orchiectomy (n = 11) or early orchiectomy due to
The Finnish Patient Insurance Centre offers a reliable necrosis of testicle (n = 6) were further analysed using
source of information for the analysis of serious urological pain and quality-of-life questionnaire (letter/telephone
complications related to inguinal hernia surgery [11]. In the call) approximately 7 years (range 2–15 years) after
present study, we analysed all the reported urological inguinal hernioplasty. Early orchiectomy as a result of
complications related to adult inguinal hernia surgery from total vascular occlusion of testicular vessels and total
the Patient Insurance Centre during an 8-year period. A testicular necrosis was performed usually during the first
long-term quality-of-life survey of patients undergoing week after inguinal hernioplasty. Late orchiectomy as a
orchiectomy as a result of intractable scrotal or testicular result of intractable pain syndrome was performed after
pain and/or ischemia was also performed. first week (usually after months) of inguinal hernioplasty.
Scrotal ultrasound was always used as a diagnosis of early
vascular changes of the testicles and nerve blocks for late
Patients and methods testicular or scrotal pain. Persistent inguinal and testicular
pain was asked separately using numeric rating scale
The patient Injury Act in Finland was brought into force on (NRS; range 0 = best outcome/no pain, 10 = worst out-
the first of May 1987. To obtain full compensation for come/most pain). The study protocol was approved by the
patient injury, proof of malpractice is no longer required. Research Ethics Committee of the Hospital District of
The Patient Injury Act ensures compensation for patient Northern Savo, Kuopio, Finland.
injury that has sustained in connection with medical The annual number of all inguinal and femoral hernio-
treatment and health care, e.g. (1) probably has arisen as a plasties in Finland was acquired from the Finnish Hospital
consequence of examination or treatment, (2) has been Discharge Register, which collects information regarding
caused by an infection or inflammation, and (3) has been diagnosis, dates of admission, discharge and surgical pro-
caused by an accident connected with examination or cedures of each patient. The purpose of this register is for
treatment. Every Finnish hospital has an official patient research development, administration and planning. The
ombudsman who helps the patient to prepare a claim when register is maintained by the National Board of Health.
necessary. Every patient is insured by the Finnish Patient Every communal and private hospital collects data that are
Insurance Centre, to which all major and majority of automatically sent to the register at the end of each year
123
Hernia (2015) 19:53–59 55
Inguinal hernioplasties Table 1 The total number of inguinal hernia procedures and operated
in Finland 2003-2010 femoral hernias in Finland in 2003–2010
n=91923
Number of patients (%)
123
56 Hernia (2015) 19:53–59
123
Hernia (2015) 19:53–59 57
patient (71-year-old male) died after the laparoscopic orchiectomy should be postponed until all other testis
hernia repair associated with scrotal haemorrhage, scrotal preserving strategies have been considered.
infection and subsequent cardiac failure. Early ischemic orchitis typically presents 2–3 days after
Altogether 31 patients (50 %) with urological compli- inguinal hernia surgery and can progress to infarctation,
cations received financial compensation from their hospi- total necrosis and atrophy of testis. The early ischemic
tals. The mean sum of money was 3,600 ± 2,670 Euros injury is likely due to thrombosis of the venous plexus,
(range 825–10,920 €). rather than iatrogenic arterial injury or inappropriate clo-
sure of the inguinal canal. Ultrasound/duplex scanning of
the postoperative acute scrotum can help to differentiate
Discussion ischemic orchitis from infection or haemorrhage [7].
Unfortunately, testicular torsion cannot be ruled out using
After inguinal hernia repair, testicular necrosis and sub- radiological imaging and prompt scrotal exploration may
sequent atrophy as a result of ischemic orchitis is a well- sometimes be necessary. Although ischemic orchitis,
known but a very rare complication. The distinction atrophy and subsequent orchiectomy are uncommon inju-
between scrotal vs testicular pain and neuropathic vs ries, all patients should be informed of these potential
nociceptive pain was not attempted in the present study, complications and operative consent should include these
because our data were register-based and retrospective. Our risks irrespective of the type of hernia or the surgical
main goal was to evaluate the value of early or late approach. An operation for recurrent hernia carries a par-
orchiectomy in relieving intractable testicular pain syn- ticularly high risk for testicular injuries. Testicular ische-
drome after inguinal hernia surgery. One-fifth of litigation mia can be reversed with prompt mesh loosening, removal
claims related to inguinal surgery was due to urological of mesh or too tight sutures. Early evaluation and explo-
complications, and in half of them the final diagnosis was ration of suspected ischemic orchitis after inguinal hernia
testicular ischemia, atrophia or pain. We found that half of repair may allow symptomatic relief and prevention of
the patients with serious testicular injuries were referred to testicular atrophy [9]. In prompt re-operation, there are no
orchiectomy and in two-thirds, the removal of testis was evidence-based studies to guide surgeon whether ischemic
beneficial. Intractable chronic testicular pain resulted more testis should be removed or left in situ to avoid chronic
often in late orchiectomy than early ischemia. In most pain syndrome. Furthermore, there are no guidelines to
severe cases of testicle pain, late orchiectomy may be the treat acute vascular thrombosis in testicular vessels using
final operative intervention in these patients. These patients anti-thrombotic agents. Our retrospective study indicated
had most likely nociceptive pain due to testicular tissue that early orchiectomy did not always benefit the patient,
injury than neuropathic pain due to testicular nerve injury. but substantial pain relief and alleviation of other symp-
In our study, 20–25 % of patients continued to have severe toms were achieved in over half of the patients.
