Sculpture Critique - Lidded Box

Name: Title of Work:

3 complete sentences

1. Describe the craftsmanship of your box. Is it neat? Did it hold together well? What details did you pay
attention to?

2. What was your word? How did you incorporate your word into your box? Be specific.

4. What advice would you give to a future Sculpture student completing this project?

5. How well did you manage your time and resources throughout the process of creating this box? Do
you see areas you could improve?

On a separate piece of paper complete the 4 step critique process for a peers’ work. 3
complete sentences for each step. Staple critiques together.
 Category A 20-19 B 18-17 C 16-15 D-F 14-0 Criteria I am
Excellent, Very Good, Average/Develo Undeveloped looking at in
Outstanding Above Average ping Below Average work

Directions/ Met all project Met all project Met majority of Did not meet Referred to
Project requirements. requirements project expectations. sketches and
Directions Went above and and expectations requirements. Very few research,
beyond Followed Followed requirements worked hard
expectations. directions directions with met, did not when facing
Followed prompting follow adversity
directions directions

Creativity/ Researched and Selected best Did not fully Incomplete Thought and
Originality sketched several idea of three, develop 3 ideas. sketches, poor effort put into
ideas before created an Average design design designs.
settling on 1. interesting and execution quality/creative
Created design choices
interesting and represented in
original design final

Craftsmanship Excellent Very good Average Poor Box is neat and

craftsmanship. craftsmanship, craftsmanship. craftsmanship well made.
Displays displays Evidence of Held together
understanding understanding of rushed/sloppy in the kiln.
and mastery of process work Glazed neatly
process

Daily Effort Evidence of Student worked Project was Project Worked

and Time pride in work hard and finished but it completed with throughout
Management through effort, completed the could have been minimal effort. class. Did not
exhibits project, good improved with Student lacked distract others.
excellent time time more effort focus and time Completed on
management management management time

Critique Critique is well Well written, Majority Does not meet Time and
written and reflective answers are at sentence thought placed
thoughtful. critique, meets least 3 requirement into critique
Evidence of care sentence sentences. evidenced by
in writing. requirement reflection
Meets sentence
requirement

Comments: Total: