Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The processing of dragon fruit into jams has emerged as a promising solution
against the short shelf life of the fruit at ambient temperature that could limit its
the acidulant used and with the growing preference for natural food additives
among the consumers, the potential use of citrus juices as acidulants in jam
making was explored in this study. With the aim of comparing and evaluating
made with orange, lemon and calamansi juices, the three jam treatments were
moisture content, pH, firmness, total soluble solids content and viscosity, via a
analysis where their total plate count was determined for a period of three weeks.
The results revealed that orange, lemon and calamansi juices gave rise to dragon
fruit jams with rather similar physicochemical properties, except for their pH,
where orange juice gave rise to jams with a significantly higher pH (4.55)
compared to the other treatments, and viscosity, where each jam treatment was
found to have a viscosity that was significantly different from each other. The
jam treatments were also found to have similar sensorial qualities, where the
major differences were the significantly lower acceptability of dragon fruit jams
made with orange juice in terms of their taste (5.81) and overall acceptability
(6.07), as compared to those of the jams made with calamansi juice, which were
6.64 and 6.83, respectively. Additionally, it was demonstrated that all jam
INTRODUCTION
Ever since the dawn of mankind, fruits have undoubtedly become an integral
to have these sources of nourishment well preserved long after their harvesting.
Amid the vast variety of preserved fruits that our ancestors had successfully
fabricated, jams, which might have arisen from a primeval attempt on fruit
Bawa, 2006). Being a technique of fruit preservation that precedes canning and
p.189) and Thakur, et al. (1997 cited in Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006, p.189), jam
homemakers. These products of fruits would then become more popular and
pectin, as well as the principles underlying the generation of the gel matrix of
pectin, sugar and acid. Whilst preparation of jam products involves the
alone would not be enough to give rise to the final products (Vibhakara and
Bawa, 2006). Instead, the acidity of the fruit possesses an equal importance as
p.189), and this aspect of jam making is well managed by what is known as an
acidulant.
Acidulants have been utterly essential in bringing the pH of the jam into the
range that is necessary for the formation of gel, and optimizing the sensory
properties of the final product (Bourne, 2017). Being either acids that are
inherent in fruits or those that are added to the fruits later in the processing,
acidulants have been versatile regardless of their form, such that these
compounds have had critical roles in preservation, flavouring and so on, other
Owing to the fact that no two acids would possess identical physicochemical
Whereas the behaviour of each acid is not dependent upon pH and there is no
necessary preference of one particular acid over another, citric acid is the
juices as acidulants in jam making, as the organic acid content in the juices of
citrus fruits has been found to be comprising of predominantly citric acid, along
with malic and succinic acid (Vandercook, 1977 cited in Liu, Heying and
citrus juices in food industry as additives, as suggested by He, et al. (2011 cited
in Lv, et al., 2015, p.1) and Kelebek and Selli (2011 cited in Lv, et al., 2015,
p.1), has further boosted such potential. In this study, juices of orange, lemon
and calamansi had been chosen as three separate sources of acidulants for jam
making as oranges and lemons are the most widely known instances of citrus
nations (Liu, Heying and Tanumihardjo, 2012; Hoyle and Santos, 2010).
In this study, the effect of different types of citrus juices as acidulants on the
attributes of the final jam product would be investigated via the making and
analysis of dragon fruit jam. Dragon fruit had been selected as the type of fruit
from which jams would be derived as the quality and features of dragon fruit
has made the fruit crop highly demanded in the domestic market of countries
where the fruits are produced, and the international market (Le Bellec, Vaillant
status in the markets around the globe, dragon fruit could have its commercial
success restricted by its short shelf life, as it is only able to last for 3 to 4 days
at room temperature (Le Bellec, Vaillant and Imbert, 2006). This undesirable
attribute of dragon fruit can be easily overcome by having the fruit processed
into jams, whose quality, in turn, is significantly influenced by the acidulant
added therein. Besides, as the flesh of dragon fruits has been found to be of low
The aim of this study was to compare and evaluate the effect of different types
of citrus juices, which are orange, lemon and calamansi juices, as acidulants on
1.2 Objectives
ii. To evaluate the sensory properties of dragon fruit jam made with
juices) as acidulants.
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Jam
for Jams
that is derived from at least one type of fruits by mixing the fruit, which can be
in the form of whole fruit, sliced fruit, fruit pulp or puree that have or have not
to this definition, jams must have been composed of two ingredients, namely
the fruit ingredient and the sweetener, and these ingredients have also been
strictly defined by Codex Alimentarius Commission (2017 p.2) as well. For the
fruit ingredient, Codex Alimentarius Commission (2017 p.3) has specified that
the fruit content of finished jam product shall be at least 45% or 35% in general,
with exception given to certain fruits. In the case of mixed fruit jam, reduction
of the minimum fruit content must be done in accordance with the percentages
of the fruits used. Sweeteners, on the other hand, have been defined as (i) all
sugars that are defined by Codex Alimentarius Commission in its standard for
sugars, (ii) fruit sugars, (iii) syrup of fructose, (iv) brown sugar and (v) honey,
which Codex Alimentarius Commission has defined in its standard for honey.
Codex Alimentarius Commission (2017 p.4) has also permitted the use of any
other proper ingredients of plant origin, such as herbs and spices, provided that
these ingredients are not added with the intention of disguising poor product
Codex Alimentarius Commission (2017 p.4) has mandated that the finished jam
products shall have soluble solids content of 60 to 65%. The upper limit of
permitted soluble solids content for jams has not been restricted to 65%, as it
where the finished products are retailed. The end product shall possess a proper
gel consistency in addition to a colour and flavour that are not deemed to be odd
to the type of fruit to which the jam is derived, while having the flavour and/or
colour imparted by any other ingredients added taken into account. Also, it shall
not contain any defective materials that are commonly found in fruits (Codex
fruits as its main ingredient. According to Vibhakara and Bawa (2006), jams
can be derived from five distinctive forms of fruits, which are (i) fresh fruits, (ii)
fruits under cold storage, (iii) fruits that have received thermal treatment, (iv)
fruits that are treated with sulphur dioxide, and (v) dried or dehydrated fruits.