orchialgia despite orchiectomy, which is much lower rate Clinical management of chronic testicular pain after
than reported (80 %) by previous reviews [1, 2]. In patients inguinal hernia surgery includes a careful assessment of
with failed orchiectomy, testicular pain was more than differential diagnosis, such as haematoma or infection [17].
likely neuropathic because of testicular nerve injury rather After clinical examination, urine analysis, inguinal sonog-
than nociceptive due to testicular tissue injury. However, raphy, computerised tomography and magnetic resonance
123
58 Hernia (2015) 19:53–59
imaging may give additional information [1, 2]. Nonsur- the frequency of pain in open versus laparoscopic surgery,
gical management of testicular pain includes analgesics, in mesh versus non-mesh techniques, in the hospital status,
injection therapy with corticosteroids/local anaesthetics in the surgeon’s training level or in patients with recurrent
and other pharmacological treatment of chronic neuro- hernia repair. We believe that almost all serious events
pathic pain (e.g. tricyclic antidepressants, such as ami- leading to orchiectomy after inguinal hernia surgery were
triptyline; gabapentinoids, gabapentin or pregabalin; reported to the Patient Insurance Centre.
serotonine-norepinephrine re-uptake inhibitors, duloxetine
and venlafaxine). When testicular pain is a result from
nerve entrapment or mesh-induced fibrosis, removal of the Summary
mesh or inguinal nerve transection by laparoscopic or by
open approach may be the treatment of choice [18–20]. Urological injuries form one-fifth of the major complica-
Very recent reports suggest that extension of the standard tions after inguinal hernioplasty. Our study indicated that in
triple neurectomy to include proximal genitofemoral two-thirds of patients with persistent nociceptive testicular
nerve for treatment of inguinodynia or scrotal pain after pain, pain can be substantially diminished by performing
hernioplasty is a safe and effective procedure [19, 20]. orchiectomy as the last operative choice.
Triple neurectomy may help in scrotal pain but not in
testicular pain. Before removing painful testis, microsur- Acknowledgments The technical assistance of Mrs. Saija Lehtinen
and Mrs. Pirjo Halonen (bio-statistical analysis) are greatly
gical denervation of the cord may also be attempted [1, acknowledged. The experiments comply with the current laws of
2], but this technique does not address neuropathic lesions Finland.
proximal to the cord. In Finland, this technique is very
seldom utilised in chronic testicular pain syndrome. In the Conflict of interest Kirsi Rönkä, Jaana Vironen, Hannu Kokki,
Tapani Liukkonen and Hannu Paajanen declare no conflict of interest.
present patient cohort, no mesh was removed before
orchiectomy, nor was any nerve resection tried to relieve
the pain. However, non-operative treatment, such as
injections of lidocaine/corticosteroids was attempted with
References
many patients.
