Sie sind auf Seite 1von 32

Integrated Business Services

(IBS)
Taking Shared Services to the
next Level of Peak Performance
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Contents

Editorial 03
Drivers for Integrated Business Services 04
Essential Characteristics and Differentiators of IBS 06
Comprehensive Service Management Framework 10
Components driving Peak Performance
IBS as a Catalyst for Enablement of Comprehensive 13
Data Driven Insights
Business Model Optimization (BMO) within IBS 16
Context at a Glance
Tax Considerations for Integrated Business Services 21
Organizations
Delivery Model Considerations for Integrated 23
Business Services (IBS)
Enabling Technologies as Crucial Ingredients 25
to Succeed on the IBS journey
Is it right for your organization? 28
Visual Analytics for more effective IBS Decision 29
making with Visual Decision Xccelerator™
Events/Publications 31

02
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Editorial

Ever since Deloitte first began to design Since the last decade, more and more provide you with interesting insights into
and realize shared services models at our multifunctional SSCs have been set up by the hot topics currently driving IBS set-ups
global clients over two decades ago, our global enterprises. In this organizational and optimizations in companies all around
trait and objective has been to research form two or more business functions are the globe. Lastly, we will draw from long-
and develop latest shared services trends regionally concentrated and controlled by standing expertise and share with you
and act as a pioneer in the sector of a regional SSC Head. This set up allows for some of our best practice examples on
enterprise transformations. Deloitte´s an increased functional and geographical methodology and state-of-the-art tools to
breadth and depth of knowledge is unique footsprint into value added SSC and implement IBS organizations.
and makes us the market leader in this outsourcing activities. Furthermore,
area. companies put an increased focus on Enjoy the read.
automation as well as a use of cross-
Leading shared services organizations functional technology. Multifunctional SSCs
are increasingly on their way to leave the usually have cross-functional governance,
traditional shared services paradigma increasingly share assets and practice
behind to push towards Integrated true customer satisfaction. They measure
Business Services (IBS) – shifting the their performance and quality levels by
operational and organizational set-up of negotiated Service Level Agreements
shared services beyond function-based (SLAs).
and process driven service delivery
philosophy. However, there is still much A move to IBS requires much more than
confusion and mixed terminology around simply asking shared services centres to
IBS. cooperate. lt represents a fundamental Frank Schäfer
shift in how businesses think about and Partner
Traditionally, SSCs were established with manage shared services and outsourcing. German Human Resources Transformation
a cost focus in mind. Individual functions Those that get it right can achieve Service Line Lead
were managed in discrete SSCs with enormous improvements in performance
little sharing and only a regional delivery and due to the good experiences with
footprint at most. Charging was based implemented SSCs companies are now
on FTE and only limited use was made of approaching services that have been out
governance, Service Level Agreements of scope up to now, such like Mergers &
(SLAs) or continuous improvement. Acquistions and Analytics Services.
Many companies have followed the SSC
development over the years and are now Thus, with this publication, we aim to give
on the journey to Integrated Business a comprehensive overview of Integrated
Services (IBS). IBS organizations are Business Services and what it is really all
sophisticated service companies that about. We will focus on the evolution of
offer enormous benefits because of their shared services organizations over the
multifunctional and global service-line last years and why IBS – nowadays - is the
orientation. superior model to strive for. Also, we will

03
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Drivers for Integrated


Business Services

Mature users of shared services and that lessons learnt are used to reduce risk
outsourcing often report that different as they strive for even more efficiencies.
functions, business units, and regions have They want to share infrastructure to drive
implemented their solutions in different faster speed-to-value and avoid reinventing
ways, resulting in a confusing array of the wheel.
contracts, agreements, arrangements,
practices, and processes. It is not unusual Even organizations that have not used
to find situations in large organizations shared services or outsourcing in the past
where HR has its own dedicated shared are now actively considering Integrated
services centers, while finance has shared Business Services as a way to benefit from
services centers in some regions and the experiences of others and overleap the
outsourcing arrangements in others. learning curve.
Equally, we have seen organizations where
IT has its own collection of disparate Our market research1 and client experience
outsourcing arrangements, including have especially highlighted three key trends
several helpdesks, while marketing, sales currently driving the shift to an Integrated
and customer service use entirely different Business Services approach:
suppliers and systems. In some cases,
different departments in a single company Increased global operations
are using the same providers — but with •• As solutions are available to address
different contract terms — with little or no prior concerns such as language skills,
coordination across organizational silos. time zone coverage, and regulatory
Leaders of these organizations want to requirements, geographic barriers are
bring order to this chaos. They want to decreasing.
know where they’ll find the next tranche •• A strategic choice is being made to
of incremental value. They are concerned balance cost optimization and proximity
about managing their exposure to global when starting up operations. This
locations and providers. They want to suggests either greater comfort with
improve controls. enhanced connectivity or an increase
in scope of higher value-add activities,
Less experienced organizations may which companies prefer to locate closer
have implemented shared services or to existing operations.
outsourcing for only one or two business
units or functions. And while the journey
might not have been easy, the results are
likely proving to be worth the effort. These
organizations are eager to leverage their
current successes to drive value in other
parts of the business. They want to ensure
1
Deloitte Shared Services Survey 2015

04
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Leverage lessons learned


•• Organizations are skipping the
single-function concept and pursuing
multifunction SSCs at the start of their
shared services journey based on lessons
learned from more mature SSCs.
•• Organizations are adopting hybrid shared
services models and are customizing
service delivery models by function.
Matthias Thalmann
Focus on continuous improvement Partner
•• IBS is becoming a true enabler of Human Capital Advisory Services
the end-to-end process view and is
driving significant end-to-end process
improvements.
•• Organizations are leveraging service level
agreements SLA/ SLAs conversation and
scorecards to focus time and energy on
continuous improvement.

