Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Effects of increased cell phone and social media usage on interpersonal communication
Communicology 371
R. Kelly Aune, Ph.D.
24 April 2018
Peter Kim`
Sean Putney
Mart Joshua Lopez
McKaela Sanders
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
2
Table of Contents
Table of Contents……………………………………………………………………..2
Hypothesis……………………………………………………………………………..3
Methods………………………………………………………………………………...5
Participants…………………………………………………………………….5
Materials………………………………………………………………………...6
Design…………………………………………………………………………...6
Procedures……………………………………………………………………..7
Results………………………………………………………………………………..…8
T Tests………………………………………………………………………..….8
Group Statistics……………………………………………………..…………9
Report………………………………………………………………………..….11
Summary…………………………………………………………………..……15
Discussion………………………………………………………………………..…....16
References…………………………………………………………………….…….....21
Appendix…………………………………………………………………….……........23
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
3
Hypothesis
H1: The increased use of cell phones and social media has enhanced
interpersonal communication.
H2: The increased use of cell phones and social media has not enhanced
interpersonal communication.
Mankind has been fascinated and consumed by the invention of the mobile
device. With the advancement of cellular devices, technology has become more
tools to connect with their network from the past and present. Cellular devices and
social media establishes several new avenues to keep in touch and enhances the ease
of communication.
functions that serve as very useful tool. Out of 84 individuals surveyed through
SurveyMonkey, 53.6% spent over seven hours a week using their cell phones. The use
of phone applications has become a primary accessory to cell phones. The question
arises, has the abundance of cell phone usage lead to larger and more easily
Through the use of mobile devices, people are communicating with each other
more frequently. Since the advent of the Internet, social media has shifted the social
paradigm. People are now spending more time communicating in an online space,
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
4
rather than in person. The results of the investigation can influence the way individuals
perceive the use of cell phones and social media and how future technology is
Although there is an increase in usage of cell phones and research shows people
are spending a significant amount of time on their devices, there is a positive correlation
history. With just the touch of the button, people can participate in a video conference
The term “third places” refers to a place where a person goes when are not
working, attending school, or at home. These are places like the gym, the beach, or
perhaps the bar. As society is making a generational shift in many regards of life, there
has also been a shift in what is considered a third place. People are spending a
significant amount of time using cell phones. Individuals can use devices as a source of
“Friends:” Social Capital and College Students’ Use of Online Social Network Sites,
quoted as saying, “online SNSs (Social Network Sites) support both the maintenance of
existing social ties and the formation of new connections” (Oxford, 2007, Paragraph 3).
Through the use of mobile applications and the ever growing list seen in the app
store, it is enticing for users to download new apps. Applications can also allow people
Methods
self-made and managed Survey Monkey project. The following information will outline
Participants
84 surveys were utilized in the collection of data in the experiment. The survey
was shared through typical mediums of social networks and through the University of
Hawaii email system. Due to emailing other students within the university, majority of
data collected was from 21-25 year olds. This age group makes up for 40% of the data
collected. The network of the 84 individuals surveyed spans from a centralized group of
the four students working on the project: Kim, Lopez, Putney, and Sanders.
The participants of this survey accessed this survey on through time electronic
devices with no time restrictions. According to the Survey Monkey platform, participants
spent an average of 3 minutes and 39 seconds to complete the survey. From all 84
participants, there was a 100% completion rate of the 24 question survey. The 100%
completion rate refers to the amount of people who began the survey and ultimately
finished the survey. This does not refer to the skipped questions that may appear on the
data set.
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
6
Materials
device. Survey Monkey does not showcase data regarding how the survey was
conduct the experiment as everything was performed through basic devices that had
The tools used to analyze and organize data include Microsoft Excel, Survey
Monkey’s on-site data analysis/trends, and IBM SPSS Statistics. IBM SPSS Statistics
was the main tool for analyzing data through independent-sample t-tests to compare
means and to define the means throughout the raw data collected.