Whilst all these forms of fruits can be processed into jams, it is claimed that
jams of the highest quality are generally given rise by fresh fruits (Vibhakara
high quality fruit to work with, no matter which form of fruit is intended to be
processed into jam, as the quality of fruit would be the primary determinant of
that of the finished product. The selection of fruit of superior quality is also
essential because it is mostly the original fruit that contributes to the colour and
Another major ingredient of jams, apart from fruits, would be sweetening agents.
product (Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006). Other than giving jams their body and
bulk, sweeteners are held accountable for the texture of jams as these substances
control viscosity of jams by aiding in the formation of gel within the fruit
agents has also made them an eligible preserving agent as they could bind to
moisture in the jam that is needed by the microbes for survival and growth
Being one of the important factors that govern the formation of the gel, gelling
Fishman and Jen (1986 cited in Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006, p.191), a gelling
agent would be considered ideal if the addition of this gelling agent in a product
does not lead to the disruption of product aroma or flavour. Whereas multiple
types of gelling agent, such as gelatin and agar, are applicable in the production
of jams, pectin remains to be the most common one used in fruit and jam
of pectin that occurs naturally in fruits is varying depending on the type of fruit,
its degree of ripeness during the period of processing, and the environmental
gels when it has been dissolved in water. Being a colloid with negative charges
in a fruit substrate that is acidic, pectin would establish a fibrous network with
equilibrium as resulted from the addition of sugar to the colloid. This fibrous
network would then give rise to the gel that is critical for jams (Smith, 2003).
The fourth and the final fundamental constituent of jams would be the acidulants.
Acidulants are added in jams for various purposes. Other than the main function
Though it may have been viewed as a process with definite simplicity, the
Whilst a number of methods have been applicable for the making of jam, all of
these methods would have processed fruits into jam through the basic steps of
fruit preparation, boiling, and finishing (Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006). The
process of jam manufacturing begins with the selection of suitable fruits for
processing, where fruits with full maturity, rich flavour and desirable texture are
desirable. The selected fruits would have their surface cleaned with water to
remove any of the dirt present. In the case where the residues of lead or arsenic
spray may be present on the fruit, the fruit should then be sanitized in a warm
1% hydrochloric acid solution before being rinsed in water (Giridhari Lai, et al.,
Fruit selection would be crucial to the finished jam product as it determines the
(Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006). This ratio is dependent upon the fruit variety, the
degree of ripeness of the fruit, and the desired effect, though the ratio of 1:1 is
commonly employed in most fruit jams as it is suitable for a wide range of fruits
including berries and pineapples. Conversely, for fruits that are sweet and have
low acidity, lesser amount of sugar would have been required (Vibhakara and
Bawa, 2006).
The next step, boiling, is one of the most vital steps in the making of jam. As
Kumar, 1988 cited in Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006, p.199). During the process of
boiling, skimming of the fruit pulp should be done when necessary for the sake
constant stirring of the mixture. Boiling will be continued until the jam has
comprised of three major steps, namely pre-cooling, filling and cooling of filled
jam. According to Rauch (1965 cited in Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006, p.200),
cooling of the jam prior to filling should be done until the jam is close to its
setting point, and extensive control is essential to prevent the limit from being
exceeded so that disruption of the gel and curdling of the jam would not occur.
After that, the cooled jam would then be filled into the glass jars. Filling should
be done in a manner that results in a headspace of 1.25 cm at most for each filled
glass jar. Loose placement of the jar lids on the jars should be done as soon as
filling has taken place, and these lids should be tightened within 2 to 3 min after
the filling process. This would allow the exhaustion of the air from the
headspace of each filled jar. Following the filling process, the filled jam must
not be cooled in a hasty manner. Cooling of the glass jars and their content has
to be done by air cooling and it is carried out until the jam product has been well
set. Upon cooling, condensation of the steam in the headspace of the filled jar
will also take place, and this will result in the creation of a hermetic seal that
can largely prevent the deterioration of the jam product during storage
(Vibhakara and Bawa, 2006). This concludes the basic steps of jam
manufacturing.
2.2 Acidulants
Acidulants are crucial in the processing of jam where the pH of the jam affects
the formation of the gel and determines whether the gel formed would be of
pectin with high degree of methoxylation (HM pectin), is used as the gelling
agent for jam making (Baker, et al., 2004). This is because whilst the properties
of gel are influenced by the concentrations of sugar, pectin and acid, mass
production of jam will usually have the batches of jam cooked to an established
total soluble solids content and with a fixed amount of pectin, leaving the
these acidulants would drive the formation of a network of water and solute
trapping lattice from the precipitated molecules of pectin. They propel the
formation of such a network by reducing the electrostatic repulsion between the
formation among them (Featherstone, 2016). This network of lattice would then
give rise to the gel that gives the jam its body. In addition, via pH reduction,
Acidulants have also been significant in the preservation of jam as they are
germination that will result in the spoilage of jam or even cause foodborne
both the pH-lowering effect of the acidulants as well as the action of the acids
in their undissociated state are accredited for this effect, it is widely known that
the latter plays a predominant role in exhibiting the antimicrobial activity of the
dissociating within the interior of the microorganisms and thus, interfering with
the pH gradient that was maintained across the plasma membrane of the
microbes (Raju and Bawa, 2006). It is also worth mentioning that the pH-
lowering effect of the acidulants would enhance the activity of the undissociated
acids by shifting the equilibrium in a manner that favours the latter. Also, in the
case where preservatives like benzoates are added to jam, acidulants would
Acidulants are also incredibly important for the modification of the flavour of
jam, where their absence would have rendered the product to have an utterly flat
taste. Acidulants allow the development of the flavour of the jam up to its full
to sourness ratio, which is also known as the ratio of brix to acid, can be adjusted
even though it is close to balance in order to have the chief flavour of the jam
expressed and those peripheral flavour notes enhanced so that they would not
characteristics that are not related to each other, and masking the unpleasant
(Dziezak, 2003).
