Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Dissertation
Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy
By
2019
Dissertation Committee:
1
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction........................................................................................................3
1.1 Background of the Problem.....................................................................................3
1.2 Statement of Purpose...............................................................................................7
1.3 Research Questions................................................................................................15
1.4 Significance of Study.............................................................................................15
References..........................................................................................................................20
2
Chapter 1: Introduction
In high school, art class was my most cherished class and Mr. Art Counts was the
teacher I respected and admired the most. I didn’t feel like just another student he had to
lecture. He asked who was going to take me to prom. He bought us a candy bar on our
birthday. If I was going through a hardship, he would always lend a listening ear and
offered advice. These actions showed me he cared about his students’ lives outside his
classroom. He got to know us each on a personal level and formed authentic and
undergraduate, masters’, and doctoral education as well, the common thread was that
they were all very empathetic. Mr. Counts, along with other caring educators whom I
had strong relationships with in my life, inspired me to choose the career path as an art
teacher.
undergraduate school, my studio art classes shifted to centering the ideas communicated
through art, and suddenly art become empowering to me. I was astonished by such a
different definition or function of art. Art classes were suddenly not so concerned with
the elements and principles of art, with the technical skills, or portraying the world
realistically like I was used to in high school. Now we were challenged to really
consider the ideas communicated through our art and focus heavily on incorporating
3
meaning. I was unexpectedly asked why my art mattered. What would my artwork do?
What did my artwork say? Art started to become something entirely different to me, full
of meaning, not just beauty, and a space to imagine and create possibilities. My
relationships with my art teachers and an art curriculum rich in meaning became
therapeutic to me and was one of the ways to explore my feelings and express my
therapy. Many scholars have explored the relationship between art and therapy,
especially within the art therapy profession, but also within art education. The
characteristics described rang true to me. Art is another way to communicate, where
opportunities for students to have “more meaningful control over their personal
experience” especially a traumatic experience they are grappling with (Andrus, 2006, p.
178). Art promotes healing through “release and representation of innermost thoughts
and feelings” in a way that is socially acceptable (Rubin, 1982, p. 57). The result of this
helps shape students’ “sense of self and adopt a more positive identity” (Andrus, 2006,
p. 179). Although these concepts are mostly explored in the art therapy realm, these
characteristics are useful within an art education program as well. Why shouldn’t an art
education program provide opportunities for students to express emotion and develop
and effective ways” (Andrus, 2006, p. 183). Art teachers should not just be concerned
4
with teaching elements and principles of art, but instead should “realize the power of art
Empowerment and transformation through art was prevalent in my own past art
experiences. When I needed a distraction, creating art became a meditation for me; as I
got into the ‘flow’, I focused on the paintbrush and the feel of the paint in my extended
hand, and everything else in the world seemed to slip away. But in other times, my art
making was transformative. As tough times in my life arose, sometimes art helped me
reveal and work through my muddy emotions about each situation to clarify, understand,
and make sense of my experiences. Personally, I think the strongest purposes for art
issues and identity,” exploring “big questions in the world,” and finally “providing a
What art education can be and do has grown the more I have explored and been
exposed to different pedagogies and theories in the university setting and from observing
other teachers’ classrooms. I saw a shift in art education from Discipline-Based Art
doctoral program I learned about the use of “big ideas” in the artmaking process by
Walker, art education professor emeritus at The Ohio State University (OSU). She
argued for teachers to update their curriculum from the traditional curriculum (for
students’ lives and contemporary artmaking” (Walker, 2006, pg. 192). Walker
advocated using big ideas to steer learning, such as “identity, relationships, humans and
nature, power, change, [and] conflict” (Walker, 2006, pg. 190). She argued artworks
5
should relate to the students’ lives. Students selected a “big idea” to explore all semester
through various artmaking and research projects and then created mind maps relating
their chosen topic to various contemporary artists. This approach to curriculum led to
meaningful projects, in which students could explore ambitious topics and ideas.
