Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Copyright ©2012. The American Association of Petroleum Geologists. All rights reserved. We thank Bill Hart, Russ Propes and colleagues
Manuscript received March 7, 2011; provisional acceptance July 1, 2011; revised manuscript received at BP for suggesting the concept and term
September 9, 2011; final acceptance September 23, 2011. “autosuture.” We thank Mark Rowan, Joseph
DOI:10.1306/09231111036
terminate upward in shortened, overlying roof between lobes in the canopy outline (Hardin, 1989;
sediments (Lee et al., 1989, 1992; Liro et al., 2004). Jackson and Talbot, 1989; Lee et al., 1989). This
Sutures typically intersect the base of salt at the cusp is commonly the fastest way to identify a po-
crest of a broad structural high in the base of salt; tential suture. In the interior of a canopy, sutures
this high is produced by two salt sheets climbing may also connect to windows through the canopy
upsection toward one another before they coalesce. where the sheets did not quite merge (Hardin, 1989;
Superimposed on this broad high may be a nar- Jackson and Talbot, 1989).
rower notch of sediment at the base of the suture Despite all this information on suture geom-
(Liro et al., 2004). etry, very little has been published on how sutures
In map view, sutures form polygonal networks form, leaving several unanswered questions. How
separating canopy feeders (e.g., Jackson and Cor- do sutures initiate? Is there more than one way a
nelius, 1985; Jackson et al., 1990; Liro et al., 2001, suture evolves? Why do sutures have so many dif-
2004) (Figure 2B). However, some areas contain ferent geometries? Where do sediments trapped in
more sutures than can be explained by the num- sutures come from, and how do they get incor-
ber of mapped feeders (Kadri et al., 2000; Liro porated into the salt? How can sutures outnumber
et al., 2001). Small fold belts parallel to a suture feeders in some places? Why are some parts of
can deform roof strata on either side (Lee et al., sutures reflective on seismic data and others not?
1989). Where sutures intersect the edge of a salt Why are intrasalt reflectors abundant in some areas
canopy, they typically coincide with the boundary and nearly absent in others? Why is there a narrow
notch in the base of salt below many sutures? And, mic examples from the Gulf of Mexico, although
finally, what can sutures tell us about the larger the link to evolutionary models is necessarily more
scale evolution of salt-canopy systems? interpretive.
The goals of this article are to describe system-
atically how individual sutures form and evolve
and to discuss how this knowledge clarifies the his- SUTURE TERMINOLOGY
tory of salt-canopy systems on a regional scale. Most
of our evolutionary models are based on physical- Before describing processes, we must establish ter-
model examples, which have the advantages that minology for salt-sheet sutures. Current usage is
the suture origin is unambiguous and the evolution loose, with “suture” used to refer to the three-
is fully documented. We also present several seis- dimensional (3-D) surface separating salt supplied
buttressed against a salt ramp, but frontal auto- ond, the weight of the overriding lobe creates a
sutures can form anywhere faster moving parts of suture trench in front of its toe (Figures 6, 9B).
a salt sheet encounter slower moving parts. This trench fills with sediment and thickens the
Because overriding autosutures form in a broad sequence about to be overridden. This process ex-
zone of roof shortening, an autosuture is typically plains why many overriding autosutures terminate
accompanied by smaller shortening structures that upward into partly overridden minibasins (Figure 7).
trend parallel to the autosuture trace. Multiple over-
riding autosutures are near the toes of some salt Autosutures Formed by Encircling
sheets, resembling an imbricate thrust belt (Figure 7).
An analogy to thrusting is tempting, given the Two lobes of a spreading salt sheet can separate to
presence of upward-steepening reflections that ac- bypass an obstacle and then rejoin on the down-
commodate override and shortening. However, the stream side of the obstacle, forming an encircling
similarities are limited. The contact between over- autosuture (Figures 10, 11). In our models, the ob-
ridden roof and the overlying salt may or may not be stacle is typically a thicker part of the salt-sheet roof
a fault, depending on whether basal shear or frontal (perhaps a carapace block), but it is most effective
rolling dominated while the salt was emplaced. as a minibasin whose base has nearly welded, slow-
Furthermore, because the concave-upward (listric) ing its transport to the front of the sheet. Depending
geometry is a function of roof subsidence, it is not on its strength, the obstacle may be deformed by
a fault trajectory. Finally, most of the rock above passage of the enveloping salt (Figure 11).