2.2.1.4 Metal Chelation
prevention of oxidative reactions that take place naturally in jam products and
activity, where these acidulants would bind or confine metallic ions that are
present in jams and are the catalysts for these oxidation reactions (Deshpande,
would also exert a synergistic effect on the activity of these antioxidants and
Enhancement of the nutritional value of jam products can also be done with
dehydroascorbic acid would take place, and its occurrence would be associated
with the swift depletion of the activity of vitamins in jams. This reaction can
of a low degree of redox potential that does not favour the oxidation of ascorbic
acid. With that, the recovery of ascorbic acid from its oxidized form is made
qualities, had found that the acidulants would not be as influential as the nature
of the raw fruit materials and the parameters established for the jam production
were, on the sensorial properties of the jam products assessed. This conclusion
had been made from their discovery that the sensorial quality of the different
quince jam products was not correlated with the organic acid profile of these
products at all. Ferreira, et al. (2004) went on to infer that it was the manner in
which the quince pulp was processed that would be the sole determinant of the
quality of the final quince jam product. Whilst the findings and inferences of
Ferreira, et al. (2004) are indeed solid, it is noteworthy that the study was not
able to determine if the organic acids that were detected from the samples were
naturally occurring compounds in the quince pulp or were the acidulants added
during the processing of quince jam, thus making the statement made by
Ferreira, et al. (2004) against the effect of acidulants on the quality of jam to be
inconclusive.
The inference made by Ferreira, et al. (2004) against the efficacy of acidulants
in jam quality optimisation was later overthrown by the findings of Khan, et al.
(2017) in their research on the quality of the newly developed jam that they
showed that jams made from two of the three formulations that employed citric
acid as the acidulant retained their desirable quality best throughout the storage
period. The results had also shown that although jams made with the acidulant
were not significantly better than those that were made without the acidulant in
terms of their quality characteristics at the beginning of the storage period, the
acidulant would later be proven to be essential for the maintenance of the jam
quality as it minimized the undesirable quality changes that took place in the
jams along their storage (Khan, et al., 2017). With these findings of Khan, et al.
(2017), the importance of acidulants on the quality of jams have been effectively
verified.
2.3 Citrus Juices
Making
types of food. Among the citrus juices that are utilized in the food and beverage
industry, lemon juice might have been the most prominent one. Whilst the high
acidity of lemon juice has made it less popular for consumption in its pure form,
it is the same property that grants the juice its miscellaneous uses in the
in juices. Apart from that, its tartness, tanginess and freshness has also made it
2003).
Similar to lemon juice, calamansi juice has also been useful in the preparation
and production of a variety of foods owing to its acidity. In Asian nations, the
(Ramadugu, et al., 2017; Hoyle and Santos, 2010). On top of that, it is also a
regular constituent in marinades and salad dressings (Bhat and Paliyath, 2016).
In certain nations, people have also been using calamansi juice as an additive
for the preparation of various foods (Abdullah, Ch’ng and Yunus, 2012).
As for orange juice, despite this particular citrus juice has yet to have
noteworthy application in the food and beverage industry, its potential for
the acids that contribute to the acidity of the juices of lemon and calamansi are
conducted by Kale, et al. (2012), orange juice was blended with soy milk as an
attempt to mask the unpleasant beany flavour of the latter. This attempt was
proven to be successful as not only that the orange juice had the undesirable
flavour masked, it had also enhanced the likability of the soy milk. The findings
of Kale, et al. (2012) had proven that orange juice could be useful as an
reasonable.
juices as acidulants in jam making comes from the statements made by Igoe and
Hui (1996), Cheong, et al. (2012), Najafpour (2007), and Rababah, Al-u’datt
and Brewer (2015), respectively. According to Igoe and Hui (1996), and
Cheong, et al. (2012), citric acid, which is an acidulant that is commonly used
in the production of jams, are present in the fruits of lemons, calamansi as well
as oranges as the acid of predominance. Igoe and Hui (1996), and Najafpour
(2007) had also stated that this acid is extractable from, but not limited to, the
juices of lemon. On the other hand, the abundance of citric acid in the particular
juices of lemon had also been highlighted by Rababah, Al-u’datt and Brewer
(2015), and according to them, it is this attribute that leads to the frequent
lemon, calamansi and orange are neither the primary sources of commercial
citric acid nor the main acidulants employed in jam manufacturing, the above
as the juices of other citrus fruits, as acidulants in jam making (Igoe and Hui,
The capability of citrus juices as acidulants in the making of jam has also been
a citrus juice that is known for its acidity, lemon juice has had its antimicrobial
(2006), lemon juice was found to be inhibitory against seven Vibrio strains,
the citric acid present therein, saying that this acid inhibited microbial growth
via a mode of action that is the same as that of the commercial, synthetic
acidulants. On the other hand, the antibacterial properties of lemon juice was
evaluated and compared against those of orange juice in a research carried out
by Aburowais, Banu and Nisha (2017). In their research, Aburowais, Banu and
Nisha (2017) discovered that the antibacterial activity of lemon juice was
evident and superior as compared to that of orange juice, as the former was
found to be effective in inhibiting the growth of five of the six microbial strains
microbe of concern in canned foods, while orange juice was shown to be non-
properties of orange juice as the juice was shown to be inhibitory against all of
Mothershaw and Jaffer (2004) inferred that the inhibitory effect of orange juice
against the microbes was contributed by the low pH of the juice, and that orange
juice’s antibacterial activity was heavily dependent upon its pH. While the
explain the contradiction between the results obtained by Aburowais, Banu and
Nisha (2017), and Mothershaw and Jaffer (2004), the antibacterial activity of
On the other hand, the antibacterial activity of calamansi juice had also been
prolong the shelf life of the latter by improving its microbiological stability.
