Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Notable persons
Moritimer Cordero- businessman, VP of Panama Marketing Corp.; markets inter-island passenger
vessels
Tony Robinson- an Australian based in Brisbane, Managing Director of Aluminum Fast Ferries Australia
(AFFA)
Allan Go- owner/operator of ACG Express Liner Cebu
Felipe Landicho and Vincent Tecson- lawyers of Go
MAIN ISSUES
W/N Cordero has the legal personality to sure respondents for breach of contract
W/N respondents may be held liable for damages to Cordero
SC RULING
Cordero is the real-party-in-interest
- Sec. 2, Rule 30, Rules of Court: such party is the one “to be benefited or injured by the judgment
in the suit/ the party entitled to avail a suit
- Robinson and AFFA dealt only with Cordero and pays the latter directly
There is breach of exclusive distributorship and respondents are liable for damages to petitioner for
acting in bad faith and disregarding Cordero’s rights
- Cordero was excluded from transaction when the respondents ceased communicating with him
without due explanation and ignoring the fact that he is the appointed exclusive distributor of
the SEACAT vessels
- He was not paid by Robinson the balance of his commission
GF EQUITY vs. ARTURO VALENZONA [G.R. No. 156841: June 30, 2005]
ISSUE
W/N Paragraph 3 of the contract is violative of the mutuality principle, and consequently, of
Valenzona’s rights
SC RULING
Par. 3 clearly transgresses the principle of mutuality of contracts under Art. 1308 of the NCC
There was abuse of rights in the part of GR Equity, as enshrined in Art. 19 of the NCC
- GF Equity was not precluded from the right to pre-terminate the contract provided that it has
legal basis for doing so, which it failed to justify.
- The act of pre-termination was based on stipulation, an illegal ground.
- However, the pre-termination was not willful, Thus, there can be no malice/bad faith in GF
Equity’s part