Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
INTRODUCTION
1.0 Overview
This section of the research work comprises the background to the study which gives the
description of work to be done. It also contains the statement of the problem, causes of the problem,
the purpose of the project, the significance of the study and the delimitation and limitation of the
study.
Science is defined as the systematic study of things around us. It is a broad field of study which
uses unconfounded empirical tests to develop, discover, and explain systematic frameworks within
which relationships can be explored, studied, and established. Chemistry is one major branch of
science which deals with the study of matter and its composition and properties. One area that
needs special attention in chemistry, is the area of the study of gases because of its abstract nature.
According to Stavy (1988), the studies related to gases are quite problematic because of the
abstract, mostly invisible nature of gases which raises the level of difficulty for students’ learning.
Students have difficulty relating the various conditions under which gases are studied – pressure,
volume and temperature. The concept related to gases are examples of chemistry concepts that
attracted the attention of science education researchers (Çetin et al., 2009; Schuttlefield et al.,
2012). Kautz et al (2008), investigated students’ understanding of the ideal gas law. It was
suggested that after instruction many students were not able to correctly interpret and apply the
ideal gas law. In particular, difficulties with pressure, volume and Avogadro’s law were prevalent.
1
A pre-test on ideal gas law was given to form two (2) science students of Awutu Winton Senior
High School, who were supposed to have treated gas laws (ideal gas law) to see how well they
understood the concept. From the results, it was observed that out of a total of forty-two (42)
students, only six representing (14.3%) appeared to have understood to some extent the concept of
ideal gas law . The rest demonstrated various degrees of lower levels of comprehension which
implies that they do not have adequate knowledge on the topic “ideal gas law”.
From the pre-test result and further interaction with the students, I concluded that, form two (2)
science students of Awutu Winton Senior High School lack the understanding of the concept of
the ideal gas law. It was against this background that I deemed it fit to conduct the study in order
I conducted an unstructured interview to know why most of the students did not perform well in
Six (6) of these students fear chemistry and thus put in no effort to learn it.
appropriate teaching learning materials during instruction, and the abstract nature
of the concepts.
Thirty (30) of the students taught they need extra periods to go over the topics they
Forty (40) of the students taught that the unavailability of a trained chemistry
2
1.4 Purpose of the Study
This study is aimed at improving the academic performance and understanding of form two (2)
science students of Awutu Winton Senior High School, Awutu Bereku, in the concept of the Ideal
gas law.
This study will help to improve the academic performance and understanding of form two (2)
It would also help to place emphasis on using appropriate teaching learning materials to enhance
The study will also serve as basis of other studies in furtherance of students’ understanding of
this concept.
Factors that affect students’ performance in the study of the ideal gas law.
The extent to which students’ performance in the ideal gas law will be improved through
3
1.7 Research Questions
1. What factors affect students’ performance in the study of ideal gas law?
2. To what extent will students’ performance in the concept of ideal gas law be improved
1.8 Limitation
The animation used in this study was restricted to teaching the concept of ideal gas law because it
helped students to visualise the abstract gas molecules and the effects of the various conditions on
This study will involve form two (2) science students of Awutu Winton Senior High School,
4
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 Overview
This study was designed with the sole purpose of enhancing students’ performance in the concept
of the ideal gas law through the use of animations. The previous chapter identified students’
learning difficulty, this chapter reviews literature related to the problem. The review focuses on
The theoretical work done was based on objectivists and constructivists views on learning whiles
Technology Integration
Description of Animation
5
2.1 Theoretical Framework: Two Views
As education changes to reflect new social and educational needs, teaching strategies also change;
consequently, strategies change for integrating technology into teaching and learning (Ambrose,
2014). Today, educators’ definition of the appropriate role of technology depends on their
perceptions of the goals of education itself and appropriate instructional methods to help students
Most educators seem to agree that changes are needed in education. But learning theorists disagree
on which strategies will achieve the best educational goals today. This controversy has served as
a catalyst for two different views on teaching and learning. One view, which is called directed
a branch of the cognitive learning theories. The other view, which is referred to as constructivist
evolved from other branches of thinking in cognitive learning theory. A few technology
applications such as drill and practice and tutorials are associated only with directed instruction;
most others (problem solving, multimedia production, web-based learning) can enhance either
directed instruction or constructivist learning, depending on how they are used. These beliefs
People with radically different views on an issue frequently use different terms to describe
essentially the same thing. According to Sfard (1998) differences in the language used to describe
learning sprung from two different metaphors used for learning: the acquisition metaphor and the
participation metaphor. She notes that “... the acquisition metaphor is likely to be more prominent
6
in older writings, [and] more recent studies are often dominated by the participation metaphor” (p.
5). These differences in language signal fundamental differences in thinking about how learning
To understand how these differences come about, it is important to recognize that both directed
instruction and constructivist approaches attempt to identify what Gagné (1985) called the
‘conditions of learning’ or the ‘sets of circumstances that is obtained when learning occurs’ (p. 2).
Both approaches are based on the work of respected learning theorists and psychologists who have
studied both the behaviour of human beings as learning organisms and the behaviour of students
in schools and classrooms. The two approaches diverge when they define learning and describe
the conditions required to make learning happen and the kinds of problems that interfere most with
learning. They disagree because they attend to different philosophies and learning theories, and
The differences begin with underlying epistemologies: beliefs about the origins, nature, and limits
of human knowledge. Constructivists and objectivists (those who espouse directed methods) come
from separate and different epistemological “planets,” although both nurture many different tribes
or cultures (Molenda, 1991; Phillips, 1995). Philosophical differences can be summarized in the
following way:
Objectivists. Knowledge has a separate, real existence of its own outside the
human mind. Learning happens when this knowledge is transmitted to people and
7
Constructivists. Humans construct all knowledge in their minds by participating
in certain experiences; learning happens when one constructs both mechanisms for
learning and his or her own unique version of the knowledge, coloured by
signal dramatic differences in the curriculum and teaching and learning methods that each
considers appropriate and effective. Sometimes, these differences of opinion have generated
strident debate (Baines & Stanley, 2000). Yet many believe that both kinds of strategies may prove
useful to teachers for addressing commonly recognized instructional and educational problems.