coincided with the decrease in the microbial load of sugarcane juice. On top of
that, it had also been discovered that the extent of decrement in both the total
plate count as well as the yeast and mould count of sugarcane juice was directly
A number of health benefits have been associated with dragon fruit owing to
the nutritional and functional components that are found in the flesh and seed
fruit is perhaps best known as a rich source of minerals, with substances such
as sodium, magnesium, potassium as well as phosphorus present in the fruit in
amounts that are remarkable and are apparently greater than those of other
tropical fruits including pineapple and mango (Liaotrakoon, 2013). Dragon fruit
is also rich in certain vitamins like vitamins C and B3, despite other vitamins,
namely vitamin A, vitamin B1 and vitamin B2, are found in the fruit in rather
making up part of the oligosaccharides that exist in the dragon fruit, and these
The seeds of the dragon fruit are also an undeniable contributor to the nutritional
value of the fruit as well. The presence of vitamin E and essential fatty acids in
these edible seeds in considerable amount have given rise to seed oil that
contains properties that are beneficial to human health. Besides, the seeds of
dragon fruit may also contain insoluble fibre such as cellulose and
Apart from its nutritional value, dragon fruit has also been known to be
considerably greater than those in other tropical fruits including lychee and
oxygen and metal chelators, in dragon fruit (Liaokratoon, 2013). On the other
hand, it has also been discovered that the red-fleshed dragon fruit variety
Other than the antioxidative activity, dragon fruit is said to be exhibiting anti-
proliferative activity as well (Kim, et al., 2011 cited in Liaokratoon, 2013, p.20).
Whilst dragon fruit has been popular in Asia as well as South America, it was a
relative unknown for Europeans and North Americans until mid-1990s (Le
Bellec and Vaillant, 2011). Although it is still being labelled as a niche product,
exports of dragon fruit from the producer countries have seen a considerable
increase in recent years, and now the fruit has earned a place in the retail of rare
exotic fruits (Le Bellec, Vaillant and Imbert, 2006). Whilst the implementation
of commercial policies in some countries from which dragon fruits are produced
and exported has been the driving force behind the success of dragon fruit in the
market of exotic fruits, the inherent qualities and attributes of the fruit is equally
important for it to gain its current status (Le Bellec and Vaillant, 2011).
At the present time, there are two main segments in the market that the dragon
fruit attracts, namely Asian and European customers. Asian customers’ demand
for the fruit is rather regular along the year, and the trade of dragon fruit in this
market segment usually peaks at the Spring Festival (Le Bellec, Vaillant and
fruits on a regular basis throughout the year. Instead, the purchase of dragon
fruit by these customers would primarily take place during the Christmas season,
which is also when dragon fruit, along with other exotic fruits, is popularized
Vaillant and Imbert (2006), dragon fruit has a rather short shelf life at this
temperature range, where it is able to remain fit for human consumption for only
3 to 4 days. Despite the shelf life of dragon fruit can be improved by subjecting
the fruit to storage at low temperature, rapid deterioration of the eating quality
of the dragon fruit would inevitably take place once the fruit is moved out of
cold storage (Nerd, et al., 1999 cited in Le Bellec and Vaillant, 2011, p.263).
This has been proven by Nerd, et al. (1999, cited in Mercado-Silva, 2018, p.344),
who reported an abrupt decrease in malic acid content as well as a great decrease
of firmness in the dragon fruit, which was previously stored at 6 ºC, once the
fruit was removed from storage and exposed to ambient conditions. The
be tackled by having the fruit processed into jams, which as a means of fruit
preservation, can prolong the shelf life of the fruit and maintain its eating quality
for a greater period of time at ambient temperature, thus justifying the making
3.1 Materials
3.1.1 Ingredients
The ingredients utilized for this study had been classified into three categories,
namely fruits, sweetener and thickener. Whilst all of the fruits were purchased
obtained from the hypermarket TESCO and Siti Bakery Ingredients House
(Hylocereus
polyrhizus
Rose)
sinensis (L.)
Osbeck)
limon (L.)
Burm.)
(Citrus
microcarpa)
sugar
balance
FORNELLO
2000
cabinet
analyser
Systems
Three treatments of dragon fruit jam, each of which differs in the citrus juice
Ingredient (Weight, g)
sugar
The dragon fruit was processed into jam in accordance with the procedure as
Firstly, the cut and sliced pulp of dragon fruit was simmered over medium heat
by means of induction cooker, with the cooking power set to be 500 W. After
simmering had been allowed to persist for 5 min, fine granulated sugar was
added and the mixture was mixed well. Concurrently, the cooking power of the
boil for 5 min before the particular citrus juice (calamansi/orange/lemon juice)
was added. Subsequently, the mixture was allowed to boil for another 5 min,
and 2.5 g of pectin powder was added into the mixture. Simultaneously, the
cooking power of the induction cooker was reduced to 500 W. The mixture was
stirred well and finally, the jam produced was hot filled into a Mason jar that
had been sterilized prior. The jam sample was stored at room temperature until
Basu and Shivhare (2012), such that the colour of each jam sample was
determined via a colorimeter that was calibrated with standard white calibration
plate prior to the measurement. Illuminant D65 and 10°viewing angle were
employed as the references for the colorimeter, which would measure colour by
CIELAB colour space. For each jam sample, an adequate amount of the sample
was placed in a Petri dish such that the dish was completely filled with the
sample. The values of L*, a* and b*, which represent lightness, redness to
colorimeter for each sample. The colour measurement of each jam treatment
was conducted in triplicate and the results were expressed as mean ± standard
deviation.
