Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ABSTRACT survey was limited to 25°C but it was expected that the dis-
crepancies would be even larger if other temperatures were
A theoretical approach was used to predict the water activity (a,) at
15°C and 35°C of selected saturated salt solutions used as standards
considered. It is obvious that for different regulatory agencies
in the range of microbial growth (20.57-0.97). For this purpose a to adopt an a, specification for foods, and for different re-
rigorous thermodynamic model to predict osmotic coefficient was used. searchers to reproduce each others a, measurements, there
The results agreed very well with experimental measurements at 15°C must be an “universal” agreement on the values to be assigned
and 35°C for most salts studied, which included NaBr, NaCl, to reference standards of saturated salt solutions. This agree-
(NH&S04, KCl, BaC12, and KzS04. For KNOs the agreement at the ment should include not only 25°C but also other temperatures
higher temperature was somewhat less satisfactory and the reasons for of interest of microbial growth.
this behavior are discussed. The purpose of this study was to use a theoretical approach
based on the thermodynamic properties of strong electrolyte
aqueous solutions to calculate the a, of selected saturated salt
INTRODUCTION solutions in the temperature range 15-35°C. The study covered
IT IS WELL KNOWN that adjustment of the water activity the range of a, of most interest to microbial growth (=0.57-
(a,) of foods is an important method of controlling spoilage 0.97). The predicted results were compared with experimental
by microorganisms (Troller and Christian, 1978). This has been data obtained with an electric hygrometer previously calibrated
recognized by regulatory agencies in several countries who with unsaturated salt solutions for which agreement on their
have incorporated the a, principle in the definition of standards a, at 15°C and 35°C existed.
for various preserved foods.
The U.S. Food & Drug Administration has adopted the water MATERIALS & METHODS
activity specification in the definition of low-acid foods (FDA,
1973) as has the FAO/WHO Codex Alimentarius Commission Materials
(FAO/WHO, 1979) and the European Community for the trade Saturated salt solutions were prepared by mixing a large excess of
of meats products (EEC, 1976). The reliability of most a, each salt and distilled water and stored at 15°C (?0.2”C) or 35°C
measuring devices such as electric or fiber-dimensional hygro- (kO.2”C) in a forced convection low-temperature incubator for var-
meters, strongly depends on proper calibration using reference ious days before using. Seven reagent grade salts were used: sodium
sources of a,. Saturated salt solutions are used by a large bromide, sodium chloride, ammonium sulfate, potassium chloride,
number of people as a convenient way to provide solutions of barium chloride, potassium nitrate and potassium sulfate. These salts
have been used extensively as reference standards of water activity in
known a,. They are reproducible reference standards because
the range of interest to the present study. Unsaturated solutions of
no measurement of concentration is needed and if the salts are sodium chloride and lithium chloride were prepared using anhydrous
properly chosen no interfering vapors are present (Stoloff, 1978; reagent grade salts for calibration of the hygrometer at 15°C and 35°C.
Gal, 1981).
Considerable data and several reviews are available on the Measurement of a,
a, of standard salt slurries (Stokes and Robinson, 1949; Wex-
ler and Hasegawa, 1954; Young, 1967; Rockland, 1960; In- The a, of the six saturated salt solutions at 15°C and 35°C was
ternational Critical Tables, 1926; Labuza et al., 1976; Greenspan, measured using a Novasina Humidat-TH2 Thermoconstanter hygro-
1977). Unfortunately, most reports in the literature do not agree meter (Novasina AC, Ch-8050 Zurich, Switzerland). This instrument
on the exact a, of each saturated salt solution. Considerable has a built-in accurate temperature control device which maintains the
sensor and the sample at constant temperature in the range 0-50°C.
