Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The fulltext of this document has been downloaded 2632 times since 2006*
Users who downloaded this article also downloaded:
(2014),"Managing brand presence through social media: the case of UK football clubs", Internet Research, Vol. 24 Iss 2 pp.
181-204 <a href="https://doi.org/10.1108/IntR-08-2012-0154">https://doi.org/10.1108/IntR-08-2012-0154</a>
(2009),"Social networks, football fans, fantasy and reality: How corporate and media interests are invading our
lifeworld", Journal of Information, Communication and Ethics in Society, Vol. 7 Iss 1 pp. 54-71 <a href="https://
doi.org/10.1108/14779960910938098">https://doi.org/10.1108/14779960910938098</a>
Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by emerald-srm:572615 []
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service
information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please
visit www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company manages a portfolio of
more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online
products and additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication
Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.
generate revenue and bombard fans with Trusts are run as industrial and provident
marketing images. Instead it looks at sites that societies (IPSs) and are excellent examples of
allow fans to express themselves in the way fans becoming involved in the running of their
Labour's Football Charter wanted or are clubs. To date, around 47 clubs have set up
independent from football's big business Supporters' Trusts, all of these have
machine. established a presence on the Net (Supporters
Direct, 2002) under the watchful eye of the
Supporters Direct team. The Supporters
Supporters Direct Direct Web site is clearly a focus for fans
wanting to take an active role in the running
So, what has the impact been and might the of clubs.
Internet be the fans' saviour? The Supporters The Northampton Town Football Club
Direct initiative is one area of fan power that Trust was the original and a Trust member
receives great attention and praise from the now has a seat on the board. An analysis of
Downloaded by Symbiosis International University Lavale, Mr Sudip Sam At 08:13 20 October 2018 (PT)
gurus at the SNCCFR. Supporters Direct was the Northampton Town Trust by academics
one of the bi-products of the Football Task at Birkbeck College advocated the use of the
Force's (1999a) third report Investing in the Web in canvassing fans' views:
Community. At the launch, the then Culture If a Trust is to represent the fans' views then it
Secretary, Chris Smith MP said: needs to maintain a consistent dialogue with the
There is an increasing danger in these days of fans. The Trust can only maintain a meaningful
high finance in football, that clubs can become dialogue by pointing to where it stands on club
separated from their fans. They may lose sight of issues and the needs of the fans. This may
the value of their supporters and could be involve using space in the match programme,
tempted to ignore the desires and passion of their fanzines, websites or simple leaflets (Frampton et
following. I don't want fans of any club to be al., 2001).
taken for granted (Department of Culture,
Media and Sport, 2000). The Northampton Town Trust has both an
extensive Web site (http://www.ntfctrust.
The introductory press release from the
co.uk/) and an e-mail update service.
Department of Culture Media and Sport
(DCMS) sets the scheme out as follows:
Culture Secretary Chris Smith today launched a
Co-operative Bank backed scheme to help fans Wimbledon Football Club
play a part in running the clubs they love.
Under the ``Supporters Direct'' scheme, a team A related phenomenon is the growth of
of experts established by the Football Trust will independent supporters associations (ISAs)
advise fans who want to play a responsible role in over recent years. In many respects these are
the future of their team. With some help towards similar to Supporters' Trusts but tend to be
start-up costs, supporters will be able to create
forums for like minded fans and shy away
Supporters' Trusts to acquire shares in their
clubs. The project is backed by the Co-op Bank, from the financial and political responsibilities
which has started a preferential banking service a trust might undertake. A good example of
to help make the Trusts a success (Department how supporters might use trusts and ISAs on
of Culture, Media and Sport, 2000). the Web to make their views heard (and
Supporters Direct is based at Birkbeck more) concerns Charles Koppel's desire to
College and has an admirable Web site move Wimbledon Football Club away from
(http://www.supporters-direct.org/). The their spiritual home to Milton Keynes.
Web site contains advice on how to set up a The Wimbledon Independent Supporters
Supporters' Trust, formulate a constitution, Association (WISA) has been around for
buy and manage shares in a club and even many years and its Web site (http://
gain a seat on the board. There is a quarterly www.wisa.org.uk/) shows how the Net can be
newsletter e-mailed out to members of used to keep fans informed, canvass opinions
Supporters Direct and the site even hosts an and muster and mobilise support. At the
e-mail group for like-minded individuals. moment, WISA is organising a vigil at the
Based at Yahoo! but accessed via the Football Association (FA) headquarters
Supporters Direct Web site, this e-group where a tribunal is hearing evidence about the
allows members of trusts to share their ideas implications of moving the club to Milton
and experiences in a co-operative spirit. Keynes. People interested in helping out are
274
Football fan power and the Internet: net gains? Aslib Proceedings
Caroline Auty Volume 54 . Number 5 . 2002 . 273±279
asked to e-mail vigil@wisa.org.uk. The WISA message across. If WISA really had their wits
Web site also contains instructions on: about them they could do worse than register
. how to contact the FA with your views; all potential domain names the club might
. how to e-mail, how to address the letter to want to use if it relocated and fill them with
Adam Crozier; campaigning material (e.g. mkdons.com/ or
. the deadline for written submissions; miltonkeynesdons.com). A case of poaching a
. 25 facts about Wimbledon FC and goal if ever there was one.
