Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
net/publication/273681475
Effect of Coarse Aggregate Size And Shape on the Strength and Flow
Characteristics of Self-compacting Concrete
CITATIONS READS
4 3,573
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
bond strength and splicing of reinforcement in recycled concrete aggregate View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Krishnamurthy Pandurangan on 17 March 2015.
Abstract smaller than 0.125 mm). Fly ash, limestone powder, silica
fume, rice hush ash etc., are used as filler materials.
Three ingredients of concrete have a specific and Super-plasticizers along with viscosity modifying agents
significant effect on the characteristics of Self are added to improve the self-compacting property of
Compacting Concrete. Out of the three ingredients the SCC. The ingredients of concrete have a significant effect
shape and size of coarse aggregate has more influence on the characteristics of Self-Compacting concrete.
on the properties of fresh and hardened concrete. Proportioning of SCC is influenced by the various
Coarse aggregate shape and size also affects concrete ingredients added to concrete is discussed below.
strength through a complex relationship of aggregate-to-
cement paste bonding properties. The particle shape Influence of Mineral Admixtures
and size of coarse aggregate is influenced by feed rock
properties, the type of crusher, and the way in which the The term 'powder' used in SCC refers to a blended mix of
crusher is operated. While feed rock properties and cement and filler particles smaller than 0.125 mm. The
crusher type determine achievable limits on particle filler increases the paste volume required to achieve the
shape, crusher operation is still the most important desirable workability of SCC. The addition of filler in an
single factor affecting shape. Due to insufficient stages appropriate quantity enhances both workability and
of crushing of feed rock, aggregates supplied from most durability without sacrificing early strength (Mata,
of the crushers are flaky and elongated, which is 2004).Noguchi et al.,(1999) emphasizes use of excess
sensitive to the properties of fresh and hardened paste in the mix to cover the surface area of the
concrete. Hence, a study on the influence of size and aggregates and to minimize the friction between them.
shape of locally available coarse aggregates on the Excess paste improves the flowability and decreasing the
strength and flow characteristics of SCC is the main segregation risk. However, excessive powder materials
intention of this paper. Two grades of SCC mixes with 60 could make the mixture too viscous and reduce its
% and 40% replacement of cement with flyash are used mobility [1,2].EFNARC, (2005)specifies a typical content
in this study. The results of this study show that the of powder ranging from 350 kg to 600 kg per/m3 of
flowability and strength of the high volume flyash SCC concrete. It has also indicated that the use of cement
concrete mix with 10 mm to 16 mm MSA is found to be content more than 500 Kg/m3 can be dangerous and
better than low volume flyash SCC with 20 mm MSA. increase the heat of hydration and shrinkage [3]. Oliveira
et al, (2006) indicates that the addition of fly ash results
Introduction in a better performance of the self-compacting concrete
appraised through the water absorption by capillarity
Self-compacting Concrete (SCC) was ?rst developed in [4].Prakash et al, (2009) indicates that paste volume has
Japan in 1988 in order to achieve noise free construction a predominant effect on the fresh concrete properties in
sites with improved quality of concrete. The use of SCC comparison with water or powder content. The w/p ratio
offers economic, social and environmental bene?ts over had a good co-relation with the compressive strength of
traditional vibrated concrete construction. concrete and proposes that it is possible to produce SCC
with powder content as low as 350 kg/m3 [5].Bouzoubaa
The constituent materials used for the production of SCC and Lachemi (2001) incorporated high volumes class F
are the same as those for conventionally vibrated normal fly ash as filler in the range of 40 to 60% by mass of
concrete except that SCC contains lesser aggregate and powder and kept the powder content constant at 400
greater powder content (i.e. cement and filler particles kg/m3. A slump flow as high as 700 mm, a flow time
Fly
MSA Blocking Fly MSA Blocking
ash step, Variation Variation
(mm) mm ash(%) (mm) step, mm
(%)
40 18.75 - 40 20 18.75 -
20
60 19.70 + 5.0 % 10 10.20 -45.6 %
40 10.20 - 60 20 19.70 -
Fig. - 4 V-Funnel time for LVF-SCC and HVF-SCC 10
60 14.60 +43.13% 10 14.60 -25.88%
3.70 %, 19.0 %, 72.0% and 88.0 % in 20 mm, 16 mm,
12.5 mm and 10 mm MSA respectively. Hence the
guidelines, the maximum limit of the flow time is 8 secs.
amount of coarse aggregates less than 10 mm is very
Similar to the other flow test results, V-funnel flow time
less in 20 mm MSA and hence the blocking step is high for
increased as the size of coarse aggregate increased.
mixes with 20 mm aggregates.
Hence, 10 mm size aggregate had the largest filling
In this study, the maximum blocking step of 19.70 mm ability.
was obtained for mixes with 20 mm MSA and 60 %
It is evident from Table -2 that as the maximum size of
flysash. This value is less than the maximum of 20 mm as
aggregates is reduced, the flaky and elongated nature of
per ENFARC standards. As the volume of flyash is
the aggregates increases. In spite of this drawback, the
increased from 40 % to 60 %, the blocking step increased
slump flow in SCC mixes with 10 mm MSA is more than
5.0 % in SCC with 20 mm MSA and 43.13 % in SCC with 10
SCC with 20 mm MSA. This proves that the influence of
mm MSA. The blocking step is less for 10 mm aggregates.