Design
The experiment utilized a questionnaire to help answer the main hypothesis. The
questioning was set to answer whether or not social media enhances interpersonal
dependent variable which is the level of convenience and ease of communicating with
other people. The following survey designed is aimed to answer the proper questions to
help build educated inferences that high phone usage enhances human interaction.
and age. Participants were then asked to identify and measure the amount of phone
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
7
usage per week. The following line of questions helped gauge the amount of
commitment the user has to each individual’s phone usage. Questions regarded anxiety
when without access to cellphone to the financial commitment one has to a device.
Questions regarding phone usage were also targeted from a moral and ethical point of
view. The two questions were meant to gauge how the participant felt about the right
age regarding cell phone usage and the overall positive or negative effect of its
existence.
networks that the participants are using. According to the Pew Research Center, as of
January 10, 2018, 69% of adults use at least one social media site with Facebook being
the most popular. The survey was also designed to help understand the use of social
media on cellular devices. Questions regarding time spent on social media, personal
Procedures
The data was collected on one platform utilizing the questionnaire service known
as Survey Monkey. 24 questions were created on the website and the link was copied
and shared through four individuals involved in the project. The goal was to collect data
categories included demographics, cell phone usage, and social media usage. Each
Results
(Refer to Appendix A)
From the responses, the demographics showed that 65% of participants were
female, and 35% were male. With regards to age, 19.05% of participants stated they
years old, 13.10% were within 26 to 30 years old, and 27.38% stated that they were
the area of cell phone usage. It began by asking the participants how many hours a
week they spend on their phone. The results were across the board with 53.57% of
participants spending over seven hours a week on their phone. 17.86% of surveyors
reported they spend five to seven hours a week, 16.67% reported three to five hours,
9.52% reported one to three hours, and only 2.38% reported that they spend less than
one hour a week on their phone. An independent-samples t-test was conducted to
analyze the provided demographics to better assess who was surveyed. The following
phone between male and female. The survey asked for hours spent on the phone in
separate categories. These categories included less than one hour, 1-3 hours, 3-5
hours, 5-7 hours, and more than 7 hours. These five groups were labeled 1-5 in
those surveyed, the average time spent on a phone a week between both male and
Table 1
Independent-sample t-test comparing means of genders and hours spent on their phone
week
Note. hoursonmp = hours spent on cell phone a week, Female = female participant,
Male = male participant
surveyors would be anxious if they left their cell phone at home. As for phones being a
distraction, the data showed that women are more easily distracted by their phone when
focusing on other tasks. Participants were asked to rate their level of vulnerability to
being distracted by their mobile phone on a scale from 1-50. Table 2 represents the 56
female participants had an average vulnerability level of 37.44% out of 50. While males
Table 2
Independent-sample t-test comparing means of genders and their vulnerability to being
distracted by their phone.
94.05% of participants reported that they do not feel the need to have the newest
cell phone on the market, leaving only 5.95% who feel they need to have the newest
model. The survey also questioned participants whether they ever spend money for
in-app or app purchases. 75% of respondents claim they do not, whereas 25% claim
that they do spend money. An average of 87.80% of participants reported they feel that
cell phones enhance human interaction. 12.20% reported they feel that the use of cell
phones handicap interaction. Table 3 represents the compared means between the
amount of hours spent on a phone each week and whether or not they felt that cell
Table 3
Independent-sample t-test comparing means of hours spent on cell phone and whether
they felt that it enhanced or handicapped human interaction
a cell phone between the two types of individuals. Our audience was then asked at what
age they think that it is appropriate for a child to have a cell phone. The data collected
wide range of results, displaying that 2.38% think ages three to five, 1.19% think ages
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
11
five to seven, 9.52% think ages seven to ten, 38.10% think ages 10 to 13, and 48. 81%
think after the age of 13 is appropriate to have a cellphone. When asked if they use their
cell phone to escape awkward social interactions, 72.62% of participants reported yes.