Some of the ways in which these differences are reflected in the classroom are summarized in table
1.
8
Table 1: Methodological Differences Between Directed and Constructivist Theories
Directed Constructivist
Teacher roles Transmitter of knowledge; expert source; Guide and facilitator as students
director of skill/concept development generate their own knowledge;
through structured experiences collaborative resource and
assistant as students explore
topics
Curriculum Based on skill and knowledge hierarchies; Based on projects that foster
characteristics skills taught one after the other in set both higher level and lower level
sequence skills concurrently
Learning goals Stated in terms of mastery learning and Stated in terms of growth from
behavioural competence in a scope and where student began and
sequence increased ability to work
independently and with others
Types of activities Lecture, demonstration, discussions, Group projects, hands-on
student practice, seatwork, testing exploration, product
development
Assessment Written tests and development of products Performance tests and products
strategies matched to objectives, all tests and products such as portfolios; quality
match set criteria; same measures for all measured by rubrics and
students checklists; measures may differ
among students
9
2.5 Merging the two Approaches
As Molenda (1991) observed, an either-or stance seems to gain us little. Rather, both sides need to
find a way to merge the two approaches in a way that will benefit learners and teachers. A link
between the two planets must be forged so that students may travel freely from one to the other,
depending on the characteristics of the topics at hand and individual learning needs. Sfard (1998)
agrees that “one metaphor is not enough” (p. 10) to explain how all learning takes place or to
Bereiter (1990) initially supported directed instruction methods and later shifted toward
constructivist principles. He suggested that much of what educators want students to achieve is
sufficiently complex that none of the existing learning theories can account for how it is actually
learned, let alone the conditions that should be arranged to facilitate learning. He points out the
futility of theory and research that attempts to (1) identify relevant social, environmental, or
individual influences on learning such as prior experiences, types of reinforcement, and learning
styles; and (2) quantify their comparative contribution to what he calls difficult learning, that is,
Bereiter (1990) also observed that each of these contributing factors tends to interact with others,
thus changing their relative importance. He quotes Cronbach’s vivid metaphor: “Once we attend
to interactions [between these relevant factors], we enter a hall of mirrors that extends to infinity”
(p. 606). Practicing teachers could encounter endless variations of explanations about how people
learn or fail to learn. Escaping from this hall of mirrors will require, Bereiter to maintain a more
all-inclusive learning theory than those currently available. In light of Bereiter’s observations, the
debate between directed and constructivist proponents seems likely to inspire different methods
10
primarily because they focus on different kinds of problems (or different aspects of the same
problems) confronting teachers and students in today’s schools. Like the blind men trying to
describe the elephant, each focuses on a different part of the problem, and each is correct in limited
observations.
It is the combination of the two proponents in teaching that guided this research. Proficient
approaches. To implement each of these strategies, teachers should select technology resources
and integration methods that are best suited to their specific needs.
Focus on teaching sequences of skills that begin with lower level skills and build
Pursue global goals that specify general abilities such as problem-solving and
research skills.
11
Emphasize alternative learning and assessment methods: exploration of open-ended
For many educators, any mention of technology in education immediately brings to mind the use
of some device or a set of equipment, particularly computer equipment. Muffolletto (1994) says
that technology is commonly thought of in terms of gadgets, instruments, machines and devices
hence most educators will defer to technology as computers. Only about 24 years ago, a history of
technology in education since 1920 placed the emphasis on radio and television with computers as
an afterthought (Cuban, 2001). Saettler (1990) urges those seeking precision to remember that “the
historical function of educational technology is a process rather than a product. No matter how
sophisticated the media of instruction may become, a distinction must always be made between
the process of developing a technology of education and the use of certain products or media within
a particular technology of instruction” (p. 4). Therefore, in the view of most writers, researchers
and practitioners in the field, useful definitions of educational technology must focus on the
process of applying tools for educational purposes as well as the tools and materials used. As
Muffoletto (1994) puts it, “Technology … is not a collection of machines and devices but a way
of acting”. (p. 25). Based on this background, Roblyer (2002) stated that educational technology
is a combination of the processes and tools involved in addressing educational needs and problems,
with an emphasis on applying the most current tools: computers and their related technologies.
12
2.8 Historic Perspectives on Educational Technology
examining four different historical perspectives on these processes and tools, all of which have
helped shape current practices in the field. These influences come to us from four groups (media,
The instructional design or instructional systems movement took shape in the 1960s, adding
approaches to solving educational problems originated in military and industrial training but later
emerged in university research and development projects. The basic school practices began to
reflect systems approaches when university personnel began advocating them in their work with
schools. These approaches were based on the belief that both human and non-human resources
(teachers and media, respectively) could be parts of a system for addressing an instructional need.
13
From this viewpoint, educational technology was seen not just as a medium for communicating
instruction matched to carefully identified needs (Heinich, et al., 2000). Resources for delivering
instruction were identified only after detailed analysis of learning tasks and objectives and the
From the 1960s through the 1980s, applications of systems approaches to instruction were
influenced and shaped by learning theories from educational psychology. Behaviourist theories
held sway initially and cognitive theories gained influence later. Views of instructional systems in
the 1990s also were influenced by popular learning theories; however, these theories criticized
systems approaches as too rigid to foster some kinds of learning, particularly higher order ones
(Naisbitt, 1999). Thus, the current view of educational technology as instructional systems seems
Just as the AECT had its origins in the media systems view of educational technology, the
International Society for Performance Improvement (ISPI) grew out of the view of educational
technology as a systems approach to instruction. Originally named the National Society for
Programmed Instruction, the ISPI is still concerned primarily with creating a validating
The advent of computers in the 1950s created yet another view of educational technology.
