Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Introduction
Addressing higher education issues of Latino Students in predominantly white institutions can be
a topic that institutions of higher education may not be ready to embrace. The challenge may
come from the fact that Predominantly White Institutions (PWI’s) of Higher Education may not
be willing to accommodate the appropriate funds to meet the demands that Latino students may
need. Failure to pay attention to these issues may hurt these institutions in the recruitment and
retention of these students. Previous research on Latino students has focused on factors affecting
these students throughout their lifespan in education. Some of those research studies have
focused on the primary educational experiences that Latinos have encountered leading to their
years entering college. For example, Verdugo (2006) states that factors that have been attributed
to the low graduation rate of Latinos include lack of cultural understanding, inadequate academic
advising, non-supportive school climate, and fewer rigorous courses available. These findings
may open the door for further research to happen and help gain a better understanding about the
changes that institutions of higher education can make in order to enhance the services that this
By exploring the factors affecting Latinos from obtaining degrees of higher education,
research can provide higher education administrators with better ways to assist Latino students
within the classroom or advising settings. It can also provide policymakers the appropriate
information needed for them to make better decisions when it comes to allocating funds for the
recruitment or retention of Latino students. It will provide the students with better ways to
identify their needs and request for their institutions to provide better services based on their
individual needs. It will also provide parents with more information that can in turn provide
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 3
them the opportunity to establish better ways to encourage their kids to continue their
Minimal research attention has been directed towards the things that institutions of higher
education can do to better serve this population of students. Latinos are the largest non-White,
youngest, and fastest-growing U.S. racial/ethnic population, but their college attainment rates
remain the lowest of all groups (Gandara & Contreras, 2009; Swail, Cabrera, & Lee, 2004).
Even though this population of students is growing so rapidly within the United States, evidence
shows that little attention has been given to improve the way that these students are assisted
within institutions of higher education. According to Bowen, Chingos, and McPherson, (2009)
Latinos are expected to compose over half of the college-age population growth within the next
decade. Raising their postsecondary attainment rates presents one of the most critical policy
concerns for improving the overall educational attainment level in the United States. Latino
students are admitted in large numbers at these predominantly white institutions, yet many of
these institutions lack to graduate Latino students at the same rates that they are admitting them.
Therefore, it is imperative that institutions of higher education find better ways to assist and
serve Latino students in order for their graduation completion rates to change.
Bowen, Chingos, and McPherson (2009) emphasize that Hispanics’ tendency to “under
match” where they enroll—that is, to enroll in a less selective institution than one for which they
are academically qualified—is the primary reason for Hispanics’ lower educational attainment
rates, since students at less selective institutions graduate at lower rates than those from more
selective institutions. Thus, not beginning college at a four-year institution is a key factor
limiting Latino students’ educational attainment (Arbona & Nora, 2007; Gandara & Contreras,
2009). Verdugo (2006) suggests that, “Latino students are more likely not to be placed in
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 4
Language Learners (ELL), or personal perception of the students’ potential.” The fact that there
are clear factors affecting this population of students in various ways in comparison to other
populations, allows for researchers to further examine the things that can be implemented at
institutions of higher education, in order for institutions to better serve these students.
The purpose of this literature review is to examine the issues that Latino students are
facing at PWI’s of higher education across the United States while seeking to achieve their
Bachelor’s degree. This literature review will also seek to bring awareness to the administrators
of these PWI’s in the hopes that they can utilize the gathered information/findings and enhance
the services that they currently provide the Latino students at their respective institutions. The
hope is for this literature review to allow for the reader to gain a better understanding on the
current issues that Latino students have to overcome in order to achieve a degree completion
status. Some of the recurring themes among the literature consists of the poor guidance of the
college admissions process, socioeconomic status, lack of college readiness due to underfunded
K-12 school systems, lack of connection to the campus upon their arrival to these institutions and
Literature Review
As the number of Latino students increase in institutions of higher education across the United
States so do the strategies to recruit this population of students. When it comes to recruitment
strategies student affairs practitioners cannot overlook Latino students. Many institutions are
becoming more successful at recruiting Latino students but fall short on serving them once they
enroll at their institutions. Martinez (2010) studied the experiences of Hispanic college students
at a private university in the Midwest. Through the study Martinez was seeking to gather
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 5
qualitative data that touched on support services, social and academic influences, campus
climate, sense of belonging, cultural influences and challenges that Hispanic students have.
