Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
OF JURISPRUDENCE
By Serena Trezise
The Fitzroy Town Hall was the first home of the radical Fitzroy Legal Service
Photo: Committee for Urban action at State Library of Victoria (www.slv.gov.au)
1
Melbourne’s skid row
Walking the streets of Fitzroy lined with brunch hotspots, rooftop bars, yoga
studios and organic food stores, you could be forgiven for forgetting that just
fifty years ago the suburb was considered one of the most disadvantaged and
dangerous in Victoria.3 In the early 1970s, Fitzroy was renowned as the place
where more murders were committed per square inch than anywhere else in
the state.4 High rates of unemployment and homelessness, a large immigrant
population, and a reputation as a meeting place for disaffected youths meant
that this now hipster haven was widely regarded as Melbourne’s skid row.5
For many in the Fitzroy community, their experience of poverty went hand in
hand with a lack of understanding around their rights. 6 This allowed
authorities such as the police and the Housing Commission to push people
around with little or no repercussions.7 Many residents complained of police
brutality 8 , while Housing Commission tenants struggled to enforce basic
entitlements and were frequently evicted for trivial reasons.9 As no national
2
legal aid scheme then existed and state schemes were extremely restrictive
and difficult to access 10 , there was very little advice and representation
available to low-income earners wanting to ascertain and assert their legal
rights.11
The 1960s and early 70s saw the rise of transnational protest movements.12
These recognised government and market failures to ensure that the civil
rights and liberties of all people were protected equally.13 Protest culture
became synonymous with youth culture as an unprecedented demographic of
young people expressed their frustration with conservative governments and
structures though nonviolent campaigns and civil disobedience.14 In Australia,
support for Aboriginal rights, anti-war rallies, and the women’s liberation
movement were sites of protest that demonstrated the power of collective
action to demand social change.15
3
In this context of radicalism and activism, the inaccessibility of the law and
legal processes to disadvantaged and marginalised people was increasingly
recognised as a rights issue.16 In America, community legal centres had
operated since the 1930s and the provision of free legal advice and
representation was considered instrumental in the Johnson administration’s
‘war on poverty’ in the 1960s.17 The absence of similar government support in
Australia did not deter local activists, who recognised the potential for free,
shop-front legal assistance to empower disadvantaged communities.18
In Fitzroy, youth worker John Finlayson saw the potential for a free legal
service to similarly empower his young clients who frequently faced court on
charges of theft, assault and car theft.23 Finlayson told the Nation Review that
nearly all kids from Fitzroy and surrounding neighbourhoods had police
records, and were resigned to the prospect of gaol when facing charges
4
because they couldn’t afford legal representation and didn’t know how to
defend themselves.24 In 1972, Finlayson and his colleagues Michael O’Brien
and Lou Hill organised a public meeting to discuss the establishment of a free
legal service in Fitzroy.25
5
Open for Business!
Photo: Age, 20 December 1972, 5
Fitzroy is revolting!
The Fitzroy Legal Service set out to revolutionise the way legal assistance
was provided. Private legal offices were considered inaccessible to
disadvantaged people not only because of their fees, but their inner-city
locations, opening hours and sense of formality.31 Language barriers were a
deterrent for both non-English speakers and for everyday people confronted
with complicated legal jargon.32 To improve the accessibility of legal help to
low-income earners, volunteers at the service were encouraged to dress in
causal clothing and conduct their dealings with clients as informally and in the
plainest language possible.33 Non-legal volunteers would often attend client
interviews with lawyers to make sure advice was understandable to someone
without legal training and interpreters were on hand to assist clients from non-
English speaking backgrounds.34 The service was located in the heart of the
community and opened from 5.30pm until 11pm five nights per week, so that
clients could attend outside work hours.35 The shabby, cramped offices were
a world away from the intimidating wood-panelled, leather-scented, hushed
6
realm of private legal practice.36 It was hoped that this new mode of service
delivery would give the local community confidence that they could access
and understand information about their legal rights.37 On any given night
volunteers would assist a broad range of problems, from drug offences to theft
and divorce, housing disputes, sex offences and murder.38
7
Ch-Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes
The service’s commitment to bringing about social reform was not just
aspirational. When underlying issues were identified, test cases and advocacy
were employed to bring about practical change. Several clients, for example,
presented at the service having been pressured into entering credit
agreements with the Waltons chain of department stores that they could not
afford to repay.47 The service defended one of these clients against a debt-
recovery action that Waltons had initiated in the Magistrates’ Court.48 It was
successfully argued that Waltons’ contracts breached the Money Lenders Act
and that, as the store didn’t have a money lender’s license, it could not
enforce its credit agreements.49 This case resulted in change beyond one
client’s success in court. A whole class of vulnerable consumers benefited
from the store being brought within the constraints of the Money Lenders Act.
