CED 38 (13567)WC

(Draft Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700)

MANAK BHAVAN, 9 BAHADUR SHAH ZAFAR MARG, NEW DELHI 110002

व्‍यापक‍परिचालन‍मसौदा

हमािा संदर्भ : सीईडी 38/टी-13 17 January 2019

त‍
कनीक ‍सममतत‍ : ‍‍विमिष्ट संिचना‍विषय सममतत,‍सीईडी‍38
प्राप्‍तक
‍ ताभ‍:
1) मसविल‍इंजीतनयिी‍विर्ाग‍परिषद्‍के‍रूचच‍िखने‍िाले‍सदस्‍य‍
2) सीईडी‍38 ि‍उसक ‍सर्ी‍उपसममततयों के‍सर्ी‍सदस्‍य
3) रूचच‍िखने‍िाले‍अन्‍य‍तनकाय
महोदय(यों),
निम्‍िलिखित ‍मसौदा‍संखग्‍
ि‍ैं:

प्रलेख‍संख्‍
या िीषक

सीईडी‍38(13567 ) कंक्र ट‍क ‍ऊँची‍इमाितों क ‍संिचनात्मक‍सुिक्षा के‍मानदं ड, IS 16700 ‍‍

WC‍‍‍
क ‍संिोधन‍सं.‍1 ICS 91.080.40

कृपया‍इस‍मािक‍के‍मसौदे ‍ का‍अवखोकि‍करें ‍और‍अपिी‍सम्‍मन य ‍ यै‍ब ा ‍े ैुए‍भेज‍े कक‍यदद‍

यै‍ मािक‍ के‍ रूप‍ में ‍ प्रकालिि ‍ ैो‍ ो‍ इि‍ पर‍ अमख‍ करिे‍ में ‍ आपके‍ व्‍यवसाय‍ अववा‍ कारोबार‍ में ‍ ्‍‍या‍
कदििाइया‍आ‍सक ी‍ैं‍।

सम्‍मन य भेजिे की अंन म न थव: 16 फिििी 2019

सम्‍मन ‍ यदद‍ कोई‍ ैो‍ ो‍ कृपया‍ अधोैस्‍ ाक्षरीरक‍ को‍ संखग्‍ि‍ ोोममेट ‍ में ,‍ ced38@bis.gov.in or
abhishek.pal@bis.gov.in‍पर‍ईमेख‍कर‍दें ‍।‍
‍‍‍

यदद‍कोई‍सम्‍
मन ‍प्रा्‍‍ ‍िैकं‍ ैो ी‍ै‍अववा‍सम्‍मन ‍में ‍ केवख‍भााा‍सम्‍बन्‍धी‍रुटदु ‍ैुई‍ ो‍रपरो्‍‍ ‍
प्रखेत‍को‍यवाव ‍अंन म‍रूप‍ददया‍जाएगा‍।‍यदद‍सम्म्‍म‍ ‍ किीकी‍प्रकृन ‍की‍ैुई‍ ो‍ववाय‍सलिमन ‍के‍
अध्‍यक्षरी‍के‍परामिश ‍ से‍ अववा‍रिकी‍इ्‍‍ ा‍पर‍आगे‍ की‍कायश वाैक‍के‍लिखए‍ववाय‍सलिमन ‍को‍भेजे‍ जािे‍ के‍
बाद‍प्रखेत‍को‍अंन म‍रूप‍दे ‍ददया‍जाएगा‍।‍
यै‍प्रखेत‍भार ीय‍मािक‍ब्‍
यरू ो‍की‍वबसाइ ‍पर‍भी‍ै‍।‍
‍
धन्‍यवाद‍।
‍र्िदीय,

‍‍‍‍‍‍‍ ‍ (संजय‍पंत)
संखग्ि‍:‍रपरलिखित ‍‍‍‍‍‍प्रमख
ु (मसविल‍इंजीतनयिी)
 CED 38 (13567)WC
(Draft Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700)

