Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Reboiler Circuit
Debottleneck with No
Hardware Changes
With a thorough investigation and proper problem diagnosis, an entire gas plant limited by a
deethanizer reboiler circuit was successfully debottlenecked
T
Henry Kister his article de- 15'-6"
Fluor Corp. scribes a case
study of a
gas plant (de-
IN BRIEF signed by others) that
2'-6"
20'-4"
20'-4"
Baffle
Process description
Min
This newly built gas plant was bottle-
necked by its deethanizer stripper. The 24"
18"
tower bottleneck appeared in the re- Tower bottoms Vortex breaker
To rebuilders
Vortex breakers
boiler circuit. In early April 2014, the au-
thor’s company (which had no involve- ment by notched-bottom seal pans. FIGURE 2. As part of the deethanizer
ment in the tower or reboiler design, but As shown in Figure 2, the 8-in.-deep stripper tower base geometry, a preferen-
tial baffle divides the tower bottom into a
has extensive experience in distillation notches in the seal pans are located reboiler draw sump and a bottom product
design and troubleshooting), was re- right above the reboiler-draw compart- draw sump. All of the liquid from the trays
quested to assist with investigating the ment. There are no notches above the is directed into the reboiler draw sump via
a notch arrangement, while all the liquid
root cause of the bottleneck and to find bottom-draw compartment. The pur- returning from the reboilers is directed
ways to overcome it. pose is to feed all the bottom-tray liquid toward the bottom product draw sump via
A task force, including process and to the reboilers. cutouts in the reboiler return pipes
operation engineers from the operating The vapor-liquid mixture returning
company and Fluor’s distillation spe- from the thermosiphon reboilers enters
cialists, was created. The joint team above the bottoms-draw compartment
identified the root cause. Based on the via two opposite 24-in. nozzles. Each
root cause, a solution was successfully nozzle is equipped with a pipe that ex-
implemented. After this the deethanizer tends to close to the centerline of the
stripper and gas plant were returned tower and has a cutout that measures
to full operation, achieving the design 4 ft, 6 in. in the bottom quadrant. Both
rates. Described below is the trouble- cutouts are directed toward the bot-
shooting investigation that was carried toms-draw sump (Figures 1 and 2).
out, and the lessons learned. The purpose is to have all the reboiler-
The deethanizer stripper is a tower that return liquid enter the bottoms-draw
is 15 ft, 6 in. in diameter. It is equipped compartment, and to have none enter
with four-pass conventional valve trays the reboiler-draw compartment. The
with moving round valves. The tower vapor returning from the reboilers as-
base contains a preferential baffle that cends to the bottom tray, while the liquid
divides the bottom sump into a separate returning from the reboilers descends to
reboiler-draw compartment and a sepa- the bottoms-draw compartment.
rate bottoms-draw compartment. Liquid This design generates a once-through
leaving the bottom valve tray is diverted [1] thermosiphon reboiler system. Such
to the reboiler-draw compartment (Fig- a system intends to capture all of the
ure 1). From there it flows into a battery liquid leaving the bottom tray and feed
of four horizontal thermosiphon reboil- it directly to the reboiler. The reboiler-re-
ers. The liquid from the bottom tray is turn liquid is entirely drawn as bottoms
diverted to the reboiler-draw compart- product. None of the reboiler-return liq-
shooting before trying out a fix. the E-4A and B reboilers, the tem- FIGURE 4. Shown here are the process
One useful reference point was peratures of naphtha entering and data for the very initial operation of the
process data from the very initial op- leaving were about 400°F and 320°F, stripper-reboiler circuits. Before 23:00
hours, both circuits operated simultane-
eration of the stripper. The operating respectively. At time 22:40 hours, the ously and stably with the same steam
charts from shortly after initial start stripper feedrate plunged, steadying flows and naphtha temperature differ-
up (Figure 4), at a stripper feedrate of at about 1,200 bbl/h 40 minutes later. ences for each circuit. After 0:00 hour, the
steam rate to E-3A dropped and the tem-
about 1,700 barrel per hour (bbl/h), To improve stability, the plant manu- peratures of naphtha entering and leaving
show both the A and B circuits op- ally reduced the steam flowrate to E-3A, E-4A became the same, suggesting boiling
erating simultaneously and stably. to about 8,000 lb/h, with the steam rate and circulation in the circuit had stopped
Both E-3A and E-3B reboilers oper- to E-3B remaining at its previous value.
ated stably
CIC-10307 with
halfp a steam
page ad.qxd flowrate
3/25/07of 6:19
ThePMnaphtha Page 1temperatures into and out
about 32,000 lb/h to each. For both of E-4A became the same, about 360°F,
Circle 07 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.chemengonline.com/66431-07
SUPERFRAC®
and possible damage there. It is im-
portant to avoid excessive buildup
of liquid up the tower.
In principle, the level transmitter trays for challenging separations
can be watched during the operation
to avoid excessive liquid level. This
Delivering exceptional capacity AND efficiency for over 25 years.
was difficult in this deethanizer strip-
per. Since the reboiler-return pipe is SUPERFRAC® trays are especially beneficial in applications requiring a large
only 2 feet above the baffle (Figure number of theoretical stages or where mass transfer efficiency is critical:
2), and the vapor from the reboiler
• Increased capacity AND efficiency when revamping conventional trays
return blows downward, causing a
or minimized tower dimensions for new plants
frothy dispersion, the frothiness may
reduce the specific gravity and lead • Complete access for maintenance inspections without needing to
to an optimistically low level mea- remove trays
surement. Also, the high tap of the
level transmitter is just less than 2
YOU CAN RELY ON US.
feet above the baffle, which may ™
At low pressure drops, parallel once-through thermosiphon circuits may switch from
their intended steady-state with even split between the circuits to an unintended steady-
state with uneven split between the circuits. Reduced heat transfer and/or instability
may result.
1
• TURNKEY SYSTEMS OR INDIVIDUAL KEY COMPONENTS OFFERED
2 • EXPLOSION PROOF, ASME, CE, OTHER RATINGS AVAILABLE
3
x=y line
4
Bottoms
composition
and solvents, pharmaceutical intermediates, flavors,
fragrances, foods, oils, bio-based materials, and more.
www.popeinc.com
Batch Mode System Continuous Mode System
1-262-268-9300
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHEMENGONLINE.COM AUGUST 2017 37
Circle 16 on p. 62 or go to adlinks.chemengonline.com/66431-16