8
The service also partnered with the newly opened La Trobe University Legal
Studies Department- a world leader in the study of law as a social institution51-
to produce the Legal Resources Book, a layperson’s guide to common legal
problems.52 This publication proved to be a hit, with thousands of copies
selling in just a few weeks.53 In an interview with the Age, lawyer Julian
Gardner claimed that the book had become a household staple, similar to a
dictionary.54 He attributed the book’s success to the fact that it was meeting a
real community need for legal education. 55 Sales provided much-needed
funds for the service, which originally survived on the generosity of volunteers
and supporters and ad-hoc government grants.56
9
brought about major changes in the way legal services, and in particular legal
aid, is delivered in Australia.
A radical legacy?
The service’s dual aims of providing accessible legal assistance on one hand,
and community education and social reform on the other have remained
central to its operation and the operation of community legal centres
generally.65 Given the limited resources of most free legal services, these
aims have at times proven difficult to balance.66 Government funding tied
solely to the provision of direct legal advice has led to claims that community
legal centres have been co-opted by the very system they set out to disrupt.67
In response to this challenge, it has been argued that it is essential for
community legal centres to continue to harness, nurture and embody the
radical urge for social justice of the 1960s and 70s.68 Continuing to agitate for
social change on behalf of disadvantaged and vulnerable people will ensure
that community legal centres continue the radical and important legacy of the
Fitzroy Legal Service.
10
Bibliography
Primary Sources
Attwood, Alan, ‘Fitzroy police station tries to maintain a positive outlook’, Age, 30 Jul. 1983,
p. 5 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 16 Oct. 2018.
Beattie, Max, ‘70,000 marchers take over city: Big M-day sit-down for peace’, Age, 9 May
1970, p. 1 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Childs, Kevin, ‘Lawyers open free legal aid centre in Fitzroy’, Age. 27 Dec. 1972, p. 5 in
Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Chubb, Phillip, ‘Eviction-it’s an offer you can’t refuse’, Age, 17 Jul. 1974, p. 12 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
‘Dressed like this, the law looks human to the young’, Age, 2 July 1986, p. 5 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
‘Free Legal Aid, and in a variety of sizes’, Age, 27 Jan. 1997, p. 2 in Newspapers Publisher
Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Grattan, Michelle, Aboriginies get a new voice’, Age, 27 Nov. 1972, p. 9 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Hardy, Graham, ‘Lawyers to hunt cases in the pubs’, Sydney Morning Herald, 10 Feb. 1980,
p. 17 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Innes, Prue, ‘Sergeant must pay bash victim’s costs’, Age, 30 Jul. 1983, p. 5 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 16 Oct. 2018.
-- ‘Fitzroy legal service tots up client 30,000’, Age, 14 Mar. 1985, p. 17 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 13 Oct.
‘Maltreatment Alleged Over Eviction’, Age, 8 Dec. 1958, p. 7 in Newspapers Publisher Extra
[online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Mayne, Gillian, ‘What the women’s march was about’, Sydney Morning Herald, 13 Mar. 1972,
p. 8 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
O’Connor, Ursula, ‘Aborigines and the law’, Sydney Morning Herald, 30 Mar. 1971, p. 7 in
Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 16 Oct. 2018.