Milton Keynes; WISA also benefits from an alternative
. an online comments form for supporters match day programme/fanzine Yellow and
of other clubs sympathetic to Blue produced so fans opposed to the move
Wimbledon's plight to contact the FA by do not have to give money to Charles Koppel
e-mail. when they buy a programme. The editor,
In terms of mobilising support, the WISA Niall Couper, gave an interview on The
Web site asks for volunteers to help with Guardian's football portal
Downloaded by Symbiosis International University Lavale, Mr Sudip Sam At 08:13 20 October 2018 (PT)
specific tasks and asks for fans' views using footballunlimited.co.uk in which he talked
the WISA chat facility and mailtos. The about the background of Yellow and Blue:
WISA Web site also includes pages common Yellow and Blue is a 48-page full colour glossy
magazine. With a boycott on club merchandise
to other ISAs, namely news, social dates and
in the wake of Charles Koppel's plan to take
even a WISA e-mail service. Wimbledon to Milton Keynes, we are the
In addition to the long-established alternative matchday programme for both home
independent supporters' association at and away fans.
Wimbledon, fans have recently set up a The idea was first mooted on a website.
Wimbledon supporters' trust, the Dons Twelve days later, we went to print with a 32-
page colour programme with ads from Kiss FM
Trust, under the Supporters Direct scheme.
and Cherry Red records and regular columnists
The initial aim of the Trust is: signed up (Couper, 2001).
. . . to raise as much money as possible. This will
open up several possibilities. The Trust may be Yellow and Blue is available on the Web at:
able to purchase significant shareholdings in http://www.yellowandblue.org/
Wimbledon Football Club, or may want to part
purchase a plot of land, or help finance the
construction of a new stadium in the local
community (The Dons Trust, 2002). IMUSA
The Dons Trust has also used the Web Another example of an ISA flexing its muscles
as a means of campaigning and mobilising. online concerns Rupert Murdoch's threat to
It can be found on the Web at http://www. take over Manchester United Football Club
thedonstrust.org/ and includes an online and thus unite football with television rights
membership form (sadly, this has to be posted once and for all. The Independent
with remittance snail mail), the Trust's Manchester United Supporters Association
constitution, how to get elected to the board (IMUSA) mobilised to stop the move and this
and a news page. Volunteers to help with the was a multi-faceted campaign that attracted a
campaign are recruited online using a lot of media attention. An article in the Red
comments form. Pepper looks at the approach taken by IMUSA
Wimbledon supporters, via WISA and the and notes the following:
Dons Trust, have made productive use of the The Internet proved vital in pulling together
Web in other ways. When Koppel first distant resources and researching material on
suggested moving the club to far away Milton Murdoch's activities. Fans all over the world
Keynes, WISA registered the domain name could become involved and a website was
http://www.mknoway.co.uk/ as a focal point quickly established as a central repository for
materials and a source of information on the
for discontented fans. Someone has also
campaign's progress (Walsh and Brown, 2000).
registered the domain name
charleskoppel.com and this page links to a Today, the IMUSA site library (http://
picture of Milton Keynes, Charles Koppel www.imusa.org/library.htm) details the
and some money bags and carries the slogan supporters' fight against Murdoch along with
``Why euthanasia must be legalised copies of the documents mounted at the time:
immediately.'' Less professional than the Keep United for United, the submission to
WISA approach but it certainly gets the the Office of Fair Trading and an extract from
275
Football fan power and the Internet: net gains? Aslib Proceedings
Caroline Auty Volume 54 . Number 5 . 2002 . 273±279
.
website and in the programme but as less than
sides seem to be having a great time
twenty per cent of the match going support looks
at these it is little wonder (IMUSA Fans' Forum, visiting new places and meeting new
2002). people while England fans are getting into
trouble?
. Should our clubs be doing more to
encourage women, families and minority
Online voting and discussion
communities to go to matches?
Trusts and ISAs aside, there are examples of . Should they be doing more to help the
clubs trying to involve fans in the decision local community? If so, what?
making process over the Web. Some clubs . What can be done to encourage more
have asked fans to vote online and select their young people to take part in local
club's next kit. Leyton Orient did this (Leyton football, and to make the experience
Orient Football Club, 2002), but perhaps the positive and welcoming for all sections of
best example of kit power is Southampton the community?
