 TANADA V.

TUVERA, 146 SCRA 446

 PEOPLE V. PATALLIN ET. AL., GR NO. 125539, JULY 27, 1999
 ACCENTURE V. COMMISSIONER, GR NO.190102, JULY 11, 2012
 UP V. DIZON, GR. NO. 18112, AUGUST 23, 2012
 COMMISSIONER OR INTERNAL REVENUE V. SAN ROQUE POWER CORP. 707
SCRA 66
 RLETA V. PEOPLE 436 SCRA 273
 MORALES V. SKILLS INTEMATLONAL COMPANY, 500 SCRA 186
 IN RE: PETITION TO SIGNIN THE ROLL OF ATTORNEYS, 706 SCRA 264
 GATCHALIAN V. DELIM, 203 SCRA 12
 THOMSON V. CA, 298 SCRA 280
 US V. SOLIMAN, 36 PHIL 5
 KIDA V. SENATE, GR NO. 151258, JANUARY 1, 2012
 TING V. VELEZ-TING, 582 SCRA 694
 CASTRO V. DELORIA, 577 SCRA 20
 VLRTUCIO V. ALEGARBES, 679 SCRA 412
 MONTAJES V. PEOPLE, GR NO. 183449, MARCH 12, 2012
 FELIPE V. ELEUTERIO, ET. AL., GR NO. L-4606, MAY 30, 1955
 UE V. JADER, NO. 132334, FEB. 7, 2000
 RADIO COMMUNICATION OF THE PHILS. V. CA, GR NO. 44748, AUG.29, 1986
 WASSMER V. VELEZ, GR NO. L-20089, DECEMBER 26, 1964
 HERMOSISIMA V. CA ET. AL., L-14628, SEPT. 30, 1960
 LIRAG TEXTLLE MILLS V. CA and ALCANTARA, L·30736, APRIL 14, 1975
 GASHEM V. SHOOKAT BAKSH V. CA, 819 S 115
 AMONOY V. SPOUSES GUTIEREZ AND FERNIDA, FEB. 15, 2001
 PEOPLE V. BAYOTAS, 236 S 229
 SARMIENTO V. CA, GR. NO. L-96740, MARCH 25, 1999
 URBANO V. IAC, GR 72964, JAN. 7, 1988
 NICASIO BERMUDEZ SR. V. BOHOL, GR NO. 18193, FEBRUARY 27,1963
 ALBERCA V. VER, 160 S 590
 DYOGL V. YATCO, GR NO. L·9623, JANUARY 22, 1957
 YAKULT PHL. V. CA, GR NO. 91856, OCTOBER 5, 1990
 PEOPLE V. CONSING JR., 395 S 366
 DE LEON V. MABANAG, 70 PHIL. 202
 APA ET. AL., V. FERNENDEZ ET. AL., 59 SCAD 759
 TE V. CA, GR NO. 126746, NOV. 29, 2000
 PIMENTEL V. PIMENTEL, GR NO. 172060, SEPT.13, 2010
 ARDIENTE V. PASTORFIDE,701 SCRA 389
 GREGORIO V. CA, 599 SCRA 594
 CBK POWER CO.VS. CIR, 714 SCRA 46
 UY V. PUBLIC ESTATES AUTHORITY, 589 SCRA 1
 REPUBIC V. CA, 596 SCRA 57
 WLLLAWARE PRODUCT CORP. V. JESICHRIS MANUFACTURING CORP., 734
SCRA 238
 CONTINENTAL STEEL V. MONTANO, GR NO. 182336, OCTOBER 13, 2009
 MARCOS V. MANGLAPUS, GR NO., 88211, OCTOBER 27, 1989
 PEOPLE V. BUGALAO, GR NO.184757, OCTOBER 5, 2011
 OROPESA V. OROPESA, GR NO.184528, APRIL 25, 2012
 CREWLINK V. TERINGTERING, GR NO. 166903, OCTOBER 14, 2012
 DE JESUS V. SYQUIA, 58 PHIL. 866
 GELUZ V. CA, L-16439, JULY 20, 1961
 RALLOS V. FELIX GO CHAN, ET. AL., GR NO. L-24332, JANUARY 31, 1978
