Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The use of the transient hot-wire technique for measurement of the thermal
conductivity of an epoxy-resin reinforced with glass fibres and/or carbon
multi-walled nanotubes
M.J. Assael a, K.D. Antoniadis a, D. Tzetzis b,*
a
Thermophysical Properties Laboratory, Chemical Engineering Department, Aristotle University, Thessaloniki 54124, Greece
b
Queen Mary College, University of London, Materials Department, London E1 4NS, UK
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Carbon nanotubes are considered to be ideal candidates for matrix reinforcement in fibre-reinforced
Received 5 February 2008 composite materials. In order these new multifunctional materials to be used at their optimum potential,
Received in revised form 21 July 2008 precise measurements are completely essential. This article is focused in the accurate measurement of
Accepted 29 July 2008
the enhancement of the thermal conductivity of an epoxy-resin, reinforced initially with plies of plain
Available online 13 August 2008
weave glass fabric then by carbon multi-walled nanotubes (C-MWNT), and finally with both these two
macroscopic and nanoscopic reinforcements at hand. The technique employed was the transient hot-wire
Keywords:
technique, as it was recently modified to be able to measure the thermal conductivity of solids in an abso-
Nano composites
B. Thermal properties
lute way, with an uncertainty of better than 1%. Following validation of the technique, the results
C. Finite element analysis (FEA) revealed that in the case of reinforcing the epoxy with glass fibres, with volume fraction of 28%, the ther-
Transient hot-wire mal conductivity increase was 27% compared to plain epoxy-resin. When reinforced with 2% by weight
C-MWNT the enhancement was 9% and when reinforced with both the C-MWNT and glass fibres the
enhancement was the highest value obtained, being 48%.
Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction Nowadays the use of nanoparticles for the polymer matrix rein-
forcement becomes a highly desirable procedure in order to en-
In recent years there have been an increasing number of hance both the physical and the mechanical properties of the
applications requiring more efficient and lightweight thermal composite [7]. It should be noted that the numerical and the ana-
management such as communication satellites, high-density lytical methods and assumptions regarding the calculation of the
electronics, and advanced aircraft. The fibre-reinforced compos- effective thermal conductivity made for conventional composites
ites are considered as ideal candidates for many of these appli- have to be reanalysed in order to be applied for the nanocompos-
cations and knowledge of the mechanical as well as physical ites. Clearly, such analyses also necessitate very accurate and reli-
properties, pertinent to these materials, has become a very cru- able experimental data for comparison.
cial design input. Despite the fact that there is a plethora of Various techniques have been used in the past in order to
established standards and/or procedures for the measurement measure experimentally the thermal conductivity of conven-
of the various mechanical properties of composites, the same tional fibre-reinforced materials [8–10]. Nevertheless, no single
does not apply to the measurement of a number of physical technique exists for measuring the thermal conductivity of com-
properties, including the effective thermal conductivity. As a re- posites that can provide the basis for establishment of a stan-
sult, the lack of reliable thermo-physical data may hinder the dard. The reliability of a specific method depends on various
full utilization of composites. It should be mentioned, that the factors, such as the speed of operation, the required accuracy
thermal conductivities of a fibre-reinforced composites can be and execution under various environmental conditions, and the
calculated from various theoretical, empirical, as well as numer- size and shape of the available specimen. Therefore, the develop-
ical methods. However, each of these methods has certain ment of new experimental methods to measure this property
assumptions applicable for certain specific cases and ranges accurately for composite materials under different environmental
[1–6]. Thus, the determination of reliable experimental data for conditions is highly attractive.
validation purposes is of paramount importance. Over the last 5 years the transient hot-wire technique was fur-
ther advanced to allow absolute, very accurate measurements of
the thermal conductivity of solids [11–15]. In addition, the
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: t.dimitris@qmul.ac.uk (D. Tzetzis).
enhancement of the thermal conductivity of fluids in the presence
0266-3538/$ - see front matter Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.compscitech.2008.07.019
M.J. Assael et al. / Composites Science and Technology 68 (2008) 3178–3183 3179
samples, in order to minimize contact resistance between the wire and a 0.05 K maximum difference radially. These differences have
sensor and the solid, the wire sensor is placed inside a flat layer of no significant effect in the final quoted uncertainty of the thermal
soft silicone paste which in turn is squeezed between two blocks of conductivity measurement.
the solid. Heat is transferred from the wire via the silicone paste to During a single run, 1000 temperature versus time points are
the solid. registered usually from 20 ls up to 10 s, with a very accurate
In Fig. 2, the new sensor, composed of two 25-lm-diameter bridge that has been described elsewhere [11]. In this technique
Ta wires, is shown. The solid material is considered in this case in general, there are five unknown parameters:
as the plain epoxy-resin blocks or the composite laminates and
nanocomposites. As details of the sensor and the technique are – the thickness of the paste (which, in the new sensor, is exactly
given elsewhere [11,15], only a brief description is included here. equal to 1 mm);
The two wires, of 2 cm and 5 cm lengths, are spot-welded on – the paste’s thermal conductivity and the (density specific
1 mm Ta support wires which are flattened to 0.5 mm at their heat capacity) product;
ends. Two 1-mm-thick SS strips on the top and bottom of the – the sample’s thermal conductivity and the (density specific
sensor ensure that the samples are kept exactly 1 mm apart, heat capacity) product.