How to avoid testicular complications during inguinal 1. Kumar P, Mehta V, Nargund VH (2010) Clinical management of
hernia surgery? Too extensive dissection of a distal hernia chronic testicular pain. Urologia Int 84:125–131
sac, dislocation of the testis from the scrotum into the 2. Granitsiotis P, Kirk D (2004) Chronic testicular pain: an over-
wound and concomitant scrotal surgery should all be view. Eur Urol 45:430–436
3. Wantz GE (1984) Complications of inguinal hernial repair. Surg
avoided [4]. Another cause of the testicular infarctation in Clin North Am 64:287–298
the laparoscopic inguinal hernia surgery is the cautery 4. Reid I, Devlin HB (1994) Testicular atrophy as a consequence of
excision of the hernia sac that may lead to venous injury inguinal hernia repair. Br J Surg 81:91–93
[6]. Ultrasound and Doppler sonography studies have 5. Skandalakis JE, Skandalakis LJ, Colborn GL (1996) Testicular
atrophy and neuropathy in herniorrhaphy. Am Surg 62:775–782
indicated that mesh implantation or perimesh fibrosis does 6. Moore JB, Hasenboehler EA (2007) Orchiectomy as a result of
not adversely affect ipsilateral testicular blood flow in open ischemic orchitis after laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair: case
or laparoscopic techniques and thus, mesh application is report of a rare complication. Patient Saf Surg 7(1):3–6
still a safe procedure in male patients in whom testicular 7. Mincheff T, Bannister B, Zubel P (2002) Focal testicular
infarction from laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair. JSLS
function is important [21, 22]. Accordingly, no certain type 6:211–213
of mesh was related to increased urological complaints in 8. Phillips EH, Arregui M, Carroll BJ et al (1995) Incidence of
postoperative outcome in this study. complications following laparoscopic hernioplasty. Surg Endosc
To our knowledge, nationwide review of severe uro- 9:16–21
9. Chu L, Averch TD, Jackman SV (2009) Testicular infarction as a
logical complications related to inguinal hernia repair has sequela of inguinal hernia repair. Can J Urol 16:4953–4954
not been performed earlier [23–26]. One Swedish popula- 10. Junge K, Binnebösel M, Kauffmann C et al (2011) Damage to the
tion-based analysis indicated that the patient’s self-report spermatic cord by the Lichtenstein and TAPP procedures in a pig
frequency of testicular pain was 120/1,643 (8.3 %) [23]. model. Surg Endosc 25:146–152
11. Paajanen H, Scheinin T, Vironen J (2010) Nationwide analysis of
Our register-based study indicated that inguinal hernia complications related to inguinal hernia surgery in Finland:
repair is very rarely associated with serious urological a 5 year register study of 55,000 operations. Am J Surg 199:
postoperative complications. The majority of litigation 746–751
claims were related to the repair of primary hernias, non- 12. Cheek CM, Black NA, Devlin HB (1998) Groin hernia surgery: a
systematic review. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 1:S1–S20
emergency operations and to open technique. This is in line 13. Rutkow IM (2003) Demographic and socioeconomic aspects of
with the frequency and type of hernia procedures per- hernia repair in the United States in 2003. Surg Clin North Am
formed annually in our country. We found no difference in 83:1045–1052
123
Hernia (2015) 19:53–59 59
14. Franneby U, Sandblom G, Nordin P, Nyren O, Gunnarsson U 21. Ramadan SU, Gokharman D, Tuncbilek I et al (2009) Does the
(2006) Risk factors for long-term pain after hernia surgery. Ann presence of a mesh have an effect on the testicular blood flow
Surg 244:212–219 after surgical repair of indirect inguinal hernia? J Clin Ultrasound
15. Bay-Nielsen M, Kehlet H, Strand L (2001) Quality assessment of 37:78–81
26 304 herniorrhaphies in Denmark: a prospective nationwide 22. Celik AS, Memmi N, Celebi F et al (2009) Impact of slit and
study. Lancet 358:1124–1128 nonslit mesh technique on testicular perfusion and volume in the
16. Keskimäki I, Aro S (1991) Accuracy of data on diagnosis, pro- early and late postoperative period of the totally extraperitoneal
cedures and accidents in the Finnish hospital register. Int J Health preperitoneal technique in patients with inguinal hernia. Am J
Sci 2:15–21 Surg 198:287–291
17. Jenkins JT, O’Dwyer PJ (2008) Clinical review: inguinal hernias. 23. Fränneby U, Sandblom G, Nyrén O, Nordin P, Gunnarsson U
BMJ 336:269–272 (2008) Self-reported adverse events after groin hernia repair, a
18. Nariculam J, Minhas S, Adeniyi A, Ralph DJ, Freeman A (2007) study based on a national register. Value Health 11:927–932
A review of the efficacy of surgical treatment for and patholog- 24. Callesen T, Bech K, Kehlet H (1999) Prospective study of
ical changes in patients with chronic scrotal pain. BJU Int chronic pain after groin hernia repair. Br J Surg 86:1528–1531
99:1091–1093 25. Bay-Nielsen M, Perkins FM, Kehlet H (2001) Pain and functional
19. Ducic I, Dellon AL (2004) Testicular pain after inguinal hernia impairment 1 year after inguinal herniorraphy: a nationwide
repair: an approach to resection of the genital branch of genito- questionnaire study. Ann Surg 233:1–7
femoral nerve. J Am Coll Surg 198:181–184 26. Kehlet H (2008) Chronic pain after groin hernia repair. Br J Surg
20. Amid PK, Chen DC (2011) Surgical treatment of chronic groin 95:135–136
and testicular pain after laparoscopic and open preperitoneal
inguinal hernia repair. J Am Coll Surg 213:531–536
123