Studies such as this one open the door for researchers to further examine the findings in order
enhance the services that these institutions are providing this population of students along with
Lack of Resources
Admissions process. As the Hispanic population grows, the volume of Hispanic students
entering college is also expected to increase. Although the growth of well-prepared Hispanic
students has also increased in the last 30 years, Hispanic students continue to underperform,
compared to other student groups (Miller & Garcia, 2004). The Latino population across the
United States is one of the fastest growing population of minorities. This means that this
population of students is also growing very rapidly within institutions of higher education.
Therefore, there is a demand in studying better ways to serve Latino students. Martinez (2010)
found that bridge programs, student organizations, faculty advisors, family support and a
welcoming environment influences students to stay focused and stay in school. Miller and
Garcia (2004) explained that the number of Hispanic students obtaining a college degree have
the lowest college GPA, when compared to Whites and Asian Americans. These findings urge
institutions of higher education to find out what can be done in order to bridge the gap of Latino
Musoba and Krichevskiy (2014) utilized survival analysis to examined two key first year
courses, mathematics and English, and tested whether they were predictive for long-term student
Many schools determine students’ admission into their institutions based on the grade point
average and ACT score. If a student does not meet their requirements many times they are
denied admission into such institutions. Musoba and Krichevskiy (2014) found that early
coursework in math and English were important for all students. For Latino students, success in
their first math and first English composition courses significantly predicted graduation, but first-
term GPA was not significant. This tells higher education practitioners that universities should
also consider utilizing other factors when it comes to the application process and looking to
Musoba and Krichevskiy (2014) also found that Latino students’ performance in their first
English composition and first math courses were significant predictors of graduation. This means
that higher education practitioners must seek to find a way to be able to provide remedial courses
for students that may need them. If a student does not feel like they are smart enough to be admitted
into four-year institutions, then more than likely they will seek to start at a community college.
Starting at a community college may increase the risk of Latino students never moving on to an
institution that provides them with the opportunity to obtain a bachelor’s degree. When recruiting
Latino students, it is imperative for institutions to take such findings into consideration.
Institutions of higher education should also establish new research studies that can help them
identify what factors are affecting Latino students from completing degrees in their respective
schools. Such results can help find identify what the institutions can do in order to make sure that
these institutions admit students and support them once they arrive to campus.
Language Barriers. Peters, Sawyer, Guzman, and Graziani (2014) studied how Latino
individuals who prefer to communicate in Spanish lack linguistically and culturally proficient
mental health professionals with whom they can communicate effectively. Their study
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 7
illustrated the components necessary to facilitate the overall success of Latino, Spanish-speaking
students in attaining advanced degrees by developing them into competent bilingual service
providers (Peters, Sawyer, Guzman, & Graziani, 2014). These findings can also make reference
to the lack of support that these students may feel upon their arrival to these institutions. If
students do not feel like they have someone to connect with at their respective institutions it may
discourage students from returning the following semester. Students like to feel welcomed and
connected to the campus in order to create a sense of home away from home. In order for
institutions must do better at hiring faculty and staff that are representative of their population of
students.
background and/or being the first family member to attend college is higher than most other
racial and ethnic groups in the United States (NCES, 2010). In many cases, the families do not
have the resources to provide any financial support. One study reported that 86.4% of bilingual
counselors, who had completed a bilingual counselor-training program, indicated that they would
have been unable to acquire a school counselor certification without the financial support offered
by a federal grant (Sawyer, 2006). This states that there is a high need for financial support for
Latino students. This can be a determining factor for why Latino students do not complete a
degree of higher education. If they cannot afford the high costs of obtaining a four-year degree
then obtaining a professional degree almost seems out of the question. Institutions must do
better at providing Latino students with more financial opportunities that can in turn provide
them with the appropriate financial support to pay off their debt. Students should not have to
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 8
drop out of school due to the lack of financial support if they have the merits and leadership for
scholarship opportunities.
Financial Aid. According to Peters, Sawyer, Guzman, and Graziani (2014) there are
financial, academic, and personal support issues to address when it comes to assisting Latino
students with achieving degrees of higher education in particular advance degrees. Musoba and
Krichevskiy (2014) found that financial aid was associated with degree completion for Latino
students. Latino students who received larger dollar amounts of financial aid in their first semester
were more likely to graduate (Musoba & Krichevskiy, 2014). Financial aid seems to be a trend
when it comes to degree completion for all students but especially for this population of students.
The results for this study also reiterate that standardized test scores do not predict who will
graduate for students at a Hispanic Serving Institution (Musoba & Krichevskiy, 2014). These
results help support the need to change using standardize tests as a mean to offer admission to
students or even determine their success at institutions of higher education. If higher education
practitioners wish to recruit more Latino students they need to look at other factors to determine
Poor K-12 education. Students that come from disadvantaged communities are often the
ones that struggle the most with receiving an education that prepares them for college.
According to Peske and Haycock (2006) the very children who need strong teachers the most are
assigned, on average, to teachers with less experience, less education, and less skills than those
who teach other children. If students are being taught by teachers with less experience that can
result in Latino students having to face greater academic challenges upon their arrival to these
PWI’s. Peske and Haycock (2006) state that despite clear evidence that brand-new teachers are
not as effective as they will eventually become, students in high poverty and high-minority
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 9
schools are disproportionately assigned to teachers who are new to the profession. Knowing
these facts is crucial to understanding the impact that a K-12 educational system can have on
this in order to understand some of the needs that these students may have upon their arrival to
campus.
Having inexperienced teachers educating students that come from lower socio-economic
communities creates a huge gap between providing students with college entrance and degree
completion. In 2004, the U.S. Department of Education report showed that in schools where at
least 75 percent of the students were low-income, there were three times as many uncertified or
out-of-field teachers in both English and science (Educated, Jan 3, 2005, p.4). This means that
students are receiving an education from teachers whose content knowledge is not sufficient for
the effective teaching of students who come from such communities. This creates a bigger
deficit in meeting the needs that Latino students have because this can prevent a student from
meeting the leaning outcomes that must be met prior to graduating from high school. If students
education that will create another barrier that can prevent Latino students from being
College Environment
Lack of college readiness upon arrival. Swail, Cabrera, & Lee (2004) studied how
Latinos are performing compared with all students, but also provided comparisons with White,
Asian, and African American students. In addition to background descriptive data, they looked
at a number of variables which offer insight into how motivated and prepared Latino students are
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 10
for postsecondary work, risk factors that inhibit progress, and details about their educational
historically underrepresented at the post-secondary level are students of color, those from low-
income backgrounds, and first-generation students are still less likely to prepare for, apply for,
enroll in, and persist through postsecondary education (Cabrera & La Nasa, 2000). Through this
study Swail, Cabrera, & Lee (2004) found that Latinos are more likely to enroll in a two-year
rather than a four-year institution, delay entry into postsecondary education and delay for longer
periods, attend part-time, attend more than one postsecondary institution, enroll at a publicly-
Swail, Cabrera, and Lee (2004) also found that Latino students are less likely to aspire to
secondary degree, and earn a degree within four years. Swail, Cabrera, and Lee (2004), also
state that by 2050, Latinos will be the majority ethnic group in America. For that reason and
others, it is imperative that public policy focus more rigorously on the academic pipeline issues
for Latino youth, understanding completely that dealing with these issues has the potential to
raise the bar for all children (Swail, Cabrera, & Lee 2004). These findings that Swail, Cabrera,
and Lee have discovered throughout their study emphasize the importance of ensuring that
researchers focus their attention on issues affecting and preventing Latino students from
College Persistence. Ojeda (2014) examined how college persistence intentions and life
noted the importance of examining the role of culture on the educational experiences and well-
being of Latina/o college students (Gloria, Castellanos, & Orozco, 2005). Other research found
that Latina/o students feel more alienated on campus than their White peers (Lopez, 2005).
Results indicated that cultural adaptation significantly and independently influenced college
White American culture as well as acculturated to Mexican American culture. These finding are
consistent with research that found that acculturation was related to educational goals (Flores et
al., 2006). If students do not feel connected to the campus that they are attending this will
diminish the chances that they will graduate and receive a bachelor’s degree. Creating a sense
of belonging means more than establishing a cultural center on campus for that population of
students. There is plenty of room to help identify better ways to assist students to adjust to a
campus culture that is inclusive of all cultures and that promotes a diverse campus for all
students.
adaptation and academic attitudes among Latinas/os in the United States can clarify this relation.
perspective into research that examines cultural adaptation as a predictor of academic variables
among U.S. Latina/o adolescents. Findings suggest that efforts to promote biculturalism among
U.S. Latina/o high school students are most likely to have a beneficial effect on academic
attitudes when they focus on helping these students understand the personal meaning of the two
Polakovich (2014) also states that at a time when only 1 out of 10 U.S. Latinas/os who initially
enrolls in school will complete a college degree, this understanding cannot come soon enough.
This reinforces the need to further discuss topics that can allow institutions of higher education
to understand how they can better serve Latino students and in turn raise the number of Latinos
graduating from their respective institution. If student affairs practitioners understand the needs
of the students that they are serving it can provide better opportunities of awareness and raise the
The research mentioned above calls for an urge to further examine the things that Latino
students are faced with on a daily basis as they transition from a high school into a university
setting. The need to become aware of such deficiencies becomes greater each year as the
number of Latino students continues to rise. Student affairs practitioners cannot continue to
ignore the needs of Latino students because this can be detrimental for the enrollment and
graduation achievement rates of all institutions. In order to enhance the success rates of all
students, colleges and universities must first learn to serve their most vulnerable population of
students. Once they have learned to create inclusive spaces for their marginalized students than
will enhance the education for all the students that they serve.
Parental Support. Meza (2011) studied the role that parental support plays in promoting
the academic success and retention of Latino students in higher education. The study also
gathered data that provided valuable information regarding the feelings that parents had in
regards to the way that the university supported their children. Some of the feelings shared also
spoke to the lack of support from institutions of higher education and how that lack of support
eventually led Latino students to leave the institutions. Approximately six of every 10 students
of color who entered a four-year college or university failed to earn a bachelor’s degree within
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 13
six years (Museus, 2007). Latinos are also less likely than their Caucasian peers to obtain a
bachelor’s degree (Kohler & Lazarin, 2007). This shows that this population has needs that are
preventing them from achieving degree completion within the four years and opens the door for
further research to be done. According to Meza (2011) campus officials cannot fully address the
needs of Latino students without understanding whether parental support influence retention and
how colleges and universities might support parents as they attempt to support their children.
Meza’s (2011) found that parental support is very significant in the retention of Latino students
especially for students that come from a tight family background. The more support the student
receives from the parents the more motivated they will be to complete a degree.
Many Latino students rely on parental support in order to achieve things that may not
seem attainable such as a bachelor’s degree. Meza’s study found that parents trust the institution
to provide support for their children and it also found limited efforts by university officials in
making contact with the parents. The problem with parental involvement at a level of higher
education is the fact that parents feel disconnected when an institution does not commit to
making sure that they are involved in the process. However, Meza (2011) found that parents still
feel that they can support their children by instilling values that emphasize the importance of
education and validate their children’s educational efforts. This provides educators with a need
to further examine ways that can include the family in the process of serving Latino students and
help raise the number of Latino students that graduate from such institutions.
Poor academic advising. Being able to identify the things that make a student reach
degree completing is important for institutions of higher education all across the nation.
Research has shown that academic support services are critical for the success of students who
may be unprepared for college level work (Tinto, 1999). If student affairs practitioners are
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 14
aware of the needs that students have that can provide feedback needed to advocate for better
services for students. According to Rheinheimer and Mann (2000) academic support services
can help underprepared or at-risk students not only catch up to but, in some cases, surpass their
better prepared counterparts. One of the challenges that many of the first-generation Latino
students experience is being unaware of the college requirements for graduation. Latino students
will rely on services such as academic advising to provide them with the appropriate information
and guidance to ensure that they are taking the correct courses for graduation. If a student
receives poor academic advising that can delay their graduation date while adding to the
financial debt that the student is responsible for meeting. Students want to make sure that their
experiences are being validated through their success so providing them with accurate academic
advising information can ensure that these students do not take any unnecessary courses that can
Campus engagement. Research on Latinos has established that specific aspects of the
the institution (Hurtado, Carter, & Spuler 1996). Although the academic part of the adjustment
is particularly important to Latino Students, student affairs practitioners cannot overlook the
things that help Latino students stay connected to the campus culture. Some PWI’s have made
an effort in establishing resource centers that can help the student find a connection to campus.
Finding these resources centers may impose a greater challenge for Latino students if they are
not familiar that such centers exist. If they are the first in their family to attend college they may
not be familiar with the types of campus resources and engagement opportunities that are
Smedley, Myers, and Harrell's (1993) reported that Latino students on predominantly
White campuses face specific stresses associated with their minority status. This means that
many Latino students do not feel welcome and have encountered uninviting settings. Smedley,
Myers, and Harrell's (1993) also reported that minority freshmen exhibit considerable
psychological sensitivity to the campus social climate, including interpersonal tensions with
White students and faculty and actual or perceived experiences of racism and discrimination. It
is already stressful for Latino students to arrive to a campus with low numbers of faculty and
staff members that resemble them. If Latino students do not feel like they are welcome to the
campus by other students, faculty or staff that may cause for them to feel disconnected and
wanting to go home often. If these students go home often they may find it easier to simply stay
at home after one semester than go through the hassle of attending and living in a university
According to Hurtado, Carter, and Spuler (1996) studies have found that early transition
experiences that facilitate the formation of peer groups and adjustment to college can be
PWI’s is not enough. Institutions must make a commitment to Latino students that creates a
welcoming setting by all members of the institutions. Latino students should be able to form
peer groups that can help them adjust to campus and those peer groups should not only come
from the Latino resource centers at these institutions. This commitment must come from every
office that provides services to these students. Building community for Latino students is
Building community. In order to be able to support Latino students at PWI’s there must
commitment means that institutions can be more proactive about how they advertise the
engagement opportunities available for Latino students upon their arrival to these PWI’s. If
these institutions, make the commitment to promote opportunities for all students nothing stops
them from creating advertisements that let Latino students know that they matter and that they
are welcomed at their respective institution. This commitment will also require more than just
pictures on a bulletin board. This will require for institutions to make a commitment to hire
faculty and staff that resemble the Latino population of students. Showing Latino students that
their presence matters will allow them to become more responsive to the opportunities
established for them and be more incline to building a community that can enhance their
Conclusion
College enrollment data reveal that Latino students play a significant role in institutions
institutions fail to recognize and seek to understand the needs that Latino students face they will
continue to fail the Latino students that they recruiting. In order to enhance the services and meet
the demands that Latino students have, administrators must make an institutional commitment,
that allows for the entire university to find better ways to serve these students. Institutions
cannot continue to recruit Latino students and fail them upon their arrival to these PWI’s.
Therefore, it is imperative for PWI’s to create initiatives that will provide an opportunity to find
better ways to present college admission processes to Latino students and their families and take
into consideration their socioeconomic status when it comes to creating college costs. These
institutions must also keep in mind the lack of college readiness that Latino students may come
with due to underfunded K-12 school systems. This will also open the door to understanding how
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 17
the lack of connection to the campus and poor academic advising at their respective institutions
References
Acevedo-Polakovich, I. D., Quirk, K.M., Cousineau, J.R., Saxena, S.R., and Gerhart, J. I.
(2014). Acting Bicultural Versus Feeling Bicultural: Cultural Adaptation and School-
Related Attitudes Among U.S. Latina/o Youth Journal of Hispanic Higher Education
Bowen, W., Chingos, M., and McPherson, M. (2009). Crossing the Finish Line: Completing
Jossey-Bass.
Flores, L. Y., Ojeda, L., Huang, Y., Gee, D., & Lee, S. (2006). The relation of acculturation,
American high school students’ educational goals. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 53,
260-266.
Gandara, P., & Contreras, F. (2009). The Latino education crisis: The consequences of failed
Gloria, A. M., Castellanos, J., & Orozco, V. (2005). Perceived educational barriers, cultural
Gonzalez, R.G. (2013) Same and Different: Latino College Students’ Perceptions of
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 19
Themselves and Other on Campus. Journal of Hispanic Higher Education. (Vol. 12,
pp.3-22). doi:10.1177/1538192712440173
Hurtado, Sylvia, Deborah F. Carter, and Albert J. Spuler. 1996. "Latino Student Transition
Lopez, D. J. (2005). Race-related stress and sociocultural orientation among Latino students
during their transition into a predominantly White highly selective institution. Journal of
Rheinheimer, D.C., & Mann, A. (2000). Gender matching, floor effects, and other tutoring
Martinez, E. (2010). Higher Education in the Midwest: Factors Influencing the Experiences
from:http://epublications.marquette.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1010&context=cps_
professional
From:http://search.proquest.com/docview/892758434/previewPDF/B712408F50D74EC7
PQ/1? accountid=12846
Miller, L. S., & García, E. E. (2004). Better Informing Efforts to Increase Latino Student
doi:10.1177/0013124503261329
National Center for Education Statistics. (2010). Status and trends in the education of racial
http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2007/minoritytrends/ind_1_4. asp#S
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 20
National Center for Education Statistics, Monitoring Quality: An Indicators Report, December
2000
Ojeda, L., Castillo, L. G., Rosales-Meza, R., and Piña-Watson, B. (2013). Mexican
doi:10.1177/1538192713498899
Peske, H.H., Haycock, K. (2006) Teaching Inequality. How Poor and Minority Students Are
http://www.mepwisc.org/Content/files/teach_inequality_rpr.pdf
Peters M.L., Sawyer, C. B., Guzmán, M.R., and Graziani, C. (2014) Supporting the
http://www.academia.edu/2056976/Building_a_multicontextual_model_of_Latino_colleg
e_enrollment_Student_school_and_state-level_effects
Education.
http://www.mpow.org/elisheva_sadan_empowerment_chapter3.pdf
Smedley, Brian D., Hector F. Myers, and Shelley P. Harrell. 1993. "Minority-Status
ADDRESSING ISSUES OF LATINO STUDENTS IN PWI’s 21
Stresses and the College Adjustment of Ethnic Minority Freshmen." Journal of Higher
Education 64:434-52.
Swail, W. S., Cabrera, A. F., & Lee, C. (2004). Latino youth and the pathway to
Tinto, V. (1999). Taking student retention seriously: Rethinking the first year of college.
neglect. National Education Association, Human and Civil Rights. Washington, DC.
www.nea.org/mco/images/hispaniced.pdf