and hence the paste thickness is also equal to 1 mm. In a spe-
cially made base, two 25-lm-thick polyimide films (Kapton, Du- The parameters concerning the paste properties are obtained
Pont) (10 cm 5 cm) are held while a silicon paste (HIGH TEMP from measurements at short times (20–0.3 s). Having acquired
Red silicone, Type 650, VersaChem) is laid over them. The sensor those, the parameters related to the sample can be obtained from
with the wires is placed on top of one of them, while the other measurements at longer times (0.3–10 s).
is placed over it. Then the specially made base is squeezed tight In order to fully describe the complete geometry of the sensor,
to 1 mm. After about 1 week, the silicone paste becomes harder the COMSOL Multiphysics V.3.2b finite element package is em-
but still retains some elastic properties. This produces an elastic ployed. This allows precise modeling of the sensor, i.e. the wire,
layer of exactly 1 mm thickness, with Kapton on the outside, and the silicone paste, the Kapton film (negligible effect), and the solid,
the silicone paste with the two wires on the inside. Furthermore, resulting in perfect agreement between the experimental points
this assembly ensures that the Ta wires are in the middle of the and the calculated temperature versus time curve from 20 ls to
silicone layer. To measure the thermal conductivity, the sensor is the last time measurement. Hence, full advantage of the whole
squeezed between the two pieces of the sample. temperature versus time curve is obtained.
The whole arrangement is placed in the center of an accurate,
vertical three-zone tubular furnace (Carbolite, Model TVS 12).
The temperature is determined using two platinum resistance 3. Results and discussion
thermometers embedded on the top and bottom of the half cylin-
der. The thermometers are calibrated versus a Class I certified, 3.1. Validation of the technique
Tinsley platinum resistance thermometer to a maximum uncer-
tainty of less than ±80 mK (all temperatures refer to ITS-90). Preli- Validation of the proposed configuration was performed using
minary measurements with platinum resistance thermometers the liquid toluene that has been proposed by the Subcommittee
placed in the position of the wires, showed a 0.4 K maximum dif- on Transport Properties of the International Union of Pure and
ference between the top and the bottom of the sensor cylinder Applied Chemistry as a standard thermal conductivity liquid with
an uncertainty of ±0.6% [21]. Evidently, an advantage of the pro- Taking into account the aforementioned discussion as well as
posed thermal conductivity measurement configuration is that it the uncertainty in the temperature of the furnace discussed previ-
can also be employed to measure the thermal conductivity of flu- ously, the estimated absolute uncertainty of the technique is better
ids. The wires with their support were placed in toluene at 302 K than ±1%. This estimate concurs very well with the measured value
and 1000 points of temperature versus time were obtained. To cal- for the thermal conductivity of toluene (and of Pyroceram 9606
culate the thermal conductivity of toluene, the COMSOL package [15]). Also, the uncertainty in the measurement of the product
was employed, but instead of the properties of the silicone layer, (density specific heat capacity) is about ±5%.
the Kapton film, and the solid, the properties of liquid toluene were
used. In Fig. 3 the temperature rise versus the logarithm of the time 3.2. Thermal conductivity of plain epoxy-resin blocks
is shown. The thermal conductivity value obtained from the super-
imposition of the COMSOL calculated values and the experimental Following the validation procedure, the wires were placed in
ones, deviates by 0.4% from the proposed value by the Subcommit- the silicone paste, and the sensor, prepared as described in the pre-
tee on Transport Properties of the International Union of Pure and vious section, was placed between two blocks of the epoxy-resin
Applied Chemistry, whereas the product (density specific heat polymer. Seven different sets of epoxy-resin blocks were prepared
capacity) was found to deviate by ±0.3% from literature values by weighing as described above. The values of the thermal conduc-
[22,23]. tivity of these samples are shown in Fig. 4. These values indicate
It was mentioned in the previous sections that the technique that although the technique is accurate to ±1%, the actual values
employed is an absolute technique. The total uncertainty is associ- measured differ by ±2% because of inhomogeneities in the samples
ated with the uncertainties in the following variables [15]: probably attributed to factors like imperfect mixing or non-identi-
cal composition.
(a) Uncertainty in the voltage supplied to the wires. A digital Fig. 5 shows a typical run at 298.15 K (1000 measurements
voltmeter (HP 34401A) was employed with an uncertainty between 0.01 s and 10 s). The first part of the curve is related to
of ±1 lV. This resulted in an uncertainty in the final thermal the properties of the silicone paste and the second part to the
conductivity value of the order of 106%.
(b) Uncertainty in the temperature coefficient of resistance of
the tantalum wires. This was obtained by measuring accu-
rately the resistance of the wires at known temperatures.
