GP Entry Guide 2019

dr sarah cooper’s
gp recruitment guide
Getting into GP Training 2019
Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)
-1-
Contents
Introduction 3
Overview of the Selection Process 4

• Stage 1 - Determination of Eligibility 4
• Stage 2 - Computer Based Test 4
• Stage 3 – Selection Centre 5
o Stage 3 scenarios from 2015 6
o Tips for Written Prioritisation 7
o Tips for Simulation Exercises 8
• Stage 4 - Allocation 9
The Survey 10
• How best to prepare for the SRA 11
• How best to prepare for the Selection Centre 12
Responses received 13
• East Midlands 14
• East of England 15
• Kent, Surrey & Sussex 19
• London 21
• NHS Scotland 28
• North East 32
• North West 34
• South West 40
• Thames Valley 43
• Wales Deanery 44
• Wessex 45
• West Midlands 48
• Yorkshire & the Humber 50
Final Word 54
-2-
Introduction
Thank you for downloading this free guide which I hope you will find useful. I first wrote this
guide in 2009 describing my experiences of trying to get into GP training. I wanted to know
“how best should I prepare?” to maximise my limited revision time squeezed in between busy
shifts and other family commitments. Back then I was (& still am!) a sad obsessive-
compulsive. I had collated lots of information from various sources to help me navigate the
entry process which I used to create a lengthy document. Which I shared with my colleagues
who then suggested I share with the rest of the country which I did via a website created by
a family friend which hasn’t changed at all! Since then time has flown and over 23,000 people
have downloaded the guide! And I now administer a facebook group -
https://www.facebook.com/groups/GPEntry/ which you please must join!
I’m sure you will have asked or wanted to ask GP trainees in the year above how they
prepared or asked the same question on forums or on social media, etc. Everybody has their
own experiences and in this document you will have access to the most up-to-date opinions
from those in the year above across the whole country!
This guide is made up entirely of feedback kindly provided by last year’s candidates. This
guide, and the ones before, would not exist without such feedback. Unfortunately, this year I
have received less replies than before – perhaps my emails are ending up in the junk folder?
I would urge all those reading this – please, please do not ignore my email when I
contact you after stage 4 and please add my 2 email addresses
mail@gprecruitment.info and mail@gprecruitmentmail.co.uk to your safe list. And
whilst you are at it, I would also advise you to add the domain oriel.nhs.uk as well
as so many people report missing important emails from Oriel as they end up in their junk
folder. Please do it now.
My husband asks me why I still bother compiling this guide. After all, I don’t get paid for
doing it and it is quite time consuming. To that I would answer, I found it difficult getting a
GPST1 post and some of my very capable friends failed to obtain a training post. If I could
help others gain a GP training post who could savour the highs (& lows) of the 3 most
wonderful years of training that I have been fortunate enough to experience then all this
hard work would have been worth it.
This non-commercial guide is still free of sponsorship or advertising and hence will be entirely
objective. It its totally transparent - all the emails I received are reproduced from page 13
onwards. This guide is not meant to take the place of the excellent applicant’s guide
published by the National Recruitment Office for GP Training but should be seen as
an adjunct. This guide is accurate at the time of writing but please note rules and regulations
can change quickly so please double check with the NRO.
Good Luck & God bless!
-3-
Overview of the Selection Process
Entry into GP specialist training involves successfully negotiating 4 stages:
Stage 1 - Longlisting - Determination of

Eligibility
Applications for GP Speciality Training are made online at the National Recruitment Office
(NRO) for GP Training website (http://gprecruitment.hee.nhs.uk). The aim of the online
application is to ensure that you are eligible for GP Training. There are currently 3 application
rounds (2 rounds for August entry and 1 round for February entry).
Stage 2 (Speciality Recruitment Assessment) -

Computer Based Test
If you meet all the eligibility criteria you will be invited by email to attend a computer based
assessment. When I took Stage 2, it was a traditional pen & paper assessment held
simultaneously at various centres nationwide on a Saturday to minimise disruption to the NHS.
However, for the last six years, the assessment has been computer based and held at
Pearson VUE (http://www.pearsonvue.co.uk) test centres worldwide. The assessment is
offered every day Mon-Sat (you can choose which day) during a week in early January, April
or September. It is a case of first come first served so be sure to make your selection early
before your venue of choice gets fully booked and you end up having to travel to somewhere
unfamiliar.
Paper 1 - Professional Dilemmas (58 questions in 110mins)

There are 2 types of Professional Dilemma MCQ – Ranking & Multiple Best Answer (MBA)
A) Ranking
With this type of question a scenario is presented followed by a number of possible
options which need to be ranked in order from the most to least appropriate.
B) Multiple Best Answer (MBA)
With this type of question a scenario is presented followed by a number of possible
options which you will be asked to select two or three from which together are the
most appropriate response to the situation.
Paper 2 - Clinical Problem Solving (97 questions in 75mins)

Questions are of the Extended Matching Question (EMQ) and Single Best Answer (SBA)
variety.
Direct Pathway to Offers

In 2016, the NRO trialled a Direct Pathway to Offers. For the trial, all applicants who received
a total score of 575 (roughly top 10%) from the SRA would qualify for the new, streamlined
route which meant they did not have to attend the Selection Centre. Qualifying applicants
were ranked first, before those who were deemed appointable via Selection Centre, which
increased their chance of receiving a training programme in their first choice location.
-4-
Stage 3 - Selection Centre Interviews
Depending on your performance in the SRA you may be asked to attend a Selection Centre
most likely at your first choice deanery. It may feel depressing that some of your colleagues
have already made it through via the Direct pathway and avoided the selection centre but
don’t be too disappointed. You have done well to make it through to this stage. So
congratulations. You are almost there but there is still a lot of work to do. The ratio of
candidates to vacancies at Stage 3 is usually about 1.5:1 or more for some of the more
competitive deaneries. I suggest you start preparing for the selection centre as soon as you
can after the SRA as there isn’t much time between the 2 stages.
The assessments
There will be 2 types of exercises to perform – a written exercise and patient simulations (x3).
Back in my day, candidates also had to perform a Group exercise where 4 candidates would
discuss a significant issue under the observation of the examiners (felt like an episode of the
Apprentice with 4 overzealous, overdressed 20-somethings trying desperately to say
something to impress the deanery’s version of Karen Brady).
A) Written Exercise
You are given a series of tasks (the context may be primary or secondary care in the NHS) to
prioritise and you have 30 minutes in total to write down what order you would prioritise
these tasks and justify why. There are also a few self-reflection questions at the end.
B) Simulation Exercise
There are 3 different scenarios with actors to complete - a consultation with a patient; a
consultation with a relative or carer and a consultation with a non medical colleague. A
physical examination will not be necessary so please don’t attempt one!
You have a total of 10 minutes to read the briefing note and to complete the encounter. The
actor will play a defined, rehearsed role, which will bring out specific issues and an assessor
will sit in during the exercise but will not participate in any way so just pretend they aren’t
there. Easier said than done!
Stage 3 Marking Scheme
The personal skills that will be specifically assessed:

1. Empathy & Sensitivity
2. Communication Skills
3. Conceptual Thinking & Problem Solving
4. Professional Integrity
5. Coping with Pressure:
These domains are marked as either:

Very Good Demonstration (Strength) 3 points
Sufficient Demonstration 2 points
Mixed Demonstration (Weakness) 1 point
Little or No Demonstration 0 points
If you receive a “Little or No Demonstration” on any exercise you will be deemed unsuitable
for GP training this year. If you receive too many “Mixed Demonstrations” again you will be
deemed unsuitable for GP training this year.
-5-
Stage 3 scenarios (unedited) from 2015 entry (courtesy of Dr Roopa Chauhan –
East Midlands Deanery 2015)
Written
Read the top: it said I had 1 hour to complete the tasks before mandatory teaching and
which I HAD to attend.
1) HCA wants to talk to you about sexual assault from a doctor.

2) A nurse wants to talk to you about her daughter. You saw her daughter the night before in
a&e. She has simple constipation and her pregnancy test was negative. The nurse is worried
she has an ectopic pregnancy. The daughter hasn't given you permission to speak to her
mum.
3) A nurse wants to speak to you as all the adrenaline ampules on the ward are 6 months out
of date. He has a clinic in 20mins to attend.
4) A nurse is upset after a cardiac arrest. He feels there should have been a DNAR In place.
He feels "he can't do this anymore".
5) A nurse calls you from another ward as a patient is kicking off about something and is
becoming physically aggressive.
Scenarios
A) Patient - has had a small variceal bleed. She wants to self discharge. She had a major
previous bleed 11 months ago and the consultant has advised keeping her overnight for
observations and an endoscopy tomorrow. The issue here is that her husband has ms and is
having a relapse. She doesn't want to leave him at home alone and therefore wants to
leave. I offered interim and ict but she was competent so still gave her the option if she
wanted to. She was alcohol dependent but didn't get a chance to cover this
B) Relative- son of the patient wants to talk to you about his dad. Dad came in with a chest
infection and was treated. He then had a stroke 2 days ago and has residual right sided
weakness and slurred speech. The real problem was the son was concerned that ?chest
infection was the cause of stroke, why wasn't dad out of hospital as usually he's only in for a
couple of days and dad is the main carer for mum at home who is not coping. Lots to cover
in not a lot of time. I explained they're not linked but could have explained what causes
stroke more. I suggested interim placement and ict again!
C) Colleague - nurse is concerned that another nurse "d" has made mistakes. Not washing his
hands and turning up late, but has seen him giving 4 paracetamol to a pt and pt had to
correct him. I had to tease out of her that she was worried and wasn't sleeping. She made a
throw away comment about jo. I clarified jo was the nurse in charge. She had escalated the
problem but nothing was done. On further probing; the nurse feels that jo and d are shacking
up and that's why nothing has been done. I offered help but wasn't really sure exactly where
to go. I just suggested having a word with jo and d and getting the managers involved.
-6-
Tips for written prioritisation (courtesy of Dr Brendan Fletcher – East of England
Deanery 2012 entrant)
Read:
1. GMC: Good Medical Practice
a. May be good to be able to quote from it
2. BMA Communications Skills e-Learning
Prioritisation:
1. Personal safety
2. Patient safety (not in monitored area with another team)
3. Patient safety (in monitored area or with another team)
4. Extended patient issues:
a. Symptoms
b. Dignity
c. Confidentiality
5. Personal Issues
Considerations:
1. Acknowledge that the personal issues may impact on patient care (e.g. worrying
about a deadline)
2. Relate priorities back to the other stems
3. Use correct ranking scheme (e.g. LETTERS or NUMBERS)
4. Say what you would normally do (e.g. dictate letters immediately after a surgery)
5. There may be a need for further information and state this if you think it
Options:
1. Can someone else help? (are they competent and make sure they report that they
complete the task)
2. Use support services (on-call team, partners in the practice, pharmacist, receptionist)
3. Ask receptionist or practice manager to speak to patients if they are angry and
waiting
4. Suggest home visits after surgery or making double-appointments for next time
Reflective Bit:
1. New exercise for a doctor-in-training
2. Say what went well
3. Say what went badly
4. Give at least one specific learning point
5. Acknowledge the impact that a personal issue would have on practice
-7-
Tips for simulation exercises (courtesy of Dr Brendan Fletcher – East of England
Deanery 2012 entrant)
1. Do not act
2. Create a safe environment:
a. Might need to move furniture
______________
1. Introduction and putting the patient at ease

a. Good morning. My name is Brendan Fletcher and I am one of the doctors
in______.
2. Actively listening
a. Allow the patient to start and do not interrupt them
3. Relevant psychosocial information:
a. How is this affecting you?

b. Is there a financial impact?
c. Are you able to share your worries with anyone?
d. Who do you have at home with you?
e. Are work colleagues being supportive?
f. Is this affecting your sleep?
In medical science there are things we can measure with tests and scans and there are
things that we can measure because we ask about them.
4. IDEAS: What does the patient think is going on with them?

