Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
This paper was received the SAIL Award 2009, which was presented to the authors in the Twenty-fourth Indian Engineering Congress held at
Suratkal during December 10-13, 2009.
INDIAN STEEL INDUSTRY : TODAY AND TOMORROW From a fledgling industry, steel in twenty-first century has
beckoned a virtual resurrection. After three decades of near
‘We still have a number of persons in our country in SAIL, flat growth, steel industry has registered a buoyant growth
TISCO and other big and small steel plants who have the of 7.9 percent during 2001 to 2007. Crude steel production
capabilities. They have the will to excel and transform the which was 0.85 bt in 2001 crossed 1.3 bt in 2007. India's
country, given a long-term vision. We should be ready to steel production and consumption in 2009 is showing a
compete in outside market. If our steel industry gears up in positive trend1.
about three to four years, Indian steel can be both in Indian
and foreign markets. Our vision should be towards this’. In the era of planned economy, iron and steel, a core and
Indian 2020: A vision for the new millennium by APJ Adbul basic sector, received the full attention of the Government.
Kalam and YS Rajan. It became a key sector for public investment for the first
Five-Year Plan itself.
The Indian Steel industry is more than 100 years old now.
Till 1990, the Indian steel industry operated under a Sector Structure/Market Size
regulated environment with insulated markets and large-
scale capacities reserved for the public sector. Production The Indian steel industry entered into a new development
and prices were determined and regulated by the stage from 2005 to 2006, resulting in India becoming the
Government, while SAIL and Tata Steel were the main 5th largest producer of steel globally which is being moved
producers, the latter being the only private player. to third place as depicted in Figure 1. Producing about 55 Mt
of steel a year, today India accounts for over 7% of the
The industry took its first faltering steps in 1907 with the world's total production. India is the only country in the world
setup of the first integrated steel plant in Jamshedpur by to post a positive overall growth in crude steel production
TISCO. Since then the Indian steel industry has emerged at 1.01% for the January to March period of 2009. The
as one of the core sectors in the Indian economy with a recovery in steel production has been aided by the improved
very significant impact on economic growth. As it traversed sales performance of steel companies. The steel sector2- 4
its long history during the past 60 years, the Indian Steel grew by 5.3% in May 2009.
Industry has responded to the challenges of the highs and
lows of business cycles. Production
The Indian steel industry can be divided into two distinct Steel production grew at 1.2% in the January to March
producer groups: quarter of 2008 to 2009 over the same period last year.
The fourth quarter saw most of the large steel companies
í Major Producers : Also known as Integrated Steel such as SAIL, Tata Steel, Essar and JSW operating at full
Producers (ISPs), this group includes large steel capacity. Indian Steel industry has surpassed the negative
producers with high levels of backward integration and growth registered by rest of the countries other than China.
capacities of over 1 Mt. These include SAIL, TISCO,
RINL, ESSAR, ISPAT and JSW. Now many new steel
1351 1330
plants are coming up. 1400 1251
India
í Other Producers : This group consists of smaller
Crude steel production, Mt
1200 World
stand-alone steel plants that include producers and
processors of steel, such as, processors/ rerollers, 1000
January
Rank
stand alone units making pig iron and sponge iron 800 3
to May
2009
SAGA OF STEEL 600 Rank 448
Rank Rank
Since, the beginning of the twentieth century, the global 400 6
6 5
steel industry has witnessed a chequered history. Starting 200 49.4 53.1 55.1 22.7
from its role in construction and household sector to provide
0
the major inputs for arms and ammunition, steel industry 2006 2007 2008 2009
gradually became an integral part of the development and
growth of nations. Figure 1 Indian steel production at global level
16 IE(I) Journal–MM
The National Steel Policy has a target for taking steel
1400 UAE – 1252
production up to 110 Mt by 2019 to 2020. Nonetheless,
1200 Apparent steel
with the current rate of ongoing green field and brown field consumption of
kg/capita
1000 > 150 Mt, the
projects, the Ministry of Steel has projected India’s steel 800 countries present gap
capacity to touch 124.06 Mt by 2011 to 2012. In fact, based World
600
average
on the status of Memoranda of Understanding (MOUs) 400
– 170
signed by the private producers with the various state 200 India – 33
governments, India's steel capacity5,6 is likely to be 293 Mt 0
Taiwan
South Korea
Germany
France
China
UAE
Hong Kong
Japan
Australia
USA
India
by 2020.
Consumption
Weakness
The factors for revival of Indian steel industry are buoyant
í Endemic deficiencies;
100
90
í Systemic deficiencies;
80
í High cost of capital;
65
Gap : ~ 20
60 to 25 Mnt í Low labour productivity;
42 í High cost of basic inputs and services;
40 34
í High rate of taxes;
20
í Quality issues and less expenditure on R&D.