The particular time I realized the challenges of meaningful art and “big ideas”
was during my first opportunity teaching an undergraduate writing course at The OSU
called Visual Arts: Exploring Diversity and Social Justice. The first assignment, a
personal identity narrative paper, was due only three weeks into the semester. As I
anxiously sat down to grade my students’ papers, I was amazed at how much the students
opened up to me about personal issues. One student told a story about her struggle
coming to terms with her bisexual identity. Another wrote about her mom dying a slow
death with brain cancer. Students composed stories of battles with anorexia, of poverty,
and of distress with being Muslim in America after the terrorist attacks in the United
States on September 11, 2001. I was shocked that the students trusted me with this
knowledge about themselves, and was lost with how to respond. Although this
assignment was written, I imagine the same conflicts happening within art education
With meaningful and personally relevant art projects come problems, especially if
strong relationships are built between students and teachers. I wasn’t prepared for the
responses I received in my classroom. The only training I received was suicide training
where I was taught not to get too involved, but to push the troubled students towards
receiving help from a certified counselor, which seemed like a distant and cold approach.
6
I became interested in the blurred line between private lives and professional or school
lives. My art teacher in high school cared about my private life, and because of that I was
more engaged in the art classroom. Freire, Brazilian educator and philosopher, shares
how a teacher is “of course an artist, but being an artist does not mean that he or she can
make the profile, can shape the students. What the educator does in teaching is to make it
possible for the students to become themselves” (Freire, 1990, p. 302). Caring about
students as holistic people makes it possible for them to feel comfortable being
themselves. However, what happens when what they share about themselves is
troublesome? How does the teacher handle or cope with what she or he learns about
her/his students’ lives and respond in an appropriate but supportive, non-dismissive way?
border between private and professional led to my interest in trauma and how it is
addressed in the art classroom. There are numerous ways an individual’s identity and
emotional challenges outside the classroom impact student learning as well as teacher
health. Interest and research in resilience and Adverse Childhood Experiences (or ACEs)
Edwards, Koss & Marks, 1998). After finding ACES are very common in students, the
behavioral policies and punitive punishment, which further exacerbates issues, and
students’ trauma and stress that causes formally perceived ‘disruptive’ behavior (now
seen as a reaction to prolonged stress). Counselors make visits to the student’s home to
7
help the family work through their problems if possible, and give them information on
has resulted in decreased referrals and fights in schools, I’m concerned that the teachers
are not being taught the skills to take care of themselves and cope with the trauma they
hear about. My research serves as an opening for others to enter dialogue on how
teachers are affected by the trauma their students experience, and argues teachers cannot
The audience for my research is teachers with empathetic and caring pedagogies,
teachers with curricula utilizing therapeutic art, teachers with compassion fatigue who are
considering dropout, and teachers with a high population of students with trauma. My
research is also aimed at school administrations that have high teacher dropout or
turnaround and/or a high student population with trauma, pushing for more professional
Many students are affected by poverty, violence, family members that are
(Andrus, 2006, p. 182). ACE research showed that one in every three or four students
divorce, and incarcerated household member (Anda & Felitti, 2003). Furthermore,
students experience strain because of the United States’ “continual patterns of inequality
and discrimination based on race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, social class, and
8
disability (Sleeter & Grant, 2007, p. 2). Some of these topics are considered taboo,
inappropriate to discuss, private, and not considered the ‘teacher’s job,’ and therefore are
not touched upon in the classroom. Yet they greatly impact the students and classroom
Behavioral ‘problems’, distrust of adults, withdrawal and isolation are just a few ways the
experiences manifest. Additionally, many high schools are plagued by violence and
Though violence is not new in schools of lower-economic status, what has caught
national attention in current events is the abundance of violence and crime in schools of
affluent suburbs. Attention to school shootings has drastically increased in recent years,
and high school students have protested lack of attention to gun violence and mental
health issues by walking out of schools. My research aligns and extends the conversation
of the ‘walk up, not out’ movement, which calls for students (and I argue teachers, too) to
walk up to fellow isolated or reserved students and talk to them with compassion,
through relationship building and supporting student’s wellbeing and mental health
through the art curriculum and working with school counselors. The National Art
Education Association (NAEA) responded to the Santa Fe High School Shooting and
highlighted how arts education experiences “promote better understanding of self and
others, compassion and empathy” but school culture doesn’t have an underlying value of
relationships and mental health for students and teachers (Huyler & Defibaugh, 2018).