5. CONCERNS: What is the patient particularly concerned about and why?
6. EXPECTATIONS: Why did they consult today? What do they hope to get from the
consultation?
I am glad that you came to see me today as I can see that this is worrying you.
7. Clinical Questioning:
a. Do not focus on this
b. Address RED FLAGS
8. Explanation and differential diagnosis
a. Do not focus on this
9. Management plan
a. Offer the patient some choices
b. Offer support services
10. Summarise
11. Check patient’s understanding
a. Offer patient information leaflets or Patient.co.uk
12. Follow-up and review plans
a. Consider further appointment with other family members
Obviously, we care very deeply about the wellbeing of all the patients in the practice,
but I am unable to discuss them with others, even family members who also care
very deeply about them.
b. Consider further double-appointment next time
-8-
STAGE 4 - Allocation
Applicants will be ranked in a single list nationally based on their performance throughout the
selection process. Applicants who qualified for the Direct Pathway will be ranked first, above
those who were deemed appointable via the Selection Centre. Offers are made in rank order
based on this national ranking.
You will be given 48 hours (exclusive of weekends) to respond to an offer and have the
option to accept, decline or hold. Only one offer can be held at any one time, across all
specialty applications in a round. If you fail to respond to an offer within the 48 hour window
you will be deemed to have declined the offer.
Upgrades
If you rank highly enough to be made an offer, this will be made to the highest ranked
Training Programme preference that is available when your interview rank is reached. If this
Training Programme offer is suitable for you and you do not want to be considered for any
other preferences you have ranked higher, you can choose to simply accept it.
However, applicants do have the option of getting one of their higher ranked GP Training
programme preferences, should they become available, by opting into upgrading. The
upgrading option is available to all offers that have been held or accepted, but not where an
offer has been declined. If you opt into upgrading and a higher preferenced offer becomes
available, the upgrade will be automatic.
Remaining vacancies
Any vacancies that are left unfilled at the end of this process will be re-advertised as another
round of national recruitment.
-9-
The Survey
In late April & May 2018 after the offers were sent out by the respective deaneries, I emailed
these who downloaded my guide with the following simple 5 minute questionnaire:
1. What deanery did you apply to? Were you successful?
2. Your thoughts on the Application form - any pitfalls or any tips?
3. Stage 2 MCQ preparation - How did you prepare? What resources did you use
and how would you rate them out of 10?
4. How did you find the Stage 2 MCQ computerised assessment? Any tips for
future candidates?
5. Stage 3 preparation - How did you prepare? What resources did you use and
how would you rate them out of 10?
6. How did you find the Stage 3 assessment day? Any tips for future candidates?
7. Any final thoughts (or moans!) about your recent experience of the GPST
selection process?
I received 69 replies broken down by deanery as below:
All the respondents in the survey were successful.
- 10 -
How best to prepare for the SRA?
Resources used by last year’s candidates for the SRA:
Satisfaction Survey (Ratings out of 10)
- 11 -
How best to prepare for the selection centre?
Resources used by last year’s candidates for the selection centre:
Satisfaction Survey (Ratings out of 10)
- 12 -
Responses received
The responses I received are shown on the subsequent remaining pages. I have simply cut
and pasted the replies from the emails in their entirety – warts and all. There are plenty of
spelling and grammar mistakes. Some responses were very detailed others very brief. Some
questions were left blank, for example, the stage 3 parts if the candidate was a “direct
entrant”. There are so many useful hints & tips I would recommend you take your time to
read the rest of this document.
They are shown in order of deanery by alphabetical order and by candidate name again by
alphabetical order.
East Midlands P.14

East of England P.15
Kent, Surrey & Sussex P.19
London P.21
NHS Scotland P.28
North East P.32
North West P.34
South West P.40
Thames Valley P.43
Wales Deanery P.44
Wessex P.45
West Midlands P.48
Yorkshire & the Humber P.50
The eagle-eyed amongst you will realise that unfortunately I received no responses from
candidates applying to the NIMTDA or DPMD deaneries.
- 13 -
EAST MIDLANDS
Onyeka Ibe
Application Form Application process is self explanatory and simple straight
forward process.
Stage 2/SRA I used only the MCQ bank for a period of 6weeks, while
Preparation working a full time job and regular locums. I would rate it 9
out of 10.
Stage 2 You have to be time conscious especially for the situational
Assessment judgment part of the test; always look for the pattern.
Stage 3 I used MCQ bank for stage 3, no one to practice with. Its an
Preparation exam that expects a good interactive and doctor-patient
relationship skill. I would rate the material 8 out of 10.
Stage 3 Practice, practice, practice for stage 3; groups, videocalls...
Assessment
Stage 4 My deanery responses on time to emails and her really
helpful. They want you.
Final Thoughts No regrets.
- 14 -
EAST OF ENGLAND
Ash Dave
Application Form Oriel website and GP recruitment website, very helpful and
application process was very easy.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQbank 9/10 & passmedicine 7/10 (used
Preparation passmedicine only for SJT).
Stage 2 Keep practicing MCQ and especially the SJT.
Assessment
Stage 3 Used emedica 9/10 (it is very expensive but gives a very
Preparation good idea of the format of the examination), also the actors
used as close to real examination actors. You also find study
partners in the course), mcqbank online revision (only for
the videos) 9/10.
Stage 3 Very helpful staff, the scenarios are indeed challenging so
Assessment the key is keep practising.
Stage 4 Oriel website is great.
Final Thoughts It is a very smooth process and I am pleased with the
outcome.
Gracie Dowling-Mardon
Application Form Generally simple, free text section not challenging. Line up
your references in advance- especially if you’re currently on a
year out of training, as they might be people you worked
with a long long time ago!
Stage 2/SRA I used Pastest question bank, I think it was about the right
Preparation level and number of questions. The most useful bit is doing
them under time pressure to get used to that aspect of the
exam. 8/10. I also got a couple of books out of the BMA
library, these were OK but not amazing, I didn’t end up using
them much as its better to practice on a computer like the
real exam. I also had a quick look through a book I used for
finals, which was ‘complete revision notes for medical finals’-
not everything in here is relevant, but its about the right
level for the clinical section I think. I had all the good
intentions of starting in November and doing a few questions
a week until the exam… obviously in reality this didn’t
happen-I did a few sporadic sessions in December, and then
revised all day for the 5 days leading up to the exam in early
January.
Stage 2 Book early into a centre thats convenient for you, you don’t
Assessment want to spend the time before the exam being stressed
about travelling there. If you sat your driving theory in the
UK, you may want to book into the same centre- its nice
being somewhere familiar! (I sat my driving theory so many
times that the centre was very familiar..!). At the centre I
used (Cheltenham) they gave me ear plugs so I wasn’t
disturbed at all by other people coming and going. The test
itself was ok, the biggest issue is time pressure. The
professional dilemmas section is very much like the SJT you
probably sat before FY1- I actually had some of the exact
same questions (but that still doesn’t help you know what
the right answer is…!). I did manage to complete it in time
though. The clinical questions were not too tricky, if you’ve
made it through foundation years, you’ll make it through this
- 15 -
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 I decided after the initial application that I wanted to defer 3
months. I told them this at the appropriate time after they
confirmed my allocation to the deanery. They replied saying I
needed to tell them before submitting application and it was
too late to do this now. 3 days later they emailed saying that
they were wrong and I could defer. If you want to defer, just
make sure you’ve checked what the guidance says and stick
with it. The admin team is the usual chaos we have come to
know (and love?!) about anything to do with the NHS.
Final Thoughts I think I found the process in general easier than my
colleagues applying for other specialties. I was so pleased to
get a direct pathway offer, this really takes the stress off- so
if you think you can, put in a few extra hours before the
exam, it may pay off! Just keep track of the deadlines and be
prepared for the usual administrative fight and you’ll be fine!
Thanks so much for your help via the guide! Its so
useful having something to refer to with all the information
in, and some guidance from others, especially if (like me) you
are having a year off so can’t chat about it with colleagues at
work!
Menaka Padmanathan
Application Form The application form was quite straightforward and easy
enough to fill up. Probably one of the easier application
forms I filled.
Stage 2/SRA I prepared mainly with some reading of Oxford Handbook
Preparation and also questions on Passmed. Also did some questions on
Pastest via a friend's log-in. Would have done more
questions. I found the questions on Pastest closer to the
actually MCQ question. Pass medicine was good but the
questions were much lengthier. However they had quite a lot
of explanations post the questions which helped fill
knowledge gaps. I would rate Pastest 8/10, Passmedicine
6/10.
Stage 2 I found it relatively straightforward but found I had quite a
Assessment few gaps in knowledge. A lot of the questions were things I
knew in medical school but haven't revisited in a while, i.e.
Paeds Orthopaedic questions, Rheumatology questions. I
found that the questions for jobs I haven't done in F1/F2
were trickier naturally. I would recommend reading up on
rheumatology (i.e. the antibodies etc).
Stage 3 Did not do as much preparation for this. Mainly read the
Preparation sample scenarios on the GP NRO website and the sample
questions for the written bit.
Stage 3 Selection Centre assessment was not too bad. They make
Assessment you feel quite at easy and everyone is approachable and
friendly. It is a bit daunting as it's pretty much like doing
OSCEs again. Tips would be to just stay calm and be natural.
Talk to the actors in the scenarios as you would your own
patient.
Stage 4 Again very straightforward. We were given an opportunity to
rerank our preference after the interviews. We received
- 16 -
allocations in a few weeks post interview.
Final Thoughts GP NRO were quite helpful and prompt with replying to any
queries regarding application.
Kamil Singh
Application Form Start to complete application form as soon as possible to
give candidate maximum time to rank choices.
Stage 2/SRA I used passmedicine and MCQbank. Passmedicine was
Preparation somewhat useful (7/10) but MCQbank was most like the
actual exam (9/10).
Stage 2 Questions were similar to MCQbank. Ensure you are aware of
Assessment time restrictions and manage your time well so that you can
answer all questions. Overall I did feel pushed for time
somewhat during this examination.
Stage 3 I attended Emedica course which was helpful and similar to
Preparation actual examination. I then practised mock consultations with
a colleague to improve technique and flow of consultation. I
would rate Emedica course (9/10).
Stage 3 Try to remain relaxed. The actors are very good. Follow your
Assessment structure and don’t rush.
Stage 4 Process online was straight forward. Thinking about
choosing to upgrade offer can be difficult if you have a
partner, etc. When I applied there was no facility to link
application with another candidate.
Final Thoughts Overall relatively straightforward. I believe good planning
and revision will help candidates to maximise their score on
tests and increase their chance of getting into their ideal
deanery and job rotation.
Faye Smith
Application Form Application forms were straight forward. would be useful to
clarify of the references needed HAD to be previous
clinical/educational supervisors, or just consultants you had
worked with. In reading the small print, I changed mine to
clinical supervisors.
Stage 2/SRA Prepped using mcq bank. rate 8/10. good similar format.
Preparation
Stage 2 Found the assessment ok. knew what to expect.
Assessment
Stage 3 Prepped very little actually. spoke to colleagues who had
Preparation experienced it. read info on gp recruitment website and your
handbook. 9/10.
Stage 3 Needed more advice on where to park and enter the football
Assessment stadium at Peterborough!!!! So many entrances, and last
thing you need when you’re already on edge. Well structured
and run day. Tips: stay calm, the Calgery- Cambridge model
for comms skills.
Stage 4 more info on the different rounds you can apply for, I.e
rounds 2 and 3 are left over jobs. More info on the money
incentive for some jobs, which jobs etc. I was originally
prepared to opt for job further away for money incentive.
However, when faced with the jobs available in round 2,
these were gone. My plans ended up changing (and probably
for the best). I needed up with my top choice in the end.
- 17 -
Final Thoughts Another point to end that more info on switching to go
training would have been helpful. I was a cmt2. Decided to
apply and switch for round 2 applications. There is very little
info/ ppl to contact who k ow what’s going to regarding
what will be considered for consideration to reduce the
training.
Nicola van der Westhuyzen

