CENTRO ESCOLAR UNIVERSITY

School of Accountancy and Management

Manila

RATING SHEET FOR STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT CASE DEFENSE

Date:____________________________

CASE:______________________________________ CLASS: _______________________________

PLEASE CHECK YOUR RATING OF THE DEFENDING GROUP BASED ON THE CRITERIA BELOW
USING THE LEGEND: 5–Strongly agree, 4-Agree, 3-Moderately agree, 2-Disagree, 1-Strongly
disagree

A. PREPARATION (20 points)

NO. CRITERIA 5 4 3 2 1
1 ATTIRE – The members of the group were
dressed appropriately well (with name tags).
2 DOCUMENTS – Members had copies of the
case facts and the case report.
3 DECORATIONS – The group prepared
appropriate decorations.
4 TIME MANAGEMENT – The program started
and ended on time.

B. PRESENTATION (30 points)

NO. CRITERIA 5 4 3 2 1
5 ORIGINALITY – The presentation was original
and well-conceptualized.
6 CLARITY – The points raised in the
presentation were clear to me.
7 COMPLETENESS – All the salient points of the
case were included in the presentation.
8 ABILITY TO SUSTAIN INTEREST – My interest
was sustained during the entire presentation.
9 TECHNOLOGY – The presentation made use
of audio-visual technology.
10 CREATIVITY – The presentation was creative
and well-thought.

C. DEFENSE (50 points)

NO. CRITERIA 5 4 3 2 1
11 CORRECTNESS – The answers of the group
were precise, accurate and correct.
12 KNOWLEDGE OF THE PAPER – The group
seemed to know the case very well.
13 EXPLANATION – The group members were
successful in explaining their answers.
14 COMMUNICATION – The use of the English
language was maximized.
15 COURTESY – Questions were answered
politely, courteously and professionally.
16 TEAMWORK – The group helped each other
during the question-and-answer proper.
17 APPLICATION – The members applied
pertinent Strategic Management principles.
18 PARTICIPATION – All group members were
able to answer at least one question.
19 DISPOSITION – The group seemed to enjoy
what they are doing.
20 CONVINCING POWER – The group members
seemed to know what they were talking about.

/emtichepco