3.2.2.2 Measurement of Moisture Content
analyser. For each jam sample, 2.0 g of the sample was spread evenly on a glass
fibre sheet, which was then placed on a disposable aluminium foil pan. The
aluminium foil pan, together with the content within, was placed onto the
sample pan of the moisture analyser. Quick mode operation was selected as the
measurement method used by the moisture analyser for this analysis, whereby
each sample would be subjected to heating at 200°C for about 3 min before the
drying temperature would be lowered to the temperature that was set for the
program, which was 160°C (A&D Company, 2004). The measurement would
moisture content for each jam treatment was completed in triplicate and the
3.2.2.3 Measurement of pH
The pH value of each jam sample was measured with a pH meter. Before
pH 4.0, 7.0 and 9.0. The pH value of each sample was obtained by having the
electrode dipped into the sample after it was rinsed with distilled water and
wiped clean. The pH measurement was completed in triplicate for each jam
probe of 36 mm in diameter was employed for the analysis. The jam sample, as
contained in a jar, was placed on a heavy duty platform. The sample was then
compressing the sample at a velocity of 1.0 mm/s. Once the probe had
compressed the sample for a distance of 8 mm, it would then stop the
The texture of each sample was expressed as its firmness. For each jam
treatment, texture analysis was conducted in triplicate and the results were
The total soluble solids of each jam sample was measured via a refractometer,
which was calibrated with distilled water before each measurement was taken.
An adequate amount of jam sample was placed on the prism of the refractometer
such that the prism was completely covered by the sample. The total soluble
measurement of total soluble solids for each jam treatment was conducted in
number 6 was employed for the measurement. The measurement was done by
having the spindle submerged in the sample and allowing it to rotate at a rotating
speed of 5 rpm for 1 min. The viscosity of the sample would then be calculated
by the viscometer. The viscosity measurement for each jam treatment was
deviation.
Olivera and Salvadori (2009 cited in Tan, 2017, p.37). The sensory test
employed for this sensory evaluation was acceptance test, whereby 75 untrained
panellists from Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman were recruited and required to
each of the nine verbal responses was assigned with a number, with ‘9’ being
assigned to the response of ‘Like extremely’, ‘1’ being assigned to the response
of ‘Dislike extremely’, and a central point of ‘5’ that represented ‘Neither like
nor dislike’ (Olivera and Salvadori, 2009 cited in Tan, 2017, p.37; Wichchukit
and O’Mahony, 2014). Each of the jam samples served was assigned with a
three-digit random code and the samples were served in random order based on
the master sheet constructed prior. The panellists were mandated to rinse their
mouths with the rinsing water provided before evaluating each sample. The
sensory test was conducted in a sensory evaluation laboratory for interference
standard deviation (Olivera and Salvadori, 2009 cited in Tan, 2017, p.37).
Total plate count of each jam sample was determined throughout a storage
period of three weeks where the samples were stored at room temperature
(Gómez, et al., 2013). The analysis of total plate count was conducted based on
the pour plate method as described by Maturin and Peeler (2001), with slight
of the sample with 225 mL of Ringer’s solution and subjecting the mixture to
and 10-3 were prepared from the homogenate. One mL of each prepared dilution
was then transferred to two empty, sterile Petri plates, before 15-20 mL of
cooled molten plate count agar was added to each plate. Thorough and uniform
mixing of the mixture was done by rotating each plate in alternate directions,
and subjecting the plates to back-and-forth motion. The agar was allowed to
solidify before the plates were incubated at 37°C for 48 h. Following incubation,
the number of colonies observed on each plate was counted. Only plates with
25-250 colonies were taken into consideration, whereas counts were recorded
to be too few to count (TFTC) and too numerous to count (TNTC) for plates
with less than 25 colonies or more than 250 colonies, respectively. Total colony
forming units per gram of jam sample (cfu/g) was calculated for each jam
The data obtained from each analysis were subjected to statistical analysis using
(ANOVA) was conducted among the data for each analysis to determine the
presence of significant difference among the mean values of the jam treatments
at significance level of p ≤ 0.05, and for the mean values in which significant
test was conducted to identify the pair(s) of mean values that is significantly
different.
CHAPTER 4
RESULTS
The results of physicochemical analysis that had been conducted on the samples
triplicate measurements that had been done, are shown in Table 4.1. The three
moisture content, texture and total soluble solids content, with no significant
difference existing among the mean values of these three treatments as obtained
orange juice as acidulant, had been found to acquire a distinctive and markedly
higher pH value. On top of that, in terms of viscosity, the three jam treatments
differed from each other significantly, with Treatment B (Dragon fruit jam made
with orange juice as acidulant) and Treatment C (Dragon fruit jam made with
lemon juice as acidulant) obtaining the highest and lowest mean values of
Colour
content (%)
solids (ºBrix)
The sensory scores obtained for the jam treatments with regards to their aroma,
mean ±standard deviation of the scores given by 75 panellists and are presented
in Table 4.2. The three jam treatments had shown no significant difference in
the degree to which their aroma is liked, with mean scores ranging from 5.57 to
5.80. Likewise, the absence of significant difference was also recorded in the
mouthfeel, where all of these treatments were indicated to possess a look and a
texture that were in overall, liked moderately and slightly by the panellists,
respectively. Apart from that, the taste of Treatment A (Dragon fruit jam made
with calamansi juice as acidulant) had been found to be significantly more well
(Dragon fruit jam made with lemon juice) was not significantly different from
the previous two treatments. Similar trend had also been observed on the overall
acceptability among the jam treatments. Whilst the acceptability of the three
jam treatments on the various sensory parameters evaluated had been positive,
it is noteworthy that Treatment A (Dragon fruit jam made with calamansi juice
as acidulant) had scored a relatively higher mean values in all attributes than the
other two treatments, whereas Treatment B, on the other hand, had been
recorded with the lowest mean scores among the jam treatments.
Table 4.2: Mean sensory scores of the jam treatments with regards to the
sensory parameters evaluated.