05
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Essential Characteristics
and Differentiators of IBS

The term Integrated Business Services about all support services throughout the
is often used as a synonym for organization, with a common leadership
multifunctional shared services that are and governance structure tied to overall
globally oriented. This definition misses out organizational objectives.
fundamental characteristics of IBS.
While there are many flavors of Integrated
Some organizations view Integrated Business Services in the market, we have
Business Services simply as having identified five essential characteristics and
cooperation among all their functional behaviors that are necessary to drive the
shared services centers, perhaps with sustainable performance improvements
some common forums to share learning. most organizations seek.
In these situations, the only thing binding
the centers together is a loose global Multifunction
leadership structure that may not even An organization may have started its
have direct support from corporate journey with a single function or business
executive leadership. Other organizations process, but true Integrated Business
— those practicing true Integrated Services organizations are multifunctional
Business Services — view the opportunity in scope —and have significant integration
as a fundamentally different way of thinking across those functions. Common functions

Fig. 1 – Business Service Type Maturity

Integrated
Business
Services
(IBS)
Global
Business
Services
(GBS)
Multi-
Function Service and
SSC product lines
Integrated Service
SSC Management
Multiple functions Global service
Global Service owners Integrated
Individual functions Multiple functions Management network

06
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

include Finance, HR, IT, Customer Service, of services are centric to the strategic
Procurement, and Operations (e.g. and tactical orientation of IBS. Enhancing
Logistics, Supply Chain) — as well as those customer experience is the guiding
that are specific to an industry, such as principle and philosophy of an internal
claims processing in insurance. service provider. The goal is to operate
beyond cost-cutting potentials. The general
True service concept change towards a service-oriented culture
IBS organizations see themselves less goes hand in hand with value-adding and
as an „extended workbench“ of busines knowledge-based service offerings.
functions rather than as a service provider
that achieves to create true value add to Global orientation
the corporate success. The clients - either IBS organizations achieve maximum
internal functions such as HR and Finance flexibility through a mix of globally
or external customers - and their demand positioned integrated service teams as

Fig. 2 – Hub & Spoke Model

Local GBS
Employees
(Satellite) Regional
SSC
(Spoke)

Regional
SSC
(Spoke)
Global
Regional
Hub
SSC
(Spoke)
Local GBS
Employees
(Satellite)

07
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

well as external partners. The service is Service Excellence


provided locally, regionally or globally. Due to language barriers, strong
The access to global talent pools enables fluctuations as well as low quality
companies to respond dynamically to standards, some companies are currently
fluctuations in the service needs of single assessing the reintegration of their SSCs
business units. Other features include into the retained organization. Often the
new and adapted hard and software lack of service culture is being named as
components (enabling technologies) as well the main reason. Service culture is key to
as HR Cloud solutions. The combination an excellent service.
of the previously mentioned trends makes
it possible for companies to execute Mature IBS organizations do no longer
especially expansions or mergers and speak of Process Excellence in this context,
acquisitions in an effective and efficient but rather of Service Excellence. It is about
manner as the degree of standardization leaving the process level and taking on the
allows for newly acquired companies client’s point of view. For this purpose, it
to be integrated much easier into the is necessary to establish a service culture
organization. amongst IBS staff, which constitutes a
huge challenge for a company’s Change
Involvement of external service Management department. While processes
providers and systems can be modified rather
As IBS is operating as an independent quickly, the change in people’s mindset is a
service providing unit, it is responsible for lengthy process, which might never be fully
involving external service providers for achieved.
example in the payroll area. In practice, this
means that IBS can –based on volume and It also implies that the skill set of IBS
costs- decide independently, if a service employees will need to change radically
should be provided internally or through from a transactional to an advisory focus.
an external service provider - as long as the Hence, IBS talent management needs to be
initial level of service quality is maintained. seen in the light of the changing (technical)
A prerequisite is a standardization of environment and talent attraction,
processes, systems and services on a development and rentention become
global level to the extent that a relatively increasingly important.
large volume can be given to a provider.
This often results in much better conditions
that can be passed on to the client. High
service quality at a relatively low level of
costs is the resulting benefit.

08
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

The topic of Service Excellence can


be further supported by the following
measures:

•• The aim is the development of the


highest level of service standard from a
client perspective. Thus, service-based
products should be established and
function-based services should be
avoided. Anika Ahrenhold
•• Service simplification: The client shall Senior Consultant
receive the desired product as simple as Human Capital Advisory Services
possible and without any efforts on their
side. It should be easier for the client
than before.
•• Clear point of contact: Cumbersome
searches in organizations and single
functions should be avoided.

Reduction of contact channels such as


Employee Self-Services (ESS), portals,
chats, mail, telephone. Depending on the
customer segment, one to two channels
are often sufficient.

09
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Comprehensive Service Management


Framework Components driving Peak
Performance

Many companies do not exhaust the full organization including the hierarchical
potential of an IBS transformation. Initially, structure and reporting lines. Furthermore
centralizations and standardizations bear the formal setting of IBS governance bodies
significant benefits. However, often a lack comprising of steering committee, advisory
of shared responsibility to continuously board and user committee remains
improve services slowly sets. This is essential for a comprehensive governance
accompanied by increasing costs due to structure. The governance bodies to foster
shadow processes. Missing acceptance a strong relationship between the shared
and trust in SSCs lead employees in the services organization and the operating
company to use individual databases and units. Furthermore governace bodies might
Excel sheets. The services of the SSC are, be implemented from the organizational
hence, requested only pro forma. The real perspective but also need the operational
process, however, is executed alongside. legitimization to act efficiently. Therefore
For this reason, companies should a matter of course is the need of defining
prioritize Service Management during their responsibilities, the definition of IBS
IBS journey. A fully pronounced Service governance meetings and consultation
Management policy that regulates the cycles in combination with strategic
operative and organizational relationship directions and escalation processes with
between the IBS organization and formal decision points.
their internal and external partners is
recommended. It is essential to develop IBS Service Level Agreements (SLA)
or to enhance the service management include a formal definition of terms and
framework early in the journey towards conditions for service delivery, volume,
IBS. There are four elementary parts to measurement, charging, reporting and
every Service Management Framework: maintenance. Furthermore it is a formal
Governance, Service Level Agreements definition and internal contract for
(SLA), Management Processes and services and responsibilities description,
Customer Management. which is universally valid for all involved
parties, stakeholders and customers.
The IBS Governance defines a structure As IBS´ main differentiator is the service
to provide strategic guidance to the IBS orientation, the service or product
organization within the overall enterprise definition is the key component for SLA.
organization. Governance includes It comprises of the scope of services and
formal processes of interaction and products to be delivered by IBS as well
decision-making among the stakeholders as service elements, process flows and
involved in IBS that lead to the creation splits including enabling technology and
and reinforcement of SSC norms and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP). This
directions. One key component objective comes along with the definition of roles
is the integration of IBS into the overall and responsibilities out of the governance