Business, industry, and military trainers, as well as educators in basic and higher education,
recognized the instructional potential of computers. Many of these trainers and educators predicted
that computer technology would quickly transform education and become the most important
14
component of educational technology (Truett, 1996). Although instructional applications of
computers did not produce the anticipated overnight success, they inspired the development of
another branch of educational technology. From the time that computers came into classrooms in
the 1960s until about 1990, this perspective was known as educational computing and
programmers and systems analysts. By the 1970s, however, many of the same educators involved
with media, audiovisual communications, and instructional systems were directing the course of
research and development in educational computing. By the 1990s, these educators began to see
systems, and computer-based support systems. At that point, educational computing became
The organization that represents this view of technology in education is the International Society
for Technology in Education (ISTE), the product of a merger between two computer-oriented
groups: the International Council for Computers in Education (ICCE) and the International
Association for Computers in Education (IACE). IACE was known for most of its existence from
1960. Currently, ISTE is an influential force leading the movement for technology skill standards
Each of these perspectives on technology in education has made significant contributions to the
current body of knowledge about processes and tools to address educational needs. But, as Saettler
(1990) points out, no single paradigm that attempts to describe educational technology can
characterise satisfactorily what is happening with technology in education today and what will
15
happen in the future. Furthermore, all of the organizations described here seem engaged in a
struggle to claim the high-profile term educational technology. Each seems determined to assign
a definition based on the perspective and concerns of its members; each wants to be identified with
As we look today at what technology is doing – and what it promises to do – in classroom across
the country, teachers and trainee teachers are supposed to have adequate knowledge in technology.
Computers and other technology resources have improved in capabilities and user-friendliness to
educators. Some of the most innovative and promising practices in education today involve
technology and the promise of even more exciting capabilities foreshadow even greater benefits
for teachers.
Technology is, above all, a channel for helping teachers communicate better with students. This is
reflected in the increasing number of communication tools available today. Some of these tools
are the mobile phones, internet and intranet facilities. As espoused by Roblyer, 2002:
The use of technology can shape and increase the knowledge of teachers. It is
in this direction that teachers and trainee teachers need to be exposed to the use
of technology.
Technology is us – our tools, our methods and our own creative attempts to
be part of our path to a better life, rather than an obstacle in our way.
Some desirable changes that technology brings are for example; distance
16
rather than by travelling to another location. Currently, information about many
things that were farfetched are now within the reach of man. Example,
Roblyer (1999b) asserted that teachers must be as informed and analytical in technological issues
as they want their students to become. More teachers who understand the role technology plays in
society and in education are needed. Naisbitt, (1999), put it rightly, “… whenever new technology
is introduced into society, there must be a counterbalancing human response … the more high tech
(it is), the more high touch (is needed)” (p. 35).
In an increasingly technological society we need more teachers who are both technological savvy
and child centered (Miller, 2001). That is why it is expedient for trainees to be taught using
Motivating students to learn, to enjoy learning, and to want to learn more has assumed greater
importance in recent years as we recognize strong correlations between dropping out of school and
undesirable outcomes such as criminal activity. The drive to keep students in school is an urgent
national priority. Technology (animation) has an important role to play in achieving this goal.
Kozma and Croninger (1992) described several ways in which technology might help to address
the cognitive, motivational, and social needs of at-risk students and several software packages that
were either designed or adapted to appeal to these kinds of students. Technology-based methods
17
have successfully promoted several kinds of motivational strategies that may be used individually
or in combination.
Renowned learning theorist Gagné (1985) proposed that gaining the learner’s attention is the first
and foremost task (event) in providing optimal conditions for instruction. Although other aspects
of instruction must direct this attention toward meaningful learning, the visual and interactive
features of many technology resources seem to help focus students’ attention and encourage them
to spend more time on learning tasks (Summers, 1991). Substantial empirical evidence indicates
that teachers frequently capitalize on the novelty and television-like attraction of computers and
multimedia to achieve the essential instructional goal of capturing and sustaining learners’
attention.
Another powerful case for using technology resources is that some technological media can
facilitate unique learning environments or contribute unique features to make traditional learning
Integrated learning systems and subsequent products based on them have capitalized on the
computer’s unique ability to capture, analyze and present data on students’ performances during
learning. A teacher attempting to demonstrate a set of skills to a large group of students needs
accurate up-to-date, easy-to-analyze information on what each student is and is not learning. A
18
instruction or CMI system) can most effectively provide this essential information. Small, palm-
top computers allow teachers and researchers to keep moment-to-moment records of their
observations of students; anticipate affordable expert systems that can provide instruction, analyze
students’ errors and learning styles, and provide feedback tailored to unique learning needs
Basic communications and mathematics skills remain essential, but so is the need to solve
problems and think critically about complex issues. In addition, curriculum is beginning to reflect
the belief that students need not master basic skills before going on to higher level skills. The
engaging qualities of technology resources such as multimedia and the internet allow teachers to
set complex long-term goals that call for basic skills, thus motivating students to learn the lower
level skills they need at the same time they acquire higher level ones (Solomon, 1995).
A very important but often overlooked reason for using technology resources is to help teachers
cope with their growing paperwork load. Teachers and organizations have recognized that if they
spend less time on record keeping and preparation they can spend more time analyzing student
needs and having direct contact with students. Teachers can become more productive through
training in technology-based methods and quick access to accurate information that may help them
meet individual needs. Many technology resources can help teachers increase their productivity:
word processing, spreadsheet, database, grade book, graphics, desktop publishing, instructional
management, and test generator programs along with online communications between teachers (e-
19
2.13 Learning Theories Associated with Directed Instruction and Implication to Technology
Integration
There are two different theories of learning that contributed to the development of directed
instruction:
Behavioural theories
Information-processing theories
These theories developed from a branch of cognitive psychology that focused on the memory and
storage processes that make learning possible. They viewed the process of learning in human
beings as similar to that of how a computer processes information. Theorists in this area explored
how a person receives information and stores it in memory, the structure of memory that allows
learning something new and build on something learned previously, and how a learner retrieves
information from short- and long-term memory and applies it to new situations (Atkinson &
Skinner and others viewed the teacher’s job as modifying the behaviour of students by setting up
situations to reinforce students when they exhibited desired responses, teaching them to exhibit
the same response in all such situations. These behavioural principles underlie two well-known
programmed instruction.