0 Opportunities
Current Projected Capacity Current
demand demand addition (P) supply í Unexplored rural market and other sectors;
Demand side Supply side
í Export penetration and increase in demand;
All figure in Mt
Figure 4 Steel demand projections in India í Mergers and acquisition.
18 IE(I) Journal–MM
Threats so as to catch the demand bus of steel in time to achieve
profit and business.
í Slow industry growth;
As the gap between domestic production and demand
í Technological change; grows in India, imports of steel will increase. But to meet
í Price sensitivity and demand volatility; this supply challenge, the industry must develop new
technology, improve energy efficiency and unlock more
í China factor. challenging resources. Contractors and suppliers must
increase their capacity to support the industry, reducing cost
PEST Analysis and schedule uncertainty and improving productivity.
Governments can contribute by providing access to areas
It is an investigation of the important factors that are
that are currently off-limits to the industry and adopting
changing which influence a business from the outside like
efficient and coordinated greenhouse gas emissions
change in government and policies, economics, social
regulations.
trends and living standard and technology.
The certain areas of difficulties and the ways to face the
After understanding the various issues arising after SWOT
challenges of a growing demand for steel in India are
and PEST analysis, revival factors and the kind of strategy
mentioned here.
can be devised and followed. These will provide various
challenges and opportunities for developing a turnaround Vertical and Backward Integration and Moving towards
by the Indian steel industry. The struggling of Indian steel Raw Material
industry with high manufacturing costs, long production
cycles and capacity bottlenecks elaborate a detailed Coking coal, iron ore and scrap shortage are responsible
technical blueprint that can show the required technical for the increased cost of production, coupled with low
improvements. average prices of Rs 17000 to Rs 18000 TPA in the past.
Integrated players with their own captive mines for iron ore
Challenges for Revival and Growth of Steel in India: and coal will find it an advantage as they will be shielded
Suggested Ways from the fluctuating prices of raw materials. In steel, vertical
integration is still very valid and a very important supply
The growing self-confidence of our steel industry is
chain strategy.
manifested by the fact that Indian producers are now
enlarging their global reach and presence. De-integration of Process/Consolidation
The key drivers of steel demand and growth in India are: Consolidation within the industry is the need of the hour as
it might generate benefits of economies of scale and
í Industry driven economic growth;
improve labor productivity. Also, a set-up of semi-finished
í Infrastructure development; capacities near the place of availability of raw materials
and capacities for finished products near the place of
í Raw material security through adoption of appropriate consumption will act as a major booster for the players
policy; within the industry due to the savings in freight cost.
Consolidation of companies also means consolidation of
í Growing population and low per capita steel
their supply chain, resulting in changes in distribution
consumption;
network, transport consolidation and consolidation in
í Housing and high degree urban development; sourcing policy of raw materials.
í Steel intensive products demand like high demand in Long Product Cycle and Product Differentiation
the auto sector; Increased focus on branded products could allow the
í About 100000 MW new capacities (90% of present) producers to charge a premium for their products and
will be added in power sector in next seven years. improve their average per tone realizations. Also, increased
This should also act as strong driver of steel growth. focus on value-added products will help improve revenues
for companies as cold rolled coils, galvanized steel and
The Indian steel manufacturers are faced with some major color coated steel enjoy better per tonne realizations than
problems and concerns, which work as inhibiting factors to Hot Rolled (HR) coils.
their effort towards gaining the competitive edge and growth
of the sector. Steel has very low barriers in terms of product differentiation
as it doesn't fall into the luxury or specialty goods and thus
Steel demand will grow and steel producers of India have does not have any substantial price difference. However,
not only to bridge the gap in demand but also to feel their certain companies like Tata Steel still enjoy a premium for
presence globally. In order to meet this objective, various their products because of its quality and its brand value
planning and settlements/steps to be taken on urgent basis created more than 100 years back.
20 IE(I) Journal–MM
1000 Others Labour pose any significant threat to steel as the latter cannot be
Energy credit Energy
Raw materials replaced completely and the cost differential is also very
Depreciation and interest
high. In the domestic steel industry, demand still exceeds
800
171 the supply. India is a net importer of steel. However, a threat
157 from dumping of cheaper products does exist. Plastics and
160 143
600 155 composites pose a threat to Indian steel in one of its biggest
160 markets — automotive manufacture.
153 398
383
400 399 372 Utilization of Idle Assets
289
245
307 Steel industry is a capital intensive industry, in the process
200 123 98
77 57 35 89 of development a lot of idle assets have been generated
58 36 66 81 108 88 65 both in terms of physical and production. The companies
63 40 71
0 34 51 43 55 46 are in delima to choose and how to utilize them.