The resistance of the wires was measured with a ±0.01%
uncertainty, while the temperature was recorded by a Class
I (±1 mK) certified Tinsley platinum resistance thermometer.
Hence, the temperature rise was obtained with an uncer-
tainty of better than ±20 mK, which results to an uncertainty
of the final value of the thermal conductivity of less than
±0.05%.
(c) Uncertainty in the real time measurement. Time was
recorded in a 16 bit mode, i.e. with an uncertainty of
±1 ls. However, in the thermal conductivity calculation,
the logarithm of the real time is involved. This results in
an uncertainty in the final thermal conductivity value of
±0.001%. Fig. 4. The thermal conductivity of different sets of epoxy-resin polymer at 307.5 K.
3182 M.J. Assael et al. / Composites Science and Technology 68 (2008) 3178–3183
Fig. 5. Typical temperature rise as a function of time for epoxy-resin polymer at 298.15 K.
properties of the epoxy-resin polymer. The results for the thermal shown in Table 1 and plotted in Fig. 6. In the same figure the pre-
conductivity of the epoxy-resin polymer as a function of tempera- vious measurements of the thermal conductivity of the epoxy-
ture are shown in Table 1 and plotted in Fig. 5. The thermal con- resin are shown for comparison purposes. It can be seen that rein-
ductivity, k (W m1 K1), values shown in Table 1, were fitted as forcing the polymer with the glass fabric resulted approximately in
a function of the absolute temperature T (K) to an equation, a 27% increase in the thermal conductivity. That increase may be a
result of the relatively good conducting nature of the glass fibres
T
k ¼ kð298:15 KÞ 0:1118 þ 0:880 ; ð1Þ compared to the epoxy-resin matrix. Since the fibre interaction be-
298:15
comes more important as the fibre volume fraction increases, the
where the value of the thermal conductivity, k(298.15 K) thermal conductivity would be expected to increase as the conduc-
(W m1 K1) is given in Table 1. The maximum deviation of the tive effect would become more significant. Regarding the behav-
experimental points presented in Table 1 from the above equation iour of the composite with the temperature, the observed
is 1.07%, and the standard deviation at the 95% confidence level increase in thermal conductivity follows a linear relationship that
is 0.69%. has resulted from the stronger dependence of the epoxy matrix
with the temperature, i.e. a parallel (linear) relationship was ob-
3.3. Thermal conductivity of glass fibre-reinforced epoxy tained between the thermal conductivity and the temperature in
the measurements of the plain epoxy blocks (Fig. 6).
The measurements of the thermal conductivity of the glass The values in Table 1 were obtained by placing the samples
fibre-reinforced epoxy-resin as a function of the temperature are with the glass fibres parallel to the sample axis, thus parallel to
the wires of the sensor. Measurements on samples with the 60°
angle show that the orientation of the fibres had no real effect on
Table 1
the thermal conductivity. It seems that the isotropic nature result-
Measured properties of the composites as a function of temperature ing from the amorphous character of the glass fibres probably nul-
lifies the effect of orientation of the fibres in the composite.
Material T (K) k (W m1 K1) Dka (%)
The thermal conductivity, k (W m1 K1), values shown in Table
Epoxy-resin polymer 298.15 0.252 0.83 1, were fitted as a function of the absolute temperature T (K) to an
307.46 0.255 0.72
equation,
320.32 0.267 0.22
335.84 0.275 1.07
T
348.78 0.290 0.84 k ¼ kð298:15 KÞ 0:3784 þ 0:6254 ; ð2Þ
298:15
Epoxy-resin polymer + 298.15 0.320 0.38
glass fabric (0°/90°)20 312.20 0.330 0.20 where the value of the thermal conductivity, k(298.15 K)
320.12 0.338 0.61 (W m1 K1) is given in Table 1. The maximum deviation of the
333.81 0.347 0.54
experimental points presented in Table 1 from the above equation
348.50 0.353 0.57
is 0.61%, and the standard deviation at the 95% confidence level is
Epoxy-resin polymer + C-MWNT + 298.15 0.324
0.29%.
glass fabric (0°/90°)20 (laminate cut 306.93 0.332
at 60° angle from principal axis) 320.27 0.345
3.4. Thermal conductivity of carbon nanotube-reinforced epoxy
Epoxy-resin polymer + C-MWNT 298.15 0.275
Epoxy-resin polymer + C-MWNT + 298.15 0.373
The thermal conductivity of the two sets of samples was mea-
glass fabric (0°/90°)20
sured at room temperature and the results are shown in Table 1
a
Dk = 100 [(k kfit)/kfit], with kfit from Eqs. (1) and (2). and plotted in Fig. 6, along with all previous measurements for
M.J. Assael et al. / Composites Science and Technology 68 (2008) 3178–3183 3183
ment was 48%. In order to fully exploit the potential of the tran-
sient hot-wire technique and the associated accuracy in the
measurements, experimental quantification of the thermal con-
ductivity of new advanced materials is under schedule considering
the tremendous advances in the topic of nanocomposites.
References