Sayers, Stuart, ‘Bringing law to the people’, Age, 1 Jan. 1983, p. 42 in Newspapers Publisher
Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018;
Sturgess, Gary, ‘Ten years on, book launch marks new legal deal for the poor’, Age, 18 Dec.
1982, p. 13 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
11
‘Young Men Without Work or Friends Trouble In Fitzroy’, Age, 25 Sept. 1963, p. 6 in
Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 18 Oct. 2018.
Williams, Graham, ‘A job for the left-over lawyers’, Sydney Morning Herald, 9 Sep. 1977, p. 7
in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Secondary Sources
Armstrong, Susan, ‘What has Happened to Legal Aid?’, University of Western Sydney Law
Review, 5/1 (2001), 91.
Biondo, Sam & Field, Chris, ‘Back to the Future: 25 years of Fitzroy Legal Service’, Alternative
Law Journal, 22/6 (1997), 282.
Chesterman, John, Poverty Law and Social Change: The Story of the Fitzroy Legal Service
(Cartlon South, VIC: Melbourne University Press, 1996).
-- ‘Twenty Years of the Fitzroy Legal Service: A Look Back for a Look Forward’, Alternative
Law Journal, 17/6 (1992), 257.
Della-Vergini, Arna, ‘Sex-starved, suit-wearing volunteers say ‘we don’t know’ to service
restructuring: Volunteers at the Fitzroy Legal Service’, Alternative Law Journal, 22/6
(1997), 287.
Foley, Gary, ‘Black Power in Redfern 1968 – 1972’, The Koori History Website, (5 Oct.
2001)<http://www.kooriweb.org/foley/essays/pdf_essays/black%20power%20in%20r
edfern%201968.pdf >, accessed 4 Sept. 2018
McCulloch, Jude & Blair, Megan, ‘From Maverick to Mainstream: Forty years of Community
Legal Centres’, Alternative Law Journal, 31/1 (2012),12.
Neal, David, ‘Delivery of Legal Services: The Innovative Approach of the Fitzroy Legal
Service’, Melbourne University Law Review, 11 (1978) 427.
-- ‘Law and Power: Livin’ in the 70s’, Law in Context, 29/2 (2013) 99.
Noble, Peter, ‘The Future of Community Legal Centres’, Alternative Law Journal, 37/1 (2012),
22.
Rich, Nicole, ‘Reclaiming Community Legal Centres’ (Report, Victoria Law Foundation
Community Legal Centre Fellowship 2007-8, 2008).
Van Moorst, Harry, Fitzroy Legal Service (Honours Thesis, University of Melbourne, 1973).
12
Images
Aboriginal People and Torres Strait Islander Peoples – Industry and Employment – Aboriginal
Legal Aid Service, Redfern, 1974, c. 1974, National Library of Australia, Canberra, in TROVE
[online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Beattie, Max, ‘70,000 marchers take over city: Big M-day sit-down for peace’, Age, 9 May
1970, p. 1 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Childs, Kevin, ‘Lawyers open free legal aid centre in Fitzroy’, Age. 27 Dec. 1972, p. 5 in
Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Collins, John T., Fitzroy Town Hall, c. 19 Sep. 1971, State Library of Victoria, Melbourne, in
State Library of Victoria Digital Image Pool [online database] accessed 13 Oct. 2018.
Committee for Urban Action, Napier Street, Fitzroy, from Moor Street – west side, c. 1970-
1974, State Library of Victoria, Melbourne, in State Library of Victoria Digital Image Pool
[online database], accessed 13 Oct. 2018.
Committee for Urban Action, George Street, Fitzroy, from Webb Street to Gertrude Street –
west side, c. 1970-1974, State Library of Victoria, Melbourne, in State Library of Victoria
Digital Image Pool [online database] accessed 13 Oct. 2018.