–72 –66 –79 –91 –102 –89 – 68
Upstream Supply Chain and Challenges of Remote
South Korea
China
Global average
Brazil
CIS
India
Japan
– 200 Logistics
ª Any single forecast of production will be wrong; Figure 7 Business strategic approach
22 IE(I) Journal–MM
Developing scenarios in greater depth, monitoring collaborative arrangements among competitors in mutually
strategies more rigorously, and remaining focused on the beneficial areas could be explored.
long term will all help strategists boost the odds of creating
plans that can lead their companies through the turbulence Joint R&D may save a lot of investments and joint marketing
and revival of their business and growth towards excellence in noncompetitive areas will help in getting better results at
and competitiveness. lower costs. However, as the Indian steel industry is
extremely fragmented, it will be more reasonable to expect
Over and above the most important thing is to manage the an evolutionary rather than a revolutionary consolidation.
strategy through ‘strategic decisions’ that answer the Example: once SAIL was planning to change business
questions asked while formulating it. restructuring based on long and flat products and the
strategy of corus16 is shown in Figure 8.
Transforming growth of Indian Steel Industry :
Through Restructuring Financial Restructuring
Even the best change plan will not achieve sustainable With steel and textiles being the two areas where most
business results, unless it is directly tied to the company’s Financial Institutions (FIs) have huge NPAs, the two areas
organizational and business strategy. Restructuring evolve have been declared as no-go by the FIs.The restructuring
with senior management and through internal teams, to plan for companies like Jindal Vijaynagar Steel (JVSL) and
analyze the business, review its strategy and highlight the the Mittal-controlled Ispat Industries (IIL) have been again
challenges to a successful implementation. The need is to stopped, albeit temporarily. Restructuring of high cost debt
understand capability and appetite for change so that steel is estimated to increase their competitiveness in the global
demand grows upon strengths and mitigates weaknesses. markets with better ability to manage the cyclicality of the
industry. The initiative by the steel companies to go for
í Strategies for growth External Commercial Borrowings (ECB) and FCCB for
replacing high cost debt is aimed at further reducing the
ª On the demand side
cost of debt. The companies should try to remain in black
è Extensive promotional campaigns; and maintain sound financial health with focus at
repayments of borrowings and disinvestments.
è Strengthening of rural delivery chain;
The recent upturn in the sector enabled many companies
è Encouraging infrastructure development. to pay off their long-term debts early and, in general, interest
payments have also come down. Essar Steel, for instance,
ª On supply side has come out of the purview of CDR (corporate debt
restructuring) by repaying its entire CDR debt of Rs 2800
è Creation of additional capacity;
crore. In the process, it has brought down the average
è Removal of bottlenecks in the availability of raw interest cost from 11.6% to 8% to 9% per annum. Mukand
material; has pumped in funds from the sale of land it owned in Kurla,
thereby reducing bank borrowings. And Bhushan Steel has
è Encourage R&D; paid off a lot of its high-cost debt. There is thus a need to
24 IE(I) Journal–MM
Identify Data from sales, profit, etc must be used to evaluate the
projects, Ports progress and success of the strategy and to inform of
lead times
Railways changes to the transformation and restructuring in the light
Supporting Enabling
and trigger
Dams of it.
volumes
Pipelines Skilled workers
Power
Marketing approaches to brand products will not only
distribution enhance customer acceptance and loyalty, but also allows
Identify Power generation Dwellings steel companies to charge a premium. Accordingly, it is
projects and Schools
Airports Health being witnessed that companies like Tata Steel, SAIL, Essar,
timing under Roads
different Community JSW, Jindal Stainless, increasingly focusing on branding
growth steel. For Tata Steel, branded products accounted for 25%
scenarios Macro Micro
share in flat products and 31% share in long products, sales
Develop scenarios for incremental population
during H1 financial year 2005 (against 21% and 30%,
impact as the fundamental driver of local
government and agency planning respectively, in H1 financial year 2004). Tata Tiscon, Tata
pipes, Tata agrico, Tata shakti are some of the brands from
Figure 9 Factors for infrastructural restructuring
Tata steel. SAIL is having SAILJYOTI for GP/GC plates/
close to Rs 100 crore. Bhushan Steel has captive power sheets, SAIL-TMT rebars for construction, SAILCOR for
plants in Khopoli and will set up a 2000 MW thermal power wagon and coaches, SAILMA for earthmovers and bridges,
plant in Orissa. Essar Steel has power supply agreements SAIL-HITEN for ATM machines, SAIL KAVACH for bullet-
with Essar Power and Bhander Power. proof jackets. Innovative advertisements also add to brand
value17.
