Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
h i g h l i g h t s
Banana leaf ash was assessed as pozzolanic materials in concrete and mortar products.
Banana leaf ash demonstrated pozzolanic activity index with a strength of 7.900 MPa.
Worldwide productions of banana may generate up to 10 million tons of ashes from their leaves.
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The worldwide productions of banana were bigger than 95 million tons, which resemble to, approxi-
Received 13 September 2013 mately, 10.22 million tons of ashes. Additions of these residues or banana leaf ash (BLA) in mortars were
Received in revised form 2 December 2013 investigated by ratios of 0–10% in replacement to weight of the Portland cement as pozzolanic materials.
Accepted 16 December 2013
The products were characterized by chemical compositions, SEM, rheology and pozzolanic activity index.
Available online 23 January 2014
Hardened materials were characterized by tearing it in walls. The mechanical and chemical resistance
performances of 10% and 20% BLA concrete samples were also evaluated by artificial ageing chambers.
Keywords:
The BLA was considered a pozzolan material.
Banana leaf ash
Pozzolan
Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Mortar
Concrete
Materials characterization
1. Introduction amorphous silica in small particle size, with high surface area
and low loss on ignition; and, the second, by Pedrozo [12], whose
The application and use of mineral admixtures in mortar and researched the utilization of 15% and 25% ratios of residual rice
concrete have been widely studied in recent decades to improve rush ashes in structural concrete for long life span on chloride envi-
the resistance and durability of their composites and reduce the ronment exposition. Their products performances had decreased
cement consumption, because of the substitution of this material the cement consumption, had increased the mechanical and chem-
in rates of 8–10% [1–9]. In addition, unusual and wasted materials ical resistances of Portland concrete and had reduced the conse-
in concrete may prove to be technically feasible solutions to quent environmental impact in agriculture and construction areas.
improve good performance, diminishing costs of production and A pozzolan material is defined by ASTM C 125-13 [13] as a prod-
reducing local environmental impact [3,7,10]. As examples, two uct that has chemical structure based on siliceous or siliceous and
cases of important natural materials assessed in Brazil to the civil aluminous material, with little or no portions of cement but that
engineering areas as pozzolan can be cited: the first one is the will, in finely divided form and with water, it reacts chemically
bagasse ashes, investigated by Cordeiro et al. [11] which identified with calcium hydroxide at ordinary temperatures to form com-
their high pozzolanic activity, attributed to the presence of pounds that has cementitious properties. The pozzolanic activity
arises from the reaction of amorphous silica with Ca(OH)2 to form
calcium silicate hydrate gel as the basic reaction presented in the
Eq. (1).
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +55 41 3361 6220; fax: +55 41 3361 6141.
E-mail address: kfportella@pq.cnpq.br (K.F. Portella). xSiO2 þ yCaO þ zH2 O ¡ xCaO ySiO2 zH2 O ð1Þ
0950-0618/$ - see front matter Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2013.12.030
R.C. Kanning et al. / Construction and Building Materials 54 (2014) 460–465 461
2. Experimental
2.1. Materials
Fig. 1. (a) Schematic drawing of the prismatic reinforcing bar; (b) view of the metal and graphite bars and their dimensions (mm); and (c) electrochemical electrodes (WE –
carbon steel CA-50; CE – graphite electrode; and CSE – reference electrode).
462 R.C. Kanning et al. / Construction and Building Materials 54 (2014) 460–465
Table 1
Results for the tensile strength in bending and axial compressive strength of BLA mortars.
Table 2
Average adherence strength of the BLA mortars (MPa).
Fig. 4. Photograph illustrating the rupture face of the 10% BLA mortar specimen
after the bonding strength test. The highlighted region (lighter shade) A shows the
substrate, B is the mortar, and its interface has added grout (darker).