27.38% reported that they do not use their phone to escape awkward social
interactions. Facebook had the highest level of engagement with reports showing
85.71% usage, with YouTube in second place displaying 70.24% usage. 66.67% of
participants reported they use snapchat, with Instagram following closely with 65.48%
usage. 28.57% of participants reported they use Twitter, 22.62% reported they use
LinkedIn, and 3.57% reported they do not engage in social networking. In regards to
social media usage, the participants were asked to provide the amount of
connections/friends/followers they have on their primary social media and how many of
them do they talk to. The following results are listed below in Table 4.
Table 3
Comparing means of hours spent on cell phone and whether they felt that it enhanced
or handicapped human interaction
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
12
Not all participants answered questions as eight participants were excluded from
answering the number of contacts and four individuals did not answer the question of
how many people they converse with on that specific platform. The average amount of
contacts that an individual is 848.38 people, while they only speak to 29.78% of those
they are connected to. Therefore, the data shows that an individual will only speak to an
average of 3.5% of their total contacts on their primary social media. Furthermore,
participants were given the opportunity to select from a variety of answers regarding
why they use social media. 92.86% reported they use social media to keep in touch with
family and friends, 58.33% use to share their experiences, 55.95% use to find
information, and 45.24% use to share media. 29.76% of surveyors also reported they
use social media to get opinions, 26.19% use to make new friends and to make
professional business contacts, and 22.62% use to play games. Figure 1 visualizes the
information to greater illustrate the stark difference between the first and second ranking
reasons.
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
13
Figure 1
Bar graph comparing the most common uses for social media among the 84
participants
When asked if the participants felt more comfortable cybernetically or in real life
when conversing with a friend, 79.52% reported face-to-face conversation and 20.46%
stated cybernetic conversation. 51.19% of participants claimed that they spend over five
hours a week socializing outside of school or work. 26.19% reported three to five hours,
17.86% stated one to three hours, and 4.76% claimed less than one hour. Surveyors
were then given a selection of settings to which they prefer for relaxation. 70.24% prefer
home, 47.62% prefer out with family or friends, 39.29% prefer outside doing physical
activities, and 19.05% prefer to be online for relaxation. When asked if they ever
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
14
experience the fear of missing out, 53.09% of participants reported no and 46.91% of
participants stated yes. 52.38% of surveyors claim they do not feel less intimidated
communicating through their smartphone, whereas 47.62% reported that they do feel
connect with people that they do not know. 45.24% responded that they do not, and
54.76% reported that they do. 58.33% of surveyors stated that they do not consider
their followers their friends, whereas 41.67% responded that they do. When asked if
they would approach someone they do not know in real life, but know online, 49.40% of
respondents claim that it depends. However, 27.71% responded yes and 22.89%
reported no. Along with this, participants were asked if social media boosts confidence
boost.
Lastly, surveyors were asked whether social media has made a positive or
negative on impact on their life. 81.93% of participants answered that it has made a
positive impact while 18.07% have replied in the negative. This particular question
The data collected helps support the original hypothesis with some limitations.
When reviewing the data it was clear that people, across all demographics were utilizing
their phone and social media to a high extent. The average amount of time spent on
their phones throughout the week was around 5-7 hours. Secondly, 92.94% of
participants utilized their social media to connect and keep in touch with family and
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
15
friends. This reason tops the list of several reasons why the surveyors utilized social
media, the closest reason falls to “sharing experiences” with 58.82% of participants
similar fashion to two telling questions. The first question is “Do you feel that cell phones
specific to the use of social media, “Do you feel as though Social Media has a positive
or negative impact on your life?” From the surveyors, 81.93% of individuals felt that
social media provides a positive impact on their life. These two questions were
answered in a way that showcases cell phone usage in a more positive light. It supports
the hypothesis in that many individuals believed it had value to provide with human
interaction and overall quality of life. Within the survey design, questions that would help
gauge the negative effects that the use of cellular phones can have on interpersonal
escape mechanism from awkward interactions, etc. Unfortunately, the major limitation
with the data supporting the hypothesis is that the dependency of cellular phones have
Table 3
Means test for vulnerability level of being distracted by phone when completing tasks
that they were easily distracted by their cell phones at a rating average of 39 points.