Application Form The form was simple to complete in the most part, just
plugging in the information they require. The only confusion
I had was regarding the box which asks if you are planning
on deferring entry - it stated on the form that you could only
defer for statutory reasons (such as maternity leave or
illness), however this is contrary to the reality that they are
happy for anyone to defer. I ticked "YES" and wrote a short
explanation of my plans for F3. Better to be honest from the
start as to your intentions to defer was my reasoning and it
all worked out fine for me.
Stage 2/SRA I used Passmedicine. I revised for 1 month before the exam,
Preparation whilst working on ED so on average did about an hour a day
over the month. I didn't get anywhere near completing the
question bank. I found they were good questions that
matched up to those asked in the exam. I would recommend
it. 9/10 I used the book "Succeeding in the GP ST Stage 2
Situational Judgement Tests / Professional Dilemmas:
Practice Questions for GPST / GPVTS Stage 2 Selection By
(author) Nicole Corriette, By (author) Matt Green and
completed that book to familiarise myself with the SJT
component of the exam. 9/10.
Stage 2 I found I was quite pressurised for time to complete the
Assessment clinical problem solving part of the assessment.
Stage 3 The day before I looked up the format of the interviews. I did
Preparation one practice attempt at the written exercise the day before -
this was helpful to familiarise myself with this part of the
assessment as it is very pressured for time.
Stage 3 It was a good day. All of the interviews were purely focused
Assessment on communication skills.
Stage 4 I have deferred the entry by one year and this has been a
very easy process.
Final Thoughts
- 18 -
KENT, SURREY & SUSSEX
Lily Craver
Application Form Straight forward application process.
Stage 2/SRA I used both MCQ bank and Passmedicine. I stared slowly
Preparation going through MCQ bank in November and making notes
around the topics I was getting wrong. I then took 2 weeks
off in January and went through all the questions and
answers to both MCQ bank and pass medicine. I found it
useful using both resources as they both covered different
things that came up in the exam.
Stage 2 Very straightforward. Keep an eye on the time and make
Assessment sure you know where you need to be at half time.
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 Straight forward. It can take some time to here from your
allocated deanery, but don’t worry they will contact you!
Final Thoughts
Victoria Margesson
Application Form I thought the application process was fairly straight forward
although I was surprised how short the window for your
referees to submit the reference. It was a struggle when
mine was on sabbatical.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank and borrowed a couple of BMA library
Preparation books. I did not have to attend stage 3 as was in the top
10%.
Stage 2 I found the MCQ fairly straightforward. The questions were
Assessment less complicated than expected.
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts I found your guide very useful and i'm sure played a big role
in me getting a high mark so thank you.
Safia Zaffarullah
Application Form I didn’t realise there was a question on our motivation for
wanting to be a GP, this threw me off a little. Although I’m
not sure how or if it was actually used in the selection
process.
Stage 2/SRA Passmedicine - 7/10 Pastest - 7/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 It’s quite a long exam, but it goes very quickly. Calculate
Assessment how much time you roughly have for per question in the PD
and clinical scenarios part (the latter is less) before you go in
to the exam.
Stage 3 Emedica course - 10/10. (I got full marks on stage 3),
Preparation Practicing scenarios with friends - 10/10, Also, practicing the
writing scenarios as much as you can beforehand is very
- 19 -
important for two reasons - you need structured answers,
and you need to be able to write within the time limit! 30
minutes is very little time to complete all the questions.
Stage 3 There can often be a bit of waiting around.
Assessment
Stage 4 No complaints.
Final Thoughts In general a fair process. GP national recruitment office are
very friendly and helpful.
- 20 -
LONDON
Sharon Carter
Application Form The initial application form is very easy and straight forward,
just make sure you complete and submit the alternative for
for foundation training if you completed FY2 training over 4
years ago.
Stage 2/SRA MCQ was SJT heavy so make sure you spend enough time
Preparation revising this, they also put more weight on SJTs when
calculating your final score.
Stage 2 I almost ran out of time on the SJT's which was not the case
Assessment when I did all the online practice questions.
Stage 3 MCQbank had a lot of scenarios to practice which I did with a
Preparation few friends.
Stage 3 Ran quickly and smoothly, assessment was much more on
Assessment communication skills, ICE etc rather than clinical
knowledge.
Stage 4 We got an email with the breakdown which was straight
forward, goes through each station and the breakdown of
the assessment.
Final Thoughts Process is easy enough but very long. I found
communication with the London deanery very difficult and
kept getting different information. They didn't have a clear
timeline of when job preferences will be released and when
we will get the final outcome. Otherwise a straight forward
application process.
Harriet Cosh
Application Form Simple to fill in.
Stage 2/SRA Used mcqbank.co.uk for 1 month. 9/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 More questions about A&E than expected, would have been
Assessment useful to have an A&E rotation before or known so that you
can revise A&E management e.g. observation time after
anaphylaxis Simple. Can highlight questions and go back to
them.
Stage 3 Used mcqbank.co.uk for 1 month. 9/10.
Preparation
Stage 3 Did not find that I needed to prepare for these as they were
Assessment all ethical scenarios that your current practise should guide
you through. Answer the questions truthfully and
empathetically . Try to fit ICE in.
Stage 4 Expect them to be tell you late.
Final Thoughts Find out about the deferral process early on as they said to
us that they cannot guarantee you the same London group if
you want to defer.
Mark Isherwood
Application Form Pretty straightforward and self-explanatory. As always,
making sure you choose reliable referees is probably key.
Stage 2/SRA I used Pasmed and MCQ bank. I got full marks in the clinical
Preparation section, so they obviously work.
Stage 2 The clinical questions were straightforward. I stupidly
- 21 -
Assessment allowed myself to run out of time in the situational
judgement section. Should have practiced timings more.
Stage 3 MCQ bank was invaluable. Lots of scenarios on the site and
Preparation many of them with videos of candidates doing it well to learn
from. 9/10.
Stage 3 Organisers were about an hour late, with no apology or
Assessment explanation. No food or water provided, so take your own if
you’re likely to get hungry.
Stage 4
Final Thoughts The fact that most regions won’t tell you what the specific
jobs that you are applying for are, is incredibly frustrating.
But there’s not much you can do about it.
Lisa Linpower
Application Form The application form was straightforward - just fill in the
boxes. You can fiddle with referees at any point.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank after reading the 2017 Sarah Cooper guide
Preparation - and it was great. The questions were very similar to the
SRA exam. The SJT stuff was particularly useful, I did loads
of them, once you get a feel for what they're looking for your
marks improve. Also used the GMC website.
Stage 2 MCQ computerised assessment was fine; cold though, so
Assessment wear layers. Time was just about right, I had ten minutes to
spare once I'd gone back over the questions I wanted to.
Stage 3 I did a days emedica course for stage 3. With work and
Preparation children I had little time so decided to throw some money at
it. It was totally worth it - an excellent course, with actors
and mock exams and lots of feedback. I'd massively
recommend it if you just want a quick one stop shop. I got
52/52 in my stage 3, didn't drop a single mark; I'm a good
communicator anyway, but the course helped me polish
things nicely, tips on what they are looking for/wanting to
hear to let them tick ALL the boxes. I didn't do anything else
apart from read the Sarah Cooper guide and talk to GP
trainees in my hospital.
Stage 3 Selection centre day was not very well organised, so much
Assessment unnecessary hanging around. I had to travel from London to
Oxford because all the London slots got booked within 8
hours of the booking opening. I'd recommend you find out
what time it opens and set an alarm (they don't email/text to
let you know). The stations themselves were super straight
forward; colleague (HCA) who was worried about a bereaved
colleague not performing well at work (concerns over
alcohol) - was just mega fluffy, checked about Pt safety,
offered to help them escalate to appropriate channels,
checked they were okay. Relative; partner of a pt who had
recovered well after an uncomplicated apendectomy who did
not want his partner discharged (had an old lover who is
having a hard time staying over, he'd prev had an affair with
her and promised never to see her again), I just explained
that we cant keep her in hospital, not good for her (HAI's) or
NHS beds, offered to help him discuss with partner, asked if
the ex lover needed help (was fleeing domestic violence).
Patient station; in ED, had a Pt who had been discharged by
my consultant with an ankle injury that was NAD. He wanted
a sick note for work (that I couldn't/didn't give), turned out
- 22 -
that his daughter was dying in another country and he cant
afford time off work without sick pay - also had other
financial pressures; didnt give sick note, but was kind and
offered referral to financial help people and to go to GP ? to
see if they could help ("GP's look after a whole person, not
just their ankle"). The best advice is to suspend disbelief and
immerse yourself - forget its all an act and be like you would
be with a patient/colleague/relative in real life (if you were a
patient and kind person with plenty of time!).
Stage 4 Allocation process was outrageously frustrating. They
changed they way they allocate and we were the guinea pig
year - so many things went wrong. Now you rank a LETTER
[ie the letter 'N' is Homerton hospital (hackney), Queens
(romford) and Chase farm (barnett)]. You are told what
letter you have been allocated quite soon. Then you rank
again all the jobs within all of the hospitals in your group.
This is done at a regional level and is rather adhoc with excel
sheets and emails into spam. I wanted to stay at my local
hospital and defer entry for a year. There were not guidelines
about when/how to defer, lots of people missed the
deadline. They also didn't tell us that if you defer you cant
then rank jobs within your allocated letter group - so you get
the left over dregs of the applicants the following year that
may be in a hospital miles away. I ended up withdrawing,
thinking that I'd rather go through the assessments again
and stay close to home (I have children) than end up in a
hospital with a 2 hour commute each way. After I withdrew
they contacted me to say I could likely rank my jobs next
year - all deferred people are put into a regional pot and
contacted after 6 months - they hadn't worked out how any
of the new system would work and were clearly winging it, in
London certainly. The only way I could contact a person was
through a portal 8 clicks away from an obscure page I found
a link to - then they replied with a do not reply email
address!
Final Thoughts The SRA and assessment centre are both fairly straight
forward. The SJT part is 60%; clinical paper only 40% so
bear that in mind and do a lot of SJT stuff (MCQ bank and
GMC website). Be yourself in the assessment centre and
don't try to tick too many boxes like a robot/final year med
school OSCE's. Just be a nice helpful competent person -
thats what they're looking for! Expect complete confusion
with the ranking and allocation process until they smooth
things out - I am under the impression they haven't a clue
what they're doing, but are trying to get better candidates in
less desirable locations.
Katherine McWhirter
Application Form I don’t think so.
Stage 2/SRA Passmedicine - not that similar to the question style but
Preparation useful as a revision resource. Emedica question bank- less
useful. Didn’t always agree with the answers and layout I
found less helpful although the practice papers were good.
Stage 2 I thought it was pretty fair. GMC case studies were useful for
Assessment preparation for the sjt part. I thought the Standard of the
mcq questions was about what you would expect it to be.
- 23 -
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 Rank groups and then about a month later given jobs within
groups to rank.
Final Thoughts Would have been useful to know the jobs within the groups
when ranking groups!
Arun Prakasam
Application Form Applied with Alternative certificate for Foundation
competency, which was quite straightforward, but make sure
you prioritize this task early so that your consultant doesn't
feel rushed to sign you off. Prioritising your choice of
deanery was very cumbersome. It takes some time to get
used to how it works, sort of trial and error.
Stage 2/SRA pass medicine 8/10, mcq bank 9/10, emedica 7/10, Best of
Preparation the lot was mcqbank. Use NICE guidelines and OHCM to
cross-reference and make notes of new/tough points so that
you could go back and revise. It is very important to revisit
the mcqs for the second time which will reinforce the points
you tend to forget, so allow time to revise mcqs for 2nd time.
Stage 2 PD questions are sort of hit and miss. Having said that, MCQ
Assessment bank PD questions were well detailed and reading them
helped a lot. Stay calm whilst doing PD questions. A clear
mind will be the one which will score high as PD questions
are more pragmatic than anything else.
Stage 3 emedica 9/10, mcqbank videos 10/10, youtube
Preparation videos(relevant CSA videos, relevant aman arora videos)-
7/10. Make sure you watch the fantastic videos that are at
the bottom of the explanatory notes in Stage 3 mcqbank
questions. Those helped a lot. Practice scenarios from
emedica with friends and family. My wife was my
patient/relative/colleague for almost all of the 30 odd
emedica scenarios. Try to record your body language with a
mobile or handheld, so you can play it back and change if you
make any awkward subconscious movements whilst you
speak ( i was constantly biting my nails whilst listening,
which was very awkward. Stopped it and my dialogues were
more natural). Write down phrases to use when you get
stuck, like 'i understand it is a difficult time for you...' Allow
the other person to talk. Listen, listen, listen.
Stage 3 well organised. I had to travel near to the exam center, a day
Assessment prior, so that I could avoid any motor-way delays. But, that's
just me. The choice is yours. But, the crux of the matter is to
have a good 7-hour sleep and well-hydrated body on the day
of the exam.
Stage 4 Oriel is top notch. sometimes, important emails from Oriel
would end up in the spam folder. Make sure you check your
spam folder atleast on a weekly basis so that any nasty
surprises are avoided.
Final Thoughts Facebook GPST groups were helpful. It was in all, a nerve-
racking experience but, the reward is truly enjoyable. All the
best to the future GP trainees!
- 24 -
Catherine Scott
Application Form It seemed fairly straightforward; I don’t recall any issues.
Stage 2/SRA I spent around a week or two beforehand doing past
Preparation questions whenever I had the chance. I used PassMedicine
which I would rate as 10/10.
Stage 2 There were no great surprises in the MCQs. I find the SJT
Assessment style questions hard in general, and this was still the case in
the final exam. The practice questions I did on PassMedicine
were perhaps a little formulaic in the end, and the final exam
seemed to have some real curve balls.
Stage 3 I used the only text book in my hospital library, which I think
Preparation was “Succeeding in the GPST stage 3”. I read through the
relevant sections in the week before the selection centre,
and did all the timed practice ranking questions following
their suggested analysis method.
Stage 3 The simulated patients/relatives were as expected and