MANAK BHAVAN, 9 BAHADUR SHAH ZAFAR MARG, NEW DELHI 110002

DOCUMENT DESPATCH ADVICE

Reference Date
DRAFT IN WIDE CIRCULATION
CED 38/T-13 17.01.2019

TECHNICAL COMMITTEE:
Special Structures Sectional Committee, CED 38

ADDRESSED TO:
a) All Interested Members of Civil Engineering Division Council, CEDC
b) All Members of CED 38 and its subcommittees,
c) All others interests
Dear Sir (s),
Please find enclosed the following draft amendment to the Indian Standard:

Doc No. Title

CED 38 (13567) Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700: 2017 Criteria for Structural Safety of
WC Tall Concrete Buildings
ICS 91.080.40
Kindly examine the draft Indian Standard and forward your views stating any difficulties
which you are likely to experience in your business or profession, if this is finally adopted as National
Standard.
Last Date for comments: 16 February 2019.

Comments, if any, may please be made in the format as enclosed and e-mailed to the
undersigned at ced38@bis.gov.in or abhishek.pal@bis.gov.in in word format.
In case no comments are received or comments received are of editorial nature, you will
kindly permit us to presume your approval for the above document as finalized. However, in case
of comments technical in nature are received then it may be finalized either in consultation with the
Chairman, Sectional Committee or referred to the Sectional Committee for further necessary action
if so desired by the Chairman, Sectional Committee.
The document is also hosted on BIS website: www.bis.org.in

Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,

(Sanjay Pant)
Head (Civil Engg.)
Encl: As above
 CED 38 (13567)WC
(Draft Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700)
FORMAT FOR SENDING COMMENTS ON THE DOCUMENT

[Please use A4 size sheet of paper only and type within fields indicated. Comments on each clause/sub-clause/
table/figure, etc, be stated on a fresh row. Information/comments should include reasons for comments, technical
references and suggestions for modified wordings of the clause. Comments through e-mail to
ced38@bis.gov.in and abhishek.pal@bis.gov.in shall be appreciated.]

Doc. No.: CED 38 (13567) WC BIS Letter Ref: CED 38/T-13 Dated: 17 January 2019

Title: Draft Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700: 2017 Criteria for Structural Safety of Tall Concrete
Buildings; ICS 91.080.40

Name of the Commentator/ Organization: _______________________________

Clause/ Para/ Comments/Modified Wordings Justification of Proposed

Table/ Figure Change
No. commented
 CED 38 (13567)WC
(Draft Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700)
BUREAU OF INDIAN STANDARDS

DRAFT FOR COMMENTS ONLY

(Not to be reproduced without the permission of BIS nor used as an Indian Standard)
Draft Amendment No. 1
TO
IS 16700: 2017 CRITERIA FOR STRUCTURAL SAFETY OF
TALL CONCRETE BUILDINGS
Special Structures Last Date for Comments:
Sectional Committee, CED 38 16 February 2019

[Page 4, clause 5.3 a), first line] – delete ‘translational’

(Page 4, Table 1) – Substitute below with the existing:

‘Table 1 Maximum value of Height, H above Top of Base Level of Buildings with Different
Structural System for Lateral Loads, in metre
(Clause 5.1.1)
Sl Seismic Structural System
No.

Moment Frame Structural Wall Structural Wall + Structural Wall + Structural Wall +
Moment Perimeter Frame Framed Tube
Frame

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7)

i) V NA 120 150 150 180
ii) IV NA 150 200 200 225
Iii) III 60 200 225 225 250
iv) II 80 250 250 250 250
’

(Page 4, Table 1) – Substitute below with the existing:

‘Table 2 Maximum Slenderness Ratio ( Ht / Bt )

(Clause 5.1.2)
Sl Seismic Structural System
No.
Moment Frame Structural Wall Structural Wall + Structural Wall + Structural Wall +
Moment Perimeter Frame Framed Tube
Frame
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7)
i) V NA 8 8 9 9
ii) IV NA 8 8 9 9
Iii) III 4 8 8 9 10
iv) II 5 9 9 10 10
’
(Page 5, clause 5.4.1) – Substitute the following with the existing:
‘5.4.1 Lateral Drift
 CED 38 (13567)WC
(Draft Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700)

