Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
STEWART
B. ROODAND SIG HEINZE-MILNE
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alta., Canada T l K 3M4
Received August 5, 1988
forest decline during the 20-year interval; declines of 4.7, 4.6, and 6.1 % occurred along the St. Mary, Belly, and Waterton
rivers, respectively. Thus, the damming of two rivers in southern Alberta has been followed by a rapid and dramatic down-
stream decline in riparian forests. Further, the close association between the location and extent of the forest decline supports
a causal relationship between the river damming and the forest decline. Possible causes of the decline are discussed, including
drought-induced mortality, particularly of seedlings.
rivikre Belly non endigute est demeurte relativement inchangee au cours de la pQiode d'ttude,montrant une rtduction de
moins de 1%. Les parties d'amont (non endigutes) des trois rivibres ont subi un dCclin au cours des deux dtcades; des dCclins
respectifs de 4,7, 4,6, et 6,l ont t t t notts le long des rivibres St. Mary, Belly et Waterton. Ainsi, l'endiguement de deux
rivibres dans le sud de 1'Alberta a caust un dtclin rapide et dramatique des forCts ripariennes. En outre, l'association Ctroite
entre la localisation et le degrt du dtclin forestier indique une relation causale entre l'endiguement et le dCclin forestier. Les
causes possibles du dtclin sont discuttes et comprennent peut-Ctre la mortalitC, en particulier celle des semis, causCe par la
sbcheresse.
[Traduit par la revue]
R Y RESERVOIR
WATERTON RESERVOIR
For personal use only.
FIG. 1. Location of the dams and rivers in southwestern Alberta from which poplar abundances were determined from air photos. Gauging
stations are represented by (*).
Methods (Rood et al. 1986), there was less rationale for investigating specific
differences in the decline of the different poplar genotypes.
The study area (Fig. 1) consists of three river valleys in the south- Two sets of air photos were used to identify riparian poplar forests:
west corner of Alberta. The Belly, St. Mary, and Waterton rivers 1961 (scale = 1 : 3 1 680) and 1981 (scale = 1 : 60 000). Transparen-
originate in alpine tundra (elevation 2000-3000 m) in the Lewis cies were placed on one of a stereoscopic pair of air photos, and
Range of the Rocky Mountains and flow northeasterly through mon- rivers and riparan poplar forests were traced on the transparency. The
tane forest and the Rocky Mountain foothills (aspen parkland) before abundance of poplar forests was measured from the transparencies by
cascading into the treeless stretches of fescue prairie (elevation 900- a lineal ticking method measured to the nearest rnillimetre. In this
1000 m). All three rivers originate from mountain snowmelt and rain- method, the tracing of the rivers was broken into 1-mm segments and
fall runoff, are relatively steep in gradient, and contain generally
the number of segments associated with forest was counted. This
clear and cold water. The river discharges are quite erratic, respond- procedure did not consider the two-dimensional area of the forests,
ing quickly to changes in precipitation and temperature. but estimated the lineal distance of forest abundance, a one-dimen-
Hydrological data were collected by the Water Survey of Canada sional representation.
(Environment Canada 1985, 1986). Figures 3 -5 represent typical
Ten 4-km river reaches were evaluated upstream and downstream
data for the study area and originate from hydrometric gauging sta- from the St. Mary and Waterton dams and a corresponding 80-km
tions 05AD003 at the Waterton River near Waterton Park (upstream stretch of the Belly River was also studied (twenty 4-km segments for
data), 05AD008 at the Waterton River near Stand Off (downstream, each river). For each 4-km study segment, the proportion of river
1950- 1966), and 05AD028 at the Waterton River near Glenwood
with a poplar forest associated with at least one river bank was deter-
(downstream, 1967- 1985). Figure 6 represents data from stations mined, and this value is referred to as the "forest abundance." Mean
05AD005 at the Belly River near Mountain View (upstream) and (* SE) forest abundances were calculated from the 10 segments of
05AD002 at the Belly River near Stand Off (downstream). each of the six river sections (three rivers, upstream and down-
The riparian ecosystem along southern Alberta prairie rivers is stream). The 80-km sections upstream and downstream from the
floristically relatively simple with the dominant, and generally exclu- dams comprised almost the entire rivers; hence, this sampling evalu-
sive, large woody plants present being poplars (Shaw 1976). Populus ated most of the river valley forests rather than providing a sample
angustifolia, P. balsamifera, and P. deltoides comprise a unique, for extrapolation to a larger population.
natural, disectional, trispecific hybrid swarm (Brayshaw 1965; Rood
et al. 1986). Results and discussion
No attempt was made to investigate possible preferential survival
of the poplar species or of certain hybrids. Rather, in the present Along undarnrned segments of rivers in southern Alberta
study only overall forest abundances were determined. Since the (i.e., the Belly River and upstream portions of the St. Mary
three species freely interbreed forming a continuous hybrid swarm and watertonrivers), forests generally occurred along
1746 CAN. J . BOT. VOL. 67, 1989
Downstream
River Upstream Downstream -upstream
St. Mary -4.7k 1.8 -47.8,4.0 -43.1
Belly (undammed) -4.6+1.5 -0.1 k 2 . 6 4.5
Waterton -6.1k1.9 -22.9k1.7 -16.8
NOTE: Values are means t SE of 10 values, except downstream St. Mary for
which nine values were included.