10
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

component, because IBS depends on the Change Management and Knowledge Management (KM)
definition of process related parties within Communication •• Capturing, developing, sharing, and
the service delivery flow. The next SLA •• Internal and external communication effectively using organizational and
component is the design of performance procedures to all relevant IBS enterprise knowledge
metrics. It includes the definition and stakeholders •• Enabler for organizational learning,
measurement of performance standards •• Change Management concept to ensure improved performance, competitive
for each service product. Therefore a trouble-free modifications within the advantage, innovation, the sharing
cascading Key Performance Index (KPI) organization of lessons learned, integration and
model on organizational, process and continuous improvement
individual level is the tool for measure Vendor Management
service delivery performance. On top •• Formal description of interaction with Service Excellence (SE)
of these three SLA components a 3rd parties, suppliers and outsourced •• Progressional optimization activities
comprehensive charging mechanism organizations for speed, cost an service quality
regulates the billing and pricing. It is •• Tracking, monitoring and reporting on enhancements
fundamental especially in the fields of vendor performance for periodic review •• Identification, assessment, improvement
internal cost reduction/cutting, cost and contract negotitions and measurement of service
allocation and tax optimization purposes. improvements
Performance Management
The Management Processes component •• Tracking, monitoring and reporting
within the Service Management Framework of performance at individual, team,
has a wide range of sub-components that process and organizational level with
focus on the definition all service related KPI structure and Operational Level
supporting topics and processes within Agreements (OLA)
the IBS delivery environment. Furthermore •• Formal definition of performance review
it includes formalization of approaches, to assure performance improvement
behaviors and operational pre-conditions activities
and procedures to ensure a smooth and
regulated service delivery mode with at People Development
least seven component objectives: •• Alignment of individual and team
performance with IBS performance
Demand Management targets objectives and compensation &
•• Periodic demand for services from benefits
business •• Management of competencies, skills, job
•• Plan for IBS resource requirements descriptions and career opportunities
as well as learning needs analysis and
trainings for SSC staff

11
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Full IBS focus lies on the product and surveys) to derive necessary improvement
the service. Therefore the fourth SMF action items and report on progress.
component Customer Management is very
essential for delivering high performance To that effect CCM is the formal
services. It comprises of two elements: definition on the bi-directional contact
Customer Relationship Management (CRM) communication channels and procedures
and Customer Contact Management (CCM). between IBS and the customers, internal
& external partners. Furthermore CCM
Within CRM we build the formal customer comprises of definition of ticket and service
relationship strategy and program with request capturing, routing, monitoring, Sascha Brockmann
contact points, the overall CRM goals and resolution and reporting in alignment Manager
specific objectives. In addition IBS leading of customer contact channels with the Human Capital Advisory Services
organizations define within CRM the overall ERP/ cloud / enabling technology
customer satisfaction measurement with framework and strategy.
feedback activities (e.g. questionnaires,

Fig. 3 – Service Management Framework Model

Global Business Services (GBS) | Shared Service Center (SSC) Customers and Internal
& External Partners
Governance

• Business Units |
Service Level Agreements
Management Processes Customer Management Geographies
(SLA)
• Business Functions
1. Service and Product 1. Customer Relationship
1. Demand Management • Employees
Definition Management
• Corporate Customers
2. Change Management and 2. Customer Contact • Vendors and Suppliers
2. Roles and Responsibilities
Communication Management

3. Performance Metrics 3. Vendor Management

4. Charging Mechanism 4. Performance Management

5. People Development

6. Knowledge Management

7. Service Excellence

ERP | Cloud | Enabling Technology

12
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

IBS as a Catalyst for Enablement of


Comprehensive Data Driven Insights

Although big data is not a new idea data integration and analytics, but not all
anymore, the concept of enhanced succeeded. There is a set of critical success
reporting and analytics for improved factors which needs to be addressed – and
business insights in an IBS context IBS has a tremendous impact on those
continues to gain momentum. What does it
really offer, and how should you be thinking Critical Success Factor 1: Building
about it? consistency in data structures
•• Even with a strong corporate governance
If they have not done so already, many structure, an enterprise can face a
businesses will be making significant higher risk of data quality issues when
investments in data integration (i.e. master functions and BUs develop their own
data & reporting) and analytics designed master data. Additional complexity arises
to improve their knowledge of customers; when different BUs have control over
re-position products in the market; drive how they use and report on information.
more profitable sales; better manage At the same time, corporate decision-
resources; and ultimately deliver better makers often struggle with disparate
financial performance. At present, however, presentations that entail drawing entirely
these investments typically are driven at different conclusions (e.g. BUs presenting
function/business unit level — rather than data that reflects upon themselves in the
in a holistic, enterprise-wide fashion. most favorable manner)

At the same time, many IBS organizations How IBS can help
are seeking out opportunities to provide •• Establishing data integration and
higher-order services of strategic value to analytics as a service within the IBS
support business growth. Frontrunner in organization means that there is a
data integration and analytics are often single owner for governance and data
realizing significant value from aligning management across the enterprise,
these two trends. These new capabilities which is an essential stepping stone
help the organization and each of its on the way towards “one version of
business units (BUs) in outperforming the truth.” Transferring control of data
its competitors. Just as IBS have often to IBS has the potential to establish a
managed to centralize the non-core much-needed independent authority
activities from Finance, IT, Sales, Marketing for data standards. IBS is designed to
and HR, there is considerable potential take responsibility for maintaining data
value to be realized for units providing consistency across the organization.
master data, reporting and analytics •• The IBS concept not only helps
capabilities as a one-stop service within to promote consistency in data
the IBS organization. Numerous companies structures, but also to centralize quality
have been seeking to get the most out of management. Thus eliminating the