When design lateral forces are applied on the building, the maximum inter-storey elastic lateral drift
ratio (∆max /hi) under serviceability loads (wind load with return period of 20 years), which is estimated
based on section properties for serviceability loads mentioned in 7.2, shall be limited to H/500. For
a single storey the drift limit may be relaxed to hi/400. For the designed earthquake load, the drift
shall be limited to hi/250.’
(Page 5, clause 5.6.1, line 2) – Substitute ‘minimum structural topping’ for ‘minimum screed’
(Page 5, clause 5.6.2.3, line 4) – Substitute the following with the existing:

‘5.6.2.3 At any storey, the minimum width of floor slab along any section after deduction of openings
shall not be less than 5 m, if there is no perimeter beam. Further, the cumulative width of the slab
at any location shall preferably not be less than 50 percent of the floor width.’

(Page 5, clause 5.6.3, line 2) – Substitute ‘exceed’ for ‘be less than’
(Page 5, clause 5.6.4) – delete.
(Page 5, Table 3) – delete.
(Page 5, clause 5.7.2.3) – Substitute ‘20 mm’ for ‘16 mm’
[Page 6, Table 4, Sl No. i), Column 3] – Substitute ‘0.18’ for ‘0.15
(Page 6, clause 6.3.2, first sentence) – Substitute the existing sentence with the following:
‘6.3.2 For buildings in Seismic Zone V deterministic site-specific design spectra may preferably be
estimated and used in design.’
(Page 6, Table 5) – Insert ‘Percent’ after ‘Minimum’ in the title.
(Page 7, clause 7.3.10, line 3) – Delete ‘(P∆u/H)’.
𝑃 ×∆
(Page 7, clause 7.3.10) – Insert ‘, where 𝜃 = H × hi
(see IS 1893).’ at the end of the sentence.

(Page 8, clause 7.4.6) – Substitute the following with the existing:

‘7.4.6 To calculate the effect of creep and shrinkage, selected strain prediction models of
concrete shall be based on established principles of mechanics elaborated in specialist literature.’
[Page 8, clause 8.1.3.3.1, (f) 4)] – Substitute the following with the existing:
‘4) Backstay diaphragm floor shall be at least 150 mm thick, with double mess reinforcements not
less than 0.25 percent of cross section area in each direction.’
[Page 11, clause 8.1.3.3.3 d) 2), line 5] – Substitute ‘Table 7’ for ‘Table 5’
[Page 11, clause 8.1.3.3.3, e)] – Substitute the existing with the following:
‘e) Plan irregularities of Type I (torsion irregularity) and Type III (diaphragm discontinuity) as per
Table 5 of IS 1893 (Part 1), shall not be present in the first topmost connected floor and the first
floor of the tower above the connected floor.’
[Page 11, clause 8.1.3.3.3, g)] – Substitute ‘Topmost slab’ for ‘All floor slabs’.
 CED 38 (13567)WC
(Draft Amendment No. 1 to IS 16700)
(Page 13, clause 8.5.12, line 4) – Substitute ‘above’ for ‘only’.
[Page 13, clause 8.5.13, b)] – Delete.
[Page 13, clause 8.5.13, c), first line] – Delete ‘and transverse’.
(Page 13, clause 8.6 and 8.6.1) – Delete.
[Page 14, clause 9.3.1, c)] – Substitute the following with the existing:
‘c) have a depth of at least 1.5 times of estimated width of foundation subject to minimum
of 20 m in soil and minimum of 15 m in rock.’
[Page 14, clause 9.7.2, f)] – Insert following at the end:
‘; where X and Y are orthogonal axes in plan.’
(Page 14, clause 10, Title) – Substitute the title ‘RECOMMEDATION FOR NON-
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS’ with the existing.
(Page 18, Table 12, line 1) – Substitute ‘(xiii)’ for ‘(xii)’.
(Page 18, Table 12, line 2) – Substitute ‘(xiv)’ for ‘(xiii)’.
[Page 18, Table 12, Sl No.(xiii), Description]– Substitute ‘structural topping’ for ‘screed’
[Page 21, Clause A-5.1 f)] – Insert ‘and above’ at the end.