SAIL is already having dedicated power plants and is busy
with new proposals based on coal bed methane (CBM). Restructuring in Government Policies and Review
Further, JSW — which was dependent on the Goa port System
earlier — has set up a dedicated jetty. Freight costs have
come down due to this. The company paid Rs 55 lakh The government to have a mineral policy in favour of Indian
demurrage (charges levied if a vessel is berthed beyond companies as china will be a major competitor to overcome.
the time allowed or agreed upon) in 2004 to 2005. In 2005 The fast decision for allotment of leases of mines etc to be
to 2006, it didn’t pay any. Indian companies are also taken based on certain rules and regulations to promote
engaged in backward integration to mitigate risks. For growth and expansion of Indian steel industry. Technology
instance, Bhushan Steel and Strips buy hot-rolled steel and policy is to be so designed by the government that it will
converts them to high-end cold rolled and galvanised steel generate the thrust to update the technology by the steel
for auto and white good application. Today, it is setting up a producers to have clean and healthy India. However, the
3 Mt steel making and hot rolling facility in Orissa. major restructuring is required in the method of review of
the policies and implementation of the same.
Restructuring in Marketing Approach
STRATEGIES FOR REVIVAL AND GROWTH ON
Increasing and promoting the steel consumption could INDIAN STEEL INDUSTRY
prove to be a potent medium-term strategy for the Indian
steel manufacturing units. New avenues should be explored The strategy suggested for the reversal of the steel industry
and market expanded for steel companies to turnaround in India is double layered in nature, effecting the reversal
specially thrust on rural marketing. The restructuring in the and at the same time sustaining the reversal. The strategy
aggressive market approaches will bring the image of the has to be growth and survival oriented. The survival part
steel companies. This includes alliance with the companies, would assure the survival of the industry in the fierce
making of strategic business units and e-business. Despite competitive atmosphere and the growth part would boost
selling products at a reduced margin, the ultimate consumer the sustainable growth of the industry. The two different
had not benefited because traders and other intermediaries parts of the strategy has to be integrated into one to have
reaped high profits after judging the local demand-supply the expected results.
situation, this is the place where real restructuring in
marketing-selling is to addressed. The strategies are based on time frame make the
companies ahead of competitors. These include short term,
The marketing strategy shall focus around: medium term and long term formulation at corporate,
business and functional level to revive the demand and
í Development of a system so that company production attain growth.
and customer specification can be met at the same
time or (customization); Short Term Strategies : Quality Reinforcement
í Giving quality and specification which is of world level; The short-term plan is aimed at providing a lease of life to
í Creating competitive differentiation through focused the ailing steel industry. It would also help it to withstand
marketing approach. the adverse pressures of the environment and move
The way out is to utilize the idle assets and maximize the Past (low) Future (high)
revenues by aggressive marketing and collection of Time (intensity of competition)
payments along with efforts to select products and markets
that give maximum net sales realization and return. Figure 10 Competitive environment and innovative technology
26 IE(I) Journal–MM
market — consolidation to control the price of steel by factor in the survival of the Indian steel industry in the age
controlling the supply. Examples: Mittal Steel’s acquisition of globalization. The cost reduction would be the main
of its rival arcelor and Tata Steel’s acquisition of corus, the aspect of the improvement pertaining to the competitiveness
second largest steel producer in Europe, reducing cost by of the industry. The manufacturers under the steel industry
having control over the raw materials for a long term basis. in India have to focus their attention in the areas such as:
Major players in the steel industry to adopt a collaborative í The reduction in the cost of operations;
and competitive approach to create distribution channels
in semi-urban and rural areas; share best practices to í The reduction in the costs pertaining to the working
become cost competitive; effectively tackle environment capital;
issues; focus on development of skills of steel industry í The reduction in the costs pertaining to the production
personnel; and develop products that are best suited to the inventory or stock that is not sold;
needs of Indian steel users.
í The improvement in the economics operating in the
LONG AND MEDIUM TERM STRATEGIES : POLICY technological aspects of production;
AND ORGANIZATIONAL REINFORCEMENT
í The transposition of basic materials of production;
The key strategies which companies can adopt in this
scenario is to focus on value-added products, rationalize í The sources of the procurement should be different.
cost structure through better manpower planning, logistics
and raw material sourcing. The companies with a focus on Technology Transfer, Technology Adaptation and
the domestic market are likely to be more favorably placed, Innovation
given the relatively stronger demand from the local users.
Indian companies lack experience in managing innovation
Raw material security to drive merger and acquisition in
and there are no easy recipes to follow. Intellectual Property
the long-term.
Rights (IPRs) play an important role in protecting innovations
Larger Mines and Fragmented Small Players from being copied by others and companies now have to
formulate IPR strategies that complement their competitive
Presently 300 mines produce 206.4 Mt of iron ore, where strategies.
mines of 2 MTPA and above are only few run by public
sectors, large private sectors and government undertakings. Lack of expenditure in research and development can be
It is the need of the hour to combine small mines and run seen in the balance sheet of the Indian steel majors. There
only large mines to get the following benefits : is need of Technology push from the R&D for:
í Larger mines have higher profitability to take care of í From specific project requirements (user specs);
CSR, environment;
í Product development strategy and evolution (driver
í Loss of ore in mine barriers will be minimized; approach);
í Lower cut off ore can be mined with better technology. í From competition analysis (follower approach);
It can be seen from Figure 11 that 39.6% of crude steel í Tuning technology to business.
production is by other small steel makers which required
R&D which was considered to be a technology incubator
attention as well11, 9.