How should schools on a structural level emphasize students’ and teachers’ mental and
emotional health? My research argues for approaching mental health proactively as part
9
of pedagogy and curriculum, but also pushes for more supportive services for teachers
who approach students with empathy and may hear troublesome stories.
Teachers are experiencing the same trends as other social workers, such as
emergency medical technicians, nurses, doctors, and firemen; trends of detachment and
unprofessional to display emotion or get too close to patients (2017, p. 123). She notes
how doctors were encouraged to “dissociate themselves from the physical and emotional
turmoil of practice and develop an ‘objective gaze’” (Kelly & Dornan, 2017, p. 123).
While this was practical to avoid contagious patients or protect against infection, it also
created distance, loss of empathy, and re-enforced power dynamics. Kelly observed how
ironically, “a call to care, an idea of connecting with others, is what motivates many of us
to become physicians” (Kelly & Dornan, 2017, p. 123). After “long hours, sleep
express and pay less attention to ‘gut instinct’; or the physical sensations induced by the
emotional reaction of a distressed person in pain” (Kelly & Dornan, 2017, p. 124). Many
of these same issues parallel the structure of school systems. An environment in which
teachers are overworked and under supported may result in an unfortunate distance and
dissociation with students, going against the empathy needed to help students, which
providers might be similar to how teachers cope with the trauma they hear from their
10
former paramedic, and a program director at the San Fransisco Paramedic Association
outline a destructive list that included workers “keeping thoughts or feelings to oneself,
avoiding conversations about calls, picking and choosing calls, reducing workload to
bare minimum required, consuming alcohol, and engaging in risky behaviors” (Collopy,
Kivlehan, & Snyder, 2012). The constructive list of strategies to cope consisted of
“talking with colleagues, thinking about positive benefits of work, focusing on outside
interests, thinking about [a worker’s] own family, looking forward to off-duty time,
“black” or dark humor, using available mental health services, and talking with [a]
discussions of compassion fatigue, burnout, and better ways of coping with seeing
The medical school at The OSU has responded to the compassion fatigue of
students in the field with the Ether Magazine, an annual magazine where students and
staff create art in response to what they are experiencing in their careers. The magazine
initiates “artistic discussion within the community, allowing the exploration of what it
conceived notions of what it means to be either” (The Ether Arts Magazine, 2017).
They also created the S.T.A.R. Program (Stress Trauma And Resilience) to offer
medical students the mental and psychological support needed to deal with stress and
trauma. As the trauma experienced by these social workers may be similar to what
teachers might see in the classroom, it would be beneficial to better prepare teachers on
how to handle students’ trauma. A few discussions of compassion fatigue within special
education exist, but unfortunately there was little discussion in regards to art education.
11
Along with this gap in literature, there was minimal preparation in regards to how to
respond to students’ trauma within the art education programs I have attended. Other
than suicide prevention and small sections of required readings, which I am thankful to
have had (not many Graduate Teaching Associates (GTAs) are specifically taught a
course on how to teach college courses in other universities) I wish I had more
When I first arrived at The OSU, I started my position as a GTA where I served
as the Instructor of Record. The first semester, I enrolled in “Teaching at the College
Level,” a course designed specifically for new GTAs in the Department of Arts
skills, critical issues, and teaching challenges with which college faculty grapple on a
daily basis” (Savage, 2016, p. 1). We spent a day talking about student mental health
with a professional from “REACH,” which is The OSU’s suicide training program to
‘C’ommunicate hope, and ‘H’elp Access Care/Treatment. Advice was offered for how
to reach out, express concern, and how to connect students to people and services for
help and care. The REACH program urged teachers to build a campus culture of caring
and recommended building strong connections with others in order to prevent suicides.