‘Dressed like this, the law looks human to the young’, Age, 2 July 1986, p. 5 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Ellis, Rennie, T-Shirt, “Fitzroy Legal Service…”, c. 198-?, National Library of Australia,
Canberra, in TROVE [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Halla, K. J., Russell Street west, c. 1972, State Library of Victoria, Melbourne, in State Library
of Victoria Digital Image Pool [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Wells, Diana, Puzzled by the Legal System?, c. 1986, State Library of Victoria, Melbourne, in
State Library of Victoria Digital Image Pool [online database] accessed 13 Oct. 2018.
13
Endnotes
1
‘Community Legal Centres’ National Association of Community Legal Centres [website],
(2018) <http://www.naclc.org.au/cb_pages/clcs.php> para. 1, accessed 13 October 2018.
2
Ibid.
3
John Chesterman, Poverty Law and Social Change: The Story of the Fitzroy Legal Service
(Cartlon South, VIC: Melbourne University Press, 1996), p. 47.
4
Ibid.
5
Kevin Childs, ‘Lawyers open free legal aid centre in Fitzroy’, Age. 27 Dec. 1972, p. 5 in
Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018; ‘Place of Paradox (2)
Fitzroy at Crossroads’, Age, 20 Nov. 1963, p. 25 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online
database] accessed 17 Oct. 2018.
6
Chesterman, op. cit., p. 66.
7
Childs, loc. cit.
8
‘Punched by policeman, court told’, Age, 27 Feb. 1975, p. 10 in Newspapers Publisher Extra
[online database] accessed 16 Oct. 2018; Alan Attwood, ‘Fitzroy police station tries to
maintain a positive outlook’, Age, 30 Jul. 1983, p. 5 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online
database] accessed 16 Oct. 2018; Prue Innes, ‘Sergeant must pay bash victim’s costs’, Age,
30 Jul. 1983, p. 5 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 16 Oct. 2018.
9
Childs, loc. cit.; ‘Maltreatment Alleged Over Eviction’, Age, 8 Dec. 1958, p. 7 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018; Philip Chubb, ‘Eviction-it’s an offer
you can’t refuse’, Age, 17 Jul. 1974, p. 12 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database]
accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
10 Harry Van Moorst, Fitzroy Legal Service (Honours Thesis, University of Melbourne, 1973)
p. 18.
11
David Neal, ‘Law and Power: Livin’ in the 70s’, Law in Context, 29/2 (2013), p. 101.
12
Jude McCulloch and Megan Blair, ‘From Maverick to Mainstream: Forty years of
Community Legal Centres’, Alternative Law Journal, 31/1 (2012), p. 13.
13
Ibid.
14
Sam Biondo and Chris Field, ‘Back to the Future: 25 years of Fitzroy Legal Service’,
Alternative Law Journal, 22/6 (1997), 283.; ‘Youth in Ferment’, Age, ‘Education’, 9 Jun. 1970,
p. 14 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
15
Ibid; Michelle Grattan, ‘Aboriginies get a new voice’, Age, 27 Nov. 1972, p. 9 in
Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018; Max Beattie, ’70,000
marchers take over city: Big M-day sit-down for peace’, Age, 9 May 1970, p. 1 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018; Gillian Mayne, ‘What the women’s
march was about’, Sydney Morning Herald, 13 Mar. 1972, p. 8 in Newspapers Publisher Extra
[online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
Chesterman op. cit., p, 13.
16
17
Susan Armstrong, ‘What has Happened to Legal Aid?’, University of Western Sydney Law
Review, 5/1 (2001), p. 96.
18
Chesterman, loc. cit.
19
Gary Foley, ‘Black Power in Redfern 1968 – 1972’, The Koori History Website, (5 Oct.
2001)<http://www.kooriweb.org/foley/essays/pdf_essays/black%20power%20in%20redfern%
201968.pdf >, p. 12, accessed 4 Sept. 2018; Ursula O’Connor, ‘Aborigines and the law’,
Sydney Morning Herald, 30 Mar. 1971, p. 7 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database]
accessed 16 Oct. 2018.
20
Ibid.
21
Ibid.
22
Ibid.
