Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The purpose of this study was to develop porous concrete with acceptable permeability and strength
Received 8 November 2012 using recycled aggregate from waste crushed concrete. The optimum mix proportions were employed
Received in revised form 10 April 2013 to prepare porous concretes using normal and recycled aggregates. Tests carried out on porous concrete
Accepted 11 June 2013
were: void ratio, coefficient of permeability, compressive and flexural strengths. The effect of recycled
Available online 7 July 2013
aggregate on total void ratio, strength and permeability was examined. Styrene butadiene rubber-based
redispersible polymer powder and latex were introduced to mixtures to improve strength properties. The
Keywords:
total void ratio of porous concrete incorporating recycled aggregate was larger than that of porous con-
Porous concrete
Recycled aggregate
crete with normal aggregate. The addition of polymer modification resulted in a slight decrease in total
Permeability void ratio regardless of type of aggregate. The compressive strength of porous concrete using recycled
Compressive strength aggregate was lower the one using normal aggregate. However, the compressive strengths of porous con-
Flexural strength cretes using normal and recycled aggregates were significantly improved by 57% and 79% respectively,
Polymer–cement ratio due to polymer modification. The use of recycled aggregate along with optimum content of polymer
Total void ratio could produce acceptable porous concrete with both enough drainage and strength properties.
Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0950-0618/$ - see front matter Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2013.06.022
1244 M. Aamer Rafique Bhutta et al. / Construction and Building Materials 47 (2013) 1243–1248
system of high porosity and interconnected voids to quickly drain tures. The aim was to enhance the strength of porous concrete, particularly the one
incorporating recycled aggregate. The properties of polymeric admixtures are given
off water, its poresity depends upon application and size of aggre-
in Table 2.
gate. Porous concrete (no-fines concrete) is a unique and effective
environmentally friendly material that is being extensively devel-
2.2. Mix proportions
oped and used for last four decades in North America, Europe
and Japan in various applications such as to reduce the amount The porous concrete mixtures comprised of Portland cement, water and coarse
of runoff water and improve the water quality near pavements aggregate containing normal and recycled aggregates. To improve the strength of
and parking lots [5–10]. Due to water-permeating, water-draining, porous concrete, latex polymer in powder and liquid forms were used. Various pre-
liminary mixes were prepared to obtain the optimum mix proportion of porous
and water-retaining performances of porous concrete, it has been
concrete. Polymer was first mixed with mix design water and no extra water was
utilized in road pavement, sidewalks, parks and building extension, added. The optimum mix proportions are presented in Table 3. The polymer–ce-
as well as for plant bedding and permeable gutters [5,11–15]. ment ratios (P/C) of 0%, 3% and 5% by mass of cement were used. Porous concrete
Unfortunately, no technical data and information are available on has already low water–cement ratio. Therefore, it is important to maintain the
mix design water content in porous concrete for proper mixing. High water absorp-
development activities and applications of porous concrete in
tion of recycled aggregate may result in lower water content in the mix. This could
South East Asia particularly, Malaysia. Located near the equator, affect the mixing adversely and the produced concrete will have large void ratio,
Malaysia’s climate is categorized as equatorial being hot and hu- low strength and may not fulfil the specific mix design requirements. Therefore,
mid throughout the year. The average rainfall is 2500 mm a year recycled aggregate used were first pre-soaked for 12 h prior to casting. Aim was
[16], necessitating the introduction and popularization of porous to avoid the absorption of mix water by the aggregates in fresh mixture.
Ordinary Portland cement was used in this study. Crushed granite aggregate JCI Test Method (Report on Eco-Concrete Committee for Void
and waste crushed concrete were used as normal and recycled aggregates, respec- Ratio of Porous Concrete (draft) was employed to determine the to-
tively. A source of recycled aggregate is shown in Fig. 1. The crushing of waste con- tal void ratio of porous concrete cylinders (u100 200 mm) [19].
crete was carried out inside the laboratory. Recycled aggregate was not washed and The total void ratio was obtained by dividing the difference be-
used as is. Table 1 shows the properties of aggregates. The aggregate size distribu-
tion of normal and recycled aggregates is demonstrated in Fig. 2. Commercially
tween the initial mass (M1) of the cylinder specimen in the water
available styrene butadiene rubber (SBR) based redispersible polymer powder and the final mass (M2) measured following air drying for 24 h
(RPP) and latex emulsion (Latex) were used as polymeric admixtures into the mix- with the specimen volume (V), where qM is the density of water.