20
2.15 The Information-Processing Theorists: The Mind as a Computer
Behaviourist like Skinner focused only on external, directly observable indicators of human
learning. During the 1950s and 1960s, a group of researchers known as the cognitive learning
theorists began to hypothesize a model that would help people visualize what is impossible to
observe directly (Eggen & Kauchak, 2001, p. 258). Though some constructivists disassociate
themselves with them, the information-processing theorists were among the first and most
influential of the cognitive-learning theorists. They hypothesized processes inside the brain that
Although no single, cohesive information-processing theory of learning summarizes the field, the
work of the information-processing theorists is based on a model of memory and storage originally
proposed by Atkinson and Shiffrin (1968). According to them, the brain contains certain structures
that process information much like a computer. This model of the mind as computer hypothesizes
that the human brain has three kinds of memory or “stores” (Ormrod, 2001, p. 225):
Sensory registers. The part of memory that receives all the information a
person senses.
According to this model, learning occurs in the following way. First, information is sensed through
receptors: eyes, ears, nose, mouth, and/or hands. This information is held in the sensory registers
21
for a very short time (perhaps a second), after which it either enters STM or is lost. Many
information-processing theorists believe that information can be sensed but lost before it gets to
STM if the person is not paying attention to it. Anything people pay attention to goes into working
memory, where it can stay for about 5 to 20 seconds (Ormrod, 2001). After this time, if information
is not processed or practiced in a way that causes it to transfer to LTM, then it, too, is lost.
must be linked in some way to prior knowledge already in LTM. Once information does enter
LTM, it is there essentially permanently, although some psychologists believe that even
information stored in LTM can be lost if not used regularly (Ormrod, 2001).
Information-processing views of learning have become the basis for many common classroom
practices. For example, teachers ask interesting questions and display eye-catching materials to
increase the likelihood that students will pay attention to a new topic. While presenting
information, they give instructions that point out important points and characteristics in the new
material and suggest methods of “encoding” or remembering them by linking them to information
Educational psychologists such as Gagné and Ausubel provided many instructional guidelines
designed to enhance the processes of attention, encoding, and storage. Gagné proposed that
teachers use a hierarchical “bottom-up approach,” making sure that students learn lower order
skills first and build on them. Ausubel, by contrast, recommended a “top-down” approach; he
proposed that teachers provide “advance organizers” or overviews of the way information will be
22
presented to help students’ developmental frameworks on which to “hang” new information (Gage
Information-processing theories have also guided the development of artificial intelligence (AI)
applications, an attempt to use computer animations that can simulate the thinking and learning
behaviours of humans. Much of the drill practice software available is designed to help students
usually are associated with more traditional, teacher-directed forms of instruction. Robert Gagné
is considered a leader in developing instructional guidelines for directed instruction that combine
the behavioural and information-processing learning theories. He asserted that teachers must
accomplish at least three tasks to link these learning theories with teaching practices:
Teachers must make sure that students have all the prerequisite skills they need to learn a new
skill. This may involve identifying component skills and the order in which they should be taught.
Teachers must arrange for appropriate instructional conditions to support the internal processes
involved in learning; that is, they must supply sequences of carefully structured presentations and
23
activities that help students understand (process), remember (encode and store), and transfer
Finally, teachers must vary these conditions for several different kinds of learning (Gagné, Briggs,
Gagné used the information-processing model of internal processes to derive a set of guidelines
that teachers could follow to arrange optimal “conditions of learning.” His set of nine “Events of
Instruction” was perhaps the best known of these guidelines. These events are: gaining attention;
informing the learner of the objective; stimulating recall of prerequisite learning; presenting new
correctness; assessing performance; and enhancing retention and recall (Gagné, Briggs, & Wager,
1992).
Gagné, Wager, and Rojas (1981) showed how Gagné’s Events of Instruction could be used to plan
lessons using computer animations. That said, only an animation that could “stand by itself” and
accomplish all of the necessary events of instruction could best serve the purpose (objective).
Behaviourist and information-processing theories have not only helped establish key concepts such
as types of learning and instructional conditions required to bring about each type: they also laid
the groundwork for more efficient methods of creating directed instruction. These methods, known
24
as systematic instructional design or systems approaches, incorporated information from learning
Systematic methods came about largely in response to logistical problems in meeting large
Integration
Constructivist strategies are based on principles of learning derived from branches of cognitive
science. This area focused specifically on students’ motivation to learn and ability to use what they
learn outside the school culture. Constructivist strategies try to respond to perceived deficiencies
in behaviourist and information-processing theories and the teaching methods based on them. In
addition, constructivists try to inspire students to see the relevance of what they learn and to
prevent what Cognition and Technology Group of Vanderbilt, CTGV, (1990) calls inert
knowledge, or student failure to transfer what is already known to the learning of other skills that
These theories are based on the ideas of revered educational philosophers, psychologists, and
practitioners such as John Dewey, Lev Vygotsky, Jerome Bruner, Jean Piaget, and Howard
Gardner. Later work by Seymour Papert, John Seely Brown, the Cognition and Technology Group
at Vanderbilt.
25
2.19 The Contributions of Early Cognitive Learning Theories
Educators credit theorists such as John Dewey, Lev Vygotsky, Jean Piaget, and Jerome Bruner
Several of Dewey’s ideas support constructivist models of teaching and learning. Among these
ideas is the need to center student instruction around relevant, meaningful activities. Prawat (1993)
recalled Dewey’s label of “worse than useless” (p. 6) any instruction that did not center on
problems already within the child’s experience. He emphasized that learning should be hands-on
He objected to commonly used teaching methods that used a “one-way channel of communication
– from teacher to student through direct drill and memorization . . .” (Smith & Smith, 1994). He
believed that meaningful learning resulted from students working cooperatively on tasks that were
As Bruce (2000) noted, Dewey would likely have approved of technologies like the Internet being
used to help students communicate with each other and learn more about their society. Dewey’s
emphasis on the need for cooperative learning would mesh well with technologies used for
developing group projects and presentations. However, as Dewey himself recognized, the central
problem with all these resources is combining them into a curriculum that encourages intellectual
challenge.
26
Jean Piaget’s Theories: Cognitive Development in Children
Ormrod (2000) summarizes Piaget’s basic assumptions about children’s cognitive development in
Children’s knowledge of the world becomes more integrated and organized over time.
Cognitive development depends on interaction with one’s physical and social environment.
