HP Heater # 3 Top Final

1.
0 Introduction
M/s. Adani apower Private Limited, Mundra, Gujarat. has awarded a Work contract to ASTRON
Certifications India Private Ltd., Chennai to carry out Eddy Current Testing of HP Heater # 3
tubes at Unit # 09, 660 MW Turbine during annual overhaul. The same tubes were
tested. The same was carried out between 19th to 28th NOVEMBER 2018. This is the final report
on the findings.
2.0 Eddy Current Examination Of Condenser Tubes

Testing Principle
The Eddy Current Testing Technique is employed for the detection of surface and sub – surface
defects. The primary magnetic field created by the alternating current flowing through the
inspection coil induces an eddy current on the surface of an electrically conductive test specimen.
This eddy current produces a secondary magnetic field which in turn opposes the primary magnetic
field. This cause a change in the impedance of the inspection coil. The changes in the impedance of
the coil is detected using a software based 4 channel Multi Frequency Eddy Current (MFEC)
Equipment. This impedance change is amplified and filtered to remove unwanted signals. Filtering
is done in two stages - High-Pass (HP) filter and Low-pass (LP) filter. The changes in impedance are
then displayed as Lissajus curves. The various parameters required for the testing were set using a
Standard Calibration Tube with fabricated defects. The defects were machined to meet the
requirements of Standard recommendation - ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section V,
Article 08, Appendix– II-.2017
Since the Eddy Current Testing Technique depends on the local changes and the interruption in
the flow caused by the physical condition of the test specimen and changes in the material
properties, various factors like inspection coil size, basic frequency, shape etc., become very
important and optimization of these factors are most important. The required testing
parameters were optimized during calibration at our lab to focus on detection of local changes in
Astron Certification (India) Private Limited.New No. 1/30 (Old No. 1/7C), Ground Head Office: Astron Group Office # 01 & 03, First Floor,
FloorMugalivakkam Main Road, MugalivakkamChennai - 600125, Tamilnadu, Building # 13, Plot # 16, Mussafah M-44, PO Box: 4582,
India.Tel.: +91 - 44 - 4851 8666astron-india@astrongroup.com Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates.www.astrongroup.com
Eddy current and interruption in the flow of Eddy current due to physical condition of the
HP Heaters # 1 tubes and changes in material properties.
Specimens to be tested were tubes of the HP Heaters # 3. HP Heaters # 3 consisted of a

few thousands of tubes of diameter 16mm and thickness 2.5 mm and madeof stainless steel
material. These were supported by a number of Internal Baffle plates in between two end
sheets. These tubes may have undergone deterioration due to service conditions and by water
chemistry, temperature, flow, and other plant operational parameters. The defects that cause
failure of condenser tubes are pitting, dents, general wall thinning, localized wall loss, cracks and
deposition. Some of these defects are pronounced near tube supports plates. Early detection and
characterization of defects will prevent forced outages of the HP Heater # 3 tubes and helps to plan
proper corrective action.
3.0 Details Of Eddy Current Equipment Employed

Software based Multi-frequency Eddy Current (Ectane 2) Equipment was employed for the
examination of the HP Heater # 1 tubes @ Unit # 09, 660 MW M/s. Adani apower
Private Limited, Mundra, Gujarat. ,. This is an advanced Eddy Current examination system
Manufactured by M/s. Eddyfi Technologies Canada.
3.1 Test Setup
The diagram shows the test set up of Ectane 2 system, which consists of the following
components:
1. Personnel computer with Tubepro Data Acquisition Software
2. Ectane 2 Hardware
3. Encircling type-Differential Probe with 15m long cable.
4. Standard calibration tube with an artificial defects.
Following are some of the salient features of the equipment.
Four simultaneous frequencies and four independent channels were operated as follows:
Channel 1 - is operated in the differential mode to detect pits.
Channel 2 - is the mixer channel to cancel the tube sheet signal.
Channel 3 - is used in absolute mode to detect thickness variations.
Channel 4 - is a flaw discrimination channel. This channel is used to differentiate
real defects from conductive deposits.
Software for data acquisition, data analysis, data storage and report generation.
3.2 Probe Selection
Unit # 09 HP Heater # 3 U tubes has two parts ( Pass “A” & Pass “B” ) The tubes are made of
stainless stell (304) 2.5 mm wall thickness and length about 10000 mm. Eddy current probes with
dia. Of 13mm and 15 m length were selected for carrying out Eddy Current examination of the tubes.
4 . 0 Re f e r e n c e S t a n d a r d Fo l l o w e d
SN Standard Descriptions
1 ASME Sec V 2017 Non Destructive Examinations
2 ASNT SNTC 1A Personnel Qualification and eritiicationof Non Destructive

2018 Testing Personnel
3 ASTM E 316 Definition of terms relating to electromagnetic testing
4 ASTM E 426 Electromagnetic (eddy current) testing of seamless and
welded tubular products austenitic stainless steel and similar
alloys
5 ASTM E 690 In-situ electromagnetic (eddy current) examination of

nonmagnetic heat-exchanger tubes
4 . 1 S t a n d ar d C a l i b r a t i o n T u b e
A standard tube with identical composition of stailess stell (304)material having same
dimensions of condenser tubes of OD of 16 mm and nominal wall thickness of 2.5 mm. The standard
tube with artificial defects were fabricated as follows to meet the requirements of Standard
specification for Eddy Current Examination of Tubular Products – ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel
Code - Section – V, Article 08.
Artificial Defects for Calibration:
Defect a: 1.6mm wide ,20%of WT( 0.5 mm depth ) external circumferential notch.
Defect b: 1.6mm wide ,20%of WT( 0.5 mm depth ) internal circumferential notch.
Defect c: 2mm dia,drilled upto 100%( 2.5 mm depth )of WT ,single wall
Defect d: 2.8mm dia,drilled upto 80%( 2.0 mm depth )of WT ,single wall
Defect e: 2.8mm dia,drilled upto 60%( 1.5 mm depth )of WT ,single wall
Defect f: 4.8mm dia,drilled upto 40%( 1.0 mm depth )of WT ,single wall
Defect g:4.8mm dia,drilled upto 20%( 0.5 mm depth )of WT, Four holes 900 apart, circumfer.
Note: WT= wall thickness
4.2 Equipment Calibration(At Lab):
Calibration was done by setting eddy current parameters i.e., frequency, phase, gain, filters in all the four
channels. Basic frequency selected was based on the type of tube material, tube thickness and
conductivity of the material. Other frequencies were set as per standard criteria of the system. The
phase, gain (AC and DC) values, HP filters, LP filters, X/Y ratio were initially set at optimum values to
get adequate signals and later fine tuned. The probe was manually drawn through the calibration
tube at an optimized speed. The Lissajus curves were carefully scrutinized and the phase, gain and
other parameters were adjusted suitably to give optimum voltage value. The calibration parameters
were recorded for future reference.
4.3 Test Location
The eddy current (Eddyfi Ectane 2) system was placed at Front side of the Unit # 09HP Heater # 3.
All the electrical connections were appropriately made.
4.4 Equipment Calibration(At Field):
The Eddy current parameters that were set at laboratory for calibration were recalled at site and
calibration was verified before starting the testing. After ensuring the optimization of the
parameters, the testing was carried out. Signals from artificial defects, which were introduced in
the standard tube and set up parameters were stored for reference.
4.5 Data Collection
After calibration the selected eddy current probe was made to traverse through the actual HP
Heater # 3 tubes. A few dummy runs were made and proper markings were done with respect to,
tube length, probe speed, etc. Eddy current signals were collected in Lissajus curves while the
probe was being pulled out through the tube.
After balancing, calibration was verified at suitable intervals to maintain same conditions. As per
the customer's requirement about 5219 tubes (total) were tested from all two Passes of the
Unit # 09HP Heater # 3. The eddy current data obtained from the tubes was recorded. The details
of the tested tubes are given in Tables below. The eddy current signals obtained from some of the
tubes from different sections are given in Figures . These are typical results based on the extent of
damage of the tubes.
COLOR CODE USED FOR WALL LOSS
DESCRIPTION SYMBOL
NDD
10-19.9%
20-29.9%
30-39.9%
40-49.9%
50-59.9%
60-69.9%
70-79.9%
80-89.9%
90% THRU WALL
RSTR-PARTIAL
OBS-NO DATA
PLUGGED
TUBE TEST SUMMARY
FLAW FLAW
S. No. ROW Column WALL LOSS % S. No. ROW Column WALL LOSS %
TYPE TYPE
1 1 NDD 26 1 NDD
1 26
2 1 2 NDD 27 1 27 NDD
3 1 3 NDD 28 1 28 NDD
4 1 4 NDD 29 1 29 NDD
5 1 5 NDD 30 1 30 NDD
6 1 6 NDD 31 1 31 NDD
7 1 7 NDD 32 1 32 NDD
8 1 8 NDD 33 1 33 NDD
9 1 9 NDD 34 1 34 NDD
10 1 10 NDD 35 1 35 NDD
11 1 11 NDD 36 1 36 NDD
12 1 12 NDD 37 1 37 NDD
13 1 13 NDD 38 1 38 NDD
14 1 14 NDD 39 1 39 NDD
15 1 15 NDD 40 1 40 NDD
16 1 16 NDD 41 1 41 NDD
17 1 17 NDD 42 1 42 NDD
18 1 18 NDD 43 2 1 NDD
19 1 19 NDD 44 2 2 NDD
20 1 20 NDD 45 2 3 NDD
21 1 21 NDD 46 2 4 NDD
22 1 22 NDD 47 2 5 NDD
23 1 23 NDD 48 2 6 NDD
24 1 24 NDD 49 2 7 NDD
25 1 25 NDD 50 2 8 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
9 NDD 76 2 34 NDD
51 2
2 10 NDD 77 2 35 NDD
52
2 11 NDD 78 2 36 NDD
53
2 12 NDD 79 2 37 NDD
54
2 13 NDD 80 2 38 NDD
55
2 14 NDD 81 2 39 NDD
56
2 15 NDD 82 2 40 NDD
57
2 16 NDD 83 2 41 NDD
58
2 17 NDD 84 2 42 NDD
59
2 18 NDD 85 3 1 NDD
60
2 19 NDD 86 3 2 NDD
61
2 20 NDD 87 3 3 NDD
62
2 21 NDD 88 3 4 NDD
63
2 22 NDD 89 3 5 20-29.9 %
64
2 23 NDD 90 3 6 NDD
65
2 24 NDD 91 3 7 NDD
66
2 25 NDD 92 3 8 NDD
67
2 NDD 93 3 9 NDD
68 26
69 2 27 NDD 94 3 10 NDD
70 2 28 NDD 95 3 11 NDD
71 2 29 NDD 96 3 NDD
12
72 2 30 NDD 97 3 13 NDD
73 2 31 NDD 98 3 14 NDD
74 2 32 NDD 99 3 15 NDD
75 2 33 NDD 100 3 16 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
101 3 17 NDD 126 3 42 NDD
102 3 18 NDD 127 3 43 NDD
103 3 19 NDD 128 3 44 NDD
104 3 20 NDD 129 3 45 NDD
105 3 21 NDD 130 3 46 NDD
106 3 22 NDD 131 4 1 NDD
107 3 23 NDD 132 4 2 NDD

108 3 24 NDD 133 4 3 NDD
109 3 25 NDD 134 4 4 NDD
110 3 26 NDD 135 4 5 NDD
111 3 27 NDD 136 4 6 NDD
112 3 28 DENT DENT 137 4 7 NDD
113 3 29 NDD 138 4 8 NDD
114 3 30 NDD 139 4 9 NDD
115 3 31 NDD 140 4 10 NDD
116 3 32 NDD 141 4 11 NDD

117 3 33 NDD 142 4 12 NDD
118 3 34 NDD 143 4 13 NDD

119 3 35 NDD 144 4 14 NDD
120 3 NDD 145 4 15 NDD

36
121 3 37 NDD 146 4 16 NDD
122 3 38 NDD 147 4 17 NDD

123 3 39 NDD 148 4 18 NDD
124 3 40 NDD 149 4 19 NDD
125 3 41 NDD 150 4 20 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
151 4 21 NDD 176 5 NDD
1
152 4 22 NDD 177 5 2 NDD
153 4 23 NDD 178 5 3 NDD
154 4 24 NDD 179 5 4 NDD
155 4 25 NDD 180 5 5 NDD
156 4 26 NDD 181 5 6 NDD
157 4 27 NDD 182 5 7 20-29.9 %

158 4 28 NDD 183 5 8 NDD
159 4 29 NDD 184 5 9 NDD
160 4 30 NDD 185 5 10 NDD
161 4 31 NDD 186 5 11 NDD
162 4 32 NDD 187 5 12 NDD
163 4 33 NDD 188 5 13 NDD
164 4 34 NDD 189 5 14 NDD
165 4 35 NDD 190 5 15 NDD
166 4 36 NDD 191 5 16 NDD

167 4 37 NDD 192 5 17 NDD
168 4 38 NDD 193 5 18 NDD

169 4 39 NDD 194 5 19 NDD
170 4 40 NDD 195 5 20 NDD

171 4 41 NDD 196 5 21 NDD
172 4 42 NDD 197 5 22 NDD

173 4 43 NDD 198 5 23 NDD
174 4 44 NDD 199 5 24 NDD
175 4 45 NDD 200 5 25 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
201 5 26 NDD 226 6 5 NDD
202 5 27 NDD 227 6 6 NDD
203 5 28 NDD 228 6 7 NDD
204 5 29 NDD 229 6 8 NDD
205 5 30 NDD 230 6 9 NDD
206 5 31 NDD 231 6 10 NDD
207 5 32 NDD 232 6 11 NDD
208 5 33 NDD 233 6 12 NDD
209 5 34 NDD 234 6 13 NDD
210 5 35 NDD 235 6 14 NDD
211 5 36 NDD 236 6 15 NDD
212 5 37 NDD 237 6 16 NDD
213 5 38 NDD 238 6 17 NDD
214 5 39 NDD 239 6 18 NDD
215 5 40 NDD 240 6 19 NDD
216 5 41 NDD 241 6 20 NDD
217 5 42 NDD 242 6 21 NDD
218 5 43 NDD 243 6 22 NDD
219 5 44 NDD 244 6 23 NDD
220 5 45 NDD 245 6 24 NDD
221 5 46 NDD 246 6 25 NDD
222 6 NDD 247 6 26 NDD
1
223 6 2 NDD 248 6 27 NDD
224 6 3 NDD 249 6 28 NDD
225 6 4 NDD 250 6 29 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
251 6 30 NDD 276 7 10 NDD
252 6 31 NDD 277 7 11 NDD
253 6 32 NDD 278 7 12 NDD
254 6 33 NDD 279 7 13 NDD
255 6 34 NDD 280 7 14 NDD
256 6 35 NDD 281 7 15 NDD
257 6 36 NDD 282 7 16 NDD
258 6 37 NDD 283 7 17 NDD
259 6 38 NDD 284 7 18 NDD
260 6 39 NDD 285 7 19 NDD
261 6 40 NDD 286 7 20 NDD
262 6 41 NDD 287 7 21 NDD
263 6 42 NDD 288 7 22 NDD
264 6 43 NDD 289 7 23 NDD
265 6 44 NDD 290 7 24 NDD
266 6 45 NDD 291 7 25 NDD
267 7 1 NDD 292 7 26 NDD
268 7 2 NDD 293 7 27 NDD
269 7 3 NDD 294 7 28 NDD
270 7 4 NDD 295 7 29 NDD
271 7 5 NDD 296 7 30 NDD
272 7 6 NDD 297 7 31 NDD
273 7 7 NDD 298 7 32 NDD
274 7 8 NDD 299 7 33 NDD
275 7 9 NDD 300 7 34 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
301 7 35 NDD 326 8 14 NDD
302 7 36 NDD 327 8 15 NDD
303 7 37 NDD 328 8 16 NDD
304 7 38 NDD 329 8 17 NDD
305 7 39 NDD 330 8 18 NDD
306 7 40 NDD 331 8 19 NDD
307 7 41 NDD 332 8 20 NDD
308 7 42 NDD 333 8 21 NDD
309 7 43 NDD 334 8 22 NDD
310 7 44 NDD 335 8 23 NDD
311 7 45 NDD 336 8 24 NDD
312 7 46 NDD 337 8 25 NDD
313 8 1 NDD .338 8 26 NDD
314 8 2 NDD 339 8 27 NDD
315 8 3 NDD 340 8 28 NDD
316 8 4 NDD 341 8 29 NDD
317 8 5 NDD 342 8 30 NDD
318 8 6 NDD 343 8 31 NDD
319 8 7 NDD 344 8 32 NDD
320 8 8 NDD 345 8 33 NDD
321 8 9 NDD 346 8 34 NDD
322 8 10 NDD 347 8 35 NDD
323 8 11 NDD 348 8 36 NDD
324 8 12 NDD 349 8 37 NDD
325 8 13 NDD 350 8 38 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
351 8 39 NDD 376 9 14 NDD
352 8 40 NDD 377 9 15 NDD
353 8 41 NDD 378 9 16 NDD
354 8 42 NDD 379 9 17 NDD
355 8 43 NDD 380 9 18 NDD
356 8 39 NDD 381 9 19 NDD
357 8 40 NDD 382 9 20 NDD

358 8 41 NDD 383 9 21 NDD
359 8 42 NDD 384 9 22 NDD
360 8 43 NDD 385 9 23 NDD
361 8 44 NDD 386 9 24 NDD
362 8 45 NDD 387 9 25 NDD
363 9 1 NDD 388 9 26 NDD
364 9 2 NDD 389 9 27 NDD
365 9 3 NDD 390 9 28 NDD
366 9 4 NDD 391 9 29 NDD

367 9 5 NDD 392 9 30 NDD
368 9 6 NDD 393 9 31 NDD

369 9 7 NDD 394 9 32 NDD
370 9 8 NDD 395 9 33 NDD

371 9 9 NDD 396 9 34 NDD
372 9 10 NDD 397 9 35 NDD

373 9 11 NDD 398 9 36 NDD
374 9 12 NDD 399 9 37 NDD
375 9 13 NDD 400 9 38 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
401 9 39 NDD 426 10 18 NDD
402 9 40 NDD 427 10 19 NDD
403 9 41 NDD 428 10 20 NDD
404 9 42 NDD 429 10 21 NDD
405 9 43 NDD 430 10 22 NDD
406 9 44 NDD 431 10 23 NDD
407 9 45 NDD 432 10 24 NDD
408 9 46 NDD 433 10 25 NDD
409 10 1 NDD 434 10 26 NDD
410 10 2 NDD 435 10 27 NDD
411 10 3 NDD 436 10 28 NDD
412 10 4 NDD 437 10 29 NDD
413 10 5 NDD 438 10 30 NDD
414 10 6 NDD 439 10 31 NDD
415 10 7 NDD 440 10 32 NDD
416 10 8 NDD 441 10 33 NDD
417 10 9 NDD 442 10 34 NDD
418 10 10 NDD 443 10 35 NDD
419 10 11 NDD 444 10 36 NDD
420 10 12 NDD 445 10 37 NDD
421 10 13 NDD 446 10 38 NDD
422 10 14 NDD 447 10 39 NDD
423 10 15 NDD 448 10 40 NDD
424 10 16 NDD 449 10 41 NDD
425 10 17 NDD 450 10 42 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
451 10 43 NDD 476 11 23 NDD
452 10 44 NDD 477 11 24 NDD
453 10 45 NDD 478 11 25 NDD
454 11 1 NDD 479 11 26 NDD
455 11 2 NDD 480 11 27 NDD
456 11 3 NDD 481 11 28 NDD
457 11 4 NDD 482 11 29 NDD

458 11 5 NDD 483 11 30 NDD
459 11 6 NDD 484 11 31 NDD
460 11 7 NDD 485 11 32 NDD
461 11 8 NDD 486 11 33 NDD
462 11 9 NDD 487 11 34 NDD
463 11 10 NDD 488 11 35 NDD
464 11 11 NDD 489 11 36 NDD
465 11 12 NDD 490 11 37 NDD
466 11 13 NDD 491 11 38 NDD

467 11 14 NDD 492 11 39 NDD
468 11 15 NDD 493 11 40 NDD

469 11 16 NDD 494 11 41 NDD
470 11 17 NDD 495 11 42 NDD

471 11 18 NDD 496 11 43 NDD
472 11 19 NDD 497 11 44 NDD

473 11 20 NDD 498 11 45 NDD
474 11 21 NDD 499 11 46 NDD
475 11 22 NDD 500 12 1 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
501 12 2 NDD 526 12 27 NDD
502 12 3 NDD 527 12 28 NDD
503 12 4 NDD 528 12 29 NDD
504 12 5 NDD 529 12 30 NDD
505 12 6 NDD 530 12 31 NDD
506 12 7 NDD 531 12 32 NDD
507 12 8 NDD 532 12 33 NDD
508 12 9 NDD 533 12 34 NDD
509 12 10 NDD 534 12 35 NDD
510 12 11 NDD 535 12 36 NDD
511 12 12 NDD 536 12 37 NDD
512 12 13 NDD 537 12 38 NDD
513 12 14 NDD 538 12 39 NDD
514 12 15 NDD 539 12 40 NDD
515 12 16 NDD 540 12 41 NDD
516 12 17 NDD 541 12 42 NDD
517 12 18 NDD 542 12 43 NDD
518 12 19 NDD 543 12 44 NDD
519 12 20 NDD 544 12 45 NDD
520 12 21 NDD 545 13 1 NDD
521 12 22 NDD 546 13 2 NDD
522 12 23 NDD 547 13 3 NDD
523 12 24 NDD 548 13 4 NDD
524 12 25 NDD 549 13 5 NDD
525 12 26 NDD 550 13 6 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
551 13 6 NDD 576 13 31 NDD
552 13 7 NDD 577 13 32 NDD
553 13 8 NDD 578 13 33 NDD
554 13 9 NDD 579 13 34 NDD
555 13 10 NDD 580 13 35 NDD
556 13 11 NDD 581 13 36 NDD
557 13 12 NDD 582 13 37 NDD