13
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

proliferation of ad hoc reports and/ Critical Success Factor 3: Developing


or significant rework by the functions cross-functional, data-driven insight
and BUs. As a result the data can all be •• When it comes to data-driven insights,
viewed in the same way. The richness the whole is truly greater than the sum of
of common, shared reports with key its parts. Although functions and BUs can
measures from multiple functions brings realize initial success in developing their
exponential business value as it drives own master data, reporting and analytics
improved decision making. capabilities, true insights often created
•• An additional bonus is that data can now through the ability to quickly, easily and
officially be “watermarked” (i.e. a semi- confidently link the data and the input
transparent image that sits behind the from multiple functions/BUs ( e.g. from
text of the report) and certified, since IBS Finance and Sales).
functions act as independent authority. •• Additional insights and value can be
generated if the organization can adeptly
Critical Success Factor 2: Meeting layer in and manage third party data
the evolving analytical needs of the sources as well.
business
•• In today’s fast-paced environment, How IBS can help
businesses benefit from the ability to •• A fundamental driver for a successful
move quickly into new territories or shared comprehensive data management
new segments to stay ahead of their capability is a single entity with both
competition. At other times, they find ownership and access to consistent data
themselves dealing with an increasingly from functions and BUs. This entity can
volatile marketplace. Time is of essence become the cornerstone of progress
when making business decisions in these as it provides the organization with the
situations, and if the data/reporting ability to derive genuine insight and take
structures are not in place, the enterprise action on it. Thereby consistent data is
will miss out on opportunities. used to generate reports focused on key
functional measures, but can also be
How IBS can help combined with third-party information
•• IBS is, by nature, customer-focused. By (such as macro-economic forecasts) to
transferring ownership of the master increase the value of all the information
data, reporting and analytics capabilities exponentially.
to IBS, the enterprise is able to tap into •• Example: A leading consumer products
the structural support needed to easily company used multi-function analytics
scale, modify and improve the services to across Finance, Sales, Marketing and
meet the changing needs of the business. Supply Chain to conclude that an
•• The combination of governance, anticipated poor crop season in one
consistent data structures across entities sales region would drive down demand
and a dedicated team whose skills range for migrant workers and with it the
from transactional data management demand for particular products. Due to
to higher-order analysis means that IBS this macro-economic predictive business
provides the timely information and analytics capability, the company
insights that the business requires. This was able to anticipate the decreased
enables leadership to make decisions sales, adjust inventory, and make
that keep the organization ahead of the corresponding marketing decisions to
competition and out of harm’s way. boost sales in other regions.

14
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Critical Success Factor 4: Career paths Critical Success Factor 5: Maximizing


for data & analytics resources data integration & analytics
•• The skill sets within any proper data investments
management capability can run the •• When functions and BUs make
gamut—from transactional data autonomous decisions to invest in
management to basic reporting and their own master data, reporting and
at the far end of the value spectrum, analytics capabilities, the investments
predicative analytic skills that may require cannot achieve maximum return.
a PhD. A delicate balance between Individual entities tend to develop their
hiring enough resources with the proper own methods for analyzing data and Albrecht Altenhöner
skills to meet business needs and structuring reports. Thus significant Director
maintaining a sustainable payroll cost rework is required before consolidation, Strategy & Operations
structure needs to be found. It is difficult, in addition to both quality and accuracy
expensive and, in some cases, unrealistic of the data being called into question.
to duplicate this capability across Precious decision-making time can be
multiple functions/BUs. lost during iterations and what starts out
as smart investments may ultimately turn
How IBS can help into a costly way for the enterprise to run
•• One of the major constructs of IBS, its business as a whole.
regardless of function, is the ability to
provide relevant training and career How IBS can help
progression possibilities through a •• Building high performance in analytics
variety of roles—including management and reporting generally involves
positions. For individuals who have investment in both technology
historically worked exclusively within applications and infrastructure.
a function or BU data management By bringing management of these
team the typically more rigorous IBS investments under the purview of the
talent management process can be IBS organization, the company as a whole
a welcome change. There are more can benefit from smarter, big-picture
personal development opportunities investments designed to promote a
as they frequently gain exposure to consistent architecture built to meet
multiple areas of the business. New end-to-end business requirements. The
internal opportunities may arise to approach is typically more cost-efficient
take a leadership role, either specific and the resulting capabilities better.
to data management within the larger
IBS hierarchy; or within another BU/
corporate.
•• The benefit to the business can be
substantial, as building a capability team
designed to service the organization
in its entirety, allows for new sourcing
strategies to be considered. For example
reporting functions of low sensitivity and
low complexity may be appropriate to
move to lower-cost locations, while more
advanced capabilities might be sourced
in a differentiated fashion.

15
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Business Model Optimization (BMO)


within IBS Context at a Glance

When companies are discussing the •• Undertaking operational initiatives to


implementation of a SSC they should take pursue revenue and margin growth
the chance to also think of optimizing •• Evaluating rationalization of the supply
their entire business model and have chain
additionally tax effects in mind. In this •• Harmonizing and standardizing the
evolving economic environment, it is always business, processes and systems along
a good time to review your global business the supply chain
model and ask the question, “How can •• Integrating acquisitions with existing
you create value by pursuing new market structures
share, developing new markets, and gaining •• Centralizing management and the
greater economies of scale?” Some of the intellectual property (IP)
ways to create value in an organization •• Centralizing management, regionally or
include: globally

Fig. 4 – Business Model Optimization

What are companies


looking for today?

Platform Sustainability
for growth

Centralizing Achieving
management sustainable
in one earnings
location improvement

Business
Globalizing Model
and/or Optimization Simplification
regionalizing of the business
their model
businesses

Harmoni-
Reducing
sing and
supply chain
standardising
and overhead
of business
costs The answer is Business
processes
model optimization

16
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

As you evaluate these and other types and after sales service, where the IBS is
of ideas to transform your business, it is focusing on the Services and Support
important to assess if you are considering functions.
all the relevant factors that may help to
build value within your organization, such BMO involves the development of a new
as the opportunities and effect of tax on operating model which has business and
important business initiatives. Deloitte tax benefits
brings a fresh perspective with BMO –
Business model optimization. •• BMO is primarily about developing
operating models that are commercially
BMO at glance – What can be driven and that provide operational
improved? benefits
BMO looks at a company’s value chain •• Secondly, it is about developing a tax
to optimize the primary value creating and legal structure that aligns with and
activities in R&D, procurement, planning supports the operating model to ensure
& manufacturing, sales & distribution that these benefits are captured