Assessment similar to OSCE scenarios I had done at medical school.
Having practised the ranking questions a lot, I felt well-
prepared and finished with time to spare. The key for me was
understanding what the examiners were looking for, and
following the same analysis method for each question.
Stage 4 Timely and brief - I’m not sure any more would be useful.
Final Thoughts It was all fine. I applied for deferred entry right from the
start as I am going on maternity leave before the end of F2. I
am disappointed to hear now that HEE cannot guarantee my
programme despite me clearly applying for deferment in
advance. I guess it’s the same for everyone, but it feels a
little unfair.
Reena Sookun
Application Form Application form straightforward from what I remember.
Stage 2/SRA I used pass medicine only, felt this was a bit easier than the
Preparation real assessment but I did well enough to get through to the
next round so it must have been sufficient.
Stage 2 The clinical problem solving part was ok but the professional
Assessment dilemmas were tricky. Practising to time is very important
as you may find yourself spending too long on some of the
professional dilemma type questions.
Stage 3 I used a book a GP trainee let me borrow- it was GPST Stage
Preparation 3 - Ultimate Guide to the GPST/GPVTS Selection Centre by
Gail Allsopp. As I was in a busy hospital job at the time of
preparing, I had to focus on specific parts of the book. I
went through all the prioritisation tasks as I had been told
by other GP trainees this could be the trickiest due to time
constraints. With regard to the simulations, I read through
all the colleague scenarios and the relative scenarios. In
total, I role played about 6 scenarios properly. There isn't
time to practice all the scenarios but reading through a lot of
them helped pick up key themes.
Stage 3 I ended up doing my assessment in Cambridge as I left it too
Assessment late to book a London slot. The assessment centre was well
organised. The simulations were reasonable. I think it's
apparent they want to see how you can 'think on your feet'
and 'outside the box' under pressure. They were not
straightforward in determining the purpose of the
- 25 -
consultation. Mine broadly were: 1) Patient: explaining to
patient she could not have surgery for her varicose veins on
the NHS but she was a divorcee who had a new partner and
was worried he would think her legs were unattractive. 2)
Relative: daughter who's father had a operation and she
essentially needed a place to live as she had split up with her
partner. She as staying at her father's place but this was too
small for both him and her. She was under the impression he
may not make through the operation which would mean she
could stay in his flat. 3) HCA who wanted me to access notes
for his father who was staying on the oncology ward where I
was working. He was quite insistent about me doing this.
His mother was also an alcoholic. I felt the written task was
the most difficult as you need to write legibly and succinctly
in a short amount of time. This is definitely the part which
needs a lot of practice before hand.
Stage 4 Can't remember the feedback-think it was a grid with a
comment such as fail, clear fail, pass, clear pass for each
station and the different skills they were assessing.
Final Thoughts I think clearly, if you can do well enough on the MCQs to go
straight through without having to do stage 3 that saves a
lot of hassle. I didn't and still got my first choice London VTS
scheme so it's possible without going straight through. The
simulations and written task I think are good assessing skills
needed in general practice and are reasonable but do take
some time and effort to prepare. I think if you are a decent
communicator you will be fine with this.
Aqsa Syed
Application Form No. Very straightforward. Those interested in deferring
should mention on the form, otherwise possibility of request
being rejected if made later.
Stage 2/SRA MCQBANK- didn’t used it properly. 8/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 Straightforward. Plenty of time. Time divided between
Assessment sections- can’t carry time forward between sections.
Stage 3 Emedica scenario- 6/10.
Preparation
Stage 3 Good organisation- did mine in London.
Assessment
Stage 4 In time.
Final Thoughts Competition for London is quite fierce. Every point makes the
world’s difference.
Louise Taylor
Application Form The application form seemed pretty straightforward. I didn’t
get e-mail notifications from Oriel so make sure you check it
regularly especially around the time of booking the MSRA,
selection centre and ranking jobs. MSRA sessions also book
up quickly so if you have a preference about where to sit
it/don’t want to travel far, book a place quickly! After
accepting a job, chase up your references to complete their
bit as you only have a month to have the 3 completed.
Stage 2/SRA Questions from MCQbank - 9/10; SJT papers from the
Preparation Foundation Programme website - 10/10; Read all of the GMC
- 26 -
guidance - 7/10
Stage 2 It’s very long!! Important to keep to time to make sure you
Assessment answer every question as there is no negative marking.
Stage 3 MCQbank - 10/10. Great resource, had lots of the scenarios
Preparation from previous years and lots of examples so the actual thing
was a lot less daunting having been through them. There are
definitely the same themes that come up time and again.
Stage 3 Day was run very well - everything explained very clearly on
Assessment the day about how it would run. Simulation exercise - when
10 minutes was over a bell rang and the ‘patient’ just walked
out so worth keeping an eye on the time to make sure you
get a chance to say all the things you want to. Written
exercise - the options to rank were very wordy! There wasn’t
much time to digest all the info, order the options and then
write an explanation for the ranking, so again worth keeping
an eye on the time.
Stage 4 Fairly self explanatory but just to keep an eye on oriel as I
found I didn’t get the notification emails. And following
allocation, regarding ranking of jobs, I found the emails from
LASE went to my spam!
Final Thoughts Thank you very much for your email and for putting together
the guide - it was very helpful. I hope my feedback (below)
is helpful.
Odunlami Wuraola
Application Form Fine. I would suggest being able to update personal details
e.g mobile, address just incase it changes.
Stage 2/SRA Pass medicine online 5/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 Do as much test questions as possible.
Assessment
Stage 3 Stage 3 Course in London. 10/10.
Preparation
Stage 3 Great. Just like doing osces from medical school.
Assessment
Stage 4 Dartford recruitment was terrible. Put me in a lot of stress.
Giving doctors jobs the retracting it should be a never event.
Final Thoughts Over capacity error should never happen.
- 27 -
NHS SCOTLAND
Alysha Aikman
Application Form Easy to complete.
Stage 2/SRA Passmedicine - 7/10. This was good for revision of general
Preparation medicine and had a large question bank. However I found it
wasn't particularly reflective of the questions which came up
in the exam. The SJT questions were quite similar to the
exam and provided clear explanations to answers.
Stage 2 I found I was quite pushed for time for the second section
Assessment (knowledge base). If I were to do it again I'd flag any
questions that I couldn't make a quick decision on to come
back to at the end, instead of working through them all
sequentially.
Stage 3 MCQ bank - 9/10 - The scenarios given were very similar to
Preparation those that came up in the exam. Worthwhile doing a few
scenarios to prepare with a friend/relative. The extended
SJT questions were also very useful, particularly the example
answers and feedback on those answers. However, no
personal feedback is immediately available, although there is
an option to send in videos of consultations if you would like
this.
Stage 3 This takes a few hours due to the admin involved (longer
Assessment than you'd expect!) - quite a few people were caught out by
booking transport earlier than the finishing time. The
request to bring a photocopy of the front cover of your
passport is genuine - I thought this was a mistake!
Candidates tended to be wearing work clothes much like you
would on a ward or for clinic.
Stage 4
Final Thoughts Fairly straightforward.
Alicia Garland
Application Form Its much more straightforward than bbt or cmt.
Stage 2/SRA Online question bank. Passmedicine 8/10. Started 2 weeks
Preparation before as i didnt realise this was a thing before that date.
Not sure it helped me. I passed but the questions were
bizzare on the day.
Stage 2 Its crazy. Pick the most appropriate option from a list of
Assessment things which are awful. Practice banks probably the only
way to prep to learn what theyre looking for. Has nothing yo
do with your actual clinical competence.
Stage 3 Practice with friends.
Preparation
Stage 3 Stay calm.Elicit hidden agendas. Actively listen. Stick to your
Assessment guns.
Stage 4 Got first choice. But turned it down in favour of bbt.
Final Thoughts The exam needs to be ditched. The selection centre was false
but OK. Roleplays so prepare yourself for difficult coms
roleplays.
Ailsa Gellan
Application Form Be careful when entering your employment history as quite
- 28 -
confusion the way you need to order them. Also don't forget
to put your time in university in as otherwise will appear as
an employment break and potentially cause problems!
Stage 2/SRA MCQ bank online questions - 8/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 Generally ok, found it quite hard to revise for given the wide
Assessment array of topics it can cover. I regretted not spending more
time doing practice questions. I found some of the medical
questions quite frustrating as I felt they sometimes
didn't give enough detail and a couple of the answers could
have been right depending on how you interpreted the
information. I also found the SJT style questions quite
frustrating as often I didn't really feel any of the answers
where ideal and therefore tricky to rank. Found it harder
than the SJT in medical school as there sometimes wasn't a
clear best and worse option. Good to do see practice
questions to get used to layout of questions.
Stage 3 MCQ bank - 9/10.
Preparation
Stage 3 Quite nice as far as interviews goes - everyone very friendly.
Assessment Worth reading up what to expect in the 3 stations and doing
some practice scenarios. I felt much less nervous having
done this.
Stage 4
Final Thoughts If applying for Scotland don't forget to look up which
deaneries offer the golden handshake/ cash incentive!
Jennifer Mitchell
Application Form Give yourself plenty of time to get in touch with your three
referees before the application process begins!
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank, 8/10 for clinical, 5/10 for situational
Preparation judgement questions.
Stage 2 It was pretty straight forward and much like sitting the
Assessment situational judgement paper in medical school (although
with, what felt like, less information per question)
Stage 3 I read GMC material (6/10) and practised timing myself for
Preparation the consultation parts. Make sure you finish the paper
including the reflection part at the end - time yourself on this
beforehand to ensure you leave enough time. I know a few
people who left with reduced scores because of this.
Clear process. Be aware that the GP practice you will
be going to with each set of jobs is avilable to view when
completing the form. Again, I have a colleague who didn't
realise this, based their choices on the hospital rotations
available and now has a GP practice fairly far from where
they live.
Stage 3 Timing is everything! Make sure you have enough to contact
Assessment your referees, complete the application, complete the
assessments and think carefully about your job ranking. Find
your university certificate in advance as this will need
photocopied and the original brought to the assessment day
along with your other documents.
Stage 4
Final Thoughts Revise when you're able to - there are lots of resources
available. Focus on your communication skills for the
assessment day.
- 29 -
Emma Wilson
Application Form I found the application form easy to complete - this was
mostly due to the information provided in this recruitment
guide and from the Oriel Applicant Guide. I was glad to have
the dates for my previous rotations already noted down in
my CV as this would have been one of the more time-
consuming parts of the application. I would also ensure you
nominate referees early and ensure they are aware of the
time frame for submitting the reference early to avoid
chasing up references before the end date.
Stage 2/SRA I started preparing around 4-5 months in advance and used
Preparation this recruitment guide, resources provided by GPNRO and
MCQbank mainly. I would recommend starting preparation
early so that you don’t have to cram hours of revision around
your shifts and especially around Christmas and New Year!
MCQ bank covered both CKT and SJT content well and I
found their questions to be at a similar level to that of the
assessment with excellent feedback after each question - the
price for MCQbank was also quite reasonable considering the
content of the resource. Resources: MCQbank 10/10 GPNRO
resources 6/10 - I found this resource less useful as the
answers were not provided for multiple sample exercises.
Stage 2 I found the assessment process to be straightforward and
Assessment was happy to see that my assessment centre (Aberdeen)
booked out a room just for the GP assessment and we didn’t
have to worry about other exams taking place that may have
had loud audio etc. I felt I had sufficient time for the SJT
questions but found I had to manage my time carefully for
the CKT as the allocated time was very tight. I also found
some of the CKT questions to be quite vague with little
information provided, which proved difficult when trying to
answer questions quickly and efficiently. Otherwise the
assessment process was structured and uncomplicated.
Stage 3 Resources used: GPNRO resources 6/10 - again answers not
Preparation provided for multiple sample exercises so less useful; Role
playing with colleagues - particularly useful to practice
scenarios with friends/family who don’t have a medical
background. MCQbank 10/10 - again excellent feedback for
questions and provides great structure for answering written
paper and for consultations. Videos of consultations were
also provided with detailed feedback about consultation style
and content which were very useful. I would recommend
starting preparation for the selection centre soon after the
MSRA as the period of time between finding out if you have
qualified for direct entry or not and your interview date is
very short.
Stage 3 I found the Selection Centre assessment to be quite useful,
Assessment and found the assessment was structured but not too
regimented as I’ve seen some Selection Centres have been
from previous feedback. We had the written exercise first
(Selection Centre in Edinburgh) which I felt well prepared for
and finished with good time. Time management was very
important for the written exercise and I would highly
recommend having key reflection points already in mind as
there are many common themes in the scenarios used (e.g.
- 30 -
time management, team working, respect for colleagues,
leadership skills, patient safety etc.) - MCQbank was
excellent for providing key points for reflection to apply in
these scenarios. A number of candidates in my assessment
had not practiced any of the written exercise scenarios
available and they all found they didn’t have time to
complete the written exercise (particularly the reflection
section). The patient simulations went smoothly and our
actors were all well prepared - I didn’t find any of them to be
too challenging or obstructive to progression of the
consultation. I got the impression our ability to build rapport,
problem solve, structure a consultation and explore
patient/relative/colleague ideas/concerns/expectations and
our general communication skills were the main points under
assessment. I didn't feel our clinical knowledge was
particularly assessed. I would recommend making sure you
have all the correct documentation and the appropriate
photocopies before attending the assessment (of the 15
people present at our assessment only 2 of us actually had all
of the correct documentation required).
Stage 4 I was fortunate to get my first choice and found the process