Fig. 3. SEM micrograph and EDS spectra at fracture surface of the mortar with
10% BLA after 56 days of natural environment ageing. Magnification: 650. EDS diameter of 6.3 mm and a length of 125 mm, as shown schematically in Fig. 1.
spectra – region A, gel with Si/Ca = 1.10 and Al/Ca = 0.38 relationships; and region The bars were previously polished to reduce the passivation oxide layer and there-
B: gel composition – Si/Ca = 0.65 and Al/Ca = 0.25 relationships. fore prevent the inclusion of an additional variable in the electrochemical system. A
delimited central bar area of approximately 220 mm2 was left by encapsulating the
bars with insulating tape at both of ends (as shown in the schematic drawing in
After periods of curing, the samples were pulled out by a saw cup with a diam- Fig. 1(b and c)). In this case, a bar of graphite was used as the counter electrode.
eter of 50 mm and a maximum depth of (18 ± 2) mm. The specimens were analyzed The corrosion potential measurements and the impedance tests were per-
by the pullout test as recommended [10,32]. formed according to the literature [33,34] after 11 months of ageing times. The
The results of the potential resistance of the tensile adherence of the mortars guidelines described in ASTM C876 [33] provide basic principles for the evaluation
were obtained by Eq. (3), and the rupture surface was analyzed according to their of the reinforcing steel corrosion in concrete and indicate the relative probability of
form of disruption on mortar interface|ceramic blocks or substrates. corrosion activity as a function of the half-cell potential reading for a Cu/CuSO4
(CSE) reference electrode. These values were referred to oxidation potentials.
Ri ¼ P i =Ai ð3Þ The specimens were then exposed in a standard cyclic salt spray chamber [35]
and a humidity chamber (95 RH%, (25 ± 2) °C) for a period longer than 150 days and
where, Ri is the adherence resistance to traction (MPa), Pi is the rupture load (N) and then analyzed by EIS tests in maximum intervals of 20 days.
Ai is the area of the specimen (mm2). To investigate the factory performance BLA concrete with 10% (%weight/binder
weight) cement substitution was also casted as cross arms for electrical distribu-
2.4. Concrete specimens tions networks, with a 0.5% (W/B) ratio and a slump result of 300 mm. The basic
proportion was 1:1.6:2.56:0.5:0.1:1.0 (cement:sand:gravel:water:BLA:additive).
Concrete cylinders of 100 mm diameter and 200 mm high were used to deter- The CPII-Z 32 cement consumption was 425 kg m3.
mine the compressive and flexural strength. The concrete samples were removed
from their molds after casting for 24 h, cured in water for 28 days and analyzed
at 7, 28 and 91 days. 3. Results and discussion
The micrographic analyses of fractured concrete surfaces were performed using
a XL30 model Philips Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM). Gold was applied to the 3.1. Raw materials
surfaces by sputtering.
The open circuit potential (OCP) or corrosion potential by electrochemical
impedance spectroscopy (EIS) tests were performed on reinforced concrete speci-
The aggregate was classified as quartz with a maximum dimen-
mens. The specimens were cast in rectangular sections of (91 49) mm and sion of 4.8 mm without the presence of deleterious substances
100 mm high, with three longitudinal bars of carbon steel CA-50 with a nominal above the limits of the standard [17]. The coarse aggregates were
R.C. Kanning et al. / Construction and Building Materials 54 (2014) 460–465 463
2000
1500 -2
3,76.10 Hz 3.2. Mortar specimens
1000
500
The average content of entrained air in mortar with the addition
0 of 5%, 7.5%, and 10% was (7.66 ± 0.09)% and therefore it was lower
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000
than the reference (8.06 ± 0.14)%, what indicated a possible filler
Z' (Ω)
effect due the amount of fines added.
(b) The squeeze flow test by axial compression showed a similar
rheological behavior between the compositions studied. The BLA
Fig. 5. (a) Corrosion potentials of uncoated reinforcing steel in concrete submitted samples presented smaller deformation than the reference mortar.
to 95RH% and a temperature of (23 ± 2) °C and (b) EIS complex plane diagram This result was possible due the reduced quantity of air incorpo-
(Nyquist) spectra 10% BLA rebar as a function of the cyclic salt spray time of
rated by the angled faces that forms its microstructure. Thus, more
exposure and CSE reference electrode.
effort may be needed to spread it on floors and walls, diminishing
its productivity.
characterized as basaltic rock with a maximum feature size of The index of water retention of BLA mortars was higher than
9.5 mm. Their size distribution was in accordance to the recom- the reference one. They were classified as U4 for 10% BLA, U3 for
mendations of the standard and the literature [17–19]. 7.5 and 5% BLA, and U2 for the reference [38].