Fig. 5 – BMO at a glance


Revenue
Growth

R&D and Manu- Sales &


Purchasing Distribution
Shareholder Value Creation

Marketing facturing Service

Integration of business functions in the primary value chain


Operating
Margin

Central Mfg & Sales &


IP Company Procurement Planning Distribution
Efficiency

Entrepreneur Entrepreneur Entrepreneur


Asset

Support functions: support the activities of the primary value chain


Finance HR IT

E.g. shared service operations

17
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

•• BMO has a long and well established •• Operational underperformance due to


track record and much more than silo functions, functional organizations
“creative accounting” is required for and few cross functional performance
companies to maximize the financial metrics
benefits and justify their new operating •• Average customer service, high supply
structures chain costs and underutilization of
•• BMO helps to standardize the business, resources due to lack of regional or global
processes and IT sytems along the value supply chain management, planning and
chain functions control
•• Underuse of intellectual property
The typical starting point is a including dilution of value (e.g.
suboptimal, decentralized operating inconsistent brand positioning), missed
model opportunities (e.g. failure to leverage local
Many multinational companies have grown IP) and tax inefficient management
organically or through acquisition, with •• Lack of standardization of processes,
emphasis on local country operations roles and systems
or multiple stand alone business units •• Indirect tax inefficiencies and costs
within a region, which drives inefficient •• Volatile and unpredictable taxable profits
operational, tax and legal structures. by division, country and period
Consequencse of a suboptimal structure
are in most cases BMO removes the sub-optimization and
unlocks various operational and financial
•• Duplication of functions and processes in improvements through the move to a more
operating companies or across divisions centralized structure
and business units
•• Proliferation of legal entities, customer
management and invoicing centers
leading to complication, high transaction
costs and poor customer service

Fig. 6 – Decentralized versus centralized operating model

MGT
Plant Sales
Plant DC Sales

MGT Plant MGT Sales

Plant DC Sales
Plant Sales
MGT
DC DC DC
Plant DC Sales

Decentralized (country based) Centralized (regional or global)

• Point-to-point planning • Single point of accountability for most critical


• Diverging policies and service levels business processes
• Different processes per location • One operating model
• Different performance measures • Central planning, strategy and policy setting
• Inconsistent organizational structure • Single set of KPIs for performance management
• Roles, structure and locations often result of • Consistent and harmonized processes
‘history’ • Logical location of roles and functions

18
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

BMO involves the transfer of


functions, assets and risks to a
centralised regional company

Fig. 7 – Degrees of centralization

There are different degrees of centralization:


the more that is centralized, the greater could be the business and tax benefits and the BEPS risk

As an example, fast More Full Principal


moving consumer goods Centralized Supply Chain Centralized
Brand Management Centralized
companies have adopted Innovation Centralized
a range of operating
models over time with Supply Chain Principal
Business

varying degrees of centra- Supply Chain Centralized


Model

Brand Management Local


lization and standardization. Innovation Local
• Differing operating models What is the
Country Model right model
have led to a range of Supply Chain Local
options for tax models. for your client?
Brand Management Local
More Innovation Local
• There is a spectrum of Local
operating models relating Quantum of
Least Tax Highly Tax
to aspects of the full supply Efficient Total Financial Benefits Efficient
chain ranging from a full
Principal Company to the centralization of brand management only with a Supply Chain Principal being
somewhere between these two options.
• Supply chains evolve and the tax alignment of the supply chain can evolve with the business strategy
rather than trying and changing everything in a ‘big bang’ approach.

19
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

The BMO approach •• Developing a BMO structure involves


Business Model Optimization (BMO) is a consideration of the specific elements of
suite of experience-based protocols for the tax design
developing solutions to a wide range of •• This iterative process balances the
tax issues and opportunities based on tax requirements with the business
the Deloitte value pyramid. Consisting requirements to find the proper
of proven methodologies and “SMART” arrangements
technology, and based on the combined •• An integral part of the process is
experience of Deloitte’s knowledgeable identifying the risks to achieving the tax
professionals, it enables Deloitte to and business objectives and developing Andreas Süß
provide optimal levels of assurance and strategies to address them effectively Partner
transparency in addressing the full range of and in harmony European Business Model
your global tax and business needs. Optimization (BMO) Leader
Future Changes and challenges
Deloitte´s BMO service offering focuses on Currently companies have to be aware of
helping multinational companie integrate the fact that the OECD is changing the tax
their operational and tax planning in a landscape (BEPS regulations). Especially
scalable and sustainable way to help companies who have already implemented
business along the value chain. a centralized structure have to rethink their
business modell in order to save their ETR.
Already during the initial assessment The Deloitte BMO specialist have invested
experts from Consulting (HR, IT, Strategy, in the upcoming new legal requirements
Process), Tax and Legal are working and developed the necessary Business
together in order to get the full picture of a model changes which might speed up the
company´s potential. transformation and minimize risk.

Fig. 8 – Operating model and tax considerations

The tax
analysis
impacts the
development of
the operating
model

The operating
model and tax
structure form an
integral part of
future planning
developments

The business
strategy forms the
framework for the
development of the
operating model and
identification of tax
opportunities

20
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Tax Considerations for Integrated


Business Services Organizations

Tax can contribute cost savings to an IBS Choice of technology and level of
project or can create new costs from IBS automation
to an organization. The following overview It is imperative that best-in-class
summarizes common tax matters and tax technology is in place for the SSC to provide
issues to be addressed to reduce tax costs good quality data to support tax decisions
and to avoid creating new tax risks from and calculations. Furthermore significant
IBS. cash savings can often be achieved by
enhancing data quality. Tax should also be
Ongoing tax matters related to consulted on the level of automation to
processes reduce IBS error rates.
Failing to obtain tax deductions can easily
eat into the cost savings from IBS, which Record retention, storage of paper
should be addressed by good governance, originals, and data access
in particular relevant and correct Tax law requires long record retention
documentation. pertaining to all accounting entries
and accounting records supporting tax
Stable, portable and well-documented returns. Local rules may require local
accounting processes storage of all paper originals, which can
If possible, process standardization often be addressed via scanning. The IBS
and process documentation should be organization must also ensure data access
undertaken before accounting processes during future tax audits.
are transferred to IBS. This will involve
drafting Desktop Procedures (DTPs) One-time tax issues when setting up
summarizing and illustrating all tax- IBS
sensitive steps to be performed by IBS. While process deficiencies generally do not
jeopardize the success of an IBS project,
Definition of data quality, controls and there are a few one-time tax issues that
Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) may put the entire project or major IBS
Tax tends to be the largest consumer of benefits at risk.
finance data. Unlike finance, tax cannot
apply ‘materiality’ when preparing tax Tax authority notifications or consents
returns. Tax must therefore define the data Some countries require tax authority
quality levels for IBS and must agree the notification or consent when relocating
controls and KPIs for measuring IBS data tax-relevant accounting process (in full or
quality and process compliance. in part) to an IBS organization. Failure to
undertake such notification or to obtain
such consent prior to the relocation may
trigger fines and penalties or may even
require relocation back to the transferring
country.