(in the past) but today it linked to the business process by
Cost Competitiveness of Indian Steel Industry creating leading edge products and processes.
A long term strategy is required to become cost effective Lack of adoption of scientific mining methods, especially
for sustainability. The reduction of the cost is another major by small players, leads to inefficient extraction of ores from
commercial mines. There is a need for ore miners, as well
as the state governments to focus upon adopting the latest
Others 39.6% technology for ore mining for supply at pace and good
SAIL 26.6% quality.
technologies from developed nations. Since late ‘50s, large According to an estimate, with the growing need for oil and
number of steel producers in India went for technical gas transportation infrastructure, a US$ 118 billion
collaborations with the world majors. Many public sector opportunity is waiting to be tapped by steel manufacturers
steel plants were built with collaboration from countries like in the next five years. Indian steelmakers are set to make
United Kingdom, Germany and erstwhile USSR. In earlier the most of booming global demand for steel pipes and
years, many of these plants faced problems in their tubes with the government withdrawing the 10% duty on
collaboration projects. the exports of these products. According to a study by ICICI
Direct, Indian steel companies are likely to get 19% of the
Export Market Penetration total global demand in the years to come.
It is estimated that world steel consumption will double in Therefore enhancing domestic capabilities to offer high end
next 25 years. Quality improvement of Indian steel products for the high end application segments in domestic
combined with its low cost advantages will definitely help in markets is the biggest challenge.
substantial gain in export market. Signs of revival are being
Capacity Expansion and Technology Upgradation :
witnessed in overseas markets. Iraq, for instance, is
Quality Issues and Project Management
committing more than $40 billion in reconstructing its entire
war ravaged cities. Iran and other countries in the Gulf are Capacity enhancement through technology upgradation and
likewise pumping in a lot of money in infrastructure. modernization is called by the demand in steel and the
stringent quality issues of the customer and some of the
Once the government accelerates investment in capacity expansion programs are mentioned 5,6,20 in
infrastructure, steel consumption will go up manifold. Table 4.
Construction of grain silos, roofing in rural sides,
construction of natural gas pipelines and changes from The need for steels with superior performance capability at
bamboo scaffoldings to steel will spur domestic lower cost has seen a steady increase over the last few
consumption. Emphasis on these would be mutually decades. This has been met through continuous
beneficial, besides arresting environment damage. While upgradation of Iron and steel making and rolling
the demand for steel will continue to grow in traditional technologies which require a regular attention. The various
sectors such as infrastructure, construction, housing hindrances in the path of modernization must be removed
automotive, steel tubes and pipes, consumer durables, and planning to mitigate the past problems as mentioned
packaging, and ground transportation, specialized steel will below:
be increasingly used in hi-tech engineering industries such í As the project progresses, it may be found that the
as power generation, petrochemicals, fertilizers, etc. The scope of the project has changed which requires
new airports and railway metro projects will require a large adjustments to cost, time, quality, risk or other project
amount of stainless steel. deliverables;
28 IE(I) Journal–MM
í The ever-changing nature of our economies and í State-of-the-art on-line testing and quality control
organizations creates uncertainty on organizational facilities;
priorities. One of the most frustrating experiences a
project manager can suffer is managing within this í Envisaging Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)
environment — while the project is being implemented; across its plants.
í A change in top management may be accompanied Many steel giants are coming with the technologies where
by a change in priorities and even in the direction of the dependencies on basic raw materials like coking coal,
expansion and other efforts; Iron ore Lumps are not there. For example, POSCO is
coming with FINEX technology.
í A full project management-training curriculum has
While the steel companies have enough resources to
been missing to address the ongoing development
finance these massive projects, major problems faced by
needs of functional management, project sponsors,
them are on the front of land acquisitions, forest clearances,
project managers and team members. The various
and iron ore mining leases for the Greenfield projects.
aspects of project management like hands-on skills
Despite all these problems, none of the steel companies
and techniques that enhance the ability to manage all
have made announcements to shelve their projects. This
elements of a project, risk management, knowledge
can be attributed to the presence of significant amount of
retention strategies and other important aspects of
high quality iron ore and coal reserves in India and the
project management success has been missing.
potential opportunities in infrastructure, auto and
Probably this is true to all the major steel projects
construction sectors. Thus, long term scenario looks
carried till date in India.
promising indeed.
Organizations have never linked their projects back to their
Focusing on each project's challenges and learning from
corporate strategies and plans, which have led, project
them will help to build a more capable and successful project
delays. One must understand how each project contributes
management capability.
to achieving corporate goals.