With that limitation in mind, the data showcases that there are perceived positive
Discussion
The aim for this hypothesis was to see if the usage of cellphones and social
media either enhances or does not enhance interpersonal communication. Overall, the
results showcased that the increased usage of cell phones and social media has
The design of the survey was meant to help interpret several ideas that will be
reviewed in the following segment. Depending on the question, there may be a positive
or negative leaning connotation of what the question is trying to grasp. It was crucial to
collect information that would help confirm the hypothesis, while having data on both
easily are you distracted by your phone when focusing on other tasks?“ A positive
question may be “Do you feel that cell phones enhance or handicaps human
interaction?”
After the general demographic statistics were taken, participants were asked to
provide information regarding their general cell phone usage throughout the week.
54.12% of individuals answered that they use their phones for over seven hours a week,
this is a majority of the survey takers. Although a majority of individuals spent over 7
hours of time, the compared mean between male and female is comparable. Both male
and female average to about 5-7 hours a week on their cell phones. Along with gauging
a quantifiable amount of time spent on the phone, the survey was designed to help
illustrate the dependency of their cellphones. There are two major sections to
making to their product. Their financial commitment through app or in-app purchases
and whether the user feels the need to purchase the newest phone as it comes out.
When reviewing the data, users do not feel connected to those two issues. 94.05%, a
large majority of participants did not feel the need to purchase the newest phone on the
market. As for making app and in-app purchases, 75% of surveyors do not make any
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
18
purchases. The second section of visualizing dependency is the physical and mental
dependency to their cell phone. Understanding more of their dependency can help put
into perspective the amount of use that is going into their daily interpersonal
communication. Surveyors were asked how easily distracted they were by their phones
distractedness of a cell phone when competing other tasks. Secondly, participants were
asked if they utilized their cell phones as a means to escape awkward social
dependency on their phone. The notable piece of data in this set is that 87.80% of the
participants feel that the use of cell phones has ultimately enhanced human interaction.
individuals still feel that positive value is added into human interaction.
The second section the survey design gauges one of the primary uses of the cell
phone, social media. Participants were asked to defined the social media they used, the
amount of contacts they had on their primary social media, and how many of them they
engaged in conversation with. Maybe most importantly, is the question that requests the
reasons for using social media. These four questions provided insight of the breadth of
someone social media networks that the participants were on. The second and third
only 3.5% of their friends on their primary social media. It is worthwhile to compare a
that they use social media to keep in touch with friends. Yet, the participants are only
engaging an average 3.5% of their contacts. There may be a few possible reasons for
such a large gap between the amount of friends and friends that are engaged. It is
possible that the participants are using their social media as a pool of contacts in case
they would like to contact their friends in the future, not necessarily on a daily basis.
Secondary to that, it may be that the participants would only contact their online
engagement was not worded well enough. The original wording was “Out of those
friends; how many do you have conversations with on that platform?“ This question
does not define the frequency of conversations and may invite skewed answers into the
study. A suggestion for a future design would be wording the question that properly
frames the frequency in the surveyor’s head. An example of a better question may be
“Out of those friends; how many conversations do you have (weekly) with them on that
platform?“ Although the data set seemed to contradict itself in the area, it supports
comfortable conversing cybernetically or in real life. Approx. 79% of individuals felt more
comfortable conversing with friends in real life. This piece of data agrees with the
previous notion that it may be possible that the participants are only conversing with
others if completely necessary since most feel comfortable with interacting face-to-face.
The future research on cell phone usage and correlation with humans interaction is still
new. The trajectory of cellphone usage will only increase as spending more time on cell
phones are common and “acceptable”. As people may use their cellphones to escape or
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
20
to “kill” time, the reasons are limitless. There are potential of future studies on this topic
as the complexity and usage are increasing and it provides an opportunity to dig deeper
within research. There are several ideas and suggestions to consider if the study was
executed again. First of all, the verbiage of the questions could have been more
effective in defining the meaning of the question. Frequencies, amounts, and age
groups were not strictly defined and could have skewed the data in several ways. Also
research would be better worded and geared towards different type of app users.
