Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Fires in Buildings
Summary
Fires in buildings may have enormous consequences for safety and economy. Therefore the fire
design of structures is an important factor for public safety and the design of buildings. In recent
years fire safety engineering has become a new discipline integrating all aspects of fire safety
(structural, technical, organisational), into the design of buildings. With regard to structural fire
design, in addition to good construction practice, safe and easily applicable design methods are
needed both for structural members and complete structures subjected to fire. This paper gives an
overview of fire action, fire safety concepts, structural fire design as well as recent developments
and the main trends in fire safety engineering.
Keywords: Fires in buildings, fire action, fire safety concepts, structural fire design, fire safety
engineering, prescriptive- and performance-based fire safety design.
1. Introduction
Some decades ago fire safety concentrated on performing fire tests on structural elements in
furnaces. However during the last several decades fire safety has attracted the interest of engineers
and scientists all over the world. Fire safety science still includes fire testing, but now has a main
focus on fundamental research into fire action starting from the combustion process, fire
development and fire spread through the building, as well as the mechanical and thermal behaviour
of materials, their reaction to fire and the performance of the building structure during the fire.
Technical measures for fire protection have been developed and human behaviour in the case of a
fire has been studied.
Based on such fundamental knowledge, advanced calculation methods have been developed using
analytical and numerical tools. The computer simulation of fire and smoke development and their
spread through a building as well as the heating and mechanical behaviour of structural elements
and complete structures have become possible during the last few years. Even models to simulate
human behaviour and escape exist.
Fire is an extreme event that rarely or never occurs during the lifetime of a building. However, once
it occurs it has huge consequences for the safety of the building, its occupants and the rescue teams
and can lead to large financial losses. A growing understanding of the nature of fire, as well as
concepts and measures to control fire has allowed the reduction of the number of disastrous fires to
an acceptable level. Statistical data show that in developed countries the level of fire safety is
steadily increasing. This can be seen from the decreasing number of fire fatalities per year and
100,000 inhabitants in most industrialised countries [1].
IABSE SYMPOSIUM LISBON 2005 2
2.5
Deaths per 100,000 person
Switzerland
1.5 Germany
USA
0.5
0
85
86
88
89
91
93
94
95
96
98
00
97
99
01
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
19
19
20
Table 1 Fire fatalities per 100,000 inhabitants. The number is decreasing for most countries.
In the past, fire safety concepts focused on structural and some organisational measures, whereas
today they include a large proportion of sophisticated technical measures like sprinkler and water
mist systems, smoke detection systems and smoke evacuation systems. About 80% of fire fatalities
occur in dwellings (at home) mostly as single fatalities. In Switzerland structural measures are at a
very high level, while technical measures like smoke detection or even sprinklers are very unusual
in dwellings.
2. Fire action
Fire can only start if combustible material, oxygen and an ignition source are present. The
combustion process releases heat energy, gases and smoke. While the gases and the smoke are the
main killers in a fire (approx. 80% of fire fatalities are due to smoke), heat is the primary reason for
the damage to the structure of a building. The knowledge of the time-temperature development
during a fire in a building is therefore important when analysing the structural behaviour. To
describe the fire action it must be simplified in a model. Several nominal fire curves have been
proposed in codes to be used in the design process. The most frequently applied curves are the ISO
834 fire curve, the ASTM E119 curve or more recently the hydrocarbon and external fire curve as
given in the Eurocodes. They provide a simple relationship for the temperature of the gases in a
compartment as a function of time. They represent a fully developed fire; the significant amount of
time that sometimes elapses from the beginning of the fire to the fully developed fire is neglected.
Further, the cooling down phase of the fire is not taken into account and the nominal fire curves
increase monotonically with time.
IABSE SYMPOSIUM LISBON 2005 3
time [min]
Figure 1 Three temperature-time curves according to Eurocode 1, Part 1-2 [2]
A more realistic model of fires is given by the parametrical fire curves, which take into account the
most important parameters for temperature development, namely:
- the type of combustible material
- the ventilation conditions in the room
- the thermal properties of the enclosures
- the fire fighting action
Parametrical fire curves can be easily calculated with formulas developed for limited boundary
conditions, as given for example in Eurocode 1, Parts 1-2, Appendix A [2].
For a more comprehensive and more detailed analysis, computer simulations may be used, e.g.
multi-room zone models or computational fluid dynamics models. With such simulations more
complicated environments and more detailed parameters can be taken into account than with the
simplified parametrical fire curves. However, employing computer simulations may be time-
consuming and costly.
the building immediately when fire breaks out. A clear layout of the building making it easy for the
occupants to find their way out, as well as (illuminated) signs to direct the occupants to safe exits
and measures to keep tenable conditions in the rooms and escape ways like smoke evacuation and
emergency illumination are important. Computer programs have been developed even to analyse
evacuation [3]. Human behaviour is a challenging interdisciplinary field of research.
5.3.1 Wood
Wood burns at its surface, releases energy and thus contributes to fire propagation. Wood has good
insulation properties and small thermal elongations. Wood changes into charcoal at a temperature of
around 300°C thus loosing section area. For conditions similar to the ISO fire the reduction of the
section area can be described by the burning rate. The burning rate for soft wood is constant with a
value of around 0.7 mm/min.
5.3.2 Concrete
Concrete may spall close to its surface. Spalling reduces the effective cross-section and exposes the
reinforcement. The extent of spalling depends on many parameters such as the moisture content, the
density, the type of gravel, the mechanical stresses, etc. Adding polypropylene fibres (PP) has a
positive effect as the melting of the fibres reduces the vapour pressure produced by the heating of
the moisture.