558 13 13 NDD 583 13 38 NDD
559 13 14 NDD 584 13 39 NDD
560 13 15 NDD 585 13 40 NDD
561 13 16 NDD 586 13 41 NDD
562 13 17 NDD 587 13 42 NDD
563 13 18 NDD 588 13 43 NDD
564 13 19 NDD 589 13 44 NDD
565 13 20 NDD 590 13 45 NDD
566 13 21 NDD 591 13 46 NDD

567 13 22 NDD 592 14 1 NDD
568 13 23 NDD 593 14 2 NDD

569 13 24 NDD 594 14 3 NDD
570 13 25 NDD 595 14 4 NDD

571 13 26 NDD 596 14 5 NDD
572 13 27 NDD 597 14 6 NDD

573 13 28 NDD 598 14 7 NDD
574 13 29 NDD 599 14 8 NDD
575 13 30 NDD 600 14 9 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
601 14 10 NDD 626 14 35 NDD
602 14 11 NDD 627 14 36 NDD
603 14 12 NDD 628 14 37 NDD
604 14 13 NDD 629 14 38 NDD
605 14 14 NDD 630 14 39 NDD
606 14 15 NDD 631 14 40 NDD
607 14 16 NDD 632 14 41 NDD

608 14 17 NDD 633 14 42 NDD
609 14 18 NDD 634 14 43 NDD
610 14 19 NDD 635 14 44 NDD
611 14 20 NDD 636 14 45 NDD
612 14 21 NDD 637 15 1 NDD
613 14 22 NDD 638 15 2 NDD
614 14 23 NDD 639 15 3 NDD
615 14 24 NDD 640 15 4 NDD
616 14 25 NDD 641 15 5 NDD

617 14 26 NDD 642 15 6 NDD
618 14 27 NDD 643 15 7 NDD

619 14 28 NDD 644 15 8 NDD
620 14 29 NDD 645 15 9 NDD

621 14 30 NDD 646 15 10 NDD
622 14 31 NDD 647 15 11 NDD

623 14 32 NDD 648 15 12 NDD
624 14 33 NDD 649 15 13 NDD
625 14 34 NDD 650 15 14 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
651 15 15 NDD 676 15 40 NDD
652 15 16 NDD 677 15 41 NDD
653 15 17 NDD 678 15 42 NDD
654 15 18 NDD 679 15 43 NDD
655 15 19 NDD 680 15 44 NDD
656 15 20 NDD 681 16 1 NDD
657 15 21 NDD 682 16 2 NDD

658 15 22 NDD 683 16 3 NDD
659 15 23 NDD 684 16 4 NDD
660 15 24 NDD 685 16 5 NDD
661 15 25 NDD 686 16 6 NDD
662 15 26 NDD 687 16 7 NDD
663 15 27 NDD 688 16 8 NDD
664 15 28 NDD 689 16 9 NDD
665 15 29 NDD 690 16 10 NDD
666 15 30 NDD 691 16 11 NDD

667 15 31 NDD 692 16 12 NDD
668 15 32 NDD 693 16 13 NDD

669 15 33 NDD 694 16 14 NDD
670 15 34 NDD 695 16 15 NDD

671 15 35 NDD 696 16 16 NDD
672 15 36 NDD 697 16 17 NDD

673 15 37 NDD 698 16 18 NDD
674 15 38 NDD 699 16 19 NDD
675 15 39 NDD 700 16 20 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
701 16 21 NDD 726 17 1 NDD
702 16 22 NDD 727 17 2 NDD
703 16 23 NDD 728 17 3 NDD
704 16 24 NDD 729 17 4 NDD
705 16 25 NDD 730 17 5 NDD
706 16 26 NDD 731 17 6 NDD
707 16 27 NDD 732 17 7 NDD

708 16 28 NDD 733 17 8 NDD
709 16 29 NDD 734 17 9 NDD
710 16 30 NDD 735 17 10 NDD
711 16 31 NDD 736 17 11 NDD
712 16 32 NDD 737 17 12 NDD
713 16 33 NDD 738 17 13 NDD
714 16 34 NDD 739 17 14 NDD
715 16 35 NDD 740 17 15 NDD
716 16 36 NDD 741 17 16 NDD

717 16 37 NDD 742 17 17 NDD
718 16 38 NDD 743 17 18 NDD

719 16 39 NDD 744 17 19 NDD
720 16 40 NDD 745 17 20 NDD

721 16 41 NDD 746 17 21 NDD
722 16 42 NDD 747 17 22 NDD

723 16 43 NDD 748 17 23 NDD
724 16 44 NDD 749 17 24 NDD
725 16 45 NDD 750 17 25 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
751 17 26 NDD 776 18 7 NDD
752 17 27 NDD 777 18 8 NDD
753 17 28 NDD 778 18 9 NDD
754 17 29 NDD 779 18 10 NDD
755 17 30 DENT DENT 780 18 11 NDD
756 17 31 NDD 781 18 12 NDD
757 17 32 NDD 782 18 13 NDD

758 17 33 NDD 783 18 14 NDD
759 17 34 NDD 784 18 15 NDD
760 17 35 NDD 785 18 16 NDD
761 17 36 NDD 786 18 17 NDD
762 17 37 NDD 787 18 18 NDD
763 17 38 NDD 788 18 19 NDD
764 17 39 NDD 789 18 20 NDD
765 17 40 NDD 790 18 21 NDD
766 17 41 NDD 791 18 22 NDD

767 17 42 NDD 792 18 23 NDD
768 17 43 NDD 793 18 24 NDD

769 17 44 NDD 794 18 25 NDD
770 18 1 NDD 795 18 26 NDD

771 18 2 NDD 796 18 27 NDD
772 18 3 NDD 797 18 28 NDD

773 18 4 NDD 798 18 29 NDD
774 18 5 NDD 799 18 30 NDD
775 18 6 NDD 800 18 31 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
801 18 36 NDD 826 19 16 NDD
802 18 37 NDD 827 19 17 NDD
803 18 38 NDD 828 19 18 NDD
804 18 39 NDD 829 19 19 NDD
805 18 40 NDD 830 19 20 NDD
806 18 41 NDD 831 19 21 NDD
807 18 42 NDD 832 19 22 NDD
808 18 43 NDD 833 19 23 NDD
809 18 44 NDD 834 19 24 NDD
810 18 45 NDD 835 19 25 NDD
811 19 1 NDD 836 19 26 NDD
812 19 2 NDD 837 19 27 NDD
813 19 3 NDD 838 19 28 NDD
814 19 4 NDD 839 19 29 NDD
815 19 5 NDD 840 19 30 NDD
816 19 6 NDD 841 19 31 NDD
817 19 7 NDD 842 19 32 NDD
818 19 8 NDD 843 19 33 NDD
819 19 9 NDD 844 19 34 NDD
820 19 10 NDD 845 19 35 NDD
821 19 11 NDD 846 19 36 NDD
822 19 12 NDD 847 19 37 NDD

823 19 13 NDD 848 19 38 NDD
824 19 14 NDD 849 19 39 NDD
825 19 15 NDD 850 19 40 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
19 41 NDD 20 22 NDD
851 876
852 19 42 NDD 877 20 23 NDD
853 19 43 NDD 878 20 24 NDD
854 19 44 NDD 879 20 25 NDD
855 20 1 NDD 880 20 26 NDD
856 20 2 NDD 881 20 27 NDD
857 20 3 NDD 882 20 28 NDD

858 20 4 NDD 883 20 29 NDD
859 20 5 NDD 884 20 30 NDD
860 20 6 NDD 885 20 31 NDD
861 20 7 NDD 886 20 32 NDD

862 20 8 NDD 887 20 33 NDD
863 20 9 NDD 888 20 34 NDD
864 20 10 NDD 889 20 35 NDD

865 20 11 20-29.9 % 890 20 36 NDD
866 20 12 NDD 891 20 37 NDD
867 20 13 NDD 892 20 38 NDD
868 20 14 NDD 893 20 39 NDD
869 20 15 NDD 894 20 40 NDD
870 20 16 NDD 895 20 41 NDD
871 20 17 NDD 896 20 42 NDD
872 20 18 NDD 897 20 43 NDD

873 20 19 NDD 898 20 44 NDD
874 20 20 NDD 899 20 45 NDD
875 20 21 NDD 900 21 1 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
21 2 NDD 21 27 NDD
901 926
902 21 3 NDD 927 21 28 NDD
903 21 4 NDD 928 21 29 NDD
904 21 5 NDD 929 21 30 NDD
905 21 6 NDD 930 21 31 NDD
906 21 7 NDD 931 21 32 NDD
907 21 8 NDD 932 21 33 NDD

908 21 9 NDD 933 21 34 NDD
909 21 10 NDD 934 21 35 NDD
910 21 11 NDD 935 21 36 NDD
911 21 12 NDD 936 21 37 NDD
912 21 13 NDD 937 21 38 NDD
913 21 14 NDD 938 21 39 NDD
914 21 15 NDD 939 21 40 NDD
915 21 16 NDD 940 21 41 NDD
916 21 17 NDD 941 21 42 NDD

917 21 18 NDD 942 21 43 NDD
918 21 19 NDD 943 21 44 NDD

919 21 20 NDD 944 22 1 NDD
920 21 21 NDD 945 22 2 NDD

921 21 22 NDD 946 22 3 NDD
922 21 23 NDD 947 22 4 NDD

923 21 24 NDD 948 22 5 NDD
924 21 25 NDD 949 22 6 NDD
925 21 26 NDD 950 22 7 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
22 8 NDD 22 33 NDD
951 976
952 22 9 NDD 977 22 34 NDD
953 22 10 NDD 978 22 35 NDD
954 22 11 NDD 979 22 36 NDD
955 22 12 NDD 980 22 37 NDD
956 22 13 NDD 981 22 38 NDD
957 22 14 NDD 982 22 39 NDD

958 22 15 NDD 983 22 40 NDD
959 22 16 NDD 984 22 41 NDD
960 22 17 NDD 985 22 42 NDD
961 22 18 NDD 986 22 43 NDD
962 22 19 NDD 987 23 1 NDD
963 22 20 NDD 988 23 2 NDD
964 22 21 NDD 989 23 3 NDD
965 22 22 NDD 990 23 4 NDD
966 22 23 NDD 991 23 5 NDD

967 22 24 NDD 992 23 6 NDD
968 22 25 NDD 993 23 7 NDD

969 22 26 NDD 994 23 8 NDD
970 22 27 NDD 995 23 9 NDD

971 22 28 NDD 996 23 10 NDD
972 22 29 NDD 997 23 11 NDD

973 22 30 NDD 998 23 12 NDD
974 22 31 NDD 999 23 13 NDD
975 22 32 NDD 1000 23 14 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
23 15 NDD 23 40 NDD
1001 1026
1002 23 16 NDD 1027 23 41 NDD
1003 23 17 NDD 1028 23 42 NDD
1004 23 18 NDD 1029 23 43 NDD
1005 23 19 NDD 1030 23 44 NDD
1006 23 20 NDD 1031 24 1 NDD
1007 23 21 NDD 1032 24 2 NDD

1008 23 22 NDD 1033 24 3 NDD
1009 23 23 NDD 1034 24 4 NDD
1010 23 24 NDD 1035 24 5 NDD
1011 23 25 NDD 1036 24 6 NDD
1012 23 26 NDD 1037 24 7 NDD
1013 23 27 NDD 1038 24 8 NDD
1014 23 28 NDD 1039 24 9 NDD
1015 23 29 NDD 1040 24 10 NDD
1016 23 30 NDD 1041 24 11 NDD

1017 23 31 NDD 1042 24 12 NDD
1018 23 32 NDD 1043 24 13 NDD

1019 23 33 NDD 1044 24 14 NDD
1020 23 34 NDD 1045 24 15 NDD

1021 23 35 NDD 1046 24 16 NDD
1022 23 36 NDD 1047 24 17 NDD

1023 23 37 NDD 1048 24 18 NDD
1024 23 38 NDD 1049 24 19 NDD
1025 23 39 NDD 1050 24 20 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
24 21 NDD 25 2 NDD
1051 1076
1052 24 22 NDD 1077 25 3 NDD
1053 24 23 NDD 1078 25 4 NDD
1054 24 24 NDD 1079 25 5 NDD
1055 24 25 NDD 1080 25 6 NDD
1056 24 26 NDD 1081 25 7 NDD
1057 24 27 NDD 1082 25 8 NDD

1058 24 28 NDD 1083 25 9 NDD
1059 24 29 NDD 1084 25 10 NDD
1060 24 30 NDD 1085 25 11 NDD
1061 24 31 NDD 1086 25 12 NDD
1062 24 32 NDD 1087 25 13 NDD
1063 24 33 NDD 1088 25 14 NDD
1064 24 34 NDD 1089 25 15 NDD
1065 24 35 NDD 1090 25 16 NDD
1066 24 36 NDD 1091 25 17 NDD

1067 24 37 NDD 1092 25 18 NDD
1068 24 38 NDD 1093 25 19 NDD

1069 24 39 NDD 1094 25 20 NDD
1070 24 40 NDD 1095 25 21 NDD

1071 24 41 NDD 1096 25 22 NDD
1072 24 42 NDD 1097 25 23 NDD

1073 24 43 NDD 1098 25 24 NDD
1074 24 44 NDD 1099 25 25 NDD
1075 25 1 NDD 1100 25 26 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
25 27 NDD 26 8 NDD
1101 1126
1102 25 28 NDD 1127 26 9 NDD
1103 25 29 NDD 1128 26 10 NDD
1104 25 30 NDD 1129 26 11 NDD
1105 25 31 NDD 1130 26 12 NDD
1106 25 32 NDD 1131 25 13 NDD
1107 25 33 NDD 1132 25 14 NDD
1108 25 34 NDD 1133 25 15 NDD
1109 25 35 NDD 1134 25 16 NDD
1110 25 36 NDD 1135 25 17 NDD
1111 25 37 NDD 1136 25 18 NDD
1112 25 38 NDD 1137 26 19 NDD
1113 25 39 NDD 1138 26 20 NDD
1114 25 40 NDD 1139 26 21 NDD
1115 25 41 NDD 1140 26 22 NDD
1116 25 42 NDD 1141 26 23 NDD
1117 25 43 NDD 1142 26 24 NDD
1118 25 44 NDD 1143 26 25 NDD
1119 26 1 NDD 1144 26 26 NDD
1120 26 2 NDD 1145 26 27 NDD
1121 26 3 NDD 1146 26 28 NDD
1122 26 4 NDD 1147 26 29 NDD
1123 26 5 NDD 1148 26 30 NDD
1124 26 6 NDD 1149 26 31 NDD
1125 26 7 NDD 1150 26 32 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
26 33 NDD 27 14 NDD
1151 1176
1152 26 34 NDD 1177 27 15 NDD
1153 26 35 NDD 1178 27 16 NDD
1154 26 36 NDD 1179 27 17 NDD
1155 26 37 NDD 1180 27 18 NDD
1156 26 38 NDD 1181 27 19 NDD
1157 26 39 NDD 1182 27 20 NDD
1158 26 40 NDD 1183 27 21 NDD
1159 26 41 NDD 1184 27 22 NDD
1160 26 42 NDD 1185 27 23 NDD
1161 26 43 NDD 1186 27 24 NDD
1162 26 44 NDD 1187 27 25 NDD
1163 27 1 NDD 1188 27 26 NDD
1164 27 2 NDD 1189 27 27 NDD
1165 27 3 NDD 1190 27 28 NDD
1166 27 4 NDD 1191 27 29 NDD
1167 27 5 NDD 1192 27 30 NDD
1168 27 6 NDD 1193 27 31 NDD
1169 27 7 NDD 1194 27 32 NDD
1170 27 8 NDD 1195 27 33 NDD
1171 27 9 NDD 1196 27 34 NDD
1172 27 10 NDD 1197 27 35 NDD
1173 27 11 NDD 1198 27 36 NDD
1174 27 12 NDD 1199 27 37 NDD
1175 27 13 NDD 1200 27 38 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
27 39 NDD 28 20 NDD
1201 1226
1202 27 40 NDD 1227 28 21 NDD
1203 27 41 NDD 1228 28 22 NDD
1204 27 42 NDD 1229 28 23 NDD
1205 27 43 NDD 1230 28 24 NDD
1206 27 44 NDD 1231 28 25 NDD
1207 28 1 NDD 1232 28 26 NDD

1208 28 2 NDD 1233 28 27 NDD
1209 28 3 NDD 1234 28 28 NDD
1210 28 4 NDD 1235 28 29 NDD
1211 28 5 NDD 1236 28 30 NDD
1212 28 6 NDD 1237 28 31 NDD
1213 28 7 NDD 1238 28 32 NDD
1214 28 8 NDD 1239 28 33 NDD
1215 28 9 NDD 1240 28 34 NDD
1216 28 10 NDD 1241 28 35 NDD

1217 28 11 NDD 1242 28 36 NDD
1218 28 12 NDD 1243 28 37 NDD

1219 28 13 NDD 1244 28 38 NDD
1220 28 14 NDD 1245 28 39 NDD

1221 28 15 NDD 1246 28 40 NDD
1222 28 16 NDD 1247 28 41 NDD

1223 28 17 NDD 1248 28 42 NDD
1224 28 18 NDD 1249 28 43 NDD
1225 28 19 NDD 1250 28 45 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
29 1 NDD 29 27 NDD
1251 1276
1252 29 2 NDD 1277 29 28 NDD
1253 29 3 NDD 1278 29 29 NDD
1254 29 4 NDD 1279 29 30 NDD
1255 29 5 NDD 1280 29 31 NDD
1256 29 6 NDD 1281 29 32 NDD
1257 29 7 NDD 1282 29 33 NDD

1258 29 8 NDD 1283 29 34 NDD
1259 29 9 NDD 1284 29 35 NDD
1260 29 10 NDD 1285 29 36 NDD
1261 29 12 NDD 1286 29 37 NDD
1262 29 13 NDD 1287 29 38 NDD
1263 29 14 NDD 1288 29 39 NDD
1264 29 15 NDD 1289 29 40 NDD
1265 29 16 NDD 1290 29 41 NDD
1266 29 17 NDD 1291 29 42 NDD

1267 29 18 NDD 1292 29 43 NDD
1268 29 19 NDD 1293 29 44 NDD

1269 29 20 NDD 1294 30 1 NDD
1270 29 21 NDD 1295 30 2 NDD

1271 29 22 NDD 1296 30 3 NDD
1272 29 23 NDD 1297 30 4 NDD

1273 29 24 NDD 1298 30 5 NDD
1274 29 25 NDD 1299 30 6 NDD
1275 29 26 NDD 1300 30 7 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
30 8 NDD 30 34 NDD
1301 1326
1302 30 9 NDD 1327 30 35 NDD
1303 30 10 NDD 1328 30 36 NDD
1304 30 12 NDD 1329 30 37 NDD
1305 30 13 NDD 1330 30 38 NDD
1306 30 14 NDD 1331 30 39 NDD
1307 30 15 NDD 1332 30 40 NDD

1308 30 16 NDD 1333 30 41 NDD
1309 30 17 NDD 1334 30 42 NDD
1310 30 18 NDD 1335 30 43 NDD
1311 30 19 NDD 1336 30 44 NDD
1312 30 20 NDD 1337 30 45 NDD
1313 30 21 NDD 1338 31 1 NDD
1314 30 22 NDD 1339 31 2 NDD
1315 30 23 NDD 1340 31 3 NDD
1316 30 24 NDD 1341 31 4 NDD

1317 30 25 NDD 1342 31 5 NDD
1318 30 36 NDD 1343 31 6 NDD

1319 30 27 NDD 1344 31 7 NDD
1320 30 28 NDD 1345 31 8 NDD

1321 30 29 NDD 1346 31 9 NDD
1322 30 30 NDD 1347 31 10 NDD

1323 30 31 NDD 1348 31 11 NDD
1324 30 32 NDD 1349 31 12 NDD
1325 30 33 NDD 1350 31 13 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
31 14 NDD 31 39 NDD
1351 1376
1352 31 15 NDD 1377 31 40 NDD
1353 31 16 NDD 1378 31 41 NDD
1354 31 17 NDD 1379 31 42 NDD
1355 31 18 NDD 1380 31 43 NDD
1356 31 19 NDD 1381 31 44 NDD
1357 31 20 NDD 1382 32 1 NDD

1358 31 21 NDD 1383 32 2 NDD
1359 31 22 NDD 1384 32 3 NDD
1360 31 23 NDD 1385 32 4 NDD
1361 31 24 NDD 1386 32 5 NDD
1362 31 25 NDD 1387 32 6 NDD
1363 31 26 NDD 1388 32 7 NDD
1364 31 27 NDD 1389 32 8 NDD
1365 31 28 NDD 1390 32 9 NDD
1366 31 29 NDD 1391 32 10 NDD

1367 31 30 NDD 1392 32 11 NDD
1368 31 31 NDD 1393 32 12 NDD

1369 31 32 NDD 1394 32 13 NDD
1370 31 33 NDD 1395 32 14 NDD

1371 31 34 NDD 1396 32 15 NDD
1372 31 35 NDD 1397 32 16 NDD

1373 31 36 NDD 1398 32 17 NDD
1374 31 37 NDD 1399 32 18 NDD
1375 31 38 NDD 1400 32 19 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
32 20 NDD 33 2 NDD
1401 1426
1402 32 21 NDD 1427 33 3 NDD
1403 32 22 NDD 1428 33 4 NDD
1404 32 23 NDD 1429 33 5 NDD
1405 32 24 NDD 1430 33 6 NDD
1406 32 25 NDD 1431 33 7 NDD
1407 32 26 NDD 1432 33 8 NDD