Questions can be geared towards an app and communications with better precise data.
Secondly, there were questions where scale was not created correctly. Instead of a 1 to
10 scale, there were scales such as 1 to 50 and 1 to 100. A future study would benefit
from more defined answers to better find an association or correlation within the data.
Thirdly, numerical answers should not be grouped, but defined specifically. An example
of this would be the age groups defined in the paper, it created a difficult process of
defining the data in analysis form. Lastly, if given the opportunity to complete the study
alternative could be hosting the survey natively through polls on Instagram or Facebook.
This will provide insights to location, age, and survey results on a platform that is
This is the beginning of research regarding human interaction and the way the
mobile world has presented itself as a third space for participants. With the data
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
21
collected, the data generally supports the main hypothesis that the increased time spent
on cell phones and social media enhances human interaction. Cell phones,
smartphones, and other social media apps were made to connect people from all over
the world. In the study, the participants showed through data that was majority of the
reason why they use their smartphones. However, it is also common to see that the
References
O'Keeffe, Gwenn Schurgin, et al. “The Impact of Social Media on Children, Adolescents, and
pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/127/4/800.short.
“Relationships among Smartphone Addiction, Stress, Academic Performance, and Satisfaction with
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0747563215303162.
“Social Media Fact Sheet.” Pew Research Center: Internet, Science & Tech, 5 Feb. 2018,
www.pewinternet.org/fact-sheet/social-media/.
“Social Media and Loneliness: Why an Instagram Picture May Be Worth More than a Thousand
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0747563216302552.
“We're All Connected: The Power of the Social Media Ecosystem.” Business Horizons, Elsevier, 16
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B-5-JeCa2Z7hSDBhbFIyVXZfMGM/edit
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
23
Ellison, et al. “Benefits of Facebook ‘Friends:" Social Capital and College Students' Use of Online
https://academic.oup.com/jcmc/article/12/4/1143/4582961
Dos, Bulent. “The Relationship Between Mobile Phone Use, Metacognitive Awareness and
Academic Achievement.” European Journal of Educational Research, vol. 3, no. 4, 2014, pp.
192–200., doi:10.12973/eu-jer.3.4.192.
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1085990.pdf
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
24
Appendix
b. No
12. Do you engage in any social networking?
a. No, I don’t engage in any social networking
b. Facebook
c. LinkedIn
d. Youtube
e. Twitter
f. Instagram
g. Snapchat
13. How many friends do you have on your primary social media?
a. (fill in)
14. Out of those friends; how many do you have conversations with on that platform?
a. (fill in)
15. Does social networking allow you to have freedom of speech?
a. Yes
b. No
16. Why do you use social media? (You can tick more than one response)
a. To find information
b. To play games
c. To make professional and business contacts
d. To keep in touch with family and friends
e. To make new friends
f. To get opinions
g. To share videos/ pictures/ music
h. To share your experiences
17. Do you feel more comfortable cybernetically or in real life when having a conversation with a
friend?
a. Cybernetic conversation
b. Real life conversation
18. How many hours a week do you spend socializing outside of school/work?
a. 0-1 hours
b. 1-3 hours
c. 3-5 hours
d. Over 5 hours
19. What’s your preferred setting for relaxation?
a. At home
b. Outside doing physical activities
c. Out with family/friends
d. Online
20. Do you ever have a “fomo”? (fear of missing out)
a. Yes
b. No
21. Do you feel less intimidated communicating through your smartphone?
a. Yes
b. No
22. On a scale of 1-10 how much do you feel the need to have your cell phone with you at all times?
(10 being I absolutely need my cellphone, 1 I couldn’t care less)
Effects of increased cell phone and social
media usage on interpersonal communication
26