The results of the physical and chemical cement CPII F-32 The results of the tensile strength in bending and axial com-
and CP II Z 32 were in accordance to the materials specification pression are shown in Table 1. All of the BLA mortars presented
[21]. better performance than the reference ones. The reference mortar
The BLA used had an average particle diameter after milling of might be classified as R6 and the BLA mortars as P6 [28].
15 lm, approximately. The chemical composition of the particles, The specific mass of the BLA mortar was (1.91 ± 0.02) kg m3.
in terms of the main oxides, were SiO2 = 48.7%, Al2O3 = 2.6%, and This value is 3% higher than the reference.
Fe2O3 = 1.4%, and thus they met the requirements establishing a The capillarity coefficient decreased with the addition of BLA in
minimum content of 50% of these minerals [36]. The loss on igni- the mortar and was classified as C2 [38].
tion (5.06%) was close to the maximum stipulated limit (6%). The A micrograph of the fracture surface of a sample with 10% BLA
amount of Na2O, which is responsible for the appearance of efflo- aged during 56 days in natural environment is shown in Fig. 3, with
rescence or the occurrence of alkali aggregate reaction, was a magnification of 650. A standard monolithic mortar with low
0.21%, a value lower than 1.5%, the upper limit according to the porosity was observed in the region A with a gel composition of
standard. Because of its nature and composition, the BLA was Si/Ca = 1.10 and Al/Ca = 0.38 relationships, and B with a gel phase
classified as E [36]. based on Si/Ca = 0.65 and Al/Ca = 0.25 relationships.
Table 3
Circuit parameters (Rs – electrolyte resistance, Rp – charge transfer resistance, and CPE – constant phase element) and equivalent circuit model estimated for the 10% BLA rebar
system submitted to 28 days at 95 RH%, 90 days in cyclic salt spray, and 184 days in a cyclic salt spray ageing chamber.
The results of the average strength of adhesion of the mortar/ In Fig. 6 is shown the cross arms for electrical distribution net-
substrate surfaces of 28, 56 and 91 days and the locations of break- works casted with 10% BLA materials in substitution of same
age are shown in Table 2. weight ratio of binder (CPII Z 32 Portland cement). Their compres-
All mortar specimens had ruptured in the substrate and could sive strength results at 25 days after casting was 32.1 MPa, over
be classified as resistance blocks [32], which may be a result of then the product specification limit that is 25 MPa. The products
the lower porosity of the substrate surface due the penetration of were casted without factory alteration processes and will be test
cement slurry mortar particles into the blocks by the capillary ef- in Salvador seashore natural environment.
fect. The roughcast created a bridge between the adhesive and
the substrate mortar with a bigger contact area for plastering mor-
tar and thus improving the adherence. Then, the results showed 4. Conclusions
the disruption of the ceramic blocks, as shown in Fig. 4. For this
reason, the result cannot be classified according to the recommen- The BLA materials demonstrated pozzolanic activity index with
dation [38]. a strength of ((7.900 ± 0.098) MPa). They had good performance in
terms of the fresh state parameters and the mechanical behavior in
the hardened mortar state. The compressive strength until 10% BLA
3.3. Concrete samples mortar mixture was nearly 25% higher than the reference sample
and approximately 10% greater than that under tensile stress in
The mechanical strength of the concrete with 20% BLA was bending on average.
(48 ± 2) MPa at 28 days. This value was 12% higher than the 0% The mechanical strength of the concrete samples with 10% and
BLA one, at the same water/binder ratio. 20% BLA mixtures were (38 ± 2) MPa and (47 ± 2) MPa at 28 days,
The average tensile strength under diametrical compression of respectively. These values were 25% and 40% higher than the 0%
the composition having 20% BLA was (5.2 ± 0.7) MPa at 28 days, BLA. Both materials had good electrochemical parameters after
corresponding to an increase of approximately 20% with respect approximately 200 days in humidity and in the cyclic salt spray
to the 0% BLA. chamber ageing.