and below the autosuture is viscous salt, which dis- In contrast to overriding autosutures, which
torts continuously as the autosuture grows. Thus, form by imbrication of the top of salt, encircling
no equivalents to fault-bend folds or most other autosutures involve the entire thickness of a spread-
features of classic fold and thrust belts exist. ing sheet and thus connect the top to the base of
Roof sediments trapped in an overriding auto- salt. If sediments aggrade as the salt lobes approach
suture typically thicken toward the upper surface one another, the lobes may each climb slightly up-
of the sheet for two reasons. First, units closer to the section toward one another, producing a subtle
surface were overridden later, so they had a chance structural high along the basal suture line. This
to accumulate more sediment before override. Sec- structural high may grow faster if roof sediment
above the two lobes slumps into the gap between extensional structures are produced by stretching
them, producing a pile of mass-transport complexes of the roof as salt accelerates around an obstacle
that must be surmounted before the lobes can (Figure 11B–D). Many of these extensional struc-
merge. In the physical model, this pile of debris at tures are then squeezed shut as salt decelerates in
the base of salt records the advance direction of the the toe of the sheet.
sheet (Figure 12). Similar ridges are seen on base-
salt maps from the Sigsbee Escarpment (Figure 13).
Unlike overriding autosutures, which are mostly ALLOSUTURES
frontal, encircling autosutures are typically lateral
(Figures 11–13). The roofs of the two merging lobes A salt sheet typically climbs upsection away from
are trapped along the autosuture and form a zone its feeder, especially where the sedimentation rate
of seismic reflectivity that extends from top to base is high relative to sheet advance (Vendeville and
of salt. In our models, neither lobe overrides the Jackson, 1990, 1991). If subsalt strata are not de-
other, so their autosuture is steeply dipping. formed after a sheet is emplaced, the base of the
An encircling autosuture is typically associated salt sheet also climbs structurally away from its
with much less roof shortening than an overriding feeder and reaches its apex around the rim of the
autosuture. A small belt of suture-parallel compres- sheet (Figure 3B). If two such sheets merge to form
sional folds or thrusts in the roof may adjoin the an allosuture, then the basal suture line should lie
autosuture (Figure 11F). Farther from the suture, along a structural high in the base of salt (Figure 2).
roof structures in the lobes reflect the strongly 3-D The basal suture line marks where two salt sheets
flow pattern produced by two lobes wrapping around collided. The line is a root zone from which the rest
the obstacle (Figure 11). These may include exten- of the allosuture extends upward. Any roof sedi-
sional faults and compressional folds or thrusts. The ment trapped in the allosuture should, in principle,
connect down to the basal suture line. The base of Symmetric Allosutures
an allosuture is similar to (but typically much longer
than) the base of an encircling autosuture. An allo- In some situations, neither salt sheet overrides the
suture is thus fundamentally different from an over- other during allosuturing, producing a steeply dip-
riding autosuture, which forms entirely through im- ping symmetric suture (Figures 14, 15). Most sym-
brication of the salt-sheet roof without necessarily metric allosutures form at the sides of salt sheets
connecting to the base of salt. instead of the front. Symmetric allosutures can re-
In most allosutures one salt sheet overrides the semble encircling autosutures in cross section but
other, generally because the overriding salt sheet has can be distinguished by mapping feeder diapirs.
more salt or lies farther updip. Sheet override dur- Symmetric allosutures separate feeders, whereas
ing suturing produces a strongly asymmetric allo- encircling autosutures do not.
suture. In a few cases, neither sheet overrides the Following allosuturing, continued flow of salt
other, and a much simpler symmetric allosuture is toward the suture from both sides inflates the salt
formed. sheets and transports the roofs toward one another.
Inward transport of the roofs produces compres- rounded buckle folds (Figure 14C). Precursor struc-
sional zones in the roofs on either side of the suture, tures can invert to form squeezed diapirs or salt-
which widen through time (Figure 14). In lateral involved overthrusts (e.g., the roof of salt sheet A
allosutures, these belts may also have a component in Figure 15). Thicker, stronger roofs without pre-
of strike slip if one sheet advances faster than the cursor structures can resist shortening or buckle into
other because of variations in salt supply. gentle long-wavelength folds.