of accepting an offer to be straightforward. I would keep an
eye on the recruitment timeline and check your portal
regularly as Oriel’s system for sending out email updates for
your application are often delayed days after the update!!
Final Thoughts Thank you so much for your fantastic recruitment guide. I
felt the process of applying was much easier and less
stressful with all the feedback provided in this guide.
- 31 -
NORTH EAST
Ewelina Emilianowicz
Application Form Overall it was self explanatory and simple. Pitfal, you need to
get FY1-2 competencies signed off, everything in the form
has to be ticked as completed.
Stage 2/SRA MCQ bank, Emedica, Oxford clinical handbook of medicine;
Preparation MCQ 10, Emedica 9.
Stage 2 It was easy to go through questions, organized in a good
Assessment way. TIps, time is a factor, you have to have the answer
right away. No time to go back. I would not suggest flagging
any questions, just going one by one, if not sure about an
answer just quess and move on.
Stage 3 Emedica, MCQ bank- both would rate as 10. Dont need to
Preparation atted a face to face course. Online is enought, just give time.
Stage 3 That was the most stressful and difficult part for me. I camw
Assessment out feeling like a failue, but in the end ended up passing. Try
to stay calm, think if ICE, be nice, polite, allow patients to
talk.
Stage 4 No problems.
Final Thoughts
Razna Latif
Application Form I thought the application was overall straightforward, at first
when you have to rank your preferences it says 0 places so
still put down your preferences as later on vacancies do turn
up. One problem I had I did miss important messages as I
didn't always check my oriel account. Also you have to be
quick to book the test date as I had one day off to do stage
two I live in the north east no dates we're available for stage
2 near where I lived only date available was in London 8.30
in the morning so I had to take a coach overnight to arrive
there on time as I had finished my a&e shift at 10pm and
coach was the only public transport that would get me there
on time so I tried to sleep on the coach and arrived in
London at 6am ready to do the test.
Stage 2/SRA I used both emedica and mcqbank for stage 2 I felt both
Preparation were good i would rate both of them 8/10 and felt well
prepared when using them.
Stage 2 I felt the computerised test was straight forward but have to
Assessment be quick with the answers.
Stage 3 I used MCQ bank I would give it 10/10 it was amazing
Preparation prepared me really well for stage 3 went through all the
scenarios with my sister and then went through the
scenarios again and made notes on useful phrases. I also
went through the written prioritisation exercise scenarios
from MCQ bank and made notes. I thought of going on a
course but didn't need to MCQbank was all I needed.
Stage 3 Did run out of time for the written prioritisation exercise, I
Assessment didn't like the fact that I wasn't able to highlight the sheet
with the scenarios on especially when there was a lot of text.
Stage 4 It was good that they told us early about my offer at 9.15am.
Final Thoughts I felt it was straightforward. The timescales is actually short
between all the stages especially if you are working during
that time so it might be a good idea to start preparing for
- 32 -
stage 2 as soon as you apply. Don't wait for the results of
stage 2 to consider preparing for stage 3. As soon as you are
eligible for either stage 2 or 3 book your slot as it could
mean you have to travel far or worse not find a venue sit the
exam. Thank you for your guide I found it really helpful and
have been using it throughout the application process.
Katie Mellor
Application Form
Stage 2/SRA I used Pass Medicine (which I used for finals).The questions
Preparation were similar to the real thing. The topics were most helpful.
It bought up a few topics that came up I wouldn’t have
looked at otherwise. I found it useful from to increase my
confidence pre test. Friends used MCQ bank. I panicked just
before and signed up to this too. This was unnecessary. Both
sites are similar.
Stage 2 I thought it went smoothly. I had no problems with the way
Assessment it worked.
Stage 3 I used some of the example scenarios on MCQ bank. These
Preparation were helpful to get in the right mind set. Communication
skills are being tested so it is was something that didn’t need
lots of practice.
Stage 3 The selection centre was daunting. I didn’t realise you have
Assessment to call in the patient/other role play participant on my first
station and wasted time. This wasn’t very clear. Just stay
calm and don’t over think things. Talk to the person infront
of you as you would in normal working conditions.
Stage 4 Northumbria covers such a large area. It needs to be broken
down more. Specialities grouped together varied a lot so it
was difficult to rank them in order of preference.
Final Thoughts
Keren Wee
Application Form
Stage 2/SRA I used passmedicine.
Preparation
Stage 2 It was ok.
Assessment
Stage 3 I used books.
Preparation
Stage 3 A lot of waiting around.
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts
- 33 -
NORTHWEST
Alice Chigagure
Application Form Application process very straightforward, and GPNRO
regularly send reminder emails and respond promptly to
emails.
Stage 2/SRA I revised for about 3 months before - (albeit very slow
Preparation progress for first 2 months ), First 2 months - I used pass
medicine and emedica. Passmedicine was good for general
background knowledge, but Emedica was most like the exam
questions!, I also used MCQ bank for the final month leading
up to the exam - again like E-medica it was similar to the
exam ! out of 10 passmedicine 7/10, Emedica 10/10, MCQ
bank 9/10, I thought the exam was fair , similar to finals
(possibly a bit easier!) did well , scored band 3 in both the
SJT and clinical knowledge section.
Stage 2 I was very annoyed by the MCQ test - perhaps it was just me
Assessment and pehaps it had been mentioned and I had simply
forgotten. I didn't realise that once you finish part A
(situational judgement) and move onto the MCQ (part B) you
cant go back. I had a bit of a nightmare durig the exam as I
lost track of time , and looked up at the clock and assumed I
only had 45 minutes total to completethe whole exam,As a
result I rushed through the SJT in order to finish it all. To my
horror the screen displayed a message 'thank you for
completing part A , you can now move onto part B, pease
note you cannot go back) . I was so annoyed as the SJT has
the most weighting and I hade essentially done in half the
allocated time ! - so beware".
Stage 3 To be honest I did one evenings worth of preparation for the
Preparation scenarios- me and 2 friends practiced for 6 hours straight
arounf takeaway I wouldn't recommend it - but that said I
scored very highly at stage 3 Overall !scoring 34 /36 for the
scenarios and 14/16 for the written exercise. On the day
staff were very friendly and there was lots of water but no
food. The only problem is I feel that the day gets dragged
out a bit too much , I was an afternoon candidate so arrived
at midday and we did not finish until 5 ! For the written part
I used a green book called @GP ST stage 3 written and
simulation exercises - 2nd edition , Huges and Tanna - rating
8/10 - very useful especially for written exercise. I should
have purchased the E-medica stage 3 scenarios as a friend of
mine had them and they were very good - rating 9/10.
Stage 3 Tips- remember to bring food and water , as well as all the
Assessment required ID. Also book your test centre ASAP ! the slots go
very quickly and by the time Oriel send you a text most have
been booked ! - I luckily got one close to me.
Stage 4 Allocation process was straightforward for me , towards the
deadline, Oriel sent us a final reminder to make sure our
allocation rankings were correct. I luckily got my first choice
. Oriel also send texts but these are often a few hours after
things have been updated on Oriel so check Oriel regularly as
well as your emails.
Final Thoughts Overall process very good and very straightforward.
however, most of Oriel is very user friendly apart from being
able to find the specific dates for things e.g. interview date s,
- 34 -
dates offers are posted etc.. Additionally there is not contact
number for Oriel /GPNRO and it would be useful to speak to
someone from time to time.
Wynne Chong
Application Form I was not aware that you could change your referee choices
after submitting the application. A pre-knowledge of that
would have been helpful as I changed my 1 of my referees
due to lack of response from them. I did not receive a reply
from the email found on Oriel for certain queries. I found it a
lot more straightforward ringing the NHS England contact
number directly. They are based in Piccadilly Place in
Manchester. I was put through to someone who could help
answer questions regarding Oriel and the application.
Stage 2/SRA I prepared using MCQBank for both clinical problem solving
Preparation and professional dilemma questions. I would rank MCQBank
8 out of 10. for clinical problem solving. It was more difficult
than the questions on the SRA which made me feel more
confident. I didn't feel MCQBank helped with professional
dilemma questions. I don't think it is possible to prepare for
professional dilemma questions as these are so varied and
situational.
Stage 2 I found the assessment very straightforward. It is exactly
Assessment the same as a driving theory test. They provided earplugs, a
marker pen and a board for you to write on. I did not need to
use the writing material as there were no questions
requiring calculations. The earplugs were useful as the sound
of clicking mouses can be quite a deterrent in such a small
quiet enclosed space. I found it useful to flag up questions
that I was not sure of. There is no time to waste and you
generally spend about a minute on each question. I was able
to review all the questions I flagged up towards the end.
Stage 3 I prepared by using the selection centre material on
Preparation MCQBank. I practised the simulation exercises with a fellow
applicant and practised the written exercises on my own. I
decided against going to any courses due to previously
successful applicants advising that they did not find the
courses particularly helpful. The written exercises on
MCQBank were far shorter than that of the actual day. I
generally spend about 15-30 seconds reading each scenario
on MCQBank.
Stage 3 On the day the scenarios were fairly long and took at least 1
Assessment minute to read each of them. This was unexpected and I
almost ran out of time with this exercise. I felt the
simulation exercises on MCQBank were far more complicated
than that of the actual day. I actually thought this was an
advantage as the simulations on the day were much easier to
deal with. There was a photocopier at the selection centre
for those who didn’t bring copies of their documents.
Stage 4 I thought it was a straightforward process. I got my 5th
choice but accepted the offer with upgrades. I was then
upgraded to my 2nd choice quite quickly. I would encourage
applicants who didn’t get their top choices to do the same.
Final Thoughts
- 35 -
Michael Durbar
Application Form I used mcq bank went through every question once in the 4
weeks prior to the exam, reread whole of the good medical
practice books and redid the sjt questions.
Stage 2/SRA Would have been helpful to revise rheumatology and the
Preparation different anti ccp etc as there seemed to be a lot of questions
regarding these. The cetre did not allow any coats or
jumpers so agree with your previous corespondents re
clothes.
Stage 2
Assessment
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts The offer process was smooth but the preemployment run by
Pennine Acute seems totally disorganised and incompentent.
Emma Hughes
Application Form Don't recall any particular pitfalls - just leave enough time to
go through it properly as can take a while!
Stage 2/SRA Mostly just used Pass Medicine question bank - I would say 7
Preparation out of 10.
Stage 2 Very tight for time in clinical section but plenty of time for
Assessment the SJT section.
Stage 3 Went to a Blackstone Tutors course and did plenty of
Preparation practice with some other trainees who were applying.
Stage 3 Not too bad at all. Take a watch to time the OSCE style
Assessment stations as no warning buzzer goes off at 5 or 9 minutes and
it's easy not to finish. Written section very tight for time.
Stage 4 I will be starting an ACF post in GP so the allocation process
was quite different for me.
Final Thoughts
Sophie McMurray
Application Form Pretty straightforward and self-explanatory.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank to prepare and found it had some similar
Preparation questions/themes to the actual exam. It was a good way of
refreshing knowledge on a whole host of topics and
prompted me to brush up on some areas that I didn’t
perform so well in, using past revision notes. I would rate
MCW bank 9/10. One of my only critiques of it would be that
the timed sessions (where you set the time and number of
items) actually cram in more questions than the actual exam,
as some ‘items’ have more than one question attached to it.
This did mean I had much more time than I expected in the
actual exam.
Stage 2 Being able to flag certain questions you’re not sure on is a
Assessment good way of marking which ones to go back to at the end if
you have time.
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
- 36 -
Assessment
Stage 4 I received a direct offer for my first choice. All
communication ran smoothly and I was well-informed
throughout.
Final Thoughts Thanks for the guide, it gave a great overview of the
application process, especially as I was locuming this year
and so didn’t have that much other advice regarding the
process!
Shail Jalan
Application Form Its quite straightforward. Its one of the simplest applications
to fill out.
Stage 2/SRA I used online questions. 8/10. I used the oxford handbook of
Preparation medicine. 5/10 It was good.
Stage 2 The PD part of the questionnaire was very mind boggling. I
Assessment think it should be shortened.
Stage 3 I used online resources. 10/10. I did role play with
Preparation colleagues which was most helpful.
Stage 3 It was alright. Just be prepared to be there for at least 5-6
Assessment hours.
Stage 4 No point giving preferences.
Final Thoughts The selection process is good. I just wish there was more
transparency in the allocation of area and posts.
Isabelle Short
Application Form Clear to fill out and self explanatory.
Stage 2/SRA I read the guide and did some MCQs on MCQ bank - not sure
Preparation how useful this was, I did not do many questions (and
therefore was probably a waste of money!). I felt the most
useful thing that helped me was that I had a 4 month GP
rotation before applied!
Stage 2 It was clear - make sure to read the questions carefully!
Assessment
Stage 3 I was lucky enough not to need to go!
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts None - thanks for the guide
Samantha Simpkins
Application Form Very simple, no additional room for extra achievements. I
asked for a deferred start date and reduced time due to
previously completing CMT on the form and this was granted
later
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ Bank - I’m not sure it really helped to be honest.
Preparation I passed without needing to interview but I didn’t do as well
on the SJT questions and didn’t learn that much from the
bank. Not sure it was worth the money over the cheaper
banks.
Stage 2 Simple to complete. Time consuming!!
Assessment
Stage 3
- 37 -
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts Really pleasant experience compared to applying to CMT!
M Stockdale
Application Form Applied to northwest, was successful, initially allocated not
to first choice, but upgraded to 1st choice trust later.
Stage 2/SRA Used several tetbooks with mcqs and also paid for mcq bank
Preparation online. Both very good resources, textbook 7, mcqbank 9/10.
Stage 2 Straight forward compute based assessment, trickier than I
Assessment was anticipating but nothing out of the ordinary.
Stage 3 Didn't really use much to prepare, just went through a few
Preparation scenarios and talked to previous candidates.
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts if i could go back i would revise more thoroughly, particularly
commonly assessed areas with varied question topics,
particularly endocrine, ENT and visual problems. The
interview day booked up very quickly, make sure you book
straight away and stay closeby to avoid any travel delays