Treatment A B C
acceptability
Table 4.3 showed the total plate count (cfu/g) of samples of the three jam
table, it is indicated that the samples, regardless of the period of storage, had
been constantly giving rise to plates with less than 25 colonies, and such
A B C
DISCUSSION
A number of trends had been observed from the results of the physicochemical
analysis conducted against the three jam treatments. Firstly, the analysis of the
colour of each of the three treatments had shown that none of the treatments had
values obtained for the three treatments were found to be lacking of significant
explained by plausible theory, the obtained values of L*, a* and b* for the jam
they are compared against those obtained for the pulp of different varieties of
dragon fruit as conducted by Chemah, et al. (2011). As the samples of all three
jam treatments employed red-fleshed dragon fruits, they were expected, and did
possess a colour that did not deviate much from the original dragon fruit pulp
colour. In other words, they were supposed to have L*, a* and b* values that
match those of the red-fleshed dragon fruit pulp. Whilst the L* values of the
treatments were indeed close to the L* value of the pulp of the red dragon fruit
undatus), in accordance with the results obtained from the experiment executed
by Chemah, et al. (2011). The only plausible reason behind this phenomenon is
that the seeds present in the dragon fruit jam might have been widely dispersed
over the Petri dish to which the samples were added and the readings were taken,
thus causing the colorimeter to measure the colour of the seeds themselves
rather than the true colour of the jam sample. This is supported by the fact that
the L* values of the three treatments, which indicate the lightness of the colour
detected and were ranging from 29.31 to 29.74, are not even close to the L*
value of the white dragon fruit pulp, which was 54.9 as according to the results
obtained by Chemah, et al. (2011). The lower L* value of the samples have also
indicated that the colour detected is much darker than that of the pulp of H.
Whilst the values of a* and b* of the three jam treatments were out of
expectations, it is deduced that all of the citrus juices used as the acidulant for
the dragon fruit jam did give rise to samples with a colour that is similar to the
pulp of the red-fleshed dragon fruit, judging from the similarity between the L*
values of the treatments and that of the red-fleshed dragon fruit pulp, as well as
the visual appearance of the samples. The retention of the colour of the pulp in
the jam samples could be attributed to the ability of each of the citrus juices to
within the red-fleshed pitahaya’s pulp, and prevent it from degradation upon
acid, along with ascorbic and isoascorbic acids, is able to enhance the stability
of betacyanin which would otherwise decompose and result in colour loss upon
heating. As the citrus juices are rich in citric and ascorbic acids, it is apparent
that these juices were responsible for the preservation of colour in the dragon
Other than the values of L*, a* and b*, the three jam treatments had also shown
35.06% to 38.44%, the mean moisture content obtained for the three jam
treatments is reasonable as the range does not deviate much from the range of
Naeem, et al. (2017). On the other hand, it has also been discovered that the
moisture content of the jam samples is enormously lower than that of the dragon
fruit, which ranges from 83% to 89% according to Liaotrakoon (2013). The
removal of the jam samples upon thermal treatment, as the samples were
allowed to boil for 10 min. In other words, the source of acidulant would have
Despite there has been no significant difference over the colour and moisture
content of the three jam treatments, the different type of citrus juices used had
been proven to be influential to the pH of the jam samples. This was indicated
by the results that Treatment B (Dragon fruit jam made with orange juice as the
acidulant) had a significantly higher pH than the other two jam treatments. The
evidently resulted from the difference in acidity of the citrus fruits to which the
citrus juices were extracted. According to Bamise and Oziegbe (2013), and Lee
(2000), among the three citrus juices that were employed for the current
experiment, orange juice would be the one with the lowest acidity, and
calamansi juice, on the other hand, would be the most acidic citrus juice. This
was proven by the results of their analyses, whereby the mean pH of the juices
of oranges, lemons and calamansi were found to be 4.0, 3.1 and 2.4, respectively
(Bamise and Oziegbe, 2013; Lee, 2000). These findings are discovered to be
matching with the results obtained for the current experiment, where Treatment
B (Dragon fruit jam made with orange juice as the acidulant) was determined to
be the treatment with the highest pH, and Treatment A (Dragon fruit jam made
with calamansi juice as the acidulant) was found to have the lowest pH among
the three treatments analysed, thus justifying the positive correlation between
the acidity of the citrus juice used and that of the dragon fruit jam.
the three jam treatments, the results of texture analysis revealed that such
difference would have no influence over the firmness of the three jam treatments.
As the firmness of the jam treatments reflects the strength of the gel structure
(2016), the amount of pectin used would be the pivotal determinant of the
continuity of the gel structure formed, which in turn influences the gel strength.
On the other hand, the acidity, and the concentration of the sugar in the jam
would control the rigidity of the gel (Featherstone, 2016). As both the amount
of pectin and sugar employed in the formulation of the three jam treatments was
the same, the absence of significant difference among the firmness of the three
was found to be existing among the pH of the jam treatments, the results of
firmness suggested that the difference in pH was not extensive enough to lead
citrus juices used as the acidulant is speculated to have no notable effect on the
Next, a similar trend had also been observed for the results of total soluble solids
content of the three jam treatments, where significant difference was found to
be absent. The total soluble solids content of the three jam treatments, which
ranged from 74.77% to 77.10%, is rather similar with those of the strawberry
jam analysed by Owolade, et al. (2016), the latter of which exhibited a mean
total soluble solids content of 80.00% at Day 0 of storage. This indicates that
the results of total soluble solids of the jam treatments are rather unsurprising
Aishikin and Nurul Ain, 2017, p.51), there exists a high and positive correlation
between the sugar content of a jam and its total soluble solids content.