Cognitive development can occur only after certain genetically controlled neurological
changes occur.
Many technology-using teachers feel that using visual resources such as Logo and animations can
help raise children’s developmental levels more quickly than they would have occurred through
maturation; thus, children who use these resources can learn higher level concepts than they
normally would have been able to understand until they were older. However, research evidence
to support their belief is still being gathered. Other educators feel that young children should
experience things in the “real world” before seeing them represented in the more abstract ways
27
2.20 Factors that affect student’s performance in Chemistry lessons
According to Keeves and Morgenstern (1992), attitude of the learner affects performance. This
was also supported by Anderson (2006) and Freedman (1997) who explained that attitude and
achievement are related and that a positive attitude towards science lesson results in a good
achievement. Most senior high school students developed some negative attitude towards science
from the basic level. This negative attitude manifested in the form of lack of interest, satisfaction
The pedagogical content knowledge of a teacher is also crucial in teaching and learning of concepts
in chemistry. Pedagogical content knowledge has been viewed as a set of special attributes that
helped someone transfer the knowledge of content to others (Geddis, 1993). It deals with the most
useful forms of representation of ideas, the most powerful analogies, illustrations, examples,
explanations, and demonstrations which are the ways of presenting and formulating a subject/topic
Again, Shulman (1987) stated that pedagogical content knowledge includes those special attributes
a teacher possessed that helped him/her guide a student to understand content in a manner that was
personally meaningful. Shulman explained further that pedagogical content knowledge includes
"an understanding of how some particular topics, problems, or issues are organised, presented, and
adapted to the diverse interests and abilities of learners, and presented for instruction" (p. 8). He
also suggested that pedagogical content knowledge was the best knowledge base of teaching: The
key to distinguishing the knowledge base of teaching lies at the intersection of content and
pedagogy, in the capacity of a teacher to transform the content knowledge he or she possesses into
forms that are pedagogically powerful and yet adaptive to the variations in ability and background
that students have. This is supported by Ausubel (1968) that the important single factor influencing
28
meaningful learning is indeed, what the learner already knows, and as such should be ascertained
Other factors that affect students’ performance in chemistry lessons are: past experiences of the
learners, material availability (Murphy, 1990), presentation of concepts and topics in an abstract
(Ornstein, 2006).
Also truancy, lack of motivation, time available for teaching and learning, learning strategies
students employ and self-efficacy are also identified as factors affecting student performance
(Bandura, 1997; Nisbet & Shucksmith, 1986). Finally, self-regulations and school climate are also
among other factors that affect student performance in chemistry lessons (Shunk, 2005).
movement when the film is shown as sequence. The animation used in this research was designed
the various gas laws that make up the ideal gas law. The video includes how the various conditions
under which gases are studied, vary as the conditions vary. The animation also shows the various
conditions under which the various laws, namely Boyle’s, Charles’ and Avogadro laws, hold.
At some point, it shows a cylinder supplying gas molecules during Avogadro’s law, a piston being
used to increase pressure during Boyle’s law and a Bunsen burner to produce temperature increase
29
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.0 Overview
In this chapter, the researcher presents the study area, the research design, population, sample,
research instruments, validity and reliability of the research instruments, data analysis procedure
The study was carried out at Awutu Winton Senior High School, Awutu Bereku. The school is
sited between Akoti junction and Awutu Bereku on the Winneba – Kasoa road, about 800 metres
from Akoti junction in the Awutu Senya West municipality of the Central region of Ghana. To get
to the school, one will take the Winneba – Kasoa road. About eight hundred metres (800m) from
the Akoti junction, the school is located just on the left side of the road.
The study is an action research; an educational action research is a process in which participants
examine their own educational practice systematically and carefully, using the techniques of
research. Its purpose is to solve a specific classroom or school problem, improve practice or make
decision at a single local site (Asamoah-Gyimah & Duodu, 2007). Individual teacher action
research usually focuses on a single issue in the classroom. The teacher may be seeking solutions
learning difficulties.
30
It is also an intervention, on a small scale, put in place to diagnose a problem and attempt to solve
However, during or after the implementation of the findings, other issues may emerge, which
In spite of this limitation, I chose this type of design because it helps me to produce valid
information and knowledge that has immediate application in the classroom. It also helps to solve
problems which have direct effect on students’ academic performance as the problem is identified
This study has a target population of forty two (42) students comprising of all the second year
science students of Awutu Winton Senior High School, Awutu Bereku. This class is made up of
two groups – agricultural science and general science. The agricultural science group is made up
of twenty seven (27) students while the general science group is made up of thirty (15) students.
Purposive sampling was used to select the agricultural science group as my sample population
based on the results of the pre-test. After analyzing data from the pre-test, I realized that, both
groups have the problem but the agricultural science group was mostly affected.
31
3.4 Research Instruments
The instruments used for the study were test (pre-test and post-test), unstructured interview, and
observation.
Test
A test is a series of questions which serve as a measuring tool used for collecting specific
information from subjects (participants) to aid in finding solution to a research problem (Fianu,
2005). This instrument was used because it is an effective way of securing information from
students as well as an ideal method for measuring students’ performance. The pre-test and post-
test were prepared and self-administered to ensure that the test items were in line with the course
content.
The pre-test was used during the pre-intervention stage to determine the extent of the problem
while the post-test was used at the post-intervention stage of the research to ascertain the
The pre-test and post-test were similar in structure but different in content. They both consisted of
two parts. The first part of both tests were made up of five short answer items on laws that make
up the ideal gas law and their mathematical expressions. The second part also consist of two short
answer items on combination of the laws and the units of the universal gas constant. The questions
in part one of both the pre-test and post-test attracted 1 mark each and those in part two attracted
2.5 marks each. The total score each of the tests was 10 marks and each student was expected to
get 5 marks or above to pass the test. Each exercise lasted for 30 minutes.
32
The researcher observed that some students state laws without stating the condition(s) under which
they hold. Some students also have problems with the mathematical expressions and the
The pre-test will be used to ascertain whether students truly have a problem in understanding the
concept of the ideal gas law. The post-test will also be administered to know the impact of the
intervention strategy.