21
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Accounting records on foreign servers Transfer pricing


Many countries require tax authority The tax authorities in the IBS location
notification or consent when a taxpayer generally require cost-plus compensation
relocates his accounting ledger with tax- with an arm’s-length mark-up, which may
relevant data to a foreign server. Failure to be fully or partially non-deductible to
notify or obtain consent before relocation some service recipients. Early discussions
may trigger fines and penalties or may even provide an incentive for the tax authorities
require a relocation of the server and/or in the IBS location to negotiate as they want
the ledger back to the transferring country. businesses to set up operations in their
jurisdiction. Andreas Kowallik
Location choice and withholding tax Partner
Tax should be involved in the choice of the Tax Management Consulting
location, which can often be tax-optimized
(e.g. by choosing a low-cost IBS location
that is also low-tax or offers a tax holiday).
A major tax issue to review is withholding
tax on payments for IBS services. At this
point, the job of tax is to avoid or minimize
the related costs.

Fig. 9 – Deloitte Tax Methodology for IBS

Deloitte Tax Methodology for IBS Projects Ongoing tax matters related to processes
Failing to obtain tax deductions can easily eat into the cost savings
IBS Processes IBS Introduction from IBS, which should be addressed by good governance, in parti-

& cular relevant and correct documentation:


1. Stable, portable and well-documented accounting processes;
2. Definition of data quality, controls and Key Performance
Indicators (KPIs);
3. Choice of technology and level of automation; and
Tax authority notifications/consents
4. Record retention, storage of paper originals, and data access.

Tax data on foreign servers


One-time tax issues when setting up a SSC  
While process deficiencies generally do not jeopardize the success
of an IBS project, there are a few one-time tax issues that may put
Location choice the entire project or major IBS benefits at risk. These one-time tax
issues are outlined on the left-hand side and should be proactively
addressed.
Withholding tax
Conclusion
Transfer pricing An IBS project can be used to accelerate automation, standardize
processes and transform the use of technology. As many examples
from publicly-quoted and private companies in Europe show, none
of the tax process matters and none of the one-time tax issues are
Determine tax documentation for IBS processes insurmountable or prohibitively complex to overcome. For the tax
and one-time tax issues from the IBS creation department, being actively involved an IBS project allows to contribute
value to the organization in the form of tax benefits and a higher level
of quality from migrating finance processes to a well-run and well-
founded IBS.

22
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Delivery Model Considerations for


Integrated Business Services (IBS)

Several general delivery models exist Maintaining proximity to stakeholders A diligent and fact-based evaluation
for IBS: a captive (in-house) model and and business overall is an important prerequisite for the
an outsourced model, next to hybrid Proximity to key stakeholders is a key development and implementation of a
derivatives. Over the past years, a argument for a captive delivery model. proficient delivery model decision. Next to
sustained momentum towards outsourced Driving compliance, monitoring business the general strategic rationals, a thorough
delivery models can be observed across developments, sensing the business, can financial analysis and cultural/risk related
the IBS customer base. In line the often be realized better in a captive format. discussions are a key foundation for the
outsourcing market continues to develop decision. Often, hybrid models paired with
its capabilities. Today next to the traditional Typical value drivers for an on-, near- and off-shore scenarios need
outsourcing providers, a number of “outsourced” delivery model to be modelled evaluated and tested to
medium sized focused service providers Use service providers efficiencies and consider all factors that could impact the
exist. While initially only low-value tasks expertise delivery model choices (please see section
have beed considered for an outsourced Service providers often have a scale of on Visual Decision Xccelerator™ within this
delivery model, increasingly more tactical operations and existing technology set-up document).
and complex activities are being proposed that allow greater process efficiencies and
and successfully implemented as part of an productivity levels. The usage of proficient
integrated business service delivery model. IT systems and standardized process
models provide access to leading practice
Typical value drivers for an “in-house” technology solutions.
delivery model
Maintain critical competencies/know- De-prioritizing non-strategic activities
how Non-critical and lower value tasks are
Retaining critical end-to-end processes as often graded non-core. Here the cost/
well as functional expertise and knowledge value equation for captive resources is
are major arguments in favour of an “in- often difficult to sustain. Often the strategic
house” delivery model. This is especially argument is brought up that management Dr. Philipp Zimmermann
the case for sensitive market conditions or can better focus on core and strategic Director
business critical operations. activities once non-stratigic activities have Strategy & Operations
been outsourced.
Direct control aligned with overall risk
priorities Speed to benefits realization and
Keeping the direct control of operations is service flexibilitiy
at the heart of several firms that consider One common argument for an
an “in-house” model. A key reason to opt outsoured delivery model is the speed of
for an in-house model is also to avoid a implementation through the use of existing
lock-in scenario. Strong internal controls infrastructure. Service providers can often
aligned with internal governance and risk leverage their significant experience, best-
priorities are being mentioned. practices in transferring and optimizing
similar operations and often have a
higher flexibility to up- or downscale the
operations.
23
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Enabling Technologies as Crucial


Ingredients to Succeed on the IBS
journey

Aiming for service excellence instead of as much data sources and tools as possible
sole process excellence means a shift of and based on efficiency.
weight from a more technocratical point
of view to a client centered organization. In order to support the IBS Organization,
Keeping this in mind, the IBS need to one usually sees a set of tools and
adhere to three guiding principles: technologies enabling the service delivery
model along the tiered services structure.
Deliver Value through people – which Besides ticket tools and enterprise portals,
include provision of the right tools in order which are crucial for an efficient SSC, we
to enable IBS staff to deliver excellent usually see tools for content and document
services based on timely provision of management as well as telephony. The
accurate data and input needed to maturity of these technologies is based
accomplish high-quality delivery of services on sizing, the technical progress of the
IBS organization and can differ across
Providing Self Services to clients in a countries, industries and functions.
modern and stylish way to attract them
and ensuring use of those services instead The latest and greatest in the area of
of provoking tier skipping. Even “sexy” tools Enabling Technologies
can loose traction the moment data and Besides of the above-mentioned state of
services are not provided in time or are the art technology, there are some new
inaccurate. Therefore, the technologies trends and technologies arising on the
used need to be seamlessly integrated with horizon:

Fig. 10 – Definition of Robotic Process Automation (RPA)

Emulates human execution Robots are a virtual workforce Sits alongside existing infra-
of repetitive processes with controlled by the business structure, governed and
existing applications operations teams controlled by IT