 PEOPLE V. TIROL AND BALDESCO, GR NO. L-30538, JANUARY 31, 1981
 PETITION FILED BY ZITO NGO BURCA, L-23252, JAN. 30,1967
 MOY YA LIM YAO V. COMMISSIONER OF IMMIGRATION, 41 S 292
 YUNG UAN CHU V. REPUBLIC, GR NO. 34973, APRIL 14,1988
 FLORENCIO MALLARE, 59 S 45
 CUA SUN KE V. REPUBLIC, GR NO. 29674, APRIL 8, 1988
 LABO V. COMELEC, GR NO. 86564, AUG. 1, 1989
 LIMBONA V. COMELEC, 555 S 391
 REPUBLIC V. CAGANDAHAN, 565 S 72
 SILVERIO V. REPUBLIC, G.R. NO. 174689, OCT. 22, 2007
 STAR PAPER CORP. V. SIMBOL, GR NO. 164774, APRIL 12,2006
 DUNCAN V. GLAXO, GR NO. 162994, SEPT. 17, 2004
 MAKATI SHANGRILA V. HARPER, GR NO. 189998, AUGUST 29, 2012
 REPUBLIC V. ALBIOS, 707 SCRA 584
 TRINIDAD V. CA, 289 SCRA 188
 MACUA VDA. DE AVENIDO VS. AVENIDO, 714 SCRA 447
 WIEGEL V. SEMPLO DY, 143 S 499
 COSCA V. JUDGE PALAYPAYON, 55 S 7S9
 GERONIMO V. CA, 43 SCAD 311
 ALCANTARA V. ALCANTARA, AUGUST 28, 2007
 NEGRE V. RIVERA, ADM. MATTER 34-MJ, JUNE 22, 1976
 PEOPLE V. BITDU, 58 PHIL. 817
 NINAL V. BAYADOG, GR NO. 133778, MARCH 14, 2000
 MORIGO V. PEOPLE, GR. NO. 145226 FEB. 6, 2004
 VILLANUEVA V. CA, GR NO. 99367, JANUARY 27, 1992
 ALCAZAR V. ALCAZAR, GR NO. 174451, OCT. 13, 2009
 DE CASTRO V. DE CASTRO, GR NO. 160172, FEBRUARY 13,2008
 ABBAS V. ABBAS, GR. NO. 183896, JANUARY 30, 2013
 ALCANTARA V. ALCANTARA, GR NO. 167746, JANUARY 28, 2007
 REPUBLIC V DAYOT, GR NO. 175581, MARCH 28, 2008
 ARANES VS. OCCIANO, A.M. NO. MTJ-021390, APRIL 11, 2002
 NAVARRO V. JUDGE DOMAGTOY, 72 SCAD 328
 SY V. CA, GR NO. 127263, APRIL 12, 2000
 CORPUZ V. STO TOMAS, 628 SCRA 266
 FUJIKI V. MARINAY, 700 SCRA 69, [2013]
 BAYOT V. CA, 570 SCRA 4726
 ANDO V. DEPARTMENT OR FOREIGN AFFAIRS, GR NO. 195432, AUG. 27, 2014
 GARCIA VS. RECIO, GR NO. 138322, OCT. 2, 2001
 CORPUZ V STO. TOMAS, 628 SCRA 226
 REPUBLLC V. ORBECIDO GR NO. 154380, OCT. 5, 2005
 VAN DORN V. ROMOLLO, GR NO. 68470, 139 S 139
 QUITA V. QUITA, 300 S 406
 PILAPIL V. IBAY SOMERA, 174 S 653
 LLORENTE V. CA, 345 S 592
 ROEHR V. RODRIGUEZ, 404 S 495
 RECIO V. RECIO, GR NO. 138322, OCT. 2, 2001
 BAYOT V. CA, GR NOS. 155635/16379, NOVEMBER 7, 2008
 CATALAN V. CATALAN-LEE, 665 SCRA 487
 BARNUEVO V. FOSTER, 29 PHIL. 606
 JULIANO LLAVE V. REPUBLIC, 646 SCRA 637
 IWASAWA V. GANGAN, 705 SCRA 699
 MANZANO V. SANCHEZ, ADM. MATTER NO. MTJ 001329, MARCH 8, 2001
 REPUBLIC V. DAYOT, 550 S 435