Focus on Reduction in Product Development Cycle
The list below highlights some of the top project
and Branding of Products with Customer Service
management challenges in past faced by Indian Steel
Industry which may continue in future also which are Increased focus on branded products could allow the
required to be addressed by the steel producers of India producers to charge a premium for their products and
for timely completion of the projects to meet the demand improve their average per tonne realizations. Also,
are: increased focus on value-added products will help improve
revenues for companies as cold rolled coils, galvanized steel
1. Unrealistic deadlines; and color coated steel enjoy better per tonne realizations
than HR coils.
2. Communication deficit;
Long Contracts/Marketing Alliance
3. Scope changes due to lack of.
Players within the industry enter into long contracts for their
4. Resource competition projects usually compete for
finished products with automobile original equipment
resources (people, money, time) against other projects
manufacturers. This will mitigate demand risks, ensure high
and initiatives, putting the project manager in the
product off-take and better capacity utilization.
position of being in competition. Management of
project Portfolio to define and set priority across all Search of New Markets
projects was really missing.
Domestic steel demand would reach 70 Mt and steel supply
The new technology to be adopted with focus on the major would touch 77 Mt by the end of the terminal year of 11th
key technological areas mentioned below: Plan, ie, 2011 to 2012. These would represent 40% and
66% growth rates respectively as compared to 2007 to
í 100% production of steel through BOF route or 2008, the first year of the Eleventh Plan period. The
alternate technology; Marketing Strategy shall focus around:
í 100% processing of steel through continuous cast í Developing such a system so that company production
route; and customer specification can be met at the same
time or (Customization);
í Provision of alternative fuel injection methods like coal
dust/tar injection in all the blast furnaces; í Giving quality and specification which is of world level;
í State-of-the-art process control computerization / í To create competitive differentiation they are adopting
automation; focused marketing approach;
30 IE(I) Journal–MM
In the third week of March, four major EAF players in South centric processes, cost effectiveness, enhanced profitability,
Korea, ie, Dungkuk Steel, Inchon Iron and Steel, Korea Iron product quality and stake holder satisfaction. The plan
and Steel and Kangwon Industries — decided to band envisages strengthening of IT communication network,
together under a common holding company in an attempt establishing Production, Planning and Control (PPC)
to reduce excess capacity. The excess capacity (according computerization and implementation of Enterprise
to estimates, in the region of 4 Mt) would either be scrapped Resource Planning (ERP) and Manufacturing Execution
or sold to outsiders. The same decision has been taken by System (MES) to avail the benefit of transparency in
four major Japanese steel makers — NKK, Nippon Steel, negotiations and purchasing at best available market price.
Sumitomo and Hitachi. They have agreed to a production
cut of 10 Mt and another 10 Mt of capacity would be phased The software vendors should come up with specific
out of the system in the next fiscal. solutions for the steel plants as they have for other verticals.
There is a need for lot of automation in the industry. The IT
The third visible trend is the strategy followed to pick up applications can help them streamline both supply and
scrapped plants at a bargain and then turn them around. process chains that will ultimately help them reduce cost
Ispat International has become the world’s largest EAF steel and increase productivity. Moreover steel companies need
producer by picking up inexpensive steel assets at to adapt ‘business models’ for volume market and changing
throwaway prices and then reworking the plant to make it business scenario and marketing for branding the products.
operationally efficient. The company also derives a lot of
incentives from the government which also has an effect The introduction of SAP solutions within Tata Steel has led
on the cost structure of the final product. This strategy has to efficient business processes, enhanced customer
so far paid rich dividends for Ispat International. But such service, reduced costs, improved productivity, accelerated
companies are more the exception rather than the rule. transaction time, workflow management and reduction in
the number of credit management errors.
The fourth visible trend is to try to look inwards into the
local market rather than exports or imports. This is clearly ‘Post the introduction of the SAP solution, the results have
seen in the synergy between the strategies pursued by been terrific. The company has spent close to Rs 40 crore
China and Japan. Construction activity has reached a on SAP implementation, and has already saved Rs 33
saturation point in Japan. Accordingly, Japanese crore’, said by Mr R C Nadrajog, Vice President (Finance),
manufacturers are selling plants which are into long TATA Steel. The manpower cost has reduced from over
products (mostly used in the construction sector). $ 200/t two years ago, to about $140/t in 2000. The overdue
Simultaneously China, which is in a different stage of outstanding has been brought down from Rs 5170 millions
economic development, has shown keen interest in picking in 1999 to Rs 4033 millions by June 2000. The inventory
up the Japanese plants. carrying cost has drastically deflated from Rs 190/t to
Rs 155/t . To add to this, there have been significant costs
At the end of day, the strategy to scrap inefficient plants to savings through management of resources with the
cut down losses might well clinch the deal for players in the implementation of SAP.
Asian region.