doubt has arisen about the accuracy of water activity of satu- The hygrometer was operated following the procedure described in
rated salt solutions in view of the recent review by Greenspan detail by Kitic et al. (1986). Each a, measurement represents the
(1977). His work reflects very well the uncertainties of liter- average of three determinations. As shown previously (Kitic et al.,
ature values from various workers. Recently, Resnik et al. 1986), three replicates are enough to obtain a precision of f 0.005
(1984) reported the results of a world survey of a, values at a, when using the Novasina Thermoconstanter for measuring the a,
25°C of selected saturated salt solutions used as standards in of saturated salt solutions in the range of interest of this study. To
the range of a, 0.57-0.97, which is of most interest to micro- measure the a, of saturated salt solutions at 15°C and 35°C the in-
bial growth. Their results confirmed the discrepanciesbetween strument was first calibrated at these temperatures using other stan-
laboratories regarding the correct a, to assign to each salt. The dards for which agreement exists on their a, at 15°C and 35’C. Chirife
and Resnik (1984) and Kitic et al. (1986) proposed the use of unsat-
urated solutions of NaCl and LiCl as isopiestic standards for calibra-
tion of a, measuring devices at various temperatures and showed that
there was excellent agreement (theoretical and experimental values)
Authors Kitic, Favetto, and Chirife are with PRO/PA (CONICET-
on the exact value of the a, of these solutions; thus these values were
FCEyN), Depto. de Industrias, Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y used for the calibration of the Novasina Thermoconstanter at 15°C
Naturales, Univ. de Buenos Aires, 1428 Buenos Aires, Republica and 35°C. Table 1 shows the data used for the calibration; at least six
Argentina. Author Pereira Jardin is with lnstituto de Tecnologia points were used at each temperature. NaCL solutions are useful as
de Alimentos (ITAL), Campinas, S.P., Brasii. Author Favetto is a standards only for values of a, of about 0.75 and above (saturation
member of CONICET, Argentina. Author Resnik is a member of
value); for this reason LiCl solutions were used as standards for lower
Comisi& de lnvestigaciones Cientificas de la Provincia de Bue-
a, values. Equilibration times for measuring a, of each saturated salt
nos Aires, Argentina. were previously determined and ranged between 30-90 min.
+ q13 ln f + qdT - Tr) (6) NaCI 15 0.752 k 0.001 0.753 k 0.001 0.753
25 0.751 +- 0001 ___ ___
r
35 .._. f 0.001
0.750 __--. 0.749 I 0.001 0.751
where Tn is 298.15”C and the values of the parameters PJH&S04 15 --_ __- 0.804
qr . . . . q14 are given in Table 3. These values, along with 25 0.803 k 0.001 ___ ___
35 ___ ___ 0 797
Bq. (3), (4), (5), (2) and (1) allow a rigorous and accurate
prediction of the a, of NaCl solutions for the whole concen- KCI 15 0.858 + 0.002 0.859 f 0.002 0.860
25 0.842 + 0.001 0.842 -+ 0.001 ---
tration range (up to saturation) and any desired temperature. 35 0.827 + 0.001 0.827 f 0.001 0.828
The values of the Debye-Htickel parameters(Eq. 2) at different BaCls 15 ___ 0.910 f 0.001 0.908
temperaturesare given by Ananthaswamy and Atkinson (1984) 25 0.903 f 0.001 ___ ___
and those of b and 01are taken as temperature independent. 35 --_ 0.894 k 0.002 0.893
Recently, Holmes and Mesmer (1983) applied the ion-in- KNOs 15 --_ 0.948 f 0.001 0.943
25 0.926 IT 0.001 -__ ___
teraction model of Pitzer (1973) to aqueous solutions of the
35 ___ 0.889 f 0.002 0.898
alkali metal chlorides to 250°C. Their resulting set of equations
provide a thermodynamic description within the accuracy of KzSQI 15 ___ 0.979 -+ 0.000 0.977
25 0.975 -c 0.000 -__ ___
the reported experimental data. The parameters B(O),B(l) and 35 ___ 0.972 f 0.000 0.971
CMx are described by arbitrary functions of temperature, f(T) OThe fluctuations in a, values arise from the standard deviation of the solubility
of the form data.
b Predicted using Pitzer’s model (Eq. 2) with parameters for 25°C or with the rigorous
temperature dependence for 15’C and 35°C [Eq. (4). (5). 0%. and (7)l.
f(T) = pl + PZ ($ - f) + p3 ln f + ~4 (T - ‘G) (7) c Predicted using Pitzefs model with approximation for the temperature dependence
IEq. WI.