1408 32 27 NDD 1433 33 9 NDD
1409 32 28 NDD 1434 33 10 NDD
1410 32 29 NDD 1435 33 11 NDD
1411 32 30 NDD 1436 33 12 NDD
1412 32 31 NDD 1437 33 13 NDD
1413 32 32 NDD 1438 33 14 NDD
1414 32 33 NDD 1439 33 15 NDD
1415 32 34 NDD 1440 33 16 NDD
1416 32 35 NDD 1441 33 17 NDD

1417 32 36 NDD 1442 33 18 NDD
1418 32 37 NDD 1443 33 19 NDD

1419 32 38 NDD 1444 33 20 NDD
1420 32 39 NDD 1445 33 21 NDD

1421 32 40 NDD 1446 33 22 NDD
1422 32 41 NDD 1447 33 23 NDD

1423 32 42 NDD 1448 33 24 NDD
1424 32 43 NDD 1449 33 25 NDD
1425 33 1 NDD 1450 33 26 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
33 27 NDD 34 8 NDD
1451 1476
1452 33 28 NDD 1477 34 9 NDD
1453 33 29 NDD 1478 34 10 NDD
1454 33 30 NDD 1479 34 11 NDD
1455 33 31 NDD 1480 34 12 NDD
1456 33 32 NDD 1481 34 13 NDD
1457 33 33 NDD 1482 34 14 NDD

1458 33 34 NDD 1483 34 15 NDD
1459 33 35 NDD 1484 34 16 NDD
1460 33 36 NDD 1485 34 17 NDD
1461 33 37 NDD 1486 34 18 NDD
1462 33 38 NDD 1487 34 19 NDD
1463 33 39 NDD 1488 34 20 NDD
1464 33 40 NDD 1489 34 21 NDD
1465 33 41 NDD 1490 34 22 NDD
1466 33 42 NDD 1491 34 23 NDD

1467 33 43 NDD 1492 34 24 NDD
1468 33 44 NDD 1493 34 25 NDD

1469 34 1 NDD 1494 34 26 NDD
1470 34 2 NDD 1495 34 27 NDD

1471 34 3 NDD 1496 34 28 NDD
1472 34 4 NDD 1497 34 29 NDD

1473 34 5 NDD 1498 34 30 NDD
1474 34 6 NDD 1499 34 31 NDD
1475 34 7 NDD 1500 34 32 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
34 33 NDD 35 15 NDD
1501 1526
1502 34 34 NDD 1527 35 16 NDD
1503 34 35 NDD 1528 35 17 NDD
1504 34 36 NDD 1529 35 18 NDD
1505 34 37 NDD 1530 35 19 NDD
1506 34 38 NDD 1531 35 20 NDD
1507 34 39 NDD 1532 35 21 NDD

1508 34 40 NDD 1533 35 22 NDD
1509 34 41 NDD 1534 35 23 NDD
1510 34 42 NDD 1535 35 24 NDD
1511 34 43 NDD 1536 35 25 NDD
1512 35 1 NDD 1537 35 26 NDD
1513 35 2 NDD 1538 35 27 NDD
1514 35 3 NDD 1539 35 28 NDD
1515 35 4 NDD 1540 35 29 NDD
1516 35 5 NDD 1541 35 30 NDD

1517 35 6 NDD 1542 35 31 NDD
1518 35 7 NDD 1543 35 32 NDD

1519 35 8 NDD 1544 35 33 NDD
1520 35 9 NDD 1545 35 34 NDD

1521 35 10 NDD 1546 35 35 NDD
1522 35 11 NDD 1547 35 36 NDD

1523 35 12 NDD 1548 35 37 NDD
1524 35 13 NDD 1549 35 38 NDD
1525 35 14 NDD 1550 35 39 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
35 40 NDD 36 23 NDD
1551 1576
1552 35 41 NDD 1577 36 24 NDD
1553 35 42 NDD 1578 36 25 NDD
1554 36 1 NDD 1579 36 26 NDD
1555 36 2 NDD 1580 36 27 NDD
1556 36 3 NDD 1581 36 28 NDD
1557 36 4 NDD 1582 36 29 NDD

1558 36 5 NDD 1583 36 30 NDD
1559 36 6 NDD 1584 36 31 NDD
1560 36 7 NDD 1585 36 32 NDD
1561 36 8 NDD 1586 36 33 NDD
1562 36 9 NDD 1587 36 34 NDD
1563 36 10 NDD 1588 36 35 NDD
1564 36 11 NDD 1589 36 36 NDD
1565 36 12 NDD 1590 36 37 NDD
1566 36 13 NDD 1591 36 38 NDD

1567 36 14 NDD 1592 36 39 NDD
1568 36 15 NDD 1593 36 40 NDD

1569 36 16 NDD 1594 36 41 NDD
1570 36 17 NDD 1595 36 42 NDD

1571 36 18 NDD 1596 36 43 NDD
1572 36 19 NDD 1597 37 1 NDD

1573 36 20 NDD 1598 37 2 NDD 116
1574 36 21 NDD 1599 37 3 NDD
1575 36 22 NDD 1600 37 4 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
37 5 NDD 37 30 NDD
1601 1626
1602 37 6 NDD 1627 37 31 NDD
1603 37 7 NDD 1628 37 32 NDD
1604 37 8 NDD 1629 37 33 NDD
1605 37 9 NDD 1630 37 34 NDD
1606 37 10 NDD 1631 37 35 NDD
1607 37 11 NDD 1632 37 36 NDD

1608 37 12 NDD 1633 37 37 NDD
1609 37 13 NDD 1634 37 38 NDD
1610 37 14 NDD 1635 37 39 NDD
1611 37 15 NDD 1636 37 40 NDD
1612 37 16 NDD 1637 37 41 NDD
1613 37 17 NDD 1638 37 42 NDD
1614 37 18 NDD 1639 38 1 NDD
1615 37 19 NDD 1640 38 2 NDD
1616 37 20 NDD 1641 38 3 NDD

1617 37 21 NDD 1642 38 4 NDD
1618 37 22 NDD 1643 38 5 NDD

1619 37 23 NDD 1644 38 6 NDD
1620 37 24 NDD 1645 38 7 NDD

1621 37 25 NDD 1646 38 8 NDD
1622 37 26 NDD 1647 38 9 NDD

1623 37 27 NDD 1648 38 10 NDD
1624 37 28 NDD 1649 38 11 NDD

1625 37 29 NDD 1650 38 12 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
38 13 NDD 38 38 NDD
1651 1676
1652 38 14 NDD 1677 38 39 NDD
1653 38 15 NDD 1678 38 40 NDD
1654 38 16 NDD 1679 38 41 NDD
1655 38 17 NDD 1680 39 1 NDD
1656 38 18 NDD 1681 39 2 NDD
1657 38 19 NDD 1682 39 3 NDD

1658 38 20 NDD 1683 39 4 NDD
1659 38 21 NDD 1684 39 5 NDD
1660 38 22 NDD 1685 39 6 NDD
1661 38 23 NDD 1686 39 7 NDD
1662 38 24 NDD 1687 39 8 NDD
1663 38 25 NDD 1688 39 9 NDD
1664 38 26 NDD 1689 39 10 NDD
1665 38 27 NDD 1690 39 11 NDD
1666 38 28 NDD 1691 39 12 NDD

1667 38 29 NDD 1692 39 13 NDD
1668 38 30 NDD 1693 39 14 NDD
1669 38 31 NDD 1694 39 15 NDD
1670 38 32 NDD 1695 39 16 NDD
1671 38 33 NDD 1696 39 17 NDD
1672 38 34 NDD 1697 39 18 NDD
1673 38 35 NDD 1698 39 19 NDD

1674 38 36 NDD 1699 39 20 NDD
1675 38 37 NDD 1700 39 21 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
39 22 NDD 40 5 NDD
1701 1726
1702 39 23 NDD 1727 40 6 NDD
1703 39 24 NDD 1728 40 7 NDD
1704 39 25 NDD 1729 40 8 NDD
1705 39 26 NDD 1730 40 9 NDD
1706 39 27 NDD 1731 40 10 NDD
1707 39 28 NDD 1732 40 11 NDD

1708 39 29 NDD 1733 40 12 NDD
1709 39 30 NDD 1734 40 13 NDD
1710 39 31 NDD 1735 40 14 NDD
1711 39 32 NDD 1736 40 15 NDD
1712 39 33 NDD 1737 40 16 NDD
1713 39 34 NDD 1738 40 17 NDD
1714 39 35 NDD 1739 40 18 NDD
1715 39 36 NDD 1740 40 19 NDD
1716 39 37 NDD 1741 40 20 NDD

1717 39 38 NDD 1742 40 21 NDD
1718 39 39 NDD 1743 40 22 NDD

1719 39 40 NDD 1744 40 23 NDD
1720 39 41 NDD 1745 40 24 NDD

1721 39 42 NDD 1746 40 25 NDD
1722 40 1 NDD 1747 40 26 NDD

1723 40 2 NDD 1748 40 27 NDD
1724 40 3 NDD 1749 40 28 NDD

1725 40 4 NDD 1750 40 29 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
40 30 NDD 41 14 NDD
1751 1776
1752 40 31 NDD 1777 41 15 NDD
1753 40 33 NDD 1778 41 16 NDD
1754 40 33 NDD 1779 41 17 NDD
1755 40 34 NDD 1780 41 18 NDD
1756 40 35 NDD 1781 41 19 NDD
1757 40 36 NDD 1782 41 20 NDD

1758 40 37 NDD 1783 41 21 NDD
1759 40 38 NDD 1784 41 22 NDD
1760 40 39 NDD 1785 41 23 NDD
1761 40 40 NDD 1786 41 24 NDD
1762 40 41 NDD 1787 41 25 NDD
1763 41 1 NDD 1788 41 26 NDD
1764 41 2 NDD 1789 41 27 NDD
1765 41 3 NDD 1790 41 28 NDD
1766 41 4 NDD 1791 41 29 NDD

1767 41 5 NDD 1792 41 30 NDD
1768 41 6 NDD 1793 41 31 NDD

1769 41 7 NDD 1794 41 32 NDD
1770 41 8 NDD 1795 41 33 NDD

1771 41 9 NDD 1796 41 34 NDD
1772 41 10 NDD 1797 41 35 NDD

1773 41 11 NDD 1798 41 36 NDD
1774 41 12 NDD 1799 41 37 NDD

1775 41 13 NDD 1800 41 38 NDD
FLAW FLAW
S. No. ROW Column WALL LOSS % S. 1No. ROW Column WALL LOSS %
TYPE TYPE
41 39 NDD 42 24 NDD
1801 1826
1802 41 40 NDD 1827 42 25 NDD
1803 42 1 NDD 1828 42 26 NDD
1804 42 2 NDD 1829 42 27 NDD
1805 42 3 NDD 1830 42 28 NDD
1806 42 4 NDD 1831 42 29 NDD
1807 42 5 NDD 1832 42 30 NDD

1808 42 6 NDD 1833 42 31 NDD
1809 42 7 NDD 1834 42 33 NDD
1810 42 8 NDD 1835 42 34 NDD
1811 42 9 NDD 1836 42 35 NDD
1812 42 10 NDD 1837 42 36 NDD
1813 42 11 NDD 1838 42 37 NDD
1814 42 12 NDD 1839 42 38 NDD
1815 42 13 NDD 1840 42 39 NDD
1816 42 14 NDD 1841 42 40 NDD