In my experiences, this was the first time student mental health was addressed within my
teacher education, but it was only discussed for two hours and it was specifically tailored
Two other books required by the course offered bits of advice, though
12
In a chapter titled “Students as People,” Lang, an associate professor of English at
You will be tempted...to offer your counsel, drawing upon your life experience
and your instincts and common sense. Resist that temptation...listen patiently and
compassionately, and then give them a brochure and direct them to counseling.
The first time you do this; it will feel cruel—but counseling is not part of your
job” (Lang, 2008, p. 184).
The author then described how “you will not have the time to get emotionally involved in
the personal lives of your students” (Lang, 2008, p. 187). This reminded me of a quote
from Apple, an educational theorist, who notes: “death in the classroom refers to teachers
who stop trying to reach each and every student or teachers who succumb to rules and
regulations that are dehumanizing” (Apple, 1993). Lang’s discussion of how professors
Bain, the President of the Best Teachers Institute in New Jersey and Washington
D.C. and the author of the other teaching book required in my College Teaching Course
offered a different take on how to treat students. Bain described a professor, Bell, who
“takes a few minutes at the beginning of each session to talk with them [students] about
their lives and to share personal moments from his own” (Bain, 2004, p. 148). Bell’s
pedagogy blurred the distinctions between private and professional lives which was a
drastically different approach than Lang’s pedagogy. After each class the professor
gathered the students assigned to lead class discussion that day and took a picture of them
“posing the students this way and that with all of the concern, love, and pride of a parent
at a graduation ceremony” (Bain, 2004, p. 149). He then took the team out to eat to talk
and explore the students’ “lives and ambitions, marvels at their accomplishments, [and]
shares their concerns” (Bain, 2004, p. 149). Although Bain didn’t say how the professor
13
handled student hardships, I can’t imagine him simply giving a student a brochure to go
I agree that handling student hardship is the counselor’s job, but I advocate for art
teachers and counselors to create better relationships to work with students experiencing
setting. Since the student came to the teacher with a problem probably because of a
strong established relationship, passing a brochure would surely damage the relationship
and trust that was previously built. Also, sometimes students that need counseling the
most don’t get help because of our cultural stigma; the need for counseling is perceived
The OSU, we have high quality free counseling and assistance provided by our
Counseling and Consultation Service, and although there is immediate assistance for
many colleges have specialized services offered for students, mandates for counselors in
K-12 education varied greatly state by state. According to the American School
Counselor Association (2017), Ohio doesn’t require a counselor by law, and a mandate is
not currently being considered. Some schools may not have counselors due to lack of
funding, and others may have counselors rotating between multiple schools throughout
the week. With shortages of counselors and long waiting lists, I advocate for art teachers
to bridge the gap between the students who reach out to them and counselors (if
counselors are available). Art teachers and counselors can work as partners for the social
welfare of students. If no counselors exist, art teachers may be the only source for help
14
for students who are struggling, and may be the only ones to point kids in the direction of
community resources.
Teachers won’t be able to help students if they are not taking care of themselves.