 SANTOS V. SANTOS, 737 SCRA 637
 REPUBLIC V. CANTOR, 712 SCRA 1
 REPUBLIC V. GRANADA, 672 SCRA 432
 MALLION V. ALCANTARA, GR NO. 141528, OCTOBER 31, 2006
 SANTOS V.CA, GR. NO. 112019, 58 SCAD 17
 YAMBAO V. REPUBLIC AND YAMBAO, GR NO. 184063, JANUARY 24, 2011
 HALILI V. HALILI and REPUBLIC, GR NO. 165424, JUNE 9, 2009
 VELASCO V. VELASCO, GR NO. 36075, FEBRUARY 16, 1995
 MARCOS V. MARCOS, GR NO. 136490, OCTOBER 19, 2000
 MATIAS V. MATIAS, GR NO. 109975, FEBRUARY 9, 2001
 RUMBAUA V. RUMBAUA, GR NO. 166738, AUGUST 14, 2009
 CHI MING TSOI V. CA, 266 S 325, same ruling as that of TSOI V. CA, 78 SCAD 57
 ANTONIO V. REYES, GR NO. 155800, MARCH 10, 2006
 TE V. TE, GR NO. 161793, FEBRUARY 13, 2009
 REYES V. REYES, GR NO. 185286, AUGUST 18, 2010
 CHOA V. CHOA, GR NO. 143376, NOV. 26, 2002
 DEDEL V. DEDEL, GR NO. 151867, JANUARY 29, 2004
 SIAYNGCO V. SIAYNGCO, GR NO. 158896, OCT. 27, 2004
 REPUBLLC V. HAMANO, GR NO. 149498, MAY 20, 2004
 REPUBLIC V. CA and MOLINA, GR NO. 108763, FEBRUARY 13, 1997
 TING V. TING, GR NO. 166562, MAR. 31, 2009
 PAZ V. PAZ, GR NO. 166579, FEB. 18, 2010
 LIM V. LIM, GR NO. 176464, FEB. 24, 2010
 LIGERALDE V. PATALINGHUG, GR NO. 168796, APRIL 15, 2010
 TORING V. TORING, GR. NO. 165321, AUGUST 3, 2010
 MARABLE V. MARABLE, GR NO. 178741, JANUARY 17, 2011
 OCHOSA V. ALANO, GR NO. 167459, JANUARY 26, 2011
 ODAYAT V. AMANTE, 77 S 338
 YAP V. CA, 145 S 229
 CARINO V. CARINO, GR NO. 132529, FEB. 2, 2001
 BOBIS V. BOBIS, 336 S 747
 ANTONE V. BERONILLA, GR NO. 183824 FEB 6, 2004
 MORIGO V. PEOPLE, GR NO. 145226 FEB 6, 2004
 REPUBLIC V. NOLASCO, 220 S 20
 REPUBLIC V.CA, GR. NO. 159614, DECEMBER 9, 2005
 ANGELITA VALDEZ V. REPUBLIC, GR NO. 180863, SEPT.8, 2009
 REPUBLIC V. BERMUDEZ-LORINO, GR NO. 160258, JANUARY 19,2005
 REPUBLIC V. TANGO, GR NO. 161062, JULY 31, 2009
 VILLANUEVA V. CA, GR NO. 132995, OCTOBER 27, 2006
 REPUBLIC V. IYOY, GR NO. 152577, SEPT. 21, 2005
 CORPUS V. OCHOTERENA, 453 S 446
 MAQULIAN V. MAQULIAN, GR NO. 155409, JUNE 8, 2007
 DINO V. DINO, GR NO. 178044, JANUARY 19, 2011
 CASTLLLO V. DE LEON CASTILLO, 789 SCRA 503
 DOMINGO V. CA, 226 SCRA 572
 JARILLO V. PEOPLE, 622 SCRA 24
 CHAN-TAN V. TAN, 613 SCRA 592
 LASANAS V. PEOPLE, 727 SCRA 98
 GANDIONCO V. HON. PENANRANDA ET.AL., GR NO. L-72984, NOV. 27, 1987
 BROWN V. YAMBAO, 102 PHIL 968
 PACETE V. CARRIAGA, 231 S 321