The resulting corrosion potentials (relative CSE reference elec- BLA can be used as pozzolanic material in civil structures with
trode) for the 0%, 10% and 20% BLA concrete samples are shown advantages such as lower costs and the equivalent reduction of
in Fig. 5(a) at time of exposure at 95 RH% humidity chamber. After environmental impacts resulting from the accumulation of this
approximately 300 days of exposure, neither of the BLA nor RC type of residue in the field. The concrete dosage with 10% BLA
concrete samples demonstrated high probability of reinforcing materials were satisfactory casted as cross arms for electrical dis-
steel bar corrosion. tribution networks factory production.
The EIS of concrete rebars, exposed to cyclic salt spray atmo-
sphere, showed that the behaviors of the BLA samples differ from
that observed in the RC, possibly due to the decrease of the alkali Acknowledgements
concentration present in first one, caused by the pozzolanic reac-
tion. Until 150 days of exposure, the 0% BLA samples showed a The authors wish to acknowledge the UFPR, COELBA, LACTEC,
greater tendency toward corrosion, with potential values in the re- CNPq and ANEEL for financial support and infrastructure.
gion of highest probability, as indicated by the standard [33].
The complex plane diagram (Nyquist) of the 10% BLA rebar at
References
time of the cyclic salt spray is illustrated in Fig. 5(b). In Table 3
are presented their EIS parameters evaluated by a schematic equiv- [1] Habeeb GA, Mahmud HB. Study on properties or rice husk ash and its use as
alent circuit. The results showed that there was no variation in the cement replacement material. Mater Res 2010;13:185.
[2] Safiuddin MD, West JS, Soudki KA. Flowing ability of the mortars formulated
electrolyte resistance of concrete, Rs. The charge transfer resistance
from self-compacting concretes incorporating rice husk ash. Constr Build
Rp diminished with ageing time in cyclic salt spray exposure. The Mater 2011;25:973.
equivalent circuit model was based on Feliu et al. [39]. [3] Chindaprasirt P, Rukzon S. Strength, porosity and corrosion resistance of
ternary blend Portland cement, rice husk as fly ash mortar. Constr Build Mater
2008;22:1601.
[4] Veiga MR, Velosa A, Magalhães A. Experimental applications of mortars with
pozzolanic additions: characterization and performance evaluation. Constr
Build Mater 2009;23:318.
[5] Rossignolo JA. Effect of silica fume and SBR latex on the paste-aggregate
interfacial transition zone. Mater Res 2007;10:83.
[6] Kanning RC, Portella KF, Costa MRM, Puppi RFK. Evaluation of pozzolanic
activity of banana leaf ash. In: International conference on durability of
building and components. Porto, Portugal; 2011.
[7] Vaičiukynienė D, Vaitkevičius V, Kantautas A, Sasnauskas V. Utilization of by-
product waste silica in concrete–based materials. Mater Res 2012;15:561.
[8] García R, de la Villa RV, Rodríguez O, Frías M. Mineral phases formation on the
pozzolan/lime/water system. Appl Clay Sci 2009;43:331.
[9] Akram T, Memon S, Obaid H. Production of low cost self compacting concrete
using bagasse ash. Constr Build Mater 2009;23:703.
[10] Kanning RC. Utilização da cinza de folha de bananeira como adição em
argamassas de cimento Portland. (Thesis). Brasil: Universidade Federal do
Paraná; 2013.
[11] Cordeiro GC, Toledo Filho RD, Fairbairn EMR. Caracterização de cinza do
bagaço de cana-de-açúcar para emprego como pozolana em materiais
cimentícios. Quim Nova 2009;32:82.
[12] Pedrozo EC. Estudo da utilização da cinza da casca do arroz residual em
concretos estruturais: uma análise da durabilidade aos cloretos. Brasil:
Dissertação de Mestrado, Universidade Federal de Santa Maria; 2008.
[13] ASTM C125, Standard terminology relating to concrete and concrete
aggregates; 2013.
Fig. 6. Cross arms for electrical distribution networks casted with 10% BLA [14] Aurore G, Parfait B, Fahrasmane L. Bananas, raw materials for making
materials in substitution of the binder. processed food products. Trends Food Sci Technol 2009;20:78.