shape on the flowability of SCC is negligible. This is
The reduction in blocking step is 45.6% when 40% flyash
because of the fact that the resistance to flow due to
is used and 25.88%, when 60% of flyash is used in the
irregular shaped aggregates is overcome by the high
SCC mix. The addition of flyash makes the mix cohesive
paste volume in SCC mixes. Moreover, it is to be noted
and reduces the flowability of concrete.
that the slump of normal vibrated concrete reduces with
V-Funnel test results plotted in Fig. - 4 measures the flow reduction in the maximum size of coarse aggregate and
time required for SCC to pass a narrow opening and give the shape of aggregate.
an indication of the filling ability of SCC. As per EFNARC
Influence of coarse aggregate size and shape on the
Table -6 Fresh Properties of NVC and SCC mixes Compressive Strength
Type of SCC / Aggregate Size Slump Time (s)
NVC (mm) Spread /Slump The compressive strength of the various mixes used in
(mm) this study is reported in Table -8. It is evident from Table - 8
LVF - SCC 20.0 646 5.60 that the 7 days compressive strength of normally vibrated
LVF - SCC 16.0 660 4.80 concrete was more than that of LVF SCC and HVF SCC
LVF - SCC 12.5 695 4.30 .The % reduction in 7 days compressive strength of SCC
LVF - SCC 10.0 707 4.00 mixes as compared with the reference mix for 20 mm, 16
HVF -SCC 20.0 665 5.92 mm, 12.5 mm and 10 mm size coarse aggregates was
HVF -SCC 16.0 670 5.23 19.35%, 16%, 16.38% and 8.82% for LVF SCC mixes and
HVF -SCC 12.5 690 4.93 20%, 15.10%, 15.99%, 7.45% for HVF SCC respectively.
HVF -SCC 10.0 705 4.28 Similarly, the % reduction in 28 days compressive
NVC 20.0 87 * - strength of SCC mixes as compared with the reference
NVC 16.0 85 *
- mix for 20 mm, 16 mm, 12.5 mm and 10 mm size was
NVC 12.5 81 * - found to be 10.80%, 7.42%, 5.97%, 3.34% for the LVF
SCC mix. In the case of HVF SCC mix the reduction was
NVC 10.0 76 * -
5.8%, 4.63% and 2.22% for 20,12.5 and 10 mm MSA
* In normal vibrated concrete only slump was measured respectively.
Comparing the compressive strength at 7 days and 28 mixes with elongated and flaky aggregates can be
days for both the SCC mixes, only a marginal variation was minimised by using high volume of flyash in the SCC mix.
seen to occur at 7 days age. (+4.00 to +16.5 % at 28 days
and +0.50 to -8.37%). Conclusions
In case of normally vibrated concrete and LVF SCC, it is Based on the limited study carried the following
found that mix with 20 mm aggregate showed increase in conclusions can be drawn.
strength when compared to the mixes with smaller 1. Irrespective of the maximum size of aggregates, Both
maximum size of coarse aggregate. LVF SCC and HVF SCC concretes designed in this study
satisfy the filling and passing ability requirements
The ratio of the 7 days compressive strength to 28 days specified by EFNARC.
compressive strength of the normally vibrated concrete 2. As the maximum size of the aggregate increased from
and SCC for various sizes of aggregates is shown in Fig -5. 10 mm to 20 mm, the slump flow decreased by an
This ratio indicates the rate of attaining the early and 28 amount of 28.57% and 27.70% for LVF SCC and HVF
days strength. When studying the percentage increase SCC respectively. However, the slump in normally
between the 7 days and 28 days compressive strength it vibrated concrete decreased by 12.6 % as the
was found that HVF SCC mix showed higher percentage of maximum size of coarse aggregate is decreased from
increase of 51.18%, 59.24%, 42.32%, 44.51% for 20 20 mm to 10 mm.
mm, 16 mm, 12.5 mm and 10 mm size respectively. It can 3. As the maximum size of aggregate is increased from
thus be concluded that as the flyash content increased 10 to 20 mm, the blocking step increased by 83.82%
the rate of attaining the strengths also increases from the for LVF SCC and by 34.93% for HVF SCC.
age of 7 days to 28 days. 4. The flowability of the SCC mix with low volume flyash
concrete with 10 mm aggregates is better than any
The compressive strength of the mixes with 10 mm MSA other combination of mixes used in this study.
is less than the compressive strength of mixes with 20 5. The shape of the aggregate has no influence on the
mm MSA. This is due to the fact that flaky and elongated flowability of SCC mixes. However, use of flaky and
aggregates are more when the maximum size of elongated aggregates reduces the strength of SCC
aggregate reduces. This is evident from the flakiness and and normally vibrated concrete.
elongation indices reported in Table - 2. Moreover, it is 6. Use of 60% volume of flyash in SCC mixes with
evident from Table – 8 that the reduction in strength with elongated and flaky aggregates produces concrete
with good flowability and strength.
References
1. MATA .L.A. Implementation of self compacting
concrete(SCC) in prestressed concrete girders, M.Sc
thesis, North Carolina State University. Report No.119,
2004.
2. NOGUCHI T., OH S.G. and TOMOSAWA F. Rheological
Approach to Passing Ability Between Reinforcing Bars of
Self-Compacting Concrete,1st International RILEM
Symposium on Self-Compacting Concrete, Sweden, RILEM
Publications S.A.R.L, 1999.
Fig.-5 Percentage of 7 days to 28 days 3. The European Guidelines for Self- Compacting Concrete:
Compressive Strength of concretes Specifications, Production and Use, 2005,