The style of shortening in the roofs depends on
roof thickness and on any precursor salt structures. Asymmetric Allosutures
Precursor structures, such as diapir walls, are weak
zones that localize deformation. Thin roofs without In most natural canopies, one salt sheet overrides
precursor structures tend to form short-wavelength, the other, producing an asymmetric allosuture (e.g.,
Figures 5, 16). Overriding produces characteristic sheet. Instead, the overriding sheet began to bull-
structures both in the suture and in roof strata near doze its neighbor, pushing sediments trapped in
the apical suture line. the suture forward (Figures 18B–D, 19D–G). This
Overriding offsets the apical suture line in the bulldozing stretched the suture, eventually tearing
direction of override, producing a suture that dips trapped sediments away from the basal suture line
back toward the overriding sheet (Figure 17). In and obscuring the connection between the suture
section view, asymmetric suture lines are commonly and the correlative basal suture line. Only a thin
listric and connect the offset apical and basal su- trail of sedimentary fragments connects the main
ture points. body of suture sediments back to their basal point
A physical model illustrates how these inclined (Figure 19E–G). The same dismemberment is seen
sutures form (Figures 18, 19). As the overriding in natural sutures (e.g., Figure 16B). Similar suture
sheet advanced, salt in the overridden sheet was geometries could also be created if a salt sheet over-
expelled away from the suture, causing the suture rides the previously stretched and fragmented roof
to subside. This process deformed the suture, as of a neighboring sheet.
suture lines that were initially steep (Figure 19B, C) In models, most sediments trapped along the
became listric as suturing became more mature allosuture form the core of an isoclinal fold; each
(Figure 19D–G). Salt in the overridden sheet was limb was separately derived from the different roofs
displaced away from the suture, inflating the other of the colliding sheets. This geometry arises because
parts of this sheet (Figure 19G). Subsidence and the roof of the overriding sheet sheds sediment ei-
salt expulsion thus compensated for override, re- ther by slumping or frontal rolling against the roof
sulting in relatively little difference in freeboard be- of the overridden sheet. In natural salt canopies, we
tween the two salt sheets. Suture subsidence and interpret the trapped sediments as mostly derived
inflation in front of the overriding sheet made it from the overridden sheet, which would be the
progressively more difficult for this sheet to con- likely outcome if the overriding sheet advances by
tinue advancing across the top of the overridden basal shear directly across the roof of its neighbor.
Whatever their origin, these sediments are com- salt-cored thrusts, and even overriding autosutures
monly disrupted into boudins as the suture stretches that exploited preexisting weak zones in the roof
during overriding and subsidence (Figures 16B; 19F, (Figures 8, 16, 18, 19). Compressional structures
G). Less commonly, suture sediments may be im- adjacent to the apical suture line are typically much
bricated or buckled if transported to a zone of more modest in the roof of the overridden sheet.
shortening (Figure 20).
Asymmetric allosutures may also be associ-
ated with structures in the salt-sheet roofs near the GUIDELINES FOR INTERPRETING
apical suture line. Salt-sheet collision places the SUTURE TYPE
adjacent roofs in compression, causing the roofs to
shorten if they are weak enough. In physical mod- Allosutures form between two feeders, whereas
els, most shortening is in the roof of the overriding autosutures form from a single feeder. Distinguish-
sheet (Figures 18D, 19). Structures in this small ing between them is thus critically important in
overriding fold belt include folds, squeezed diapirs, interpreting salt-canopy evolution. Making this
distinction is not always possible, but several guide- on the periphery of a single sheet whose edge first
lines can help in the interpretation of the origin of divides into two small lobes and then sutures. Be-
many sutures (Figure 21). cause encircling autosutures normally do not over-
Encircling autosutures in many ways have the ride much, sediments trapped in the suture typi-
clearest origin (Figure 21A). Encircling flows typi- cally remain connected to the basal suture line.