Table 1
Physical properties of aggregate.
Type Gradation (mm) Density (g/cm3) Water absorption (%) Absolutea volume (%) Unit weight (kg/m3)
Normal aggregate 5–20 2.55 1.2 55.6 1620
Recycled aggregate 5–22 2.34 4.6 57.5 1542
a
Absolute volume = aggregate mass/density.
cled aggregate compared to porous concrete incorporating normal strength of porous concretes improved 26% and 57% for normal
aggregate. This could be due to reduction of bonding between aggregate, and 47% and 79% for recycled aggregate. The compres-
aggregate and cement paste when using recycled aggregate and sive strength was also enhanced using latex with the same P/C ra-
partly by the increased void ratio. Generally, it is expected that tios and increments in strength were 19% and 47% for normal
the compressive strength of porous concrete is related to the aggregate, and 43% and 68% for recycled aggregate. It is believed
strength of aggregate and total void ratio. A polymer modification that the addition of RPP gave greatly improved internal cohesion
is considered and incorporated into the mixtures to improve the and water retention between cement matrix and aggregate and in-
strength of porous concrete, particularly, the one using recycled creased the bonding force between neighbouring aggregate parti-
aggregate. It is evident that the addition of both RPP and latex cles [10].
could increase the compressive strength of all porous concretes
as well as increase the contact area between neighbouring aggre-
gate particles, more importantly; these commingle along with ce- 4.3. Effect of recycled aggregate and polymer on relationship between
ment hydration products and create two interpenetrating total void ratio and compressive strength
matrices which work together, resulting in improved compressive
strength [6,17]. The mean value of compressive strength of porous Fig. 6 represents the effect of aggregate type on relationship be-
concrete is fairly uniform in three specimens as depicted by varia- tween total void ratio and compressive strength of porous concrete
tion bars. without polymer. The variation in total void ratio is the mean of
The compressive strengths of porous concretes using normal three identical specimens. Effect of polymer type (polymer–ce-
and recycled aggregates improved significantly due to polymer ment ratio: 5%) on relationship between total void ratio and com-
modification. At P/C ratios of 3% and 5% for RAA, the compressive pressive strength of porous concrete using recycled aggregate is
Fig. 4. Total void ratio vs. type of porous concrete. Fig. 5. Compressive strength of porous concrete.
M. Aamer Rafique Bhutta et al. / Construction and Building Materials 47 (2013) 1243–1248 1247
Fig. 9. Effect of aggregate type on relationship between total void ratio and
Fig. 8. Coefficient of water permeability vs. type of porous concrete. coefficient of water permeability.
Acknowledgments
References
[1] Mohammad TU, Awal MA, Mahbub AA, Mohammad RH. Recycling of
demolished concrete as coarse aggregate. In: Proceeding of international
conference on advances in cement based materials and applications in civil
Fig. 11. Flexural strength vs. type of porous concrete, Note, : total void ratio. infrastructure (ACBM-ACI), Civil Engineering Department, University of
Engineering and Technology, Lahore, Pakistan, A-One Publishers, Lahore;
tion products [17]. Unlike the brittle cement paste, the polymer 2007. p. 1077–89.
[2] FHWA, Transportation applications of recycled concrete aggregate. Federal
network is relatively strong in tension zone, which contributes sig- Highway Administration, Washington, D.C.; September 2004. p. 47.
nificantly to the flexural strength of porous concrete. [3] ACI Committee 555. Removal and reuse of hardened concrete. ACI Mater J
2002; 99(3): p. 300–25.
[4] RILEM Recommendation. 121-DRG guidance for demolition and reuse concrete
5. Conclusions and masonary, Specifications for concrete with recycled aggregates. Mater
Struct 1994; 27: p. 557–9.