Unstructured interview
According to Kusi (2012), unstructured interview is a technique often used to gather data in
qualitative studies. It has no definite structure and involves free-style discussion with the
interviewee.
Though unstructured interview as a research instrument may be meaningless when the interviewer
fails to establish cordial and friendly relationship with the interviewee, the researcher however
used it because of its flexibility and freedom which enabled me to unveil relevant and sensitive
information through probing. This instrument also helped me to determine the various causes of
the inability of the students to understand the concept of the ideal gas law.
Observation
Observation is the act of recognizing and noting facts or occurrences. The Concise Oxford
Dictionary (2001) defines observation as accurate watching and noting of phenomena as they occur
in nature with regard to cause and effect or mutual relations. From the description of Fainu (2005)
and Cobuild (2003) on the other hand, one can conclude that observation is the process of studying
33
things or people and being able to tell what they are, what they are capable of or why they behave
I perceived that, the students have a problem when it comes to elements, their chemical symbols
Although observation has an advantage of overcoming the bias which the phrasing of questions
may have on respondents, Asamoah-Gyimah and Duodu (2006) noted that, its disadvantages
cannot be done away with and that data collected through observation are authentic.
Validity of an instrument is the extent to which the instrument measures what it is intended to
measure. It is categorized into two types: internal validity and external validity. Reliability of an
instrument on the other hand refers to the degree of consistency of the results. Bell (1993), defined
reliability as the extent to which a test or procedure produces similar result under constant
conditions on all occasions. That is, the instrument should produce similar results when they are
To ensure validity of the instruments, the questionnaire and pre-test and post-test were given to
some science tutors for proof-reading. The tests were then administered to the second year general
science students of Odukpong Senior High School, Kasoa since they have the same curriculum.
Mistakes and ambiguities were then corrected before the tests were finally administered to the
sample population.
To ensure the reliability of the test items, trial testing was done twice at Odukpong Senior High
School, Kasoa.
34
3.6 Data analysis procedure
The raw scores from the pre-test and post-test activities were analyzed using the t-test. The raw
scores were also converted into bar graph/histogram and frequency tables with percentages of
The intervention strategy I used was an animation which I downloaded with the outmost scrutiny
of its content. I chose to download the animation because I have limited skills in the area of
designing animations of that kind. Also, the content of the animations gave me all that I could
Before the intervention lesson, students were put into six groups and assigned to read and make
notes on the gas laws (namely, Boyle, Charles, Avogadro and ideal gas laws). The researcher used
five periods (two for the first and three for the second) within one week for the intervention. The
researcher started the intervention lesson by brainstorming with the students using questions to
help students state the laws that make up the ideal gas law. Three students were called, one from
each group, to present what they have written to the class. After each presentation, the researcher
used the animation to guide the students to describe how the conditions vary and also guide them
to establish the mathematical relationship between the various conditions. Figures below show the
animations of the various laws that make the ideal gas law.
35
Fig 1: animation of Boyle’s law – volume is inversely proportional to pressure at constant
temperature
constant pressure
36
Fig 3: animation of Avogadro’s law – volume is directly proportional the number of
The researcher used oral questioning and answers periodically to assess students’ learning and give
individual attention where necessary. The researcher closed the lesson by letting students
summarize the lesson and informed students on the topic for the next lesson and closed the class.
The second intervention lesson started with a quick recap of the previous lesson and the remaining
groups gave their presentations in turns. The researcher then proceeded to guide the students to
put the three laws together to form the ideal gas law. The researcher introduced the universal gas
constant, R and guided the students on how to change the unit of the volume to suit the unit of R
since it could be given as 8.314 Jmol-1k-1 or 0.082 atmdm3mol-1k-1. The researcher explained that
if R is given as the former, the unit of the volume should be in m3 and if it is given as the latter,
the volume should be in dm3. The researcher used question and answer to summarize the lesson.
Two days after the intervention activities, the researcher administered the post intervention test to
results from the post-test and realised that students now understood the importance of stating
37
conditions under which laws hold. Using the animation to illustrate, students can now express the
various laws mathematically and also establish the relationship between and among the various
conditions.
38
CHAPTER FOUR
4.0 Overview
This chapter comprises of the analysis of the data collected, presentation of findings and
discussions in order to determine the effect of animation on science two (2) students of Awutu
Winton Senior High School in the concept of the ideal gas law.
The results and discussions were presented based on the sequence in which the research questions
were posed.
Research question 1: What factors affect students’ performance in the study of ideal gas
law?
To find out some of the factors that affect form two (2) science students’ performance in the study
of the ideal gas law, an unstructured interview was conducted and the responses given below in
table 2.
39
Table 2: Results of Unstructured Interview of Respondents
Number of students
Response from students
Yes (%) No (%)
Class tests were not given on the concept of the ideal
gas law. 20 (74.1) 7 (25.9)
The concept, gases, was presented in an abstract
form. 23 (85.2) 4 (14.8)
Assignments, if given at all, were not marked on
25 (92.6) 2 (7.4)
time.
The teacher in their first year did not use teaching
26 (96.3) 1 (3.7)
and learning materials.
The teacher rushed through the concept. 26 (96.3) 1 (3.7)
Students do not have text books and other reading
materials for reference. 21 (77.8) 6 (22.2)
N = 27
From table 2 above, 20 students representing 74.1% of the total number of students stated that
class tests were not given on the concept. Evaluation and assessment play major role in teaching
and learning of a concept. This supports Shaila’s (2011) idea that assessing students’
understanding after a concept makes the teacher aware of the state of the learner. This was evident
in the students’ responses to the item, prompt feedback is relevant to both the teacher and the
student.
Twenty three (23) students representing 85.2% responded that the topic was presented in abstract
form. This supports Ornstein’s (2006) assertion that the use of concrete and real materials make
students understand concepts very well. Hence these students (85.2%) could not understand the
40
Twenty five (25) students representing 95.6% responded that assignments, if given at all, were not
marked on time. Prompt feedback is needed. According to Baines and Stanley (2000), prompt
feedback to students makes them know what they have done right or wrong. This would also
motivate them.