1817 42 15 NDD 1842 42 41 NDD
1818 42 16 NDD 1843 43 1 NDD

1819 42 17 NDD 1844 43 2 NDD
1820 42 18 NDD 1845 43 3 NDD

1821 42 19 NDD 1846 43 4 NDD
1822 42 20 NDD 1847 43 5 NDD

1823 42 21 NDD 1848 43 6 NDD
1824 42 22 NDD 1849 43 7 NDD

1825 42 23 NDD 1850 43 8 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
43 9 NDD 43 34 NDD
1851 1876
1852 43 10 NDD 1877 43 35 NDD
1853 43 11 NDD 1878 43 36 NDD
1854 43 12 NDD 1879 43 37 NDD
1855 43 13 NDD 1880 43 38 NDD
1856 43 14 NDD 1881 43 39 NDD
1857 43 15 NDD 1882 43 40 NDD

1858 43 16 NDD 1883 44 1 NDD
1859 43 17 NDD 1884 44 2 NDD
1860 43 18 NDD 1885 44 3 NDD
1861 43 19 NDD 1886 44 4 NDD
1862 43 20 NDD 1887 44 5 NDD
1863 43 21 NDD 1888 44 6 NDD
1864 43 22 NDD 1889 44 7 NDD
1865 43 23 NDD 1890 44 8 NDD
1866 43 24 NDD 1891 44 9 NDD

1867 43 25 NDD 1892 44 10 NDD
1868 43 26 NDD 1893 44 11 NDD

1869 43 27 NDD 1894 44 12 NDD
1870 43 28 NDD 1895 44 13 NDD

1871 43 29 NDD 1896 44 14 NDD
1872 43 30 NDD 1897 44 15 NDD

1873 43 31 NDD 1898 44 16 NDD
1874 43 32 NDD 1899 44 17 NDD

1875 43 33 NDD 1900 44 18 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
44 19 NDD 45 6 NDD
1901 1926
1902 44 20 NDD 1927 45 7 NDD
1903 44 21 NDD 1928 45 8 NDD
1904 44 22 NDD 1929 45 9 NDD
1905 44 23 NDD 1930 45 10 NDD
1906 44 24 NDD 1931 45 11 NDD
1907 44 25 NDD 1932 45 12 NDD

1908 44 26 NDD 1933 45 13 NDD
1909 44 27 NDD 1934 45 14 NDD
1910 44 28 NDD 1935 45 15 NDD
1911 44 29 NDD 1936 45 16 NDD
1912 44 30 NDD 1937 45 17 NDD
1913 44 31 NDD 1938 45 18 NDD
1914 44 33 NDD 1939 45 19 NDD
1915 44 34 NDD 1940 45 20 NDD
1916 44 35 NDD 1941 45 21 NDD

1917 44 36 NDD 1942 45 22 NDD
1918 44 37 NDD 1943 45 23 NDD

1919 44 38 NDD 1944 45 24 NDD
1920 44 39 NDD 1945 45 25 NDD

1921 45 1 NDD 1946 45 26 NDD
1922 45 2 NDD 1947 45 27 NDD

1923 45 3 NDD 1948 45 28 NDD
1924 45 4 NDD 1949 45 29 NDD

1925 45 5 NDD 1950 45 30 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
45 31 NDD 46 17 NDD
1951 1976
1952 45 33 NDD 1977 46 18 NDD
1953 45 34 NDD 1978 46 19 NDD
1954 45 35 NDD 1979 46 20 NDD
1955 45 36 NDD 1980 46 21 NDD
1956 45 37 NDD 1981 46 22 NDD
1957 45 38 NDD 1982 46 23 NDD
1958 45 39 NDD 1983 46 24 NDD
1959 45 40 NDD 1984 46 25 NDD
1960 46 1 NDD 1985 46 26 NDD
1961 46 2 NDD 1986 46 27 NDD
1962 46 3 NDD 1987 46 27 NDD
1963 46 4 NDD 1988 46 28 NDD
1964 46 5 NDD 1989 46 29 NDD
1965 46 6 NDD 1990 46 30 NDD
1966 46 7 NDD 1991 46 31 NDD
1967 46 8 NDD 1992 46 32 NDD
1968 46 9 NDD 1993 46 33 NDD
1969 46 10 NDD 1994 46 34 NDD
1970 46 11 NDD 1995 46 35 NDD
1971 46 12 NDD 1996 46 36 NDD
1972 46 13 NDD 1997 46 37 NDD
1973 46 14 NDD 1998 46 38 NDD
1974 46 15 NDD 1999 46 39 NDD
1975 46 16 NDD 2000 47 1 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
47 2 NDD 47 27 NDD
2001 2026
2002 47 3 NDD 2027 47 27 NDD
2003 47 4 NDD 2028 47 28 NDD
2004 47 5 NDD 2029 47 29 NDD
2005 47 6 NDD 2030 47 30 NDD
2006 47 7 NDD 2031 47 31 NDD
2007 47 8 NDD 2032 47 32 NDD

2008 47 9 NDD 2033 47 33 NDD
2009 47 10 NDD 2034 47 34 NDD
2010 47 11 NDD 2035 47 35 NDD
2011 47 12 NDD 2036 47 36 NDD

2012 47 13 NDD 2037 47 37 NDD
2013 47 14 NDD 2038 47 38 NDD
2014 47 15 NDD 2039 48 1 NDD

2015 47 16 NDD 2040 48 2 NDD
2016 47 17 NDD 2041 48 3 NDD
2017 47 18 NDD 2042 48 4 NDD
2018 47 19 NDD 2043 48 5 NDD
2019 47 20 NDD 2044 48 6 NDD
2020 47 21 NDD 2045 48 7 NDD
2021 47 22 NDD 2046 48 8 NDD
2022 47 23 NDD 2047 48 9 NDD

2023 47 24 NDD 2048 48 10 NDD
2024 47 25 NDD 2049 48 11 NDD
2025 47 26 NDD 2050 48 12 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
48 13 NDD 49 1 NDD
2051 2076
2052 48 14 NDD 2077 49 2 NDD
2053 48 15 NDD 2078 49 3 NDD
2054 48 16 NDD 2079 49 4 NDD
2055 48 17 NDD 2080 49 5 NDD
2056 48 18 NDD 2081 49 6 NDD
2057 48 19 NDD 2082 49 7 NDD

2058 48 20 NDD 2083 49 8 NDD
2059 48 21 NDD 2084 49 9 NDD
2060 48 22 NDD 2085 49 10 NDD
2061 48 23 NDD 2086 49 11 NDD
2062 48 24 NDD 2087 49 12 NDD
2063 48 25 NDD 2088 49 13 NDD
2064 48 26 NDD 2089 49 14 NDD
2065 48 27 NDD 2090 49 15 NDD
2066 48 28 NDD 2091 49 16 NDD

2067 48 29 NDD 2092 49 17 NDD
2068 48 30 NDD 2093 49 18 NDD

2069 48 31 NDD 2094 49 19 NDD
2070 48 32 NDD 2095 49 20 NDD

2071 48 33 NDD 2096 49 21 NDD
2072 48 34 NDD 2097 49 22 NDD

2073 48 35 NDD 2098 49 22 NDD
2074 48 36 NDD 2099 49 23 NDD

2075 48 37 NDD 2100 49 24 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2101 49 25 NDD 2126 50 12 NDD
2102 49 26 NDD 2127 50 13 NDD
2103 49 27 NDD 2128 50 14 NDD
2104 49 28 NDD 2129 50 15 NDD
2105 49 29 NDD 2130 50 16 NDD
2106 49 30 NDD 2131 50 17 NDD
2107 49 31 NDD 2132 50 18 NDD

2108 49 32 NDD 2133 50 19 NDD
2109 49 33 NDD 2134 50 20 NDD
2110 49 34 NDD 2135 50 21 NDD
2111 49 35 NDD 2136 50 22 NDD
2112 49 36 NDD 2137 50 23 NDD
2113 49 37 NDD 2138 50 24 NDD
2114 49 38 NDD 2139 50 25 NDD
2115 50 1 NDD 2140 50 26 NDD
2116 50 2 NDD 2141 50 27 NDD

2117 50 3 NDD 2142 50 28 NDD
2118 50 4 NDD 2143 50 29 NDD

2119 50 5 NDD 2144 50 30 NDD
2120 50 6 NDD 2145 50 31 NDD

2121 50 7 NDD 2146 50 32 NDD
2122 50 8 NDD 2147 50 33 NDD

2123 50 9 NDD 2148 50 34 NDD
2124 50 10 NDD 2149 50 35 NDD

2125 50 11 NDD 2150 50 36 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2151 50 37 NDD 2176 51 25 NDD
2152 51 1 NDD 2177 51 26 NDD
2153 51 2 NDD 2178 51 27 NDD
2154 51 3 NDD 2179 51 28 NDD
2155 51 4 NDD 2180 51 29 NDD
2156 51 5 NDD 2181 51 30 NDD
2157 51 6 NDD 2182 51 31 NDD

2158 51 7 NDD 2183 51 32 NDD
2159 51 8 NDD 2184 51 33 NDD
2160 51 9 NDD 2185 51 34 NDD
2161 51 10 NDD 2186 51 35 NDD
2162 51 11 NDD 2187 51 36 NDD
2163 51 12 NDD 2188 52 1 NDD
2164 51 13 NDD 2189 52 2 NDD
2165 51 14 NDD 2190 52 3 NDD
2166 51 15 NDD 2191 52 4 NDD

2167 51 16 NDD 2192 52 5 NDD
2168 51 17 NDD 2193 52 6 NDD

2169 51 18 NDD 2194 52 7 NDD
2170 51 19 NDD 2195 52 8 NDD

2171 51 20 NDD 2196 52 9 NDD
2172 51 21 NDD 2197 52 10 NDD

2173 51 22 NDD 2198 52 11 NDD
2174 51 23 NDD 2199 52 12 NDD

2175 51 24 NDD 2200 52 13 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2201 52 14 NDD 2226 53 2 NDD
2202 52 15 NDD 2227 53 3 NDD
2203 52 16 NDD 2228 53 4 NDD
2204 52 17 NDD 2229 53 5 NDD
2205 52 18 NDD 2230 53 6 NDD
2206 52 19 NDD 2231 53 7 NDD
2207 52 20 NDD 2232 53 8 NDD

2208 52 21 NDD 2233 53 9 NDD
2209 52 22 NDD 2234 53 10 NDD
2210 52 23 NDD 2235 53 11 NDD
2211 52 24 NDD 2236 53 12 NDD
2212 52 25 NDD 2237 53 13 NDD
2213 52 26 NDD 2238 53 14 NDD
2214 52 27 NDD 2239 53 15 NDD
2215 52 28 NDD 2240 53 16 NDD
2216 52 29 NDD 2241 53 17 NDD