 LAPUZ SY V. EUFEMIO, 43 S 177
 MACIAS V. JUDGE OCHOTORENA, JULY 30, 2004
 ARROYO V. ARROYO, 42 PHIL. 54
 TENCHAVEZ V. ESCANO, 15 S 355
 MATABUENA V. CERVANTES, 38 S 284
 AGAPAY V.CA, 85 SCAD 145
 GARCIA V. SUNLIFE ASSURANCES CO. OF CANADA, 48 PHIL. 53
 GARCIA V. SANGIL, 53 PHIL 968
 UY V. CA, GR NO. 102726, 51 SCAD 428
 UY V. CA, GR. UO. 109557, NOV. 29, 2000
 PNB V. CA, 153 S 435
 VLLLARANDA V. VILLARANADA, FEB. 23, 2004
 NICOLAS V. CA,154 S 635
 TINITIGAN V. TINITIGAN, 100 S 619
 PARTOSA-JO V. CA, 216 S 692
 LEDESMA V. INTESTATE ESTATE OF CIPRIANO PEDROSA, 219 S 808
 JESSIE PLSUENA V. HEIRS OF PETRA UNATIG ET. AL., GR. NO. 132803, AUG. 31,
1999
 MENDOZA V. REYES, 124 S 154
 SANTOS V. BARTOLOME, 44 PHIL. 76
 ALVAREZ V. ESPIRITU, L-18833, AUG. 14, 1965
 LIM V. GARCIA, 7 PHIL. 320
 ABELLA V. DIAZ, 59 PHIL. 326
 MAGALLON V. MANTEJO, 146 S 282
 MATTHEWS V. TAYLOR, GR NO. 164584, JUNE 22, 2009
 SARMLENTO V. IAC, GR NO. 75409, AUG. 17, 1987
 WONG V. IAC, 200 S 292
 JOCSON V. CA, 170 S 333
 FLORES AND FLORES V. FLORES, 48 PHIL. 288
 DEL VAL V. DEL VAL, 29 PHIL. 534
 MUÑOZ V. RAMIREZ, GR. NO. 156125, AUG. 25, 2010
 AYALA INVESTMENT AND DEVELOPMENT CORP. V. CA, GR. NO. 118305, FEB.
12, 1998
 SPOUSES BUADO V. CA AND NICOL, GR NO. 145222, APRIL 24, 2009
 JOHNSON AND JOHNSON PHIL. INC. V. CA, GR. NO. 102692, SEPT. 23, 1996
 SPOUSES RAVINA V. VILLIA ABRILLE, ET. AL., GR. NO. 160708, OCTOBER
16,2009
 FUENTES V. ROCA, GR. NO. 178902, APRIL 21, 2010
 VALDEZ V. RTC-QC (BR. 102) AND CONSUELO VALDEZ, GR NO. 122749, 72
SCAD 967
 CASTRO V. MIAT, 397 S 271
 MANACOP V. CA, ET. AL., GR NO. 97898, AUGUST 11, 1997
 DE APARICIO V. PARAGUYA, L-299771, MAY 29, 1967
 JAO V.CA, GR NO. L-49162, JULY 28, 1987
 ILANO V. CA, 48 SCAD 43
 RODRIGUEZ V. CA ET.AL., 245 SCAD 150
 PEOPLE V. TUMIMPAD, 235 S 483
 TAN V. TROCIO, 191 S 764
 COLORADO V. CA, GR NO. 39948, FEB. 28, 1985
 REYMOND PE LIM V. CA, 80 SCAD 685
 TISON V. CA ET. AL., 85 SCAD (1997 CASE)
 MARQUIBO ET. AL. V. IAC ET. AL., 52 SCAD 425
 SANTOS V. REPUBLIC, 21 S 379
 REPUBLIC V. HON. RODOLFO TOLEDANO, 52 SCAD 124
 REPUBLIC V. CA ET. AL., GR NO. 92326, JANUARY 24, 1992,
 SAYSON V. CA, 205 S 24
 ESTATE OF HILARIO RUIZ V. CA, 67 SCAD 20
 CERVANTES V. FAJARDO, GR NO. 79955, JAN. 27, 1989
 ESPIRITU V. CA, 242 S 362
 TAN V. REPUBLIC, 102 S 666
 PEOPLE V. VELLOR, 105 S 797