cally meet as a short lateral suture just downdip of Overriding typically forms one or more frontal
an enfolded obstacle, which is typically a grounded autosutures near the toe of a salt sheet slowed by
minibasin. Structural fabrics in the top of salt or another sheet or by aggradation of the abyssal plain
roof reflect salt flow encircling this obstacle (e.g., (Figure 21B). Sediments trapped in the autosuture
Figure 13). The autosuture is merely an ornament form a rearward-dipping, listric, intrasalt reflector
that commonly terminates into a partly overridden foundered roof material, and coherent seismic noise
minibasin along the apical suture line (Figure 21B). may also produce reflections. In many cases, sutures
Overriding autosutures may occur in swarms, re- can be distinguished from these by their association
sembling an imbricate thrust belt. Because an over- with lobe boundaries, apical and basal suture lines,
riding autosuture forms by imbrication of the salt- or location with respect to feeders. However, this
sheet roof, no basal suture line exists. distinction may not be possible in cases where
Allosutures are generally easy to identify, al- intrasalt reflections are highly dismembered. Sec-
though they share aspects of both encircling and ond, subsalt structures may deform the base of a
overriding autosutures (Figure 21C). Because allo- salt canopy, creating structural highs and lows in
sutures separate two independently sourced salt the base of salt that are unrelated to salt emplace-
sheets, they are marked by a broad base-salt cul- ment. Care should be taken to map subsalt structure
mination below the basal suture line. These cul- as well as the base of salt to determine whether base-
minations, together with salt-sheet edges, form a salt highs and lows are related to canopy emplace-
regional network separating canopy feeders from ment or to subsequent deformation.
one another. Most lobe boundaries in the canopy
margin are terminal allosuture points (Figure 1),
although a few may instead be associated with en- SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
circling autosutures (e.g., Figures 11–13). Finally,
roof sediments trapped in allosutures may extend The questions posed in the introduction of the
in a near-continuous band from basal to apical su- article can be answered as follows.
ture lines, if sheet override has been minor. How-
ever, these sediments may tear from the basal suture How Do Sutures Initiate? Is There More Than
line after major override, which can be difficult to One Way a Suture Evolves?
distinguish from an overriding autosuture.
Two factors can greatly complicate suture in- Salt-sheet sutures form in one of three ways. (1) An
terpretation. First, sutures are not the only sources overriding autosuture forms when the back of a salt
of intrasalt reflections in canopies. Material orig- sheet overrides the front. (2) An encircling auto-
inally interbedded with the salt, igneous intrusions, suture forms after two lobes of the same salt sheet
separate to bypass an obstacle and then rejoin on encircling autosutures and allosutures form where
the downdip side of the obstacle. (3) An allosuture separate salt lobes and salt sheets collide. These
forms when salt sheets sourced from separate feeders sutures extend across the entire salt allochthon
collide. from the basal suture line to the apical suture line.
Second, sutures deform to varying extents. In
Why Do Sutures Have So Many the absence of override, the suture is a near-vertical
Different Geometries? zone above the basal suture line. If one lobe over-
rides the other, the weight of the overriding lobe
Sutures have different geometries for two reasons. depresses the suture into the canopy, typically form-
First, sutures can have different geometries when ing a concave-up geometry steepening up to the
they first form. Because overriding autosutures form apical suture line. Continued override stretches the
by imbricating the salt-sheet roof, they have an api- suture, breaking trapped sediments into isolated
cal suture line but no basal suture line. In contrast, boudins and possibly tearing these sediments away
from their basal and apical suture lines. Subsequent apical suture line were overridden most recently, so
deformation within the canopy system, such as they may include units younger than those trapped
secondary diapirism or gravity-driven deformation, at depth in the suture.
would likely result in increasing dismemberment
of the sutures. Why Can Sutures Outnumber Feeders in
Some Places?
Where Do Sediments Trapped in Sutures
Come from, and How Do They Get Sutures may locally outnumber feeders for two
Incorporated Into the Salt? reasons. First, autosutures do not require a second
feeder. Second, allosutures may get transported for
Sediments trapped in sutures are from the roofs long distances, obscuring the relationship with the
of the sheets involved in the collision. With negli- original feeders. If allosutures get transported be-
gible override, both roofs may contribute sediments yond adjacent feeders into other parts of the can-
trapped in the suture. If an advancing lobe overrides opy, they may outnumber nearby feeders.