Charlotte Thorne
Application Form The form itself was straightforward, lengthy and thanks to
your advice I started filling it out early which made the
process easier.
Stage 2/SRA I paid for MCQ bank, as others had said it was most like the
Preparation MSRA. 9/10 (really really good, just a shame it is
significantly more expensive than other resources). I did find
that the questions were very similar, although am not sure
that the extra money made MCQbank worthwhile for the
clinical knowledge questions alone.- I found that the SJT
section of MCQbank was really helpful, both for the written
exam and the 'interview' section, and would highly
recommend it as these are the areas that seemed to set
applicants apart.
Stage 2 As with all exams, some questions had typos +/ did not
Assessment seem to make sense which was frustrating. I found that I
had enough time to complete all of the questions. We were
advised not to take food or drink, but our test centre allowed
food and drink to be near you which we could get to during a
break - I recommend this!
Stage 3 MCQbank 9/10 - Plenty of resources with role play guidance
Preparation and generic feedback built around key approach points. I
thought this was really helpful, as it led me to develop a
basic structure for different scenarios and allowed me to
drop the 'acting' which helps gain the extra marks. Practicing
the written part and a few role play scenarios with a friend
was enough for this. The video consultations were also
helpful, to gauge where I was at compared to another
candidate, and to consider my wording to difficult questions.
- 38 -
Stage 3 This was a long day, I was warned in advance that we would
Assessment be waiting around a lot so took a book and plenty of food -
strongly advise this! Well organised, the staff were very
friendly, and the actors and examiners were fair and
encouraging. I think a lot of candidates became stressed
because the scenarios were difficult/ awkward - it is
important to remember that you do not need to have the
answer! Just end with an appropriate plan (which could be:
'I'll go and discuss this with my seniors, and then can we
meet again this afternoon?') was often appropriate.
Stage 4 It was unclear which day we would be informed about our
offers, and it was made very clear that if we did not accept in
good time the offer would be withdrawn. This felt a little
stressful as I had booked a holiday during the 3 week
window in which I thought we would hear back with offers. I
would say be aware that you may receive an offer within a
fairly big window of time, but as long as you have internet
access the process to accept/ accept with upgrades is
very easy.
Final Thoughts I thought that the process overall was fair. I was glad I
prepared for the MSRA exam in advance, mainly the SJT
section as I felt that the tactics of ranking were most
important. I received an e-mail from the Selection Centre
about a month after the 'interviews' for travel expenses
claims, and there was a section on the to claim for overnight
stay in a hotel as well. It might be worth looking into this for
your test location if you are having difficulty with the
logistics of getting there. It is a shame the recruitment
website isn't set up so that the process is clearly outlined,
but this guide was really helpful and meant that I could
focus on one bit at a time - thank you! Thank you so much
for creating this guide, and for continuing to work hard to
make others feel comfortable in applying to GP training.
Overall, with your guidance and speaking to those who are
a year or two into their GP training, the process was
straightforward. However, the GP recruitment websites are
not ideal! And important information is difficult to find!
- 39 -
SOUTH WEST
Farnaz Akbar
Application Form It was straightforward, but some of it was repeated again
after Ward , after acceptance in pre-registration process.
Stage 2/SRA MCQ bank-10/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 Keep track of time, try to finish before time.
Assessment
Stage 3 Solo, but I have been recently preparing for PACES course,
Preparation that was great help.
Stage 3 Again allocate time for each written task. MCQ bank style for
Assessment interview was of great help.
Stage 4 Straightforward, but waiting for outcome was quite stress
full.
Final Thoughts Many thanks for providing such a useful information. It
streamlined and helped me in preparation without drowning
myself in information jungle. please continue.
Elspeth Bisson
Application Form
Stage 2/SRA I mainly used passmed and mcqbank - rated both as useful -
Preparation scored well in exam.
Stage 2 Quite a lot of paeds and dermatology. Much easier to revise
Assessment when can apply to patients have actually treated.
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 This was all quite stressful - long waits for allocations,
upgrades, job allocations once in upgrade etc. Got 3rd
choice of Bath was then moved up to Bristol and Somerset
but elected to move back to Bath. Severn deaneries actually
more competitive than London this year - I got direct entry
and foolishly assumed I would get straight into Bristol but
this did not happen.
Final Thoughts I found it pretty stressful to be honest. Hated how I was just
a number and never any personal touches. I think everyone
assumes its easy to get a GP job but actually you aren't
treated particularly kindly and still some healthy
competition.
Clemency Clarke
Application Form Very straightforward. Currently doing an F3 in Australia and
there is a place to explain why you don't hold a GMC license
if applicable.
Stage 2/SRA I only went throught the MCQ bank (9/10) and read through
Preparation the answers. Once I had gone through these I also bough
pastest (6/10) but I didn't find it nearly as good actually.
Only helpful thing was you can put it on your phone.
Stage 2 It was fine. The centers were very strict about everything
Assessment including checking my glasses. You're not allowed water in
the center which is a bit ridiculous I thought. Make sure to
- 40 -
practice the online one just to know the system.
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts Overall straightforward- not trying to trick you. Your guide
was so helpful- thank you very much!
Sireesha Dhannapuneni
Application Form Very straightforward, no pitfall experienced.
Stage 2/SRA MCQ Bank 9/10 BMJ on Examination 8/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 It is very time pressurised. I am not very fast as such. My
Assessment goal was to be able to answer all questions with in the time
and was glad I managed to do so. Make sure you manage to
attempt and answer all questions.
Stage 3 MCQ bank- very good 10/10.
Preparation
Stage 3 Can be very daunting on the day. Be yourself and remember
Assessment there are a lot of limitations for simulation (patient, relative,
colleague) scenarios. I prepared for the scenarios with high
expectations after watching the videos on MCQ bank
material but the role players are not as good in the real
examination as the person in the video.
Stage 4 No issues with feedback, it is quite generic.
Final Thoughts The whole process of GP recruitment may initially appear
complex however there is lot of useful info everywhere, once
familiarise yourself, you find that it is very straightforward.
Georgie Maguire
Application Form Application form was straight forward and user friendly (as
long as you weren't using a phone).
Stage 2/SRA I used passmedicine and MCQ bank. I would give
Preparation passmedicine 8/10 as it was so user-friendly and I loved the
qn layout etc but found that the material was too focused on
guidelines so MCQ bank would be 8/10 as the content
seemed to come up more in the actual exam but I hated the
layout of the website.
Stage 2 The assessment was tricky. I learnt that it is definitely
Assessment beneficial to revise for SJT. I had focused on preparing for
the knowledge section which I did well in but didn't do as
well on the SJT section. So much time for the SJT part and
very short of time for the main section.
Stage 3 I prepared using MCQ bank stage 3 role play examples and
Preparation written prep. I would rate it 10/10. It was very helpful and
glad I took the time to run through some role plays with my
partner (non-medic). I scored 100% in both parts so
preparation was definitely helpful.
Stage 3 I thought the selection centre day ran smoothly once it
Assessment actually got started but we had to wait an extra 2 hours
before it started in the morning so that made everyone more
nervous. I did mine in Bristol. I had been warned that you
don't have long in the written component but I would
- 41 -
reiterate that advice as I felt very rushed and half an hour
goes by in a flash.
Stage 4 Allocation was straight forward, although they emailed later
than they actually released the offers on Oriel and when I
got upgraded I wasn't notified until 2 days after.
Final Thoughts Overall very good selection process. It does seem to drag on
and takes up more time than I had previously appreciated
but I am pleased with the outcome and think it is quite
fair. Thank you for your guide, it was very helpful.
Lauren Pearce
Application Form
Stage 2/SRA Used MCQBank. Very useful 9/10. Good question
Preparation explainations
Stage 2 Similar to practice questions. Go with your gut on ethics
Assessment part, try not to overthink. Have an idea of timing for each
question.
Stage 3 MCQBank scenarios- got friends/family to roll play. Very
Preparation useful and a good reflection of scenarios. For the part of
prioritising tasks was also very useful - made me come up
with some good stock phrases to use in multiple situations
9/10.
Stage 3 Fine. The writing task threw me off a bit as it was quite
Assessment different to practice ones, but don't get too focused on
getting the correct order and just find reasons to justify your
original decision- even if you change your mind halfway
through .
Stage 4 Good and timely. 100% for 3 interview stations and 100%
for written exercise.
Final Thoughts None. Travel can be claimed back which I hadn't realised!
Stage 3 takes a good four hours, don't expect to finish early!
Can claim a cpd certificate for six hours from MCQBank for
£8.
- 42 -
THAMES
Gillian Warren
Application Form Application form was straight forward.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank as the feedback on your guide seemed very
Preparation positive. I would rate it 9/10.
Stage 2 I felt the clinical questions were fair however the SJT
Assessment questions were really random and quite unrealistic scenarios
at times.
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 Allocation seemed straight forward. I was disappointed
when I found out from my deanery that rotations were
allocated randomly and not based on application score as I
had done well in the MCQ. It wasn't what I'd expected so
would have been good for the rotation allocation process to
have been explained prior to applying. However fortunately I
still managed to get my first choice of rotations
Final Thoughts Many thanks for making your guide, I found the information
invaluable!
- 43 -
WALES
Peter Hancock
Application Form Very self explanatory.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank which was excellent. I focused too much
Preparation on the clinical questions during my preparation, I wish I’d
spent more time on the situational judgement part as it’s
worth more marks. It’s harder than the SJT for the
foundation program
Stage 2 I’I was very pushed for time.
Assessment
Stage 3 Again I used MCQ bank. There are videoed simulation
Preparation consultations which were very useful and very like the actual
consultations in the selection centre.
Stage 3 Everyone was very friendly and helpful, I did not feel like
Assessment anyone was trying to catch me out.
Stage 4 I was allocated Gwent in South Wales. I chose this so I can
live in Bristol and drive. It’s much less competitive than
Severn deanery, I got my top choice of jobs which I
definitely would not have got in Severn.
Final Thoughts Compared to speciality recruitment it was much quicker and
easier, and at no point was a portfolio required.
Ffion Prothero
Application Form Straightforward and pretty easy.
Stage 2/SRA MCQ books, 9/10. There isn’t long to prepare, only about a
Preparation couple of weeks. I didn’t want to tempt fate in getting all the
books before i knew I was invited to do the assessment so
had less time. Probably better to concentrate on the clinical
than the professional dilemma part as it’s more clear cut-you
either know the answer or you don’t. Common sense is the
professional one and very difficult to knoe the ‘wrong’
answer.
Stage 2 There was only a 2 minute gap between the two
Assessment assessments, they said at the reception that there was 5 and
you could stretch your legs but no so it gets tiring. I had
oven an hour left for both so left early, it isn’t bad, just have
to get on with it.
Stage 3 Didn’t prepare, I though it was best to be myself and do
Preparation exactly as I would if I was at work faced with these patients.
Found this approach to be straightforward and felt much less
nervous.
Stage 3 Had pretty much full marks in all the stations so must have
Assessment done something right!
Stage 4 None, happy with my first choice.
Final Thoughts Very efficient and swift process from beginning to end.
- 44 -
WESSEX
Rich Cross
Application Form Straightforward from what I remember – but took longer to
fill out than I thought it would.
Stage 2/SRA MCQ bank – 9/10 Gpstcourses 3/10.
Preparation
Stage 2 Do lots of MCQ bank questions. Clinical knowledge similar to
Assessment finals. Think about specialties (derm, micro, paeds, O&G).
Stage 3 MCQ bank videos, spoke with GP trainees.
Preparation
Stage 3 Don’t get stressed. Remember to ask about “how they feel”
Assessment and “is there anything else troubling you” etc. The actors
were fair especially compared to GKT OSCEs which I had to
endure!
Stage 4 Straightforward.
Final Thoughts Not too taxing in the end!
Lauren Lock
Application Form It was unclear whether to tick the box for deferred entry on
the application form as it said this was only for ‘statutory
reasons’ e.g. sickness, pregnancy etc. I didn’t get a reply
when I asked the deanery and the guidance online said to
send a letter explaining why you want to defer within 2
weeks of getting an offer. So I didn’t tick the box and sent
the letter and I was granted deferral. Others, did tick the box
and automatically got the deferral- I think it depends on the
deanery.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank for 1-2 months but was also on a GP
Preparation rotation at the time which was useful. I would rate MCQ
Bank 10/10- and I got a high enough score to get direct
entry.
Stage 2 The computerised assessment was clear and easy to use.
Assessment
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts Make sure you email you’re references to remind them to do
it- one of mine was on annual leave for the 2 weeks before
the deadline and I hadn’t realised they’d not done it, but
easy to change referees which is what I did in the end. Not
sure what happens if your references aren’t complete! :/
Rachael McGowan
Application Form Application form felt fairly straightforward. Couldn't work
out how to rank the jobs though - didn't realise it was simply
drag and drop.
Stage 2/SRA I used passmedicine (8/10) and MCQ bank (9/10).
Preparation
Stage 2 It was fine. You need to pace yourself, make sure you learn
Assessment some opthalmology/radiology in preparation stages. The SJT
- 45 -
questions feel a bit like you could argue for 4/5 options in
the top slot, remember it's ranking them in order of
preference, not the order you would actually do the tasks.
Stage 3 Got direct pathway to offers so didn't need to prepare. Had
Preparation already purchased MCQ bank for this though and think it
would have been good.
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 This was straightforward, no problem. I was particularly
impressed with the speed of communication from Wessex
Deanery - no sooner were the offers out that we got emails
on ranking the jobs / requests for information about the
general area we would be living in so that they could
appropriately allocate the GP roles.
Final Thoughts Felt pretty straightforward to me. GP Recruitment Guide
definitely demystified it!
Pratiksha Patel
Application Form The application form is pretty straightforward I felt, no
obvious pitfalls just to send a few days before the deadline
due to sometimes crashing.
Stage 2/SRA I used passmedicine - i did not think it was representative -
Preparation felt it was a lot easier than the actual exam and think