Competent Workforce and Manpower
Potential Utilization through Information
Technology (IT) Many contractors do not have appropriate staffing levels to
supply planners and schedulers to large projects. When a
The advantage of a proper IT-based information system is number of projects will come for execution at a time,
that accurate information can be obtained at a much faster manpower availability will be a real constraint. One of the
rate, reducing downtime and speeding up decision-making major innovative HR practices is the use of work teams
process. Since, time is more than money, it would have with multi-skill training and responsibility. In particular, the
direct impact on cost. The objective would be to implement use of production workers for routine maintenance reduces
IT in all operations and to integrate these with day-to-day the need for specialized maintenance workers, who are
decision-making process. IT applications will help in often underutilized. The use of multi-skilled workers and
streamlining both process chain and supply chain and would fewer job classifications is critical to a high-performance
thereby result in cost reduction and increase in productivity. workplace in the steel industry.
Therefore, the need to train the manpower to make them In order to execute successful growth strategies and provide
acquaintance with the new IT tools has to be the part of the growth teams with the skills, know-how, and tools to
strategic planning for successful implementation of the generate growth opportunities, evaluate these opportunities
project. There is a need to adopt the usage of IT to harness to create a growth pipeline, and implement a growth strategy
its potential for project management at appropriate places to deliver measurable business results shall be part of the
for monitoring and control even during project execution. strategies to achieve sustainability.
Steel plants in India are still using legacy software in India.
They are unable to take advantage of IT in order to attract The methods that are adopted for the creation of wealth in
global customers. IT applications to achieve customer the Indian steel industry are also supposed to act as
The assignment of respective jobs as per the merit and The Ministry of Steel has also been able to rationalize the
expertise available within the organization will be a real classification of coking coal in consultation with the Coal
challenge for smooth execution of the project. Hence faster Ministry so as to reduce the impact of royalty payable on
planning and shaping of projects is required to take the this basic raw material. Import duties on several raw
services of available resources. This is to be clearly materials, such as, scrap, ships for breaking, coke, non-
understood that the so-called big advantage of low labour coking coal etc. used by the steel industry has been reduced
cost in India is more or less a myth for two reasons. It has steadily over the past four to five years.
widely seen that more man hours utilized often neutralizes Import Duty
low wage rates. Also, low wage rates are the root causes
of poor labour productivity. In the last budget, imports duties on finished steel items
have been increased as a result of rationalization of tax
Government Policies and Directives structure.
The Ministry of Steel is expected to play a crucial role in Excise Duty
ensuring harmonious and integrated growth of the steel
sector in India. Steel being a core sector, its sustained The Finance Ministry was requested not to resort to further
growth is a prerequisite for attaining the level of GDP growth increase in Excise Duties on iron and steel materials, in
envisaged in the Eleventh Five-Year Plan. The Ministry of the last few budgets. On the other hand, a case has been
Steel is expected to play the role of a facilitator to remove made to reduce the excise duty levels on all finished steel
bottlenecks faced by Indian steel sector. This includes items, especially long products (which are consumed by
ensuring the availability of raw materials, development of the construction sector) by at least 10%, as the construction
infrastructure, constant interaction with Financial Institutions sector cannot avail of MODVAT benefit.
for making provision of the needed capital and also
interacting with other concerned Ministries and Departments Strengthening of Anti Dumping Mechanism
of the Government for appropriate policy responses. To check the increasing trend of cheap imports in certain
categories of flat products especially from CIS and South
Boosting Demand in the Steel Consuming Sectors
East Asian countries, the Ministry of Steel has urged the
To boost the demand and consumption of steel an Institute Commerce Ministry and the Finance Ministry to strengthen
for Steel Development and Growth (INSDAG) has been anti dumping mechanism so that fast decision on dumping
set up in Kolkata with leading steel producers in the country can be taken.
as its members. The Development Commissioner for Iron The strategy suggested for the reversal of the steel industry
and Steel (DCI&S) has launched a National Campaign for in India is double layered in nature, effecting the reversal
increasing the demand for steel, in nontraditional sectors, and at the same time sustaining the reversal. The strategy
particularly in the construction, rural and agro-based has to be growth and survival oriented. The survival part
industrial sector. Moreover, interest rates will have to come would assure the survival of the industry in the fierce
down to enable a common man to buy a house and other competitive atmosphere and the growth part would boost
utilities the sustainable growth of the industry. The two different
Duty on Project Imports parts of the strategy has to be integrated into one to have
the expected results.
To enhance the consumption of steel in the country, the
The reduction of the cost is another major factor in the
Finance Ministry has been urged to provide a level playing
survival of the Indian steel industry in the age of
field to domestic steel producers for steel supply against
globalization. The cost reduction would be the main aspect
International Competitive Bidding (ICB) under 'project
of the improvement pertaining to the competitiveness of
imports' in the fertilizer, power, oil sectors by exempting
the industry. The manufacturers under the steel industry in
them for excise and sales tax.