Automated solution can work Robots work with existing


24/7 and help to manage peaks IT architecture

Applicable across functions, like Robots can be trained by


Finance, HR, IT & Procurement business users

Double-digit reduction in error Cuts data entry costs by up


rates to 70%

24
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Cloud solutions are starting to grow is increasing – we are now witnessing


together with on premise solutions – thus next generation cloud solutions such
enabling organizations to profit from both as SAP HANA Cloud Portal & SAP C4C,
types of technologies. In addition, new CRM Infor Cloud Suite or Neocase HR Power
tools (e. g. salesforce.com, c*link or Acces emerging and being adopted in numerous
Edge) begin to be used more frequently European companies. Whilst some of
allowing for a new approach to employee these applications origin from on-premise
portal by providing well structured and solutions, they are now utilizing the cloud.
user friendly intuitive tier 0 platforms, - Thus, the state of the art services are
integrating ticket self services, employee combined with the benefits of cloud based André Dahlke
and manager self services as well as mobile solutions such as faster implementation, Manager
services and apps for travel, expenses and lower maintenance costs and centralized Human Capital Advisory Services
leave requests/approvals. rollout of updates across the whole
technology. In the long term, these and
Based on Deloitte’s 2015 Shared other services and solutions will help
Service Survey, 69% of the interviewed moving HR into the cloud while bridging the
companies aim for improved productivity gap on a midterm perspective.
of center operations. Robotic Process
Automization (RPA) could be one tool In summary, it can be stated that
supporting organizations to achieve companies are moving into the cloud and
their aspired target. While we have seen other new technologies (like robotics) to
lots of improvement in the Finance area, some extent. As seen with core HR services
robots are now coming also to HR Shared e.g. talent or learning there are some
Services. First companies already started pioneers which are already a leap ahead.
implementing robots in their Shared However, the majority of companies is
Services to support their human agents in still implementing single cloud modules
a faster facion while ensuring high quality and observing the pioneers’ approach
processes and delivery. while focusing on hybrid solutions and
architectures first. Based on the global
A last trend to be mentioned is the move sourcing trend, we will see a more dynamic
into the cloud. As the number of DACH move into modern solutions within the
companies using cloudbased solutions next years.

25
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Fig. 11 – Overview IBS Enabling Technology

Caseworkers Process Owner


Self Service Contact Center
Subject Matter Experts Policy Experts
• Single point of access to • Single point of contact • Local & Remote • Functional SMEs: HR CoE,
all HR information & for HR Operational Functional specialists Legal, Finance, IT, Pro-
transactions services • Local & Remote curement, HRBP & HRM
• Personalized HR • HR query handling Operational specialists • Operational Excellence:
experience support • Complex HR query Service centers, Blended
resolution model, Regional trans-
action capability
• Back office process
execution
Enablers: Governance, service level agreement & metrics, Policies, processes, procedures & compliance, Vendor mgt
• Transactions
• Information
Employees,

Executives,
Managers,

• Enquiries

Tier 0 Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3


HR

Technology Enablers: HR Portal, Knowledge Mgt tools, Reporting & Analytics, Integrated technologies incl vendors

66% 28% 5% 1%
• Self services • Case Management Tool • Case Management Tool
• Content Management • Telephony • Document Management
Systems • Content Management • HR tools
• Enterprise Portal Systems • HR Information Systems

Fig. 12 – Technology spending (Deloitte Shared Services Survey 2015)

What is your SSC technology platform? How are you allocating spend on technology for your SSCs?

Enhancing
Multiple ERP and Other
analytic
non-ERP systems
capabilities
(not integrated)
6%
20% 7%
Single instance Improve
of single interaction/
Multiple ERP and 20% ERP system 18%
service with
non-ERP systems 8% customers
(integrated)

14%
69%
Multiple ERP Improve
systems 17%
productivity of
center operation
Multiple instances of
single ERP system

Technology spend
• SSCs are operating with a variety of technology strategies with over 40% operating with multiple ERP systems
• A majority of the respondents indicated that they are investing their technology related spend to improve productivity of their centers

Source: Deloitte, Shared Services Survey 2015

26
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Is it right for your


organization?

Adopting an Integrated Business Services Establish ongoing process leadership


model can produce significant benefits – A key enabler for Integrated Business
but making it work is easier said than Services effectiveness is having process
done. Here are some practical tips for owners who control how a process is run
implementing Integrated Business Services throughout the organization.
that might help you decide whether it is
right for your organization: Aggressively manage change
It is important to develop a structured
Decide how far to go change and communications plan well in
There are three primary stages of advance that can help deliver clear and Ute Gottschling
Integrated Business Services: Sharing consistent messages to all functions and Manager
between support services operations stakeholders involved in the process. Human Capital Advisory Services
without co-location, sharing with co-
location, and sharing with co-location
and enterprise-wide Integrated Business Fig. 13 – IBS Integration Framework
Services governance.

Establish sponsorship at the highest Fully Integrated Business Services


executive levels
Geographical scope Local/regional Global
Although an Integrated Business Services
initiative might be rooted in a single silo, it Degree of value-add Transactional Process improvement & advisory
requires enterprise-level sponsorship from
the board, CEO or COO. Functional scope One function Multi-function

Single over-arching governance


Governance By/In function
Define an effective leadership with one IBS Lead, often C-level
structure Continuous Specific to function/ Enterprise-wide with common
improvement business unit budget & tools
Many Integrated Business Services leaders
report to someone in the C-Suite, which Process ownership Informal process networks End-to-end Global Process Owners
is likely to ensure appropriate senior Myriad of customer Universal customer interface
Customer interaction
executive sponsorship. interaction tool supported by standard toolset
Multiple systems and One integrated platform, centralized
Systems & master data
decentralized master data master data management
Choose an organization structure that
In-house and outsourcing Managed services blending captive
promotes global integration Sourcing
not aligned and outsourcing solutions
Different companies use different People development Specific to center and/ IBS competency model and training
organizational structures for support or function curriculum
services, often based on the extent to Location Separate functional centers
Co-location into multi-functional
centers
which they employ Integrated Business
Services.