MCQbank was better (I only used this 2 days before the
exam and didn’t get through it of course) but future
applicants - I would recommend MCQbank.
Stage 2 Just try not to take too long as time goes really quickly.
Assessment
Stage 3 I used emedica online, the resources are really good and I
Preparation got my partner to practice as the patient, colleague, relative
using those scripts. It was the mos helpful thing. The
emedica course was also something I went to, not sure if it
helped more for just making me feel productive and
confidence boosting but you do get to practice and see
others practice which is really good.
Stage 3 The assessment centre I guess felt stressful, like OSCE all
Assessment over again but actually was fine when you started. Time just
goes too quickly in the stations though so practice with time.
Stage 4 Quite straightforward - you get a choice and can accept or
hold or decline and then can get upgraded too. You can move
the rankings around so can put something lower higher if
you want. I got my second choice and then upgraded to
Winchester first choice after a few days.
Final Thoughts Nothing else to add but more than happy to take any
questions from anyone if they need.
Alexander Prudence-Taylor
Application Form Suited to purpose, read it through two or 3 times.
Stage 2/SRA Book and BMJ learning questions; both were closer to the
Preparation SJT for entry to Foundation Schools; questions are more cut
and dry, whereas the GP entry questions were more waffle
and at times it would present you with no good solutions,
and you cannot work out which domain it is primarily
attempting to test. BMJ learning 7/10.
- 46 -
Stage 2 Best to remember that there is a difference between ‘ideal
Assessment world answers’ and ‘real world, practical answers’, and this
seems to test ideal world answers; I think that being in
medical practice actually negatively affects your ‘ideal world
answers’ because from practice you know that half the
answers, while ‘ideal’, are silly suggestions because they
wouldn’t work in the real world, as much as we’d like them
to. Then you have an internal argument as to whether you
answer ‘practically or ideally’. So you never know where you
sit.
Stage 3 Read through possible scenarios on the website, reviewed
Preparation the biopsychosocial model of allowing them to talk, then
exploring their ICE and what they really want (exactly what
being a Foundation doctor in hospital and ED beats out of
you!) – was a nice refreshing thing actually.
Stage 3 Cold, I thought people would be at least a little more social,
Assessment but it was full of people I presume were applying to other
specialities also because I would not have thought they’d be
GPs! Also I appeared in a suit which all my bosses in
hospital advised and there were toehrs there in
jeans! Couldn’t work out if I was over dressed or they were
severely underdressed.
Stage 4 You get a cryptic message from horus that you have to read
between all the code to work out if you have an offer or not.
Final Thoughts There’s no opportinuty to show all the extra work like audits
and research you’ve done.
- 47 -
WEST MIDLANDS
B Ineela
Application Form application process was simple and straight.
Stage 2/SRA pass medicine - 6/10
Preparation
Stage 2 assessment was okay. Time management is the main issue.
Assessment
Stage 3 emedica - 9/10
Preparation
Stage 3 was expected and well organised
Assessment
Stage 4 allocation process is very slow but okay
Final Thoughts
Sanusi Gbolahan
Application Form Requires a lot of detail and dates . Might be a bit difficult to
keep up. It’s helpful that if a date discrepancy occurs , it gets
flagged up and you are notified .
Stage 2/SRA Mcqbank -8/10; Emedica - 6/10 None of the preparatory
Preparation resources give a 100% idea of how the actual exam feels .
All you get is a good idea .
Stage 2 It’s important to go into the assessment centre prepared
Assessment with an open mind
Stage 3 Mcqbank stage 3 online resource 10/10; Emedica stage 3
Preparation session . 10/10. This was expecially helpful close to the
exam because certain situations where I was not sure of
during preparation were clarified . Scored a 51/52
Stage 3 it’s alright to be nervous . Just do what you would in an
Assessment actual consultation and ‘dig deep then wide ‘ with the
questions
Stage 4 The preferencing process is important . Think through the
preferencing and have them ranked on your preference
rather than what you think others might choose .
Final Thoughts Studying for the stage 2 bit is the most difficult part .
Everything else gets easier after that
Abdullah Habeebu
Application Form It was pretty straightforward
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQBank and will rate them 9/10
Preparation
Stage 2 The timing appeared short, especially for the second part. If
Assessment unsure about an answer, just guess and move on. You can
return to the question if chanced at the end.
Stage 3 I uesd MCQbank and will rate them 9/10
Preparation
Stage 3 It was straightforward. Get to know the venue and how to
Assessment get there before the exam day if possible.
Stage 4 It is fair.
Final Thoughts It was a comparatively easy and straightforward process.
I was successful but had to relinquish it because I
tried to defer my start date, my request was refused and I
was unable to resume.
- 48 -
Sarika Kapoor
Application Form Application form quite straightforward. Difficult to rank
choices from a smartphone, maybe clearer instructions on
drag and drop.
Stage 2/SRA Emedica 8.5/10 layout similar, MCQbank 8/10, Passmedicine
Preparation 8/10 good for consolidating learning with explanations but a
lot also irrelevant.
Stage 2 Did not like SJT part, confusing questions and seemed very
Assessment subjective. No question banks helped for this but maybe
should have used them!
Stage 3 Emedica course - scenarios and attending day interview
Preparation course which was super useful as individual feedback given
and really replicated exam scenario. Would highly
recommend as got full marks! Course material also helped
with essay question and structure of answers. 10/10
Stage 3 See above. Quite relaxing surprisingly.
Assessment
Stage 4 Quite difficult ranking all the jobs in the West Midlands
central region. I noticed other regions were split up into
hospital which would probably be a lot easier as oppose to
ranking 64 jobs.
Final Thoughts fair process in terms of knowledge and interview skills. I do
think knowledge should superseed SJT though in terms of
contributing to overall score. SJT seems very subjective and
still not sure how much this is actually a true reflection of a
candidate. Thanks for your guide! Really helped me out!!
- 49 -
YORKSHIRE AND HUMBER
Maya Boro
Application Form Application form straight forward and easy.
Stage 2/SRA Passmedicine
Preparation
Stage 2 I thought it was straightforward. I did rush in the end
Assessment though, maybe I should have practised timing.
Stage 3 Prepared with a GP registrar.
Preparation
Stage 3 Assessment day was very straight forward. No surprises.
Assessment There was good introduction from the organisers about the
day and also a debrief session at the end. There was also a
Q&A about the whole recruitment process, and specific
things regarding Yorkshire & Humber region.
Stage 4 No issues. I got my first choice. Yorkshire & Humber released
all of their programmes so I was able to make the right
choice.
Final Thoughts It was easy - nothing to worry about.
Amy Cartwright
Application Form Found the application pretty straightforward with the help of
this guide.
Stage 2/SRA I used pass medicine. It did the job but wasn’t very inspiring.
Preparation 7/10.
Stage 2 Set up was pretty standard but not much time - work quickly
Assessment and if you’re stuck, make an educated guess, flag it to come
back to and move on!
Stage 3 Just read this guide for stage 3 and made sure I’d read the
Preparation question format before the day. I was told not to prepare
much by previous applicants.
Stage 3 Selection centre prioritisation exercise was pretty short on
Assessment time and lots of my tasks to prioritise were fairly non-urgent
which made prioritising them tricky. The scenarios were all
fairly similar to what I’ve faced in Foundation.
Stage 4 No problems or complications.
Final Thoughts Found the whole thing quite straightforward and stress-free!
Rachel Casey
Application Form Application form is fairly straightforward, would recommend
getting in touch with your references to remind them to
complete it, I know some colleagues had a hard time chasing
them up.
Stage 2/SRA I used MCQ bank which was really helpful, I'd say 8/10. It
Preparation also gives you practice examples for Stage 3 which was
great. I was on a busy medical job at the time so didn't do as
much revision as I'd have wanted to, but doing these
questions whenever I got a spare few minutes really helped.
Having said that I'd recommend not worrying too much
about it! The question bank of exam questions seemed to be
so broad, and you can't cover everything, you just have to do
what you can.
Stage 2 The computerised exam system was easy to use - I'd
- 50 -
Assessment recommend taking advantage of the flagging system so you
can review questions you're not sure on. MCQ bank has an
option of viewing the questions as you would in the exam so
you can get used to the layout which was helpful.
Stage 3 I used MCQ bank to prepare for Stage 3 (8/10) - they have
Preparation practice scenarios which I went through with friends. I'd
definitely recommend practicing a few of the written
prioritisation questions as you are very time-limited! But the
actual practical stations aren't really things you can rehearse
or prepare for too much, just need to relax on the day.
Stage 3 You have quite a lot of waiting around on the actual day, so
Assessment bring snacks or try to arrange to go with friends or people
who will help you to relax.
Stage 4 Using the computer system to rank jobs was fairly
straightforward. The actual allocations was quite frustrating
as a few of my colleagues were able to log in and change
their preferences after we had been allocated a scheme,
meaning when they were upgraded they were upgraded into
their 1st choice rather than 2nd/3rd (I didn't do this and
didn't end up getting my 1st choice). Hopefully they will sort
this out for next year as it doesn't seem very fair.
Final Thoughts Thanks, your guide was a great help last year.
Prerna Chinoy
Application Form Application form was very straightforward, mostly factual
questions.
Stage 2/SRA I did BMJ on examination questions over a weekend, mostly
Preparation to get the feel of the format.
Stage 2 MCQ Was harder than I anticipated. I would advise a lot of
Assessment practice questions and get. Good rest the night before.
Stage 3 I used your guide, some sample free questions I found
Preparation online. that was all more than enough. I rate your guide
10/10.
Stage 3 selection centre day was a long wait to start and a long
Assessment day,so eat before it and be calm. It was straightforward with
no tricks.
Stage 4 Allocation was by regular email, be sure to keep an eye on
oriel.
Final Thoughts
Sabri Garoushi
Application Form Application form was efficient.
Stage 2/SRA I used Pass-medicine. I guess it was fine, I did not really
Preparation finish all of the Mcqs but it was helpful for preparation. I
would say 7 out of 10.
Stage 2 Time management is very important in this bit. You can
Assessment easily be eluded by spending more time on some MCQs and
then you find out that you have not finished and you are out
of time.
Stage 3 I did again the Pass-Medicine. again 7 out of 10. It was the
Preparation online one, watched most of the videos.
Stage 3 I think it was fine. I mean just act normal and do what you
Assessment do in daily basis and things can be alright. Just make sure to
bring all of the related documents with you.
- 51 -
Stage 4 I was lucky to get the Deanery and the city I wanted, and
this was my target, as if this was not the case I would not
have accepted the offer.
Final Thoughts Of course the long process and the multiple assessments
down the line. Just a nightmare I guess!
Muniba Khan
Application Form Very detailed and time consuming. But very important. Think
twice.
Stage 2/SRA I used the online pastest questions . well enough.
Preparation
Stage 2 very similar to pastest questions, be relaxed and confident!
Assessment
Stage 3 I used GMP scenarios they were very relevant 10/10. I also
Preparation did some practice with a friend who was using MCQ bank
and got to know little about them, for essay qs I just looked
at 2 example questions available free online (?blackhouse
may be) website
Stage 3 no food so bring your own food
Assessment
Stage 4 no concerns
Final Thoughts its a long way to finish training so be prepared!
Catriona McNicol
Application Form Fairly straightforward. If applying using a Alternative Form
of Competencies then give yourself plenty of time e.g. at
least 3.5 months to get it completed as you require at least 3
months supervision from the person who will sign you off
and it's a really long form to complete, so your supervisor
will undoubtedly need some time after your 3 month post to
do so.
Stage 2/SRA MCQBank, battered on through as many clinical questions as
Preparation possible but in reality only got about 1/5th of them done.
Didn't revise the SJT questions as I feel these are more
common sense based and practicing questions just makes
you question your own innate judgement.
Stage 2 Absolutely fine. Arrive with enough time to settle yourself in
Assessment as you need to show ID, lock things away and then queue up
to enter the room. Wear the headphones provided as they
cut out background noise and keep you focussed. You have
more time than you think.
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 Just be sure that if you're in a large Deanery that you are
applying for the correct area, check, double check and check
your choices one more time. Really straight forward, no
complications.
Final Thoughts I found it to be a really straightforward process.
J Roscoe
Application Form It was simple.
- 52 -
Stage 2/SRA Passmedicine. 10/10
Preparation
Stage 2 Easy if well prepared. Plenty of time.
Assessment
Stage 3 I did not have to interview due to my high exam result.
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4 First choice job through direct application
Final Thoughts Noone ever looks at your CV!
Anna Watkinson-Powell
Application Form I found the initial application straightforward but people
must ensure they check their spam as that's where my oriel
emails went!
Stage 2/SRA I used passmedicine for the msra exam and would rate 9/10
Preparation as good range questions and good value.
Stage 2
Assessment
Stage 3
Preparation
Stage 3
Assessment
Stage 4
Final Thoughts Advice would be to check oriel on regular basis.
Claire Wilson
Application Form Application form was fine. Just ask your referees first before
putting them down and also check that they can fill in tinge
reference on Oriel. 2 of my referees couldn’t access Oriel so
had to fill out a paper reference which took extra time.
Stage 2/SRA I used Passmedicine for both PD and clinical knowledge
Preparation sections and would recommend it. They were similar to the
exam.
Stage 2 It was a long exam! Just made sure you time keep as you
Assessment don’t want to run out of time.
Stage 3 I prepared using MCQBank. I don’t think the scenarios were
Preparation that realistic but it would useful to get your head into the
mindset of the way to approach the scenarios and good
things to say. And I got full marks at the selection centre!
Stage 3 It was a very long, drawn out process on Hull. It was
Assessment freezing cold and were only given ice cold water. No tea or
coffee. The actual assessment only last for 1 hour but we
were there for 3! Go fully fed so you don’t get hungry! And
don’t be late.
Stage 4 I got my second choice area allocation but my first choice
job once we had to rank jobs.
Final Thoughts It was a long process and hard when you’re working an
intense Rota but I’m glad I’ve done it and got it out of the
way as I’m taking an F3.
- 53 -
Final Word
I hope that this guide has helped you in some small way towards your objective of securing a
GP training post.
As I have said in the introduction, this guide only works because candidates from the
previous year have responded to my annual questionnaire. I would like thank them for
making this year’s publication possible. I hope to receive your words of wisdom next year!
Please email me with any feedback (mail@gprecruitment.info) and tell your friends about the
guide.
Good Luck!
Sarah
- 54 -