India have to focus their attention in the areas such as:
Reduction in Power and Rail Tariffs
í The reduction in the cost of operations;
The Ministry of Steel has been interacting with State í The reduction in the costs pertaining to the working
Governments to provide power at reduced/ concessional capital;
tariffs especially to mini steel plants all over the country.
Similarly, the freight rates adopted by the Railways have í The reduction in the costs pertaining to the production
been rationalized after inter action with the Railway Board inventory or stock that is not sold;
32 IE(I) Journal–MM
BF top-pressure
recovery turbine BOF gas boiler
Steam recovery
Sensible heat recovery
Coking
Gas
coal Electricity recovery
Gas
Coke oven gas
Fuel saving
Continuous
caster Continuous
Hot charge rolling annealing line
Hot rolled steel
products
Hot direct
rolling
Coke dry
quenching Cold rolled steel
products
Basic oxygen
furnace
Hot Cold Batch
Blast rolling rolling annealing
Reheating
furnace furnace
furnace
Sintering machine
Hot charge rolling
í The improvement in the economics operating in the Baosteel China Merger or acquisition with
technological aspects of production; Magang Group [Ma'anshan]
and with Handan Steel to
í The transposition of basic materials of production. create world’s second
largest steelmaker behind
Future Strategies — use of Alternate Energy Sources
Arcelor Mittal
Scientists are of the view that use of coal has to be phase Blue Scope
out quickly or risk an uninhabitable planet. Controlling the
Steel Australia Disposal of downstream
emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) as a measure against
cold rolling / coating
global warming is one of the crucial environmental issues
ventures [Asia Coated
that the steel industry must undertake. If steel industry does
Product Operations] in
not abled to take care of these factors, a day may come
Thailand and Indonesia;
when production is required to stop. This may lead to
perhaps also of North Star
stoppage of many steel plants affecting the supply-demand
joint venture in the USA to a
gap. Moreover, the cost of energy will be very significant in
large CIS steel group
driving the steel industry, calling for saving of energy at
different levels of production. A schematic of potential areas Bohler
of saving energy14,19,20 is shown in Figure 12. Uddeholm Austria Special steels opportunities
Case Studies : Strategy for Revival and Growth in Eastern Europe
Cleveland
Company Country Strategic
Cliffs USA Corporate governance
ArcelorMittal Luxembourg Sale of selected Central issues
European steel assets. Mine Corus UK Long term exit from UK
safety improvements in steelmaking including
Eastern Europe. Longer- Teesside
term downstream pursuit of
GSHL Nigeria Long-term start-up of
construction markets,
Ajaokuta driven by medium-
including building design /
term ramp up of
fabrication / distribution /
downstream production
erection jv’s in Asia
Mittal Steel
Azovstal Ukraine Leverage of cost advantage/ Krivoy Rog
strategic localization through [formerly
regional M&A Krivorozhstal] Ukraine Switch (perhaps just partial
34 IE(I) Journal–MM
steel industry: The factors for revival of Indian steel industry are buoyant
global steel consumption, buoyant local steel consumption,
í Technology policy is to be so designed by the lower cost of production and adequate rise in price against
government that it will generate the thrust to update hike in input costs together with backward integration,
the technology by the steel producers; consolidation and branded product sales, marketing
alliances, etc.
í Further liberalization towards tariff structure, full
convertibility of Indian currency, more equity Even in these tumultuous times, strategic planning doesn't
participation by foreign partners, rationalization of tax have to be an exercise in anxiety-or futility.
structure etc. will be required;
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
í Steel companies must assess their core competency
and realign their strategy to cope with the internal and Authors are grateful to the colleagues of SAIL for sharing
global competition; their thoughts for the problems and various strategies/
solutions for the revival and growth of Indian Steel Industry.
í R&D focus is to be increased substantially. Authors are highly obliged to the management of RDCIS
Expenditure on R&D by steel plants should be for their valuable supports extended to them in bringing
increased. With a strong R&D base, organizations will this paper.
be able to assimilate the technology faster;
REFERENCES
í Organizational adjustments must be made while
adopting newer technologies. Effective human 1. http://www.ficci.com.
resource policy will help speedier technology adoption. 2. www.worldsteel.org.
Socio-economic aspects should be dovetailed while
selecting a technology; 3. www.steel.org.
4. http://www.cmie.com/.
í Training and retraining with updated inputs should be
a continuous process in steel plants. Training 5. jpcindiansteel.nic.in.
programmers should be designed for people from 6. ‘Agenda for 100 Days’. Ministry of Steel.
different hierarchy including top level management;
7. www.planningcommission.gov.in/.
í As economy is becoming more and more market-
8. Steel World.
driven, steel sector should also tune to it;
9. http://steel.nic.in.
í Technology transfer plans are to be worked out more
carefully. Indian firms must select appropriate 10. ‘Indian Steel Outlook’. Iisi-oecd Conference.
technology with proper scope of adoption; 11. http://www.indiansteelalliance.com.