Football Club. The Saintsfc Web site ran an
. What do you think? Don't wait for the
online vote to choose its new kit but this was ``experts'' to decide then complain.
bombarded by Portsmouth fans who tried to (Working Group on Football Disorder,
swing the vote to the most outrageous attire 2000)
for their local rivals. The recommendations produced by the group
The Saintsfc Web site commented thus: suggested that the Web site be ``maintained
Despite the best efforts of mischievous rival fans, and expanded'' (Working Group on Football
Saints will be playing in their traditional red and
Disorder, 2001, p. 9).
white stripes next season. Half time at The Dell
saw Pete Devereux of Southampton garage duo The Independent Football Commission
Artful Dodger proudly parade the new design (IFC) is another national body that seeks to
after more than 30,000 votes were cast. And redress grievances within the game and
although rival fans were reported to be voting in allows fans to e-mail their complaints. It was
their droves for the unpopular Monaco design, set up as a direct recommendation of the
the favourite choice eventually won out by a
fourth report of the Football Task Force's
comfortable margin (Southampton Football
Club, 2001). Commercial Issues:
A football ``Ombudsfan''
Most clubs now have a club charter that sets The Task Force recommends the establishment
out how the club will conduct its business. of an ``Ombudsfan'' who investigates individual
The Leeds United Customer Charter is a complaints and reports to the Football Audit
Commission (Football Task Force, 1999b).
good example of this and even mentions how
consultations take place online: The IFC has established a Web site (http://
The club consults supporters on a regular basis www.theifc.co.uk) with a ``raise an issue''
through questionnaires, FAPL annual Fans' form and promised to take on board fans'
survey, supporters' panels, focus groups and via
concerns. Unfortunately, this may be a case of
the official website. The club recognises the
voice of our junior members and will be holding the Government scoring an own goal as
annual feedback sessions to build upon our reports in the press suggest that the IFC's
existing relationship (Leeds United FC, 2002). powers are limited and people like
276
Football fan power and the Internet: net gains? Aslib Proceedings
Caroline Auty Volume 54 . Number 5 . 2002 . 273±279
Rogan Taylor were excluded from the IFC for The Evening Standard reported on the
being too closely allied with supporters' subject as follows:
groups (Chaudhary, 2002; Mellor, 2001). English football hooligans are organising a
campaign of violence on the Internet in
preparation for Euro 2000. With only a week to
go until England's opening match against
Portugal, a website names the bars where
Fanzines troublemakers can meet in Eindhoven, Holland.
Black market tickets for England games are
Fanzines are often regarded as the true voice being sold through the site by touts offering to
of the fans. Cheaply and locally produced meet cash buyers in Holland. There is also
advice on where to find the best drugs and red-
they are superb mouthpieces for fan power,
light areas and how to beat security (Das-Gupta,
and as such have transferred effortlessly to 2000).
cyberspace. A simple Google search on
fanzines reveals just how many exist in The National Criminal Intelligence Service
(NCIS) is the branch of the police concerned
Downloaded by Symbiosis International University Lavale, Mr Sudip Sam At 08:13 20 October 2018 (PT)
Mellor, D. (2001), ``A disgrace: clubs want obedient Supporters Direct (2002), available at: http://
watchdog'', Evening Standard, 13 July, p. 69. www.supporters-direct.org/links.htm (accessed 6
Millwall Football Club (2002), 23 May, available at: June 2002).
www.millwallfc.co.uk/today/view/ Walsh, A. and Brown, A. (2000), ``Fan power'', Red
Pepper, February, available at: www.redpepper.
breaking_news_detail/0,,10367~220744,00.html
org.uk/cularch/xmanu.html (accessed 6 June 2002).
(accessed 27 May 2002).
Working Group on Football Disorder (2000), available at:
Southampton Football Club (2001), New Shirt Unveiled,
www.ask-the-football-fans.gov.uk/ (accessed 5 June
official press release 29 January, available at: 2002).
www.saintsfc.co.uk/00_01/news/010129b.shtml Working Group on Football Disorder (2001), Report and
(accessed 26 May 2002). Recommendations, Home Office, London.
Downloaded by Symbiosis International University Lavale, Mr Sudip Sam At 08:13 20 October 2018 (PT)
279
This article has been cited by:
1. Dino Numerato. 2016. Behind the digital curtain: Ethnography, football fan activism and social change. Qualitative Research
16:5, 575-591. [Crossref]
2. Guilherme Guimaraes, Chris Stride, Daragh O'Reilly. 2016. Brand community, loyalty and promise in myfootballclub.co.uk.
Sport, Business and Management: An International Journal 6:2, 137-157. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
3. Chris Stride, John P. Wilson, Ffion Thomas. 2013. Honouring heroes by branding in bronze: theorizing the UK's football
statuary. Sport in Society 16:6, 749-771. [Crossref]
4. Kevin Dixon. 2011. A ‘third way’ for football fandom research: Anthony Giddens and Structuration Theory. Soccer & Society
12:2, 279-298. [Crossref]
5. Tom Gibbons, Kevin Dixon. 2010. ‘Surf ’s up!’: A call to take English soccer fan interactions on the Internet more seriously.
Soccer & Society 11:5, 599-613. [Crossref]
6. Rachel McLean, David W. Wainwright. 2009. Social networks, football fans, fantasy and reality. Journal of Information,
Communication and Ethics in Society 7:1, 54-71. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
7. Simon Chadwick, Will Garford, Guilherme Guimaraes, Daragh O'Reilly. 2008. The formation, organisation and management
Downloaded by Symbiosis International University Lavale, Mr Sudip Sam At 08:13 20 October 2018 (PT)
of MyFootballClub: Implications for marketing practice. Journal of Direct, Data and Digital Marketing Practice 10:2, 150-160.
[Crossref]