2217 52 30 NDD 2242 53 18 NDD
2218 52 31 NDD 2243 53 19 NDD

2219 52 32 NDD 2244 53 20 NDD
2220 52 33 NDD 2245 53 21 NDD

2221 52 34 NDD 2246 53 22 NDD
2222 52 35 NDD 2247 53 23 NDD

2223 52 36 NDD 2248 53 24 NDD
2224 52 37 NDD 2249 53 25 NDD

2225 53 1 NDD 2250 53 26 NDD
S. No. ROW Column WALL LOSS % FLAW TYPE S. No. ROW Column WALL LOSS % FLAW TYPE
2251 53 27 NDD 2276 54 16 NDD

2252 53 28 NDD 2277 54 17 NDD
2253 53 29 NDD 2278 54 18 NDD
2254 53 30 NDD 2279 54 19 NDD
2255 53 31 NDD 2280 54 20 NDD
2256 53 32 NDD 2281 54 21 NDD
2257 53 33 NDD 2282 54 22 NDD

2258 53 34 NDD 2283 54 23 NDD
2259 53 35 NDD 2284 54 24 NDD
2260 53 36 NDD 2285 54 25 NDD
2261 54 1 NDD 2286 54 26 NDD
2262 54 2 NDD 2287 54 27 NDD
2263 54 3 NDD 2288 54 28 NDD
2264 54 4 NDD 2289 54 29 NDD
2265 54 5 NDD 2290 54 30 NDD
2266 54 6 NDD 2291 54 31 NDD

2267 54 7 NDD 2292 54 32 NDD
2268 54 8 NDD 2293 54 33 NDD

2269 54 9 NDD 2294 54 34 NDD
2270 54 10 NDD 2295 55 1 NDD

2271 54 11 NDD 2296 55 2 NDD
2272 54 12 NDD 2297 55 3 NDD

2273 54 13 NDD 2298 55 4 NDD
2274 54 14 NDD 2299 55 5 NDD

2275 54 15 NDD 2300 55 6 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2301 55 7 NDD 2326 55 32 NDD
2302 55 8 NDD 2327 55 33 NDD
2303 55 9 NDD 2328 55 34 NDD
2304 55 10 NDD 2329 56 1 NDD
2305 55 11 NDD 2330 56 2 NDD
2306 55 12 NDD 2331 56 3 NDD
2307 55 13 NDD 2332 56 4 NDD
2308 55 14 NDD 2333 56 5 NDD
2309 55 15 NDD 2334 56 6 NDD
2310 55 16 NDD 2335 56 7 NDD
2311 55 17 NDD 2336 56 8 NDD
2312 55 18 NDD 2337 56 9 NDD
2313 55 19 NDD 2338 56 10 NDD
2314 55 20 NDD 2339 56 11 NDD
2315 55 21 NDD 2340 56 12 NDD
2316 55 22 NDD 2341 56 13 NDD
2317 55 23 NDD 2342 56 14 NDD
2318 55 24 NDD 2343 56 15 NDD
2319 55 25 NDD 2344 56 16 NDD
2320 55 26 NDD 2345 56 17 NDD
2321 55 27 NDD 2346 56 18 NDD
2322 55 28 NDD 2347 56 19 NDD
2323 55 29 NDD 2348 56 20 NDD
2324 55 30 NDD 2349 56 21 NDD
2325 55 31 NDD 2350 56 22 NDD
S. No. ROW Column WALL LOSS % FLAW S. No. ROW Column WALL LOSS % FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2351 56 23 NDD 2376 57 15 NDD
2352 56 24 NDD 2377 57 16 NDD
2353 56 25 NDD 2378 57 17 NDD
2354 56 26 NDD 2379 57 18 NDD
2355 56 27 NDD 2380 57 19 NDD
2356 56 28 NDD 2381 57 20 NDD
2357 56 29 NDD 2382 57 21 NDD

2358 56 30 NDD 2383 57 22 NDD
2359 56 31 NDD 2384 57 23 NDD
2360 56 32 NDD 2385 57 24 NDD
2361 56 33 NDD 2386 57 25 NDD
2362 57 1 NDD 2387 57 26 NDD
2363 57 2 NDD 2388 57 27 NDD
2364 57 3 NDD 2389 57 28 NDD
2365 57 4 NDD 2390 57 29 NDD
2366 57 5 NDD 2391 57 30 NDD

2367 57 6 NDD 2392 57 31 NDD
2368 57 7 NDD 2393 57 32 NDD

2369 57 8 NDD 2394 57 33 NDD
2370 57 9 NDD 2395 57 34 NDD

2371 57 10 NDD 2396 58 1 NDD
2372 57 11 NDD 2397 58 2 NDD

2373 57 12 NDD 2398 58 3 NDD
2374 57 13 NDD 2399 58 4 NDD

2375 57 14 NDD 2400 58 5 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2401 58 6 NDD 2426 58 31 NDD
2402 58 7 NDD 2427 58 32 NDD
2403 58 8 NDD 2428 58 33 NDD
2404 58 9 NDD 2429 59 1 NDD
2405 58 10 NDD 2430 59 2 NDD
2406 58 11 NDD 2431 59 3 NDD
2407 58 12 NDD 2432 59 4 NDD
2408 58 13 NDD 2433 59 5 NDD
2409 58 14 NDD 2434 59 6 NDD
2410 58 15 NDD 2435 59 7 NDD
2411 58 16 NDD 2436 59 8 NDD
2412 58 17 NDD 2437 59 9 NDD
2413 58 18 NDD 2438 59 10 NDD
2414 58 19 NDD 2439 59 11 NDD
2415 58 20 NDD 2440 59 12 NDD
2416 58 21 NDD 2441 59 13 NDD
2417 58 22 NDD 2442 59 14 NDD
2418 58 23 NDD 2443 59 15 NDD
2419 58 24 NDD 2444 59 16 NDD
2420 58 25 NDD 2445 59 17 NDD
2421 58 26 NDD 2446 59 18 NDD
2422 58 27 NDD 2447 59 19 NDD
2423 58 28 NDD 2448 59 20 NDD
2424 58 29 NDD 2449 59 21 NDD
2425 58 30 NDD 2450 59 22 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2451 59 23 NDD 2476 60 16 NDD
2452 59 24 NDD 2477 60 17 NDD
2453 59 25 NDD 2478 60 18 NDD
2454 59 26 NDD 2479 60 19 NDD

2455 59 27 NDD 2480 60 20 NDD
2456 59 28 NDD 2481 60 21 NDD
2457 59 29 NDD 2482 60 22 NDD
2458 59 30 NDD 2483 60 23 NDD
2459 59 31 NDD 2484 60 24 NDD
2460 59 32 NDD 2485 60 25 NDD
2461 60 1 NDD 2486 60 26 NDD
2462 60 2 NDD 2487 60 27 NDD
2463 60 3 NDD 2488 60 28 NDD
2464 60 4 NDD 2489 60 29 NDD
2465 60 5 NDD 2490 60 30 NDD
2466 60 6 NDD 2491 60 31 NDD
2467 60 7 NDD 2492 60 27 NDD
2468 60 8 NDD 2493 60 28 NDD
2469 60 9 NDD 2494 60 29 NDD
2470 60 10 NDD 2495 60 30 NDD
2471 60 11 NDD 2496 60 31 NDD
2472 60 12 NDD 2497 61 1 NDD
2473 60 13 NDD 2498 61 2 NDD
2474 60 14 NDD 2499 61 3 NDD
2475 60 15 NDD 2500 61 4 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2501 61 5 NDD 2526 61 30 NDD
2502 61 6 NDD 2527 62 1 NDD
2503 61 7 NDD 2528 62 2 NDD
2504 61 8 NDD 2529 62 3 NDD
2505 61 9 NDD 2530 62 4 NDD
2506 61 10 NDD 2531 62 5 NDD
2507 61 11 NDD 2532 62 6 NDD
2508 61 12 NDD 2533 62 7 NDD
2509 61 13 NDD 2534 62 8 NDD
2510 61 14 NDD 2535 62 9 NDD
2511 61 15 NDD 2536 62 10 NDD
2512 61 16 NDD 2537 62 11 NDD
2513 61 17 NDD 2538 62 12 NDD
2514 61 18 NDD 2539 62 13 NDD
2515 61 19 NDD 2540 62 14 NDD
2516 61 20 NDD 2541 62 15 NDD
2517 61 21 NDD 2542 62 16 NDD
2518 61 22 NDD 2543 62 17 NDD
2519 61 23 NDD 2544 62 18 NDD
2520 61 24 NDD 2545 62 19 NDD
2521 61 25 NDD 2546 62 20 NDD
2522 61 26 NDD 2547 62 21 NDD
2523 61 27 NDD 2548 62 22 NDD
2524 61 28 NDD 2549 62 23 NDD
2525 61 29 NDD 2550 62 24 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2551 62 25 NDD 2576 63 21 NDD
2552 62 26 NDD 2577 63 22 NDD
2553 62 27 NDD 2578 63 23 NDD
2554 62 28 NDD 2579 63 24 NDD
2555 62 29 NDD 2580 63 25 NDD
2556 63 1 NDD 2581 63 26 NDD
2557 63 2 NDD 2582 63 27 NDD
2558 63 3 NDD 2583 63 28 NDD
2559 63 4 NDD 2584 64 1 NDD
2560 63 5 NDD 2585 64 2 NDD
2561 63 6 NDD 2586 64 3 NDD
2562 63 7 NDD 2587 64 4 NDD
2563 63 8 NDD 2588 64 5 NDD
2564 63 9 NDD 2589 64 6 NDD
2565 63 10 NDD 2590 64 7 NDD
2566 63 11 NDD 2591 64 8 NDD
2567 63 12 NDD 2592 64 9 NDD
2568 63 13 NDD 2593 64 10 NDD
2569 63 14 NDD 2594 64 11 NDD
2570 63 15 NDD 2595 64 12 NDD
2571 63 16 NDD 2596 64 13 NDD
2572 63 17 NDD 2597 64 14 NDD
2573 63 18 NDD 2598 64 15 NDD
2574 63 19 NDD 2599 64 16 NDD
2575 63 20 NDD 2600 64 17 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2601 64 18 NDD 2626 65 14 NDD
2602 64 19 NDD 2627 65 15 NDD
2603 64 20 NDD 2628 65 16 NDD
2604 64 21 NDD 2629 65 17 NDD
2605 64 22 NDD 2630 65 18 NDD
2606 64 23 NDD 2631 65 19 NDD
2607 64 24 NDD 2632 65 20 NDD
2608 64 25 NDD 2633 65 21 NDD
2609 64 26 NDD 2634 65 22 NDD
2610 64 27 NDD 2635 65 23 NDD
2611 64 28 NDD 2636 65 24 NDD
2612 64 29 NDD 2637 65 25 NDD
2613 65 1 NDD 2638 65 26 NDD
2614 65 2 NDD 2639 65 27 NDD
2615 65 3 NDD 2640 65 28 NDD
2616 65 4 NDD 2641 66 1 NDD
2617 65 5 NDD 2642 66 2 NDD
2618 65 6 NDD 2643 66 3 NDD
2619 65 7 NDD 2644 66 4 NDD
2620 65 8 NDD 2645 66 5 NDD
2621 65 9 NDD 2646 66 6 NDD
2622 65 10 NDD 2647 66 7 NDD
2623 65 11 NDD 2648 66 8 NDD
2624 65 12 NDD 2649 66 9 NDD
2625 65 13 NDD 2650 66 10 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2651 66 11 NDD 2676 67 9 NDD
2652 66 12 NDD 2677 67 10 NDD
2653 66 13 NDD 2678 67 11 NDD
2654 66 14 NDD 2679 67 12 NDD
2655 66 15 NDD 2680 67 13 NDD
2656 66 16 NDD 2681 67 14 NDD
2657 66 17 NDD 2682 67 15 NDD
2658 66 18 NDD 2683 67 16 NDD
2659 66 19 NDD 2684 67 17 NDD
2660 66 20 NDD 2685 67 18 NDD
2661 66 21 NDD 2686 67 19 NDD
2662 66 22 NDD 2687 67 20 NDD
2663 66 23 NDD 2688 67 21 NDD
2664 66 24 NDD 2689 67 22 NDD
2665 66 25 NDD 2690 67 23 NDD
2666 66 26 NDD 2691 67 24 NDD
2667 66 27 NDD 2692 67 25 NDD
2668 67 1 NDD 2693 67 26 NDD
2669 67 2 NDD 2694 68 1 NDD
2670 67 3 NDD 2695 68 2 NDD
2671 67 4 NDD 2696 68 3 NDD
2672 67 5 NDD 2697 68 4 NDD
2673 67 6 NDD 2698 68 5 NDD
2674 67 7 NDD 2699 68 6 NDD
2675 67 8 NDD 2700 68 7 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2701 68 9 NDD 2726 69 9 NDD
2702 68 10 NDD 2727 69 10 NDD
2703 68 11 NDD 2728 69 11 NDD
2704 68 12 NDD 2729 69 12 NDD
2705 68 13 NDD 2730 69 13 NDD
2706 68 14 NDD 2731 69 14 NDD
2707 68 15 NDD 2732 69 15 NDD
2708 68 16 NDD 2733 69 16 NDD
2709 68 17 NDD 2734 69 17 NDD
2710 68 18 NDD 2735 69 18 NDD
2711 68 19 NDD 2736 69 19 NDD
2712 68 20 NDD 2737 69 20 NDD
2713 68 21 NDD 2738 69 21 NDD
2714 68 22 NDD 2739 69 22 NDD
2715 68 23 NDD 2740 69 23 NDD
2716 68 24 NDD 2741 69 24 NDD
2717 68 25 NDD 2742 70 1 NDD
2718 69 1 NDD 2743 70 2 NDD
2719 69 2 NDD 2744 70 3 NDD
2720 69 3 NDD 2745 70 4 NDD
2721 69 4 NDD 2746 70 5 NDD
2722 69 5 NDD 2747 70 6 NDD
2723 69 6 NDD 2748 70 7 NDD
2724 69 7 NDD 2749 70 8 NDD
2725 69 8 NDD 2750 70 9 NDD
FLAW FLAW
TYPE TYPE
2751 70 12 NDD
2752 70 13 NDD
2753 70 14 NDD
2754 70 15 NDD
2755 70 16 NDD
2756 70 17 NDD
2757 70 18 NDD
2758 70 19 NDD
2759 70 20 NDD
2760 70 21 NDD
Recommendation: Tubes having >80% wall loss should be plugged.
TEST METHOD AND PROCEDURE
SCOPE:
This procedure covers the eddy-current examination of seamless and welded
tubular products made of stainless steel and similar alloys.
This practice is intended as a guide for eddy-current examination of both seamless