by frontal rolling, then both roofs contribute sedi-
ment. If an advancing lobe overrides by basal shear, Why Are Some Parts of Sutures Reflective on
then most of the material in the suture comes from Seismic and Others Not?
the overridden roof. Some roof material from the
overriding sheet may also be included by slumping Sediments trapped along the suture can produce
onto the overridden sheet. Sediments closest to the seismic reflections. In the absence of these sediments,
a salt-on-salt suture surface will in most cases be Alternatively, roof sediments may be discontinu-
nonreflective. Discontinuous suture reflections typ- ous before being trapped in the suture possibly
ically result from dismembering sediments as a salt because the roof extended during initial advance
sheet overrides, which stretches the suture and or a suture may be complexly folded and difficult
separates the sedimentary inclusions (Figures 18). to image seismically (Figure 20).
Why Are Intrasalt Reflectors Abundant in Why Is There a Narrow Notch in the Base of
Some Areas and Nearly Absent in Others? Salt Below Many Sutures?
Intrasalt reflections in allochthonous salt are not This notch in the salt is filled with a wedge of subsalt
all related to sutures. They may instead be caused sediments, which we interpret to be composed of
by (1) sediments, lavas, or other evaporites orig- either (1) a mass-transport complex sourced from
inally interbedded within the evaporites; (2) igne- the roof escarpments of the two sheets, transported
ous intrusions; (3) foundered roof sediments; or into the narrowing gap between them (Figure 14),
(4) coherent seismic noise. However, many intra- or (2) a peripheral-plain material bulldozed in front
salt reflections in salt canopies are related to su- of the advancing salt sheets (imbricate wedges of
tures, and two main reasons exist for their spatial Hudec and Jackson, 2009). Either process can pro-
variability. duce a wedge of complexly deformed sediments at
First, sutures need a contrast in seismic im- the base of the suture. The two sheets had to climb
pedance to be reflective, which in most cases re- over this pile of debris before they could collide.
quires trapped sediments. Where salt sheets suture
before roof sediments are deposited, no sediments What Can Sutures Tell Us About the Larger
can be trapped in the suture, which is less likely Scale Evolution of Salt-Canopy Systems?
to be seismically reflective. Reflective sutures are
much more likely where salt sheets are covered by Sutures can help us understand salt-canopy evo-
a continuous seismically resolvable roof before lution in at least three ways.
suturing. First, the number and spatial distribution of
Second, more suture-related intrasalt reflec- allosutures reveal the number and location of feeders
tions occur where sutures are abundant: (1) where (Liro et al., 2004). Using allosutures to determine
feeders are closely spaced, giving rise to numerous feeder location is easier where sutures have been
allosutures; (2) at the downdip ends of major can- minimally overridden and harder after allosutures
opy systems, where transported allosutures may are sheared from their original positions.
accumulate; or (3) where salt sheets are buttressed Second, bands of overriding autosutures show
against peripheral-plain sediments or other salt where salt sheets have been buttressed against an
sheets, creating stacked, overriding autosutures. obstacle, inhibiting their advance. For example, the
rise of the Perdido fold belt in the northwestern ing, intrasalt drilling hazards, base-salt geometry,
Gulf of Mexico may have blocked advance of salt and the distribution of some subsalt reservoirs.
sheets on its landward side, which accounts for Correct interpretation of sutures should, therefore,
abundant autosuturing there. be an important component of exploration in the
Finally, the distribution and vectors of suture deep-water Gulf of Mexico and on other passive
override can be used to explain regional patterns of margins having salt canopies.
salt flow within the canopy. This picture can help
identify the largest feeders, the most rapidly ad-
vancing sheets, and the areas of thickest source salt.
APPENDIX: MODELING METHODOLOGY
All of these are important factors in structural
restoration and the evolution of subsalt sediment- High-resolution reproducible experiments recorded the evo-
transport systems. lution of salt-sheet sutures in a variety of initial setups for
The geometries, locations, and types of sutures symmetric, asymmetric, and oblique collision between two salt
sheets spreading by gravity. Colored passive markers tracked
are thus elements key to an understanding of how
salt flow within individual salt sheets. A thin, neutral-density,
salt canopies evolve. Canopy evolution, in turn, has brittle overburden recorded suturing and a surface grid tracked
implications for supracanopy traps, subsalt imag- salt-sheet motion and strains.