Twenty six (26) students representing 96.3% stated that the chemistry teacher did not use teaching
and learning materials for teaching them. According to Murphy (1990), teaching and learning
materials help to consolidate knowledge and concept of learners because these teaching and
learning materials were not used large number of the students (96.3%) could not understand the
Twenty six (26) students representing 96.3% stated that chemistry teachers rushed through the
concept of gases, gas laws and more specifically the ideal gas law. Gage, Briggs & Wager (1992)
agreed that the pace of teaching is very important for concept development. They added that
teachers must know the level of the pupils in their class of instruction and vary the pace of delivery.
It was evident from the result that a faster pace was used instead of varying pace, hence 96.3% of
Twenty one (21) students representing 77.8% of the total population of students responded that
they do not have text books and other reading materials for reference. The result of students’
responses to this proved that a large number of them were not having text books and reading
materials, hence could not perform very well. This supports Murphy (1990) who asserted that in
teaching children at any level, there should be enough teaching and learning materials which also
includes reading materials and an indication that they do not read in advance in preparation for
class.
41
Research Question 2: To what extent will students’ performance in the concept of ideal gas
A pre-test was given to the students to find out their level of comprehension before the
42
8
8
7
Number of students In Percentages
6 6
6
3
2 2 2
2
1
1
0 0 0
0
1 2 3 4 Marks
5 of students
6 7 8 9 10
A post-test was also given to students to find out students’ performance in chemical bonding after
the intervention. The results are presented in table 3 and figure 4 below.
43
10
10
9
Number of students In Percentages
4
3 3
3
2 2 2 2
2
1 1 1
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 of students
Marks 6 7 8 9 10
To find out the impact of the intervention strategy (the use of animation) on the performance of
students in chemical bonding, a comparison of the pre-test and the post-test results was made. This
From the pre-test results in table 3 and figure 4 above, twenty (20) students representing 74.1%
scored below 5 marks out of a total of 10 marks in the pre-test. Only seven (7) students representing
25.9% managed to score 5 marks and above out of a total of 10 marks in the pre-test. From the
post-test results in table 4 and figure 5 above, only seven (7) students representing 25.9% scored
below 5 out of 10 marks in the post-test and twenty (20) students representing 74.1% scored 5 and
above.
Comparing the pre-test results with those of the post-test as represented in table 5 and figure 6
above, twenty (20) students representing 74.1% failed in the pre-test as against seven (7) students
44
representing 25.9% failing in the post-test. This is evidential that larger number of students failed
in the pre-test than in the post-test. Twenty (20), (74.1%) of the students on the other hand passed
the post-test as against only seven (7) students representing 25.9% who passed the pre-test.
The comparison of the two results reveals clearly that there has been tremendous improvement in
the performance of students in the post-test as compared to that of the pre-test. This implies that
the intervention strategy was very effective in solving students’ problem in understanding the
concept of gases – ideal gas law. This result goes to confirm the findings of Kozma and Croninger
(1992) which postulates that if technology such as computer animations are used in teaching, they
go a long way to help address the cognitive, motivational and social needs of students which
Summers (1991) also affirmed the view that the visual and interactive features of many
technological resources help to focus students’ attention and encourage them to spend more time
on learning task. These all together helped to improve the performance of students.
45
Table 5: Comparing Pre-test to Post-test scores
37.0
Number of students in percentages
10
9 29.6
8
7 22.2 22.2
6
5
4 11.1 11.1
3 7.4 7.4 7.47.4 7.4 7.4 7.4
2 3.7 3.7 3.7 3.7
1 0 0 0
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Marks of students
46
CHAPTER FIVE
5.0 Overview
This chapter presents a summary of the findings and conclusion of the study. It also includes
recommendations and suggestions for further research as well as contributions of the study to
science education.
5.1 Conclusion
This action research was designed to identify the problems of form two (2) (agricultural) Science
students of Awutu Winton Senior High School, Awutu Bereku, in understanding the concept of
gases – ideal gas law and how to improve upon their performance in the concept.
According to the findings from the study, the students find it difficult to understand the concept
of gases if the lesson is presented in an abstract form or without any visual instructional media.
The researcher used animation as teaching aid to assist students to understand the concept the
The study has been very successful, in that the intervention strategy used was able to help
students improve upon their performance in the concept gases – ideal gas law. Students’
The positive results obtained by students in the post-test suggest that students attained the
requisite techniques and knowledge needed to enable them understand the concept and use such
47
To conclude the researcher can state emphatically that the intervention strategy used was very
successful.
Considering the above findings of this study at Awutu Winton Senior High School, Awutu Bereku
1. Teachers should adopt the use of animation in teaching the concept of gases – ideal gas
law to students and always use the appropriate teaching and learning material.
3. Teachers should adopt the use of hands-on activities in teaching and make the lesson
chemistry teachers to effectively handle the subject chemistry at the senior high school
48
REFERENCES
Atkinson, R., & Shiffrin, R. (1968). Human memory: A proposed system and its control processes.
New York: Academic Press.
Ausubel, D. P. (1968). The psychology of meaningful verbal learning. New York: Grune &
Stratton.
Ayikue, A. (2013). The Effect of Computer Modules on Students’ Performance in the Naming of
Hydrocarbons: A Case Study at St. Francis College of Education, Hohoe. MPhil thesis.
Unpublished.
Baines, L., & Stanley, G. (2000). We want to see the teacher. Phi Delta Kappan, 82(4), 327-330.
60(4), 603-624.
Bruce, B. (2000). Dewey and technology. The journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, 42(3),
222-226.
Bruner, J. (1973). The relevance of education. New York: Norton & Company.
Cetin P. S., Kaya E. and Geban O., (2009). Facilitating conceptual change in gases concepts,
J. Sci. Educ. Technology. 18(2),130–137.
Cognition and Technology Group at Vanderbilt. (1991b). Technology and the design of
generative learning environment. Educational Technology, 31(5), 34-40.
Cuban, L (2001). Teachers and machines: The classroom use of technology since the1920. New
York: Teachers College press.
Davydov, V. (1995). The influence of L. S. Vygotsky on education theory, research, and practice.
Educational researcher, 24(3), 12-21.
