Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1. Revocation; coupled with an interest an agent may be estopped to deny the agency as against the
principal, agent, or third persons in interest.
Art. 1873. If a person specially informs another or states by public
o He will not, however, be estopped where he has withdrawn
advertisement that he has given a power of attorney to a third person,
from the contract made with the unauthorized agent before
the latter thereby becomes a duly authorized agent, in the former case
receiving any benefits thereunder.
with respect to the person who received the special information, and
in the latter case with regard to any person. Estoppel of the government – the government is neither estopped
by the mistake or error on the part of its agents.
The power shall continue to be in full force until the notice is rescinded o But it may be estopped through affirmative acts of its officers
in the same manner in which it was given. (n) acting within the scope of their authority.
While the principal may have the absolute power to revoke, he must Whether a third person has received such notice
respond in damages for breach of contract where the termination is depends upon the facts of the particular case.
wrongful.
It should be emphasized the revocation is a power and not a right. One may be deemed to have knowledge or notice
The principal is liable for damages occasioned by the wrongful of the termination when he knows that the
discharge of the agent before the expiration of the period fixed. principal has ceased to do business, or is dealing
o The action for indemnity is not derived from law but from the with the subject matter of the agency, or the
contract of the parties. principal has appointed another agent of the
purpose.
But where no time for the continuance of the agency has been fixed,
the principal is at liberty to terminate it at will subject only to the
The agent has the power to renounce the agency relationship subject only
requirements of good faith.
to the contractual obligations owing to the principal by giving notice to
o The principal is liable under Art. 19 when such termination
the principal that he will no longer serve as an agent.
would deprive the agent of his legitimate business. He must
In effect, the agent resigns.
give the agent at least sufficient notice to allow the agent to
If there is no contract existing between the parties or if the contract
recoup his expenses and, in some cases, to make a normal
is for no fixed or definite period of time, it is terminable by the agent
profit.
at will
o But an agent cannot legally terminate an agency in order to
If the authority of the agent is in writing, the principal can compel the
take advantage of the principal’s condition or to profit by
agent to return the document evidencing the agency.
information resulting from his agency.
The purpose is to prevent the agent from making use of the power
A statement in a contract that the authority cannot be terminated
of attorney and thus avoid liability to third persons who may
by either party for a specified time adds nothing to the contract; it
subsequently deal with the agent on the faith of the instrument.
is effective only to create liability for breach thereof.
The law will not compel the parties to continue an agency if they do
Kinds of revocation
not want to do so since agency is a voluntary relationship. It deals
1. Express
with personal services, and, therefore, specific performance is
2. Implied
inappropriate.
o When the principal appoints a new agent for the same
It is not always necessary for the agent to renounce the agency expressly,
business or transaction or when the principal directly
as for example, where he has conducted himself in a manner clearly
manages the business entrusted to the agent (Aer. 1924)
incompatible with his duties as agent.
o The agent’s authority may also be revoked impliedly in the
same manner as in the case of appointment of an agent (Art. When an agent abandons the object of his agency and acts for
1869) himself in committing a fraud upon his principal, his capacity as
agent ceases.
Notice of revocation But the mere fact that the agent violates his instructions does not
amount to renunciation, and although he may thus render himself
Express notice to the agent that the agency is liable to the principal, he does not cease to be an agent.
revoked is not always necessary.
To agent
If the party to be notified actually knows, or has
reason to know, facts indicating that his authority
Art. 1921. If the agency has been entrusted for the purpose of Art. 1924. The agency is revoked if the principal directly manages the
contracting with specified persons, its revocation shall not prejudice business entrusted to the agent, dealing directly with third persons.
the latter if they were not given notice thereof. (1734) (n)
Unless the only desire of the principal is for him and the agent to manage
Art. 1922. If the agent had general powers, revocation of the agency the business together, the effect of the direct management of the
does not prejudice third persons who acted in good faith and without business by the principal himself is to revoke the agency for there would
knowledge of the revocation. Notice of the revocation in a newspaper
no longer be any basis for the representation previously conferred.
of general circulation is a sufficient warning to third persons. (n)
But if the purpose of the principal is to avoid payment of his agent’s
compensation, the implied revocation is deemed made in bad faith
Effect of revocation in relation to third persons and cannot be sanctioned without according to the agent the
commission which is due him.
Its revocation will not prejudice such third
persons until notice thereof is given them Art. 1925. When two or more principals have granted a power of
attorney for a common transaction, any one of them may revoke the
Notice is not required if the third person same without the consent of the others. (n)
already knew of the revocation
Agent is authorized As the appointment of an agent by two or more principals for a common
Personal notice is required.
to contract with transaction makes them solidarily liable to the agent for all the
Since the third persons have been made to
specified persons consequences of the agency, any one of the principals is granted under
believe by the principal that the agent is
authorized to deal with them, they have a right this article the right to revoke the power of attorney without the consent
to presume that the representation continues of the others.
to exist in the absence of notification by the In a solidary obligation, the act of one is the act of all.
principal.
Innocent third persons dealing with the agent Art. 1926. A general power of attorney is revoked by a special one
will not be prejudiced by the revocation before granted to another agent, as regards the special matter involved in the
they had knowledge thereof. latter. (n)
Agent is authorized The fact that the revocation was advertised in
to contract with the a newspaper of general circulation would be This article may also apply where the special power is subsequently
public in general sufficient warning to third persons for the granted to the same agent which had a general power.
publication constitutes notice upon everybody The general power is impliedly revoked as to matter covered by the
and this is true whether or not such third
special power.
persons have read the newspaper concerned.
A special power naturally prevails over a general power.
It is indispensable that notice of revocation be communicated in some
Art. 1923. The appointment of a new agent for the same business or way to the agent.
transaction revokes the previous agency from the day on which notice
thereof was given to the former agent, without prejudice to the Art. 1927. An agency cannot be revoked if a bilateral contract depends
provisions of the two preceding articles. (1735a) upon it, or if it is the means of fulfilling an obligation already
contracted, or if a partner is appointed manager of a partnership in the
There is implied revocation of the previous agency when the principal
contract of partnership and his removal from the management is
appoints a new agent for the same business or transaction provided there
unjustifiable. (n)
is incompatibility.
But the revocation does not become effective as between the Exceptions to Art. 1920:
principal and agent until it is in some way communicated to the 1. When the agency is created not only for the interest of the principal
latter. but also for the interest of third persons
The rights of third persons who acted in good faith and without 2. When the agency is created for the mutual interest of both the
knowledge of the revocation will not be prejudiced thereby. principal and the agent.
There is no implied revocation where the appointment of another In either case, the agency is deemed as one coupled with an interest.
agent is not incompatible with the continuation of a like authority It becomes part of another obligation or agreement.
in the first agent. The agency cannot be revoked by the sole will of the principal as
No substitution of counsel of record is allowed unless the following long as the interest of the agent or of a third person subsists
essential requisites occur: because it is not solely the rights if the principal which are affected.
1. There must be a written request for substitution o However, an irrevocable power of attorney is obligatory only
2. It must be filed with the written consent of the client on the principal who executed the agency. It cannot affect one
3. It must be with the written consent of the attorney to be substituted who is not a party thereto.
4. In case the consent of the attorney to be substituted cannot be Art. 1927 mentions of three instances of irrevocability.
obtained, there must be at least a proof of notice that the motion
for substitution was served on him in the manner prescribed by the An agency coupled with an interest cannot be terminated by the sole will
RoC. of the principal although it is so revocable after the interest ceases.
The first counsel may not be presumed substituted by a new counsel It is essential that the interest of the agent shall be in the subject
merely from the filing of a formal appearance by the latter. matter of the power conferred and not merely an interest in the
exercise of the power because it entitles him to compensation
therefor.
An agency is coupled with an interest where:
o The agent has parted with value or incurred liability at the In the second case, also according to Mechem, there is a power or
principal’s request, looking to the exercise of the power as the authority coupled with interest, which is irrevocable by the
means of reimbursement or indemnity. principal, whether by any act during his lifetime or by his death.
o The interest in the thing concerning which the power is to be A contrary view according to the Restatement of Agency is that
exercised arises from an assignment, pledge, or lien created neither type of power is revocable by the principal, whether during
by the principal with the agent being given the power to deal his lifetime or by his death.
with the thing in order to make the assignment, pledge, or lien o The Restatement uses the term power given as security “to
effectual. cover both types of cases.”
The fiduciary relationship is replaced by material consideration o De Leon: the position taken by the Restatement would seem
which bars the removal or dismissal of the agent on the ground of to be a commendable one, for the relation of trust and
loss of trust and confidence. confidence which is supposed to stand in the way of absolute
As to what constitutes sufficient interest, it must be a present irrevocability of an agent’s appointment is affected adversely
interest in the subject matter itself. as much by one type of power as it is by the other. In both
o An interest in the proceeds of the power’s exercise as cases, the agent acts for himself and not on behalf of the
compensation is not sufficient. principal.
o An agent’s interest in earning his agreed compensation is an
ordinary incident of agency, and neither a contract that the Persons with a proprietary interest in the subject matter of their agency
principal will not revoke nor a contract that the agent can are not true agents at all.
protect his rights to earn commission in spite of revocation It is said that such an agency merely differs from other types in that
will deprive the principal of control over acts to be done by it is irrevocable.
the agent on his behalf. o However, that very fact negates the possibility that it could be
o The agent’s remedy is to sue for breach of contract if the an agency relation at all.
principal terminates their contract. This is the case since one of the hallmarks of the agency
relation is that the principal must retain control over the
Whether an interest which will make an agency irrevocable exists in a agent concerning the object of his agency.
particular case is to be determined from the entire agreement and from If the principal cannot terminate the relation, he has
the facts and circumstances. surrendered that degree of control which an agency
The terminology used by the parties is not controlling. requires.
Even though an agency is made in terms irrevocable, that fact will If the power holder holds an interest for the benefit of a
not prevent its revocation by the principal where the agency or person other than the creator of the power, he is not
power is not coupled with interest. the creator’s agent.
Nor will the fact of a stipulation in the instrument that the intention
of the grantor of the power is that it shall be “construed as a power
of attorney coupled in the interest of the subject matter thereof”
prevent its revocation.