An experimental study was conducted to investigate the prop- [5] Tamai M, Mizuguchi H, Hatanaka S, Katahira H, Nakazawa T, Yanagibashi K,
Kunieda M. Design, construction and recent applications of porous concrete in
erties of polymer-modified porous concretes prepared from nor- Japan. In: Proceedings of the JCI symposium on design, construction and recent
mal and recycled aggregates. The effects of using recycled applications of porous concrete, Japan Concrete Institute; Tokyo, April, 2004. p.
aggregate and polymer modification on total void ratio, permeabil- 1–10.
[6] Huang B, Wu H, Shu X, Burdette EG. Laboratory evaluation of permeability and
ity and strength were evaluated. Based on this study, the following strength of polymer-modified pervious concrete. Construct Build Mater
conclusions can be drawn: 2010;24(5):818–23.
[7] Shu X, Huang B, Wu H, Dong Q, Burdette EG. Performance comparison of
laboratory and field produced pervious concrete mixtures. Constr Build Mater
(1) The total void ratio of porous concrete incorporating recy- 2011;25(8):3187–92.
cled aggregate was higher than those having normal aggre- [8] Wu H, Huang B, Shu X, Dong Q. Laboratory evaluation of abrasion resistance of
gate. The addition of polymer modification resulted in a Portland cement pervious concrete. J Mater Civ Eng 2010;23(5):697–702.
[9] Huang B, Dong Q, Burdette EG. Laboratory evaluation of incorporating waste
slight decrease in total void ratio regardless of type of aggre- ceramic materials into Portland cement and asphaltic concrete. Constr Build
gate. The total void ratios were achieved within the accept- Mater 2009;23(12):3451–6.
able range of 22–28% for recycled aggregate porous [10] Aamer Rafique Bhutta M, Tsuruta K, Mirza J. Evaluation of high-performance
porous concrete properties. Constr Build Mater 2012;31:67–73.
concretes.
[11] Beeldens A. Influence of polymer modification on the behavior of concrete
(2) The compressive strength for porous concrete using recycled under severe conditions. Ph. D. dissertation, Faculty of Engineering, Katholieke
aggregate was lower than the normal aggregate porous con- Universiteit, Leuven, Belgium; 2002. p. 248.
[12] Beeldens A, Van Gemert D, Caestecker C, Van Messem M. Mechanical
crete. However, the strength was significantly improved due
Properties and Structure of Porous Concrete. In: Proceedings of the 8th
to polymer modification by 57% for natural aggregate and international symposium on concrete roads, Lisbon; 1998. p. 129–34.
79% for recycled aggregate at P/C of 5% for RPP. [13] Monters F. Pervious concrete: characterization of fundamental properties and
(3) All the porous concretes showed coefficient of water perme- simulation of microstructure, PhD dissertation, University of South Carolina;
2006.
ability values between 2.4 to 3.7 cm/s, which is high enough [14] Kajio S, Tanaka S, Tomita R, Noda E, Hashimoto S. Properties of porous concrete
to be used as a drainage pavement. with high strength. In: Proceedings of the 8th international symposium on
(4) Regardless of type of aggregate and polymer, results showed concrete roads, Lisbon; 1998. p. 171–7.
[15] Wang W. Study of pervious concrete strength. Sci Technol Build Mater China
an almost linear relationship between the compressive 1997;6(3):25–8.
strength and total void ratio, and between coefficient of per- [16] Swee-Hock S. The population of peninsular Malaysia, Singapore Institute of
meability and total void ratio for all porous concretes. Southeast Asian Studies, ISBN 978-981-230-730-9; 2007. p. 1–2.
[17] Ohama Y. Handbook of polymer-modified concrete and mortars: properties
(5) The addition of polymer increases the workability of cement and process technology. New Jersey: Noyes Publications; 1995.
paste and allows the aggregate to flow better. This decreases [18] Kardon JB. Polymer-modified porous concrete review. ASCE J Mater Civil Eng
the void ratio and increases the strength of porous concrete. 1997;9(2):85–91.
[19] Japan Concrete Institute. In: Proceedings of the JCI symposium on design,
(6) Use of recycled aggregate along with polymer modification
construction and recent applications of porous concrete, Japan Concrete
could produce acceptable porous concrete having both Institute, Tokyo; 2004, p. 1–10.
enough drainage and strength properties.