27
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Visual Analytics for more effective


IBS Decision making with
Visual Decision Xccelerator™

In today’s increasingly complex world, For most organizations, massive


having the confidence to commit to a spreadsheet models and graphics are
significant business change often means used to assess one to three scenarios. But
organizations must evaluate and re- running sensitivity analysis requires models
evaluate multiple scenarios to consider to be rerun and then reviewed. Often
all factors which could impact the long this can trigger additional questions and
term benefits. Typically there are multiple more analysis. At times it can feel like each
perspectives on any one dimension so iteration moves organizations further away
gaining consensus can take months, if not from a decision to act.
years. For example, off-shoring work to a
low cost market may expose a company But what if you could instantly evaluate
to higher wage inflation and erode or any scenario and run sensitivity analysis
erase labor arbitrage savings. Or shifting in real time to help address and eliminate
activities across jurisdictions could create concerns as they are raised? What if you
tax impacts that could unintentionally could accomplish in hours what used
drive up an organization’s effective tax to take weeks? It’s possible. Through
rate and offset any estimated benefits. decades of experience working with many
Or transitioning a workforce may trigger organizations, we have developed a game-
severance payments, retention bonuses, changing proprietary tool, the Service
recruitment costs, training costs, etc. Delivery Transformation Visual Decision

Fig. 14 – Workshop Example for Visual Decision Xccelerator™

28
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

XcceleratorTM or VDX™ (pronounced


“V-Dex”). Using market-leading analytics
combined with Deloitte’s propriety market
data and selected data about your current
footprint, touch screen changes deliver
real-time visual results. This enables teams
to gain better insights and to confidently
make informed decisions, fast.

SDT VDX™ converts your organization’s Tina Junge


current state data into a visual format for Senior Consultant
multiple functions across a global footprint. Human Capital Advisory Services
We work with you to identify and collect
your data, typically including process
taxonomy, headcount, compensation,
and location information, among other
elements. Deloitte maintains detailed
cost parameter assumptions spanning
several categories, including: facilities,
locations, wages, severance, retention,
tax, and technology. Whether you are just
starting to think about how to enhance
your organization’s existing service delivery
model or are ready to start developing
the business case for future state service
delivery scenarios, our differentiated
approach can provide an accelerated path
from issues to action.

29
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Events/Publications

Publications on request Shared Services handbook: Hit the


HR goes global – Erfolgsfaktoren road
für die Implementierung von Global A practical guide to implementing shared
Business Services services.
This article explains the key characteristics
and highlights the success factors for Technology-Enabled Shared Services
implementing Global Business Services. Centers – The vital role of strategic
Link planning

Global Business Services – Better Optimize your Shared Services


Together Organization
For more than two decades, organisations A maturity model with an objective
around the world have been using shared diagnostic methodology and quantitative
services and outsourcing to improve opportunity assessment
service delivery and reduce costs within
defined parts of their businesses Now Events
leading organisations are taking the next Annual Shared Services & Business
step. Instead of operating numerous Process Outsourcing Conference
shared service centres and managing Attracting over 500 visitors from across
outsourcing vendors independently, they Europe, this is a must attend event for
are implementing Global Business Services Shared Services, Finance, HR and IT leaders
(GBS). either just starting out or running mature
Shared Service centers. Link
The value of global process owners in
global business services Part 1 & 2 Annual Shared Services & Outsourcing
This two-part article series examines the Woche
crucial role a global process owner can play Gathering of the German speaking Shared
in global business services. What are global Services Community to discuss trends and
process owners? How can organizations to shape the future of the industry.
help GPOs create enterprise-wide value?

Deloitte’s 2015 Global Shared Services


Survey Results
Key findings of Deloitte’s 2015 shared
services survey, which had representation
from more than 300 organizations around
the globe and provides data for more than
1,000 shared services centers globally.

30
Integrated Business Services (IBS) | Taking Shared Services to the next Level of Peak Performance

Contacts

Frank Schäfer Mario Schmitz Matthias Thalmann Jörg von Ditfurth


Human Resources Strategy & Operations Human Resources Service Line Lead Real Estate
Transformation Services Line Tel: +49 (0)151 5800 5630 Transformation Consulting
Lead marschmitz@deloitte.de Tel: +49 (0)151 5800 4604 Strategy & Operations
Tel: +49 (0)173 8780 939 mthalmann@deloitte.de Tel: +49 (0)151 5800 0260
frschaefer@deloitte.de jvonditfurth@deloitte.de

Sascha Brockmann Anika Ahrenhold Albrecht Altenhöner Dr. Philipp Zimmermann


Human Resources Human Resources Strategy & Operations Strategy & Operations
Transformation Transformation Tel: +49 (0)151 5800 0090 Tel: +49 (0)151 5800813
Tel: +49 (0)151 5800 3425 Tel: +49 (0)151 5800 3368 aaltenhoener@deloitte.de pzimmermann@deloitte.de
sbrockmann@deloitte.de aahrenhold@deloitte.de

Andreas Süß Andreas Kowallik


European Business Model Tax Management Consulting
Optimization (BMO) Leader Tel: +49 (0)172 8649 408
Tel :+49 172 4302 839 akowallik@deloitte.de
asuess@deloitte.de

31
Deloitte GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft (“Deloitte”) as the responsible entity with respect to the German
Data Protection Act and, to the extent legally permitted, its affiliated companies and its legal practice (Deloitte
Legal Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH) use your data for individual contractual relationships as well as for own
marketing purposes. You may object to the use of your data for marketing purposes at any time by sending a
notice to Deloitte, Business Development, Kurfürstendamm 23, 10719 Berlin or kontakt@deloitte.de. This will
incur no additional costs beyond the usual tariffs.

Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee
(“DTTL”), its network of member firms, and their related entities. DTTL and each of its member firms are legally
separate and independent entities. DTTL (also referred to as “Deloitte Global”) does not provide services to
clients. Please see www.deloitte.com/de/UeberUns for a more detailed description of DTTL and its member
firms.

Deloitte provides audit, tax, financial advisory and consulting services to public and private clients spanning
multiple industries; legal advisory services in Germany are provided by Deloitte Legal. With a globally connected
network of member firms in more than 150 countries, Deloitte brings world-class capabilities and high-quality
service to clients, delivering the insights they need to address their most complex business challenges. Deloitte’s
more than 225,000 professionals are committed to making an impact that matters.

This communication contains general information only not suitable for addressing the particular circumstances
of any individual case and is not intended to be used as a basis for commercial decisions or decisions of any
other kind. None of Deloitte GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft or Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, its
member firms, or their related entities (collectively, the “Deloitte network”) is, by means of this communication,
rendering professional advice or services. No entity in the Deloitte network shall be responsible for any loss
whatsoever sustained by any person who relies on this communication.

Issued 6/2016

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen