Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Company moats refers to ability of a firm to maintain competitive advantages over its competitors in
the same industry in order to protect its long-term profits and market share from competing industries.
Just like a medieval castle, the moat serves to protect those inside the fortress and their riches from
outsiders, as said by Warren Buffet.
1. Cost Advantage: Companies like Berger paints with significant cost advantages can undercut the
prices of any competitor, either forcing the competitor to leave the industry or at least reducing
its growth speed. Berger paints who has a sustainable cost advantage can maintain a very large
market share of its industry by squeezing out any new competitors who try to move in.
2. Marketing and promotional strategy: The company’s basic strategy is to select the target market
and position its product with the help of product segregation, image segregation, etc and Berger
has been doing it perfectly. It has been selling products at affordable prices compared to its
competitors and mainly promoting this strategy in such a way that its competitors could not
match it. For its Diwali campaign, Berger combined talent, colours, etc at an affordable price by
making the activities engaging.
Berger is committed to ensure that its operations are carried out within a well-defined internal
control framework. Good governance, well defined systems and processes, and an independent
internal audit function are the foundation of the internal control systems which helps Berger at a
great level. The company has a well-established internal control system, commensurate with its
size and spread, with defined guidelines on compliance, which enable it to run its depots, offices
and factories with a reasonable degree of comfort. The control environment ensures commitment
towards integrity and ethical values and some relief for the Board of Directors. The control
activities incorporate, among others, continuous monitoring, routine reporting, checks and
balances, authorization and delegation procedures, audits also compliance audits, which are
periodically reviewed by the Business Process and Risk Management Committee and also the
Audit Committee The data generated is shared with the Board and various committees, evaluated
and corrected.
The Company’s Enterprise Resource Management Systems with Standard Operating Procedures
based on work flows and process flow charts also provide a comfort in this regard. The Company
is fully geared to implement any statutory recommendation which may be made in this respect
and thus we can say that the quality of management of Berger Paints is far better than its
competitors mainly because of its internal management system.
The Indian paint market is expected to reach Rs 709 billion by 2019-20 from around Rs 403
billion in 2014-15. The per capita paint consumption in India which is a little over 4 kg is still
very low as compared to the already developed western nations. Therefore, as the country
develops and modernizes, the per capita paint consumption is bound to increase.
The unorganised sector controls around 35% of the paint market in the country, with the
organised sector accounting for the balance plus in the unorganised segment, there are about
2,000 units having small and medium sized paint manufacturing plants. Top organised players
include Asian Paints, Berger Paints, Kansai Nerolac among others.
Demand for paints comes from two broad categories:
Home decorations: Major segments in home decorations include exterior wall paints,
interior wall paints, wood finishes and ancillary products and enamel such as primers,
putties etc. Decorative paints account for around 75% of the overall paint market in
India. Asian Paints is the market leader in this segment whereas Berger taking the
second spot. Demand for decorative paints arises from household painting,
architectural (rare) and other display purposes. Demand in the festive season
(September-December) is significant, as compared to other periods and Berger Paints
has been exceeding in this time span since the last two years. This segment is price
sensitive and is a higher margin business as compared to industrial segment.
Industrial: Three main segments of the industrial sector include protective coatings,
powder coatings and automobile coatings. Kansai Nerolac is the market leader in this
segment following Asian Paints and Berger Paints thereon. User industries for
industrial paints include automobiles engineering and consumer durables. The
industrial paints segment is far more technology intensive than the decorative segment
thus favouring Asian Paints
The paints sector is raw material intensive, with over 300 raw materials (50% petro-based
derivatives) involved in the manufacturing process. Since most of the raw materials are
petroleum based, the industry benefits from softening crude prices.
Adding to this, the paints industry in India started with Shalimar Paints, in Calcutta, back in 1902.
During these 116 years, the industry navigated certain economic and political events,
including the two World Wars, the Great Depression, India’s Independence, etc. All through,
the industry remained at the top. A return of 330 times of the Indian paints industry in the last
two decades in which it also outperformed the stock market benchmark NIFTY (22 times)
proved the listed stocks in the paints industry to be good investments. Today, it contributes to
0.4% of the total GDP, besides contributing to employment in unorganised and organised
sectors. This is despite a mere 4-kg per capita consumption in India, against the global
average of 15-kg which is very less, indicating huge scope for growth. This can no better be
explained by the P/E of 66 belonging to the Indian paints industry, compared with an industry
average P/E ratio of 16 for the American paint companies.
Urbanisation, changing social attitudes and ways, rising incomes of individuals, industrial
growth and further infrastructure expansion, supported by the easy availability of housing
loans, are the drivers of decorative paints industry, which accounts for 75% of the estimated
$8.2-billion Indian market. The track-record shows the industry growth a growth of
approximately 2 times that of GDP growth. Research reports suggest that the decorative
paints industry is expected to touch $10.42 billion in the next 6-7 years. However, the recent
not so good growth signals from real estate and auto sectors are a challenge. With lower
crude oil prices during CY2017, the industry remained attractive, as about three-fourths of its
raw materials have been derived from crude.
For further penetration in the market, economic and competitive pricing will remain key
factors. With raw materials accounting to about 50% of net sales, the paints industry is cost-
sensitive. Key raw materials used can be divided into four categories: binders, pigments,
solvents and additives. Titanium dioxide is widely used, and other raw materials including
phthalic anhydride, pentaerythritol, methyl methacrylate, aromatics, etc, which act as binders,
solvents and additives, are derivatives of crude oil distillate used in the making of paints..
Production costs will remain sensitive to the movement of the crude oil price in the ultimate
market, though with a lag. The change in raw material costs and the change in crude oil
prices shows a strong correlation as noted by economists.
Binders, solvents and additives make up 75% of the total composition of most paints,
implying that three-fourths of the raw materials are derived from major distillates of crude oil.
Given that during the past couple of years crude oil prices were highly volatile to the extent of
annualised volatility of 35% and 24% during FY17 and FY18, respectively the
competitiveness of the organised paints industry has been continuing since to be challenging.
Based on ChemQuest analysis, the best under Indian conditions, given the information on
net sales of Indian manufacturers to the price movement of crude oil, and considering the
crude volatility and industry size, we can estimate that about `5,800 crore would be the
potential price risk amount.
There are about 300 raw materials used in the paints industry, and they are usually sourced
through imports or third parties. But most firms in the industry do not make raw material,
makes them price-takers in the market. The prices of chemicals used for producing raw
materials may outpace crude oil benchmarks and, unfortunately, paint companies might end
up paying a huge amount when prices rise.
One way of securing the input costs would be to hedge the price exposure through crude oil
futures against an input delivery contract. . With their prices being quoted in rupee,
domestically traded crude derivative contracts would help them maintain and manage their
gained exposure in the domestic currency. The key to determine the amount of exposure in
crude contracts that a hedger should take is pre-determined that is further needed to be
customised depending on the raw materials thus used and its correlation with crude oil.
Distant derivatives usually respond with a time lag, as their respective inventory stages play a
major role in determining the market price at any given point of time, as opposed to others.
It is important to measure the outstanding risk of a firm and find the best possible way to
manage and hedge it. Getting it locked in a major portion of the costs can give paint
manufacturers a significant margin boost to achieve competitive pricing and hence healthy
functioning so far. Currently, Indian paint manufacturers seem to rely largely on inventory
control and have an access to newer raw materials and suppliers. For the paints industry,
raw material price risk may not be a challenge, but an opportunity to enhance
competitiveness and thus succeed industrial peers. As their raw materials move closer to
market based pricing, commodity risk will be a reality and managing it will be a necessity in
the ultimate future.