Consequently, as the amount of sugar used in the formulation of the three jam
treatments was constant, the absence of significant difference among the total
soluble solids content of the jam treatments is rational and reasonable. Apart
from that, the obtained results have also indicated that the type of citrus juices
used as the acidulant would not pose an impact on the total soluble solids
content of the dragon fruit jam, despite Liu, Heying and Tanumihardjo (2012)
pointed out that orange juice has markedly higher sugar content compared to
lemon juice. This is likely to be owing to the amount of citrus juice added to
each jam sample. With only 5 mL of citrus juice added to each sample that was
in turn derived from 250 g of dragon fruit pulp, it is reasoned that the distinction
in the total sugar content of the citrus juice would be too minimal to lead to a
difference in the total sugar content and ultimately, the total soluble solids
Finally, the results of the viscosity of the jam treatments revealed that the three
different citrus juices used as the acidulant for the jam treatments had given rise
to dragon fruit jam with viscosity that was distinctive from one another.
Whereas Treatment C (Dragon fruit jam made with lemon juice as the acidulant)
did have a viscosity (73333.33 mPa·s) that is within the viscosity range
exhibited by the commercial jam samples examined by Jaiswal, Patel and Naik
(2015), which was 36820-78980 mPa·s, Treatment A (Dragon fruit jam made
with calamansi juice as the acidulant) and Treatment B (Dragon fruit jam made
with orange juice as the acidulant) had a noticeably higher viscosity compared
difference in either the average molecular weight of the solutes present in the
jam, or the suspended matter present in the jam, or even both. If the average
molecular weight of the solutes was the sole factor that resulted in the distinction
in the viscosity among the jam treatments, it would indicate that the average
molecular weight of solutes of the dragon fruit jam made with orange juice
would be the greatest among the three jam treatments, and that lemon juice
would have given rise to dragon fruit jam with the lowest average molecular
weight of solutes, based on the relationship between viscosity and the molecular
was attributed to merely the difference in the suspended matter, it would then
infer that the dragon fruit jam with the greatest concentration of suspended
matter would be the one that employed orange juice, followed by those that were
derived from calamansi juice, and lemon juice. Unfortunately, the inferences
made could not be validated as the average molecular weight of solutes, as well
as the concentration of suspended matter of each of the citrus juices are yet to
such aspects not feasible at the moment. Nevertheless, the type of citrus juices
used as the acidulant has been proven by the results to be influential on the
acidulants on the sensorial properties of the dragon fruit jam can be made based
speculated that the acidulant used would not influence, impart or enhance the
aroma of the dragon fruit jam, as there is no significant difference among the
mean scores obtained for the acceptability of each jam treatment in terms of
aroma. Whilst the generalized response towards the aroma of the three jam
treatments was leaning towards neutral, there had been a considerable number
of panellist who commented that little or no aroma had been detected from the
served jam samples. This can be explained by the effect of heat treatment on the
aroma-active compounds of the freshly-squeezed citrus juices used as the
that has been extracted manually is not stable, and its aroma composition would
the orange juice that has received thermal processing would have its flavour
of the original volatile compounds in the juice as induced by the heat treatment
(Bazemore, Goodner and Rouseff, 1999 cited in Perez-Cacho and Rouseff, 2008,
p.9785). Considering that the jams were allowed to boil for another 5 min after
the addition of the citrus juices as the acidulant, the heat treatment had likely
resulted in the weak or absence of aroma in the final dragon fruit jam samples.
In addition to the aroma of the three jam treatments, the panellists had no
preference on any of the jam samples served in terms of their appearance. The
obtained results for the acceptability of the appearance of the three jam
treatments indicated that every treatment had received a mean score that is close
mean scores. As Leon, et al. (2006 cited in Tanner, 2016, p.2) stated that the
was inferred that the acceptability of the appearance of the jam treatments was
attributed to the natural colours of the dragon fruit pulp. Consequently, the
acidulants should also be accredited for the results owing to their function of
observed in both the mean scores of the acceptability in appearance and the
values of L*, a* and b* obtained by the three jam treatments has also reinforced
the proposition that the three citrus juices added to the dragon fruit jam had
As for the acceptability in terms of taste, significant difference had been found
to be existing among the mean scores obtained for the three jam treatments. The
taste of Treatment A (Dragon fruit jam made with calamansi juice as the
jam made with orange juice as the acidulant), and the acceptability of the taste
of Treatment C (Dragon fruit jam made with lemon juice as the acidulant) was
of that, a number of panellists had also remarked that the jam samples served
were considerably too sweet to be evaluated alone without the use of bread as
carrier. This leads to the speculation that the significant difference obtained for
the acceptability of the taste of the three jam treatments is resulted from the
differing extent to which the sweetness of the dragon fruit jam was cut by the
citrus juices added. According to Agam (1994), acidulants are essential for the
supplying a “sour” taste to the food. The “sour” taste, on the other hand, is
dependent upon the pH and the organic acid content of the acidulants (Da
Conceicao Neta, et al., 2007). Whilst the organic acid content of the three jam
treatments had not been analysed, the results of the analysis of pH do support
to Treatment B. This would mean that calamansi juice (Treatment A) was able
to impart a greater sourness to the dragon fruit jam and hence, reduce the
sweetness of the sugar to a greater extent compared to orange juice. On the other
hand, the pH of Treatment C was found to be significantly different from
distinguishable from each other. Considering that both the pH and acceptability
organic acid profile of each of the citrus juice used. Nonetheless, the correlation
between the sourness imparted by the used acidulant and the acceptability of the
taste of the dragon fruit jam infers that the panellists had a preference on
whichever jam sample that was less sweeter than the others, thus explaining the
Whereas the taste of the three jam treatments were found to be liked to a
otherwise. All jam treatments evaluated had received a mean score that is close
to 6, showing that the mouthfeel of each of these jam treatments was liked
slightly by the panellists. The results obtained for the acceptability of mouthfeel
of the jam treatments were apparently attributed to the structure and properties
of the gel formed therein, which in turn were influenced by the acidulant in
conjunction with sugar and pectin. Whilst the results obtained for the
acceptability in mouthfeel of the three jam treatments match that of the firmness
of the jam treatments, such that significant difference was found to be absent in
both, an opposite trend is observed when the former is compared against the
results of the viscosity of the jam treatments, to which significant difference had
been found to be existing. Such contradiction would suggest that the difference
in the viscosity of the jam treatments did not influence the acceptability of the
Last but not least, the results obtained for the overall acceptability of the jam
treatments indicated that Treatment A (Dragon fruit jam made with calamansi
made with orange juice) in overall, and Treatment C (Dragon fruit jam made
with lemon juice) had been found to be indistinguishable from the other
treatments. Considering that the results obtained for overall acceptability of the
jam treatments are rather similar in trend to that of the taste of the jam treatments,
and significant difference was found to be absent among all the other sensory
attributes evaluated, it was apparent that the overall acceptability of the jam
treatments.