With support, teachers can keep facilitating meaningful art lessons and practice
healing space for students. Although I have never received any services from an art
therapist, art education, for me, provided an encouraging community and helped me
heal. After hearing difficult stories from my students, I realized I don’t have the
purpose of this study was to bring the challenges of a humanizing pedagogy to light in
1. What are the challenges of being an empathetic teacher? How do art teachers
cope with the trauma they see their students going through? Does lack of
2. How can schools nurture empathetic teachers? How can schools and teacher
preparation programs create better support systems and resources for teachers
15
The significance of the study was to better understand the role art teachers play
in the complex development of social welfare of students and to create dialogue for
teachers that have students with trauma. With greater support for teachers, especially
those whose school might not have access to a counselor or an art therapist, my study
could help the health and wellbeing of both teachers and students. My study encourages
teachers to not shy away from meaningful but possibly difficult lessons that empower
students. Finally, this study encourages teachers to form authentic relationships with
their students.
“Educators in South Africa are actually bearing the brunt of the impact of
poverty, domestic violence, child abuse, and AIDS on a daily basis in their
classrooms. Children are coming into the classroom hungry, neglected, [and]
abused...Educators have to deal with this behavior, which can often be
provocative, disturbing, and disruptive. Most educators do not have the support
or skills to deal with the psycho-social situations that they face.” (Booth, 2007, p.
171).
2007, p. 173). Booth, an art psychotherapist, assumed that if educators’ emotional needs
were met, they would be better able to provide emotional support for learners (Booth,
skills – the ability to listen, to empathize, to observe, to create a safe environment, [and]
to reflect feelings” (Booth, 2007, p. 183). In the end, the intervention built “empathy,
16
schools and the lives of vulnerable children” (Booth, 2007, p. 172). Schools in the U.S.
could take a similar approach to supporting teachers by providing time to talk in a group
The impact of not preparing teachers with the skills they need in environments of
accomplishment” (Hoffman, Palladino, & Barnett, 2007, p. 16). Burnout can eventually
lead to dropout, which harms the students by halting trusted relationships and intimacy
as attachments are broken. Teachers with an enormous capacity for feeling and
expressing empathy tend to be more at risk of compassion fatigue and burnout (Joinson,
1992, p. 116). Teachers may not experience the student’s trauma firsthand but
symptoms such as emotions, nightmares, sleep difficulties, and headaches, to just name
a few, still arise (Hoffman, Palladino, & Barnett, 2007, p. 17). Preparation within
teacher education and school support in the K-12 systems may help prevent burnout.
therapists practicing in Canada ranging from one to over fifteen years of experience in
the field. Chang’s research offers a more optimistic perspective on burnout. In the
interviews, the teachers expressed that burnout can turn out to be a positive experience,
allowing for self-growth and exploration. Teachers highlighted that being aware of
burnout before it happened, knowing what causes it, the symptoms, and how to resolve
it saved the teachers from dropping out. The findings demonstrate that discussion of
burnout and self-care during training as well as creating support systems and resources
for when burnout occurs played a key role in the music therapists’ experiences.
17
Therefore, burnout may be bound to happen and teachers just lack the knowledge and
resources to identify it and resolve it. This study offers insights and understanding of
burnout, job dissatisfaction, and teacher attrition” (Scheib, 2006). A study done in 2016
interviewed and surveyed teachers that had recently left the profession (“Reasons why
teachers leave,” 2016). The article states many teachers leave the profession because of
the huge workload that leads to no home life, poor school leadership, bullying, no
respect, continued assessment, narrow curriculum, and an obsession with data (“Reasons
why teachers leave,” 2016). Teachers may leave the profession because of fatigue and
loss of empathy. Educators who are “feeling stressed, unsupported, overwhelmed, and
that hasn’t been addressed in a preventive way. This point is demonstrated by Scheib
(2006), Dean of the College of Fine Arts at The University of Utah, who stated “local
school districts throughout the country are searching for solutions to the teacher
replace those who leave.” Instead of focusing on how to bring more teachers to the field,
it would be more productive to address how to keep teachers in the field and support
them, especially teachers with burnout and/or compassion fatigue (Scheib, 2006).
18
compassion fatigue, burnout, dropout, and student trauma. Next, I discuss these topics
and issues more fully in the literature review. For readers more interested in storying
going to Chapter 3.