GP Entry Guide 2019

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originaltitel

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

GP Entry Guide 2019

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

dr sarah cooper’s

Getting into GP Training 2019

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Overview of the Selection Process 4

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Good Luck & God bless!

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Entry into GP specialist training involves successfully negotiating 4 stages:

Stage 1 - Longlisting - Determination of

Stage 2 (Speciality Recruitment Assessment) -

Paper 1 - Professional Dilemmas (58 questions in 110mins)

Paper 2 - Clinical Problem Solving (97 questions in 75mins)

Direct Pathway to Offers

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Stage 3 Marking Scheme

The personal skills that will be specifically assessed:

These domains are marked as either:

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

1) HCA wants to talk to you about sexual assault from a doctor.

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

1. Introduction and putting the patient at ease

a. How is this affecting you?

4. IDEAS: What does the patient think is going on with them?

b. Consider further double-appointment next time

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

1. What deanery did you apply to? Were you successful?

2. Your thoughts on the Application form - any pitfalls or any tips?

I received 69 replies broken down by deanery as below:

All the respondents in the survey were successful.

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Resources used by last year’s candidates for the SRA:

Satisfaction Survey (Ratings out of 10)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Resources used by last year’s candidates for the selection centre:

Satisfaction Survey (Ratings out of 10)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

East Midlands P.14

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Nicola van der Westhuyzen

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)

Download the latest copy from http://www.gprecruitment.info (last updated 11/08/2018)