+ ps (T2 - Gr2) + p6 ln;T - 260) d Measured with the Novasina Thermoconstanter (average of triplicate determina-
tions).
where p,,. . . ., p6 are parameters.
with the exception of the term envolving p6 this equation (i.e., 15°C or 35°C as is the case in the present paper) can be
is identical with the form used by Silvester and Pitzer (1977). approximated by
The values of the parameters pt, . . . ., p6 for aqueous so-
lutions of potassium chloride are listed in Table 4; they allow
a very accurate calculation of the a, of KC1 solutions for the fcr, = 4x-c) + -&CAT (8)
whole concentration range (up to saturation) at any tempera-
ture . where f(r) is the value of the function at temperature T. The
Silvester and Pitzer (1978) gave the change with temperature values of the corresponding derivatives for the salts of interest
of the activity and osmotic coefficients. They reported results to the present study are given in Table 5. The most important
for 84 electrolytes of 1- 1, 2- 1, 3- 1 and 2-2 valence types. The conclusion is that for almost all salts considered here the tem-
parameters allow the convenient calculation of properties at perature derivatives are relatively small. Thus, for NaBr, NaCl,
other temperatures not too different from 25°C. The values of KCl, BaC12, and K2S04 where B(O)and B(l) at 25°C had a
B(O),B(l) and CMX at temperaturesnot too different from 25°C magnitude of about 0.05 or a few tenths (Table 2), the deriv-
sealed lyethylene-lined boxes of apples, oranges and lettuce with hy- simmon fruit with high carbon dioxide treatment; in vitro gelation of
drated p”ime mserta. Proc. Am. Sot. Hort. Sci. 82: 83. kaki-tannin by reacting with acetaldehyde. A ‘c. Biol. Chem. 46: 683.
Hardenburg, R.E. 1971. Effect of in-package environment on keeping qual- Per+ E. and Ng, T.G. 1984. The role of anaeroT ic respiration in germi-
ity of fruits and vegetables. HortScience 6: 198. natmg muskmelon seeds. II. Effect of anoxia treatment and alcohol de-
Honda, Y. and Ishiguro, 0. 1968. Studies on the storage of fruits and hydrogenase activity. J. Expt. Bot. 35: 366.
vegetables. II. On the keeping of some vegetables packaged with plastic Pesis, E. and Ng, T.G. 1984. The role of anaerobic respiration in germi-
bags. J. Jap. Sot. Hart. Sci. 37: 77. nating muskmelon seeds. II. Effect of anoxia treatment and alcohol de-
Kawada, K. 1982. Use of polymeric films to extend postharvest life and hydmgenase activity. J. Ex th. Bot. 35: 366.
improve marketability of fruits and vegetables-Unipack: individually Saguy I. and Mannheim C.!I 1975 The effect of selected lastic films
wrapped storage of tomatoes, oriental rsimmons and grapefruit. In and rhemical dius on th;! shelf-life of Marmande tomatoes. B Food Tech-
“Controlled Atmosphere for Storage an 8”Transport of Perishable Agri- nol. 10: 547. _
cultural Commodities”, (Ed.1 D.G. Richardson and M. Meheriuk, p. 87. Sugiura, A., Yonemori, K., Harada, H., and Tomana, T. 1979. Changes of
Timber Press. Beaverton. OR. ethanol and acetaldehyde contents in Japanese persimmon fruits and
Marcellin, P. 1961. La conservation de pommes ou de poires en atmosphere ~~;~relatlon to natural deaatringency. Stud. Inst. Ho&, Kyoto Univ.
controlee au maven d’amballaees de matiere .dastiaue.* Int. Inst. B&rig. Tolle, W.E. 1971. Vegetables affecting film permeability requirements for
Bul. Annex 1: 361. ~4$df’ed atmosphere storage of apples. Tech. Bull. U.S. Dep. Agnc. No.
Matauo, T. and Itoo, S. 1977. On mechanisms of removing astringency in
persimmon fruits by carbon dioxide treatment. I. Some properties of the MS received 112186;revised 3126186;accepted 3128186.
two processes in the deastringency. Plant Cell Physiol. 18: 17.
Matauo, T. and Itoo, S. 1982. A model experiment for destringency of per-