and welded tubular products using Bobin coil technique.
This practice covers the examination of tubular products ranging in diameter from
0.125 to 5 in. (3.2 to 127.0 mm) and wall thicknesses from 0.005 to 0.250 in.
(0.127 to 6.4 mm).
1.0REFERENCES
ASME Section V Non Destructive Examination

2.1
2016 Edition
Standard practice for Electromagnetic
ASTM E 426 Examination of Seamless and Welded
2.2
2016 Edition Tubular Products, Austenetic Stainless
Steel, Titanium and Similar Alloys.
2.0PERSONNEL QUALIFICATION
2.1 The personnel who operate the ECT test equipment with the exception of
the probe positioner / puller technician shall be a minimum Level-II in Eddy
current testing Method. Certification of the personnel shall be according to
ASNT SNTC-1A.
2.2 The evaluation of the result of the ECT must be conducted by personnel
qualified to atleast Level II
3.0PRINCIPLE OF ECT SYSTEM
3.1 Eddy-current testing is a nondestructive method of locating discontinuities in

a product. Changes in electromagnetic response caused by the presence of
discontinuities are detected by the sensor, amplified and modified in order to
record the data for analysis. Signals can be caused by outer surface, inner
surface, or subsurface discontinuities. The eddy-current test is sensitive to
many factors that occur as a result of processing (such as variations in
conductivity, chemical composition, permeability, and geometry) as well
as other test factors not related to the tubing. Thus, all received indications
are not necessarily indicative of defective tubing.
4.0COMPONENTS OF THE ECT SYSTEM:
A Computerized Ectane 2 Multi-function/multiflexing system of Eddyfi by

Canada make was used to carry out the inspection. All results were recorded to
disk and manual analysis was conducted on screen.
Calibration tube standards of similar material with artificial defects were used to
establish and verify the system response and to act as a guide for data analysis.
The system shall be consists of following three functional elements:

1) Calibration tube.
2) The inspection head assembly.
3) Laptop with ECT software i.e. Tubepro.
5.0SURFACE PREPARATION
All tubes inner surface shall be adequately cleaned to remove any dust, loose
foreign particles, internal deposits or contaminants by a suitable process such
as pressurized water jet cleaning. It is also recommended to clean the outer
surface of tube if possible.
6.0SITE REQUIREMENT
The ECT system requires a 110/220 VAC, 50 Hz AC supply at work
location.
7.0ECT INSPECTION PROCEDURE

7.1 The ECT system shall be calibrated on the standard calibration sample
as per Standard operating procedure. Calibration standards shall be
manufactured from a tubing of the same material specification, same heat
treatment, and same nominal size.
7.2 The inspection is conducted with the probe located at the far end of the
tube. The assembly is pushed to the end of the tube by feeding the hose
through the end plate of the adaptor.
7.3 To start the inspection the assembly is gradually pulled along the tube
towards the operator. The rate at which the inspection head assembly is
moved along the tube governs the degree of coverage of the tube.
7.4 The above procedure can be repeated for as many tubes are to be
inspected during the operating session. The equipment dismantle
procedures are to be inspected during the operating session. The equipment
dismantle procedures are the reverse of those carried out during the set up
of the inspection.
7.5 The pulling speed of the probe shall be kept constant during the
inspection. The pulling speed shall be at 40-80mm/s
9.0 DATA RECORDING
For the purposes of this procedure all test results will be recorded on suitable
data acquisition system.
 Each data storage unit shall contain the following information:
 Positive identification of the item under test.
 Data storage unit number.
 A reference to the contents.
 Date
 Probe identification.
Each trace shall be identified according to zone/row/tube number as
applicable.
10.0 DATA ANALYSIS
All indications shall be evaluated based on the client’s acceptance criteria
All indications shall be evaluated and reported in the form of wall thickness
loss.
11.0 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA

The acceptance criteria or rejection of tubes based on wall loss is at the
discretion of the client.
12.0 REPORTING RESULTS
12.1 Report shall be prepared with the information gathered using the
computer data files
12.2 Report all tubes wall with a wall loss reading, Percentage of wall
loss and Equipment’s front view diagram with wall loss and all reports
issued to the clients shall be signed by the person performing the
inspection.
12.3 Recommendations also available in the report.
INSPECTION PERSONNEL
Lead Technician: Mr. Rajkumar - ECT Level II
INSPECTION PERSONNEL
M/s. Arudra Engineers Private Limited

HP Heater # 3 Top Final

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originaltitel

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

HP Heater # 3 Top Final

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

1.

2.0 Eddy Current Examination Of Condenser Tubes

Specimens to be tested were tubes of the HP Heaters # 3. HP Heaters # 3 consisted of a

3.0 Details Of Eddy Current Equipment Employed

3.1 Test Setup

Channel 1 - is operated in the differential mode to detect pits.

Channel 2 - is the mixer channel to cancel the tube sheet signal.

Channel 3 - is used in absolute mode to detect thickness variations.

Channel 4 - is a flaw discrimination channel. This channel is used to differentiate

real defects from conductive deposits.

3.2 Probe Selection

1 ASME Sec V 2017 Non Destructive Examinations

2 ASNT SNTC 1A Personnel Qualification and eritiicationof Non Destructive

3 ASTM E 316 Definition of terms relating to electromagnetic testing

5 ASTM E 690 In-situ electromagnetic (eddy current) examination of

Artificial Defects for Calibration:

4.3 Test Location

All the electrical connections were appropriately made.

4.4 Equipment Calibration(At Field):

4.5 Data Collection

90% THRU WALL

75 2 33 NDD 100 3 16 NDD

106 3 22 NDD 131 4 1 NDD

107 3 23 NDD 132 4 2 NDD

114 3 30 NDD 139 4 9 NDD

115 3 31 NDD 140 4 10 NDD

116 3 32 NDD 141 4 11 NDD

118 3 34 NDD 143 4 13 NDD

120 3 NDD 145 4 15 NDD

122 3 38 NDD 147 4 17 NDD

124 3 40 NDD 149 4 19 NDD

125 3 41 NDD 150 4 20 NDD

156 4 26 NDD 181 5 6 NDD

157 4 27 NDD 182 5 7 20-29.9 %

164 4 34 NDD 189 5 14 NDD

165 4 35 NDD 190 5 15 NDD

166 4 36 NDD 191 5 16 NDD

168 4 38 NDD 193 5 18 NDD

170 4 40 NDD 195 5 20 NDD

172 4 42 NDD 197 5 22 NDD

174 4 44 NDD 199 5 24 NDD

175 4 45 NDD 200 5 25 NDD

356 8 39 NDD 381 9 19 NDD

357 8 40 NDD 382 9 20 NDD

364 9 2 NDD 389 9 27 NDD

365 9 3 NDD 390 9 28 NDD

366 9 4 NDD 391 9 29 NDD

368 9 6 NDD 393 9 31 NDD

370 9 8 NDD 395 9 33 NDD

372 9 10 NDD 397 9 35 NDD

374 9 12 NDD 399 9 37 NDD

375 9 13 NDD 400 9 38 NDD

456 11 3 NDD 481 11 28 NDD

457 11 4 NDD 482 11 29 NDD

464 11 11 NDD 489 11 36 NDD

465 11 12 NDD 490 11 37 NDD

466 11 13 NDD 491 11 38 NDD

468 11 15 NDD 493 11 40 NDD

470 11 17 NDD 495 11 42 NDD

472 11 19 NDD 497 11 44 NDD

474 11 21 NDD 499 11 46 NDD

475 11 22 NDD 500 12 1 NDD

556 13 11 NDD 581 13 36 NDD