The penetration of chlorine gases during a fire can lead to post-fire corrosion of the reinforcement.
High temperature gradients in concrete elements may lead to deformation, cracking and shear
failure or anchorage failure, especially where pre-stressed tendons are used which rely on direct
bonding.
IABSE SYMPOSIUM LISBON 2005 6
5.3.3 Steel
Steel heats up quickly due to its high thermal conductivity and therefore loses strength across the
whole sectional area. After the fire the original strength is mostly regained (exception: high strength
and cold formed steel, as well as high strength bolts).
5.3.4 Masonry
Masonry walls exhibit favourable fire behaviour. During the fire the thermal gradient may lead to a
deformation towards or away from the fire, which can then lead to buckling of the wall. The most
important parameters for the fire resistance of masonry walls are the depth of the wall, the type of
brick and the type of mortar. Plastering of the walls has a beneficial effect.
Figure 3 Good construction practice for a single-storey steel building. Multiple bracing and main
elements parallel to fire wall.
Tensile action in composite floors or arching action in concrete flat slabs may increase the fire
resistance of such structures markedly as was demonstrated in the Cardington fire tests (Fig. 4) [6].
Figure 4 Membrane action of composite floors can increase the fire resistance time considerably [6]
Redundant systems which provide alternative load path may guarantee the stability of the building
even if some individual elements collapse during a fire. A generic example is given in Fig. 5 where
the collapse of a column will not lead to the collapse of the floor [5].
IABSE SYMPOSIUM LISBON 2005 8
Figure 5 Generic example for alternative load path providing fire resistance of the complete
structure even with unprotected individual members which fail in case of fire
Figure 7 Reduction of fire resistance in function of the missing area of fire protection for IPE 240
and HEB 300 columns and different coating thickness.
The robustness of fire protection measures should therefore be taken into consideration when
performing fire design.
IABSE SYMPOSIUM LISBON 2005 10
educated engineers seek the benefit of society by providing fire safety and flexible, economically
designed buildings.
10. Conclusions
Fires in buildings can be assessed by engineering methods on a scientific basis. Fire safety
engineering integrates all aspects of fire safety (fire action, structures, human behaviour etc.) and all
type of measures (structural, technical, organisational). By combining performance-based codes and
fire safety engineering safe and efficient fire safety concept can be developed. Fire safety
engineering is still a young discipline and education and dissemination of knowledge is important
for its further development.
11. References
[1] WILMOT T., Newsletter World Fire Statistics Centre, Geneva Association, Geneva, 2004
[2] European Committee for Standardisation (CEN), prEN1991-1.2, Eurocode 1: Actions on
structures Part 1.2: General actions – Actions on structures exposed to fire, CEN, Brussels,
2001.
[3] GWYNNE S., GALEA R., et. al., “Adaptive Decision-Making in Building EXODUS in
Response to Exit Congestion”, Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium IAFSS, ISBN
0925223255, pp. 1041 – 1052, Poitier, 1999
[4] FABER M.H., KÜBLER O., FONTANA M., KNOBLOCH M., Failure Consequences and
Reliability Acceptance Criteria for Exceptional Building Structures, IBK Report Nr. 285, vdf
Hochschulverlag, Zurich, 2004.
[5] FONTANA M., “Beispiele für richtiges Konstruieren für den Brandfall”, [Good construction
practice for steel structures subjected to fire], Stahlbau, Vol. 65, No. 2, 1996, pp 60-63, Ernst
und Sohn, Berlin 1996
[6] KIRBY B. R., “Large Scale Fire Tests: The British Steel European Collaborative Research
Program on the BRE 8-storey Frame”, Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium,
International Association Fire Safety Science, IAFSS, ISBN 4-9900625-5-5, pp. 1129 – 1140,
Melbourne, 1997.
[7] European Committee for Standardisation (CEN), ENV1993-1-2, Eurocode 3: Design of steel
structures Part 1-2: Structural Fire Design, CEN, Brussels, 1996.
[8] SIA Dokumentation 81, Brandrisikobewertung, [Fire risk assessment] Schweizerischer
Ingenieur- und Architektenverein, Postfach 8039 Zürich, 1984.
[9] MAAG T., Risikobasierte Beurteilung der Personensicherheit von Wohnbauten im Brandfall
unter Verwendung von Bayes’schen Netzen, [A risk based approach to life safety in dwellings
during a fire using Bayesian networks] 2004, Dissertation ETH Zürich Nr. 15366, ISBN 3-
7281-2945-3 Zürich, 2004.
[10] FONTANA M., FAVRE J.P., FETZ C., “A survey of 40’000 Building fires in Switzerland",
Journal for Fire Safety Science 32, pp. 137 – 158, Elsevier Science, London, 1999.
[11] Fire Engineering Guidelines, Fire Code Reform Centre Ltd, Sydney, ISBN 0733704549,
Sydney 1996.
[12] FONTANA M., KNOBLOCH M., “Fire Resistance of Steel Columns with Partial Loss of Fire
Protection”, Proceedings of the IABSE Symposium Metropolitan Habitats and Infrastructure
Shanghai, pp. 352-354, IABSE, Zurich, 2004.
[13] Schweizerische Brandschutzvorschriften [Swiss Fire Regulations], 2003, Vereinigung
Kantonaler Feuerversicherungen, VKF, Bundesgasse 20, Bern, 2005