Denscombe, M. (2008). The good research guide for small scale social research projects (3rd ed.).
Buckingham: Open University Press.
Dressel, P. L., & Marcus, D. (1982). On teaching and learning in college. San Francisco: Jossey
Bass.
49
Eggen, P., & Kauchak, D. (2001). Educational psychology: Windows on classrooms. Upper Saddle
River: Merrill/Prentice Hall.
Erinosho, S.Y. (2008). Teaching science at the Secondary School: A methodological handbook.
Ibadan: Polgraphics Ventures Limited.
Fianu, J.N.K. (2005). Education Studies for Second Year Second Semester, (Unpublished).
Freedman, M. P. (1997). Relationship among laboratory instruction Attitude towards Science, and
Achievement in science Knowledge. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 34(4), 343-
357.
Gage, N., & Berliner, D. (1988). Educational Psychology. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Gagné, R. (1985). The conditions of learning. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Gagné, R., Briggs, L., & Wager, W. (1992). Principles of instructional design. Orlando, FL:
Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich.
Gagné, R., Wager, W., & Rojas, A. (1981). Planning and authoring computer-assisted instruction
lessons. Educational Technology, 21(9), 17-26).
Gardner, P., & Gauld, C. (1990). Labwork and students’ attitudes. In E. Hegarty- Hazel (Eds.),
The student Laboratory the Science Curriculum. New York City: Routledge
Geddis, A. N. (1993). Transforming content knowledge: Learning to teach about Isotopes. Science
Education, 77, 575-591.
Heinich, R. M., Russell, J., & Smaldino, S. (2000). Instructional media and Technologies for
learning. Upper Saddle River: Merrill/Prentice Hall.
Kautz C. H., Loverude M. E., Heron P. R. L. and McDermott L. C., (2008), Research on student
understanding of ideal gas law, http://www.ipn.uni-kiel.de/projekte/esera/book/b027-
kau.pdf, access date: 18/04/2008.
Keeves, J. P., & Morgenstern, C. (1992). Attitudes Towards Science Measure and effects. Changes
in Science Education and Achievement, 9(5), 122-140.
Kozma, R., & Croninger, R. (1992). Technology and the fate of at-risk students. Education and
Urban Society, 24(4), 440-453.
McNeil, B., & Wilson, K. (1991). Meta-analysis of interactive video instruction: A 10-year review
of achievement of effects. Journal of Computer-Based Instruction, 18(1), 1-6.
50
Miller, S. E. (2001). Technology: What’s it good for? Learning and Leading with Technology,
28(6), 42-45.
Molenda, M. (1991). A philosophical critique on the claims of “constructivism.” Educational
Technology, 31(9), 44-48.
Murphy, P. (1990). Gender gap in National curriculum. Physics World, 3(1), 11-19.
Ornstein, A. (2006). The frequency of Hands on Experimentation and student Attitude toward
Science; A statistical significant Relation (2005-51-Ornstein). Journal of Science
Education & Technology, 15(3), 285-295.
Prawat, R. (1993). The value of ideas: Problems versus possibilities in learning. Educational
Researcher, 22(6), 5-16.
Roblyer, M. D. (1998b). The other half of knowledge: Information literacy skills. Learning and
Leading with Technology, 25(6), 54-55.
Roblyer, M. D. (2002). The open classroom. London: Kogan Page Publishing Company.
Saettler, P. (1990). The evaluation of American educational technology. Englewood,CO: Libraries
Unlimited.
Schuttlefield J. D., Kirk J., Pienta N. J. and Tang H., (2012). Problem difficulty in ideal gas law
problems, J. Chem. Educ., 89(5), 586–591.
Shulman, L. S. (1987). Knowledge and teaching: foundations of the new reform. Harvard: ATT
Press.
51
Shunk, D. H. (2005). Self-regulated learning: The educational legacy of Paul R. Pintrich.
Educational Psychologist, 40(2), 85-95.
Smith, L. G., & Smith, J. K. (1994). Lives in education. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
Soloman, G. (1995). Planning for technology. Learning and Leading with Technology, 23(1), 66-
67.
Stavy R., (1988), Children’s conception of gas. Int. J. Sci. Educ., 10(5), 553–563.
Summers, J. (1991). Effect of interactivity upon student achievement, completion intervals, and
affective perceptions. Journal of Educational Technology Systems, 19(1), 53-57.
Truett, C. (1996). Information literacy: When computers aren’t enough. Learning and Leading
with Technology, 23(5), 65-67.
Wager, W. (1992). Instructional systems fundamentals: Pressures to change. Educational
Technology, 33(2), 8-12.
Willis, J. (1995). A recursive model based on constructivist-interpretivist theory. Educational
Technology, 33(10), 15-20.
52
APPENDIX A
PART ONE
[5 MARKS]
1. Boyle’s law states that provided ………………….. is kept constant, the volume of a
[1 mark]
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
[1 mark]
53
I. Boyle’s law
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
[1 mark]
………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………........
[1 mark]
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
[1 mark]
PART TWO
[5 MARKS]
5. State the ideal gas law.
54
1.0 mol of an ideal gas is known to occupy 22.41dm3 at 273.3 K at a pressure of 1.0132 x
105 Nm-2. Use these data to evaluate the universal gas constant R. Deduce the unit of R.
[2.5 marks]
6. 0.718 g of a gas X, occupies 1 dm3 at 0˚C and 1 atm. Of pressure. Is X CO2, CO or CH4?
Explain.
[2.5 marks]
55
APPENDIX B
PART ONE
[5 MARKS]
1. Charles’ law states that provided ………………………. is kept constant, the volume of a
[1 mark]
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………...............
[1 mark]
I. Boyle’s law
56
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
[1 mark]
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
[1mark]
[1mark]
PART TWO
[5 MARKS]
1.0 mol of an ideal gas is known to occupy 22.41dm3 at 273.3 K at a pressure of 1.0132 x
105 Nm-2. Use these data to evaluate the universal gas constant R. Deduce the unit of R.
57
[2.5 marks]
6. A 415 cm3 sample of a gas weigh 2.136 g at 294 K and a pressure of 100 KPa. Calculate
[2.5 marks]
58