R.C. Kanning et al. / Construction and Building Materials 54 (2014) 460–465 465
[15] Junior G. de SES, Morais MB, Camara TR, Willadino L. Growth of dipoid banana [28] Ezziane K, Bougara A, Kadri A, Khelafi H, Kadri E. Compressive strength of
genotypes under saline stress. Rev. bras. eng. agríc. ambient, vol. 16 no. 11. mortar containing natural pozzolan under various curing temperature. Cem
Campina Grande; 2012. Concr Compos 2007;29:587.
[16] Suchorski, D. M. ACI education bulletin E1-07, ACI committee E-701, materials [29] Tanyildizi H. Variance analysis of crack characteristics of structural
for concrete construction, ISBN 978-0-87031-248-9; 2007. lightweight concrete containing silica fume exposed to high temperature.
[17] NBR, NM, 248, Agregados – determinação da composição granulométrica. Constr Build Mater 2013;47:1154.
Brasil; 2003. [30] NBR 13279, Argamassa para assentamento e revestimento de paredes
[18] Moropoulou A, Bakolas A, Aggelakopoulou E. Evaluation of pozzolanic activity e tetos. Determinação da resistência à flexão e à compressão. Brasil;
of natural and artificial pozzolans by termal analysis. Thermochimica Acta 2005.
2004;420:135. [31] NBR 13259, Argamassa para assentamento e revestimento de paredes e tetos –
[19] Donatello S, Freeman-Pask A, Tyrer M, Cheeseman CR. Effect of milling and determinação da absorção de água por capilaridade e do coeficiente de
acid washing on the pozzolanic activity of incinerator sewage sludge ash. Cem capilaridade. Brasil; 2005.
Concr Compos 2010;32:54. [32] NBR 13528, Revestimento de paredes de argamassas inorgânicas.
[20] Sabir BB, Wild S, Bai J. Metakaolin and calcined clays as pozzolans for concrete: Determinação da resistência de aderência à tração. Brasil; 2010.
a review. Cem Concr Compos 2001;23:441. [33] ASTM C876, Standard test method for corrosion potentials of uncoated
[21] NBR, NM, 76, Cimento Portland, determinação da finura pelo método de reinforcing steel in concrete; 2009.
permeabilidade ao ar (Método Blaine). Brasil; 1998. [34] Ferraro RM, Nanni A. Effect of off-white rice husk ash on strength, porosity,
[22] NBR 13277, Argamassa para assentamento e revestimento de paredes e tetos. conductivity and corrosion resistance of white concrete. Constr Build Mater
Determinação da retenção de água. Brasil; 2005. 2012;31:220.
[23] NBR 15895, Materiais pozolânicos. Determinação do teor de hidróxido de [35] ASTM B117, Standard practice for operating salt spray (Fog) apparatus;
cálcio fixado. Brasil: Método Chapelle modificado; 2010. 2011.
[24] NBR 5751, Materiais pozolânicos. Determinação de atividade pozolânica, [36] NBR 12653, Materiais pozolânicos. Especificação. Brasil; 1992.
índice de atividade pozolânica com cal. Brasil; 1992. [37] Raverdy M, Brivot F, Paillere AM, Dron R. Appreciation of pozzolanic reactivity
[25] NBR 7215, Cimento Portland. Determinação da resistência à compressão. of mirror component. In: 7th International congress on the chemistry of
Brasil; 1996. cement. Paris, France; 1980.
[26] Itim A, Ezziane K, Kadri E. Compressive strength and shrinkage of mortar [38] NBR 13281, Argamassa para assentamento e revestimento de paredes e tetos –
containing various amounts of mineral additions. Constr Build Mater 2011; requisitos. Brasil; 2005.
25:3603. [39] Feliu V, González JA, Andrade C, Feliu S. Equivalent circuit for modelling the
[27] Nadeem A, Memon SA, Yiu Lo T. Mechanical performance, durability, steel-concrete interface. I. Experimental evidence and theoretical predictions.
qualitative and quantitative analysis of microstructure of fly ash Metakaolin Corr Sci 1998;40:975.
mortar at elevated temperatures. Constr Build Mater 2013;38:338.