the forest abundance plots for 1961 and 1981 (Fig. 2). The
average decline during the 20-year interval was almost one-
Can. J. Bot. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 99.243.105.24 on 01/09/15
DOWNSTREAM I
0
I v, DOWNSTREAM
Can. J. Bot. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 99.243.105.24 on 01/09/15
1950 19 6 0 1970 19 8 0
YEAR +F A
-- 2 0 -
V)
ro
-E
-l
10
cn
3
C)
3 0
a C) T
DOWNSTREAM
Can. J. Bot. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 99.243.105.24 on 01/09/15
DOWNSTREAM
flow alteration would only be moderated when another tribu- Geological and Natural History Survey and Museum of Canada.
tary or other drainage compensates for the flow restriction. In Dawson Bros., Montreal, Que.
the case of the St. Mary and Waterton rivers, there are no ENVIRONMENT CANADA. 1985. Historical streamflow summary:
major tributaries within 40 krn downstream of the dams. Alberta, to 1984. Environment Canada, Ottawa.
1986. Surface water data: Alberta, 1985. Environment
The poplars of southern Alberta comprise the principal, and
Canada, Ottawa.
generally only, large woody plants in the riparian forests. EVERITT, B. 1968. Use of cottonwood in an investigation of the recent
Consequently, the fate of the entire forest is ultimately tied to history of a floodplain. Am. J. Sci. 266: 417-439.
the fate of the poplars. The poplar groves provide a forest FENNER, P., BRADY, W. W., and PATTON, D. R. 1984. Observations
canopy allowing for the development of an understory of of seeds and seedlings of Fremont cottonwood. Desert Plants, 6:
shrubs and herbs. Arboreal bird nesting is common and the 55-58.
forests support a rich terrestrial fauna. The central role of 1985. Effects of regulated water flows on regeneration of
poplars in the riparian ecosystem is undeniable, and as the Fremont cottonwood. J. Range Manage. 38: 135- 138.
poplars die, so dies the riparian forest ecosystem. JOHNSON, W. C., BURGESS, R. L., and KEAMMERER, W. R. 1976.
In summary, a close relationship was established between Forest overstory vegetation and environment on the Missouri River
floodplain in North Dakota. Ecol. Monogr. 46: 59-84.
river damming and riparian forest decline in southern Alberta.
Can. J. Bot. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 99.243.105.24 on 01/09/15
and damming in southern Alberta. This study was supported Nat. 102: 59-67.
by Alberta Environmental Research Trust grant TO1016 and a PHINNEY, R. B. 1982. Flood of June 1975 in the Oldman River Basin,
University of Lethbridge research grant to S.B.R. Alberta. Environment Canada, Water Resources Branch Report.
READ,M. A. 1958. Silvicultural characteristics of Plain's Cotton-
ALBERTSON, F. W., and WEAVER, J. E. 1945. Injury and death or wood. Rocky Mt. For. Range Exp. Stn. Pap. No. 33.
recovery of trees in prairie climate. Ecol. Monogr. 15: 395-433. REILY,P. W., and JOHNSON, W. C. 1982. The effects of altered hydro-
BRADLEY, C. E., and SMITH,D. G. 1984. Meandering channel logic regime on tree growth along the Missouri River in North
response to altered flow regime: Milk River, Alberta and Montana. Dakota. Can. J. Bot. 60: 2410-2423.
Water Resour. Res. 20: 1913- 1920. ROOD,S. B., CAMPBELL, J. S., and DESPINS, T. 1986. Natural poplar
1985. Plains cottonwood recruitment and survival on a hybrids from southern Alberta. I. Continuous variation for foliar
prairie meandering river floodplain, Milk River, southern Alberta characteristics. Can. J. Bot. 64: 1382- 1388.
and northern Montana. Can. J. Bot. 64: 1433- 1442. SHAW,R. K. 1976. A taxonomic and ecologic study of the riverbot-
BRAYSHAW, T. C. 1965. Native poplars of southern Alberta and their tom forest on St. Mary River, Lee Creek and Belly River in South-
hybrids. Can. Dep. For. Publ. No. 1109. western Alberta, Canada. Great Basin Nat. 36: 243-271.
DAWSON, G. M. 1885. Map showing wooded and prairie districts, WILLIAMS, G. P., and WOLMAN, M. G. 1984. Downstream effects of
etc., in the region of the vicinity of the Bow and Belly rivers. In dams on alluvial rivers. Geol. Surv. Prof. Pap. (U.S.), No. 1286.
Maps, etc., to accompany rePo& of progress for 1882- 83 - 84.