The results of the microbiological analysis conducted against the samples of the
three jam treatments have indicated that the dragon fruit jam, regardless of the
type of citrus juices used as the acidulant, would be microbiologically stable for
at least three weeks following its preparation, when stored under room
effect of the different citrus juices as well as the synergistic antimicrobial effect
of pH by the acidulants and the heat treatment that the jam samples had received.
In the first round of microbiological examination, all the samples of the three
jam treatments, which were prepared 1 day prior to the analysis, had given rise
to plates with less than 25 colonies. This result was mainly resulted from the
heat treatment that the jam samples received and the employed technique of hot
filling during the transfer and storage of jam samples in Mason jars, as
Besides, the acidulant used in each jam treatment is also a critical cause as well.
All of the pH of the final jam samples were 4.55 or below, thus making the
dragon fruit jam a high-acid food possessing a pH value that is not greater than
4.6 (McGlynn, 2016). Being a high-acid food would mean the dragon fruit jam
does not require a severe heat treatment that would be compulsory for those
foods with pH of greater than 4.6. Instead, the heat treatment of the dragon fruit
of the viable microorganisms present in the food matrix. Therefore, since each
temperature greater than 99°C, and allowed to boil for 10 min upon its
preparation, the results for the first round of microbiological analysis was
completely reasonable.
The samples of the three jam treatments, which had been stored under room
temperature, would continue to give rise to plates with fewer than 25 colonies
as the dragon fruit jam samples had been well preserved by means of pH control
via the acidulants in addition to the control of water activity by the sugar
stability in these foods. Whilst citric acid and malic acid, as the predominant
organic acids in citrus juices, are not lipophilic and thus, are not capable of
equilibrating across the cell membrane of the microbes in the absence of specific
Kroll (1985 cited in Shafiur Rahman, 2007, p.291), by lowering the pH of the
dragon fruit jam, the acidulants would be able to limit the rate of microbial
the surface layers of microbial cells, and obstructing the uptake and excretion
antimicrobial effect of the citrus juices used as the acidulant for each of the three
jam treatments.
that of a similar analysis conducted by Rodiah, Nurul Aishikin and Nurul Ain
(2017) against their newly developed banana jam. However, their research had
predominantly the action of this preservative rather than the acidulant, though
the antimicrobial effect of the latter could be critical as well. This in turn
suggests that the dragon fruit jam must have not been preserved by solely pH
According to Raju and Bawa (2006), the dragon fruit jam might have also been
protected by the chelating action of citric acid towards essential minerals, which
microorganisms, as these compounds are vital for their growth. They also
argued that the chelating action of citric acid on essential metal ions would be
the primary mechanism behind the acid’s antimicrobial effect, rather than its
On the other hand, Steward-Woods (2017) discovered that the lemon juice acts
on the bacteria by a method that is distinctive from acidity in his research on the
would affect the bacteria by interfering with the RNA synthesis within these
microorganisms. Other than that, the flavonoids present in the lemon juice are
also accountable for its antimicrobial effect (Steward-Woods, 2017). Given the
similarity of the three citrus juices used in the current research, these findings
jam treatments.
Several types of analyses can be taken into consideration for future research in
the properties of the dragon fruit jam. Firstly, determination of the yeast and
mould count of the jam treatments can be carried out to further reinforce the
interpretations and the results of the conducted microbiological analysis that all
of the citrus juices are capable of inhibiting yeast and mould growth in the
antioxidant activity of dragon fruit jam made with the three different citrus
understanding can be gained on the effect of different type of citrus juices used
CONCLUSION
quality of dragon fruit jam made with different type of citrus juices (orange,
samples of dragon fruit jam, regardless of the type of citrus juices used as the
soluble solids content. On the other hand, the type of citrus juices used was
proven to be influential to the pH of dragon fruit jam, with orange juice being
discovered to have given rise to dragon fruit jam with pH that was significantly
higher than those of the jams as derived from lemon and calamansi juices. On
top of that, it has also been found that each of the citrus juices used would give
rise to dragon fruit jam with viscosity that was distinctive from one another.
As for the sensorial properties, it has been proven that the type of citrus juices
used as the acidulant would not pose an influence of the acceptability of the
dragon fruit jam in terms of its aroma, appearance and mouthfeel. The taste and
overall acceptability of dragon fruit jam, however, was indeed dependent upon
the type of citrus juices used. It was indicated that calamansi juice, owing to its
superior acidity over orange juice, had given rise to dragon fruit jam that was
give rise to dragon fruit jams that were well received by the panellists in terms
citrus juices were not able to impart a likable aroma in these dragon fruit jams.
Last but not least, it has also been implied that each of the citrus juices used was
able to preserve the dragon fruit jam to an extent where the jam, when stored at
difference in the antimicrobial activity of the citrus juices used, as all of these
citrus juices were shown to have the ability to inhibit microbial growth and
proliferation in the dragon fruit jam for at least three weeks, even when the jam
had been stored under the condition that was in microorganisms’ favour.