19
References
Anda R.F., & Felitti, V.J. (2003). Origins and essence of the study. ACE Reporter.
Retrieved from
http://acestudy.org/yahoo_site_admin/assets/docs/ARV1N1.127150541.pdf
Andrus, L. (2006). Art education, art therapy and therapeutic teaching: Definitions,
distinctions, and common ground. In Gerber, B. L., Guay, D. M. (Eds.), Reaching
and teaching: Students with special needs through art (pp. 177-188). Reston, VA:
National Art Education Association.
Bain, K. (2004). What the best college teachers do. Cambridge, MA: President and
Fellows of Harvard College.
Bolin, P., & Hoskins, K. (2015). Reflecting on our beliefs and actions: Purposeful
practice in art education. Art Education, 68(4), pg. 46-47.
Booth, M. (2013). Supporting educators to support learners. Journal for African Culture
& Society, 44(1), pg. 171-186.
Collopy, K. T, Snyder, S. R., Kivlehan, Sm. M. (2012). Are you under stress in EMS?
EMSWorld. Retrieved from http://www.emsworld.com/article/10776875/post-
traumatic-stress-disorder-in-prehospital-providers
Chang, K. (2014). An opportunity for positive change and growth: Music therapists'
experiences of burnout. Canadian Journal of Music Therapy, 20 (2), p.64-85.
Dunn-Snow, P. & D’Amelio, G. (2000). How art teachers can enhance artmaking as a
therapeutic experience: Art education and art therapy. Art Education, 53(3), 46-
53.
Felitti, V. J., Anda, R. F., Nordenberg, D., Williamsom, D. F., Spitz, A. M., Edwards, V.,
Koss, M. P., & Marks, J. S. (1998). Relationship of childhood abuse and
household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults. American
Journal of Preventive Medicine, 14(4), 245-258.
20
Freire, P., Horton, M., Bell, B., Gaventa, J., & Peters, J. M. (1990). We make the road by
walking: Conversations on education and social change. Philadelphia: Temple
University Press.
Hoffman, S., Palladino , J. M., & Barnett, J. (2007). Compassion fatigue as a theoretical
framework to help understand burnout among special education teachers. Journal
of Ethnographic & Qualitative Research, 2, 15-22.
Huyler Defibaugh, K. (2018). NAEA statement in response to the Santa Fe High School
shooting of May 18, 2018 press release. NAEA News. Retrieved from
https://www.arteducators.org/news/articles/385-naea-statement-in-response-to-
the-santa-fe-high-school-shooting-of-may-18-2018
Kelly, M., & Dornan, T. (2017). Crossing the chiasm: Sutured care in medical education.
In S. Travis, A. M. Kraehe, E. J. Hood, & T. E. Lewis (Eds.), Pedagogies in the
flesh (pp. 121-126). Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan.
Reasons why teachers leave the profession & what they do next. (2016, January 3).
Retrieved from http://www.apastyle.org/learn/faqs/web-page-no-author.aspx
Rubin, J. (1982). Art therapy: What it is and what it is not. American Journal of Art
Therapy, 21, 57-58.
Savage, S. (2016). Art Education 7300 Teaching at the College Level [Syllabus].
Columbus, OH: Department of Arts Administration, Education, and Policy, The
Ohio State University.
Scheib, J. W. (2006). Policy implications for teacher retention: Meeting the needs of the
dual identities of arts educators. Arts Education Policy Review, 107(6), 5-10.
Sleeter, C., & Grant, C. (2007). Making choices for multicultural education: Five
approaches to race, class, and gender. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons.
The Ether Arts Magazine. (2017). The Ohio State University College of Medicine
Website. Retrieved from https://medicine.osu.edu/students/life/pages/the-ether-
arts-magazine.aspx
21
Walker, S. (2006). How then shall we teach? Rethinking artmaking instruction. In
Teaching Artist Journal 4(3), p. 190-197.
22