Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
HARRIS PROFILE
When can the method be used? A Harris Profile is a graphic representation of the
A Harris Profile is based on the design
strengths and weaknesses of design concepts with respect
requirements for your design. Whenever
a number of alternative product concepts to predefined design requirements. It is used to evaluate
need to be compared and evaluated, the design concepts and facilitate decisions on which
Harris Profile can be used to make your concepts to continue with in a design process.
– or your team’s – evaluation explicit. As
designers make some of their evaluations An important role of the Harris Profile • It is tempting to interpret Harris
intuitively, the Harris Profile can help is to make your evaluation explicit Profiles as ‘true’ representations of the
you to make those intuitions explicit so and easy to understand: it can help to performance of design alternatives.
that you can discuss them with other stimulate discussion with your project’s However, it is important to realise
stakeholders. stakeholders in the early phases of that the performance assessment of
design, when design requirements design concepts is typically an intuitive
A Harris Profile can be useful during typically change as the concepts prediction of performance, with low
each phase of the design process, but evolve and you gain a greater shared reliability.
typically it is used after an idea generation understanding of the design problem. • The primary function of the profile is to
phase when ideas or concepts need to be communicate the evaluations that you
eliminated. Possible procedure have made after careful discussions and
STEP 1 deliberations, and if necessary to open
How to use the method? List the design requirements as fully as up discussion to sharpen the definitions
Create a Harris Profile for each alternative possible and rank them according to of requirements or improve design
design concept. A Harris Profile consists of their importance for the design project. concepts.
an assessment of how the concept meets STEP 2
each of the listed design requirements. Create a four-point scale matrix next to Tips & Concerns
The evaluations are relative, comparing each requirement, coded -2, -1, +1, and • Use drawings to represent concepts
the different concepts in terms of their +2. in each profile – this will enhance the
performance in each criterion. A four- STEP 3 communicability of your profiles.
point scale is typically used to score Create a Harris Profile for each of the • If possible, cluster the criteria.
the concepts. You should interpret the design alternatives by evaluating the • Design is not a linear process, so you
meaning of the scale positions: relative performance of each alternative might discover new design requirements
-2 = bad, -1 = moderate, et cetera. Thanks with respect to the requirements. while evaluating concepts. You can
to the visual representation, decision STEP 4 add those requirements to your Harris
makers can quickly view the overall Draw the profile by marking the scores Profile and enhance the accuracy of your
score of each design alternative for all in the four-point scale matrix for all the evaluation.
the criteria, and compare them easily. criteria. • When attributing the -2 or +2 values
STEP 5 to a criterion, be sure to colour all
Present the profiles next to each other to the blocks in the Harris Profile. Only
allow discussion with stakeholders and to then can you create a quick visual
determine which design concept has the overview of the overall score of a design
Speed
best overall score. alternative.