23
Chesterman, op. cit., p. 27; ‘Young Men Without Work or Friends Trouble In Fitzroy’, Age,
25 Sept. 1963, p. 6 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 18 Oct. 2018.
24
Chesterman, loc. cit.
Neal op. cit., p. 104.
25
26
Sam Biondo and Chris Field, loc. cit.
27
Ibid.
14
28
John Chesterman, ‘Twenty Years of the Fitzroy Legal Service: A Look Back for a Look
Forward’, Alternative Law Journal, 17/6 (1992), p. 257.
29
David Neal, ‘Delivery of Legal Services: The Innovative Approach of the Fitzroy Legal
Service’, Melbourne University Law Review, 11 (1978) p. 427.
30
Van Moorst, op. cit., p. 55.
31
Ibid., p. 27.
32
‘Dressed like this, the law looks human to the young’, Age, 2 July 1986, p. 5 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 October 2018.
33
Ibid., Chesterman, Poverty Law and Social Change, op. cit., p. 49;
34
Ibid., p. 54.
35
Cilds, loc. cit., Chesterman, Poverty Law and Social Change, op. cit., p. 42
36
Neal, Law and Power, op. cit., p. 101.
37
Arna Della-Vergini, ‘Sex-starved, suit-wearing volunteers say ‘we don’t know’ to service
restructuring: Volunteers at the Fitzroy Legal Service’, Alternative Law Journal, 22/6 (1997), p.
287.
38
Van Moorst, op. cit., p. 70.
39
Ibid., Della-Vergini loc. cit.
40
Nicole Rich, ‘Reclaiming Community Legal Centres’ (Report, Victoria Law Foundation
Community Legal Centre Fellowship 2007-8, 2008) p. 36.
41
Chesterman, Twenty Years of the Fitzroy Legal Service, op.cit., p. 259.
42
Van Moorst, op. cit., p. 39.
Chesterman, Poverty Law and Social Change, op. cit., p. 55.
43
44 Graham Hardy, ‘Lawyers to hunt cases in the pubs’, Sydney Morning Herald, 10 Feb.
1980, p. 17 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
45 Chesterman, Twenty Years of the Fitzroy Legal Service, op. cit., p. 259.
46 Van Moorst, op. cit., p. 38.
47
Chesterman, Twenty Years of the Fitzroy Legal Service, loc. cit.
Chesterman, Poverty Law and Social Change, op. cit., p. 99.
48
49
Ibid.
50
‘Free Legal Aid, and in a variety of sizes’, Age, 27 Jan. 1997, p. 2 in Newspapers Publisher
Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
51
Neal, Law and Power, op. cit., p. 103.
52
Stuart Sayers, ‘Bringing law to the people’, Age, 1 Jan. 1983, p. 42 in Newspapers
Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
53
Ibid.; Gary Sturgess, ‘Ten years on, book launch marks new legal deal for the poor’, Age,
18 Dec. 1982, p. 13 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 Oct. 2018.
54
Sayers, loc. cit.
55
Ibid.
56
Van Moorst, op. cit., p. 44.
57
Ibid., p. 45.
58
Ibid., p. 46.
59
Chesterman, Twenty Years of the Fitzroy Legal Service, op. cit., 258; Prue Innes, ‘Fitzroy
legal service tots up client 30,000’, Age, 14 Mar. 1985, p. 17 in Newspapers Publisher Extra
[online database] accessed 13 October 2018.
60
Chesterman, Poverty Law and Social Change, op. cit., p. 1.
61
Ibid.
Neal, Law and Power, op.cit., p.109.
62
63
Biondo and Field, loc. cit.
64
Ibid; Graham Williams, ‘A job for the left-over lawyers’, Sydney Morning Herald, 9 Sep.
1977, p. 7 in Newspapers Publisher Extra [online database] accessed 14 October 2018.
65
Rich, loc. cit.
66
Ibid.
67
Biondo and Field, op. cit., p. 285.
68
Peter Noble, ‘The Future of Community Legal Centres’, Alternative Law Journal, 37/1
(2012), p. 25.
15